Senate
of the
Student Government Association
of
The Johns Hopkins University
{ S. Resolution 18-19, XX }
A Resolution in Opposition of the Johns Hopkins University Police Department
Introduced By: Senator Alexander Forlenza of the Freshman Class and considered this 7th day of April in the Year 2019
Sponsored By:
Senator Sam Mollin of the Sophomore Class and Senator Claire Gorman of the junior Class
Referred to the senate by Civic Engagement which recommends its Passage by a vote of 5 to 0.
Whereas Section II of the Johns Hopkins Undergraduate Student Government Association’s Constitution states, “The purpose of the SGA is to protect and improve the rights, opportunities, and quality of life for every undergraduate student at the Johns Hopkins University;”
Whereas Section III of the Johns Hopkins Undergraduate Student Government Association’s Constitution states, “The authority of SGA is derived from the students of the Johns Hopkins University and collectively recognized by the University President and other administrators.”
Whereas Private Police forces at other American universities have had violent histories
Last spring at the University of Chicago a student, in the midst of a mental crisis, was shot by one of the university's police officers.[1]
At UCLA, in 2013, a Judge was brutalized by UCLA officers nowhere near UCLA property[2]
In 2012, an 18-year-old student at the University of South Alabama was killed by a school police officer without ever being within 4 feet of the officer[3]
Whereas the establishment of a Johns Hopkins Police Department, hereinafter private police force, will create new dangers, both physical and mental, to the students of Johns Hopkins
Whereas Private University Police forces across the nation have had a very racist history with trends of stopping black people significantly more than any other group[4], stronger use of force against black people[5][6], and generally giving black people a hard time when going about regular activities like napping.[7]
Whereas the establishment of a private police force will create a fearful environment for many black students[8], and it will also negatively affect everyone on campus who comes from a background of distrust towards the police be it because of race, religion, or sexual identity.
Whereas Johns Hopkins has claimed their training procedures would resolve internal biases of officers, but by the nature of internal biases, it is near impossible to remove them. And in many cases, the act of policing can further the inherent biases within the officers.[9]
Whereas there is no police force that has a true lack of bias in this country.[10]
Whereas the 2018-2019 SGA Referendum found that, by a significant margin of 74.4% to 25.6%, the student body is not in favor of the private police force. The same referendum which the university has used for mental health initiatives, sexual assault initiatives, and other initiatives that encompass the entire student body.
Whereas Columbia University, a similarly elite and urban college, uses an unarmed security force, and as a result, Columbia University has not been involved in killing or brutalizing any students or community residents since 1968.[11]
Whereas the presence of armed individuals on campus will lead to more violence.[12]
Whereas the Baltimore Police Department reforms have done very little to help the city[13], and creation of a private police force does not help the problems of Baltimore city.
Whereas the research report surrounding the legislation that would grant Johns Hopkins University a private police force was done by Johns Hopkins University which we in SGA strongly believe is a conflict of interest.
Whereas the food worker union, Unite Here Local 7, has come out against the creation of a private police force because of the aforementioned biases as well as the history of violence.[15]
Whereas several student groups, like students against private police, BSU, ASA, etc.., have directly express fervent opposition to the creation of a private police force. Several groups have outright protested by marching, traveling to speak to the Maryland Legislature, and even conducting a sit-in at Garland Hall.
Therefore, Be It Resolved that the Johns Hopkins Student Government Association opposes the establishment of the Private Police Force.
Be It Further Resolved that SGA implores Johns Hopkins University that if it creates a private police force that they maximize the input of Johns Hopkins students by allowing for ongoing public forums as well as a space for public criticism
Be It Further Resolved that SGA asks Johns Hopkins University to give students in some fashion oversight over the nature of the possible private police force to ensure problems of discrimination, that will occur, be minimized in an efficient manner
Specifically, we ask students to be involved in the process of investigations into matters of police brutality, discrimination, and violent action be it physically or verbally abusive
We also ask that students be involved in the hiring process concerning the prerequisites to become a police officer within the private police force
Lastly, we request that students be continually updated on all matters that could possibly instigate an investigation against a possible private police force
Be It Further Resolved that SGA asks Johns Hopkins University to continually reassess the state of affairs in and around Johns Hopkins during the implementation of a possible police force, and create a public report of the changes the private police force brings, if it is implemented.
A.We would request to see the crime data and any changes to it as a police force is enacted
B.We would also request a campus survey on the effects of a police force on mental health on campus
C.Lastly, we would request a compilation of all the complaint data collected from all stakeholders including but not limited to: students, faculty, community residents, and officers themselves.
Be It Further Resolved the University conduct a formal referendum among the student body to determine whether or not students support the private police force if they do not accept the results of SGA’s referendum.
Be It Further Resolved that a copy of this resolution be transmitted to the Johns Hopkins Board of Trustees; Secretary of the Board of Trustees, Maureen S. Marsh; University President, Ronald Daniels; University Provost, Sunil Kumar; and Dean of Student Life, Smita Ruzicka.
The Resolution hereby X by a vote of X to X with X abstentions.
Upon adoption, we have hereunto set our hands and caused the seal of the Senate to be affixed to this resolution indicating the senate’s assent and thus officially designating the resolution’s adoption as the position and is will of the Senate and the Student Body of The Johns Hopkins University.
Signatures of Enactment:
Miranda Bannister
President of the Senate
Executive Vice President of the Johns Hopkins SGA
AJ Tsang
Executive President of the Johns Hopkins SGA
Aspen Williams
Executive Secretary of the Johns Hopkins SGA
Mi Tu
Executive Treasurer of the Johns Hopkins SGA
ADDENDUM A — DEFINITIONS
SGA — The term “SGA” shall refer to the Student Government Association of The Johns Hopkins University.
Private Police — The term “private police” or “private police force” shall refer to the possible armed security force that Johns Hopkins is attempting to establish
Food Workers Union — refers to the workers union of the Charles Street Market, FFC, Levering, etc….employees
Referendum — refers to the survey put out by the SGA gathering data on several topics one of which was the private police
UCLA — Refers to the University of California, Los Angeles
BSU- refers to the Johns Hopkins Black Student Union
ASA- refers to the Johns Hopkins African Student Association
ADDENDUM B — SOURCES
[1]https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/local/breaking/ct-met-college-police-departments-tasers-20180407-story.html
[2] https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-ucla-cunningham-20140711-story.html
[3] https://prospect.org/article/campus-cops-authority-without-accountability
[4]https://www.chicagoreporter.com/new-data-supports-old-accusations-of-racial-profiling-by-university-of-chicago-police-department/
[5] https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-ucla-cunningham-20140711-story.html
[6] https://almanac.upenn.edu/archive/between/2004/profiling-summary.html
[7] https://www.cnn.com/2018/05/09/us/yale-student-napping-black-trnd/index.html
[8]https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2018/07/09/this-is-how-police-killings-affect-black-mental-health/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.d4e6a7c3c755
[9] https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2659&context=ulj
[10] https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2017/12/implicit-bias-training-salt-lake/548996/
[11] https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2018/03/the-students-behind-the-1968-columbia-uprising
[12] https://www.rand.org/research/gun-policy/analysis/supplementary/firearm-prevalence-violent-crime.html
[13] https://www.baltimoresun.com/news/opinion/oped/bs-ed-op-1202-bpd-commissioner-20181129-story.html
[14] https://newrepublic.com/article/148304/rough-justice-america-over-policed
[15] https://baltimorebeat.com/2019/03/21/the-winding-and-contested-path-to-a-johns-hopkins-police-force/
