JOHNS HOPKINS STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION
POWERS & AUTHORITIES INITIATIVE
Background Document on SGA Democratic Standing
Contents
- Abridged History of SGA Powers & Authorities
- Itemized Description of Existing SGA Powers & Authorities
- SGA Democratic Standing
Abridged History of SGA Powers & Authorities
The SGA’s existing powers and authorities with regards to the University can be traced to the emergence of the Student Council in the 1920s. At that point in time, the Student Council was housed in the Merrick Barn and was responsible for working with the Dean of Students, then the only student affairs professional at the University, to manage student activities fees and tuition. By the 1960s, increasing student activism on a national level led the Student Council to lead several additional initiatives, including the endowment of annual leadership awards and selection of the Commencement speaker. By the dawn of the twenty-first century, the SGA managed the accreditation of several hundred student organizations. The SGA was so expansive that it even appointed the chairs of FAS, MSE, and the HOP. Kwame Alston, 2018 Senior Class President, remarked that in the era of the first African-American Executive President of the SGA, the Senior Class Council even had veto power over the Commencement speaker. However, after the publication of the first Commission on Undergraduate Education (CUE) report in the early 2000s, SGA’s explicit powers and authorities began to diminish as management of student activities was shifted from peer-based management to staff-based management. SGA influence waned especially after the departure of Dean of Student Life Susan Boswell in 2013 and Director of Student Life Rob Turing in 2014.
Meanwhile, since undergraduates are not empowered with distinctive influence over the operations and service provision of the University, SGA has been dependent on dialogue throughout its history to engage in policy advocacy. Certainly, the SGA has always and continues to meet with administrators, especially as more were brought to the University, but it has often been left to SGA to make the first step to continue dialogue with administrators, rather than a mutual effort. Today, as a result, SGA has been left primarily with political or symbolic means of advocating for students - holding forums, composing resolutions, and transmitting student concerns to entities that often took courses of action in opposition to student concerns - rather than retaining access to institutional bodies that control long-term decision-making for the University or tangible day-to-day policies.
Itemized Description of Existing SGA Powers & Authorities
The following section contains descriptions of SGA’s existing abilities in regards to the University at-large. This section does not pertain directly to SGA legislation, which is considered an internal function that facilitates external operations.
<u>1. Selection and confirmation of student representatives to the Krieger Curriculum Committee and the Whiting Curriculum Committee, including the Chair of the Academic Affairs Committee.</u>
The SGA has been historically authorized to select the five student members of both the Krieger and Whiting Schools’ Curriculum Committees, which are standing committees responsible for advising the Homewood Academic Council on changes to curriculum. In the early fall of each academic year, members of each school’s dean’s staff reach out to SGA and ask for SGA to procure and confirm five student members of each committee. In addition, the SGA Academic Affairs Committee chair is granted ex-officio membership on both Curriculum Committees.
To select the five student members of each Curriculum Committee, the SGA Academic Affairs Committee conducts an open application process, evaluates applicants through a criterion-based rubric of expertise with University academic policy and ability to advocate for student viewpoints, and the ten total nominees are presented to the SGA Senate for review and confirmation. The student members’ names are then passed on to the deans of Krieger and Whiting.
<u>2. Confirmation of student nominees to the Ethics Board.</u>
The SGA has been historically authorized to confirm nominees to the Ethics Board that have been identified and screened by a subcommittee of current Ethics Board members. The Ethics Board subcommittee extends an open application to the student body, then evaluates applicants on their moral integrity and ability to apply the Academic Ethics Code to test cases or simulacra. When the nominees have been prepared, the Director of Student Conduct or a member of the Ethics Board presents the final nominees to the SGA Senate, whereupon the nominees are presented to the SGA Senate for review and confirmation.
<u>3. Selection and recommendation of student nominees to certain University-wide entities, such as the Mental Health Task Force and Mental Well-Being Working Group.</u>
The SGA, as the primary representative body of the student population on Homewood, has historically been vested with the right to appoint all student representatives on any
University-wide entity. However, the SGA has only been fleetingly consulted in appointing students to institutional bodies in the last two years. For instance, SGA was consulted on which student representatives were to be placed on the Mental Health Task Force and Well-Being Working Group, but SGA was not consulted on which students would be placed on the Second Commission on Undergraduate Education (CUE2), the Public Investment Interest Advisory Committee (PIIAC), the Homewood Council on Inclusive Excellence (HCIE), or the Diversity Leadership Council (DLC). The SGA was able to provide suggested nominees for positions such as JHU's representative to the Maryland Higher Education Commission (MHEC), yet MHEC retained the final choice of JHU's student representative. Moreover, there remain several institutional committees or councils, from the Board of Trustees to the Homewood Academic Council, that lack a student representative. In the case of the HCIE and DLC, it is serendipitous that the leaders of each organization deliberately attempt to include SGA members each year, though still the selection of undergraduate representatives is based on the councils' rather than the SGA.
4. Oversight of almost 400 student groups not chartered through the Center for Social Concern, the Dean of Student Life, an academic department or Homewood Arts.
The SGA accredits over four-hundred student organizations on Homewood campus that are not otherwise advised by the CSC, directly by DOSI, or by an academic department or Homewood Arts. The SGA is responsible for appropriating over $200,000 of monies from the Parents’ Fund to these four-hundred student organizations each year, while also appropriating monthly grants to those groups that require emergency funding for events or programs. Furthermore, the SGA ensures student organizations adhere and comply to University guidelines, lest violating organizations be stripped of recognition in the coming academic year. This is a common feature of peer institutions’ student governments, though in the case of the most impactful student governments - Duke, Princeton, UC-Berkeley - the SGA is granted more student- rather than staff-based oversight of student groups; and the proportion of SGA energies spent on student organization management (compared to student advocacy) is lower.
5. Management of $20,000 in stimulus spending for student and student group ventures, projects, and funding requests
The SGA itself is endowed with $20,000 in funding, which it uses both for internal operations and funding to distribute to groups with whom it co-sponsors events and initiatives. For example, the SGA allocated funding to sign-printing for the Ballots Not Bullets demonstrations of Spring 2018, as well as to food and drinks for the mental health accessibility Well-Fest in Fall 2017. This funding is also used to support student groups who seek funding beyond their annual SAC funding allocation and monthly grants, and are now seeking funding from additional sources like
SGA or academic departments. However, SGA’s own funding is in fact lower than in the past. As late as the 2011-2012 academic year, it was as high as $40,000.
6. Issue monthly stimulus grants through its executive financial arm, the Student Activities Commission.
The Student Activities Commission (SAC), chaired by the SGA’s Executive Treasurer, offers student groups an additional financial resource to further pursue organizational objectives. The primary focus of the SAC is to allocate annual budgets to existing students groups, after reviewing their previous year’s operations. Furthermore, the SAC allocates monthly grants to student groups who require funding for unexpected expenses, new initiatives or ideas, or if that S.A.C. has requested for the grant after the primary contact has previously communicated with a commissioner. The annual funding for SAC grants comes from the Parents Fund and consists of $200,000, to be allocated at the discretion of the Executive Treasurer.
7. The ability to deliver formal recommendations on University policy to administrators, as effectualized in the form of resolutions, public statements, meetings, and letter or email communications.
The SGA is the recognized representative voting body for undergraduates at JHU, and therefore, recommendations from the SGA are assumed to be fulfilling the wishes of the demographic it serves. Other than referenda, resolutions are considered the highest form of recommendation from the SGA. Resolutions must pass through the Senate with a majority vote. Public statements made by SGA are an official stance of the SGA on potentially contentious issues affecting the JHU community and intend to represent the beliefs held by a majority of JHU students. Furthermore, JHU’s administration has previously acknowledged the prominence of SGA’s representation by meeting with SGA representatives per request and on sitting committees where SGA has representation. Lastly, the SGA Executive Board harnesses letter and email communication to transmit these recommendations to all administrators and the Board of Trustees, as its communications are considered to speak on behalf of the undergraduate student body.
8. Regular monthly meetings with certain administrators, such as the Dean of Student Life, and the Deans of the Krieger and Whiting Schools.
SGA regularly meets with Deans whose daily work and decisions have an impact on all or many undergraduate students, on behalf of all or many undergraduate students. Current SGA pursuits, student grievances, student ideas, and valuable discussion on the undergraduate academic and non-academic environment fall under the scope of these meetings, allowing the Deans to gain insight into daily student life and giving SGA the opportunity to collaborate with administrators who have a vested interest in bettering the lives of undergraduate students. Furthermore, regular meetings are necessary such that a consistent line of communication be kept between the aforementioned Deans and the undergraduate students body that allows for discussion and understanding on behalf of both parties in all areas in which the two parties have a vested interests, especially those that are potentially contentious or would have a lasting effects on the university as a whole.
<u>9. Productive annual meetings with the President and Provost.</u>
Student Government's meetings with the President and Provost allows for valuable facetime with administrative leadership on behalf of the students. These meetings allow the President, Provost and other JHU Deans to discuss pressing concerns facing the undergraduate student body and gain an understanding of the JHU climate from the perspective of a JHU undergraduate (via SGA as their representatives). Furthermore, SGA has an opportunity to present projects it has decided to pursue and formally ask for the President's, Provost's, and Deans' support on these projects. The open dialogue at this meeting helps to foster a relationship between the current SGA and the administrators who so often work together to better the school. Lastly, the President, Provost, and Deans in attendance can offer valuable insight as to how SGA's specific goals can be attained and as to how SGA can overcome systematic difficulties it has faced in the pursuit of its goals.
<u>10. Selection and provision of annual recognition awards, including the George E. Owen Teaching Award, the Staff Excellence and Leadership Award, the Student Leadership and Excellence Award, and the Emerging Student Leader Award.</u>
The George E. Owen teaching award recognizes professors who are committed to teaching and devoted to undergraduates, incentivizing professors to passionately pursue behaviours and habits that benefit the undergraduate students on the JHU campus, in turn creating a culture that fosters learning for undergraduates. The Student Excellence Award for Leadership and Service Staff Award, otherwise known as the Staff Excellence and Leadership Award, also fosters an environment of learning and excellence for undergraduates by recognizing staff members who demonstrate a commitment to helping students in a meaningful way. The Student Excellence Award for Leadership and Service, otherwise know at the Student Leadership and Excellence award, is awarded to students who are passionate about engaging in the JHU community and have contributed greatly to student activities, incentivizing students to partake in extracurricular and cocurricular activities, for the positive growth of both the student and the university. The Emerging Student Leader Award, otherwise known as the Emerging Leader Award, recognizes students who have made new and significant contributions to student activities or show significant improvement and development in their dedication to student activities, thus incentivizing undergraduate students to relentlessly pursue excellence in their extracurricular and cocurricular activities, and in turn, better the undergraduate extracurricular and cocurricular environment for themselves and their peers.
SGA Standing and Democratic Legitimacy
The SGA, per its Constitution, is “the sole representative body of undergraduates at the University.” Furthermore, the SGA was erected “in order to strengthen student unity, represent student interests, and provide a forum for the exchange of ideas.” Indeed, the SGA speaks on behalf of all 6,000 undergraduates across the Krieger School of Arts and Sciences and the Whiting School of Engineering. Today, the SGA executes this duty through a variety of mechanisms, from management of over 400 student organizations on campus to allocation of $200,000 in funds to student groups. However, beyond the borders of SGA operations, SGA also interacts regularly with the student body. Among SGA’s means of interaction are:
1. Outreach & Feedback Mechanisms
I. Communication and Marketing Commission (CMC)
The CMC was founded in 2015 as a means of engaging the student body through online social media interaction. An executive agency chaired by the Executive Secretary and composed of five students, the CMC promotes SGA’s activities to the greater student body through a central website (sga.jhu.edu), social media (Facebook, Twitter, Instagram), and through flyers, videos, and publicity campaigns for SGA events and initiatives.
II. Policy Research and Development Commission
The newly founded Policy Research and Development Commission (PRDC), an executive agency chaired by the Executive Vice President, serves as SGA’s consulting group for policy research, survey design, data analysis, and informational support. The Commission is currently composed of three senior policy advisors: one in the domain of civic engagement and institutional equity; one in the domain of mental health and student wellbeing; and one in the domain of environmental sustainability and University facilities. Each senior policy advisor is tasked with composing reports to the Senate on these realms, and with liaising with leaders of student groups in each domain. Any SGA member can request that the PRDC compose a report on a given issue. In addition, the PRDC houses several of the most recent surveys conducted by the SGA, including the tobacco policy survey and a forthcoming academic culture survey. In the coming months, the PRDC is set to expand to ten members and begin providing on-demand policy consultation to the greater student body.
III. Well-Fest MH Feedback Board
Similar to the structure of “What Do You Want Wednesdays”, SGA’s table at the Fall 2017 Mental Health Well-Fest included a large poster board where students were able to provide their feedback as to how mental health should be improved on campus. Well-Fest involved hundreds of students, of which several visited and contributed to the poster board. Among the feedback collected was the need to destigmatize mental health and provide platforms for mental health discussion, improve faculty and staff training for mental health support, create more stress-relief activities, build a student center, and encourage self-care and healthy habits.
IV. Stomp the Stigma
Stomp The Stigma is a marketing program developed by the SGA Health, Safety and Sustainability Committee that aims to create dialogue on mental health at Johns Hopkins. In its first iteration, during the spring of 2018, the program successfully provided free snacks and mental health support quotes to students in the library during finals period. The program also hosted a successful mental health destigmatization discussion in Levering Hall that brought together several dozen students to discuss barriers to mental health improvement and services provision on campus.
V. “What Do You Want Wednesday”
On a brief hiatus during the past “What Do You Want Wednesdays” were a weekly occurrence where the late SGA Sustainability and Facilities Committee held weekly gatherings in Brody Cafe (on Wednesdays) where students were able to provide feedback to SGA on the current affairs of the campus and physically write what they wanted to see change in the University, in exchange for one Insomnia cookie. Common themes that emerged from these weekly exchanges (and later manifested in SGA initiatives) included building a student center, improving campus mental health, changing academic culture, and reducing the environmental impact of campus facilities.
VI. SGA Ambassadors Program (forthcoming)
The SGA Ambassadors program is a long-time concept that dates back to as early as April 2016, and is set to be operationalized in Fall 2018. The program will assign each SGA member to a specific set of student groups (in particular, student groups with whom SGA has less regular contact, such as groups outside the realms of civic engagement, advocacy, mental health, or sustainability) and the SGA member will be responsible for conducting monthly check-ins with the leaders of each student groups to see if the student group requires aid, assistance, or support from SGA.
VII. SGA Student Advocates Office (forthcoming)
Inspired by the University of California Student Government system, the SGA is considering the creation of a Student Advocates office that will train students in important University policies — such as the Student Code of Conduct, the Ethics Code, and Free Expression Guidelines — so that these students can provide their peers with counsel on how to deal with infractions of, or accusations of infractions of, University policies. This is important given that, at present, students are only informed of their rights and responsibilities by relevant administrators when accused of University policy violations, and no formal peer-based system exists to support students.
2. Active Collaboration with Students and Student Groups
I. Well-Fest
One of SGA's most significant co-sponsorships is the annual mental health Well-Fest. Started by the Mental Health Task Force in October 2016 and since continued by the SGA, Well-Fest brings together every mental health student group (Active Minds, APTT, YesPlus) and every well-being or mental health office in the University (Athletics and Recreation, the Counseling Center, CHEW, Student Health and Wellness) for a campus-wide mental health wellbeing awareness event. Through relaxation and de-stress activities (yoga, athletic mini-games, massages), free giveaways, food and drinks, and informational support, Well-Fest helps students decompress during the first major midterm season. In October 2017, Well-Fest was located on the Levering Courtyard and captured an audience of several hundred students.
II. Suicide Prevention Week
The SGA also supported APO's Suicide Prevention Week in November 2017 by hosting a table with informational packets on mental health resources located around campus.
III. Discourse
After being approached by President Daniels to create an encompassing civic engagement initiative that would engross the student body, SGA assisted a nascent student organization known as Discourse in becoming a recognized student group and hosting public debates on issues ranging from religious freedom to cultural appropriation. Debates hosted by Discourse regularly drew several dozen students.
IV. March for Our Lives/Ballots Not Bullets
In the aftermath of the Parkland shootings in Florida, the SGA organized several buses to the March for Our Lives for students and any JHU affiliate to attend the March. SGA successfully transported several dozen students and even a faculty member to the March. After the March, the SGA continued to engage students by providing a platform for firearm safety advocacy in the form of an initiative known as Ballots Not Bullets, which also hosted a Parkland rally in front of the Beach that drew hundreds of students.
V. Panel Discussions (IDEAL, Hillel)
The SGA supported two fellow student groups in panel discussions this year. The first, with IDEAL, involved Executive Vice President AJ Tsang speaking on a panel about freedom of expression on contemporary university campuses. The second, with Hillel, involved Executive President Noh Mebrahatu speaking on a panel about travelling to Israel and seeing the Israeli-Palestinian conflict with new eyes.
VI. Sustainability Coalition
In order to facilitate more frequent dialogue with the many students engaged in sustainability efforts on campus, the SGA joined the newfound Sustainability Coalition, which includes a host of student groups such as Students for Environmental Action, Refuel Our Future, and Take Back the Tap.
VII. Mental Health Student Group Council
Following the recommendations of the Mental Health Task Force, the SGA is following through on one of the core recommendations of the Task Force, which was to have student governments organize their mental health student groups into a unique category wherein they could communicate and collaborate more frequently on programming and policy advocacy. To that end, the SGA is convening the Mental Health Student Group Council, with membership from all mental health student groups on campus – Active Minds, APTT, YesPlus, and Peabody’s “Peabuddies” – secured. If this Homewood version of the Council is successful, it is SGA’s hope to expand first to the Bloomberg School of Public Health, and then to all JHU campuses.
3. Supporting Students and Student Groups
I. Funding Efforts
Every year, student groups regularly reach out to the SGA to co-sponsor events. Among the events co-sponsored this year and in previous years were:
- FIJI The Push (2016, 2017, 2018)
- FAS Speakers (2016, 2017)
- BlueOut Tailgate (2018)
- SEA Planet Runway (2018)
- SASH Dil Se (2018)
- UMR Muslim
- TCO Hatch Tournament (2018)
- Zachary Steinberg Memorial Tournament (2018)
- Temps D’Afrique Show (2018)
- SLAM Showcase (2018)
II. TCO Labs & Entrepreneurship Groups (Fall 2016 onwards)
In the past two years, the SGA functioned as a key stakeholder in bringing together entrepreneurship groups and the University’s newfound interest in building an innovation ecosystem. Former Executive Vice President Anna Du worked extensively with KSAS Dean Beverly Wendland and WSE Dean Ed Schlesinger to ensure that a student entrepreneurship space could be created in Wyman Park Towers, and later, near R House. In addition, she worked with Darius Graham, the director of JHU Tech Ventures (JHTV), to increase the interaction of Homewood’s student entrepreneurship groups with the University’s wider innovation ecosystem. A recent example is that in the spring of 2018, freshmen Justin Sech approached the SGA about creating a biotech lab space for undergraduates on campus. SGA members were able to connect him with JHU Tech Ventures.
III. Web Design Club (Spring 2017)
In the Spring of 2017, the nascent Web Design club faced significant difficulties in registering itself as a student group. Though the Student Organizations Committee found the group to be of merit, the digital media category coordinator found the group to overlap too much with the work of her office, and thus denied the group existence. In response, the SGA supported the Web Design club in overturning the category coordinator’s decision and adding the club to the roster of recognized student groups.
IV. IDEAL/STRUT (Spring 2018)
The SGA supported IDEAL’s effort to begin a collaborative program with local Baltimore schools on civic education. The SGA not only funded part of the initial effort, but members of SGA also provided behind-the-scenes support to IDEAL that allowed it to gain financial support from the IDEAL Lab Competition.
V. Advocates for Immigrant Health (Spring 2018)
After logistical issues with Hopkins Groups, SGA facilitated the accreditation of a student group dedicated to advocacy for migrant health rights.
4. Collaboration with Institutional Bodies
I. Mental Health Task Force
The SGA represented the undergraduate student body on the Mental Health Task Force for the entirety of the Task Force’s existence. In fact, SGA’s representative, AJ Tsang, was one of only two student representatives to attend each Task Force meeting (the other was the student representative from the Bloomberg School of Public Health). All other student representatives, especially those selected by administrators, eventually left or stopped attending Task Force meetings.
II. Mental Health Working Group
The SGA continues to represent the undergraduate student body on the Mental Health and Well-Being Working Group, which is tasked with improving student well-being on campus and implementing the recommendations of the Mental Health Task Force. SGA currently has two representatives on the Working Group - Executive Vice President AJ Tsang and Executive Secretary Aspen Williams.
III. Homewood Council on Inclusive Excellence (HCIE)
SGA also collaborates with and has representation on the Homewood Council for Inclusive Excellence. AJ Tsang (SGA Executive Vice President) and Madelynn Wellons (SGA Junior Class Senator) are both members of this council, and as a result of that they are better able to represent the student body. HCIE brings together a diverse group of students, faculty, and other Hopkins community members, and through their work, they promote diversity and inclusion on the Homewood campus. As SGA members are involved in these conversations and this work, they are better able to represent the increasingly diverse study body and are up to date on issues and opinions the students hold regarding diversity on the campus.
IV. Diversity Leadership Council (DLC)
The SGA has increased student representation on the Diversity Leadership Council, which advocates for further diversity and inclusion efforts across all nine divisions of the University. In the last year, the SGA had two representatives on the DLC: Anthony Boutros and AJ Tsang.
V. Faculty Assembly
Since April 2018, the SGA regularly sends representatives to present at the Faculty Assembly and inform faculty about current issues facing students. In addition, SGA regularly requests the aid of faculty in pushing forward its initiatives. For example, this spring, faculty expressed a willingness to add mental health information to their syllabi as well as support student efforts to build a student center.
VII. SVAC and Monument Quilt
The SGA provided financial support to CHEW for the Monument Quilt in September 2017. In addition, the SGA offered volunteers to set up the Monument Quilt.
5. Elections, Surveys and Referenda
I. Elections
SGA elections occur annually and represent an opportunity for students to engage regularly in the democratic operations of the SGA. In recent years, students engaging in pure policy advocacy have joined issue-specific advocacy groups rather than SGA, but SGA involvement remains notable.
In the past ten years, the median electoral turnout for Executive Elections has been approximately 1500 students (about 30% of eligible voters), and has been as high as 2700 students (50% of eligible voters). This is in line with peer institutions. The median electoral turnout for Spring Class Council elections has been similar among each class, and the median electoral turnout for Fall Class Council elections (the freshmen class) has been 600 students (50% of eligible voters). In addition, eight of the last ten executive elections have been fully competitive (where at least three positions have two or more candidates running). Though it is known that rising senior classes tend to see decreased turnout and candidate counts, SGA research indicates that this is attributable to how upperclassmen on campus have no central place to congregate and live in locations scattered across Charles Village, making it difficult for rising seniors to collect election signatures.
Elections have also yielded increasingly diverse SGAs. In the last ten years, the SGA has become increasingly demographically representative of the student body. Whereas the Executive Board was majority-white as late as 2015, the 2017-2018 Executive Board was the first to be composed entirely of people of color. In fact, over 80% of 2017-2018 SGA members were people of color or underrepresented minorities, and over 50% of 2017-2018 SGA members were women. Several SGA members were also first-generation college students. The future of the SGA also appears diverse; of the last four freshmen class councils, three were minority-majority. A faculty member who attended an SGA meeting this year even remarked that, “Your SGA is more diverse than any of my classes.”
II. Surveys
The SGA has conducted and will continue to conduct surveys to evaluate student feedback. Two of the largest surveys SGA conducted were in 2014 and 2018, both on the University’s tobacco policies. The final survey report can be found here.
III. Referenda
Referenda, though perhaps common in real-life government, is designed to be a rare occurrence in the SGA due to the fact that SGA itself is expected to speak on behalf of the student body. The SGA, in an effort to re-establish itself with the democratic norms of the 21st century, is working to break decades-old tradition and make referenda into a more regular occurrence. In fact, the SGA is planning to host an omnibus referendum in Fall 2018. The referendum will allow students to vote on issues such as fossil fuel divestment, tobacco policy, building a student center, and more. It is hoped that this referendum will further change the SGA Constitution to allow regular referenda.
JOHNS HOPKINS STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION
POWERS & AUTHORITIES INITIATIVE
Background Document on PIHAC
Table of Contents
1. Background
- a.History of SGA Powers & Authorities
- b.Itemized Description of Existing SGA Powers & Authorities
- c.Democratic Standing and Legitimacy
2. PIIAC Membership Proposal
- a.Proposal
- b.Institutional Benefits
- c.Investment Benefits
- d.Administrative Benefits
- e.Student Benefits
3. Peer Institution Exemplars
- a.General Student Representation on Institutional Bodies
- b.Princeton University (1971 to present)
- c.Harvard University (1983 to present)
- d.MIT (2000 to present)
Abridged History of SGA Powers & Authorities
The SGA’s existing powers and authorities with regards to the University can be traced to the emergence of the Student Council in the 1920s. At that point in time, the Student Council was housed in the Merrick Barn and was responsible for working with the Dean of Students, then the only student affairs professional at the University, to manage student activities fees and tuition. By the 1960s, increasing student activism on a national level led the Student Council to lead several additional initiatives, including the endowment of annual leadership awards and selection of the Commencement speaker. By the dawn of the twenty-first century, the SGA managed the accreditation of several hundred student organizations. The SGA was so expansive that it even appointed the chairs of FAS, MSE, and the HOP. Kwame Alston, 2018 Senior Class President, remarked that in the era of the first African-American Executive President of the SGA, the Senior Class Council even had veto power over the Commencement speaker. However, after the publication of the first Commission on Undergraduate Education (CUE) report in the early 2000s, SGA’s explicit powers and authorities began to diminish as management of student activities was shifted from peer-based management to staff-based management. SGA influence waned especially after the departure of Dean of Student Life Susan Boswell in 2013 and Director of Student Life Rob Turing in 2014.
Meanwhile, since undergraduates are not empowered with distinctive influence over the operations and service provision of the University, SGA has been dependent on dialogue throughout its history to engage in policy advocacy. Certainly, the SGA has always and continues to meet with administrators, especially as more were brought to the University, but it has often been left to SGA to make the first step to continue dialogue with administrators, rather than a mutual effort. Today, as a result, SGA has been left primarily with political or symbolic means of advocating for students - holding forums, composing resolutions, and transmitting student concerns to entities that often took courses of action in opposition to student concerns - rather than retaining access to institutional bodies that control long-term decision-making for the University or tangible day-to-day policies.
Itemized Description of Existing SGA Powers & Authorities
The following section contains descriptions of SGA’s existing abilities in regards to the University at-large. This section does not pertain directly to SGA legislation, which is considered an internal function that facilitates external operations.
1. Selection and confirmation of student representatives to the Krieger Curriculum Committee and the Whiting Curriculum Committee, including the Chair of the Academic Affairs Committee.
The SGA has been historically authorized to select the five student members of both the Krieger and Whiting Schools’ Curriculum Committees, which are standing committees responsible for advising the Homewood Academic Council on changes to curriculum. In the early fall of each academic year, members of each school’s dean’s staff reach out to SGA and ask for SGA to procure and confirm five student members of each committee. In addition, the SGA Academic Affairs Committee chair is granted ex-officio membership on both Curriculum Committees.
To select the five student members of each Curriculum Committee, the SGA Academic Affairs Committee conducts an open application process, evaluates applicants through a criterion-based rubric of expertise with University academic policy and ability to advocate for student viewpoints, and the ten total nominees are presented to the SGA Senate for review and confirmation. The student members’ names are then passed on to the deans of Krieger and Whiting.
2. Confirmation of student nominees to the Ethics Board.
The SGA has been historically authorized to confirm nominees to the Ethics Board that have been identified and screened by a subcommittee of current Ethics Board members. The Ethics Board subcommittee extends an open application to the student body, then evaluates applicants on their moral integrity and ability to apply the Academic Ethics Code to test cases or simulacra. When the nominees have been prepared, the Director of Student Conduct or a member of the Ethics Board presents the final nominees to the SGA Senate, whereupon the nominees are presented to the SGA Senate for review and confirmation.
3. Selection and recommendation of student nominees to certain University-wide entities, such as the Mental Health Task Force and Mental Well-Being Working Group.
The SGA, as the primary representative body of the student population on Homewood, has historically been vested with the right to appoint all student representatives on any
University-wide entity. However, the SGA has only been fleetingly consulted in appointing students to institutional bodies in the last two years. For instance, SGA was consulted on which student representatives were to be placed on the Mental Health Task Force and Well-Being Working Group, but SGA was not consulted on which students would be placed on the Second Commission on Undergraduate Education (CUE2), the Public Investment Interest Advisory Committee (PIIAC), the Homewood Council on Inclusive Excellence (HCIE), or the Diversity Leadership Council (DLC). The SGA was able to provide suggested nominees for positions such as JHU’s representative to the Maryland Higher Education Commission (MHEC), yet MHEC retained the final choice of JHU’s student representative. Moreover, there remain several institutional committees or councils, from the Board of Trustees to the Homewood Academic Council, that lack a student representative. In the case of the HCIE and DLC, it is serendipitous that the leaders of each organization deliberately attempt to include SGA members each year, though still the selection of undergraduate representatives is based on the councils’ rather than the SGA.
__4. Oversight of almost 400 student groups not chartered through the Center for Social Concern, the Dean of Student Life, an academic department or Homewood Arts.__
The SGA accredits over four-hundred student organizations on Homewood campus that are not otherwise advised by the CCG, directly by DOSL, or by an academic department or Homewood Arts. The SGA is responsible for appropriating over $200,000 of monies from the Parents’ Fund to these four-hundred student organizations each year, while also appropriating monthly grants to those groups that require emergency funding for events or programs. Furthermore, the SGA ensures student organizations adhere and comply to University guidelines, lest violating organizations be stripped of recognition in the coming academic year. This is a common feature of peer institutions’ student governments, though in the case of the most impactful student governments - Duke, Princeton, UC-Berkeley - the SGA is granted more student- rather than staff-based oversight of student groups, and the proportion of SGA energies spent on student organization management (compared to student advocacy) is lower.
__5. Management of $20,000 in stimulus spending for student and student group ventures, projects, and funding requests__
The SGA itself is endowed with $20,000 in funding, which it uses both for internal operations and funding to distribute to groups with whom it co-sponsors events and initiatives. For example, the SGA allocated funding to sign-printing for the Ballots Not Bullets demonstrations of Spring 2018, as well as to food and drinks for the mental health accessibility Well-Fest in Fall 2017. This funding is also used to support student groups who seek funding beyond their annual SAC funding allocation and monthly grants, and are now seeking funding from additional sources like
SGA or academic departments. However, SGA’s own funding is in fact lower than in the past. As late as the 2011-2012 academic year, it was as high as $40,000.
<u>6. Issue monthly stimulus grants through its executive financial arm, the Student Activities Commission.</u>
The Student Activities Commission (SAC), chaired by the SGA’s Executive Treasurer, offers student groups an additional financial resource to further pursue organizational objectives. The primary focus of the SAC is to allocate annual budgets to existing students groups, after reviewing their previous year’s operations. Furthermore, the SAC allocates monthly grants to student groups who require funding for unexpected expenses, new initiatives or ideas, or if that S.A.C. has requested for the grant after the primary contact has previously communicated with a commissioner. The annual funding for SAC grants comes from the Parents Fund and consists of $200,000, to be allocated at the discretion of the Executive Treasurer.
<u>7. The ability to deliver formal recommendations on University policy to administrators, as effectualized in the form of resolutions, public statements, meetings, and letter or email communications.</u>
The SGA is the recognized representative voting body for undergraduates at JHU, and therefore, recommendations from the SGA are assumed to be fulfilling the wishes of the demographic it serves. Other than referenda, resolutions are considered the highest form of recommendation from the SGA. Resolutions must pass through the Senate with a majority vote. Public statements made by SGA are an official stance of the SGA on potentially contentious issues affecting the JHU community and intend to represent the beliefs held by a majority of JHU students. Furthermore, JHU’s administration has previously acknowledged the prominence of SGA’s representation by meeting with SGA representatives per request and on sitting committees where SGA has representation. Lastly, the SGA Executive Board harnesses letter and email communication to transmit these recommendations to all administrators and the Board of Trustees, as its communications are considered to speak on behalf of the undergraduate student body.
<u>8. Regular monthly meetings with certain administrators, such as the Dean of Student Life, and the Deans of the Krieger and Whiting Schools.</u>
SGA regularly meets with Deans whose daily work and decisions have an impact on all or many undergraduate students, on behalf of all or many undergraduate students. Current SGA pursuits, student grievances, student ideas, and valuable discussion on the undergraduate academic and non-academic environment fall under the scope of these meetings, allowing the Deans to gain.
insight into daily student life and giving SGA the opportunity to collaborate with administrators who have a vested interest in bettering the lives of undergraduate students. Furthermore, regular meetings are necessary such that a consistent line of communication be kept between the aforementioned Deans and the undergraduate students body that allows for discussion and understanding on behalf of both parties in all areas in which the two parties have a vested interests, especially those that are potentially contentious or would have a lasting effects on the university as a whole.
<u>9. Productive annual meetings with the President and Provost.</u>
Student Government’s meetings with the President and Provost allows for valuable facetime with administrative leadership on behalf of the students. These meetings allow the President, Provost and other JHU Deans to discuss pressing concerns facing the undergraduate student body and gain an understanding of the JHU climate from the perspective of a JHU undergraduate (via SGA as their representatives). Furthermore, SGA has an opportunity to present projects it has decided to pursue and formally ask for the President’s, Provost’s, and Deans support on these projects. The open dialogue at this meeting helps to foster a relationship between the current SGA and the administrators who so often work together to better the school. Lastly, the President, Provost, and Deans in attendance can offer valuable insight as to how SGA’s specific goals can be attained and as to how SGA can overcome systematic difficulties it has faced in the pursuit of its goals.
<u>10. Selection and provision of annual recognition awards, including the George E. Owen Teaching Award, the Staff Excellence and Leadership Award, the Student Leadership and Excellence Award, and the Emerging Student Leader Award.</u>
The George E. Owen teaching award recognizes professors who are committed to teaching and devoted to undergraduates, incentivizing professors to passionately pursue behaviours and habits that benefit the undergraduate students on the JHU campus, in turn creating a culture that fosters learning for undergraduates. The Student Excellence Award for Leadership and Service Staff Award, otherwise known as the Staff Excellence and Leadership Award, also fosters an environment of learning and excellence for undergraduates by recognizing staff members who demonstrate a commitment to helping students in a meaningful way. The Student Excellence Award for Leadership and Service, otherwise know at the Student Leadership and Excellence award, is awarded to students who are passionate about engaging in the JHU community and have contributed greatly to student activities, incentivizing students to partake in extracurricular and cocurricular activities, for the positive growth of both the student and the university. The Emerging Student Leader Award, otherwise known as the Emerging Leader Award, recognizes students who have made new and significant contributions to student activities or show significant improvement and development in their dedication to student activities, thus incentivizing undergraduate students to relentlessly pursue excellence in their extracurricular and cocurricular activities; and in turn, better the undergraduate extracurricular and cocurricular environment for themselves and their peers.
SGA Standing and Democratic Legitimacy
The SGA, per its Constitution, is “the sole representative body of undergraduates at the University.” Furthermore, the SGA was erected “in order to strengthen student unity, represent student interests, and provide a forum for the exchange of ideas.” Indeed, the SGA speaks on behalf of all 6,000 undergraduates across the Krieger School of Arts and Sciences and the Whiting School of Engineering. Today, the SGA executes this duty through a variety of mechanisms, from management of over 400 student organizations on campus to allocation of $200,000 in funds to student groups. However, beyond the borders of SGA operations, SGA also interacts regularly with the student body. Among SGA’s means of interaction are:
I. Outreach & Feedback Mechanisms
I. Communication and Marketing Commission (CMC)
The CMC was founded in 2015 as a means of engaging the student body through online social media interaction. An executive agency chaired by the Executive Secretary and composed of five students, the CMC promotes SGA’s activities to the greater student body through a central website (sga.jhu.edu), social media (Facebook, Twitter, Instagram), and through flyers, videos, and publicity campaigns for SGA events and initiatives.
[handwritten: SGA@jhu.edu]
II. Policy Research and Development Commission
The newly founded Policy Research and Development Commission (PRDC), an executive agency chaired by the Executive Vice President, serves as SGA’s consulting group for policy research, survey design, data analysis, and informational support. The Commission is currently composed of three senior policy advisors: one in the domain of civic engagement and institutional equity; one in the domain of mental health and student wellbeing; and one in the domain of environmental sustainability and University facilities. Each senior policy advisor is tasked with composing reports to the Senate on these realms, and with liaising with leaders of student groups in each domain. Any SGA member can request that the PRDC compose a report on a given issue. In addition, the PRDC houses several of the most recent surveys conducted by the SGA, including the tobacco policy survey and a forthcoming academic culture survey. In the coming months, the PRDC is set to expand to ten members and begin providing on-demand policy consultation to the greater student body.
III. Well-Fest MH Feedback Board
Similar to the structure of “What Do You Want Wednesdays”, SGA’s table at the Fall 2017 Mental Health Well-Fest included a large poster board where students were able to provide their feedback as to how mental health should be improved on campus. Well-Fest involved hundreds of students, of which several visited and contributed to the poster board. Among the feedback collected was the need to destigmatize mental health and provide platforms for mental health discussion, improve faculty and staff training for mental health support, create more stress-relief activities, build a student center, and encourage self-care and healthy habits.
IV. Stomp the Stigma
Stomp The Stigma is a marketing program developed by the SGA Health, Safety and Sustainability Committee that aims to create dialogue on mental health at Johns Hopkins. In its first iteration, during the spring of 2018, the program successfully provided free snacks and mental health support quotes to students in the library during finals period. The program also hosted a successful mental health destigmatization discussion in Levering Hall that brought together several dozen students to discuss barriers to mental health improvement and services provision on campus.
V. “What Do You Want Wednesday”
On a brief hiatus during the past, “What Do You Want Wednesdays” were a weekly occurrence, where the [unclear: late] SGA Sustainability and Facilities Committee held weekly gatherings in Brody Café (on Wednesdays) where students were able to provide feedback to SGA on the current affairs of the campus and physically write what they wanted to see change in the University, in exchange for one Insomnia cookie. Common themes that emerged from these weekly exchanges (and later manifested in SGA initiatives) included building a student center, improving campus mental health, changing academic culture, and reducing the environmental impact of campus facilities.
VI. SGA Ambassadors Program (forthcoming)
The SGA Ambassadors program is a long-time concept that dates back to as early as April 2016, and is set to be operationalized in Fall 2018. The program will assign each SGA member to a specific set of student groups (in particular, student groups with whom SGA has less regular contact, such as groups outside the realms of civic engagement, advocacy, mental health, or sustainability) and the SGA member will be responsible for conducting monthly check-ins with the leaders of each student group to see if the student group requires aid, assistance, or support from SGA.
VII. SGA Student Advocates Office (forthcoming)
Inspired by the University of California Student Government system, the SGA is considering the creation of a Student Advocates office that will train students in important University policies – such as the Student Code of Conduct, the Ethics Code, and Free Expression Guidelines – so that these students can provide their peers with counsel on how to deal with infractions of, or accusations of infractions of University policies. This is important given that, at present, students are only informed of their rights and responsibilities by relevant administrators when accused of University policy violations, and no formal peer-based system exists to support students.
2. Active Collaboration with Students and Student Groups
I. Well-Fest
One of SGA’s most significant co-sponsorships is the annual mental health Well-Fest. Started by the Mental Health Task Force in October 2016 and since continued by the SGA, Well-Fest brings together every mental health student group (Active Minds, APITT, YesPlus) and every well-being or mental health office in the University (Athletics and Recreation, the Counseling Center, CHEW, Student Health and Wellness) for a campus-wide mental health wellbeing awareness event. Through relaxation and de-stress activities (yoga, athletic mini-games, massages), free giveaways, food and drinks, and informational support, Well-Fest helps students decompress during the first major midterm season. In October 2017, Well-Fest was located on the Levering Courtyard and captured an audience of several hundred students.
II. Suicide Prevention Week
The SGA also supported APO’s Suicide Prevention Week in November 2017 by hosting a table with informational packets on mental health resources located around campus.
III. Discourse
After being approached by President Daniels to create an encompassing civic engagement initiative that would engross the student body, SGA assisted a nascent student organization known as Discourse in becoming a recognized student group and hosting public debates on issues ranging from religious freedom to cultural appropriation. Debates hosted by Discourse regularly drew several dozen students.
IV. March for Our Lives/Ballots Not Bullets
In the aftermath of the Parkland shootings in Florida, the SGA organized several buses to the March for Our Lives for students and any JHU affiliate to attend the March. SGA successfully transported several dozen students and even a faculty member to the March. After the March, the SGA continued to engage students by providing a platform for firearm safety advocacy in the form of an initiative known as Ballots Not Bullets, which also hosted a Parkland rally in front of the Beach that drew hundreds of students.
V. Panel Discussions (IDEAL, Hillel)
The SGA supported two fellow student groups in panel discussions this year. The first, with IDEAL, involved Executive Vice President AJ Tsang speaking on a panel about freedom of expression on contemporary university campuses. The second, with Hillel, involved Executive President Noh Mebrahtu speaking on a panel about travelling to Israel and seeing the Israeli-Palestinian conflict with new eyes.
VI. Sustainability Coalition
In order to facilitate more frequent dialogue with the many students engaged in sustainability efforts on campus, the SGA joined the newfound Sustainability Coalition, which includes a host of student groups such as Students for Environmental Action, Refuel Our Future, and Take Back the Tap.
VII. Mental Health Student Group Council
Following the recommendations of the Mental Health Task Force, the SGA is following through on one of the core recommendations of the Task Force, which was to have student governments organize their mental health student groups into a unique category wherein they could communicate and collaborate more frequently on programming and policy advocacy. To that end, the SGA is convening the Mental Health Student Group Council, with membership from all mental health student groups on campus – Active Minds, APTT, YesPlus, and Peabody’s “Peabuddies” – secured. If this Homewood version of the Council is successful, it is SGA’s hope to expand first to the Bloomberg School of Public Health, and then to all JHU campuses.
3. Supporting Students and Student Groups
I. Funding Efforts
Every year, student groups regularly reach out to the SGA to co-sponsor events. Among the events co-sponsored this year and in previous years were:
- FJI The Push (2016, 2017, 2018)
- FAS Speakers (2016, 2017)
- BlueOut Tailgate (2018)
- SEA Planet Runway (2018)
- SASH Dil Se (2018)
- UMR Muslim
- TCO Hatch Tournament (2018)
- Zachary Steinberg Memorial Tournament (2018)
- Temps D’Afrique Show (2018)
- SLAM Showcase (2018)
II. TCO Labs & Entrepreneurship Groups (Fall 2016 onwards)
In the past two years, the SGA functioned as a key stakeholder in bringing together entrepreneurship groups and the University’s newfound interest in building an innovation ecosystem. Former Executive Vice President Anna Du worked extensively with KSAS Dean Beverly Wendland and WSE Dean Ed Schlesinger to ensure that a student entrepreneurship space could be created in Wyman Park Towers, and later, near R House. In addition, she worked with Darius Graham, the director of JHU Tech Ventures (JHTV), to increase the interaction of Homewood’s student entrepreneurship groups with the University’s wider innovation ecosystem. A recent example is that in the spring of 2018, freshmen Justin Sech approached the SGA about creating a biotech lab space for undergraduates on campus. SGA members were able to connect him with JHU Tech Ventures.
III. Web Design Club (Spring 2017)
In the Spring of 2017, the nascent Web Design club faced significant difficulties in registering itself as a student group. Though the Student Organizations Committee found the group to be of merit, the digital media category coordinator found the group to overlap too much with the work of her office, and thus denied the group existence. In response, the SGA supported the Web Design club in overturning the category coordinator’s decision and adding the club to the roster of recognized student groups.
IV. IDEAL/STRUT (Spring 2018)
The SGA supported IDEAL’s effort to begin a collaborative program with local Baltimore schools on civic education. The SGA not only funded part of the initial effort, but members of SGA also provided behind-the-scenes support to IDEAL that allowed it to gain financial support from the IDEAL Lab Competition.
V. Advocates for Immigrant Health (Spring 2018)
After logistical issues with Hopkins Groups, SGA facilitated the accreditation of a student group dedicated to advocacy for migrant health rights.
4. Collaboration with Institutional Bodies
I. Mental Health Task Force
The SGA represented the undergraduate student body on the Mental Health Task Force for the entirety of the Task Force’s existence. In fact, SGA’s representative, AJ Tsang, was one of only two student representatives to attend each Task Force meeting (the other was the student representative from the Bloomberg School of Public Health). All other student representatives, especially those selected by administrators, eventually left or stopped attending Task Force meetings.
II. Mental Health Working Group
The SGA continues to represent the undergraduate student body on the Mental Health and Well-Being Working Group, which is tasked with improving student well-being on campus and implementing the recommendations of the Mental Health Task Force. SGA currently has two representatives on the Working Group - Executive Vice President AJ Tsang and Executive Secretary Aspen Williams.
III. Homewood Council on Inclusive Excellence (HCIE)
SGA also collaborates with and has representation on the Homewood Council for Inclusive Excellence. AJ Tsang (SGA Executive Vice President) and Madelynn Wellons (SGA Junior Class Senator) are both members of this council, and as a result of that they are better able to represent the student body. HCIE brings together a diverse group of students, faculty, and other Hopkins community members, and through their work, they promote diversity and inclusion on the Homewood campus. As SGA members are involved in these conversations and this work, they are better able to represent the increasingly diverse study body and are up to date on issues and opinions the students hold regarding diversity on the campus.
IV. Diversity Leadership Council (DLC)
The SGA has increased student representation on the Diversity Leadership Council, which advocates for further diversity and inclusion efforts across all nine divisions of the University. In the last year, the SGA had two representatives on the DLC: Anthony Boutros and AJ Tsang.
V. Faculty Assembly
Since April 2018, the SGA regularly sends representatives to present at the Faculty Assembly and inform faculty about current issues facing students. In addition, SGA regularly requests the aid of faculty in pushing forward its initiatives. For example, this spring, faculty expressed a willingness to add mental health information to their syllabi as well as support student efforts to build a student center.
VII. SVAC and Monument Quilt
The SGA provided financial support to CHEW for the Monument Quilt in September 2017. In addition, the SGA offered volunteers to set up the Monument Quilt.
5. Elections, Surveys and Referenda
I. Elections
SGA elections occur annually and represent an opportunity for students to engage regularly in the democratic operations of the SGA. In recent years, students engaging in pure policy advocacy have joined issue-specific advocacy groups rather than SGA, but SGA involvement remains notable.
In the past ten years, the median electoral turnout for Executive Elections has been approximately 1500 students (about 30% of eligible voters), and has been as high as 2700 students (60% of eligible voters). This is in line with peer institutions. The median electoral turnout for Spring Class Council elections has been similar among each class, and the median electoral turnout for Fall Class Council elections (the freshmen class) has been 600 students (50% of eligible voters). In addition, eight of the last ten executive elections have been fully competitive (where at least three positions have two or more candidates running). Though it is known that rising senior classes tend to see decreased turnout and candidate counts, SGA research indicates that this is attributable to how upperclassmen on campus have no central place to congregate and live in locations scattered across Charles Village, making it difficult for rising seniors to collect election signatures.
Elections have also yielded increasingly diverse SGAs. In the last ten years, the SGA has become increasingly demographically representative of the student body. Whereas the Executive Board was majority-white as late as 2015, the 2017-2018 Executive Board was the first to be composed entirely of people of color. In fact, over 80% of 2017-2018 SGA members were people of color or underrepresented minorities, and over 50% of 2017-2018 SGA members were women. Several SGA members were also first-generation college students. The future of the SGA also appears diverse: of the last four freshmen class councils, three were minority-majority. A faculty member who attended an SGA meeting this year even remarked that, “Your SGA is more diverse than any of my classes.”
II. Surveys
The SGA has conducted and will continue to conduct surveys to evaluate student feedback. Two of the largest surveys SGA conducted were in 2014 and 2018, both on the University’s tobacco policies. The final survey report can be found here.
III. Referenda
Referenda, though perhaps common in real-life government, is designed to be a rare occurrence in the SGA due to the fact that SGA itself is expected to speak on behalf of the student body. The SGA, in an effort to re-establish itself with the democratic norms of the 21st century, is working to break decades-old tradition and make referenda into a more regular occurrence. In fact, the SGA is planning to host an omnibus referendum in Fall 2018. The referendum will allow students to vote on issues such as fossil fuel divestment, tobacco policy, building a student center, and more. It is hoped that this referendum will further change the SGA Constitution to allow regular referenda.
PIAC MEMBERSHIP PROPOSAL
PROPOSAL
The SGA strongly believes that the Executive President and Vice President should be annually placed on PIIAC as voting members and the primary representatives of the student body. In the past, SGA has not been granted explicitly seats on PIIAC, nor has it been granted the ability to select the undergraduate students placed on PIIAC. This places the University and its student body at a serious disadvantage, as the viewpoint of students is not fully democratically represented and the University cannot be fully certain that the student representatives on PIIAC are speaking with the intent of the student body. As such, the University’s long-term investments, whose ramifications impact student life and future alumni donations, are negatively impacted when PIIAC does not include explicit student representation. At minimum, PIIAC should thus include the Executive President and Vice President as full voting members.
The SGA further advises that PIIAC move towards the model of Princeton University, if not create a completely new committee based on Princeton’s best practices. At Princeton, the equivalent of PIIAC is known as the Council of the Princeton University Community (CPUC). Led by the President of Princeton University, CPUC brings together every single stakeholder group (faculty, students, staff and alumni) and allows those stakeholder groups to select their own representatives to the group. Moreover, the CPUC’s six annual meetings (and accompanying minutes dating back to 2014) are all open to the public, and its agendas are directly set by public comment. CPUC is also more encompassing in its guidance of Princeton’s long-term agenda-setting than PIIAC is for Johns Hopkins. CPUC has dedicated subcommittees responsible for continuously evaluating institutional governance, continuously evaluating institutional resource allocation, institutional internal regulation and compliance. Having existed since the 1970s, CPUC demonstrates that a University can cultivate a more inclusive atmosphere when all stakeholders are granted shares and say in the University’s long-term development.
Thus, the SGA implores PIIAC to amend the “Procedures for Governance of the Public Interest Investment Advisory Committee” such that in the section titled, “Committee Membership,” an additional sentence be added to the end of Clause 3 that reads, “The undergraduate student representatives on PIIAC shall be the Student Government Association Executive President and Vice President.”
INSTITUTIONAL BENEFITS
From an institutional standpoint, seating the SGA Executive President and Vice President as voting members of PIIAC would provide substantial benefits to the University.
First, the University would be able to assert that the student body is directly represented on PIIAC, due to the fact that the SGA Executive President and Vice President are elected by the student body as a whole. The University could thus, in the face of any dissent to the contrary, claim that the voice of the student body is definitively represented in investment decisions and investment recommendations made by the University. This is especially pertinent as the most recent undergraduate on PIIAC, Yadel Okorie ('17), was considered controversial among segments of the student body not for his positions (in fact, he was widely respected for his cautious politics), but because he was not a duly elected representative of the student body.
Second, in representing the student body, the SGA Executive President and Vice President represent one of the largest and most vocal stakeholders of the University. Due to the changing demographics of today's youth and their generation's outlook, contemporary college students have become increasingly socially conscious and politically knowledgeable. As a result, college students require more awareness of and influence over the investments of the institutions to which they subscribe, participate, and donate towards. Within a decade, as the earliest of the “Millennials” send their children to college, the parents of college students will also require that they and their children have a voice in institutional investment decisions. From a demographic perspective, it is thereby logical to ensure that the student body is directly represented on PIIAC.
Third, as demonstrated by Yadel’s service, membership on PIIAC requires a vast knowledge of university infrastructure and organization as well as real-life financial mechanisms and investment strategies. To that end, the SGA Executive President and Vice President constitute two of the most qualified representatives of the student body. Both are typically upperclassmen who have served in SGA since their freshman year, and both typically possess a considerable body of policy expertise and academic knowledge.
Fourth, the University’s public image — internal and external — stands to gain from the addition of the SGA Executive President and Vice President to PIIAC. Internally, the addition of the SGA Executive President and Vice President addresses concern that student viewpoints are not democratically included in investment decisions. Externally, the addition of the SGA Executive President and Vice President allows Hopkins to signal community openness and inclusive excellence in comparison to its peers.
Fifth, the University can expedite its long-term objectives by including the SGA Executive President and Vice President, as both represent crucial stakeholders in undergraduate politics and the institutional memory that is passed between generations of undergraduate students. By seating the SGA Executive President and Vice President at its table, PIIAC ensures that the student body is more aware of and more likely to support the University’s long-term objectives, from the Ten by 20 goals to the Rising to the Challenge fundraising campaign.
INVESTMENT BENEFITS
Integrating student voice into investment strategies is necessary for an institution to claim a proactive, progressive stance on investment. Students provide a lens not only into contemporary investment interests, but also into the future of the Hopkins community after graduation.
The charge of PIIAC calls upon it to ensure community engagement. Indeed, its mission statement stands as follows: to serve as “responsible and ethical investors,” and to “give independent weight to this factor [community input] in their investment policies and implementation. Through the Committee on Investments and the President, the trustees will receive and weigh advice and recommendations by the Public Interest Investment Advisory Committee concerning social issues related to those corporations in which the Hopkins endowment is separately invested.” Student representation facilitates PIIAC’s need to consider the social impact of investments. Having student representation thus maximizes the longevity of PIIAC’s outstanding ethical recommendations, as students of the current generation are the most prominent stakeholders in the social implications of the future.
Furthermore, with student misgivings on a number of current University investments, PIIAC must harness its influence for good. It is imperative that the University represents each and every stakeholder of the future to ensure that the consequences of all investments are thoroughly explored, such that every investment in industry and enterprise reaps not only fiscal and monetary but also social and political benefits for the University. By allowing the SGA Executive President and Vice President onto PIIAC ensures that students can directly aid in reaffirming the ethicality of all investments; the University can consequently ensure that its long-term returns improve society as a whole and that its investments function as a highlight for donors, alumni, current and prospective students, parents, faculty, and every staff member across the University’s nine divisions.
ADMINISTRATIVE BENEFITS
From a logistical perspective, the addition of the SGA Executive President and Vice President provide ample administrative benefits to the University.
First, the addition of the SGA Executive President and Vice President to PIIAC would reduce the time and energy required to ensure that a student is present on PIIAC. Rather than spend time sifting through student applications, PIIAC can look simply to the annually elected SGA Executive President and Vice President. In recent years, the campaign platforms of these two individuals have become so detailed, in the form of pages-long action plans and policy platforms, that it can be guaranteed that each would come to PIIAC with substantial knowledge of the university’s workings.
Second, PIIAC can increase its public profile by including the SGA Executive President and Vice President. Both figures are highly visible to the student body, with links to SGA’s widespread social media vectors. Through SGA, PIIAC can rest safe in knowing that the student body feels up-to-date on its actions.
Third, PIIAC members, who come from across all nine University divisions, can benefit from knowing student leaders from the largest single group of students (undergraduates). As PIIAC consists of expert faculty and staff, integrating the SGA Executive President and Vice President can ensure faculty-staff-student collaboration at the highest levels of the University.
Fourth, the SGA Executive President and Vice President can facilitate PIIAC’s desire to ensure community engagement in implementing the Trustee Statement on Fiduciary Investment. As previously mentioned, the SGA Executive President and Vice President represent one of the most vital conduits to the student body. Indeed, both would be able to muster SGA resources to support community fora, surveys, listening sessions, and other means of fulfilling PIIAC’s mission. Of course, the SGA Executive President and Vice President must first be seated on PIIAC to fulfill this mission.
STUDENT BENEFITS
Student life at Hopkins would benefit tremendously from the addition of the SGA Executive President and Vice President to PIIAC. PIIAC strives to ensure that “our students, faculty, and staff continue to engage in debate over important social issues.” Unfortunately, students are not represented in regular PIIAC meetings or decision-making processes, debilitating PIIAC’s ability to fulfill this mission. By seating the SGA President and Vice President on PIIAC, students would benefit from the reassurance that decisions about university investment, which is funded partially by student tuition, are inclusive of student views on the ethicality of certain investments decisions. Knowledge that students are represented on the PIIAC would ensure clearer and more diplomatic communication between students and the University, such that investments are less likely to elicit protest or more vocal acts of civil disobedience that attract the attention of external media. By allowing consistent and clear communication, students will not feel the need to make grand displays in order to feel heard.
Student representation as guided by the SGA is thus the only form of efficient and certain engagement in University investments. A lack of such representation undermines the ability of students to participate in the University decision-making process and forces the student body to seek representation through other means, while PIIAC would continue to draw the same pushback from stakeholders around the University.
PEER INSTITUTION EXEMPLARS
GENERAL STUDENT REPRESENTATION
By and large, students serve on representative bodies at peer institutions:
- The Princeton Entrepreneurship Advisory Committee has four sitting student members and five sitting alumni members.²
- The Princeton Task Force on the Future of the Graduate School has four sitting student members.³
- The Princeton Service and Civic Engagement Self-Study has three standing student members.⁴
- The Princeton Task Force on the Residential College model has four standing student members.⁵
- The Council of the Princeton University Community has five students on the Executive Committee, six students on the Priorities Committee, three students on the Governance Committee, two students on the Judicial Committee, three students on the Resources Committee, five students (including one ex officio) on the Rights and Rules Committee, and two students on the Special Committee on Naming.⁶
- The Associated Students of the University of California consists of students committees that wield influence on a variety of commissions and committees, including the Housing Commission, the Financial Wellness Commission, and the Undergraduate Academic Commission.⁷
- The Berkeley Student Advocate’s Office has student representation in all four divisions: academic, financial aid, and conduct and grievance.⁸
- The MIT Undergraduate Association has at least one student representative on every committee.⁹
² Princeton University. “Princeton Entrepreneurship Advisory Committee (PEAC).” Princeton University. March 09, 2018. Accessed June 05, 2018.http://www.princeton.edu/strategicplan/taskforces/peac/.
³ Princeton University. “Task Force on the Future of the Graduate School.” Princeton University. July 08, 2016. Accessed June 05, 2018.http://www.princeton.edu/strategicplan/taskforces/graduateschool/.
⁴ Princeton University. “Service and Civic Engagement Self-Study.” Princeton University. July 08, 2016. Accessed June 05, 2018. http://www.princeton.edu/strategicplan/taskforces/sce/.
⁵ Princeton University. “Task Force on the Residential College Model.” Princeton University. September 14, 2016. Accessed June 05, 2018.http://www.princeton.edu/strategicplan/taskforces/rescollege/.
⁶ Princeton University. “CPUC Standing/Special Committee Members, 2017-18.” Princeton University. November 13, 2017. Accessed June 05, 2018.http://www.princeton.edu/vpsec/cpuc/committees/.
⁷ “UNITS.” ASUC. Accessed June 05, 2018. https://asuc.org/commissionscommittees/.
⁸ “Student Advocate’s Office.” Student Advocate’s Office. Accessed June 05, 2018.https://advocate.berkeley.edu/.
⁹ “Institute and Faculty Committees.” MIT Undergraduate Association. Accessed June 05, 2018.http://ua.mit.edu/institutecomms/.
Students at various bodies are also empowered to exercise votes of no confidence in individuals or policies which jeopardize institutional stability:
- The UC Student Association passed a vote of no confidence in regards to tuition increases, causing a reevaluation of the budget.¹⁰
- SUNY Plattsburgh Student Senate passed a vote of no confidence in regards to three officials.¹¹
- The University of Southern Illinois Student Government passed a vote of no confidence, resulting in the resignation of their president.¹²
Duke’s student government, one of the most effective and expansive student representative organizations of our peer institutions, operates with a very similar organizational structure to the one illustrated in clauses 6 and 7. The Duke University Student Government appoints students to “University Committees,” institutions that include “any committee, council, board, task force, or other body that is established by a proper authority within Duke University.” At Duke, these include the Advisory Council on Investment Responsibility (ACIR), the President’s Council on Black Affairs (PCOBA), and the University Priorities Committee (UPC). We, the JHU SGA, feel that not only by sending representatives to institutional committees, but also by having the aforementioned administrators meet with the duly and democratically elected representatives of the SGA, the University can strengthen its institutional committees and their priorities. the administrative titles listed, when paired with duly and democratically appointed student representatives (stemming from within SGA), can become a Hopkins form of “University Committees”¹³. In this initiative, Hopkins SGA is not lobbying for direct control of the proceedings of these general administrative functions, rather just a more frequent, active, and constructive dialogue between student representatives and administration. This type of relationship is outlined by the Duke model, wherein the Executive President appoints these representatives to the councils and the Executive Vice President is tasked with the oversight of the student representatives.
¹⁰ Hussain, Shauhana, and Alexander Barreira. “UC Student Association Passes Vote of No Confidence in UC Regents, UC President Janet Napolitano.” The Daily Californian, January 14, 2015. Accessed June 05, 2018.
¹¹ Lois, and Kayla Breen. “PSU Student Senate Votes No Confidence for Officials.” Press-Republican, February 21, 2018. Accessed June 05, 2018.
¹² Chrysanthou, Athena. “USG President Impeached, Vote of No Confidence for Chancellor Carlo Montemagno.” Daily Egyptian, February 14, 2018. Accessed June 05, 2018.
PRINCETON UNIVERSITY (Ranked 1st by US News & World Report)
Princeton University, listed first in the 2017 United States US News & World Report college rankings, relies on a community council to ensure that each and every institutional stakeholder is afforded a voice in decisions made by the University. This body was founded almost fifty years ago, in 1969, and is known as the Council of the Princeton University Community (CPUC). Meeting six times per year (more than PIIAC), the CPUC involves faculty, student, staff and alumni delegates. At present, the CPUC includes 15 faculty representatives, 18 student representatives (6 graduate and 12 undergraduate), 14 staff and administrator representatives, and 4 alumni representatives. Of these representatives, 6 faculty, 3 undergraduates and 3 administrators form the CPUC’s Executive Committee.[^14]
Like PIIAC at Johns Hopkins, the CPUC is endowed with explicit authority to “consider and investigate any question of University policy, any aspect of the governing of the University, and general issue related to the welfare of the University.” The CPUC is further empowered to “make rules regarding the conduct of resident members of the University community, which rules shall be binding on them.” CPUC representatives are organized into seven standing committees: the Executive Committee, the Provost’s Priorities Committee, the Governance Committee, the Judicial Committee, the Resources Committee, the Rights and Rules Committee, and the Special Committee on Naming.[^15]
Two of these committees specifically parallel the work of PIIAC. First, the Provost’s Priorities Committee directly advises the President of Princeton University and “reviews the operating budget of the University, considers issues that arise in the course of the preparation of that budget and reviews plans for the development of the University,” and includes four undergraduates and two graduate students drawn from the CPUC membership and chosen by each respective student body.[^16] Second, the Resources Committee “considers questions of general policy concerning the procurement and management of the University’s financial resources” with an extensive portfolio that includes “issues related to the University’s endowment portfolio, including concerns related to investment responsibility and socially responsible investments, under the provisions of a set of guidelines established by the University Trustees in 1997.”[^17] Two undergraduates and one graduate student currently serve on this standing committee.
All CPUC meetings are open to the public, and all meeting agendas and minutes are publicly available, both to Princeton affiliates and non-affiliates. Most importantly, student representatives are selected by their respective student bodies or delegates thereof. In particular, the Princeton Undergraduate Student Government (USG) hosts elections for general undergraduate representatives to the CPUC, and the USG’s Executive President and Executive Vice President are automatically granted annual membership on the CPUC.
[^14]: http://www.princeton.edu/vpsec/cpuc/[^15]: http://www.princeton.edu/vpsec/cpuc/CHARTER-5-13.pdf[^16]: https://provost.princeton.edu/committees#committees-page-3-1[^17]: https://cpucresources.princeton.edu
HARVARD UNIVERSITY (Ranked 2nd by US News & World Report)
In the early 1980s, Harvard commissioned the Dowling Committee, which was charged with determining both the strengths and the weaknesses of the present system of college governance at Harvard and to consider any reforms that might improve the quality of college life. The Committee included faculty, students, staff and administrators, and derived from overwhelming student sentiment of non-representation and the demand for more control in university governance. Moreover, one of the more prominent reasons for the creation of this report was the lack of communication between the student body and administration.
The report was quickly implemented by then-Harvard President Derek Bok. His administration guaranteed student representation on bodies related to everyday student affairs, including the Committee on Undergraduate Education and the Committee on Houses and Undergraduate Life, as well as bodies related to university governance, including the Communications and Finance Committee and the Committee on Rights and Responsibility.
The Harvard Dowling Report functioned as a definitive improvement in student life at Harvard University, facilitating the growth of a governance structure that has propelled Harvard to the top of US college rankings for decades. Above all, the report empowered the Harvard Undergraduate Council to be a more efficient and democratic representation of the student body, and function as a better line of communication between students and administrators such that the University’s policies would be formed in a way that students would more wholeheartedly support the University.
MIT (Ranked 5th by US News & World Report)
MIT[^18] utilizes a highly-functional system of student representation on a total of thirty-two different task forces or committees, many of whom consider issues equivalent to those that PIAC does. From academic performance to corporate relations to LGBTQ+ issues to research guidelines, each committee has at least one, and in most cases two to four, student representatives. What our SGA is proposing fits into our existing committee structure, but accomplishes the same goal - campus wide issues tackled by a team of students and administrators working together.
In particular, the MIT Undergraduate Association, equivalent to The Johns Hopkins Student Government Association, has representatives on the following bodies:
- ACADEMIC ADVISORY BOARD
- ALUMNI AFFAIRS
- CAMPUS PLANNING
- COMMUNITY & DIVERSITY
- COMMUNITY SERVICE
[^18]: http://ua.mit.edu/uacouncil/
- EDUCATION
- EVENTS
- FINANCIAL BOARD
- INNOVATION
- INVOLVEMENT
- MARKETING
- PUBLIC AFFAIRS
- SPECIAL PROJECTS
- STUDENT-ADMINISTRATION COLLABORATION
- STUDENT SUPPORT AND WELLNESS
- SUSTAINABILITY
- TECHNOLOGY SYSTEMS GROUP
We furthermore note that MIT’s laudable Student-Administration Collaboration Board ensures a clear line of communications between administration and the student body, through recommendations made to both stakeholders. The Board conducts an annual investigation into how effective communication is between the two stakeholders and the potential augmentation of transparency. Lastly, this body sets clear expectations for both stakeholders and measures to what extent these expectations have been met.
At Johns Hopkins, we stand to remedy the lack of communication between students and the University in regard to investments. Seating SGA members on PIIAC catalyzes the development of new goals for communication, transparency, and overall trust between students and our institution. By improving communications and transparency, Hopkins can set higher expectations and achieve even more than it already has.
FOR PEOPLE READING THIS
New material is all the way at the bottom
[Seal: STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION; JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY]
JOHNS HOPKINS STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION
POWERS & AUTHORITIES INITIATIVE
Background Documents (Board of Trustees)
Contents
- Background
- a.History of SGA Powers & Authorities
- b.Itemized Description of Existing SGA Powers & Authorities
- c.Democratic Standing and Legitimacy
2. Board of Trustees Membership Proposal
- a.Proposal
- b.Institutional Benefits
- c.Investment Benefits
- d.Administrative Benefits
- e.Student Benefits
3. Board of Trustees Student Life Committee Membership Proposal
- a.Proposal
- b.Institutional Benefits
- c.Investment Benefits
- d.Administrative Benefits
- e.Student Benefits
4. Precedent at Peer Institutions
1-2 pages for each sub-point is fine!
Abridged History of SGA Powers & Authorities
The SGA’s existing powers and authorities with regards to the University can be traced to the emergence of the Student Council in the 1920s. At that point in time, the Student Council was housed in the Merrick Barn and was responsible for working with the Dean of Students, then the only student affairs professional at the University, to manage student activities fees and tuition. By the 1960s, increasing student activism on a national level led the Student Council to lead several additional initiatives, including the endowment of annual leadership awards and selection of the Commencement speaker. By the dawn of the twenty-first century, the SGA managed the accreditation of several hundred student organizations. The SGA was so expansive that it even appointed the chairs of FAS, MSE, and the HOP. Kwame Alston, 2018 Senior Class President, remarked that in the era of the first African-American Executive President of the SGA, the Senior Class Council even had veto power over the Commencement speaker. However, after the publication of the first Commission on Undergraduate Education (CUE) report in the early 2000s, SGA’s explicit powers and authorities began to diminish as management of student activities was shifted from peer-based management to staff-based management. SGA influence waned especially after the departure of Dean of Student Life Susan Boswell in 2013 and Director of Student Life Rob Turing in 2014.
Meanwhile, since undergraduates are not empowered with distinctive influence over the operations and service provision of the University, SGA has been dependent on dialogue throughout its history to engage in policy advocacy. Certainly, the SGA has always and continues to meet with administrators, especially as more were brought to the University, but it has often been left to SGA to make the first step to continue dialogue with administrators, rather than a mutual effort. Today, as a result, SGA has been left primarily with political or symbolic means of advocating for students - holding forums, composing resolutions, and transmitting student concerns to entities that often took courses of action in opposition to student concerns - rather than retaining access to institutional bodies that control long-term decision-making for the University or tangible day-to-day policies.
Itemized Description of Existing SGA Powers & Authorities
The following section contains descriptions of SGA’s existing abilities in regards to the University at-large. This section does not pertain directly to SGA legislation, which is considered an internal function that facilitates external operations.
1. Selection and confirmation of student representatives to the Krieger Curriculum Committee and the Whiting Curriculum Committee, including the Chair of the Academic Affairs Committee.
The SGA has been historically authorized to select the five student members of both the Krieger and Whiting Schools’ Curriculum Committees, which are standing committees responsible for advising the Homewood Academic Council on changes to curriculum. In the early fall of each academic year, members of each school’s dean’s staff reach out to SGA and ask for SGA to procure and confirm five student members of each committee. In addition, the SGA Academic Affairs Committee chair is granted ex-officio membership on both Curriculum Committees.
To select the five student members of each Curriculum Committee, the SGA Academic Affairs Committee conducts an open application process, evaluates applicants through a criterion-based rubric of expertise with University academic policy and ability to advocate for student viewpoints, and the ten total nominees are presented to the SGA Senate for review and confirmation. The student members’ names are then passed on to the deans of Krieger and Whiting.
2. Confirmation of student nominees to the Ethics Board.
The SGA has been historically authorized to confirm nominees to the Ethics Board that have been identified and screened by a subcommittee of current Ethics Board members. The Ethics Board subcommittee extends an open application to the student body, then evaluates applicants on their moral integrity and ability to apply the Academic Ethics Code to test cases or simulacra. When the nominees have been prepared, the Director of Student Conduct or a member of the Ethics Board presents the final nominees to the SGA Senate, whereupon the nominees are presented to the SGA Senate for review and confirmation.
3. Selection and recommendation of student nominees to certain University-wide entities, such as the Mental Health Task Force and Mental Well-Being Working Group.
The SGA, as the primary representative body of the student population on Homewood, has historically been vested with the right to appoint all student representatives on any
University-wide entity. However, the SGA has only been fleetingly consulted in appointing students to institutional bodies in the last two years. For instance, SGA was consulted on which student representatives were to be placed on the Mental Health Task Force and Well-Being Working Group, but SGA was not consulted on which students would be placed on the Second Commission on Undergraduate Education (CUE2), the Public Investment Interest Advisory Committee (PIIAC), the Homewood Council on Inclusive Excellence (HCIE), or the Diversity Leadership Council (DLC). The SGA was able to provide suggested nominees for positions such as JHU’s representative to the Maryland Higher Education Commission (MHEC), yet MHEC retained the final choice of JHU’s student representative. Moreover, there remain several institutional committees or councils, from the Board of Trustees to the Homewood Academic Council, that lack a student representative. In the case of the HCIE and DLC, it is serendipitous that the leaders of each organization deliberately attempt to include SGA members each year, though still the selection of undergraduate representatives is based on the councils’ rather than the SGA.
4. Oversight of almost 400 student groups not chartered through the Center for Social Concern, the Dean of Student Life, an academic department or Homewood Arts.
The SGA accredits over four-hundred student organizations on Homewood campus that are not otherwise advised by the CSC, directly by DOSL, or by an academic department or Homewood Arts. The SGA is responsible for appropriating over $200,000 of monies from the Parents’ Fund to these four-hundred student organizations each year, while also appropriating monthly grants to those groups that require emergency funding for events or programs. Furthermore, the SGA ensures student organizations adhere and comply to University guidelines, lest violating organizations be stripped of recognition in the coming academic year. This is a common feature of peer institutions’ student governments, though in the case of the most impactful student governments - Duke, Princeton, UC-Berkeley - the SGA is granted more student- rather than staff-based oversight of student groups, and the proportion of SGA energies spent on student organization management (compared to student advocacy) is lower.
5. Management of $20,000 in stimulus spending for student and student group ventures, projects, and funding requests
The SGA itself is endowed with $20,000 in funding, which it uses both for internal operations and funding to distribute to groups with whom it co-sponsors events and initiatives. For example, the SGA allocated funding to sign-printing for the Ballots Not Bullets demonstrations of Spring 2018, as well as to food and drinks for the mental health accessibility Well-Fest in Fall 2017. This funding is also used to support student groups who seek funding beyond their annual SAC funding allocation and monthly grants, and are now seeking funding from additional sources like
SGA or academic departments. However, SGA’s own funding is in fact lower than in the past. As late as the 2011-2012 academic year, it was as high as $40,000.
6. Issue monthly stimulus grants through its executive financial arm, the Student Activities Commission.
The Student Activities Commission (SAC), chaired by the SGA’s Executive Treasurer, offers student groups an additional financial resource to further pursue organizational objectives. The primary focus of the SAC is to allocate annual budgets to existing students groups, after reviewing their previous year’s operations. Furthermore, the SAC allocates monthly grants to student groups who require funding for unexpected expenses, new initiatives or ideas, or if that S.A.C. has requested for the grant after the primary contact has previously communicated with a commissioner. The annual funding for SAC grants comes from the Parents Fund and consists of $200,000, to be allocated at the discretion of the Executive Treasurer.
7. The ability to deliver formal recommendations on University policy to administrators, as effectualized in the form of resolutions, public statements, meetings, and letter or email communications.
The SGA is the recognized representative voting body for undergraduates at JHU, and therefore, recommendations from the SGA are assumed to be fulfilling the wishes of the demographic it serves. Other than referenda, resolutions are considered the highest form of recommendation from the SGA. Resolutions must pass through the Senate with a majority vote. Public statements made by SGA are an official stance of the SGA on potentially contentious issues affecting the JHU community and intend to represent the beliefs held by a majority of JHU students. Furthermore, JHU’s administration has previously acknowledged the prominence of SGA’s representation by meeting with SGA representatives per request and on sitting committees where SGA has representation. Lastly, the SGA Executive Board harnesses letter and email communication to transmit these recommendations to all administrators and the Board of Trustees, as its communications are considered to speak on behalf of the undergraduate student body.
8. Regular monthly meetings with certain administrators, such as the Dean of Student Life, and the Deans of the Krieger and Whiting Schools.
SGA regularly meets with Deans whose daily work and decisions have an impact on all or many undergraduate students, on behalf of all or many undergraduate students. Current SGA pursuits, student grievances, student ideas, and valuable discussion on the undergraduate academic and non-academic environment fall under the scope of these meetings, allowing the Deans to gain insight into daily student life and giving SGA the opportunity to collaborate with administrators who have a vested interest in bettering the lives of undergraduate students. Furthermore, regular meetings are necessary such that a consistent line of communication be kept between the aforementioned Deans and the undergraduate students body that allows for discussion and understanding on behalf of both parties in all areas in which the two parties have a vested interests, especially those that are potentially contentious or would have a lasting effects on the university as a whole.
9. Productive annual meetings with the President and Provost.
Student Government’s meetings with the President and Provost allows for valuable facetime with administrative leadership on behalf of the students. These meetings allow the President, Provost and other JHU Deans to discuss pressing concerns facing the undergraduate student body and gain an understanding of the JHU climate from the perspective of a JHU undergraduate (via SGA as their representatives). Furthermore, SGA has an opportunity to present projects it has decided to pursue and formally ask for the President’s, Provost’s, and Deans support on these projects. The open dialogue at this meeting helps to foster a relationship between the current SGA and the administrators who so often work together to better the school. Lastly, the President, Provost, and Deans in attendance can offer valuable insight as to how SGA’s specific goals can be attained and as to how SGA can overcome systematic difficulties it has faced in the pursuit of its goals.
10. Selection and provision of annual recognition awards, including the George E. Owen Teaching Award, the Staff Excellence and Leadership Award, the Student Leadership and Excellence Award, and the Emerging Student Leader Award.
The George E. Owen teaching award recognizes professors who are committed to teaching and devoted to undergraduates, incentivizing professors to passionately pursue behaviours and habits that benefit the undergraduate students on the JHU campus, in turn creating a culture that fosters learning for undergraduates. The Student Excellence Award for Leadership and Service Staff Award, otherwise known as the Staff Excellence and Leadership Award, also fosters an environment of learning and excellence for undergraduates by recognizing staff members who demonstrate a commitment to helping students in a meaningful way. The Student Excellence Award for Leadership and Service, otherwise know at the Student Leadership and Excellence award, is awarded to students who are passionate about engaging in the JHU community and have contributed greatly to student activities, incentivizing students to partake in extracurricular and cocurricular activities, for the positive growth of both the student and the university. The Emerging Student Leader Award, otherwise known as the Emerging Leader Award, recognizes students who have made new and significant contributions to student activities or show significant improvement and development in their dedication to student activities, thus incentivizing undergraduate students to relentlessly pursue excellence in their extracurricular and cocurricular activities, and in turn, better the undergraduate extracurricular and cocurricular environment for themselves and their peers.
SGA Standing and Democratic Legitimacy
The SGA, per its Constitution, is “the sole representative body of undergraduates at the University.” Furthermore, the SGA was erected “in order to strengthen student unity, represent student interests, and provide a forum for the exchange of ideas.” Indeed, the SGA speaks on behalf of all 6,000 undergraduates across the Krieger School of Arts and Sciences and the Whiting School of Engineering. Today, the SGA executes this duty through a variety of mechanisms, from management of over 400 student organizations on campus to allocation of $200,000 in funds to student groups. However, beyond the borders of SGA operations, SGA also interacts regularly with the student body. Among SGA’s means of interaction are:
1. Outreach & Feedback Mechanisms
I. Communication and Marketing Commission (CMC)
The CMC was founded in 2015 as a means of engaging the student body through online social media interaction. An executive agency chaired by the Executive Secretary and composed of five students, the CMC promotes SGA’s activities to the greater student body through a central website (sga.jhu.edu), social media (Facebook, Twitter, Instagram), and through flyers, videos, and publicity campaigns for SGA events and initiatives.
II. Policy Research and Development Commission
The newly founded Policy Research and Development Commission (PRDC), an executive agency chaired by the Executive Vice President, serves as SGA’s consulting group for policy research, survey design, data analysis, and informational support. The Commission is currently composed of three senior policy advisors: one in the domain of civic engagement and institutional equity; one in the domain of mental health and student wellbeing; and one in the domain of environmental sustainability and University facilities. Each senior policy advisor is tasked with composing reports to the Senate on these realms, and with liaising with leaders of student groups in each domain. Any SGA member can request that the PRDC compose a report on a given issue. In addition, the PRDC houses several of the most recent surveys conducted by the SGA, including the tobacco policy survey and a forthcoming academic culture survey. In the coming months, the PRDC is set to expand to ten members and begin providing on-demand policy consultation to the greater student body.
III. Well-Fest MH Feedback Board
Similar to the structure of “What Do You Want Wednesdays”, SGA’s table at the Fall 2017 Mental Health Well-Fest included a large poster board where students were able to provide their feedback as to how mental health should be improved on campus. Well-Fest involved hundreds of students, of which several visited and contributed to the poster board. Among the feedback collected was the need to destigmatize mental health and provide platforms for mental health discussion, improve faculty and staff training for mental health support, create more stress-relief activities, build a student center, and encourage self-care and healthy habits.
IV. Stomp the Stigma
Stomp The Stigma is a marketing program developed by the SGA Health, Safety and Sustainability Committee that aims to create dialogue on mental health at Johns Hopkins. In its first iteration, during the spring of 2018, the program successfully provided free snacks and mental health support quotes to students in the library during finals period. The program also hosted a successful mental health destigmatization discussion in Levering Hall that brought together several dozen students to discuss barriers to mental health improvement and services provision on campus.
V. “What Do You Want Wednesday”
On a brief hiatus during the past “What Do You Want Wednesdays” were a weekly occurrence where the late SGA Sustainability and Facilities Committee held weekly gatherings in Brody Cafe (on Wednesdays) where students were able to provide feedback to SGA on the current affairs of the campus and physically write what they wanted to see change in the University, in exchange for one Insomnia cookie. Common themes that emerged from these weekly exchanges (and later manifested in SGA initiatives) included building a student center, improving campus mental health, changing academic culture, and reducing the environmental impact of campus facilities.
VI. SGA Ambassadors Program (forthcoming)
The SGA Ambassadors program is a long-time concept that dates back to as early as April 2016, and is set to be operationalized in Fall 2018. The program will assign each SGA member to a specific set of student groups (in particular, student groups with whom SGA has less regular contact, such as groups outside the realms of civic engagement, advocacy, mental health, or sustainability) and the SGA member will be responsible for conducting monthly check-ins with the leaders of each student groups to see if the student group requires aid, assistance, or support from SGA.
VII. SGA Student Advocates Office (forthcoming)
Inspired by the University of California Student Government system, the SGA is considering the creation of a Student Advocates office that will train students in important University policies – such as the Student Code of Conduct, the Ethics Code, and Free Expression Guidelines – so that these students can provide their peers with counsel on how to deal with infractions of, or accusations of infractions of, University policies. This is important given that, at present, students are only informed of their rights and responsibilities by relevant administrators when accused of University policy violations, and no formal peer-based system exists to support students.
2. Active Collaboration with Students and Student Groups
I. Well-Fest
One of SGA’s most significant co-sponsorships is the annual mental health Well-Fest. Started by the Mental Health Task Force in October 2016 and since continued by the SGA, Well-Fest brings together every mental health student group (Active Minds, APTT, YesPlus) and every well-being or mental health office in the University (Athletics and Recreation, the Counseling Center, CHEW, Student Health and Wellness) for a campus-wide mental health wellbeing awareness event. Through relaxation and de-stress activities (yoga, athletic mini-games, massages), free giveaways, food and drinks, and informational support, Well-Fest helps students decompress during the first major midterm season. In October 2017, Well-Fest was located on the Levering Courtyard and captured an audience of several hundred students.
II. Suicide Prevention Week
The SGA also supported APO’s Suicide Prevention Week in November 2017 by hosting a table with informational packets on mental health resources located around campus.
III. Discourse
After being approached by President Daniels to create an encompassing civic engagement initiative that would engross the student body, SGA assisted a nascent student organization known as Discourse in becoming a recognized student group and hosting public debates on issues ranging from religious freedom to cultural appropriation. Debates hosted by Discourse regularly drew several dozen students.
IV. March for Our Lives/Ballots Not Bullets
In the aftermath of the Parkland shootings in Florida, the SGA organized several buses to the March for Our Lives for students and any JHU affiliate to attend the March. SGA successfully transported several dozen students and even a faculty member to the March. After the March, the SGA continued to engage students by providing a platform for firearm safety advocacy in the form of an initiative known as Ballots Not Bullets, which also hosted a Parkland rally in front of the Beach that drew hundreds of students.
V. Panel Discussions (IDEAL, Hillel)
The SGA supported two fellow student groups in panel discussions this year. The first, with IDEAL, involved Executive Vice President AJ Tsang speaking on a panel about freedom of expression on contemporary university campuses. The second, with Hillel, involved Executive President Noh Mebrahtu speaking on a panel about travelling to Israel and seeing the Israeli-Palestinian conflict with new eyes.
VI. Sustainability Coalition
In order to facilitate more frequent dialogue with the many students engaged in sustainability efforts on campus, the SGA joined the newfound Sustainability Coalition, which includes a host of student groups such as Students for Environmental Action, Refuel Our Future, and Take Back the Tap.
VII. Mental Health Student Group Council
Following the recommendations of the Mental Health Task Force, the SGA is following through on one of the core recommendations of the Task Force, which was to have student governments organize their mental health student groups into a unique category wherein they could communicate and collaborate more frequently on programming and policy advocacy. To that end, the SGA is convening the Mental Health Student Group Council, with membership from all mental health student groups on campus – Active Minds, APTT, YesPlus, and Peabody’s “Peabuddies” – secured. If this Homewood version of the Council is successful, it is SGA’s hope to expand first to the Bloomberg School of Public Health, and then to all JHU campuses.
3. Supporting Students and Student Groups
I. Funding Efforts
Every year, student groups regularly reach out to the SGA to co-sponsor events. Among the events co-sponsored this year and in previous years were:
- FJI The Push (2016, 2017, 2018)
- FAS Speakers (2016, 2017)
- BlueOut Tailgate (2018)
- SEA Planet Runway (2018)
- SASHI Dil Se (2018)
- UMR Muslim
- TCO Hatch Tournament (2018)
- Zachary Steinberg Memorial Tournament (2018)
- Temps D’Afrique Show (2018)
- SLAM Showcase (2018)
II. TCO Labs & Entrepreneurship Groups (Fall 2016 onwards)
In the past two years, the SGA functioned as a key stakeholder in bringing together entrepreneurship groups and the University’s newfound interest in building an innovation ecosystem. Former Executive Vice President Anna Du worked extensively with KSAS Dean Beverly Wendel and WSE Dean Ed Schlesinger to ensure that a student entrepreneurship space could be created in Wyman Park Towers, and later, near R House. In addition, she worked with Darius Graham, the director of JHU Tech Ventures (JHTV), to increase the interaction of Homewood’s student entrepreneurship groups with the University’s wider innovation ecosystem. A recent example is that in the spring of 2018, freshmen Justin Sech approached the SGA about creating a biotech lab space for undergraduates on campus. SGA members were able to connect him with JHU Tech Ventures.
III. Web Design Club (Spring 2017)
In the Spring of 2017, the nascent Web Design club faced significant difficulties in registering itself as a student group. Though the Student Organizations Committee found the group to be of merit, the digital media category coordinator found the group to overlap too much with the work of her office, and thus denied the group existence. In response, the SGA supported the Web Design club in overturning the category coordinator’s decision and adding the club to the roster of recognized student groups.
IV. IDEAL/STRUT (Spring 2018)
The SGA supported IDEAL’s effort to begin a collaborative program with local Baltimore schools on civic education. The SGA not only funded part of the initial effort, but members of SGA also provided behind-the-scenes support to IDEAL that allowed it to gain financial support from the IDEA Lab Competition.
V. Advocates for Immigrant Health (Spring 2018)
After logistical issues with Hopkins Groups, SGA facilitated the accreditation of a student group dedicated to advocacy for immigrant health rights.
4. Collaboration with Institutional Bodies
I. Mental Health Task Force
The SGA represented the undergraduate student body on the Mental Health Task Force for the entirety of the Task Force’s existence. In fact, SGA’s representative, AJ Tsang, was one of only two student representatives to attend each Task Force meeting (the other was the student representative from the Bloomberg School of Public Health). All other student representatives, especially those selected by administrators, eventually left or stopped attending Task Force meetings.
II. Mental Health Working Group
The SGA continues to represent the undergraduate student body on the Mental Health and Well-Being Working Group, which is tasked with improving student well-being on campus and implementing the recommendations of the Mental Health Task Force. SGA currently has two representatives on the Working Group - Executive Vice President AJ Tsang and Executive Secretary Aspen Williams.
III. Homewood Council on Inclusive Excellence (HCIE)
SGA also collaborates with and has representation on the Homewood Council for Inclusive Excellence. AJ Tsang (SGA Executive Vice President) and Madelynn Wellons (SGA Junior Class Senator) are both members of this council, and as a result of that they are better able to represent the student body. HCIE brings together a diverse group of students, faculty, and other Hopkins community members, and through their work, they promote diversity and inclusion on the Homewood campus. As SGA members are involved in these conversations and this work, they are better able to represent the increasingly diverse study body and are up to date on issues and opinions the students hold regarding diversity on the campus.
IV. Diversity Leadership Council (DLC)
The SGA has increased student representation on the Diversity Leadership Council, which advocates for further diversity and inclusion efforts across all nine divisions of the University. In the last year, the SGA had two representatives on the DLC: Anthony Boutros and AJ Tsang.
V. Faculty Assembly
Since April 2018, the SGA regularly sends representatives to present at the Faculty Assembly and inform faculty about current issues facing students. In addition, SGA regularly requests the aid of faculty in pushing forward its initiatives. For example, this spring, faculty expressed a willingness to add mental health information to their syllabi as well as support student efforts to build a student center.
VII. SVAC and Monument Quilt
The SGA provided financial support to CHEW for the Monument Quilt in September 2017. In addition, the SGA offered volunteers to set up the Monument Quilt.
5. Elections, Surveys and Referenda
I. Elections
SGA elections occur annually and represent an opportunity for students to engage regularly in the democratic operations of the SGA. In recent years, students engaging in pure policy advocacy have joined issue-specific advocacy groups rather than SGA, but SGA involvement remains notable.
In the past ten years, the median electoral turnout for Executive Elections has been approximately 1500 students (about 30% of eligible voters), and has been as high as 2700 students (50% of eligible voters). This is in line with peer institutions. The median electoral turnout for Spring Class Council elections has been similar among each class, and the median electoral turnout for Fall Class Council elections (the freshmen class) has been 600 students (50% of eligible voters). In addition, eight of the last ten executive elections have been fully competitive (where at least three positions have two or more candidates running). Though it is known that rising senior classes tend to see decreased turnout and candidate counts, SGA research indicates that this is attributable to how upperclassmen on campus have no central place to congregate and live in locations scattered across Charles Village, making it difficult for rising seniors to collect election signatures.
Elections have also yielded increasingly diverse SGAs. In the last ten years, the SGA has become increasingly demographically representative of the student body. Whereas the Executive Board was majority-white as late as 2015, the 2017-2018 Executive Board was the first to be composed entirely of people of color. In fact, over 80% of 2017-2018 SGA members were people of color or underrepresented minorities, and over 50% of 2017-2018 SGA members were women. Several SGA members were also first-generation college students. The future of the SGA also appears diverse: of the last four freshmen class councils, three were minority-majority. A faculty member who attended an SGA meeting this year even remarked that, “Your SGA is more diverse than any of my classes.”
II. Surveys
The SGA has conducted and will continue to conduct surveys to evaluate student feedback. Two of the largest surveys SGA conducted were in 2014 and 2018, both on the University's tobacco policies. The final survey report can be found here.
III. Referenda
Referenda, though perhaps common in real-life government, is designed to be a rare occurrence in the SGA due to the fact that SGA itself is expected to speak on behalf of the student body. The SGA, in an effort to re-establish itself with the democratic norms of the 21st century, is working to break decades-old tradition and make referenda into a more regular occurrence. In fact, the SGA is planning to host an omnibus referendum in Fall 2018. The referendum will allow students to vote on issues such as fossil fuel divestment, tobacco policy, building a student center, and more. It is hoped that this referendum will further change the SGA Constitution to allow regular referenda.
POWERS & AUTHORITIES RESOLUTION CLAUSE 1
SGA and the Board of Trustees
1. In regards to the Board of Trustees:
- a.In line and expansion with the decades-long tradition, the restoration of three Young Alumni Trustees to the Board of Trustees, such that the SGA possesses the ability to select and appoint one rising alumni to the Board of Trustees each year, with each Young Alumni Trustee granted a term of three years alongside all the voting privileges and responsibilities of a normal Trustee;
- b.The addition of two current undergraduates, selected and appointed by the SGA, to a one-year term on each of the Board of Trustees subcommittees;
Introduction
This brief will explain the context and justification for the demands in SGA Resolution 1718.08 Section 1, in which the resolution includes a demand for the restoration of three young trustees and the appointment of two undergraduates to a one year term on each Board of Trustees sub-committee.
Evidence of Other Universities with Undergraduate Representation
When looking at the policies of peer institutions to Johns Hopkins, one finds that Hopkins is far behind many of its peers in giving undergraduates representation on its Board of Trustees. A majority of the 34 [unclear] institutions that Hopkins considers its peers have policies that in the least give the undergraduate student government representation on one or more committees run by the Board of Trustees. In addition, 12 peer institutions give members of their student governments a seat and voting powers in official Board of Trustee meetings. In contrast, Hopkins has few institutional committees, councils, or bodies in which a member or appointee of the SGA has a guaranteed representative seat. Moreover, Hopkins has no student representation on Board of Trustee general meetings, and chooses to keep the content and locations of these meetings secret from the general undergraduate population that it makes policy for
Restoration of the Position of “Young Trustee” Outweighs the Impact of the SLC
The Board of Trustees website, when answering whether students are allowed to serve as Trustees, recounts the history of the Young Trustee position. The website states that while the Young Trustee position existed to give representation to one graduating student from Krieger and Whiting, these positions were eventually abolished due to requests from students for Young Trustee representation, including students from varying JHU graduate schools. The Board then decided that these questions, along with a desire to interact with more undergraduate students, merited the removal of the Young Trustee position and its replacement with the Student Life Committee (SLC).
We find the explanation for the removal of the Young Trustee position inadequate. The website cites only vague “questions” as the reason for the removal. In order to avoid facing these questions, it seems that the Board elected to simply cut Young Trustees instead. This is problematic for two reasons. The first is that the SLC fails as a replacement for the Young
Trustee position. The SLC is inadequate because students only have a voice when the committee deems it necessary. At this moment in time, students are not guaranteed a sustained position on the SLC and, therefore, have little to no information as to what the SLC, and therefore the Board of Trustees, intends to pursue as objectives to better student life. The website cites SLC efforts to reach out to the undergraduate population, including meetings with undergrads on various topics and inviting some to committee meetings. However, they have never consulted the undergraduate's elected student representative body (the SGA) on any student life policies, and the lack of a constant student presence means that the views of students are often left out. The SLC and Board of Trustees' efforts serve as a well-intentioned but inadequate effort to listen to undergraduates while stopping short of giving them any actual power or enduring influence over policies affecting them.
Should the Board of Trustees, the President, and Provost wish to implement fair and meaningful representation for students, they need to restore the Young Trustee position. Actions by the Board of Trustees to pursue a private police force, dodge full divestment from fossil fuels, and remove covered grades met so much opposition from the undergraduate student body in part because the opinions of the student body were not consulted at all. At Johns Hopkins, the power to make university-changing decisions is ultimately vested in the Board of Trustees. The status quo of completely shutting out the undergraduate student body from the Board renders our voice silent. If the Board of Trustees only has to consult the voice of the undergraduate student body when it wants to, then the undergraduate student body has no voice at all. Restoring the Young Trustee position is the one of the only ways to give students a voice in the place where decisions actually happen. The Young Trustee position would increase representation because it would give an actual vote to recent undergraduates from Johns Hopkins. SGA, the representative body of the undergraduate population, would select graduating seniors that reflect the general views of the student body and are passionate about making Hopkins a better place for everyone. These Young Alumni would be much more connected to the undergraduate population than the trustees, and would serve as a valuable voice at the Board of Trustee meetings. Additionally, this policy would mirror that of institutions such as Duke University, The University of Chicago, and Smith College.
Two Undergraduates Should be Placed on Each Board of Trustees Sub-Committee
Having young trustees attend Board of Trustee meetings is one important aspect of giving the student body more representation. However, that still leaves current undergraduates without direct representation. As stated in the above section, giving undergraduates a voice on the Board of Trustees is critical because in the end, the Board of Trustees has supreme power over the policies of this university. As paying members of the university, and those most affected by the university's policies, undergraduates have the right to have a say in what the university does. Many key policies affecting the student body are made in important Board of Trustee committees, including but not limited to the Investments, Student Life, Intermediate Sanctions, Finance, External Affairs, Academic Policy, and Compensation committees. It's particularly unfortunate to lack official and constant student representation on the Student Life committee given that this committee was created for the express purpose of listening to students. It is
- "By-Laws," JHU Board of Trustees. Accessed June 05, 2018. http://trustees.jhu.edu/by-laws/.
necessary and important to give students a voice that the Board of Trustees must listen to in all the aforementioned areas. As the official voice of the undergraduate student body, it is appropriate to allow the SGA to place undergraduates onto each of these committees.
Allowing the SGA to appoint two undergraduates on each committee will improve student representation because the Board will have a constant undergraduate voice on every committee that decides SGA policy. The Board of Trustees tries to listen to undergraduates, but it's difficult when there isn't a constant undergraduate presence while decisions are being made. With undergraduates on each committee, Trustees will have convenient access to student opinions. In cases where Trustees may not even consider that students will have a strong position, an undergraduate presence will serve as a helpful and educational resource for Trustees who are otherwise less connected with the student body. It is important for the SGA to choose these representatives, rather than having said representatives being chosen by the Board, to give the undergraduate population agency in which students represent them on committees. As the representative elected body of the undergraduate population, SGA is the organization best able to reflect the desires of the student body and translate those desires through appointments to the Trustees.
Undergraduates Deserve to Have Information on Board of Trustee Meetings
Another troubling policy of the Board of Trustees is that their actions are kept completely secret from the undergraduate student body. Students across all Johns Hopkins schools lack information as to what occurs during the Board of Trustee meetings, and therefore have no knowledge of whether their interests are being thoroughly explored and sought by the Board of Trustees. As a paying body to the school, students deserve to know where their tuition and other fees are being allocated and for what reason. This is notably important when students have a moral objection to the how the funds are allocated and are given no binding platform to voice these concerns. While a Young Trustee may have the duty to not report meeting material confidential, a Young Trustee will perceive meeting information from the perspective of a recent undergraduate, and can speak on behalf of the undergraduate student body. In addition to the restoration of a Young Trustee, giving abridged notes or at least a complete summary of all Board of Trustees meetings would go a long way towards showing the student body where their tuition is going.
Benefits to the Board of Trustees
The Board of Trustees should implement these changes above all because they fulfill the mission of the university. In his mission statement for the university, Daniel Coit Gilman said in 1876 that his aim was to make scholars “strong, bright, useful, and true.” An important part of developing such scholars is to give them a real voice in the way their university is run. It helps students feel like they can make a difference in the real world when their university trusts and respects them enough to give them representation on Board of Trustee meetings and committees. This is also in the best interest of the Board of Trustees because it seems that they want to consider the desires of the student body. The Board did choose to establish the SLC to increase undergraduate inclusion. If we take the Board at their word, Young Trustee and undergraduate committee representation would be an easy and convenient way to ascertain undergraduate sentiments on issues. The current system of seeking out student opinions in certain cases is inefficient, and it would be much easier to simply have undergraduates present at all times, so they are always able to provide their opinions, at no effort to the busy members of the Board of Trustees. Because of these reasons, we believe it would benefit the Board of Trustees and help them to better carry out their mission if our demands are fulfilled.
New Format<sup>1</sup>
Board of Trustees Membership Proposal
Proposal:
In line and expansion with the decades-long tradition, <u>the restoration of three Young Alumni Trustees to the Board of Trustees</u> such that the SGA possesses the ability to select and appoint one rising alumni to the Board of Trustees each year, with each Young Alumni Trustee granted a term of three years alongside all the voting privileges and responsibilities of a normal Trustee;
Institutional Benefits
This proposal would benefit Johns Hopkins as an institution in several ways. Chief in importance is the image of Johns Hopkins as a promoter of student power and leadership development. The new political era we find ourselves in has changed, in many ways, the priorities of students looking for a college to attend to. It’s no longer enough for an institution to simply provide an education to students, but to include them. Movements such as the March For Our Lives, lead entirely by high-school students, indicate that this is the case. If Johns Hopkins desires to continue drawing the best of the best to our university, it’s important to develop our image as a place that cultivates civil leadership. The Young Trustee position would lead to the desired outcome of a college more prestigious because of improved leadership development and inclusion, because it would deliver another important outlet for students to gain control. Students that want to be the leaders of tomorrow are impressed by institutions that trust them enough to listen to them. Given that the Board of Trustees are where most decisions of import are made, the Young Trustee position would be a meaningful way to let the student body represent their desires by naming new trustees through their elected student body.
The benefits to our institution of re-adding Young Trustees does not just stop at leadership development. Johns Hopkins, to be frank, struggles with an image of disregard for the outside world. No matter what the administration has tried to do, the wider Baltimore community and even our own student body assumes, based on our actions, that we are an institution concerned only by ourselves. Fiascos such as the failure to fully divest from fossil fuels, the private police bill, and continued efforts by Hopkins to gentrify the surrounding area stem from, among other things, a lack of diversity in voices at the Board of Trustees. A uniting figure among the trustees is that they come from positions of prestige and power, naturally disregarding the needs of those below them. The benefits of appointing young trustees would be that the SGA, in tune with the general desires of the student body as a whole, would appoint Trustees passionate about looking after more than just the wellbeing of the university. With the aid of Young Trustees virtually guaranteed to be more aware of the desires of the undergraduates and the community at large, the Board of Trustees would be exposed to valuable perspectives that they usually lack.
Investment Benefits
Along with the benefits offered by placing students on PIAAC, including Young Trustee positions on the Board of Trustees would provide an additional check against bad investments. These Young Trustees could not only advocate for good investment decisions that PIAAC has not, but could make sure that the recommendations of PIAAC are actually listened to. As the fossil fuel divestment decision demonstrated, the PIAAC decisions are not always heeded. Young Trustees could serve as the voice of the undergraduate student body, and discuss the merits of following PIAAC decisions with fellow Board of Trustees members.
Administrative Benefits
Adding Young Trustees to the board of Trustees would make it easier to listen to the voices of the undergraduate population. In the status quo, the Board of Trustees actively must seek out student opinions through the Student Life committee. This has two issues. The first is that the student life committee only really consults students on issues concerning student life. The second is that the Board must seek out student opinions, rather than have student opinions conveniently delivered to them. Assuming that the administration truly does want the opinions of the undergraduate student body at Johns Hopkins, a system in which representative Young Trustees are always present is much easier and requires much less administrative effort than the convoluted SLC system currently in place. Additionally, student opinions could be heard on things that the administration would never even consider students carry about. The administration was caught by surprise by all the outrage concerning issues such as the private police bill, partly because they did not have Young Trustees telling them this will be an issue. The administration would benefit from a new perspective, which this would provide.
Student Benefits
Placing three Young Trustees on the Board of Trustees would benefit the undergraduate student body because it would give us three representatives on the Board of Trustees; whereas we currently have zero. The Board of Trustees is the penultimate policy making body of the Johns Hopkins University. It has power over Academic Policy, Student Life policies, and the appointment of our president. It also governs all of our investments. The current student government, elected by and representative of the student body, possesses zero influence over this all-powerful group. If the Young Trustee position is restored, three recent alumni, appointed by the SGA to be representative of student body opinion, would work to make sure that the overall Board considers our opinions. These Young Trustees would represent a change in the status quo because as of now, the board only has to consider student opinion when it wants to. If the student body only has representation when the Board wants it to, it has no representation at all. We would gain ever-present voices on the vastly important issues that the Board considers every year.
The Young Trustee position would also improve student representation because it would replace the Student Life Committee. The SLC is inadequate because students only have a voice when the committee deems it necessary. At this moment in time, students are not guaranteed a sustained position on the SLC² and, therefore, have little to no information as to what the SLC, and therefore the Board of Trustees, intends to pursue as objectives to better student life. The website cites SLC efforts to reach out to the undergraduate population, including meetings with undergrads on various topics and inviting some to committee meetings. However, they have never consulted the undergraduate’s elected student representative body (the SGA) on any student life policies, and the lack of a constant student presence means that the views of students
² "By-Laws." JHU Board of Trustees. Accessed June 05, 2018. http://trustees.jhu.edu/by-laws/.
are often left out. The SLC and Board of Trustees’ efforts serve as a well-intentioned but inadequate effort to listen to undergraduates while stopping short of giving them any actual power or enduring influence over policies affecting them.
Proposal B:
<u><em>The addition of two current undergraduates, selected and appointed by the SGA, to a one-year term on each of the Board of Trustees subcommittees;</em></u>
Institutional Benefits + Investment Benefit + Administrative Benefits
Adding two undergraduate students to each of the Board of trustees subcommittees would be highly beneficial to the Board of Trustees itself, the Johns Hopkins administration, and the university itself. Most critically, adding undergraduates to each committee would be invaluable in aiding the Board of Trustees in it’s expressed goal of getting more of an undergraduate perspective in its proceedings. The Student Life Committee stands as the main sub-committee addressing undergraduate concerns, but even that committee fails to have a consistent undergraduate presence. Adding two permanent students to this committee, appointed by the representative and democratically elected student government and thus representing the views of the student body, would be an easy and convenient way for the committee to listen to undergraduates. No longer would they have to put effort into reaching out to the student body, since allowing two permanent undergraduate representatives to this committee would allow the student body to come to them. A permanent student perspective on the Student Life Committee would be beneficial because students hold valuable perspectives on the day-to-day operations of Johns Hopkins that trustees and administrators cannot replicate. Having students present at all times guarantees that there will never be a moment where the trustees on the sub-committee fail to consider an innovative student perspective.
The previous arguments apply to almost all of the subcommittees within the Board of Trustees. On committees ranging from Investments to Academic Policy, a student perspective would be a valuable addition to the years of outside experience brought by trustees and other current subcommittee members. Many critical decisions that likely originated within subcommittees faced widespread student outrage, failing to consider what said students thought. A student presence on these committees would ensure that the general undergraduate consensus on all issues is always at the table. This would have widespread benefits, from ensuring that investments made by the university (that come from undergraduate tuition money) go to where undergraduates want, to helping the Academic Policy committee consider what they do by exposing them to affected voices. In short, a permanent student presence on these committees would not only present fresh new ideas, but help prevent costly mistakes that deliver harm to the university’s image among the city of Baltimore, the undergraduate student body, and among competing peer institutions.
Student Benefits
Having Young Trustees attend Board of Trustee meetings is one important aspect of giving the student body more representation. However, that still leaves current undergraduates without direct representation. As stated in the above section, giving undergraduates a voice on the Board of Trustees is critical because in the end, the Board of Trustees has supreme power over the policies of this university. As paying members of the university, and those most affected by the university’s policies, undergraduates have the right to have a say in what the university does. Many key policies affecting the student body are made in important Board of Trustee committees, including but not limited to the Investments, Student Life, Intermediate Sanctions, Finance, External Affairs, Academic Policy, and Compensation committees. It’s particularly unfortunate to lack official and constant student representation on the Student Life committee, given that this committee was created for the express purpose of listening to students. It is necessary and important to give students a voice that the Board of Trustees must listen to in all the aforementioned areas. As the official voice of the undergraduate student body, it is appropriate to allow the SGA to place undergraduates onto each of these committees.
Allowing the SGA to appoint two undergraduates on each committee will improve student representation because the Board will have a constant undergraduate voice on every committee that decides SGA policy. The Board of Trustees tries to listen to undergraduates, but it’s difficult when there isn’t a constant undergraduate presence while decisions are being made. With undergraduates on each committee, Trustees will have convenient access to student opinions. In cases where Trustees may not even consider that students will have a strong position, an undergraduate presence will serve as a helpful and educational resource for Trustees who are otherwise less connected with the student body. It is important for the SGA to choose these representatives, rather than having said representatives being chosen by the Board, to give the undergraduate population agency in which students represent them on committees. As the representative elected body of the undergraduate population, SGA is the organization best able to reflect the desires of the student body and translate those desires through appointments to the Trustees.
Precedent at Peer Institutions
When looking at the policies of peer institutions to Johns Hopkins, one finds that Hopkins is far behind many of its peers in giving undergraduates representation on its Board of Trustees. A majority of the 34 COFHE institutions that Hopkins considers its peers have policies that in the least, give the undergraduate student government representation on one or more committees run by the Board of Trustees. In addition, 12 peer institutions give members of their student governments a seat and voting powers in official Board of Trustee meetings. In contrast, Hopkins has few institutional committees, councils, or bodies in which a member or appointee of the SGA has a guaranteed representative seat. Moreover, Hopkins has no student representation on Board of Trustee general meetings, and chooses to keep the content and locations of these meetings secret from the general undergraduate population that it makes policy for.
JOHNS HOPKINS STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION
POWERS & AUTHORITIES INITIATIVE
Supporting Background Documents
POWERS & AUTHORITIES RESOLUTION
Existing SGA Powers & Authorities
Whereas explicit and existing SGA privileges, powers, and authorities regarding the University include:
- Selection and confirmation of student representatives to the Krieger Curriculum Committee and the Whiting Curriculum Committee, including the Chair of the Academic Affairs Committee;
- Confirmation of student nominees to the Ethics Board;
- Selection and recommendation of student nominees to certain University-wide entities, such as the Mental Health Task Force and Mental Well-Being Working Group;
- Oversight of almost 400 student groups not chartered through the Center for Social Concern, the Dean of Student Life, an academic department or Homewood Arts;
- Management of $20,000 in stimulus spending for student and student group ventures, projects, and funding requests;
- Issue monthly stimulus grants through its executive financial arm, the Student Activities Commission;
- The ability to deliver formal recommendations on University policy to administrators, as effectuated in the form of resolutions, public statements, meetings, and letter or email communications;
- Regular monthly meetings with certain administrators, such as the Dean of Student Life, and the Deans of the Krieger and Whiting Schools;
- Productive annual meetings with the President and Provost;
- Selection and provision of annual recognition awards, including the George E. Owen Teaching Award, the Staff Excellence and Leadership Award, the Student Leadership and Excellence Award, and the Emerging Student Leader Award; and
Abridged History of SGA Powers & Authorities
The SGA’s existing powers and authorities can be traced to the emergence of the Student Council in the 1920s. At that point in time, the Student Council was housed in the Merrick Barn and was responsible for working with the Dean of Students, then the only student affairs professional at the University, to manage student activities fees and tuition. By the 1960s, increasing student activism on a national level led the Student Council to lead several additional initiatives, including the endowment of annual leadership awards and selection of the Commencement speaker. By the dawn of the twenty-first century, the SGA managed the accreditation of several hundred student organizations and the [unclear: largest] so strongly that it appointed the chairs of FAS, MSE, and the HOP.
However, after the publication of the first Commission on Undergraduate Education (CUE) report in the early 2000s, SGA’s explicit powers and authorities began to be swept away as management of student activities became less and less peer-based. Throughout its entire history, the SGA continued to meet with administrators, especially as more were brought to the University; but it was often left to SGA to make the first step to continue dialogue with administrators, rather than a mutual effort. Today, as a result, SGA has been left primarily with political or symbolic means of advocating for students - holding forums, composing resolutions, and transmitting student concerns to entities that often took courses of action in opposition to student concerns.- rather than retaining access to institutional bodies that control long-term decision-making for the University or tangible day-to-day policies.
Itemized Description of Existing SGA Powers & Authorities
1. Selection and confirmation of student representatives to the Krieger Curriculum Committee and the Whiting Curriculum Committee, including the Chair of the Academic Affairs Committee.
The SGA has been historically authorized to select the five student members of both the Krieger and Whiting Schools’ Curriculum Committees, which are standing committees responsible for advising the Homewood Academic Council on changes to curriculum. In the early fall of each academic year, members of each school’s dean’s staff reach out to SGA and ask for SGA to procure and confirm five student members of each committee. In addition, the SGA Academic Affairs Committee chair is granted ex-officio membership on both Curriculum Committees.
To select the five student members of each Curriculum Committee, the SGA Academic Affairs Committee conducts an open application process, evaluates applicants through a criterion-based rubric of expertise with University academic policy and ability to advocate for student viewpoints, and the ten total nominees are presented to the SGA Senate for review and confirmation. The student members’ names are then passed on to the deans of Krieger and Whiting.
2. Confirmation of student nominees to the Ethics Board.
The SGA has been historically authorized to confirm nominees to the Ethics Board that have been identified and screened by a subcommittee of current Ethics Board members. The Ethics Board subcommittee extends an open application to the student body, then evaluates applicants on their moral integrity and ability to apply the Academic Ethics Code to test cases or simulacra. When the nominees have been prepared, the Director of Student Conduct or a member of the Ethics Board presents the final nominees to the SGA Senate, whereupon the nominees are presented to the SGA Senate for review and confirmation.
3. Selection and recommendation of student nominees to certain University-wide entities, such as the Mental Health Task Force and Mental Well-Being Working Group.
The SGA, as the primary representative body of the student population on Homewood, has historically been vested with the right to appoint all student representatives on any University-wide entity. However, the SGA has only been fleetingly consulted in appointing students to institutional bodies in the last two years. For instance, SGA was consulted on which student representatives were to be placed on the Mental Health Task Force and Well-Being Working
Group, but SGA was not consulted on which students would be placed on the Second Commission on Undergraduate Education (CUE2), the Public Investment Interest Advisory Committee (PIIAC), the Homewood Council on Inclusive Excellence (HCIE), or the Diversity Leadership Council (DLC). The SGA was able to provide suggested nominees for positions such as JHU’s representative to the Maryland Higher Education Commission (MHEC), yet MHEC retained the final choice of JHU’s student representative. Moreover, there remain several institutional committees or councils, from the Board of Trustees to the Homewood Academic Council, that lack a student representative. In the case of the HCIE and DLC, it is serendipitous that the leaders of each organization deliberately attempt to include SGA members each year, though still the selection of undergraduate representatives is based on the councils’ rather than the SGA.
- Oversight of almost 400 student groups not chartered through the Center for Social Concern, the Dean of Student Life, an academic department or Homewood Arts.
The SGA accredits over four-hundred student organizations on Homewood campus that are not otherwise advised by the CSC, directly by DOSL, or by an academic department or Homewood Arts. The SGA is responsible for appropriating over $200,000 of monies from the Parents’ Fund to these four-hundred student organizations each year, while also appropriating monthly grants to those groups that require emergency funding for events or programs. Furthermore, the SGA ensures student organizations adhere and comply to University guidelines, lest violating organizations be stripped of recognition in the coming academic year. This is a common feature of peer institutions’ student governments, though in the case of the most impactful student governments - Duke, Princeton, UC-Berkeley - the SGA is granted more student- rather than staff-based oversight of student groups, and the proportion of SGA energies spent on student organization management (compared to student advocacy) is lower.
- Management of $20,000 in stimulus spending for student and student group ventures, projects, and funding requests
The SGA itself is endowed with $20,000 in funding, which it uses both for internal operations and funding to distribute to groups with whom it co-sponsors events and initiatives. For example, the SGA allocated funding to sign-printing for the Ballots Not Bullets demonstrations of Spring 2018, as well as to food and drinks for the mental health accessibility Well-Fest in Fall 2017. This funding is also used to support student groups who seek funding beyond their annual SAC funding allocation and monthly grants, and are now seeking funding from additional sources like SGA or academic departments. However, SGA’s own funding is in fact lower than in the past. As late as the 2011-2012 academic year, it was as high as $40,000.
- Issue monthly stimulus grants through its executive financial arm, the Student Activities Commission.
The Student Activities Commission (SAC), chaired by the SGA’s Executive Treasurer, offers student groups an additional financial resource to further pursue organizational objectives. The primary focus of the SAC is to allocate annual budgets to existing student groups, after reviewing their previous year’s operations. Furthermore, the SAC allocates monthly grants to student groups who require funding for unexpected expenses, new initiatives or ideas, or if that S.A.C. has requested for the grant after the primary contact has previously communicated with a commissioner. The annual funding for SAC grants comes from the Parents Fund and consists of $200,000, to be allocated at the discretion of the Executive Treasurer.
7. The ability to deliver formal recommendations on University policy to administrators, as effectualized in the form of resolutions, public statements, meetings, and letter or email communications.
The SGA is the recognized representative voting body for undergraduates at JHU, and therefore, recommendations from the SGA are assumed to be fulfilling the wishes of the demographic it serves. Other than referenda, resolutions are considered the highest form of recommendation from the SGA. Resolutions must pass through the Senate with a majority vote. Public statements made by SGA are an official stance of the SGA on potentially contentious issues affecting the JHU community and intend to represent the beliefs held by a majority of JHU students. Furthermore, JHU’s administration has previously acknowledged the prominence of SGA’s representation by meeting with SGA representatives per request and on sitting committees where SGA has representation. Lastly, the SGA Executive Board harnesses letter and email communication to transmit these recommendations to all administrators and the Board of Trustees, as its communications are considered to speak on behalf of the undergraduate student body.
8. Regular monthly meetings with certain administrators, such as the Dean of Student Life, and the Deans of the Krieger and Whiting Schools.
SGA regularly meets with Deans whose daily work and decisions have an impact on all or many undergraduate students, on behalf of all or many undergraduate students. Current SGA pursuits, student grievances, student ideas, and valuable discussion on the undergraduate academic and non-academic environment fall under the scope of these meetings, allowing the Deans to gain insight into daily student life and giving SGA the opportunity to collaborate with administrators who have a vested interest in bettering the lives of undergraduate students. Furthermore, regular meetings are necessary such that a consistent line of communication be kept between the aforementioned Deans and the undergraduate students body that allows for discussion and understanding on behalf of both parties in all areas in which the two parties have a vested interests, especially those that are potentially contentious or would have a lasting effects on the university as a whole.
9. Productive annual meetings with the President and Provost.
Student Government’s meetings with the President and Provost allows for valuable facetime with administrative leadership on behalf of the students. These meetings allow the President, Provost and other JHU Deans to discuss pressing concerns facing the undergraduate student body and gain an understanding of the JHU climate from the perspective of a JHU undergraduate (via SGA as their representatives). Furthermore, SGA has an opportunity to present projects it has decided to pursue and formally ask for the President’s, Provost’s, and Deans support on these projects. The open dialogue at this meeting helps to foster a relationship between the current SGA and the administrators who so often work together to better the school. Lastly, the President, Provost, and Deans in attendance can offer valuable insight as to how SGA’s specific goals can be attained and as to how SGA can overcome systematic difficulties it has faced in the pursuit of its goals.
<u>10. Selection and provision of annual recognition awards, including the George E. Owen Teaching Award, the Staff Excellence and Leadership Award, the Student Leadership and Excellence Award, and the Emerging Student Leader Award.</u>
The George E. Owen teaching award recognizes professors who are committed to teaching and devoted to undergraduates, incentivizing professors to passionately pursue behaviours and habits that benefit the undergraduate students on the JHU campus, in turn creating a culture that fosters learning for undergraduates. The Student Excellence Award for Leadership and Service Staff Award, otherwise known as the Staff Excellence and Leadership Award, also fosters an environment of learning and excellence for undergraduates by recognizing staff members who demonstrate a commitment to helping students in a meaningful way. The Student Excellence Award for Leadership and Service, otherwise know at the Student Leadership and Excellence award, is awarded to students who are passionate about engaging in the JHU community and have contributed greatly to student activities, incentivizing students to partake in extracurricular and cocurricular activities, for the positive growth of both the student and the university. The Emerging Student Leader Award, otherwise known as the Emerging Leader Award, recognizes students who have made new and significant contributions to student activities or show significant improvement and development in their dedication to student activities, thus incentivizing undergraduate students to relentlessly pursue excellence in their extracurricular and cocurricular activities, and in turn, better the undergraduate extracurricular and cocurricular environment for themselves and their peers.
POWERS & AUTHORITIES RESOLUTION CLAUSE 1
SGA and the Board of Trustees
- In regards to the Board of Trustees:
- a.In line and expansion with the decades-long tradition, <u>the restoration of three Young Alumni Trustees to the Board of Trustees</u> such that the SGA possesses the ability to select and appoint one rising alumni to the Board of Trustees each year, with each Young Alumni Trustee granted a term of three years alongside all the voting privileges and responsibilities of a normal Trustee;
- b.<u>The addition of two current undergraduates, selected and appointed by the SGA, to a one-year term on each of the Board of Trustees subcommittees;</u>
Introduction
This brief will explain the context and justification for the demands in SGA Resolution 1718.08 Section 1, in which the resolution includes a demand for the restoration of three young trustees and the appointment of two undergraduates to a one year term on each Board of Trustees sub-committee.
Evidence of Other Universities with Undergraduate Representation
When looking at the policies of peer institutions to Johns Hopkins, one finds that Hopkins is far behind many of its peers in giving undergraduates representation on its Board of Trustees: A majority of the 34 COFHE institutions that Hopkins considers its peers have policies that in the least, give the undergraduate student government representation on one or more committees run by the Board of Trustees. In addition, 12 peer institutions give members of their student governments a seat and voting powers in official Board of Trustee meetings. In contrast, Hopkins has few institutional committees, councils, or bodies in which a member or appointee of the SGA has a guaranteed representative seat. Moreover, Hopkins has no student representation on Board of Trustee general meetings, and chooses to keep the content and locations of these meetings secret from the general undergraduate population that it makes policy for.
Restoration of the Position of “Young Trustee” Outweighs the Impact of the SLC
The Board of Trustees website, when answering whether students are allowed to serve as Trustees, recounts the history of the Young Trustee position. The website states that while the Young Trustee position existed to give representation to one graduating student from Krieger and Whiting, these positions were eventually abolished due to requests from students for Young Trustee representation, including students from varying JHU graduate schools. The Board then decided that these questions, along with a desire to interact with more undergraduate students, merited the removal of the Young Trustee position and its replacement with the Student Life Committee (SLC).
We find the explanation for the removal of the Young Trustee position inadequate. The website cites only vague “questions” as the reason for the removal. In order to avoid facing these questions, it seems that the Board elected to simply cut Young Trustees instead. This is problematic for two reasons. The first is that the SLC fails as a replacement for the Young Trustee position. The SLC is inadequate because students only have a voice when the committee deems it necessary. At this moment in time, students are not guaranteed a sustained position on the SLC<sup>1</sup> and, therefore, have little to no information as to what the SLC, and therefore the Board of Trustees, intends to pursue as objectives to better student life. The website cites SLC efforts to reach out to the undergraduate population, including meetings with undergrads on various topics and inviting some to committee meetings. However, they have never consulted the undergraduate’s elected student representative body (the SGA) on any student life policies, and the lack of a constant student presence means that the views of students are often left out. The SLC and Board of Trustees’ efforts serve as a well-intentioned but inadequate effort to listen to undergraduates while stopping short of giving them any actual power or enduring influence over policies affecting them.
Should the Board of Trustees, the President, and Provost wish to implement fair and meaningful representation for students, they need to restore the Young Trustee position. Actions by the Board of Trustees to pursue a private police force, dodge full divestment from fossil fuels, and remove covered grades met so much opposition from the undergraduate student body in part because the opinions of the student body were not consulted at all. At Johns Hopkins, the power to make university-changing decisions is ultimately vested in the Board of Trustees. The status quo of completely shutting out the undergraduate student body from the Board renders our voices silent. If the Board of Trustees only has to consult the voice of the undergraduate student body when it wants to, then the undergraduate student body has no voice at all. Restoring the Young Trustee position is the one of the only ways to give students a voice in the place where decisions actually happen. The Young Trustee position would increase representation because it would give an actual vote to recent undergraduates from Johns Hopkins. SGA, the representative body of the undergraduate population, would select graduating seniors that reflect the general views of the student body and are passionate about making Hopkins a better place for everyone. These Young Alumni would be much more connected to the undergraduate population than the trustees, and would serve as a valuable and educational voice in Board of Trustee meetings. Additionally, this policy would mirror that of institutions such as Duke University, The University of Chicago, and Smith College.
Two Undergraduates Should be Placed on Each Board of Trustees Sub-Committee
Having Young Trustees attend Board of Trustee meetings is one important aspect of giving the student body more representation. However, that still leaves current undergraduates without direct representation. As stated in the above section, giving undergraduates a voice on the Board of Trustees is critical because in the end, the Board of Trustees has supreme power over the policies of this university. As paying members of the university, and those most affected by the university’s policies, undergraduates have the right to have a say in what the university does. Many key policies affecting the student body are made in important Board of Trustee committees, including but not limited to the Investments, Student Life, Intermediate Sanctions, Finance, External Affairs, Academic Policy, and Compensation committees. It’s particularly unfortunate to lack official and constant student representation on the Student Life committee, given that this committee was created for the express purpose of listening to students. It is necessary and important to give students a voice that the Board of Trustees must listen to in all
<sup>1</sup> “By-Laws.” JHU Board of Trustees. Accessed June 05, 2018. http://trustees.jhu.edu/by-laws/.
the aforementioned areas. As the official voice of the undergraduate student body, it is appropriate to allow the SGA to place undergraduates onto each of these committees.
Allowing the SGA to appoint two undergraduates on each committee will improve student representation because the Board will have a constant undergraduate voice on every committee that decides SGA policy. The Board of Trustees tries to listen to undergraduates, but it’s difficult when there isn’t a constant undergraduate presence while decisions are being made. With undergraduates on each committee, Trustees will have convenient access to student opinions. In cases where Trustees may not even consider that students will have a strong position, an undergraduate presence will serve as a helpful and educational resource for Trustees who are otherwise less connected with the student body. It is important for the SGA to choose these representatives, rather than having said representatives being chosen by the Board, to give the undergraduate population agency in which students represent them on committees. As the representative elected body of the undergraduate population, SGA is the organization best able to reflect the desires of the student body and translate those desires through appointments to the Trustees.
Undergraduates Deserve to Have Information on Board of Trustee Meetings
Another troubling policy of the Board of Trustees is that their actions are kept completely secret from the undergraduate student body. Students across all Johns Hopkins schools lack information as to what occurs during the Board of Trustee meetings, and therefore have no knowledge of whether their interests are being thoroughly explored and sought by the Board of Trustees. As a paying body to the school, students deserve to know where their tuition and other fees are being allocated and for what reason. This is notably important when students have a moral objection to the how the funds are allocated and are given no binding platform to voice these concerns. While a Young Trustee may have the duty to not report meeting material confidential, a Young Trustee will perceive meeting information from the perspective of a recent undergraduate, and can speak on behalf of the undergraduate student body. In addition to the restoration of a Young Trustee, giving abridged notes or at least a complete summary of all Board of Trustees meetings would go a long way towards showing the student body where their tuition is going.
Benefits to the Board of Trustees
The Board of Trustees should implement these changes above all because they fulfill the mission of the university. In his mission statement for the university, Daniel Coit Gilman said in 1876 that his aim was to make scholars “strong, bright, useful, and true.” An important part of developing such scholars is to give them a real voice in the way their university is run. It helps students feel like they can make a difference in the real world when their university trusts and respects them enough to give them representation on Board of Trustee meetings and committees. This is also in the best interest of the Board of Trustees because it seems that they want to consider the desires of the student body. The Board did choose to establish the SLC to increase undergraduate inclusion. If we take the Board at their word, Young Trustee and undergraduate committee representation would be an easy and convenient way to ascertain undergraduate sentiments on issues. The current system of seeking out student opinions in certain cases is inefficient, and it would be much easier to simply have undergraduates present at all times, so they are always able to provide their opinions, at no effort to the busy members of the Board of
Trustees. Because of these reasons, we believe it would benefit the Board of Trustees and help them to better carry out their mission if our demands are fulfilled.
POWERS & AUTHORITIES RESOLUTION CLAUSE 2
SGA Powers in University Decision-Making and Administrative Promotion
2. _In regards to the University's decision-making and administrative promotion processes:_
a. _The authority of the SGA to appoint student representatives to the committees, task forces, working groups, commissions, search committees or steering committees of any University body whose work shall impact the student body;_
b. _The ability to conduct binding referenda of confidence or no confidence in University decisions or administrators, as well as the ability to suggest promotions for those administrators who do follow through on student demands and support student activism;_
SGA’s authority is derived from and representative of the Johns Hopkins undergraduate student body. SGA’s legal responsibility is to speak on behalf of the student constituents it represents and liaise between students and faculty, staff, administration, and the Board of Trustees. SGA is, therefore, an intrinsically trusted voice for the undergraduate student body, and, furthermore, is working to expand the breadth of undergraduate representation by petitioning to hold a referendum that would increase the size of the SGA Senate from twenty-eight elected members to upwards of thirty-six elected members, as well as creating a number of executive agencies tasked with further engaging the student body on school policy. Both initiatives expand the breadth of representation of the SGA so that its representation of the undergraduate student body is steadfast. Lastly, SGA appoints members to the Ethics Board, Judiciary, and the Committee on Student Elections, furthering the representation the reach of SGA’s influence and illustrating the augmented representation of undergraduates via SGA.
This and the two following sections put forth evidence and arguments for the Second, Third, and Fourth Clauses of the “Resolution Affirming Existing Powers of the Student Government Association and Calling for the Establishment of New and Modern Powers and Authorities Regarding of the SGA Towards the University Structure”, number 1718.08.
Clause 2 demands that the SGA have the ability to appoint student representatives to any standing university body and that SGA have the power to conduct a binding vote of no confidence. Clause 3 specifies specific bodies within which SGA should have annual membership. Clause 4 demands that SGA may appoint annual representatives to additional specified committees already working in close collaboration with SGA. Evidence of expansive student representation on peer university committees will be presented, illustrating a model for undergraduate representative that is fair and meaningful, of which Johns Hopkins would be wise to pursue.
Evidence of Student Representation on Committee at Peer Institutions is a follows:
- The Princeton Entrepreneurship Advisory Committee has four sitting student members and five sitting alumni members.³
- The Princeton Task Force on the Future of the Graduate School has four sitting student members.⁴
- The Princeton Service and Civic Engagement Self-Study has three standing student members.⁵
- The Princeton Task Force on the Residential College model has four standing student members.⁶
- The Council of the Princeton University Community has five students on the Executive Committee, six students on the Priorities Committee, three students on the Governance Committee, two students on the Judicial Committee, three students on the Resources Committee, five students (including one ex officio) on the Rights and Rules Committee, and two students on the Special Committee on Naming.⁷
- The Associated Students of the University of California consists of student committees that yield influence [unclear: in a variety of] commissions and committees, including the Housing Commission, the Financial Wellness Commission, and the Undergraduate Academic Commission.⁸
- The Berkeley Student Advocate’s Office has student representation in all four divisions: academic, financial aid, and conduct and grievance.⁹
- The MIT Undergraduate Association has at least one student representative on every committee.¹⁰
Evidence of Binding Votes of No Confidence
- The UC Student Association passed a vote of no confidence in regards to tuition increases, causing a reevaluation of the budget.¹¹
³ Princeton University. “Princeton Entrepreneurship Advisory Committee (PEAC).” Princeton University. March 09, 2018. Accessed June 05, 2018.http://www.princeton.edu/strategicplan/taskforces/peac/.
⁴ Princeton University. “Task Force on the Future of the Graduate School.” Princeton University. July 08, 2016. Accessed June 05, 2018.http://www.princeton.edu/strategicplan/taskforces/gradschool/.
⁵ Princeton University. “Service and Civic Engagement Self-Study.” Princeton University. July 08, 2016. Accessed June 05, 2018. http://www.princeton.edu/strategicplan/taskforces/sce/.
⁶ Princeton University. “Task Force on the Residential College Model.” Princeton University. September 14, 2016. Accessed June 05, 2018.http://www.princeton.edu/strategicplan/taskforces/rescollege/.
⁷ Princeton University. “CPUC Standing/Special Committee Members, 2017-18.” Princeton University. November 13, 2017. Accessed June 05, 2018.http://www.princeton.edu/vpsec/cpuc/committees/.
⁸ “UNITS.” ASUC. Accessed June 05, 2018. https://asuc.org/commissionscommittees/.
⁹ “Student Advocate’s Office.” Student Advocate’s Office. Accessed June 05, 2018.https://advocate.berkeley.edu/.
¹⁰ “Institute and Faculty Committees.” MIT Undergraduate Association. Accessed June 05, 2018.http://ua.mit.edu/institutecomms/.
- SUNY Plattsburgh Student Senate passed a vote of no confidence in regards to three officials.^12
- The University of Southern Illinois Student Government passed a vote of no confidence, resulting in the resignation of their president.^13
¹¹ Hussain, Suhauna, and Alexander Barreiro. “UC Student Association Passes Vote of No Confidence in UC Regents, UC President Janet Napolitano.” The Daily Californian. January 14, 2015. Accessed June 05, 2018. http://www.dailycal.org/2015/01/11/uc-student-association-passes-vote-confidence-uc-regents-uc-president-janet-napolitano/.
¹² Lois, and Kayla Breen. “PSU Student Senate Votes No Confidence for Officials.” Press-Republican. February 21, 2018. Accessed June 05, 2018. http://www.pressrepublican.com/news/local_news/psu-student-senate-votes-no-confidence-for-officials/article_32bba4e5-547e-5943-924e-62d86018109.html.
¹³ Chrysantou, Athena. “USG President Impeached, Vote of No Confidence for Chancellor Carlo Montemagno.” Daily Egyptian. February 14, 2018. Accessed June 05, 2018. https://dailyegyptian.com/79217/news/usg-president-impeached-vote-of-no-confidence-for-chancellor-carlo-montemagno/.
POWERS & AUTHORITIES RESOLUTION CLAUSE 3
SGA Powers in Long-Term Decision-Making Bodies
3. In regards to the powers of the SGA in long-term University decision-making bodies:
a. The annual placement of the SGA Executive President and Vice President on the Public Investment Interest Advisory Committee (PIIAC) as full voting members:
- i.The addition of the SGA Executive President and Vice President to the list of University administrators notified and consulted on University crises; inclement weather, and student emergencies;
b. The annual placement of the SGA Treasurer, onto the Parents’ Council Leadership Giving Circle;
c. The annual placement of the Chair of the SGA Academic Affairs Committee, or the committee’s successors, onto the Homewood Academic Council (HAC) as a full voting member;
- i.The annual placement of two members of the SGA Academic Affairs Committee, or the committee’s successors, onto the Homewood Ethics and Conduct Board as full voting members;
- ii.The placement of a member of the SGA Academic Affairs Committee, or the committee’s successors, onto any entity tasked by the University to review the existence or “worth” of an academic department;
d. The annual placement of the Chair of the SGA Civic Engagement Committee, or the committee’s successors, onto the Agora Institute Steering Committee and the Center for Social Concern (CSC) Advisory Board;
e. The annual placement of the Chair of the SGA Health, Safety, and Sustainability Committee, or the committee’s successors, onto the Counseling Center Advisory Board;
- i.The annual placement of a member of the SGA Health, Safety, and Sustainability Committee, or the committee’s successors, onto the Residential Advisory Board (RAB) and the Community Advisory Board (CAB);
f. The annual placement of the Chair of the SGA Student Services Committee, or the committee’s successors, onto the Alumni Council as a full voting member and as a direct student representative to the Alumni Council Executive Committee;
- i.The annual placement of a member of the SGA Student Services Committee, or the committee’s successors, onto the Residential Advisory Board (RAB) and the Community Advisory Board (CAB).
g. The annual placement of the Chair of the SGA Finance Committee, or the committee’s successors, onto the Parents’ Council Leadership Giving Circle;
h. The annual placement of the Chair of the SGA Student Organizations Committee, or the committee’s successors, onto the Parents’ Council Leadership Giving Circle;
A. Public Investment Interest Advisory Committee (PIIAC)
The SGA strongly believes that the Executive President and Vice President should be annually placed on PIIAC as voting members and the primary representatives of the student body. In the past, SGA has not been granted explicitly seats on PIIAC, nor has it been granted the ability to select the undergraduate students placed on PIIAC. This places both the student body and the University at a serious disadvantage, as the viewpoint of students is not fully democratically represented and the University cannot be fully certain that the student representatives on PIIAC are speaking with the intent of the student body. As such, the University’s long-term investments, whose ramifications impact student life and future alumni donations, are negatively impacted when PIIAC does not include explicit student representation. At minimum, PIIAC should thus include the Executive President and Vice President as full voting members.
The SGA further advises that PIIAC move towards the model of Princeton University, if not create a completely new committee based on Princeton’s best practices. At Princeton, the equivalent of PIIAC is known as the Council of the Princeton University Community (CPUC)[^14]. Led by the President of Princeton University, CPUC brings together every single stakeholder group (faculty, students, staff and alumni) and allows those stakeholder groups to select their own representatives to the group. Moreover, the CPUC’s six annual meetings (and accompanying minutes dating back to 2014) are all open to the public, and its agendas are directly set by public comment. CPUC is also more encompassing in its guidance of Princeton’s long-term agenda setting than PIIAC is for Johns Hopkins. CPUC has dedicated subcommittees responsible for continuously evaluating institutional governance, continuously evaluating institutional resource allocation, institutional internal regulation and compliance. Having existed since the 1970s, CPUC demonstrates that a University can cultivate a more inclusive atmosphere when all stakeholders are granted shares and say in the University’s long-term development.
A1. Emergency Crisis List
The most recent occasion on which the SGA was actively consulted on campus safety during an emergency crisis, was during the 2016 Winter Blizzard. At that time, Executive President Jack Barthollet was consulted by members of Homewood Student Affairs to ascertain whether the campus was safe enough for non-critical employees to arrive on campus, and for students to travel onto campus from their homes or residence halls. President Barthollet ascertained that the campus was too dangerous to traverse, and accordingly, the University had a second day of cancelled classes. While some faculty protested this decision, it ultimately allowed for more students to return to campus and for less students to face injury while traversing a snow- and ice-covered campus.
In addition, SGA members are only fleetingly informed of other crises that could affect student wellbeing. At an SGA-administrator dinner in the past two years, four SGA members were privately pulled aside to discuss an opioid overdose at a local fraternity house that nearly resulted in the death of two students. SGA leadership was also not informed of the falling death of a sophomore in summer 2017 and the Steinberg family death in late 2017 until Homewood Student Affairs sent out a school-wide email, thereby slowing SGA’s own response to supporting its constituents in times of greater emotional turmoil. Furthermore, SGA is never consulted on the University response to national crises, such as DACA or Hurricanes Harvey and Maria. While the University reacted in a timely manner on DACA, it acted only selectively on Hurricanes Harvey and Maria.
[^14]: http://www.princeton.edu/vpsec/cpuc/
As such, it is crucial that the SGA Executive President and Vice President be added to the same emergency crisis contact lists as those with upper-level administrators, so that the University can respond to crises in such a way that students feel that the institution supports them, rather than attempting to engage in risk management.
B. G. H. Parents’ Council Leadership Giving Circle[^15]
The Parents’ Council Leadership Giving Circle is responsible for soliciting donations from parents, and ultimately, supporting the Parents’ Fund. The SGA Treasurer, as the final arbiter of financial allocations for over four-hundred student organizations, should be actively granted a seat on the Giving Circle such that parental leadership is made aware of ongoing student funding needs. While it is helpful for parents to meet with upper-level administrators at semesterly receptions, it is crucial that not only certain parents and their children be able to direct the purpose of the Parents’ Fund, but also the highest democratically elected financial officer of the student body.
Similarly, so too should the chairs of the SGA Finance and Student Organizations Committees. Both engage in frequent consultation with the SGA Treasurer, and both lead critical SGA operations that lend them a close connection to the monetary needs of student organizations. The Finance Committee chair is able to see what student organizations or areas of student organizations require the most stimulus spending (and thus represent the areas of most student group growth and need), while the Student Organizations chair is responsible for overseeing SGA accreditation of student organizations, and can thus see which student organizations are growing in student interest, size, and involvement. The addition of the perspective of these three officers would be an invaluable asset to the Parents’ Council Leadership Giving Circle.
C. Homewood Academic Council (HAC)
The Homewood Academic Council (HAC) is responsible for reviewing faculty promotion and demotion procedures, as well as being the final arbiter of academic policies at the University. Indeed, the HAC was responsible for voting away coveted grades in 2011. The SGA Academic Affairs Committee Chair, as the primary advocate for students’ academic perspectives, should be granted a voting seat on the Homewood Academic Council to ensure that faculty regulation is conducted in such a way that includes the interests of students, for whom JHU — the world’s first research and teaching university — was built.
At MIT[^16], several of the Homewood Academic Council’s equivalents include student representation. The MIT Faculty Policy Committee, responsible for faculty compliance with institutional regulations, includes one voting student representative. The MIT Committee on Academic Performance, responsible for setting standards of student academic output, includes three voting student representatives.
C1. Ethics and Conduct Board
[^15]: https://studentaffairs.jhu.edu/parents-families/get-involved/hopkins-parents-council/[^16]: http://ua.mit.edu/institutecommittees/
Following this, the Director of Student Conduct, Dana Broadnax, has suggested in smaller meetings that members of SGA should be given a position on the Ethics and Conduct Boards. Under the reasoning that the SGA Academic Affairs Committee is most qualified to handle matters of academic ethics, SGA demands that it appoint two members of its choice of its Academic Affairs Committee to the Ethics and Conduct Board.
C2. Departmental Review Boards
Though undergraduates were less affected by the Humanities Center restructuring of 2016 and 2017 than were graduate students, undergraduates still feared for those departments who do not traditionally yield as much federal research funding or exterior donations as their STEM counterparts: the arts, English and foreign languages, the social sciences. The most striking cause of this fear was the process by which the Humanities Center was reviewed: by a small group of faculty personally appointed by the Dean, with no consultation of student viewpoints.
To rectify this situation in the future, the SGA demands that the SGA Academic Affairs Committee be able to appoint any member of itself or the student body onto any entity tasked by the University to review the existence or “worth” of an academic department.
D. Agora Institute Steering Committee
The Agora Institute, funded by the largest non-profit donation to the Homewood campus in years, was expected to be a nexus for civic engagement across the campus. With several new faculty and a new building, the entity was expected - by students, faculty, staff and alumni alike - to revolutionize the image of Johns Hopkins in regards to politics, policy, and even Baltimore.
The Institute, while still moving forward, has shifted towards programming rather than tangible policy development or community engagement. As various campus stakeholders (including students) have pushed to see the fruits of the Institute’s early labors, the SGA firmly believes that having a vested student stake in the Institute will ensure its long-term viability and sustainability on the Homewood campus. The SGA thus encourages the University to establish a public steering committee for the Agora Institute, of which one voting member shall be the Chair of the SGA Civic Engagement Committee. The Civic Engagement Committee Chair is the SGA member who is most in touch with the civic needs of the student body, and can thus ensure that the Agora Institute will conduct community engagement in such a way that involves all, rather than simply relies on research and publications.
D1. Center for Social Concern (CSC) Advisory Board
A concept pioneered by close connections between this year’s SGA Civic Engagement Committee and CSC Interim Director Gia McGinnis, the SGA requests that its Chair be a voting member of the CSC to ensure that the University’s engagement in Baltimore is also conducted in a way that the student body can believe in and support.
E. Counseling Center Advisory Board
In many ways, the origins of JHU’s current push for improved mental health derives from this very Student Government Association. Starting with the resignation of former SGA President Jason Plush, through the Mental Health Task Force and now the Well-Being Working Group, the
SGA has been thoroughly involved in mental health reform on campus. In particular, this past year’s Health, Safety, and Sustainability (HSS) Committee collaborated heavily with the Counseling Center and its director, Dr. Matthew Torres. To ensure that collaboration in the future remains consistent, the SGA requests that the HSS chair be placed onto the Counseling Center Advisory Board as a representative of the SGA.
F. Alumni Council and Alumni Council Executive Committee
In the past two decades, the JHU Alumni Association has attempted to increase its provision of unique benefits and services to the undergraduate student body. For example, the Alumni Association allows students to become Alumni Student Ambassadors and network with the Association. The Alumni Association also offers a Baltimorean discount-coupon program for JHU students. Given this expansion of engagement with JHU students, the SGA demands that the Chair of its Student Services Committee be placed as a full voting member on the Alumni Council and as a direct student representative to the Alumni Council Executive Committee.
The benefits of this placement would be manifold. First, the Alumni Council would gain a direct perspective into the lives of current students, as represented by the Chair of the committee most responsible for student services. Second, the Student Services Chair could serve as a focal point for real-time collaborations between the SGA, JHU alumni, the student body and the Hopkins community. This could lead to increases in undergraduate interest in alumni giving, which has historically remained over 30% below those of peer institutions such as Harvard or Yale. In the long-run, this kind of collaboration could even lead to greater support for initiatives like a student center or improved financial aid for matriculating undergraduates.
E1, F1. Residential Advisory Board (RAB) and Community Advisory Board (CAB)
As the HSS Committee and Student Services Committee are SGA’s most critical evaluators and advocates of student wellness and student services, it would be beneficial for each to have voting representatives on the RAB and CAB, and even each’s executive board. On the RAB, members of the HSS Committee and Student Services Committee could improve student services provision in residence halls. On the CAB, members of the HSS Committee and Student Services Committee could promote even greater mental health and wellbeing programs.
General Peer Precedent for Student Representation on Institutional Bodies
Duke’s student government, one of the most effective and expansive student representative organizations of our peer institutions, operates with a very similar organizational structure to the one illustrated in clauses 6 and 7. The Duke University Student Government appoints students to “University Committees,” institutions that include “any committee, council, board, task force, or other body that is established by a proper authority within Duke University.” At Duke, these include the Advisory Council on Investment Responsibility (ACIR), the President’s Council on Black Affairs (PCOBA), and the University Priorities Committee (UPC). We, the JHU SGA, feel that not only by sending representatives to institutional committees, but also by having the aforementioned administrators meet with the duly and democratically elected representatives of the SGA, the University can strengthen its institutional committees and their priorities, the administrative titles listed, when paired with duly and democratically appointed.
student representatives (stemming from within SGA), can become a Hopkins form of“University Committees”<sup>17</sup>. In this initiative, Hopkins SGA is not lobbying for direct control ofthe proceedings of these general administrative functions, rather just a more frequent, active, andconstructive dialogue between student representatives and administration. This type ofrelationship is outlined by the Duke model, wherein the Executive President appoints theserepresentatives to the councils and the Executive Vice President is tasked with the oversight ofthe student representatives.
MIT<sup>18</sup> also has a similar system of functional representation of students on a total ofthirty-two different task forces or committees. Dealing with specific, strategic issues fromacademic performance to corporate relations to LGBTQ+ issues to research guidelines, eachcommittee has at least one, and in most cases, two to four, student representatives. What our SGAis proposing fits into our existing committee structure, but accomplishes the same goal - campuswide issues tackled by a team of students and administrators working together.
<sup>17</sup> https://drive.google.com/file/d/17rqE_dRmXmXmbktQIH1QUJTmWDMYwVLeptq/view?usp=sharing
<sup>18</sup> http://ua.mit.edu/uacouncil/
POWERS & AUTHORITIES RESOLUTION CLAUSE 4
SGA Powers in Advocacy-Centered Bodies Across the University
- In regards to representative bodies across the University:
- a.The annual of two representatives of the SGA, selected by the SGA, onto each of the following entities, in addition to any additional SGA members who independently apply or are selected for membership.
- i.The Diversity Leadership Council (DLC);
- ii.The Homewood Council for Inclusive Excellence (HCIE);
- iii.The Women Faculty Forum (WFF) (successor to the Committee on the Status of Women);
- a.The annual of two representatives of the SGA, selected by the SGA, onto each of the following entities, in addition to any additional SGA members who independently apply or are selected for membership.
Currently the DLC and HCIE have at least one student representative. The issue relating to the lack of student representation is this:
- Students lack the knowledge that these working groups exist
- Students who attend these meetings are fully self motivated to do so and, therefore have no binding appointment to these groups
By allowing SGA to appoint students to these entities, undergraduates on each body will serve on the behalf of SGA, and therefore, the undergraduate student body, with more tangible responsibilities in regards to attendance and reporting of these meetings. Furthermore, student representation on such bodies would allow for further communication between student, faculty, and staff, all of which are stakeholders in the aforementioned groups. The reporting on behalf of students will provide more information regarding each committee’s initiatives to the great student body, without having to exhaust valuable time and energy in searching for the committees’ minutes or archives. This model is strongly justified by the leadership models of previously presented peer institutions.
As alluded to above, SGA has itself made diplomatic connections with these entities, which is why these bodies have been allocated their own section. Now, it simply seeks to ensure that the greater student body is lended a voice on these councils.
POWERS & AUTHORITIES RESOLUTION CLAUSE 5
SGA Connection to the Administration on a Daily Basis
5. In regards to the connection of the SGA to the administration on a daily basis:
a. The joint direct advising of the SGA not only by DOSL and its subsidiaries but also by the Vice Provost for Student Affairs for all of JHU, Kevin Shollenberger;
This clause would serve to streamline SGA access to higher level administrative proceedings that often rise above the level of Student Leadership and Involvement. While DOSL and SLI have been and will hopefully continue to be incredibly important resources for SGA, SGA’s interaction with them tends to be more for objectives involving student activities and engagement, rather than tangible university policy. Going forward, the latter is exactly the area in which the SGA would like to have considerable and proportionate influence. Former MIT President Martin F. Holmes,<sup>19</sup> in his outgoing list of recommendations to create a more inclusive and representative campus, spoke of several sectors requiring student representation: “Strategic topics that have typically been outside the arena of student involvement, such as undergraduate enrollment, financial aid, responsible investment, deferred maintenance, and capital projects, have a tremendous impact on the quality of student life at MIT.” We find this sentiment to be completely applicable to the Hopkins community. Being directly advised by the Vice Provost of Student Affairs will help the SGA be properly aware of upcoming changes in policy and give the SGA a better pipeline for proposing or amending existing/forthcoming policy, as the Vice Provost deals precisely with or precisely alongside those [unclear: whose] strategic topics enumerated by President Holmes. To clarify, this advisor addition does not mean an end to our existing relationship with DOSL, as student involvement remains a fundamental tenet of the SGA mission. Rather, the change means an extension from solely student involvement to tangible student representation in strategic realms of university policy.
Similarly, when new policies are explored by university officials, SGA’s new relationship with the Vice Provost will aid in better communicating those new policies to the student body. Holmes also writes, “Some of the most heated controversies on campus focus on these strategic decisions.” On the Homewood campus, we see that logic hold up. Our most heated controversies have centered around strategic decisions to bring in a private police force, to remove covered grades, or even alter dining and housing policies and facilities. Most often these controversies are partly, if not largely, about the process to which students learned of the changes (eg. the private police initiative being announced to students a year after its conception and during a busy midterm period). In working closely with the Vice Provost specifically, SGA executives can plan prompt, timely, and clear communication strategies to disseminate valuable information to students - working to better fulfill SGA’s responsibility to be conduits of information from the top down. All of this with the goal of avoiding large campus controversies that ultimately distract from the student experience at Hopkins.
We reaffirm that institutional changes are best understood by the student body through peer-explanation, and SGA ought to be that clear and efficient conduit from administration, at the highest level, to students.
POWERS & AUTHORITIES RESOLUTION CLAUSES 6 & 7
SGA Powers in Long-Term Decision-Making Bodies
6. The establishment or re-establishment of regular meetings between the SGA Executive Board (or other designated SGA representatives) and:
- i.The Vice Provost for Student Affairs, Kevin Shollenberger (monthly);
- ii.The Dean of Student Life, as identified in summer 2018 (monthly);
- The Associate Dean of Student Wellbeing, Toni Blackwell (monthly);
- The Associate Dean of Student Conduct, Tammy Saunders or her Ethics Coordinator, Dana Broadnax (monthly);
- iii.The Dean of Academic and Student Services, Andy Wilson (monthly);
- iv.The Secretary to the Board of Trustees, Maureen Marsh (semesterly);
- v.The Senior Vice President for Finance and Administration, Daniel Ennis (semesterly);
- vi.The Vice President and General Counsel, Paul Pineau (semesterly);
- vii.The Vice President for Communications, Susan Ridge (semesterly);
- viii.The Senior Advisor to the President for Policy, Steven Ruckman (semesterly);
- ix.The President of the Board of Trustees, Jeff Aronson, or his successor (semesterly);
7. In regards to each committee of SGA and its connection to the administration^20^:
- a.The establishment or re-establishment of regular meetings between the SGA Academic Affairs Committee and:
- i.The Assistant Vice Provost for Education, Janet Shreck (semesterly);
- ii.The Assistant Vice Provost for Financial Aid, Tom McDermott (semesterly);
- iii.The Assistant Dean of Academic Advising, Jim Fry (semesterly);
- b.The establishment or re-establishment of regular meetings between the SGA Civic Engagement Committee and:
- i.The Vice President for Government and Community Relations, Thomas Lewis and his special advisor, Jeanne Hitchcock (semesterly);
- ii.The Vice Provost for Institutional Equity (OIE), Jeanine Hayes (semesterly);
- iii.The Vice Provost for Diversity and Inclusion, Fenimore Fisher (semesterly);
- iv.The Director of the Agora Institute, when named by its search committee (monthly);
- v.The Director of the Center for Social Concern (monthly);
- c.The establishment or re-establishment of regular meetings between the SGA Health, Safety and Sustainability Committee and:
- i.The Vice Provost for Institutional Equity (OIE), Jeanine Hayes (semesterly);
^20^ https://www.jhu.edu/assets/uploads/2016:01/org_chart.pdf ii. The Vice President for Facilities and Real Estate, Robert McLean (semesterly);
iii. The Vice President for Security, Melissa Hyatt (semesterly), and the Director of Homewood Safety and Security, Christina Presberry (monthly);
iv. The Office of Sustainability (monthly);
d. The establishment or re-establishment of regular meetings between the SGA Internal Affairs Committee and:
- i.The Vice President for Institutional Research (OIR), Ratna Sarkar (semesterly);
- ii.Special Advisor to the Vice Provost for Student Affairs, Jennifer Calhoun (semesterly);
e. The establishment or re-establishment of regular meetings between the SGA Finance Committee and:
- i.The Vice President for Investments and the Chief Investment Officer, Jason Perlioni (semesterly);
f. The establishment or re-establishment of regular meetings between the SGA Student Services Committee and:
- i.The Vice President for Development and Alumni Relations, Fritz Schroeder (semesterly);
- ii.The Director of Residential Life, Alison Avolio (monthly);
g. The establishment or re-establishment of regular meetings between the SGA Student Organizations Committee and:
- i.The President of the Alumni Association, David Yaffe (semesterly);
The case for these two methods of organization - regular executive meetings with generalist administrators and the pairing of issue-specific administrators with our existing committee structure - is all about productive collaboration. We see clauses 6 and 7 as a way to create a more useful working relationship between SGA and relevant administrative departments. Even with the examples mentioned from Duke and MIT, we see this structure already partly in use at Hopkins already in the form of SGA’s class councils. Each council has an advisor (either an SLI representative or the head of SYE, for the sophomore council) and that working relationship is massively important for the functioning of the council. The Class Council consults the advisor about relevant and existing resources and initiatives that correspond to the Council’s goals, while the advisor pushes and challenges those goals to more tangibly serve the interests of the class and the broader University. As SGA is right now, class councils are often viewed as the most visible and most effective arms of student government, and we believe this comes as a direct result of close collaboration with relevant administrators. SGA already often invites administrators from various departments to attend its weekly GBMs and hosts dinners with administrators, and while we seek to continue these opportunities to interface with administrative representatives, these exchanges are annual, brief, and cater to a broad SGA audience, rather than the specific individuals or committees that the speakers are relevant to. SGA representatives are also constantly working to set up ad-hoc meetings with administrators, but scheduling is often a herculean task when all parties involved have so much on their plate. To increase the general effectiveness of SGA executive and committee business, regular contact and collaboration with general-strategic (clause 6) and committee specific administrative (clause 7) personnel is not only logical, but absolutely necessary. As policy ambitions broaden and the importance of young activists in society is realized, we all must seek to empower our student representatives with efficient tools to create a community that best serves their interests. Clauses 6 and 7 expand upon SGA’s tradition of meeting with a wide range of university officials by strengthening and streamlining our administrative relationships with regular, pre-defined meetings, while SGA can increase student visibility of student-administrator relations through the committee reports it issues at each General Body Meeting.
Clauses 6 and 7 will also serve to increase the student body’s awareness of administrators’ roles, duties, and activities. A sentiment frequently expressed by the student body toward the SGA is that the administrative structure is a large, complex, and inaccessible bureaucracy, it is a perception that SGA and administration must work together to change. We believe that simply by connecting individual student representatives to many, if not all, of the university’s working branches, we can foster a feeling of connectedness to the people who shape the policies that affect the student experience, and by even simply listing all of our points of contact with administration on our SGA marketing materials, the list of people crafting our Hopkins experience will surely turn out to be more friendly and more human than the student body would have otherwise imagined.
