SENATE OF THE JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION
Consolidated General Body Meeting Agenda and Minutes
September 11th, 2018
7:00 PM to 9:00 PM, Charles Commons East Room
Agenda
Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)
Approval of the Agenda & Prior Minutes (1 min)
New Business (95 min)
Update on Situation with Dr. Tamsyn Mahoney-Steel [Link] — Professor Kristin Cook-Gailloud, Vice President Tsang (15 min)
FIJI the Push Funding Bill [Link] — President Schatmeyer (Guest: Preston Coffin) (15 min)
SGA Commissions Bills — Vice President Tsang, Secretary Williams (20 min)
Communications & Marketing Commission Codification Bill [Link]
Policy Research & Development Commission Codification Bill [Link]
CMC Member Confirmations [Link] (10 min)
JHU-ICE Severance Resolution [Link] — President Schatmeyer (20 min)
Updates from Noh (15 min)
Reports (18 min)
Executive Board Reports (4 min)
Committee Reports (7 min)
Academic Affairs — Senator Taj
Civic Engagement — President Schatmeyer, Senator Paulet
Finance — Senator Mays, Treasurer Tu
Health, Safety and Sustainability — Senator Paulet, Senator Patel
Internal Affairs — Senator Baron, Vice President Tsang
Student Organizations — President Chien, Senator Elgendi
Student Services — Senator Cai, President Schatmeyer
Class Council Reports (4 min)
Advisor Report (3 min)
Prospective Business (5 min)
Advancing Legislation
Announcements
Public Input Period
Adjournment (ESTIMATED 8:55 PM)
MINUTES
Call to Order and Roll Call Taken
Agenda and Prior Minutes Approved
New Business
Update on Situation with Dr. Tamsyn Mahoney-Steel
Member of FSA spoke to SGA Senate about updates on the situation
Represents the AAUP (American Association of University Professors)
We don’t know what has happened yet in regard to her visa status
Next steps for SGA
Letters of support, especially to the Provost
Joint resolution between SGA, GRO, and Faculty Assembly
FIJI the Push Funding Bill
Motion to move it forward in the agenda by President Schatmeyer
Motion approved
President Schatmeyer yields to an Audience Member
Covers cost of inflatable boxing ring and snacks
This will cover costs so that more money is allocated to charity
The bill is asking for $149 of SGA support
Participants push a military humvee and winners receive a prize
Senator Taj - how many participants will be there?
Audience member - the boxing ring would yield higher numbers since it would incentivize more students to be there
Senator Paulet - is there a contingency plan for bad weather?
Audience member - we can move the event to the Spring
Senator Baron - aired concerns about using the practice field during inclement weather
President Schatmeyer - the severability clause would allow SGA to keep money if the event does not occur
Senator Mollin - why is SGA the best source of money?
Audience member - it would allocate more money to the philanthropy
Senator Taj - motion to bring Fiji Push bill to the floor and approve it with President Schatmeyer’s recent amendments
Motion approved after President Schatmeyer amended the bill to reflect the correct date of the event
Senator Taj brought up his concerns about the upcoming hurricane
Senator Lucas - the money goes back to SGA if the event does not occur
Senator Chien - the hurricane will not hit us
Senator Baron - Hopkins floods a lot
Senator Taj - brings up concerns about the number of attendees of the event if there is inclement weather
President Habib - move to end discussion
Approved
Vote on the bill
Passes with 14 yesses and 1 abstention
SGA Commissions Bills — Vice President Tsang, Secretary Williams (20 min)
Communications & Marketing Commission Codification Bill
Senator Patel - the link is not working
Motion to bring bill to floor and approve
Senator Patel - what is quorum for the CMC
Secretary Williams - quorum is 3 of the 5 members
Policy Research & Development Commission Codification Bill
Vice President Tsang explains bill
Motion to introduce and approve the bill by President Schatmeyer
Bill approved
CMC Member Confirmations
All members confirmed with one abstention
JHU-ICE Severance Resolution presented by President Schatmeyer
Discussion on how ICE is not representative of Hopkins’ values and we as student should stand in solidarity against the organization
Good opportunity for our SGA to take a stand on social issues as we move towards a more policy minded
Motion to introduce and approve the resolution by President Schatmeyer
Senator Patel - where would “ties being cut” count in this resolution?
President Schatmeyer - Only goes as far as cutting ties with ICE, there is language in the bill the recognizes that a institutional partnership with the federal government is overall positive, the bill only speaks to ICE
Senator Patel - it could potentially hurt the receival of grants
Senator Baron - we are given a grant of 4 million by ICE - where would substitute this money from
President Schatmeyer - we would need to discuss this further with administration. He feels a moral obligation to cut ties with ICE, which outweighs the $4 million grant.
Senator Baron - it would specifically hurt jobs in the APL
Senator Mollin - The money we get from ICE is from research and training programs. The majority of the money we get from ICE is from training programs - tactical and leadership tours, the money we lose from the training programs would not be significant. If we lose the research funding we can find it elsewhere. ICE is affecting the lives of people now and we need to take a stand.
Senator Taj - how would this bill affect Hopkins students, other than losing money?
Senator Chien - quoting the JHU News-Letter, there was a resolution to support DACA and affirm law enforcement officials would not be allowed on campus and would help students on campus who are undocumented to remain confidential. In our resolution, SGA made it clear that we do not support ICE. They do not have authority or power to do anything on our campus (Homewood)
Senator Lucas - are we contracted with just ICE or a higher office.
Senator Elgendi - he disagrees that it won’t help student directly, since students will feel as if they’re in an environment that supports immigrants
Senator Cai - This resolution is non-binding but it is a the stance of SGA as a whole. We are a university that is respected by universities around the country.
President Habib - thanking President Schatmeyer for the resolution. Does not stand behind ICE. There are a lot of good men and women that do work for ICE. He would like the school to leverage our relationship with ICE to fix the current policies. Is there a way we can influence the changes without severing ties? What have other campuses done? As a sanctuary campus, we are preventing students from feeling at risk. Believes as SGA, we could do more in the research department to help end these policies.
Senator Taj - stands behind the spirit of the bill, but is worried about the financial aspect. Believes this bill only cleanses our conscious. What is the money being used for? Yield to President Schatmeyer
President Schatmeyer - we take them on tours around Baltimore for leadership training
Senator Paulet - as the undergraduate SGA, this resolution may not guarantee that we cut ties with ICE, but its a stance of solidarity. Northwestern and Vermont Public Schools are looking at cutting ties with ICE. Could potentially be impactful in the long term.
President Schatmeyer - Thank you for everyone’s consideration of the resolution. We should focus on how we do not support ICE. It’s a statement of values. We represent the five thousand undergraduate students, and we need to take a stand. If we don’t allow them on this campus, how dare we train them to work on the border.
Senator Taj - wants to clarify that this bill may not give us the intended results. We still need to take a stand against ICE. It is our job to explain our stance in the hope that it creates a ripple effect in other spheres of the university.
President Mebrahtu - we need to remember who we are as an organization. This resolution is a statement of values. We’ve already acknowledged that we do not want ICE on campus, so we are therefore reaffirming it. We should not consider the monetary issues on our values in regard to this case. It’s a reaffirmation of what our SGA stands for.
Vice President Tsang - is there is a tie, I will be voting yes. This resolution speaks to a broader issue of immigration today. There has been a lack of political push from our representatives. We may watch our democracy wither away if we do not take a stance today. (AJ said this in a more poetic and articulate way, but I could not type fast enough)
Senator Patel - reaffirms how the PRDC and the University can leverage our relationship with ICE
Senator Taj - motion to end discussion
Motion approved
Senator Baron - would like to have the PRDC do more research on it
Motion to approve resolution
Abstentions - Baron, Habib, Patel
Resolution Passes
Updates from Noh
Would like to address the senate
Has been reflecting on impact in the last four years
Critiques of SGA are it’s decision to be reactive and not proactive
Many of our resolutions are in reaction to the world or the university
Last year, I felt that it was my role to be more supportive of senators and student groups in any way possible - including Rise Up Rally
Did not want to impose his own opinions on the Senate
Has been reflecting on his Role in SGA
Supported Rushabh in pushing the smoking resolution
Wants the SGA to be as proactive as possible this year
Will be pushing for what he believes in - hope it does not make us all uncomfortable
Will be presenting the smoking ban from last year
It has been a conversation since 2011 and SGA has been discussing it since Noh’s freshmen year
Believes the argument for it outweigh the arguments against it
Wants to see it put into action sooner
Is worried about bureaucracy “tyranny without a tyrant”
Secretary Williams - point of information, how much are you working with HKB and CHEW
President Mebrahtu - has been working with administration to have a ban on smoking on campus
Senator Patel - with the tobacco policy - wants to approve accessibility to smoking cessation products. Has reached out to deans blackwell and Ruzicka
President Noh - does not want there to be a substitute for something like a full.
Senator Mollin - what do you mean by “bringing it up”
Secretary Williams - which administrators? The school is already offering smoking cessation products.
President Chien - There is no bill or resolution on the floor right now
Motion to end discussion - approved
Senator Mays disagrees
Executive Board Reports (4 min)
President Noh - Mcdonalds wants to have an event on campus that gives out free food. Noh has been meeting with ASA, BSU and other minority groups to have a networking event for first generation students
Vice President Tsang - visited Loyola with Secretary Williams. The Loyola President wants to bring together all SGA’s in Baltimore. We volunteered to hold an SGA conference on campus. PRDC is partially operational but applications are out. We need nominations for the curriculum committee for both Krieger and Whiting. SGA should distribute on social media. Secretary Williams and Senator Paulet met with Irene in the CSS to discuss events for first generation students. Will have a meeting to discuss Dr. Mahoney-Steel. Ten seniors are running in Senior Student Election
Senator Baron - is on the curriculum committee Sophomore year - wants to pass a theatre and arts major and loved working on the committee
Treasurer Mi Tu - SAC has been updating the bylaws and will send those to the finance committee. Finalized the budgets with student groups. Waiting on DOSL to finalize the budgets. Drafting application to be sent out this week.
Secretary Williams - same as AJ
Committee Reports (7 min)
Academic Affairs — Senator Taj
Will move forward for student reps to Whiting and Kreiger. SGA can take these spots. Two initiatives - recording classes and syllabi on SIS
Civic Engagement — President Schatmeyer, Senator Paulet
Paulet reached out to mailroom supervisor on the loss of an absentee ballot. As many Hop students are out of state students, it’s important that we ensure the absentee ballot system works at Hop. Schatmeyer will be voter engagement heavy leading up to the midterms. Will work on voter registration tabling
Finance — Senator Mays, Treasurer Tu
Meetings on Friday at 3pm. Passed the first bill today.
Health, Safety and Sustainability — Senator Paulet, Senator Patel
Menstruation products initiative - issues that come up is that entities were removing the boxes - advancing a funding bill to purchase crates for the bathrooms. Will be done in collaboration with wings. Smoking cessation program will be in discussion with deans. Fitness programs will have research done on pilot programs in hopes that it will incentivize the school to continue the programs. PATH workgroup with university leadership - working on the commission of university healthcare.
Internal Affairs — Senator Baron, Vice President Tsang
Wants to revamp bylaws. Wants to go over referendum. Wants to meet on Sunday.
Student Organizations — President Chien, Senator Elgendi
Not operating with a full committee yet because we have too many vacancies. 3-4 Freshmen will be put on this committee. Introduce Senator Elgendi as the cochair
Student Services — Senator Cai, President Schatmeyer
Senator Cai has been in contact with a startup that may bring free printing to our campus but has had trouble reaching IT. Brick rally initiative will be brought into action.
Class Council Reports (4 min)
Seniors
Class gift has reached out to class council and will be collaborating
Will be collaborating with commencement in regard to speakers
Will be collaborating with Hoptoberfest for beer tasting
Juniors
Working to fill the vacancy
Sophomores
Elected all position on the Class council. Social media meeting starting tomorrow. Looking to do a sophomore showcase newsletter as to what sophomores are doing on campus. Wants to do a grant program. Softshow (sophomore talent show) at some point this year.
Advisor Report (3 min)
Part of Baltimore Collegetown network - wants to have a Baltimore collegetown conference. When you log into Hopkins Groups, it automatically logs you into TurboVote.
Advancing Legislation
Senator Paulet - funding bill for Hoptoberfest
Senator Patel - funding bill for reimbursing sophomore class for activism fair
President Schatmeyer - private police resolution
VP Tsang - funding bill for APTT’s compassion and kindness series
Announcements
Public Input
Senator Paulet wants to bring an activist to campus about oppressive regimes
Senator Baron wants to have a crisis response training
President Schatmeyer go to the PUSH
Public Input
Where is there data on student opinion on ICE ?
Senator Taj - was referencing a previous resolution
During the discussion period of the bill, can audience members speak
VP Tsang - you must have time yielded to you by a senator
What has happened in SGA that’s been a long term project that is coming into effect
President Schatmeyer - student center initiative has been going on for ages
VP Tsang - Blue jay shuttle system - pushed a resolution for the blue jay shuttles
and pushed for divestment
How do you prepare for GBM
VP Tsang - Secretary Williams sends out Agenda. Hours of work depends on role
you play. Can be quite a lot.
