11.15.2026
3:30 PM EDT | IA.114.10BSC 201 - Barber Boardroom
ATTENDANCE
Committee MembersQuorum: 5 Members Present
| Cole Liazos-Coffey, Chair | Present | Ella Chon | Present |
| Shreemann Patel, Co-Chair | Present | Demarri Dosunmu | Present |
| Noah Sokol | Present | Boyi Chen | Present |
| Paul Woo | Present | Saanvi Kapu | Present |
| Aarshi Lamicchane | Present |
Present; Absent (Uncommunicated and/or Unexcused); Excused (Excused Absence); Late (More than 5 mins late)
Non-Committee Member Guests & Observers
- Chair of Programming Grace Guan
- Student Body President Sumire Sumi
CONVENING BUSINESS
Call to Order / Start Time:
Welcome
All Present
Resource OverviewConstitution JHU SGA Constitution (Amended September 18th 2026)By-LawsJHU SGA Bylaws (Amended November 3rd 2026)Template Bills Template Bills
LEGISLATIVE BUSINESS
Disciplinary Mark Reform PreviewS. Bill. 114.11.15.26-1 Disciplinary Mark Reform Act
Committee Chair
NON-LEGISLATIVE BUSINESS
Selecting a Vice ChairCommittee Initiatives UpdatesUpdate/Modernize Attendance Tracker – BoyiDEMO / TESTING Official SGA Attendance Sheet (2026-2027)Action Items Audit – ColeEthics Board & SGA – Paul (Nov 17 @ 3:00 pm)SGA Internal Effectiveness and Governance Survey ResponsesSGA IEGS Report of FindingsCSE ReviewCSE Constitution Feb. 2024Website review (https://docs.google.com/document/d/1FFM_U8Of00DbPmZedeHXfzHLhA7zWmdtrRTBJW8dNr0/edit?tab=t.0)Open ForumConsent Agenda DiscussionStandardizing Bill ID (e.g., S. Bill. 114.10.13.26-21)SGA-programming separation?On the State of Programming.pdfClass Programming Proposal.docxImpeachment Trial Reforms
All PresentAll PresentAll PresentAll PresentAll Present
CLOSING
NO FORMAL MEETING NEXT TWO SUNDAYS“Homework”Go through governing documents as neededClosing
All Present
11.15.2026
3:30 PM EDT | IA.114.10BSC 201 - Barber Boardroom
ATTENDANCE
Committee MembersQuorum: 5 Members Present
| Cole Liazos-Coffey, Chair | Present | Ella Chon | Present |
| Shreemann Patel, Co-Chair | Present | Demarri Dosunmu | Present |
| Noah Sokol | Present | Boyi Chen | Present |
| Paul Woo | Present | Saanvi Kapu | Present |
| Aarshi Lamicchane | Present |
Present; Absent (Uncommunicated and/or Unexcused); Excused (Excused Absence); Late (More than 5 mins late)
Non-Committee Member Guests & Observers
- Director of Programming Grace Guan
- Student Body President Sumire Sumi
CONVENING BUSINESS
Call to Order / Start Time:
WelcomeCalled to order - 3:35Cole: good to see you guys again, Saanvi will hopefully arrive soon, Aarshi has communicated he should be a little late, from what he said he said he had a finance investment workshop thing from 3:30-3:40Prreview!
All Present
Resource OverviewConstitution JHU SGA Constitution (Amended September 18th 2026)By-LawsJHU SGA Bylaws (Amended November 3rd 2026)Template Bills Template Bills
LEGISLATIVE BUSINESS
Disciplinary Mark Reform previewS. Bill. 114.11.15.26-1 Disciplinary Mark Reform ActCole: Kind of started on Tuesday, after everything that happened with the trial of Aarshi, if you could open that pleaseLots of changes, even since I initially drafted, there's something specifically I'd like to talk about before it even gets to first readingIn the document, there's a green part, 10.1.2, talking about disciplinary marks may not be assigned for…Dislike for assigning of a mark for motion by Aarshidemarri: less words betterShreemann: the judiciary has said aren't supposed to be or will not involve with disciplinary markPaul: this bylaws? oh okay procedural rules, kind of agree, where there are so many things we can consider it would be a lot, but part of our job is that, if it were just following the rules, i think our job is outside, i think we could do something like finance guidelines, where they have to do things for all students, if we had guidelines for what can be disciplinary marks; something internal to us where we can be ad hoc, we would start building precedent as common lawShreemann: would have to pass something to give them legitimacy, don't think that's a bad ideapaul: not that i think this is a bad idea, won't automatically renew, just an idea for the futureboyi: agree with paul, but specifically for free speech, this should be codified in our procedural rules for now, we have that on the side, i think this is really important, i think we should have this in our governing documentscole: i think so, what happened in practice with the disciplinary mark, we had pretty sound reasoning, as a committee, in deciding, it was a disruptive action, however, clearly, free speech, and there should be some thing that we don't penalize, this argument makes me think there should be exclusions made for these, not entirely up to me, should be not up to the discretion of ia so much as it is now, i like that idea paul both for disciplinary marks, having a guidlines document like finance, in lieu right now though, would be goodpaul: i think a lot of times, half was about impeachment, half werecole: want to represent whole senate, i know demarri went over it, or if anyone looked at itshreemann: i had something with 10.1.8, turned over by secret ballot, how necessary is secret ballot, adds a lot of time, if we do think it's necessary, shouldpaul; personally don't think it's necessary to be secret, for the senate to decide whether or not the impeachment to be validshreemann: nothing to do with impeachmentcole: or when they can do threepaul: to clear up procedural qualms before judgmentDemarri - believes that extra things about that one part to be unnecessary. We are still reviewing ourselves. If we say “no this is not free speech”, we are still IA and can interpret our own documents how we want to. Seems like extra stuff.Demarri - for secret ballots, very necessary, being nice / being a good person. If you need time to think about it, don’t get time to think about it.Shreemann - Privately, this is my friend, if this is secret, I will vote no. Important for it to be publicnoah: how would that vote be startedshreemann: also wanted to ask if we should report marks to the senatecole: 10.1.7.1.1 used to say "legitimacy"; changed to truthfulness because of ambiguity, thought that was confusing, separating did the event happen versus did youboyi:paul: part of what we're doing is not the validity, we can't do the full investigation, so perhaps the value of an allegationboyi: can't lie, last time we handled it, this is how i feel, i think people in here pushing, even if the validity of the thing, wanted impeachment, even if assigned 0, how we right that in, i don't nowpaul: there were other things discussed such as discussed,boyi: need a separate processshreemann: have thoughts, lateraarshi: boyi you were saying ia doesn't reassign marksboyi: yes we do, we vote on its validityaarshi: back to the second part, impeachment about second thing, i don't think there's previous in the laws beside disciplinary markdemarri: can you just motion to start impeachmentshreemann, cole: ⅓cole: caucus senators can have signature, there can be absencescole: i think it's important like you said paul/boyi, hard to know how to codify it, just separating did this happen versus how much does it deservenoah: and point, 0 would be included on possible onesdemarri, boyi: yescole: there was some discussion during/after broader reform of disciplinary mark system, someone wanted judiciary, who was thatsean: judiciarydemarri: i think makes sense, but not necessarycole: naturally i wrote this, but i think what we have in there is good, paul/boyi any suggestionsboyi: have questions about so if we docole: ia reports on the disciplinary mark at the next gbm, and if the senate feels like it, they can motion to overturn or modify, if they don't want to nothing happensboyi: and it's not the immediate impeachment, but the one aftercole: so when it gets triggered between 1-3 weeks then tigrgered
Committee Chair
NON-LEGISLATIVE BUSINESS
Selecting a Vice Chairdemarri: motion to confirm boyisecond: paul, ellaaye: allnay:abstain: boyiCommittee Initiatives UpdatesUpdate/Modernize Attendance Tracker – BoyiDEMO / TESTING Official SGA Attendance Sheet (2026-2027)Action Items Audit – Colecole: not a ton of billsEthics Board & SGA – Paul (Nov 17 @ 3:00 pm)cole: i didn't get a responsepaul: i did, they just didn't ccpaul: ethics board currently looks like deans just sort of find and pick, i have meeting with amy beltramif any of you would like to come i'm sure she'd be amenableboyi: what timepaul: 3pm, amr ii tuesday; i'm going to see what the process is like first and report next ia meeting, i doubt we will get an agreement outSGA Internal Effectiveness and Governance Survey ResponsesSGA IEGS Report of Findingscole: shreemann i'll let you lead thisshreemann: 6 things learned, keep in mind was before exec presentation/retreat2nd work insufficient; phillip is working; hope to have ims fully done beginning next semester3rd judiciary has visibilityasked if they could to another presentation after all senators onboarding4th better onboardingnoah: was wonderfulsgway 2.0 presentationwill be kept up for next5th meetings are inefficientwill talk about consent agenda6 members want more meaningful workexternal advisory boards, we can get more on there, even if not working specificjazz and me meeting with senators to seecole: think also ims will allow people to see initiatives; same with strategic direction as group; provides more avenues as groupsaarshi: any consistent themes/wordsshreemann: themes were compiled from people's statements and likert responsecole: reaching out updatedshreemann: helped us identify couple of people to check in withCSE ReviewCSE Constitution Feb. 2024Website review (https://docs.google.com/document/d/1FFM_U8Of00DbPmZedeHXfzHLhA7zWmdtrRTBJW8dNr0/edit?tab=t.0)cole: constitution outdated, we've had problems with themincorrect number of senators, both for when this constitution was originally posted (e.g., 9 rso senators, )couple of notable slipups in past, elected 2 black caucus senators in the springlike with aarshi, confusion of majors and academic senatorshiplooks like they're supposed to be under usshremann: not an umbrella, we are supposed to look over at them; cse has practically never had 7, there are some internal things we should probably talk to judiciary chair and cse chair, they have to pass it before we pass itcole: woulud you like to reach outshreemann: i have, but not for a full on meeting, i can do this againcole: anybody else interestedaarshi: for reforming their constitution, should we have anything that makes them held accountable for bad decision, is that something we should haveshreemann: i think 2 years ago we tried and they basically just dissolved, worried about punitiveness since, on the record, leed has been taking many of the job over the cse, i'll inquire charles about it tomorrownoah: could we in the future have sga on csepaul: was pushing last year, put down on the same grounds, naturally we couldn't have sga on there, maybe have judiciary play a bigger role, idea to put out there, interest is so low, self-perpetuating disinterestcole: could also do a bigger push to advertise cseOpen ForumConsent Agenda Discussionshreemann: explained it last time, now only foraarshi: do we want to have those go before other second readingcole: ok demarri and aarshi can work on thisStandardizing Bill ID (e.g., S. Bill. 114.10.13.26-21)SGA-programming separation?On the State of Programming.pdfClass Programming Proposal.docxgrace and sumi have been sitting here the whole time lolgrace: first does anybody have to leave it's a pretty long presentationgrace: know there has been a lot of discussionagendacontext on class programmingi've been on programming since 2023, itis point leed ahd very strong control over classp rogramming council, for example freshman formal being held at bloomberg in dc, but had to be there because of leed; this made everyone on freshman council leavein 2024 leed still had lots of power, we only met within our councilafter this year, just 3 on entire programming committee, supposed to be 11-122026: leed stepped into more advisor role, then we had whole committee meetings, battle of the classes, our flagship event, started other meetings at hopkinsno more student led, good direction75% retention ratein summary already becoming more student ledquestions to answerhow can programming ensure sufficient autonomy within leedwhat distinguishes class programming form the hop and sga programmingwhat interactions should class programming have with sga programming? what should be the role of sga chair of programmingshould beanswers to questionsprogramming autonomyrole of the chair and vice chair of programming; can sanity check leed decision to make sure leed does not make illogical choices againwhat distinguishes class pgrogramming from the hopthe way i see itclass programing: class-specific traditions and events like formalsthe hop: numerous small fun events (huge flagship traditions) limited opportunity to create new flagship, e.g. concertsga programming: tablings and event sponsorshipswhat interactions shuld class programming have with sga programmingregardless i think the chair of each class programming committee and the class presdents should reach out to each otherencourage all senators to come to meetingswhat should be the role of the chair of programmingcurrently i run class programming, i suppose plan sga retreatthis was done in the past and also do tablings, but there's really nothing written down about thisi really have no communication about this like people in comittee who want toput out and stuff in the likein the constitution it says overseeing sga programming and class programmingfunctionally very difficult and a lot of workshould become differentwas leed's idea to separate the two, hanna sent me a proposal which i will send to you allelections for chair vc and classs committeesappointmed members with fewer responsibilityleed also sgugests smaller committees (athletics, sprit, media)my thoughtsalready have separate financing, programming council don't get funding, have separate org charts, programming has no voting rights in the senate, if people say "sga" event, people say they don't like sga event, stops some people from coming to eventsif separated should limit need to change sga constitution for [programming stuffprogramming currently doesn't have the things required in the constitution; media director, we don' tknow ifn the future are there going to be new rules, this wouldbe alot of rules for IAleed's proposalmy thoughtscole: for the second to last bullet point "recruitment and retention chair" are you think there could be 2 within SGA like the sga chair of programming and then also the one that internally does recruitment toward sga and retreatgrace: could be possible, but depending on what you thinkcole: i think 1 is enoughaarshi: so these are the positions given to peoplegrace: no those would be separate. i think this could possibly be internally appointed, if you're getting someone on the student body who hasn't been beforeshreemann; i do have a couple thought, on the instagram, i think they would just need new accounts, at least sophomore one is used forbylaws deignates opposed to constitutionshreemann: i do think there needs to be a separation; it hink we put more things under the committe chair/ academic affairs, a lot of tabling already happen through the student services; a lot of what the sga programming does is done by the; in terms of recruitment and retention chair, these already are done by the presidents of senate and exec; instead of replacing with 1 or 2 positions, those are my thoughtscole: i think this sounds like it could be a good thingboyi: how would elections lookguan: right now, the chair of programming, it could be something like what the hop does, on a separate page,cole; this would still be under leed, like we're already under leed, so and you don't think that leed will provide/cause new difficultiesCole: bullying?Shreemann: What can SGA do against bullying either? Association with SGA does not necessarily protect an orgImpeachment Trial reformsShreemann and Cole: Against siloed impeachment trials, impeachment trials should be for all thingsPaul: Fears bringin up extraneous things if everyone is committed against someoneBoyi: If the accused has these set of things going against them, of course they are going to explain/give their time for defense what happened specifically with these disciplinary marks/why they were accrued and their defense against that, for them, their scope is limited, but when we go into discussion we go into discussing all of these things.Paul: Agrees with Boyi because its also closed session, so we might also want to make it so the accused can defend against themselves. Maybe a part of it where we talk amongst ourselves. Model assuming is that once the impeachment trial is triggered, the actual subject of the marks is irrelevantNow that disciplinary marks can be overturned, what should things look like?Noah - if we limit to specifically disciplinary marks. If in discussion other things get brought to light, is there anything that stops us from raising more disciplinary marksCole - after IA meeting, at next GBM, we will report disciplinary marks. Senate can motion to overturn or modify (but nothing limits that). During the impeachment trialBoyi - we should make sure they know thatRC - if anything can be brought up, let’s say the accused is acquitted. Would the ones that were discussed during a closed session that could become disciplinary marks be allowed to be filed? Also, double jeopardy?Cole - yes, if they are different and weren’t filed beforePaul - with the ⅔ vote to overturn the disciplinary mark, will the sentiment retain through into the impeachment?Noah - we’re evaluating as a wholeCole - there will be a general consensus within the SGA about overturning of disciplinary marks, might be good to allow evaluation beyond what was brought by disciplinary marksWhat else should we include in disciplinary marks?RC - heard from Sean and others about impeachments. The accused is usually there throughout the whole trial. Is there something specifically in the Constitution?Shreemann - any discussion of action of charges can be done with them present (make this change). Actually votingCole - may not participate in deliberationPaul - what if - defend, deliberate, bring back in for rebuttal, send outCensurePaul - a warning shot (time out?).Shreemann - this will just leave the seat vacant, not getting any work done
All PresentAll PresentAll PresentAll PresentAll Present
CLOSING
“Homework”Continue to look through IEGS survey feedbackContinue to look in to CSEGo through governing documents as neededClosingInformal meeting on 11/29? IA workshopRC - motion to adjournShreemann - secondAye
All Present
