Constitution and Bylaws Committee Meeting #3
Date: September 28th, 2016
Time: 6:00 PM to 6:45 PM
Members Present: AJ Tsang (chair), Sathvik Namburar, Akshay Bhamidipati, Ope Olukorede
Review of former Senator Subramaniam’s external transparency analysis:
May be overly critical
Is the report neutral?
Is the data usable?
Technology definitely limiting as a barrier
Door-closing policy not being enforced
External presentations taking too long
Need to incorporate time for questions
Set a definite time limit for questions
Make it more like the UN - total time vs speaking time (total time 15 mins, speaker time of 1 mins)
Because not everyone uses full time, can be much shorter
If need more time, can set up motion to extend
More Robert’s Rules
More ad-hocs?
Already maxed out on committees, on time, on academics
Can’t increase workload for no reason
SGA should adopt policy of “help us first, then others” - more ineffectual, people demoralized
Standard of two committees needs to end - make it optional
Advising
More faculty and dean perspective - history, polisci, is,
Fewer people on committees would be more efficient
What is an ideal committee size?
Side note for Sustainability: What happened to Meals in a Minute in Levering?
Have Bill present to GBM on 16/17 dining changes
Cliques in SGA
Certain groups of friends - but not cliques
Communication
People don’t know what we’re doing
Couldn’t get enough signatures for a petition
If people really cared, it could have happened
SGA should advertise its meetings more - not effective in marketing is true
Praise can be 50-50
Took people to push us, but if enough people care, it will happen
Student groups don’t always represent the student body
We could have disproportional representation - which is pretty widespread in SGA
Covered in ad-hoc
Is the interest in external ad-hocs there? Yes
All you need is one SGA member to chair
ReCover Hopkins
Bigger surveys, more representative
All students must be heard, not just the most vocal
Question is whether we should represent the pure majority or a melange of every belief
Hearing opinions that are voiced out
Without representative equality, no clear picture of representation
Should SGA represent a simple majority or a blend?
Should represent a blend
Does SGA need to be unified? Can it have dissent?
Need more people to voice their opinion
People not willing to voice disagreement
Encouraging more discourse in SGA at all
More rigorous vetting of things - need to play the devil’s advocate
Internal operations
All the time debating the Bylaws
Spent forever debating Bylaws
Could just be Constitution Committee
Give this committee more influence?
Give us lateral trust so that we can vote and waive changes through?
Enhance trust to let CB do the right thing
At the same time, one committee and one group of people can’t be responsible for all of SGA’s workings
Surveys
If people won’t be polite in surveys then they know people really hate us, or they just want to go off on us
Studies tend to create a positive bias, but our campus may have a negative bias
The very fact that we have a negative bias is what we should address
Incidents make people hate SGA
SGA tends to wait for controversy and pick the right side but do it the wrong way
Communication
Restore WWDW voting style in brody mse levering
Email raffle, plus online - maximize data
Use the forum to ask about sga, check off boxes
Before and after poll of sga and listening to sga
Poll everywhere in real time, vote on opinions
Later get people’s emails, send survey about event
Long Term Project Assignments
CSE Bylaws - All
Student Orgs Bylaws - Akshay
Transparency Report - Ope, AJ (send leela’s to charlie)
Student Opinion Polling - Ope, Sathvik
Administrative Petition System - AJ, Sathvik
