The Johns Hopkins UniversityThe Student Council
TENTATIVE DRAFT OF
THE JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY
UNDERGRADUATE JUDICIAL CODE
I. Preamble
It is the intention of the undergraduate students of the Johns Hopkins University to create and maintain a judicial code. This code is intended to provide a procedure and forum for airing and resolving grievances against the undergraduate community. Likewise, the code shall protect the undergraduates from unfair or unwarranted actions by other members of the University community.
II. Jurisdiction
The judicial code shall apply to the undergraduate, full-time members of the College of Arts & Sciences and the G.W.C. Whiting School of Engineering. This code pertains to any and all offenses against members of the University community, as well [handwritten: bracket/underline around “as any criminal offenses allegedly committed”] as any criminal offenses allegedly committed by an undergraduate. A member of the University community shall be defined as any full or part-time student presently registered in the University, and/or any full or part-time employee of the University. Offenses involving firearms shall be handled in a separate matter, as described by the policy stated in the Johns Hopkins University circular. The judicial code is to be administered jointly by the Judicial Board of the Student Council and the Dean of Students. This code shall be the sole University protocol for settling disputes over which it has jurisdiction.
[handwritten: small mark in right margin]
III. The Judicial Board
The Judicial Board shall be constituted as an independent committee of the Johns Hopkins University Undergraduate Student Council. The Chairperson of the Judicial Board shall be nominated by the Student Council Committee on Committees, and confirmed by majority vote of the Student Council. The Chairperson shall then sit in on the interviews for [handwritten: bracket/underline around “the other twelve members of the Board”] the other twelve members of the Board, but may not vote. The other twelve nominees must also be confirmed by the Student Council. With the exception of the initial Chairperson, the Chairperson must have [handwritten: “previously been a member of the Board” underlined; handwritten: “ok.” in right margin] previously been a member of the Board, preferably having served on a number of Hearing panels during his or her tenure. All members serve for a term of one year and may be reappointed, with the exception of the chairperson, who may serve as chairperson for only one term. [handwritten: “No past or present elected student official may serve on the Judicial Board.” underlined/marked] No past or present elected student official may serve on the Judicial Board. Should the need arise, the Committee on Committees shall select students to fill vacancies on the Board from a list of past applicants.
Levering Hall
Baltimore, Maryland 21218(301) 338-8203
IV. Hearing panels
At the beginning of the academic year, the Chairperson shall prepare a random-order list of Judicial Board members. For each incident brought before the Board, a Hearing panel is convened consisting of the next five names on the list, the sixth name being the Presiding Officer. In any case, the accused, the complainant, or any other member of the panel may challenge the impartiality of a member. The rest of the panel shall hear the charges of bias, a majority of votes being necessary to remove a member from a panel. Members may also be removed for dereliction of duty. Should any member or members be removed from a given case, their names shall be moved to the bottom of the list, and subsequent names shall be chosen. When the bottom of the list is reached, the names are to be placed in a new random-order. The Presiding official must attend all Hearings, maintain all records pertaining to his or her case and deliver same to the General Counsel's office when not in use by the panel, and shall vote only in the absence of a panel member.
V. Procedure
A. Procedure for certifying a charge:
- Any person who reasonably believes that offenses warranting disciplinary action have been committed by an undergraduate may file a written complaint against the student with the Dean of Students' office, who will forward the complaint to the Chairperson of the Judicial Board.
- A written complaint must be submitted within either:
- a.seven (7) days from the date of commission of the alleged offense, or
- b.seven (7) days from the date of discovery of either the alleged offense or the identity of the alleged offender.
- The complaint must contain the name and address of the complainant, the name of the accused, and a specific and factual statement of the offense, including a description of the damage or injury.
- The Chairperson of the Judicial Board shall mail or deliver notification to a student against whom a charge has been made, within three (3) days following the receipt of the complaint.
- Notice must be served either by hand-delivery, or by certified mail, return receipt requested.
- Notice shall contain:
a. a complete copy of the complaint
b. copies of any and all documentary evidence supporting the charge. Should any new documentary evidence be obtained after notice is served, but prior to the rendering of a final decision, copies shall be given promptly to the accused.
c. a copy of the judicial code
d. notice that all parties have a right to an advisor to assist in the preparation of the case. Only members of the University community may serve in the capacity of advisor, and may not be compensated for their assistance. The Judicial Board shall maintain a roster of students, faculty, staff, and administration who are familiar with the workings of the judicial code and procedure, and who are willing to make themselves available to serve as advisors.
e. the time and date of a scheduled meeting to consider the complaint. The meeting must be scheduled within ten (10) days of the sending of the notice. The meeting shall take place in the Dean of Students' office and shall include only the Dean of Students, the complainant, the accused, and the Chairperson of the Judicial Board. Should there be more than one complainant and/or more than one accused in a given incident, the Dean of Students and the Chairperson of the Judicial Board shall meet with each individually, than convene a meeting of all parties involved.
- Objections to jurisdiction over offenses may be submitted to the Chairperson of the Judicial Board. If the Chairperson determines that the offense is not one which falls into the code's jurisdiction, he or she shall terminate the matter and inform both parties. Either party may appeal this decision to the Dean of Students, who may overturn the decision only with the assent of both the President and Vice-President of the Student Council.
- The accused shall have the option of having his/her or their case heard by either the Dean of Students or by the Judicial Board. The choice must be made within two (2) days of the meeting in the Dean of Students' office, and the accused must inform the Chairperson within that time. The Chairperson must then inform the complainant(s) and the Dean.
VI. <u>The Hearing process</u>
- The Hearing shall be closed unless the accused files a written request with the Chairperson for a public hearing. Cases of sexual assult shall be closed. The accuser must be promptly notified of the decision. Closed Hearings shall be held in the Shriver Hall Board Room, while public Hearings shall be held in the Arellano Theater.
- All Hearings shall be taped and all concerned parties will be given access to the tape upon request.
- Security of the documentary evidence and any reports of the Hearing panel (in a jury-ruled hearing) or the Dean of Students (in a judge-ruled hearing) shall be the responsibility of either the Presiding Official of the panel, or the Dean of Students. The materials are to be kept in the Office of the General Counsel. [handwritten: phrase boxed and underlined]
- (The Dean/The Presiding Official) shall read the charges at the commencement of the Hearing and, at this point, the accused shall assert his/her/their innocence or guilt.
- (The Dean/the panel) shall receive all evidence and hear all testimony of the parties concerned and their witnesses. The accuser(s) shall present his/her/their case first, followed by a defense by the accused. (The Dean/the panel members), the accuser(s), and the accused shall all have the opportunity to examine and cross-examine all witnesses. (The Dean/members of the panel) may not discuss the case (except with other panel members.)
- The accused may be found guilty by a vote of four out of five members of the panel, or by the decision of the Dean. [handwritten: “four out of five” underlined] The verdict shall be accompanied by a written opinion stating the basis for the decision reached, and in the case of a panel Hearing, any dissenting opinion. The entire record shall then be forwarded to the Chairperson, and then to the Associate Dean of Academic Advising. [handwritten: phrase boxed and underlined]
VII. <u>Sanctions</u>
Sanctions against a guilty student are to be determined and implemented by a consensus of the Associate Dean of Academic Advising and the Chairperson of the Judicial Board. They are urged to take into consideration the sanction(s) recommended by either the Dean or the panel. The following sanctions may be imposed:
- Oral or written reprimand.
- University probation for a specific period of time. The student is to be warned that repetition of the offense may warrant the imposition of additional, and greater, sanctions.
- Compensatory payments, including the payment of fines, financial restitution, or the performance of services. A time-table for the repayment may be arranged.
- Denial of the priviledges that were abused.
- Social suspension for a specific period of time. During this period, the student is to be barred from any University-sponsered sports teams, clubs, or organizations, as well as any University-sponsered social or cultural events. A student on social suspension may not hold any office, either in a club or in student government, and must resign any offices at the onset of the suspension.
- Academic suspension for a specified period of time.
- Expulsion.
The student's failure to comply with the sanctions may warrant the imposition of additional sanctions, after affording the student notice and an opportunity to be heard. In cases where a student is found guilty and punished, and later charged with an unrelated offense, information regarding prior cases and their sanction(s) shall be witheld until a verdict is reached.
VIII. Appeals
A student has the right to appeal a conviction. Within fourteen (14) days of sanctioning, an appeal may be submitted to the Dean of the student's School and should include a request for a new Hearing, and explanation of the grounds on which an appeal is being sought. The Dean of the School shall then confer with either the Dean of Students or the Presiding Official, depending on the nature of the Hearing, and decide whether or not to allow the appeal. Should the appeal be granted, it shall be heard by the accused's choice of forums that did not hear the original case. A student may not appeal the same case twice.
[handwritten: ARMSTRONG]
[handwritten: VANDELINDE]
Sources
IMG_2716.HEIC · IMG_2717.HEIC · IMG_2718.HEIC · IMG_2719.HEIC · IMG_2720.HEIC
