JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

Freshmen Tie Resolution Process

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

Freshmen Tie Resolution Process Briefing Document

Johns Hopkins Student Government Association

Office of the Executive Vice President, AJ Tsang

Office of the Committee on Internal Affairs

September 29th, 2018

Impetus: The CSE Bylaws state that ties in the freshmen class elections can be resolved through two means. First, the CSE can unanimously vote to host a run-off election. If the CSE does not do this, then the duty falls to the Senate to break the tie by selecting one of the two candidates through a supermajority (⅔) vote. On the evening of Thursday, September 25th, it became apparent that two of the candidates for the Class of 2022 elections were tied: Eric Armstrong and Grace Wang.

Later that evening, the CSE indicated that it had not reached a unanimous consensus to hold a run-off election. As such, it fell to the Senate to break the tie through supermajority vote. After consulting with the incoming freshmen senators-elect, the CSE, and the tied candidates, the following process was developed to assist in the supermajority vote. The process was designed to ensure democratic representation of the freshmen class, transparency to the student body, and the protection of the privacy of the two tied candidates, who should not be forced to and do not wish to, at this point in their Hopkins career, “duke it out” in public view.

It should be noted that many members of the SGA, including the Internal Affairs Committee, the Executive Board, and many members of the Senate, do not feel anything but a runoff would be ethical. However, because the SGA is bound by the terms of the CSE,

Process:

Date/Time/Location

Activity

Sunday, September 30th, 20182:00 PMGilman Atrium

Interviews of Eric and Grace. Per the SGA Constitution and Bylaws, this meeting is open to anyone in SGA and the public.Questions include but are not limited to:What is your Favorite/least favorite things about Hopkins? How do you hope to make an impact?What other things (extracurriculars, sports, etc.) are you currently involved in?What are your strengths and weaknesses? What was/is your platform and the core issues you seek to address in office?What previous experiences have prepared you for SGA?Connection question - JennWhy do you think SGA matters on our campus? Ask if they have any questionsDo you have any other comments?AJ can ask Rahul about getting ORCA screens

Sunday, September 30th, 20183:00 PMGilman Atriums

The Internal Affairs prepares brief, <1 page confidential character and qualifications analysis of each candidate. These analyses are transmitted to the Senate in the weekly agenda email.

Monday, October 1st, 2018By 11:59 PMEmail

Eric and Grace are permitted to send brief (<100 word) character references and endorsement notes to the SGA. These should be sent to EVP AJ Tsang and ESE Aspen Williams.

Tuesday, October 2nd, 20187:20 PMCharles Commons East Room

Eric and Grace each give a 5-6 minute presentation on their goals for SGA. The Senate is permitted 5 minutes to ask each of them questions, moderated caucus style.

Tuesday, October 2nd, 20188:30 PMCharles Commons East Room

After discussing other new business, the Senate moves into temporary closed session to discuss which candidate may be better suited for the Senatorial position. The Senate should seek to arrive at a consensus on which candidate to select during this session, in order to ensure a supermajority is reached.

Tuesday, October 2nd, 20188:45 PMCharles Commons East Room

The Senate returns to open session. The Chairs of the Internal Affairs Committee (AJ and Jenn) summarize the best qualities of each candidate, as discussed in closed session. The Senate, by open vote or closed ballot, vote for Eric or Grace.

Grace:

Favorite thing at hop: Community, there’s always someone in her hall, people are there to ask for help, has learned to reach out, good community

Least favorite: superficial things - food,

Platform: communication, connection, clarity, - SGA communication with administrators, online forum - there should be a place for students at any time to go discuss their issues, aka, knives at the ffc, focus on the small things, easy wins

Connection - better connection with the city of baltimore, met people in baltimore and understands our relationship with baltimore, there should be more programming esp. Freshmen into baltimore, issues didn’t resonate with people during O-week because we don’t know what’s going on in the community

Clarity - knows people who were herued, no one knew about the consequences or the amnesty policy is, also sexual assault policy, the policies are too vague and people are afraid of reaching out

Other extracurriculars - WiB, Baja, plays ultimate frisbee

Strengths and weaknesses: very approachable has tried to reach out to new people more so than in high school, has branched out and explored her interests

Wants to work on mental health issues - counseling center doesn’t offer long term treatment

Previous experiences - been on the board for clubs in HS, editor for yearbook, v gritty, kept asking people, learned about marketing, VP for a sustainability club, banned plastic bags in her county, spoke to legislators and sat in county meeting, tried to host a solutionary congress - presentation style event where teams pick an issues and present a solution - discussed college rape, was also event coordinator for that. Started Build On at her school, fundraise to build schools in developing countries - has to raise 30k to build a school, like their message that they used local labor to build schools and set up systems to keep the school running, developed a 2 year plan to get the 30K. Offered services to a local community center as a tutor.

Building Connections - people are most interested when you ask them about their concerns, doesn't matter about your platform if you don’t listen to them -- divestment, mental health. Good listener - (WE NEED THIS), once people discuss what they’re passionate about they keep talking, treating all people (profs, admin) like people

Why do you think SGA matters - sga connects people when it can be difficult to organize the student body in general, it’s important to help build bridges to funnel ideas to fruition , it’s important to have a place that concentrates issues/ideas so that we can work on issues that are most pressing - SGA can be frustrating in navigating the bureaucracy - having somewhere to channel ideas and cut through red tape

Questions for us:

Send an outline with what to bring to the GBM

Eric:

Brought marketing materials and his resume!!

Favorite thing: sense of community - came from a larger highschool - people here are very friendly and he likes to see a similar community from hs

Least favorite thing: Disability access, when you walk through campus think about how someone with a wheelchair would get through, v important to him

Other extracurriculars: korean student association, club water polo - was v big in his high school

Strengths and weaknesses: congeniality likes getting to know people, focused on personally talking to people and not just advertising, good at getting to know people, hopes to bring a direct electoral connection.

Forgot weaknesses

Platform - making sga more accessible to student - not just rubber stamping what other clubs are planning, making events more direct collaborative events - market what we’re doing, did SGA in high school - really liked the programming aspect

What can SGA do - mental health issues, wasn’t recognition for stress in his high school. When he was in SGA - started Unity week- covered the entire quad area/center of campus with posters with words of affirmation, posters on the walls, “love is”, motivational speakers, partnered with drama department that outlined mental health issues. Planned “fun days” big event with inflatables and bounce houses, brought in dogs, wanted to remind people that we want a sense of community, wants to bring it to Hop

What does SGA mean to you - in high school - wasn’t just to pad his resume, position of election and representation, wanted to student body to feel unified, was also president of 150 member student congress - ran a give back thanks campaign - all staff on campus would receive a gift from the students to show appreciation, was very meaningful to them, SGA is a chance to give back and use it as a platform

How do you intend to build connections: wants to foster personal connections, people care if you talk to them and look for their response, during petitioning people only wanted to sign and didn’t care about the platform, people always have something to say, this galvanizes people to care, we should be more personal and congenial

Why does SGA matters at Hopkins: Scope of SGA is bigger here, SGA can be very impactful here, we have the ability to bring change to this campus, spoke very passionately about what we can do, has a lot of ways to make meaningful change

Recognizes that students can’t get appointments in Hell Well-has a personal anecdote, had to go to the emergency room, students deserve help

Mental health - awareness of it needs to increase, doesn’t exactly know what to do but we could potentially increase funding for mental health clubs

Information to Senate -

Grace:

In touch with student body

Has precise ideas about implementing policy

Demonstrated persistence in projects/doesn’t burn out

Eric:

High school SGA

In touch with current issues

Fosters personal connections

Sources

Freshmen Tie Resolution Process.docx