Minutes of the Constitutional Committee of the S.A.C.
Meeting of September 28, 1982
The meeting was called to order slightly after five o'clock p.m. Chairman DAVIS and Committeemen HILL, [handwritten: struck-out name, illegible], LALLY and SALLES were present.
Chairman DAVIS passed out copies of the current S.A.C. Constitution not including the three amendments passed unanimously at the Sept. 16th meeting of the full Commission, cosponsored by DAVIS and SALLES. Due to time constraints, the Council had not yet had time to consider these amendments for ratification but the Chairman said that in light of their uncontroversial nature and unanimous passage they would be approved in due course and in any event it would be in order for the Committee to assume them passed for purposes of its work pending final resolution of the question.
Chairman DAVIS said that future meetings of the Committee would be held at 5:00 on Tuesdays in the SAC Office and last approximately two hours. This meeting was for organizational purposes and for consideration solely of technical amendments and would last one hour.
Committeeman SMITH arrived at this point.
Chairman DAVIS said that he envisioned the Committee as passing on the entire document clause by clause. As each clause was opened for discussion "questions, comments, suggestions, or amendments", thus enabling discussion without presence of a formal motion on the floor. Once the Committee passed on a clause, it would be considered closed, although the report would have to again be passed by the full Committee as a draft report after consideration of comments by members of the Executive Committee. He stressed that this Committee reports to the Commission directly and not to the Executive Committee, and the latter may not modify this Committee's report, although the floor of the Commission must pass it by 2/3 vote. Committeeman SALLES asked whether this procedure nullified the normal rule of procedure allowing a question to be reopened by 2/3 vote of the Committee, saying that this would often be necessary to "clean up structure", or when enacting a change that would require changes earlier on in the document. Chairman DAVIS said that it would not, and moved that the Committee adopt this procedure. Committeeman LALLY seconded. Motion passed unanimously.
Chairman DAVIS said that this Committee's purview also included the construction of bylaws, which might be relevant as by-products of or substitutes for constitutional changes. He stated that the floor of the Commission could pass by-laws without reference to Council, so that part of the Committee's report could take effect immediately. He said he was unsure as to the margin of passage required for bylaws. Committeeman SMITH said that by-laws could be passed by 2/3 vote of the membership, and suggested further that a constitutional amendment be made allowing the Executive Committee to pass by-laws by some margin at the appropriate time.
Meeting of September 28, 1982 (cont'd)
Chairman DAVIS said that he had appointed Committeeman SALLES secretary. The last mentioned groaned audibly, and offered to resign the post if anyone objected. Chairman DAVIS asked if there were any objections "or volunteers". There were none.
Chairman DAVIS said that he expected the Committee to have produced a final report in four meetings. This, the first, was for organizational and technical matters; the second and third for clause-by-clause consideration of the draft document; the fourth for passage of the draft report after receipt of comments by the Executive Committee. He asked for objections to this timetable. There were none.
Chairman DAVIS said that for convenience all motions proposed by any Committee member shall be considered automatically seconded by the Chair so that they may be discussed and amended. He then opened the floor for business.
Committeeman SALLES said that he had prepared 17 proposals for consideration by the Committee. The majority he said were technical in nature and many of the remainder "probably noncontroversial" though substantive since several had been discussed with various Committee members. He distributed copies to Committee members. He moved that his amendments nos. 1,3,4,8,10,12,13,14,16 be considered technical and considered at this meeting in numerical order and that nos. 2,5,6,7,9,11,15, and 17 be considered substantive and considered as the appropriate clauses in the constitution were brought up for discussion. In light of the lack of necessity for formal motion to exist he would read them into the record as bases for discussion but would not introduce them as motions to avoid being repeatedly amended or withdrawn, etc., after discussion in committee. Motion passed unanimously.
Salles proposal #1 called for insertion of a new section in Article I numbered 1, and renumbering the current sections 1,2, & 3 numbered 2,3, & 4 respectively. The proposed section read: "The phrases "majority vote", "majority vote of the whole Commission", "majority vote of the full Commission" as used throughout this document shall alike refer to an affirmative vote on an appropriate motion of a majority of those present and voting at a meeting of the Commission at which there is present a valid quorum. Substitute representation of member organizations shall be as provided for elsewhere in this document and as provided for in the applicable standing rules of procedure."
Chairman DAVIS said that in light of the Debby Jeffrey situation last year, where the Chairman (Jeffrey) ruled that "majority vote" meant "affirmative vote of a majority of the membership" in the section regarding proposals of constitutional amendments, a ruling he characterized as "strange" in light of the fact that she had at an earlier meeting ruled it "majority vote of a quorum". However, he said had to be done to clarify "the whole vote business". However, he said it was a bad idea to introduce a whole section just for this purpose, and said he'd rather see the Committee reword this language as it occurred.
Meeting of September 28, 1982 (cont'd)
Committeeman SALLES agreed, saying that his proposal had been made up before he knew whether or not the Committee would be considering amendments "patchwork".
Committeeman SMITH introduced a motion that the words "(proportion) vote of a quorum", "(proportion) vote," or "(proportion) vote of the Commission", or "(proportion) vote of the whole Commission" shall be replaced by the words "(proportion) vote of a quorum of the Commission", where the word "(proportion)" in his motion shall be considered to include the phrases "majority", "three-fifths", or "two-thirds" as shall be appropriate.
Committeeman SALLES moved to exempt Article III Section 5, since he believed that that provision, dealing with the removal of at large delegates by "majority vote...expressed in a petition" meant that the petition should contain the signatures of a majority of Commission members, and simply had been worded badly. Committeeman SMITH accepted the amendment as friendly. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
- Article I Section 3 Subparagraph 2
Strike: The Commission can, by majority vote, amend...Replace: The Commission can, by majority vote of a quorum, amend...
Article I Section 3 Subparagraph 3
Strike: ...by a vote of 3/5 of a quorumReplace: ...by 3/5 vote of a quorum of the Commission
Article VII Section 1
Strike: ...by a 2/3 vote of a quorum at a meeting of the whole CommissionReplace: ...by 2/3 vote of a quorum of the Commission
SALLES proposal #3 called for a deletion of the words "The Treasurer shall notify the entire Commission in writing..." and replacement by "The Treasurer shall notify the entire Commission membership in writing."He explained that "very technically" a notification of the entire Commission would require calling a meeting of the entire Commission, which seemed contrary to the spirit of the section. Chairman DAVIS agreed.Committeeman SMITH moved that the proposal be adopted except that the words "entire Commission membership" be replaced by "all Commission members". Motion passed unanimously.
Meeting of September 28, 1982 (cont'd) -4-
CHANGES MADE
Article II, Section 1, Subsection 7
strike: "...The Treasurer shall notify the Commission in writing..."Replace: "...The Treasurer shall notify all Commission members in writing..."
SALLES proposal #4 dealt similarly with Article III, Section 2, Subparagraph 4, replacing "The Board shall notify the Commission in writing..." with "The Board shall notify all members of the Commission in writing..." Chairman DAVIS moved that the proposal be adopted but that "in the interests of uniformity" the phrase "members of the Commission" be changed to "Commission members". Committeeman SALLES seconded. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article III Section 2 Subparagraph 4
strike: The Board shall notify the Commission in writing...Replace: The Board shall notify all Commission members in writing...
SALLES proposal #8 called for replacement of the entirety of Article II, Section 1, Subparagraph 1 with the following wording: "call and preside at meetings of the Commission and the Executive Board, being responsible in each case for the giving of timely notice to all members of the appropriate body. In the case of meetings of the full Commission, notice must be given in writing to each member 48 hours prior to the scheduled time of the meeting; in the case of Executive Board meetings, the membership of the Board shall direct the Treasurer as to what shall be considered timely notice in the meaning of this article, with the proviso that in no event shall the Treasurer be required to give more than 48 hours' notice. He explained this merely defined what "timely notice" of meetings, as in this section and in Article III, Section 2, Subparagraph #13 (pending before Council) which provided that "the Chairman shall give timely notice to all SAC members, as in a meeting called under the provisions of Article II Section 1"."
Committeeman HILL said that the proposal's wording was too long and moved it be adopted replacing the semicolon after meeting with a period and striking everything thereafter. Committeeman SALLES said that HILL "was right again" about the length but said something should be done about the Executive Board. Chairman DAVIS said he didn't think it would be necessary, but suggested something might be done with Article III, Section 3. Committeeman SALLES expressed himself as satisfied. Motion passed unanimously.
Meeting of September 28, 1982 (cont'd)
CHANGES MADE
Article II, Section 1, Subparagraph 1
Strike: call and preside at meetings of the Commission and theExecutive Board and see that their decisions are faithfullyexecuted;
Replace: call and preside at meetings of the Commission and theExecutive Board, being responsible in each case for thegiving of timely notice to all members of the appropriatebody in the case of meetings of the full Commission, noticemust be given in writing to each member 48 hours prior tothe scheduled time of the meeting.
SALLES proposal #10 is quoted below, inasmuch as it was passed withoutchange at the motion of Committeeman HILL, unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article III, Section 5
Strike: by majority vote of all SAC delegates expressed in apetition submitted to the Treasurer
Replace: by a petition containing the signatures of a majorityof the general membership of the Commission submitted
to the Chairman
SALLES proposal #12 dealt with Article IV, Section 9 and called fordeletion of the words "will result in the freezing of funds" andreplacement by "as grounds for the freezing of funds". His explanationwas that the funds could only be frozen by the Executive Board orthe SAC by overturning an action (not to freeze them) of the ExecutiveBoard and could not occur without further action by operation ofconstitutional provision. Chairman DAVIS agreed, but said that hehad intended to propose deletion of this language altogether inasmuchas there was no particular reason for this language to occur here atall, since the circumstances in which the Treasurer and/or the Exec.Board could freeze funds were detailed elsewhere. However, he saidthat his amendment was substantive in nature and suggested that thisquestion be considered when Article IV, Section 9 came up for review.No motion was introduced.
Meeting of September 28, 1982 (cont'd)
SALLES proposal #13 dealt with the preamble section to Article V and called for the deletion of the words "They must be led by undergraduates" and their replacement by the words "All elected officers must be undergraduates". He explained this as a concrete definition of the words "led by", made especially important since the standing rule of procedure adopted by the Commission on Sept. 16th allowed voting by elected officers as substitutes for the specific club officers named in the constitution, and it was his impression that the Committee intended to write this provision into the constitution (the substitute voting procedure). Committeeman SMITH moved that this be adopted with the addition of the words "and voting members" after the words "elected officers". He explained that this was a requirement of the Student Body Constitution anyway and might as well be written into the S.A.C. Constitution "to avoid problems". Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article V, Prefatory Paragraph
Strike: They must be led by undergraduates.
Replace: All elected officers and voting members must beundergraduates.
SALLES proposal #14 called for replacement of the words "The whole membership of the Commission shall be convened" with "Meetings of the Commission shall be called" in Article VI, Section 1. Committeeman SMITH asked what happened, under the current or proposed wording, if a meeting was called and a quorum was not present. Committeeman SALLES said that he understood that a meeting without a quorum was a meeting, just one unable to transact business. He said that the wording regarding "meetings of the Commission" being "called" was used elsewhere throughout the document. He asked Chairman DAVIS for his opinion (as to meetings sans quorum). Chairman DAVIS said that he agreed, and that furthermore this change would have no effect on the definition of the word "meeting" anyway. Committeeman SMITH expressed himself satisfied. He moved to adopt this proposal. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article VI, Section 1
Strike: The whole membership of the Commission shall be convened...
Replace: Meetings of the Commission shall be called...
Meeting of September 28, 1982 (cont'd)
CALLES proposal #16 called for deletion of each reference to the "Student Council constitution" in Article VII, Section 2, and its replacement with "Student Body Constitution", since that was its proper name. Committeeman SMITH suggested instead that the committee recommend to Council "that it change the name of its constitution". Chairman DAVIS commented that such a change required a student referendum, and in the meantime the S.A.C. would have to produce a constitution in conformity with the current Student Body Constitution. He moved that the SALIES proposal be adopted, excepting that the references be to the "Constitution of the Student Body of the Johns Hopkins University", its formal name. Committeeman SALIES seconded, stating that while he thought the Student Body Constitution was "less than a miracle of draftsmanship" it wasn't within the purview of this Committee or the S.A.C. to suggest amendments to it. Committeeman LALLY agreed, and said that if this committee was to start talking about the problems with the Student Body Constitution, Committeeman HILL said "let's"it could stay in session for weeks". Committeeman HILL said "let's pass the thing". Passed 3-1; HILL, LALLY, SALIES in favor, SMITH dissenting.
CHANGES MADE
Article VII, Section 2
Strike: Changes in the Student Council constitution...
Replace: Changes in the Constitution of the Student Body of the Johns Hopkins University...
Strike: ...with the Student Council constitution
Replace: ...with the Constitution of the Student Body of the Johns Hopkins University
Meeting was adjourned at 6:04 pm.
Meeting of the Constitutional Committee of the S.A.C.
Meeting of October 5, 1982
Chairman DAVIS called the meeting to order. Committeemen HILL, KRUZANSKY, LALLY, and SALLES were present.
Chairman DAVIS noted the absence of Committeeman SMITH. He asked that all members of the Committee be present at the meeting which passes on the final report.
Committeeman SALLES moved to strike the words "the Student Council establishes" from the preamble to the constitution, replacing it with the wording "the student body by provision of the Constitution of the Student Body of the Johns Hopkins University", and furthermore to strike the language following the word "Commission". He explained that the Student Council had nothing to do with the establishment or continuance of the S.A.C., but rather that the S.A.C. has always existed by provision of the Student Body Constitution, even though "in that constitution's latest incarnation" the S.A.C. is considered "an executive standing committee of Council." Committeeman LALLY agreed, and added that it was typical of the technical mess that the Constitution was in that "it couldn't even get the preamble right" and that something should be done. Committeeman HILL asked to be put on record that the whole discussion was a little silly, since the Student Council clearly could not abolish the S.A.C. in light of the provisions regarding it in the Student Body Constitution. Chairman DAVIS said Committeeman SALLES was correct, but it would be more complete and less abrasive to Student Council to also add the words at the end of the preamble as amended by the proposal (i.e., after the word "Commission") "is an executive standing committee of Council." Committeeman SALLES accepted this as a friendly amendment. Committeeman KRUZANSKY asked what, if any, note should be taken in committee in light of Council's rejection last Wednesday of a unanimously passed amendment. Committeeman SALLES said that he had a proposition for the committee to recommend to the floor of the commission regarding the format of proposals to Council, but said that he wanted to wait until Committeeman SMITH arrived so that "something this critical" could be considered by the full Committee. Chairman DAVIS noted that there was a motion on the floor, and that discussion irrelevant to the motion was out of order. Committeeman HILL asked for a vote. Motion, as amended, passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Preamble (to Constitution)
Strike: The Student Council establishes...
Replace: The student body by provision of the Constitution of theStudent Body of the Johns Hopkins University establishes...
Meeting of the Constitutional Committee of the S.A.C.
Meeting of October 5, 1982 (cont'd)
Strike: to serve as its primary tool for the development of financial policyReplace: as an executive standing committee of Student Council.
Sections 1 and 2 of Article I were passed by Committee. Section 3 Subparagraph 1 was passed by Committee. Section 3 Subparagraph 2 as previously altered by Committee was passed by Committee.
Committeeman LALLY moved that the phrase "three-fifths vote" in Article I Section 3 Subparagraph 3 be deleted and replaced by "majority vote". Committeeman SALLES said this probably wasn't too bad an idea in light of the floor's inability to originate many motions, which made it only able to consider it in the form of an override of the Executive Board's action or non-action. However, the three-fifths represented "one of the few constructive compromises between the S.A.C. and Council" last semester and said he was disinclined to meddle with it, and so expressed his intention of abstaining on a vote. Chairman DAVIS said the Board was more deliberative than the floor and had the advantage of input from the Director of Student Activities. Motion failed: in favor, Committeeman LALLY; against, Committeemen KRUZANSKY, HILL; abstaining, Committeeman SALLES.
SALLES proposal #2 called for the addition of a Section 5 to Article I; he altered the numbering to section 4, explaining that when the proposal was first read into the record there had been another earlier proposed section to this article which had been handled in another way in Committee. He explained that he had originally intended to propose that the floor be entitled to take any action the Executive Board was entitled to take, except by three-fifths affirmative vote (the margin needed to override Board action) rather than simple majority vote. Chairman DAVIS had suggested to him that this was not a good idea, since actions could be passed irresponsibly without prior notice to groups involved and without a chance for consideration by the Executive Board, by its very nature more deliberative than the S.A.C. itself, and had suggested instead that there be a method of forcing the Executive Board to render a definitive decision as opposed to indefinitely postponing consideration or tabling a proposed action, which would allow a 3/5 opinion "to make itself felt" while allowing for notice and Executive Board consideration. Chairman DAVIS agreed, and said that he supported the proposal, although he wasn't sure if the words "any member of" shouldn't be substituted by "all members of". Committeeman HILL said it should be "any member of". Committeeman KRUZANSKY said he agreed. Chairman DAVIS expressed satisfaction with the original wording, and moved it be passed. Committeeman LALLY seconded. Motion passed unanimously.
'Meeting of October 5, 1982 (cont'd)
CHANGE MADE
Article I, Section 4 (new section)
Insert: Any member of the Commission may submit any proposalwithin the authority of the Executive Board to anymember of the Executive Board for the Board's consideration.The proposer may request that the Executive Board rendera definitive decision on the proposal within the shortestpracticable time. The Executive Board is bound by thisrequest and must consider and give a final approval orrejection of the proposal no later than at the closeof the second Executive Board meeting following submissionerrata: question of the proposal to the Board member, and may not tableor further postpone consideration of the proposal inquestion; such decision shall be entered on the minutesinsert: and of the Executive Board, a copy of which shall be suppliedto the originator of the proposal upon his/her request.
Committeeman SALLES moved that, in order to distinguish between
the functions of the Treasurer qua Treasurer and the Treasurerqua Chairman, Article II Section 1 be rearranged as follows:Firstly, the introductory language should be stricken and replacedwith "The Chairman of the Commission shall...".Secondly, there should follow subparagraph 1 as previously amendedby committee and subparagraph 3, renumbered subparagraph 2,with the former subparagraphs 2 and 4 being deleted;Thirdly, a line should be inserted reading "The Treasurer of theStudent Council shall..."Fourthly, there should follow subparagraphs 5 and 7, renumbered3 and 4, with subparagraph 6 being deleted.
Chairman DAVIS objected, saying this was too complex. He suggestedthat the word "Chairman" be used throughout the document to indicatethe Treasurer/Chairman, saying that if it became for some reasonrelevant it was easy to differentiate between organizational andfinancial duties. He moved to amend Salles' proposal by strikingall its provisions and replacing it with one provision: to insertthe word "as Chairman" between "and" and "shall", with the under-standing that all future references to the "Treasurer" shall bereplaced as they are reviewed with language referring to the "Chairman".Committeeman SALLES accepted this as a friendly amendment, butintroduced an additional provision to strike subparagraphs 2 and 4,renumbering subparagraphs 1,3,5,6, & 7 as 1,2,3,4, & 5. ChairmanDAVIS objected, saying that the Treasurer/Chairman was the obviousliaison between Council and the S.A.C. by virtue of serving on both;SALLES withdrew his amendment, saying that while he didn't see whythe Council had to have an explicit liaison with "what they keeptelling us is their committee" it wasn't worth "further clutteringup the motion". Committeeman HILL moved to strike subparagraph 6,renumbering subparagraph 7 as 6, on the grounds that the Boardshould appoint its own officers in accordance with customaryprocedure. Committeeman SALLES accepted this as friendly.
- 11 -
Meeting of October 5, 1982 (cont'd)
The motion of Committeeman SALLES as modified by the amendments by Chairman DAVIS and Committeeman HILL passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article II, Section 1, prefatory paragraph
Strike: ...and shall...
Replace: ...and as Chairman shall...
Strike Subparagraph 6
Renumber Subparagraph 7 as 6
Chairman DAVIS moved that Article II, Section 1, Subparagraph 7, (now 6) previously altered in committee, be further altered by striking the word "Treasurer" and replacing it by the word "Chairman". Seconded by Committeeman SALLES. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article II, Section 1, Subparagraph 6 (formerly 7)
Strike: The Treasurer shall notify...
Replace: The Chairman shall notify...
Article II, Section 1, prefatory paragraph as modified, subparagraphs 1,2,3,4 & 5 and subparagraph 6 (formerly 7) as modified passed committee.
Chairman DAVIS moved that the reference to the Treasurer in Section 2 be deleted and replaced by a reference to the Chairman. Seconded by Committeeman KRUZANSKY. Passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article II, Section 2
Strike: ...the Treasurer is unavailable...
Replace: ...the Chairman is unavailable...
Meeting of October 5, 1982 (cont'd)
Article II, Section 3, added at the S.A.C. meeting of Sept. 16, since ratified by Council, was passed unchanged by committee.
Committeeman SMITH arrived at this point.
Committeeman SALLES said that now that the entire committee was assembled, and a convenient point had been reached in the deliberations, he had a motion to introduce. He pointed out that the proposed amendment to Article VII, Section 2 reaffirming the Commission's right to be sole originator of proposals relating to its own constitution had been struck down in Council at its Sept. 29th, 1982 meeting despite its unanimous passage by the S.A.C. and despite its co sponsorship by no other than Chairman DAVIS, who had in his capacity of Student Council Treasurer introduced the motion impugning the disputed ruling (that the Student Council could originate and pass without reference to S.A.C. amendments to the S.A.C. Constitution) and was now reversing his stance. Chairman DAVIS commented as point of information that he was not challenging the right of Council to make such a ruling, nor was he going to commit himself as to whether it was correct or not, as he preferred to withhold judgement on this point; he did however feel that Council should reverse it by mechanism of ratification of the proposed S.A.C. amendment, which was why he cosponsored it on the floor of the S.A.C., and introduced and defended it in Council. He said further that he was confident of positive reconsideration by Council, and asked that the committee refrain from adopting a hostile attitude which might jeopardize passage of the amendment, which had been proposed by the Executive Board at its October 4 meeting. Committeeman SALLES said that conversation with certain Student Council members had led him to believe that an element in Council believed that it had the right additionally to amend and finally pass S.A.C. Constitutional proposals without further reference to the S.A.C. or its Executive Board, which meant that, for instance, if this Committee changed "3/5" to "majority", the Council, rather than having the right to choose between one and the other, would be able to amend the disputed fraction to "9/10" and "draft it on to the S.A.C. Constitution". He said that "carried to its logical extreme", this interpretation would mean that Council could take any single proposal of this Committee as passed by S.A.C. and use it as a vehicle for substituting a Council-written constitution. Committeeman LALLY said the idea of Council being able to amend was ridiculous. Committeeman KRUZANSKY asked the Chair what precaution it would be in order for the committee to take against "manhandling". Committeeman SALLES characterized the Council's action as a "kick in the teeth to this committee". Committeeman SALLES moved that the committee a) censure the action as 'hostile' and as having a deleterious effect on the deliberations of the Committee and b) recommend to the floor that the committee's proposals be passed as a series of individual, unamendable proposals, each dealing with one section (or where applicable, one subparagraph) of the document, leaving open the 'possibility of establishing further "linkages" between two or more of these items so as to consider them one proposal to further recommendations by committee at the time of passage of final report;
Meeting of October 5, 1982 (cont'd)
and c) to further recommend to the floor that "in order to avoid all disputes" it specify that each of these proposals was integral, indivisible, and unamendable, and that an attempt to divide the question or amend the proposal so as to render the matter not properly before Council. Motion passed, 4-1; in favor: KRUZANSKY, LALLY, SALLES, SMITH; against: HILL.
Committeeman SMITH proposed that the words "in the fall semester" in Article III, Section 1, Subparagraph 4 be struck and replaced with the words "with the month of September". Committeeman SALLES said this was clumsy, inasmuch as it provided for an election to be held "at the second meeting within September" without providing for the necessity of holding two meetings in September; what that Committeeman SMITH probably wanted to propose, he said, was that the second S.A.C. meeting of the fall semester must be held prior to September 30. Committeeman KRUZANSKY said that this could get complicated. Chairman DAVIS said that it was not a good idea to get too inflexible in constitutions. Committeeman SMITH withdrew his proposal.
Chairman DAVIS moved that the words "acting irresponsibly" in Article III Section 2 subparagraph 4 be struck and replaced with "for fiscal irresponsibility". Motion passed unanimously.
Committeeman SMITH moved that the words "to direct the Chairman" which previously began appear at the beginning of the subparagraph, be struck and replaced with "to freeze the funds and assets..." He explained that this would make the Chairman take responsibility for a potentially illegal censorship action, and in his opinion it would be correct for the Chairman to ignore a direction of the Executive Board when to do otherwise would open him to legal charges. Motion passed 4-0-1; In favor: KRUZANSKY, LALLY, SALLES, SMITH; against: none; abstaining: HILL.
CHANGES MADE
Article III, Section 2, Subparagraph 4
Strike: acting irresponsibly
Replace: for fiscal irresponsibility
Strike: to freeze the funds and assets...
Replace: to direct the Chairman to freeze the funds and assets...
Meeting of October 5, 1982 (cont'd)
Committeeman SALLES moved that subparagraph 5 be struck, as there was no reason that the Executive Board should be singled out for the ability to recommend action to Council (other than those recommendations regarding chartering, etc., mentioned elsewhere in the document), as opposed to, for instance the Commission at large. Committeeman LALLY said the provision was harmless. Motion failed 3-1; in favor: SALLES; against: KRUZANSKY, LALLY, and SMITH. Committeeman HILL left at this point.
SALLES proposal #5 called for substitution of the current subparagraph 10 of this section with the following language: "to nominate candidates for all seals, keys, and other awards. A complete and final list of all such candidates shall be presented to the Commission for its approval by majority vote of a quorum. The Commission may amend the list by majority vote. The Executive Board shall confine its award to those candidates approved by the Commission with the proviso that it may by unanimous vote award any seal, key, etc., to any person presented to the Commission as candidate irrespective of any action by the Commission." He said that the S.A.C. should have some measure of control over S.A.C. awards since they were not S.A.C. Executive Board awards, and that he had originally suggested that the S.A.C. at large have power to amend the award proposal (within certain limits (having to do with the maximum number of awards)), but that Chairman DAVIS had suggested to him this procedure. Committeeman LALLY moved the proposal be adopted. Chairman DAVIS confirmed that he generally approved of this procedure but that he felt "this kind of thing" was a matter for the bylaws. Motion failed for lack of a majority; in favor: LALLY, SALLES; against: KRUZANSKY, SMITH. Committeeman LALLY moved that the words "as shall be proper" be struck and substituted by "as shall be detailed in the bylaws". Chairman DAVIS said this was superfluous. Committeeman LALLY withdrew his proposal.
Committeeman SMITH moved that the words "and growth" be struck from subparagraph 11, since recent developments had made it less than certain that more growth was always a good thing". Committeeman HILL agreed. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article III, Section 2, subparagraph 11
Strike: ...growth and...
Replace: _____
SALLES proposal #6 called for replacement of the current wording of subparagraph 12 of this section with the following: "to establish and revise Executive Board policy guidelines. A complete list of such guidelines shall be published and made available to Commission members upon request. Any change to such guidelines shall be reported to the full Commission and is subject to overturn under the provisions of Article I, Section 4, Subparagraph 3."
Meeting of October 5, 1982 (cont'd)
Committeeman SALLES said that in light of previous action by this committee the correct reference would be to Article I Section 3 Subparagraph 3. Chairman DAVIS said that since all actions of the Executive Board were subject to overturn the last part was redundant and moved that the proposal be adopted without any of the language after "reported to the full Commission". Seconded by Committeeman KRUZANSKY. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article III, Section 2, subparagraph 12
Strike: to revise the Commission guidelines, when necessary.
Replace:
to establish and revise Executive Board policy guidelines.A complete list of such guidelines shall be published and made available to Commission members upon request. Any change to such guidelines shall be reported to the full Commission.
SALLES proposal #9 called for addition of a subparagraph 14 to this section, corresponding to and paralleling the subparagraph 13 passed unanimously by the S.A.C. at its Sept. 16 meeting and subsequently ratified by Council. This would read "Call a meeting of the Executive Board by an affirmative vote of any three members on an appropriate motion at a meeting of the Executive Board. The motion shall direct the Chairman to call a meeting at a given time, and the Chairman shall give timely notice to all Executive Board members as in a meeting called under the provisions of Article II Section 1." He defended it saying it was reasonable that Executive Board members should be allowed to call an Executive Board meeting under the same conditions as they can call a meeting of the S.A.C.
Chairman DAVIS said it was a good idea but moved instead that it be combined with subparagraph 13 by striking "the Commission" and replacing it with "the Commission or the Executive Board" and striking "all S.A.C. members" and replacing it with "all members of the appropriate body". Committeeman SALLES expressed himself satisfied, and seconded. Committeeman SMITH said that it was a bad idea to have a minority of the Executive Board calling meetings; what if the majority wanted a meeting too, at a different time? He suggested striking "three" in subparagraph 13 and replacing it with "four", and introduced this as an amendment to the DAVIS motion. Chairman DAVIS accepted this as friendly. Seconder SALLES did not. SMITH amendment to DAVIS motion passed 3-2; in favor: DAVIS, KRUZANSKY, SMITH; against: LALLY, SALLES. Committeeman LALLY moved as an amendment to the DAVIS motion that the following be inserted at the end of subparagraph 13: "The Chairman shall call a meeting of the Commission upon direction by petition signed by one-fifth of the Commission membership." Chairman DAVIS said that "something like this should be done" but [unclear: rejected] that the
Meeting of October 5, 1982 (cont'd)
proportion of the membership required should be one-third. Committeeman SMITH asked whether it wouldn't be more correct to require a fixed proportion of the S.A.C. member groups, since that was the way a quorum was calculated. Chairman DAVIS disagreed. Committeeman SMITH then moved that the word "one-fifth" in the LALLY amendment to the DAVIS proposal be struck and replaced by "one-quarter". Chairman DAVIS agreed. Committeeman SALLES said that this was a good idea, and said that this was one of the advantages of indivisible amendments; he would drop his objections to the original SMITH proposal to change "three" to "four" as the number of Executive Board members necessary to call a meeting, providing that it was indivisibly linked to a petition provision such as this by inclusion in the same indivisible amendment. Committeeman LALLY said that he would accept the SMITH amendment (of one-fifth to "one-quarter") as friendly. The LALLY amendment as amended by SMITH to the original DAVIS proposal as amended by SMITH passed unanimously. The main motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article III, Section 2, Subparagraph 13
Strike:call a meeting of the commission by affirmative vote of any three members on an appropriate motion at a meeting of the Executive Committee. The motion shall direct the Chairman to call a meeting at a given time, and the Chairman shall give timely notice to all S.A.C. members as in a meeting called under the provisions of Article II Section 1.
Replace:call a meeting of the Commission or the Executive Board by affirmative vote of any four members on an appropriate motion at a meeting of the Executive Committee. The motion shall direct the Chairman to call a meeting at a given time, and the Chairman shall give timely notice to all members of the appropriate body as in a meeting called under the provisions of Article II Section 1. The Chairman shall call a meeting of the Commission upon direction by petition signed by one-quarter of the Commission membership.
SALLES proposal #7 called for substitution for the current wording of Article III Section 3 the following: "The Executive Board shall meet at least twice a month during the academic year. A quorum of the Executive Board shall be four members, one of whom must be the Treasurer of the Student Council, the President of the Student Council, or the Director of Student Activities." He said that there was no reason the Treasurer/Chairman should be indispensable for a quorum, and that his substantive change still allowed for the prevention of a meeting solely by the at large members. Chairman DAVIS disagreed, saying that under his interpretation of the clause the President of the Student Council could also substitute
Meeting of October 5, 1982 (cont'd)
for the Treasurer for the purposes of this section due to provision in Article I Section 2, and that furthermore the Vice-President of the Student Council could substitute for the President by provisions of the Student Body Constitution. Committeeman SALLES moved his proposal be adopted as written. Motion failed; in favor: LALLY, SALLES; against: HILL, SMITH.
Committeeman SMITH moved that in line with similar changes made earlier in the document the word "Treasurer" be struck and replaced with the word "Chairman". Motion passed unanimously.Chairman DAVIS moved that the word "semi-monthly" be struck as ambiguous and replaced with the words "at least twice a month". Committeeman SALLES seconded. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
7
Article III, Section 3
Strike: ...the Treasurer and...
Replace: ...the Chairman and...
Strike: semi-monthly
Replace: twice a month
Chairman DAVIS moved that the entirety of Article III Section 4 be struck and replaced by the following: "In the event that one of the four at large members is unable to fulfill his term of office, a meeting of the Commission shall be called to fill the position by election." Seconded by Committeeman LALLY. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article III, Section 4
Strike: In the event that one of the four at large members isunable to fulfill his/her term of office, the ExecutiveBoard shall advertise the position for not less than onenor more than two weeks, interview all S.A.C. members wishingto apply and select from these applicants a replacement.
Meeting of October 5, 1982 (cont'd)
Replace: In the event that one of the four at large members is unable to fulfill his term of office, a meeting of the Commission shall be called to fill the position by election.
Chairman DAVIS announced that he had several proposals to introduce regarding Article IV. Committeeman SALLES said that since the Chairman couldn't second his own proposals he would return the latter's courtesy in the matter of a blanket second and that all proposals brought forward by Chairman DAVIS could be considered seconded by SALLES, so that discussion could proceed.
Chairman DAVIS moved that the wording "Failure to do so is grounds for freezing of funds" be struck from the preamble as redundant, and furthermore that the preamble to this Article be renumbered section 1, and that sections 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9, & 10 be renumbered sections 2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10, & 11 respectively. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article IV Section 1 (formerly Article IV, Preamble)
Strike: Failure to do so is grounds for freezing of funds.
Renumber section 1 as 2.Renumber section 2 as 3.Renumber section 3 as 4.Renumber section 4 as 5.Renumber section 5 as 6.Renumber section 6 as 7.Renumber section 7 as 8.Renumber section 8 as 9.Renumber section 9 as 10.Renumber section 10 as 11.
Committeeman LALLY moved that Section 2 (formerly 1) be amended to strike "Executive Board" and replace with "Executive Board made pursuant to this Constitution". Committeeman SMITH said that the Executive Board is required to abide by this constitution anyway, and in any event must also abide by the Student Body Constitution, the by-laws, Executive Board policy guidelines, etc. Committeeman LALLY withdrew his motion. Chairman DAVIS moved to strike the word "fully" as redundant. Motion passed unanimously.
Meeting of October 5, 1982 (cont'd)
CHANGES MADE
Article IV, Section 2 (formerly 1)
Strike: ...charter fully approved...
Replace: ...charter approved...
Chairman DAVIS moved that to properly distinguish between original (petition) and revised (after allocation finalized) budget proposals, Section 3 (formerly 2) be reworded. He also said that in his view there was no point in establishing a $400 cutoff point since such expenditures would be in order if included in an approved revised budget. Motion passed unanimously; and is cited below:
- ERRATA: Motion passed 3-0-1: Committeeman SMITH abstained.
CHANGES MADE
Article IV, Section 3 (formerly 2)
Strike: The President and Treasurer of each member organization shall be required to submit in writing, at the request of the Executive Board, an annual budget request (not applicable to Class B). Plans for any project requiring more than $400 must be submitted at least two weeks prior to financial commitment.
Replace: The President and Treasurer of each member organization shall be required to submit in writing an annual budget request to the Executive Board (not applicable to Class B organizations). All organizations receiving funding shall submit revised budgets to the Chairman.
Chairman DAVIS moved that all wording following "undergraduate community" in Section 4 (formerly 3) be struck. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Strike: undergraduate community at the Homewood campus. Funds for travel may be permitted by the Executive Board on a case-by-case basis.
Replace: undergraduate community.
Meeting of October 5, 1982 (cont'd) -20-
Committeeman SALLES moved that the entirety of Section 5(formerly 4) be struck as redundant, since any activity"open to all the undergraduate community" could not be a"private social function". Committeeman SMITH agreed, butargued in favor of leaving the provision in on the ground thatin his experience an explicit provision prevented attemptedabuses in this area. Committeeman SALLES withdrew his motion.
Chairman DAVIS moved to strike Section 6 (formerly 5) astotally redundant. Motion passed unanimously. Chairman DAVISmoved to renumber the sections earlier renumbered 7, 8, 9, 10& 11 sections 6,7,8,9, & 10. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article IV Section 6 (formerly 5)
Strike:
Member organizations may spend their allocations onlyin the manner originally budgeted. Significantdeviation requires the express permission of theExecutive Board in advance of financial commitment.
Replace: (nothing).
Renumber section 7 to 6.Renumber section 8 to 7.Renumber section 9 to 8.Renumber section 10 to 9.Renumber section 11 to 10.
Chairman DAVIS moved that the words "at the Homewood campus"be struck from Section 7. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article IV Section 7
Strike: ...undergraduate community at the Homewood campus.
Replace: ...undergraduate community.
Meeting of October 5, 1982 (cont'd)
Chairman DAVIS moved that all wording in Article IV Section 9 following "days are permitted" be struck, inasmuch as there is no reason to single out this offence as deserving a fund freeze, and that otherwise his comments regarding the striking of similar language from Article IV Section 1 (formerly Article IV, preamble) applied. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article IV Section 9
Strike: ...days are permitted; violation of this sectionwill result in the freezing of funds.
Replace: ...days are permitted.
Committeeman SMITH moved that the wording "cannot be filled by volunteer labor" be struck and replaced by "cannot feasibly be filled by volunteer labor". Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article IV, Section 10
Strike: ...cannot be filled by volunteer labor.
Replace: ...cannot feasibly be filled by volunteer labor.
Meeting was adjourned at 7:11 pm.
Minutes of the Constitutional Committee of the S.A.C.
Meeting of October 15, 1982
The meeting was called to order at 5:38 pm. Chairman DAVIS and Committeemen HILL, LALLY, SALLES, and SMITH were present.
Chairman DAVIS announced that he expected this meeting to complete preliminary consideration of the document. He further announced that at Committeeman SALLES' suggestion he would distribute copies of the draft report to members of the Student Council as well as members of the S.A.C. Executive Board.
Chairman DAVIS moved that the prefatory paragraph to Article V be renumbered section 1 and passed as previously amended by committee; he further moved that sections 1, 2, 3, 4 & 5 of Article V be renumbered 2, 3, 4, 5 & 6 respectively. Motions passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Prefatory Paragraph renumbered Section 1
Section 1 renumbered 2
Section 2 renumbered 3
Section 3 renumbered 4
Section 4 renumbered 5
Section 5 renumbered 6
Chairman DAVIS moved that in section 2 (formerly 1) the words "such groups are" be replaced by "Class A groups are" for clarification, and that such wording be adopted for Class C and D groups, as the appropriate sections are brought up for consideration. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article V, Section 2 (formerly 1)
Strike: Such groups are entitled to petition...
Replace: Class A groups are entitled to petition...
Committeeman LALLY said that similar wording (to that inserted in Section 2, formerly 1) could not be inserted in Section 4 (formerly 3) since the Student Body Constitution, which says that S.A.C. groups shall be represented by "two elected officers, preferably the President and Treasurer" specifically excepts Class C groups, where the appropriate language reads "shall be represented by the Vice President and Treasurer." Chairman DAVIS
Meeting of October 15, 1982 (cont'd)
agreed. Committeeman SALLES agreed, pointing out that this rendered part of the standing rule of procedure adopted by S.A.C. at its September 16 meeting inoperative. Committeeman HILL said he assumed appropriate language regarding voting substitutes would be written into this article. Committeeman SALLES proposed that all language in this section following "vice-president and treasurer" (that specifying representation for the Student Council by its President and Treasurer) be struck. He argued that, firstly, this section as written is debatably in conformity with the Student Body constitution since that document lists the membership of the S.A.C. in terms of delegates from Class A, B, C, D, & E organizations, mentioning the graduating classes under Class C without any reference to Student Council; secondly, even if this is ruled to be in conformity to the Student Body constitution it is clearly not required by it, and there is serious question as to whether it was ever properly passed by S.A.C. since the document passed by the S.A.C. last year by Debby Jeffrey contained a blank line marked "... to be filled in later" where this passage occurs, a procedure Committeeman SALLES called dubious; thirdly, since Student Council is "remarkably well represented in Council", he questioned the necessity of having it represented on the S.A.C. as well. Committeeman SMITH disagreed, saying that if it didn't conflict with the Student Body constitution, a question within the competency of the Student Council, then it should be considered on its merits; and furthermore that the provisions making the classes represented only by vice-president and treasurer had been to safeguard against overrepresentation of Council in S.A.C.; since Council's budget was included in the S.A.C. budget proposal, Council should have a voice in its assembly. Chairman DAVIS agreed (with Committeeman SMITH) and said that the Chairman should have the power to make or break ties; as a non-voting Chairman he would only be able to break them. Committeeman SALLES agreed with this last, but said that a clause could be inserted earlier in the document where the prerogatives of the Chairman are listed, specifically entitling him to make or break ties. Committeeman LALLY said he supported the original motion, and called for a vote. Failed for lack of a majority, in favor: LALLY, SALLES; against: HILL, SMITH;
Committeeman HILL objected to the term "student governance organizations" as ambiguous. He moved that the first sentence be stricken and substitute language inserted as follows: "Class C groups shall be the Student Council, the Freshman Class, the Sophomore Class, the Junior Class, and the Senior Class." Motion passed unanimously.
Committeeman SMITH moved that the wording "Class C groups are entitled to petition the Executive Board for annual budget allocations of student activity funds" be inserted at the end of this section to bring the structure in conformity with earlier wording regarding Class A groups. Passed unanimously.
Meeting of October 15, 1982 (cont'd)
CHANGE MADE
Article V, Section 4 (formerly 3)
Strike: Class C groups are student governance organizations.
Replace: Class C groups shall be the Student Council, the Freshman Class, the Sophomore Class, the Junior Class and the Senior Class.
Strike: its president and treasurer.
Replace: its president and treasurer. Class C groups are entitled to petition the Executive Board for annual budget allocations of student activities funds.
Committeeman [unclear: EMITH] moved that the wording "Class D organizations are publications." be struck and replaced by "Class D organizations are independent publications." He explained that otherwise this section might be taken to mean that publications put out under auspices of a group might be possessed of Class D status as individual entities. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGE MADE
Article V Section 5 (formerly 4)
Strike: Class D organizations are publications.
Replace: Class D organizations are independent publications.
Committeeman HILL moved that in Section 5 (formerly 4) the language "Class D groups are entitled to request funds annually from the Executive Board" be replaced by language similar to that used in Article V Sections 2 & 3 (formerly 1 & 2). Motion passed unanimously.
−25−
Meeting of October 15, 1982 (cont'd)
CHANGE MADE
Article V, Section 5 (formerly 4)
Strike: Class D groups are entitled to request funds annually from the Executive Board.
Replace: Class D groups are entitled to petition the Executive Board for annual budget allocations of student activity funds.
Committeeman HILL moved to strike the word "probationary" in Article V, Section 6 (formerly 5), and replace it with the word "probation." Committeeman SMITH commented that one was as correct as the other. Committeeman HILL withdrew his motion.
Chairman DAVIS moved to strike the wording "An organization may also be placed in Class E status by a majority vote of the Executive Board. This power is to be exercised as a sanction in cases of financial irresponsibility or failure to meet constitutional requirements" and substitute "An organization may also be placed in Class E status by majority vote of the Executive Board in cases of financial irresponsibility or failure to meet constitutional requirements." Committeeman SALLES pointed out that only the Student Council can change the terms of an organization's charter (not the S.A.C., Executive Board) and moved an amendment that the words "placed in Class E status" be replaced by "recommended for Class E status to the Student Council". Chairman DAVIS accepted this amendment as friendly. Committeeman LALLY said that tampering with an organization's charter was very serious and it was important that such an action not be considered by an incomplete Executive Board; he introduced an amendment to the motion to insert the words "at a meeting at which all members are present" after "majority vote of the Executive Board". The LALLY amendment to the motion passed unanimously. DAVIS motion passed 7-0-1; in favor: HILL, LALLY, SALLES; against: none; abstain: SMITH.
Committeeman SALLES suggested insertion of the following wording after "constitutional requirements" in this section as previously amended: "Such a recommendation shall not be transmitted to Student Council until after the occurrence of one general S.A.C. meeting after the action is taken." He said this was necessary to allow the S.A.C. a chance to take a position on the issue since after final action by Council an override vote on the Executive Board's recommendation would be useless. Chairman DAVIS disagreed, saying that he viewed this as an intermediate step between a "slap on the wrist" and a fund freeze. Committeeman SMITH disagreed (with Chairman DAVIS) saying that changing an organization's charter was far more serious, dealing as it did with various things including an organization's S.A.C. representation, and that a
Meeting of October 15, 1982 (cont'd)
fund freeze, which could be made conditional or to which exceptions could be granted, should rather be viewed as an intermediate step between a "slap on the wrist" and a charter change. Committeeman SALLIES agreed, arguing that the fund/asset freeze could be employed swiftly if there was any question of a serious irregularity; given that to be the case, probationary status assignment could await more deliberate consideration, including a chance for the S.A.C. as a whole to have input. Motion passed, 3-0-1; in favor: LALLY, SALLIES, SMITH; against: none; abstaining: HILL.
Chairman DAVIS suggested that the words "Expenditures of such groups must be approved by the Executive Board and their student activities account shall be open at the discretion of the Executive Board." be struck to allow the Executive Board discretion in the matter of taking a financial oversight role of such groups; furthermore, he said he was not certain what "shall be open" meant. Committeeman SMITH said that he felt the Executive Board should be required to take part in the financial deliberation of any group classified as E for probationary reasons, although not necessarily in those of groups class E solely because they are in their first year of existence. Chairman DAVIS withdrew his motion. Committeeman SMITH moved that the language mentioned in the DAVIS motion be struck, but that it be replaced by "Expenditures of such groups must be approved by the Executive Board, except for groups in the first year of operation so designated". Committeeman HILL moved an amendment to the SMITH motion that the words "by the Executive Board" be added after "so designated". Committeeman SMITH accepted this amendment as friendly. Chairman DAVIS said this language was repetitive. Committeeman HILL withdrew his amendment. Committeeman LALLY suggested that the words "at the discretion of the Executive Board" be added. Committeeman SMITH said this was redundant. Committeeman LALLY withdrew his amendment. Motion by SMITH passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article V, Section 6 (formerly 5)
Strike: An organization may also be placed in Class E status by majority vote of the Executive Board. This power is to be exercised as a sanction in cases of financial irresponsibility or failure to meet constitutional requirements. Expenditures of such groups must be approved by the Executive Board, and their student activities account shall be open at the discretion of the Executive Board.
Replace: An organization may also be recommended for Class E status to the Student Council by a majority vote of the Executive Board at a meeting at which all members are present in cases of financial irresponsibility or failure to meet constitutional requirements. Such a
(cont'd)
Meeting of October 15, 1982 (cont'd)
Replace:(cont'd) recommendation shall not be transmitted to StudentCouncil until after the occurrence of one GeneralS.A.C. meeting after the action is taken. Expendituresof such groups must be approved by the Executive Board,except for groups in the first year of operation sodesignated.
SAILES proposal #11 called for insertion of a new section 6 tothis article. He explained that this would have to be renumberedsection 7 in light of previous action by committee. The proposalcalled for the new section to read: In the case of each class ofmember organizations defined in the above sections the officersdesignated as SAC representatives shall be those entered on thegeneral membership rolls of the Commission, entitled to notice ofmeetings (as provided for in Article II Section 1 subparagraph 1),fund freeze (as provided for in Article II Section 4 subparagraph 7
and Article III Section 2 Subsection 4), entitled to petition theExecutive Board for consideration of a proposal (as provided forin Article I Section 4), and entitled to remove at-large delegatesby petition (as provided for in Article III Section 5) and shallenjoy severally and collectively the privileges of the S.A.C.general membership as provided for throughout this document.For purpose of attending at a meeting as a voting member, theofficers specified may be substituted for by an elected officerof the organization pursuant to the provisions of the constitutionsof the individual organizations concerned. The Commission shallprovide in standing rules of procedure for the credentiallingof such substitutes. He mentioned that this was probably toolong, as well as not providing for the fact that Classorganizations were prohibited from having delegate substitutesvote by provision of the Student Body Constitution. ChairmanDAVIS introduced a motion to make the new section read: "Inthe event that a group's SAC representatives are unable to attendan SAC meeting any elected officer as shall be designated by thatorganization may represent that organization at an S.A.C. meetingas a voting member." Committeeman LALLY moved an amendment to themotion striking "a group" and replacing with "a Class A, B, Dor E group's". Chairman DAVIS accepted the motion as friendly.Committeeman LALLY introduced a second amendment to the motion,to strike "any elected officer" and replace with "any voting member".Chairman DAVIS declined to consider the amendment friendly. Thesecond LALLY amendment failed 2-1; in favor: LALLY; against: HILL,SMITH; abstaining: SALES. The original DAVIS motion passed 3-0-1;in favor: HILL, SALES, SMITH; against: none; abstaining: LALLY.
Meeting of October 15, 1982 (cont'd)
CHANGE MADE
Article V, Section 7 (new section)
Insert: In the event that a Class A, B, D, or E group'sS.A.C. representatives are unable to attend an S.A.C.meeting an elected officer as shall be designatedby that organization may represent that organizationat an S.A.C. meeting as a voting member.
Committeeman SMITH proposed that an Article VI titled CENSORSHIPbe inserted, and that Articles VI and VII be renumbered VII andVIII respectively. He read the text of the proposed article intothe record as:
Section 1: The rights of freedom of speech and press shall beguaranteed to all groups by the S.A.C.Section 2: No publication, drama, dance, film, forum, or otherproduction by an S.A.C. group may be censored by theS.A.C., S.A.C. Executive Board, or any officer thereof,nor may any group be reassigned Class E status in acensorship manner.Section 3: No Class D publication may be reassigned Class E status,except by 100 days' notice.Section 4: The executive committee or editorial board of any groupwhich publishes shall be considered to be the publisherof that publication.Section 5: Any group desiring to obtain copyright under UnitedStates or international copyright law may designatethe publisher, or originator of any art form, as:
The Johns Hopkins __(blank)__ Association
Committeeman SMITH moved that Section 1 be passed as written.Motion passed unanimously. Committeeman SMITH moved Section 2.Committeeman SALLES moved that "nor may any group be reassigned"be struck and replaced by "nor may any group be recommended fora change to Class E status" in light of the fact that the S.A.C.cannot reassign without Student Council approval, as discussed inCommittee with reference to Article V Section 6 (formerly 5).Committeeman SMITH accepted the amendment by SALLES as friendly.Motion passed unanimously. Committeeman SMITH moved Section 3.Chairman DAVIS spoke against this saying that the 100 days'provision was "clumsy" and could easily take an action out ofa school year if it was proposed after mid-February. He saidthat the SALLES motion in regard to Article V Section 6 allowingpassage of one S.A.C. meeting after a recommendation of a statuschange before the recommendation became final was sufficient, andin light of the provision of Article VI Section 2 "taking careof" the censorship aspect, Class D publications were no differentthan any other group. Motion failed 2-0-2; in favor: none; against:HILL, SALLES; abstaining: LALLY, SMITH. Committeeman SALLES movedthat the proposed sections 4 and 5 be renumbered 3 and 4 in light
Meeting of October 15, 1982 (cont'd)
of committee action; motion passed unanimously. Committeeman SMITH moved section 3 (proposed as 4). Motion passed unanimously. Committeeman SMITH moved section 4 (proposed as 5). Committeeman SALLES inquired as to whether such a procedure (in copyright citation) had been forbidden previously, and how Committeeman SMITH replied that it had been permitted up until now, but that it would be forbidden under Article VI Section 3. Committeeman SALLES commented that these two sections, with one serving as an exception to the other, would be prime candidates for a 'linkage' resolution within the provisions of the resolution passed at the 10-05 meeting and suggested that Committeeman SMITH take this up at the time of consideration of the draft report. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGE MADE
Article VI, Section 1 (new section)
Insert: The rights of freedom of speech and press shall beguaranteed to all groups by the S.A.C.
Article VI, Section 2 (new section)
Insert: No publication, drama, dance, film, forum, or otherproduction by an S.A.C. group may be censored by theS.A.C., S.A.C. Executive Board, or any officer thereof,nor may any group be recommended for a change to ClassE status in a censorship manner.
Article VI, Section 3 (new section)
Insert: The executive committee or editorial board of anygroup shall be considered to be the publisher ofthat publication.
Article VI, Section 4 (new section)
Insert: Any group desiring to obtain copyright under UnitedStates or international copyright law may designatethe publisher, or originator of any art form, as:
The Johns Hopkins (blank) Association
Committeeman LALLY noticed that on the copy of the constitution supplied to committee members the addition made last year defining a quorum: "A quorum shall consist of a simple majority of all chartered S.A.C. groups" to Article VI, Section 1 was not shown. Committeeman SALLES inquired as to whether this had been for some reason deleted by Council after passage of the ruling allowing them to originate S.A.C. amendments and before their
Meeting of October 15, 1982 (cont'd)
acceptance on October 13th of the correcting amendment providing for exclusive origination by S.A.C. of S.A.C. constitutional amendments. Chairman DAVIS said that nothing of the sort had occurred, and reassured the committee that the omission was due to a typo. Committeeman LALLY moved that Article VII Section 1 (formerly Article VI, Section 1) be paged by Committee, and that the Secretary take note of the complete section when preparing the copy of the constitution as it presently stands for the final report. Motion passed unanimously.
Committeeman SMITH moved that the words "no proxy votes are allowed" be inserted as a separate sentence at the end of Article VII Section 2 (formerly Article VI Section 2). Motion passed unanimously. Chairman DAVIS moved that the word "he/she" be struck and replaced by "he". Motion passed 3-1; in favor: HILL, SALLIES, SMITH; against: LALLY. Committeeman SALES moved the words "the executive committee of" should be struck, since the word is undefined for a large number of SAC groups, who have officers but not an Executive Committee as such. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGES MADE
Article VII, Section 2 (formerly Article VI, Section 2)
Strike:
...and the position of S.A.C. representative shall be filled by the executive committee of the organization(s) involved.
Replace:
...and the position of S.A.C. representative shall be filled by the organization(s) involved. No proxy vote are allowed.
Strike:
...votes, he/she shall...
Replace
...votes, he shall...
Chairman DAVIS announced that the Student Council, at its Oct. 13 meeting, on its third consideration approved the amended Article VII, Section 1 (now to be renumbered Article VIII, Section 1 in the committee report) by 7-6 vote in the form it was resubmitted by the Executive Board, but that certain Council members had technical objections having to do with the placement of the words "All such amendments are subject to the approval of Student Council," resulting in a lack of clarity on the question as to whether the Council would have the option of disapproving an amendment it was forced to consider by student referendum. Committeeman SALLIES said that it was absurd that Student Council would be able to "hide behind a provision of the S.A.C. Constitution" when under direction of a student referendum under the provisions of the Student Body constitution. Committeeman LALLY reminded
Meeting of October 15, 1982 (cont’d)
the committee that it was discussing Student Council. Chairman DAVIS moved that the first part of the amendment be phrased "Amendments to this constitution may only be proposed by majority vote of the Executive Board or by a two-thirds vote of a quorum of the Commission. All such proposed amendments are subject to the approval of Student Council." and that the floor be opened for discussion as to how to work the referendum question in, suggesting something like "Student Council may only amend this constitution upon direction...". Committeeman SMITH moved that the DAVIS proposal be amended to add a final line: "This constitution may also be amended by student referendum." Committeeman SALLES suggested that the wording "may only be proposed to Student Council" might lead to unfortunate interpretations in the future and moved that the DAVIS proposal be amended to strike the words "to Student Council" since Council’s ratification power was provided for elsewhere. SMITH amendment to DAVIS proposal passed unanimously. SALLES amendment to DAVIS proposal passed unanimously. DAVIS proposal passed unanimously. Chairman DAVIS asked that the record show that he approved the final wording, so that questions as to his position would not arise.
CHANGE MADE
Article VIII, Section 1 (formerly Article VII, section 1)
Strike:
Amendments to this constitution may only be proposedto the Student Council by a majority vote of theExecutive Board, by a two-thirds vote of a quorumat a meeting of the whole Commission, or underdirection from the Student Body through a referendum.All such proposed amendments are subject to theapproval of the Student Council.
Replace:
Amendments to this constitution may only be proposedby a majority vote of the Executive Board, by [illegible] two-thirds vote of a quorum [illegible] of the [illegible]Commission. All such proposed amendments are subjectto the approval of Student Council. This constitutionmay also be amended by student referendum.
Article VIII Section 2 (formerly Article VII Section 1) passed bycommittee.
SALLES proposal #17 called for substitution of the current wording
of Article VII section 3 (now renumbered Article VIII Section 3)by the following: The final authority in questions of interpretationof the S.A.C. Constitution shall be the S.A.C. Executive Board, itsactions in this respect subject to the provisions of Article ISection 3 regarding overrule by a three-fifths affirmative vote
Meeting of October 15, 1982 (cont'd)
on an appropriate motion by a valid quorum of the Commission. This provision is not intended to alter the provisions of Article VII, Section 2 regarding the supremacy of the Student Body Constitution over this instrument and where a question is raised regarding conflicts between the Student Body Constitution and this constitution, or between the Student Body Constitution and rulings issued under the provisions of this article, it shall be decided by the Student Council or by any other body empowered by the Student Body Constitution to decide questions of interpretation of the Student Body Constitution." Chairman DAVIS attacked the proposal, saying that if it was passed the Student Council would probably rule that its review power included the right to review rulings on the S.A.C. Constitution. He suggested a rewording, which he asked that the record show he did NOT support, of the SALLES proposal as follows:
"Questions concerning interpretation of this constitution shall be decided by the S.A.C. Executive Board. Questions concerning conflicts between the Constitution of the Student Body of the Johns Hopkins University and this Constitution shall be decided by the Student Council."
Committeeman SALLES said this wording was acceptable as a rendition of his own proposal and moved it be adopted. Committeeman SMITH said if Student Council was going to take this power this committee may as well be the ones to give it to them, and moved to amend the SALLES proposal to insert between the sentence ending "Executive Board" and that beginning "Questions regarding" the following: All decisions concerning interpretation of this Constitution may be appealed to Student Council. Committeeman LALLY asked what would happen to this section if the Stites proposal for a new Student Body Constitution passed at referendum; Chairman DAVIS said that this provision would lapse in favor of the right to appeal to the Student Court created in that document. Committeeman SALLES asked Chairman DAVIS what in his opinion would happen to the various references to Student Council's power of review or appeal throughout the S.A.C. Constitution if the Stites proposal passed. Chairman DAVIS said they would lapse with the provisions of the Student Body Constitution with which they were designed to comply. Committeeman SMITH said that there was no point in discussing ways to make this provision comply with both the current and proposed Student Body Constitutions because the Stites proposal would necessitate other changes throughout the document. Committeeman SALLES expressed himself satisfied, and accepted the SMITH amendment as friendly. Chairman DAVIS asked that the record show he favored the SALLES proposal as amended by SMITH. Main motion passed unanimously.
Committeeman SMITH moved that this section (3) of Article VIII be renumbered as a separate Article IX, titled INTERPRETATION. Motion passed unanimously.
Meeting of October 15, 1982 (cont'd)
Article IX (formerly Article VII, Section 3)
Strike: Questions concerning interpretation of this constitution shall be decided by the Student Council.
Replace: Questions concerning interpretation of this Constitution shall be decided by the S.A.C. Executive Board. All decisions concerning interpretation of this constitution may be appealed to Student Council. Questions concerning conflicts between this Constitution and the Constitution of the Student Body of the Johns Hopkins University shall be decided by Student Council.
Chairman DAVIS said that he had proposed titles for each article in accordance with a suggestion made to him by Committeeman LALLY. Chairman DAVIS proposed that Article I be entitled THE STUDENT ACTIVITIES COMMISSION, that Article II be entitled THE CHAIRMAN, that Article III be entitled THE EXECUTIVE BOARD, that Article IV be entitled ORGANIZATIONS, that Article V be entitled CLASS STATUS, that Article VII (formerly VI) be entitled MEETINGS, and that Article VIII (formerly VII) be entitled AMENDMENTS. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGE MADE
Entitle Article I THE STUDENT ACTIVITIES COMMISSION
Entitle Article II THE CHAIRMAN
Entitle Article III THE EXECUTIVE BOARD
Entitle Article IV ORGANIZATIONS
Entitle Article V CLASS STATUS
Entitle Article VII MEETINGS
Entitle Article VIII AMENDMENTS
Chairman DAVIS announced that he was directing the Secretary to produce minute of the various meetings, to be distributed to Committee members and members of the Executive Board. He also announced that he was directing the secretary to produce a draft report in three parts: firstly, a copy of the constitution as it presently stood, including the three amendments passed at the Sept. 16 meeting as since adopted by Council; secondly, the Committee report as a series of discrete proposals in accordance with the SALLES motion at the meeting of October 5; thirdly, a copy of the S.A.C. Constitution as it would appear with all the proposed changes. These would be distributed to members of this committee, the Executive Board, the Student
Meeting of October 15, 1982 (cont'd)
Council, and the entire Commission, for comments. He stated his intention of accompanying the request for comments with a letter stating that this was a draft report, and that the final report would be placed on Tuesday, October 26, incorporating any changes the Committee chose to make in light of comments received from any of the above, and that he would assume that if no written adverse comments were received this would be tantamount to tacit approval of the Committee's work. Committeeman SALLES moved that the committee join the Chairman in this direction. Motion passed unanimously.
The Committee recessed at 8:50 pm for pizza.
The Committee was called to order at 9:05 pm.
Committeeman SMITH said that it was appropriate that the first bylaw establish an alternate means of establishing bylaws via the Executive Committee (other than by 2/3 of a quorum of the Commission as standard Rules of Order provided). He moved that a bylaw be proposed reading: "Bylaws are passed by two-thirds of a quorum of the Commission or by five-sevenths of the Executive Board". He stated that "two-thirds of a quorum of the Commission" meant "two-thirds of those present and voting" (including abstainers and etc., in the total), as opposed to "two-thirds vote of a quorum", defined as meaning a vote in which the affirmative votes counted up to twice as many or more than the negative votes. Committeeman LALLY asked whether it would mean a proportion of a fixed number, since a quorum had been defined earlier. Committeeman SMITH said that what was defined was the minimum number necessary for a quorum to be present; no matter how many members are present at a meeting, there is no such thing as "more than a quorum". Committeeman LALLY expressed himself satisfied. Committeeman SALLES moved an amendment to the SMITH proposal to change "five-sevenths" to "six-sevenths", in order to make it more difficult for the Executive Board to pass controversial bylaws "behind the back of the Commission". Committeeman HILL said this was probably unreasonable, since such a replacement would require a unanimous vote if only six members were present, which often happens. Committeeman SALLES withdrew his amendment. Motion passed unanimously.
PROPOSED BYLAW
- By-laws may be passed by two-thirds of a quorum of the Commission or by five-sevenths of the Executive Board.
Chairman DAVIS proposed the matter of seals and awards be considered, and introduced the SALLES proposal previously rejected by committee as an amendment to Article III Section 2 Subparagraph 10 as a proposed by-law numbered 2. Committeeman
Meeting of October 15, 1982 (cont'd)
SMITH objected, saying that having the floor able to amend, even only by deletion, a list of names for awards was to invite disorderly consideration by the full Commission. Chairman DAVIS agreed, and asked Committeeman SALLES as second whether he objected to a withdrawal. Committeeman SALLES disagreed, saying that it was important that the floor have some absolute say in the matter of S.A.C. awards, and that his comments on the question when it was moved as a constitutional amendment still applied. He suggested that Committeeman SMITH move to amend the DAVIS proposal to fix some maximum number of awards as a check on irresponsible additions by the floor, which might take the matter more seriously if someone's name had to be deleted in order for another person's to be added. Committeeman SMITH moved as an amendment to the DAVIS proposal that its entire language be stricken and replaced by the following wording: The procedure for awarding seals shall be as follows: a) In the second semester of each academic year the Chairman shall send written notice to all members of the S.A.C. requesting nominations for S.A.C. seals; b) Every member of the S.A.C. shall have two weeks to nominate graduating seniors for such seals. All nominations must be typed double-spaced. The nomination must contain the name and office of the S.A.C. representative making the nomination; c) The Executive Board shall review the names of all candidates for the seals and select a list of 35 who have contributed in a significant manner to the advancement of student activities while undergraduates; d) The Chairman shall inform all members of the names of those nominated for the seals; e) Members of the S.A.C. shall have one week to request in writing that names be added or deleted from the list. These requests must include a reason for the request; f) The Executive Board may then decide to add or delete those names; g) The Chairman shall then provide all members of the S.A.C., the Student Council, and Senior Class Awards Committee of the names of those receiving the S.A.C. seal. Chairman DAVIS expressed approval of the proposal, and moved that an amendment be added to change "35" to "25". Committeeman SMITH accepted the amendment as friendly. Chairman DAVIS moved another amendment to add after the words "double-spaced" in subparagraph b) the words "and include the qualifications of the nominee(s)". Committeeman SMITH accepted this amendment as friendly. Committeeman HILL moved to strike all language in subparagraph e) beginning with the word "request" and to insert following the words "one week to" the following: submit to the Executive Board a written request for additions or deletions citing reasons, which the Executive Board shall proceed to consider; and furthermore that subparagraph f) be struck and subparagraph g) renumbered subparagraph f). Committeeman SMITH accepted the amendment as friendly. Committeeman SMITH spoke in favor of his proposal, saying that the input of the floor should be very limited, at most including a right to veto the whole list. Committeeman SALLES dropped his objections to the SMITH amendment to the DAVIS proposal being considered friendly, providing that the DAVIS proposal was to be voted on subparagraph by subparagraph. Chairman DAVIS said that would be the ordinary procedure in any case. Subparagraph a) of the DAVIS proposal as amended by the SMITH amendment as further amended by
Chairman DAVIS and Committeeman HILL passed unanimously. Subparagraph b) passed unanimously. Subparagraph c) passed unanimously. Subparagraph d) passed unanimously. Subparagraph e) passed unanimously. All of the preceding were at the motion of Committeeman SMITH. Committeeman SALLES said that he still preferred the original DAVIS proposal, but in light of the consensus of the Committee would accept the SMITH amendment, providing that Committeeman SMITH's idea of allowing the floor by three-fifths vote to veto the entire list were included. He stressed that this was a grave step, that a standoff between the Commission and its Executive Board would likely result in no awards being made at all, and that it would not be done unless the Commission felt that the awards were being grossly mishandled, as was done last year. He moved to make subparagraph f) of the DAVIS proposal as amended by SMITH renumbered subparagraph g) inserting a subparagraph f) reading: There must be an S.A.C. general meeting after announcement of names for awards of seals to be considered final. At such meeting the Commission may by three-fifths vote of a quorum override the Executive Board's submission of the list. In that case the Executive Board shall reconsider the question and another meeting must be called in order for the awards to be final. Committeeman SMITH suggested and moved as amendment to the SALLES amendment the substitution of the following wording: The S.A.C. shall then approve the revised list, or veto the list by three-fifths vote of a quorum at a meeting of the Commission. If the list is vetoed the Executive Board shall revise the list and continue as in subparagraph d). Committeeman SALLES accepted the SMITH amendment as friendly. Chairman DAVIS spoke in favor of the SALLES amendment saying that while other provisions of the proposal had alleviated most of his objections to last year's procedure in handing out of awards (they were done frivolously, in great number, and without consultation with the S.A.C. membership at all) but that this additional provision would provide at least negative input from the Commission at large without the danger that it be used frivolously. Committeeman LALLY said he thought the whole proposal did not allow for much control by the Commission at large, only input which could be disregarded at the whim of an Executive Board "like last year's", but he would support the whole proposal if the amendment were incorporated. Committeeman SMITH accepted the SALLES amendment to his amendment as further amended by SMITH as friendly. Subparagraph f) was passed unanimously. Subparagraph g) was passed unanimously.
PROPOSED BY-LAW
- The procedure for awarding seals shall be as follows:
- a)In the second semester of each academic year the Chairman shall send written notice to all members of the S.A.C. requesting nominations for S.A.C. seals.
(cont'd)
Meeting of October 15, 1982 (cont'd)
b) Every member of the S.A.C. shall have two weeks to nominate graduating seniors for such seals. All nominations must be typed double-spaced and include the qualifications of the nominee(s). The nominations must contain the names and office of the S.A.C. representative making the nomination.
c) The Executive Board shall review the names of all candidates for the seals and select a list of 25 who have contributed in a significant manner to the advancement of student activities while undergraduates.
d) The Chairman shall inform all members of the names of those nominated for the seals.
e) Members of the S.A.C. shall have one week to submit to the Executive Board a written request for additions or deletions citing reasons, which the Executive Board shall proceed to consider.
f) The S.A.C. shall then approve the revised list, or veto the list by three-fifths vote of a quorum at a meeting of the Commission.***
g) The Chairman shall then provide all members of the S.A.C., the Student Council, and the Senior Class Awards Committee of the names of those receiving the S.A.C. seal. (sic)
Meeting was adjourned at 9:47 p.m.
ERRATA: Subparagraph f) should continue:
If the list is vetoed the Executive Board shall revise the list and continue as in subparagraph g).
Minutes of the Constitutional Committee of the S.A.C.
Meeting of October 19, 1982
The Committee was called to order at 5:15 p.m. Chairman DAVIS,Committeemen HILL, KRUZANSKY, SAILLES present.
Committeeman SAILLES announced that inasmuch as Chairman DAVISwould be taking the motions to pass each committee proposalas written, etc., etc. he would second for purposes of discussionall motions of the Chair.
Motion by Chairman DAVIS to accept the minutes as printed passedunanimously.
Motion by Committeeman HILL to commend the Secretary for promptpresentation of the minutes and draft report passed 2-0-1 (in favor:HILL, KRUZANSKY; against: none; abstaining: SAILLES).
Committeeman LALLY arrived at this point.All motions to accept/pass committee recommendations & proposals by ChaMotion to pass the wording of the Committee's recommendation tothe Commission passed unanimously.
Motion to accept committee proposal #1 passed unanimously.Motion to accept committee proposal #2 passed unanimously.Motion to accept committee proposal #3 passed unanimously.
Chairman DAVIS moved that "his/her" in committee proposal #4be struck and the word "his" substituted, in accordance withsimilar stylistic changes made earlier by the committee. Motionpassed unanimously.
CHANGE MADE
Article I, Section 4 (new section, ref. p. 10, p. 46)
Strike: ...at his/her request...
Replace: ...at his request...
Motion to accept committee proposal #5 passed unanimously.Motion to accept committee proposal #6 passed unanimously.Motion to accept committee proposal #7 passed unanimously.
Chairman DAVIS moved that the words "acting irresponsibly"in committee proposal #8 be struck and replaced with "forfiscal irresponsibility" in accordance with changes previously
made in Article III, Section 2, Subparagraph 4 (Committee proposal#10). Motion passed unanimously.
Minutes of the Constitutional Committee of the S.A.C. (cont'd)
Meeting of October 19, 1982 (cont'd)
CHANGE MADE
Article II, Section 1, Subparagraph 5 (formerly Subparagraph 7)
Strike: ...organization acting irresponsibly...
Replace: ...organization for fiscal irresponsibility...
Motion to accept committee proposal #8 as amended passed unanimously.
Chairman DAVIS moved to strike "his/her" and replace with "his" in Committee proposal #9, and accept the proposal as amended. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGE MADE
Article II, Section 2
Strike: perform his/her official...
Replace: perform his official,...
Motion to pass committee proposal #10 passed unanimously.Motion to pass committee proposal #11 passed unanimously.Motion to pass committee proposal #12 passed unanimously.
Committeeman CALLES noted that the phrase "Executive Committee" appeared in proposition #13, which he took responsibility for as original drafter of that passage. He moved it be accepted striking "Executive Committee" for "Executive Board". Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGE MADE
Motion to pass Committee Proposal #14 passed unanimously.Motion to pass Committee Proposal #15 passed unanimously.Motion to pass Committee Proposal #16 passed unanimously.Motion to pass Committee Proposal #17 passed unanimously.Motion to pass Committee Proposal #18 passed unanimously.Motion to pass Committee Proposal #19 passed unanimously.Motion to pass Committee Proposal #20 passed unanimously.Motion to pass Committee Proposal #21 passed unanimously.
Meeting of October 19, 1982 (cont'd)
Motion to pass Committee proposal #22 passed unanimously.
Committeeman SMITH arrived at this point.
Motion to pass Committee Proposal #23 passed unanimously.Motion to pass Committee Proposal #24 passed unanimously.Motion to pass Committee Proposal #25 passed unanimously.Motion to pass Committee Proposal #26 passed unanimously.Motion to pass Committee Proposal #27 passed unanimously.Motion to pass Committee Proposal #28 passed unanimously.
Committeeman HILL commented that the punctuation in Proposal #29, and moved a comma be inserted between the word "present" and the words "in cases of". Committeeman SALLES said he agreed, but that he had been very careful not to change anything in the report, and none of the motions (of which there were many) on this proposal showed a comma. Motion to accept Committee Proposal #29 as amended by Committeeman HILL passed unanimously.
CHANGE MADE
Article V, Section 6 (formerly Section 5)
Strike: are present in cases of
Replace: are present, in cases of
Chairman DAVIS moved that a comma be inserted after "S.A.C. meeting" and before "any" in Committee Proposal #30. Passed unanimously.Motion to accept Committee Proposal #30 as amended passed unanimously.
CHANGE MADE
Article V, Section 7 (new section)
Strike: ...S.A.C. meeting any...
Replace: ...S.A.C. meeting, any...
Motion to pass Committee Proposal #31 passed unanimously.Motion to pass Committee Proposal #32 passed unanimously.
Committeeman SMITH suggested that the words "that publishes" be inserted after "any group" in Committee Proposal #33.Committeeman SALLES suggested instead that the words "that publication" be replaced by "its publication". Committeeman SMITH moved that the words "that publication" be struck and replaced by "that group's publication". Chairman DAVIS accepted as friendly. Motion to pass Committee Proposal #33 as amended passed unanimously.
Meeting of October 19, 1982 (cont'd)
Committeeman SALLES asked, regarding Committee Proposal #34, what would happen for group's whose name did not end with the word "association". Committeeman SMITH replied that for copyright you had to be an individual, a group of individuals, a corporation, or an association, so that the copyright would be in the name of (for instance) "The Johns Hopkins College Republicans Association". Committeeman SALLES dropped his objection. Committee Proposal #34 passed unanimously.
********************
CHANGE MADE
**********************
Article VI, Section 3 (new section)
Strike: ...of that publication.
Replace: ...of that group's publications
**********************
Committee Proposal #35 passed unanimously.Committee Proposal #36 passed unanimously.
Chairman TAVIS moved that the word "or" be inserted after "Executive Board" and before "by a two-thirds". Passed unanimously. Committee Proposal #37 passed unanimously.
***********************
CHANGES MADE
***********************
Article VIII, Section 1 (formerly Article VI, Section 1)
Strike: ...the Executive Board, by a two-thirds,...
Replace: ...the Executive Board, or by a two-thirds,...
***********************
Committee Proposal #38 passed unanimously.
Committeeman SMITH moved to insert the word "the" before each reference to "Student Council" in Committee Proposal #39. Passed unanimously. Committee Proposal #39 passed unanimously.
***********************
CHANGE MADE
************************
Strike: ...may be appealed to Student Council.
Replace: ...may be appealed to the Student Council.
Strike: ...shall be decided by Student Council.
Meeting of October 19, 1982 (cont'd)
Committee Proposal #40 passed unanimously.
Committee Proposal #41 passed unanimously.
On Committee Proposal #42 Committeeman LALLY asked to reopen and correct the minutes to let the record show that he abstained on the vote on subparagraph f) of this document at the October 15 meeting. Motion passed unanimously.
Committeeman CALLES moved to strike "Committee of the names" and replace with "Committee with the names" in Committee Proposal #42. Voting passed unanimously. Motion to accept Committee Proposal #42 passed unanimously.
CHANGE NAME
Proposed By-Law #2
Strike: ...Awards Committee of the names...
Replace: ...Awards Committee with the names...
Chairman DAVIS proposed a Committee Proposal #43 adding a Proposed By-Law #7 to read: "Meetings of the S.A.C. Executive Board and of the Commission shall be conducted according to Robert's Rules of Order, newly revised". Committeeman LALLY moved to strike the words "newly revised" as redundant. Committeeman SMITH agreed, pointing out that each edition of Robert's Rules states that for each purpose it succeeds earlier edition. Chairman DAVIS accepted as friendly. Motion passed unanimously.
CHANGE RATE
Proposed By-Law #3
Meetings of the S.A.C. Executive Board and of the Commission shall be conducted according to Robert's Rules of Order.
Committeeman SMITH suggested that a by-law be moved having the Chairman appoint a Parliamentarian. Committeeman HILL said "no" since it would get complex; and the Parliamentarian would think he had the right to rule, not to recommend to the Chairman rulings, etc., etc. Committeeman LALLY agreed. Chairman DAVIS agreed saying it would be best if the Chairman had authority, and "we had enough of Debby Jeffrey appointing Parliamentarians last year". No motion was introduced.
Minutes of Meeting of October 19, 1982 (cont'd)
Committeeman HILL moved that Committee Proposals #1-#43 be finally approved for draft report purposes. Committeeman LALLY seconded. Motion passed unanimously. Chairman DAVIS asked that the record show him as approving the report.
Committeeman LALLY left at this point.
Committeeman SALLIS asked that since the minutes show that Committee Proposal #34 was intended as an amelioration and exception to Committee Proposal #33, they be "linked" as one unit in the terms of the motion recommended (p. 44). Motion passed, seconded by Committeeman HILL, unanimously. Chairman DAVIS asked that the record show him as approving.
Committeeman SALLIS moved further that the Committee define its proposals #1, #2, #3, #5, #6, #7, #8, #9, #10, #11, #14, #16, #17, #19, #22, #24, #25, #26, #27, #28, #29, #30, #31, and #40 as "technical" and affecting no powers of the Commission, its membership, or the Executive Board, or any other institution. Motion passed unanimously. Chairman DAVIS asked that the record show he approved of the definition as "technical" of these proposals.
The Committee moved to recommend to the Commission that its mandate be extended to deal with questions, comments, and concerns raised by Student Council and other parties and it be empowered to report to the Executive Board revised amendments and proposals for its proposition to Council. Committeeman SALLIS asked that the Commission direct the Chairman to call another Commission meeting between November 10 and 17. Chairman DAVIS put himself on record as saying that he would call such a meeting if Council required substantive changes to the proposals or rejected a substantive proposal. Committeeman SALLIS withdrew his motion and expressed himself satisfied.
Committee adjourned at 6:20 pm.
Addendum to draft report of the Constitutional Committee of the S.A.C.
<u>Committee Proposal #4</u> (p. 10, p. 58 minutes)
Article I, Section 4 (new section)
Any member of the Commission may submit any proposal within the authority of the Executive Board to any member of the Executive Board for the Board's consideration. The proposer may request that the Executive Board render a definitive decision on the proposal within the shortest practicable time. The Executive Board is bound by this request and must consider and give final approval or rejection of the proposal no later than at the close of the second Executive Board and may not table or further postpone consideration of the proposal in question, and such decision shall be entered on the minutes of the Executive Board, a copy of which shall be supplied to the originator of the proposal at his request.
<u>Committee Proposal #8</u> (p. 4, p. 11, p. 59 minutes)
Article II, Section 1, Subparagraph 6
corresponds to: Article II, Section 1, Subparagraph 7
freeze the funds and assets of any organization for fiscal irresponsibility, pending review by the Executive Board at its next regularly scheduled meeting. The Chairman shall notify all Commission members in writing within three days.
Current wording: freeze the funds and assets of any organization acting irresponsibly, pending review by the Executive Board at its next regularly scheduled meeting. The treasurer shall notify the Commission in writing of such action within three days.
<u>Committee Proposal #9</u> (p. 11, p. 59 minutes)
Article II, Section 2
In the event that the Chairman is unavailable or unable to perform his official duties, the President of the Student Council is empowered to perform them.
Current wording: In the event that the Treasurer is unavailable or unable to perform his/her official duties, the President of the Student Council is empowered to perform them.
<u>Committee Proposal #13</u> (p. 16, p. 59 minutes)
[unclear: (]
Article III, Section 2, Subparagraph 13
call a meeting of the Commission or the Executive Board by affirmative vote of any four members on an appropriate motion at a meeting of the Executive Board. The motion shall direct the Chairman to call a meeting at a given time, and the Chairman shall give timely notice to all members of the appropriate body as in a meeting called under the provisions of Article II Section 1. (cont'd)
Committee Proposal #13 (cont'd from p. 64)
(continuation of committee proposal:
Article III, Section 2, Subparagraph 13)
The Chairman shall call a meeting of the Commission upon direction by petition signed by one-quarter of the Commission membership.
Current wording: call a meeting of the Commission by affirmative vote of any three members on an appropriate motion at a meeting of the Executive Committee. The motion shall direct the Chairman to call a meeting at a given time, and the Chairman shall give timely notice to all S.A.C. members as in a meeting called under the provisions of Article II Section 1.
Committee Proposal #29 (p. 26, p. 27, p. 60 minutes)
Article V, Section 6
corresponds to Article V, Section 5
All organizations during their first year of existence shall be Class E, which is a probationary status. At the end of the probationary period, the organization's status will be reviewed by the Executive Board and the Student Council for transfer to permanent class status. An organization may also be recommended for Class E status to the Student Council by a majority vote of the Executive Board at a meeting at which all members are present, in cases of financial irresponsibility or failure to meet constitutional requirements. Such a recommendation shall not be transmitted to Student Council until after the occurrence of one general S.A.C. meeting after the action is taken. Expenditures of such groups must be approved by the Executive Board, except for groups in the first year of operation so designated. All organizations with Class E status shall be entitled to one representative on the Student Activities Commission; this position shall be filled by the group's chief executive officer.
Current wording: All organizations during their first year of existence shall be Class E, which is a probationary status. At the end of the probationary period, the organization's status will be reviewed by the Executive Board and the Student Council for transfer to permanent class status. An organization may also be placed in Class E status by a majority vote of the Executive Board. This power is to be exercised as a sanction in cases of financial irresponsibility or failure to meet constitutional requirements. Expenditures of such groups must be approved by the Executive Board, and their student activities account shall be open at the discretion of the Executive Board. All organizations with Class E status shall be entitled to one representative on the Student Activities Commission; this position shall be filled by the group's chief executive officer.
Addendum to the Draft Report of the Constitutional Committee of the S.A.C.(cont’d)
Committee Proposal #33 (p. 29, p. 61 minutes)
Article VI, Section 3 (new section)
The executive committee or editorial board of any group shall be considered to be the publisher of that group’s publications.
Committee Proposal #37 (p. 3, p. 31 minutes)
Article VIII, Section 1
formerly Article VII, Section 1
Amendments to this constitution may only be proposed by a majority vote of the Executive Board, or by a two-thirds vote of a quorum of [illegible] the Commission. All such proposed amendments are subject to the approval of Student Council. This constitution may also be amended by student referendum.
Current wording: Amendments to this constitution may only be proposed by a majority vote of the Executive Board, by a two-thirds vote of a quorum at a meeting of the whole Commission, or under direction from the Student Body through a referendum. All such proposed amendments are subject to the approval of the Student Council.
Committee Proposal #39 (p. 33, p. 61 minutes)
Renumber Article VIII, Section 3 to Article IX and title INTERPRETATION.
Article IX INTERPRETATION (corresponds to Article VII, Section 3)
Questions concerning interpretation of this document shall be decided by the S.A.C. Executive Board. All decisions concerning interpretation of this Constitution may be appealed to the Student Council. Questions concerning conflicts between this Constitution and the Constitution of the Student Body of the Johns Hopkins University shall be decided by the Student Council.
Current wording: Questions concerning interpretation of this constitution shall be decided by the Student Council.
Committee Proposal #42 (p. 36, p. 37, p. 62 minutes)
Proposed By-Law #2.
The procedure for awarding seals shall be as follows:
a) In the second semester of each academic year the Chairman shall send written notice to all members of the S.A.C. requesting nominations for S.A.C. seals.
b) Every member of the S.A.C. shall have two weeks to nominate graduating seniors for such seals. All nominations must be typed double-spaced and include the qualifications of the nominee(s).
The nominations must contain the name and office of the S.A.C.
Committee Proposal #42 (cont'd)
Proposed By-Law #2 (cont'd)
representative making the nomination.
c) The Executive Board shall review the names of all candidates for the seals and select a list of 25 who have contributed in a significant manner to the advancement of student activities while undergraduates.
d) The Chairman shall inform all members of the names of those nominated for the seals.
e) Members of the S.A.C. shall have one week to submit to the Executive Board a written request for additions or deletions citing reasons, which the Executive Board shall proceed to consider.
f) The S.A.C. shall then approve the revised list, or veto the list by three-fifths vote of a quorum at a meeting of the Commission. If the list is vetoed the Executive Board shall revise the list and continue as in subparagraph d).
g) The Chairman shall then provide all members of the S.A.C., the Student Council, and the Senior Class Awards Committee of the names of those receiving the S.A.C. seal.
The Committee votes to include in its report the comment that it considers its proposals #1, #2, #3, #5, #6, #7, #8, #9, #10, #11, #14, #16, #17, #18, #22, #24, #25, #26, #27, #28, #35, #37, #38, and #40 'technical'.
The Committee recommends to the Student Activities Commission that its mandate be extended to deal with questions, comments, and concerns raised by Student Council and other parties and it be empowered to report to the Executive Board as well as the Commission (rather than, as previously, exclusively to the Commission) to serve as a vehicle for resubmission of revised proposals to Council.
Sources
1982 Constitutional Committee Minutes · 1982 Constitutional Committee Minutes pt 2
