JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

Writ of Certiorari 15Feb2025

Filed in Drive as “Writ_of_Certiorari_15Feb2025.docx”

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

You are viewing the
version.

{No.24-25.1}

JHU Student Government Association Judiciary Board

Jackson Morris,

Petitioner,

vs.

The Student Government Association,

Respondent.

A Petition for Writ of Certiorari to the

Judiciary Board of the Student Government Association of

The Johns Hopkins University

Jackson Morris

Class of 2025

Email: jmorr119@jhu.edu

Submitted for the consideration of the SGA Judiciary Board on February 15th, 2025

  1. 1. Questions Presented

    1. Whether the Student Government Association’s (SGA) failure to maintain an up-to-date, publicly accessible mechanism for students to inspect the minutes and proceedings of SGA constitutes a violation of the SGA Constitution and Bylaws?
    2. Whether the Student Government Association’s current practice, in which Executive Cabinet, Class Programming Council, Senate Standing Legislative Committee, Committee on Student Elections, Judiciary Board, Policy Research & Development Commission (PRDC), Communications & Marketing Commission (CMC), and other SGA meetings are not accessible to the student body constitutes a violation of the SGA Constitution and Bylaws?
    3. Whether the Student Government Association’s failure to record votes on an individual basis constitutes a violation of the SGA Constitution and Bylaws?
  2. 2. Petition for Writ of Certiorari

Jackson Morris (“Petitioner”) is a student of the Class of 2025 at the Whiting School of Engineering. He was formerly a member of the 112th SGA, holding the elected position of Disability Caucus Senator and role of Senate Vice President until his resignation on September 27th, 2024. He respectfully petitions the SGA Judiciary Board (“Judiciary”) for a writ of certiorari to decide upon the constitutionality of several SGA practices that allegedly infringe on central rights afforded to WSE and KSAS undergraduates by the SGA Constitution regarding their knowledge of, and participation in, SGA’s minutes, meetings, and proceedings.

  1. 3. Jurisdiction

Under Article V § 2.2 of the SGA Constitution, the Judiciary Board is charged with interpreting the Constitution and Bylaws and serving as the “final avenue of appeal for all matters relating to the SGA.” Part III of the Rules of the Judiciary provides a procedure for filing a petition for a writ of certiorari by which a party may request the Judiciary to review a case. As of the submission of this petition, SGA has not established a lower tribunal or avenue of appeal empowered to interpret the Constitution and Bylaws. The petitioner had already asked the Judiciary for an advisory opinion (a request which was granted) and, despite having conveyed the opinion to the Executive and Legislative Branches of SGA and implored them to adhere to it, the actions of the Executive and Legislative Branches remain unchanged and allegedly in violation of the SGA Constitution and Bylaws. Accordingly, the Judiciary should exercise original jurisdiction over this case.

  1. 4. Table of Authorities

SGA Constitution

Article I § 3 7, 13

Article II § 3 8

Article III § 1 8,18,19

Article III § 1.2.b 15

Article III § 1.4 8

Article IV § 4 7

Article IV § 5.1 15

Article V § 2.2 4

Article V § 4.1.1 13

Bylaws of the Senate

Article III § 2.1.3.2 8

Article III § 2.1.3.2.1 8

Article III § 2.1.3.3.1.7 15

Article III § 2.1.3.3.2 8, 11, 20

Article III § 2.1.3.4 8

Article III § 2.1.5.3 8, 11

Article III § 2.1.5.4 9, 11, 21

Article III § 3.2.1.5 11

Article IV § 1.2.4.6.3.4 16, 24

Article IV § 1.2.5.1 13

Article IV § 1.2.5.5 14

Article IV § 1.2.5.5.1 15

Article IV § 1.3.2.1.2.6 11

Article IV § 1.4.2.4.4 16, 24

Article IV § 3.1.3.5.4 15

Article IV § 3.3.5.1 9, 12

Article IV § 4.1.4.2.6.2.2 16, 24

Article IV § 4.3.3.5.1 11

Article V § 3.1.4 11

Article VI § 4.1.1.2 11

  1. 5. Statement of the Case

A precursor to this Writ of Certiorari was first presented by the petitioner to the Judiciary on August 9th, 2024. As the Judiciary was shorthanded at the time (two vacancies existed), the petitioner acceded to the Chief Justice’s request to hold off on filing a Writ of Certiorari in favor of receiving na on-binding advisory opinion. On August 25th, the Chief Justice returned an advisory opinion on behalf of the Judiciary to the petitioner.

The petitioner’s correspondence with the Judiciary is attached (Appendix 1). The same day, the petitioner forwarded the Judiciary’s advisory opinion (Appendix 2) to Student Body President Stone Meng; Student Body Vice President Amy Li; Student Body Secretary Buse Koldas; Student Body Treasurer Brandon Benjamin; Chair of Programming Timothy Huang; President of the Senate Nasreen Naqvi; Interim Director of LEED Charles Norman; SGA’s Advisor Jessica Snell; and all Senate Standing Legislative Committee chairs as of that date (Oluwakemi Abiodun, Tarini Basireddy, Srigouri Oruganty, Daarian Rouhani, Omotara Tiamiyu, Shruti Tyagi, Angela Xiong). On August 27th, the petitioner sent a curated document (Appendix 3) including both the petitioner’s questions and Judiciary’s response in the 112th SGA’s Teams group in a channel visible to all Senators.

Despite the August 25th advisory opinion being widely shared and thus available to SGA members, the advisory opinion did not change the behavior of SGA leadership. On September 1st, the petitioner reminded all Executive Branch members and Senate committee chairs of their responsibilities under the SGA Constitution (Appendix 4) (Since the message was sent, the petitioner has changed his viewpoint on allowing the Student Organizations and Finance Committees to have closed votes). The petitioner explicitly noted that meetings held by Executive Branch members and Senate committee chairs “need to be open to the public and record public minutes and votes by member as of the Judiciary’s recent advisory opinion.”

The petitioner resigned from SGA on September 27th. Soon thereafter, the petitioner was removed from the 112th SGA Teams channel and SGA Google Drive. As a result, the petitioner is no longer able to access any of the minutes or proceedings of SGA not directly available from SGA’s website. They continue to be unable to view the meeting times and meeting places of SGA’s subsidiary bodies. They continue to be unable to view how their elected representatives chose to vote on matters before the Senate. Since the petitioner left SGA, SGA has not rectified the alleged constitutional violations raised in the advisory opinion. A subset of the alleged violations raised in the advisory opinion have been presented in this petition as questions for the formal consideration of the Judiciary. Each question will be presented in full.

Question 1: Constitutional Background

The SGA Constitution is unambiguous about the right for all students to inspect the minutes and proceedings of SGA. Article I § 3 states: “Students have a right to attend all meetings of the SGA, and all minutes and proceedings of the SGA shall be open to student inspection, except those deemed secure by a closed session motion by the Senate.” This right is one of only four provided for under Article I, the SGA Bill of Rights. The special placement of this clause within the Constitution underscores its importance to a transparent and accountable student government. As the clause explicitly provides for an exception, it is reasonable to infer that all restrictions that do not adhere to the closed session exception are unconstitutional or, at the very least, subject to strict scrutiny and avoided when possible. Furthermore, Article IV § 4 states: “All documents, minutes, and proceedings of the Senate shall be open to the public for inspection, except those from closed meetings.” These clauses lay a constitutional framework for the right for students to access the minutes, proceedings, and even documents generated by SGA, so long as they do not originate from a legitimate closed meeting.

The Bylaws of the Senate (“Bylaws”) are empowered under Article II § 3 of the Constitution to “govern SGA.” Thus, all regulations duly passed by the Senate and not found to conflict with the Constitution are enforceable by the Judicial Branch should members of SGA neglect or act in defiance of the duties prescribed therein.

The Student Body Secretary (“Secretary”) is the “primary recordkeeper for SGA,” (Bylaws Article III § 2.1.3.2) and must “[store] all of SGA’s digital records for protection in a secondary technological archive at the end of every year,” (Bylaws Article III § 2.1.3.2.1) as well as upload to the SGA website (sga.jhu.edu) notice of whenever minutes are not sent to the Secretary within a week (Bylaws Article III § 2.1.3.3.2). In addition, the Secretary is tasked to “[create] and [maintain] internal SGA infrastructure” (Bylaws Article III § 2.1.3.4), which should be interpreted to include, at minimum, SGA’s attendance records, official roster of members, and file management system.

The Director of Communications (“Director”) is an official role in the President’s Cabinet stipulated by the Constitution (Article III § 1.4) and the Bylaws (Bylaws Article III § 3.2.1.5). It is not an optional position that may electively be filled at the discretion of the President, as the end of Article III § 1 of the Constitution states: “The Student Body President shall appoint the Director of Social Affairs [former title of the Director of Communications].” If a Director is discharged from duty or none exist, their responsibilities fall to the Student Body President (“President”) or their delegee based on Article III § 1 of the Constitution: “The Student Body President shall… faithfully execute acts of the Senate.” This includes responsibilities mandated by the Bylaws, which themselves are an act duly passed by the Senate.

The Director is charged with presenting all “records provided by the Secretary and meeting chairs to the public in an online format that is accessible in less than 2 clicks from the SGA website homepage or 4 clicks from the SGA’s social media pages,” (Bylaws Article III § 2.1.5.3). They also must upload all SGA documents into the “public space” that were deliberated in the “public sphere” (which is all meetings except for closed meetings) including, but not limited to, legislation, minutes, and working documents within a week of receipt from the Secretary (Bylaws Article III § 2.1.5.4). Finally, the Bylaws mandate that “All SGA members’ attendance records shall be noted on the SGA’s website and shall be sent to the student body in a press release every semester,” (Bylaws Article IV § 3.3.5.1) a duty which does not have an explicit designee but can be assumed to be a joint responsibility of the Secretary and Director.

In their August 25th non-binding advisory opinion, the Judiciary stated the following: “…the role of the judiciary in the current SGA Constitution is to act as an appeals court; therefore, would [sic] the Judiciary feels it would be overstepping its boundaries to dictate to the Senate how to provide public access to meetings, minutes, and recorded votes that would allow SGA to satisfy the aforementioned clauses of the Constitution and Bylaws. Thus, the Judiciary can rule on whether we would adjudge SGA processes to meet the aforementioned clauses of the Constitution and Bylaws but not dictate HOW to achieve them. However, due to this being an advisory opinion, the Judiciary would recommend that SGA bodies post minutes, GBM meeting summaries, and Executive Cabinet/Class Programming Council Executive Team meeting summaries in a timely manner to the public SGA website (in addition to all other SGA internal meetings).”

It is true that the Judiciary acts as an appeals court and cannot dictate how SGA must pursue open-ended values such as “providing public access.” However, as demonstrated in this section, the Bylaws unambiguously mandate specific duties to the Secretary and Director in service of providing public access. The fact of whether the Bylaws are being faithfully executed, as well as whether actions (or inactions) by members of SGA run contrary to the SGA Constitution are both matters than can be ruled on by the Judiciary.

Question 1: Harms Suffered

Since the petitioner left SGA, his and the rest of the student body’s constitutionally enshrined rights as Homewood undergraduate students to freely inspect the minutes and proceedings of SGA have been summarily denied by the negligence of the Executive Branch and failure of the Legislative Branch to hold negligent members accountable. Despite having conveyed these concerns to each elected Executive Branch member and Senate committee chair on August 25th 2024 and again on September 1st 2025, this breach of rights has not been fixed since.

The SGA website communicates little about the operations of SGA and is littered with out-of-date information. The website lists Shruti Tyagi as the Chair of Student Organizations despite Ms. Tyagi resigning in Fall 2024 (Appendix 5). The SGA guiding documents — which can only be accessed via sga.jhu.edu for those not in SGA and thus exclusively contains important information about their rights with regards to SGA and the responsibilities of their representatives — are woefully out-of-date. The displayed version of the Constitution says that it was last ratified on April 11th, 2023 despite being titled “JHU SGA Constitution November 2023,” (Appendix 6) and the Constitution does not reflect the “Constitutional Attendance Amendment of 2024” which was duly passed by the Senate on September 17th, 2024 (Appendix 7). In addition, the Rules of the Judiciary document (used to file writs of certiorari) is not present and must be requested from the Judiciary themselves. Thus, the petitioner and the rest of the student body do not have access to credible information about their representatives and the rules they are bound by. These infringements create confusion over who to contact; delays in information reaching the proper person; an inability to hold members violating the guiding documents accountable; and dissatisfaction with SGA.

The website does not host the minutes from any SGA meeting, which falls short of the Bylaws’ requirement of hosting the minutes from all non-closed meetings by SGA bodies. While the SGA Instagram has a linktree that leads to a drive with the minutes of several general body meetings (GBMs) [see appendix], it is incomplete). Additionally, while resolutions and other documents can be sent through the SGA Campus Groups email, using this form of distribution alone is not compliant with the definition used in Bylaws Article III § 2.1.5.3, which indicates that such records must be linked to the website or SGA social media.

The website also fails to list the meeting times and places for all meetings of SGA committees and bodies besides GBMs, effectively making these meetings de facto closed to non-SGA members. The full extent of this practice as a constitutional violation will be investigated in Question 2. The website does not include any of the disclosures or pages required by Bylaws Article III § 2.1.3.3.2, Bylaws Article III § 2.1.5.4, Bylaws Article III § 3.2.1.5, Bylaws Article IV § 3.3.5.1, Bylaws Article IV § 1.3.2.1.2.6 (all Caucuses need to have a page on the SGA website), Bylaws Article V § 3.1.4 (information regarding accommodations requests for SGA events), and Bylaws Article VI § 4.1.1.2 (sufficient information regarding SGA’s application processes). All disclosures listed above were enshrined in the Bylaws for the sake of transparency with, or responsibility to, the students SGA represents; the petitioner and the rest of the non-SGA student body lack crucial information from SGA meetings to decide if their representatives are truly petitioning for their interests in meetings with administrators or rolling over at the first sign of adversity. They deserve access to this information, and the deprivation at present hampers the ability of those who want to inspect the conduct of incumbent members before voting for them to make informed votes in student elections.

Additionally, the website does not have a roster of all SGA members (i.e. including members of commissions) and SGA’s delegates to University advisory committees; it only includes the names and emails of Judicial Branch, Executive Branch cabinet members, programming members, and Legislative Branch members. This is a violation of access to SGA’s proceedings, which includes the appointment to and confirmation of members to all roles in SGA and beyond the body in service to the University. If the petitioner or another student was interested in getting in touch with the SGA representative to the Cross-institutional Student Advisory Committee, for instance, they would not know who to contact. It could be possible for SGA to have no representative to this body for months at a time without the public knowing.

The website’s lone attempt at informing the public of its activities is the 2024-2025 SGA Initiative Tracksheet. As of February 8th, 2025, most listed initiatives are from the 111th SGA and many of the members involved are no longer in SGA. There are only seven “prospective initiatives”, and none appear to have been updated after September 2024 (Appendix 8). The petitioner and the rest of the student body cannot see who is working on specific initiatives within SGA and may automatically assign credit for completing them to the members of SGA who disseminate information about these initiatives by posting about them on their social media. This, combined with the lack of any provided minutes whatsoever, makes it impossible for an independent observer to decide whether results advertised by SGA members running for re-election are really because of their efforts or were on their path to being implemented by the University anyways without their input.

The Secretary, as the primary recordkeeper for SGA, is charged with ensuring that an accurate record of attendance exists for all bodies of SGA and partnering with the Director or the Executive Branch member who has been delegated their duties to upload those attendance records to the SGA website. Despite such a document existing, it is not shared with the public, in violation of Bylaws Article IV § 3.3.5.1 Furthermore, it has been haphazardly updated and brings about additional problems (Appendix 9). As of February 8th, 2025, attendance records do not extend beyond September 23rd for the Executive Branch; October 15th for the Finance Committee; September 29th for the Student Services Committee; September 12th for the Internal Affairs Committee; November 9th for the Programming Committee; September 15th for the Civic Engagement Committee; and impermissible gaps of more than two weeks between meetings outside of breaks (Bylaws Article IV § 1.2.5.1) for the Student Organizations Committee and the Academic Affairs Committee. There are no attendance records for the Judiciary, CSE, Class Programming Councils, PRDC, or CMC. Only the attendance records for the General Body Meetings and Health, Safety, and Sustainability Committee are compliant. Furthermore, if the records available are accurate, last semester several members of SGA were required to have been removed from the body under Article V § 4.1.1 as they accumulated 4 unexcused absences in a semester. As a new semester has begun and attendance has been reset, it would be counterproductive and constitutionally nebulous to enforce those removals now; however, it is a severe dereliction of duty by both the Secretary and Executive Branch. The petitioner and the rest of the student body deserve to know if their representatives are, at a bare minimum, attending the meetings they are obligated to attend on account of their position (notwithstanding ad hoc meetings with administrators or other groups outside of SGA). Failure to publicize this information violates the Bylaws, the spirit of the Constitution, and leaves students uniformed as to their representatives’ conduct when voting for the re-election of members.

Question 2: Constitutional Background

The SGA Constitution is equally unambiguous about the right for all students to attend all meetings of SGA. Article I § 3 states: “Students have a right to attend all meetings of the SGA … except those deemed secure by a closed session motion by the Senate.” However, SGA does not publicize the meeting places or times of Executive Cabinet, Class Programming Council, Senate Standing Legislative Committee, Committee on Student Elections, Judiciary Board, Policy Research & Development Commission (PRDC), Communications & Marketing Commission (CMC), or any SGA meetings besides GBMs. There is no public calendar with this information to which a non-SGA member could subscribe. This practice de facto closes all non-GBM meetings to all non-SGA students. This practice, specifically by Standing Legislative Committees, is in contrast with Bylaws Article IV § 1.2.5.5, which recognizes the previously articulated Constitutional concept: “In accordance with the Constitution, any student is welcome to observe any committee meetings.”

In their August 25th non-binding advisory opinion, the Judiciary came to the following conclusion: “…due to Article 1, Section 3 in the JHU SGA Constitution, in the opinion of the Judiciary, students have a right to attend all SGA meetings, including Executive Cabinet/Class Programming Council Executive Team meetings, due to the diction of ‘Students have a right to attend all meetings of the SGA.’ In lieu of this, all minutes and proceedings of the SGA should be open to student inspection. This also applies to Judiciary and CSE meetings.”

Question 2: Harms Suffered

The petitioner and all Homewood undergraduate students have a right to attend any and all SGA meetings not legitimately closed in a manner compliant with the Constitution. By failing to publicize the information necessary for attending non-GBM SGA meetings, and therefore implicitly barring students from attending, for instance, Executive Cabinet meetings, SGA fails to uphold its promise to the students it represents of full transparency and accessibility. This, combined with the lack of published minutes from these meetings, leads to the petitioner and other members of the student body being unable to freely provide input on matters important to them when under consideration by a body of SGA and impairs their ability to make fully informed voting decisions if they would like to consider how the representative up for re-election performed in meetings besides GBMs in the previous term. It also impairs the ability of students who are not in SGA — but wish to be — to observe the processes of SGA or serve as non-voting members of committees on behalf of their student organization or cause.

Question 3: Constitutional Background

SGA’s Constitution makes clear that all votes must be public: “The Senate, in the spirit of open meetings, shall keep all votes public and shall only enter Closed Session to deliberate upon Impeachment and other sensitive matters deemed necessary by the Senate,” (Article IV § 5.1). In addition, it is a principal duty of the Secretary to see that this is done: “[The Secretary] shall keep detailed minutes of each meeting and shall take a roll call of attendance and votes,” (Article III § 1.2.b). These clauses direct the Secretary to record all votes (meaning the number of members for, against, abstaining, or absent from voting) and, since voting is “public” and at the level of roll call, voting should be recorded by name of the Senator. This transparency measure exists in the SGA Constitution for three reasons. First, it forces Senators to be confident enough in their vote that they are willing to go on record with their decision on a matter before the Senate. Second, if constituents are unhappy with the way that their Senator votes, they may respectfully confront them about the decision, exercise their right to petition for the Senator’s removal, or vote against them in the next election. Finally, it prevents tampering with the vote total.

In the Bylaws, more detail is given: “All votes made during the meeting, and, if possible via roll call or electronic voting, each senator’s vote will be recorded,” (Bylaws Article III § 2.1.3.3.1.7). A similar sentiment exists in Bylaws Article IV § 3.1.3.5.4. The quoted clause is under the subsection of Article III that directs the Secretary’s tasks. Thus, it is the responsibility of the Secretary to see to it that these votes are recorded by name and published. The Bylaws also specify the responsibilities of Standing Legislative Committees: “Committees may, in accordance with the Constitution, close meetings to discuss sensitive personnel matters by a two-thirds vote of the committee. However, all voting must take place in public with individual votes recorded as prescribed by Senate rules and legislation,” (Bylaws Article IV § 1.2.5.5.1). These clauses, in sum, prescribe that all votes are recorded publicly, save for those explicitly allocated a secret ballot vote by the Constitution. It is extremely probable that the secret votes provided for in Bylaws Article IV § 1.2.4.6.3.4 (chair removal vote), Bylaws Article IV § 1.4.2.4.4 (RSO representative vote), Bylaws Article IV § 4.1.4.2.6.2.2 (class president vote) are unconstitutional and the identified clauses should be deemed null and void.

In their August 9th non-binding advisory opinion, the Judiciary came to the following conclusion: “… due to Article 4, section 1.2.5.5.1 and Article 4, section 3.1.3.5.4 of the JHU SGA Bylaws, voting should be recorded on an individual basis, even when it occurs on a public matter.”

Question 3: Harms Suffered

The petitioner and all Homewood undergraduate students suffer from SGA’s negligence in recording votes. Students have a right to inspect the voting record of each member in SGA. Without such a measure, all votes are de facto closed. Senators can freely vote on matters in which they have a conflict-of-interest without having to justify their participation in the vote. Senators can vote for or against a matter and then misrepresent the way they voted to their constituents or other members of SGA. The counting party can freely manipulate the vote count in their favor. The Secretary’s negligence in recording votes by name and vote count has a rippling effect as the public vote is erased forever and impairs all future inspection by petitioner and all students at Johns Hopkins, including students who may want to inspect SGA minutes for archival research through the Sheridan Libraries in the future.

This negligence can be seen in the most recent GBM minutes uploaded (Appendix 10) in which there were multiple contested votes on new Senators and all votes were merely recorded as “[Senator’s name] was elected.” While it can be difficult to stomach a public vote on a student’s appointment, and Senators should take care to be as professional as possible, the student is being confirmed to an elected position in lieu of being duly elected by the entire student body; thus, students (including the students being considered for appointment, who have a substantial stake in there being a fair voting process) deserve to see how their elected representatives voted on an appointment, and, regardless, the Constitution does not provide a mechanism by which this vote can be closed. The same is true of the votes within the same meeting to confirm the Senior Class Programming Council, the vote to refer the SARU Funding Bill to the Finance Committee, the vote on the Lighting of the Quads tabling, the vote to approve the November Tabling, and the vote to approve the Leadership Workshop 2. Even unanimous votes need a vote count (ex. 45-0-0 for-against-abstain), as if a member leaves the room during a vote or otherwise abstains it is considered a different vote total than a unanimous one, and an individual who frequently refrains from voting on matters or is absent when voting may have that be held against them in the next round of elections.

This practice affects more than GBMs — the decisions of the SGA Finance Committee and SGA Student Organizations Committee have a direct impact on undergraduate students and the organizations they participate in. At present, the petitioner and other students who submit semesterly allocation requests and other grants, or, alternatively, submit documentation for re-registration or new student organization registration, do not receive notice of the official vote tally with names attached to the votes of each member of the respective committee for or against their request. This provides students with little recourse or evidence if they believe that a member with a conflict of interest has voted on their request or if they believe that another organization has been treated preferentially compared to theirs. Votes and decisions made by the Committee on Student Organizations and Finance Committee are not visible to anyone except the organizations themselves, decreasing public visibility of SGA’s proceedings and increasing the likelihood for preferential treatment of organizations that student government members are part of. By avoiding this powerful method of transparency which the Constitution mandates, SGA has impaired the public from scrutinizing their votes and damaging the public trust placed in the body.

IN SUM

The practices of SGA described above cause continuing harm to the petitioner and the student body. The Constitution succinctly enshrines the right of students to inspect the minutes and proceedings of SGA, and the Bylaws of the Senate establish an unambiguous practice of uploading these documents “into public space” — a practice that requires little effort on SGA’s part but is necessary for students to have any visibility into the affairs of SGA. The Constitution promises public access to all SGA meetings to promote accountability and transparency. The Constitution requires public votes; the Bylaws expound on this mandate and require that “…if possible via electronic voting or roll call or electronic voting, each senator’s vote will be recorded,” which is a simple request to satisfy for a body that has promoted its use of the iClicker software for recording votes. This right has been summarily trampled on when, in the minutes for an entire general body meeting, not one vote total or voter name is recorded.

In each of the matters above, SGA has callously disregarded its Constitution and Bylaws and has refused to change when confronted with the unconstitutional nature of these practices. In particular, the Executive Branch has not upheld their duty exercise executive power, failing to manage the “day-to-day affairs of the SGA and [carry] out the instructions of the Senate,” (Article III § 1). The Student Body Secretary has failed to complete multiple crucial tasks required of their position and the Student Body President has presided over an administration that has made no progress in sixth months on a constitutional problem that the Executive Branch has been aware of since the beginning of the term. If the website is to be believed, there is no mention of a Director of Communications in the President’s Cabinet; implying that the President has neglected to appoint a Director as is their duty under Article III § 1.

The continued operation of SGA in defiance of its guiding documents promises imminent future harm. With so much information regarding their representatives’ performance being withheld from members of the student body (attendance, meeting minutes, votes, etc.), student voters cannot determine whether an SGA member’s claims of active and impactful involvement are true. Given that the Committee on Student Elections (CSE) prevents candidates from “attacking, in any capacity, any other candidate,” (CSE Constitution Article IV Section 6.3) SGA candidates in contested races have an incentive to take credit for popular actions by the body even if they played little to no role in bringing about that outcome as these claims cannot easily be challenged by other candidates, and cannot be evaluated by student voters.

  1. 6. Proposed Remedies

Should the Judiciary decide in favor of the petitioner on Question 1, the following remedies are proposed:

  1. If the position of Director of Communications is vacant, the Student Body President shall immediately start a search process for a Director of Communications and shall report to the Senate at a GBM with their nomination within two weeks of this decision.
  2. The Secretary or Director shall immediately post a link to the SGA Google Drive to either the SGA website (sga.jhu.edu) or a website accessible to anyone with a JHED; all documents that were not created during a legitimately closed session will remain public and accessible in the Drive. While this case is in deliberation, no documents should be deleted from the Drive without the unanimous approval of the Judiciary.
  3. The Secretary or Director shall immediately post a link to the SGA attendance records on the SGA website and shall include this link prominently in their next student body-wide email in order to satisfy the requirement for a press release containing the attendance records every semester. The Secretary shall make every effort to retrieve the missing attendance records listed in Question 1: Harms Suffered in order to preserve them for posterity. While this case is in deliberation, the petitioner should be alerted to any change to the existing attendance records.
  4. Within two weeks of the decision, all documents, minutes, and proceedings generated during the 2024-2025 session of SGA (including but not limited to: all GBMs, committee meetings, administrator meetings, banquets, and other events) shall be made either directly accessible from the website or available on a shared drive (such as Microsoft OneDrive or Google Drive) that shall be maintained in perpetuity by the Secretary and successor Secretaries. Furthermore, the Secretary shall observe the mandate placed on them by Bylaws Article III § 2.1.3.3.2 with special attention for the remainder of their term.
  5. Within a week of the decision, the Director will ensure that all records provided by the Secretary and meeting chairs are available in an online format accessible in less than 2 clicks from the SGA website homepage or 4 clicks from SGA’s social media pages. Furthermore, the Director shall observe the mandate placed on them by Bylaws Article III § 2.1.5.4 with special attention for the remainder of their term.
  6. Within a week of the decision, the Executive Branch shall update all guiding documents available on the SGA website to reflect all amendments passed in this session and any other missing amendments. The Rules of the Judiciary shall be uploaded to the SGA website by the Secretary or Director.
  7. Within a week of the decision, all legislation that has been considered by SGA in the current (112th) session shall be finalized (dated, labeled, with the vote count, and signed; or, if failed, unsigned) and uploaded to the SGA website by the Secretary or Director. Within two weeks of the decision, all legislation in effect that has been passed by SGA (including all resolutions, bills, and guiding document amendments) in the last 4 years shall be finalized and uploaded to the SGA website by the Secretary or Director. Within a month of the decision, all past legislation that has been considered by SGA that can be found including all resolutions, bills, and guiding document amendments) shall be finalized and uploaded to the SGA website by the Secretary or Director.
  8. Within two weeks of the decision, Senate leadership and the Executive Branch shall compile a list of all SGA members and SGA’s delegates to University advisory committees, including non-SGA members nominated by SGA to serve on those bodies. This list shall be hosted on the SGA website.
  9. The Internal Affairs (“IA”) committee will, at every IA meeting for the remainder of the semester, inspect whether the tasks above have been completed. Specifically, IA will mark whether all attendance records have been entered up until the beginning of the previous week and mark whether all minutes from all meetings have been entered up until the beginning of the previous week. If any task has not been completed by the deadline, they will initiate disciplinary procedures proportional with the severity of the violation.
    1. To reduce the burden on the Secretary, within a week of the decision IA will compile a list of all meetings (GBM, Cabinet, committee, Judiciary, CSE, PRDC, CMC, programming, administrator) and events that occurred during the 112th session. This list, broken down by the meeting body and organized in chronological order, will be uploaded to the SGA website and have a link to the minutes from that meeting or description of the event.
  10. The President and Vice President of the Senate shall ensure each week for the remainder of the term that IA has performed the tasks above, and will provide an update at SGA’s GBM.
  11. The Executive Branch shall issue an apology to the student body that details the extent of the negligence described in this section and takes accountability for their actions or lack thereof, as well as the measures they are taking to remedy the violations. They shall also detail any accountability measures that are being undertaken as a result of the decision.

Should the Judiciary decide in favor of the petitioner on Question 2, the following remedies are proposed:

  1. The Secretary or Director shall, within a week, update the SGA website to include an embedded calendar or an alternative method with the location, meeting date and time, and any pre-written agenda for all Executive Cabinet, Class Programming Council, Senate Standing Legislative Committee, Committee on Student Elections, Judiciary Board, Policy Research & Development Commission (PRDC), Communications & Marketing Commission (CMC), and any other SGA body’s meetings that are not legitimately closed meetings. There shall exist some measure (ex. Teams) by which non-SGA members can receive updates about meetings so that they will be informed in case of a cancellation or change of date, time, location, meeting subject, or modality.
  2. All closed meetings (for any duration during the meeting) will have an accompanying justification that details why the meeting must be closed, as well as the vote taken to close the meeting. All closed meetings without a justification or vote satisfying Constitutional requirements will be deemed unconstitutional and automatically opened to the public.
  3. The Student Body President shall immediately draft an email to the student body that clearly explains the right of students to attend all SGA meetings and the responsibilities of the Legislative Branch, Executive Branch, and Judicial Branch in making information related to the location and format of all meetings public.

Should the Judiciary decide in favor of the petitioner on Question 3, the following remedies are proposed:

  1. The Secretary, for the rest of the term, will record votes to the specification of the Judiciary and shall include a note to their successor with instructions for proper vote recording. The Secretary shall immediately issue guidance to all SGA Standing Legislative Committees to the specification of the Judiciary.
  2. The Secretary will include a note next to all votes from this session that were improperly recorded (ex. the votes in Appendix 10) that denotes the vote as being improperly recorded. These votes, where possible, may be revisited with a majority vote of the Senate.
  3. The Secretary will add a strikethrough to Bylaws Article IV § 1.2.4.6.3.4, Bylaws Article IV § 1.4.2.4.4, and Bylaws Article IV § 4.1.4.2.6.2.2, and indicate that these sections are null and void.
  4. The Internal Affairs committee (“IA”) will, at every IA meeting for the remainder of the semester, inspect whether the tasks above have been completed. Specifically, IA will mark whether votes in the minutes for all GBM and Standing Legislative Committee meetings are public, include final vote tallies, and include Senator names if the vote was not unanimous. If any task has not been completed by the deadline, they will initiate disciplinary procedures proportional with the severity of the violation.
  5. The President and Vice President of the Senate shall ensure each week for the remainder of the term that IA has performed the task above, and will provide an update at SGA’s GBM.
  6. The Executive Branch shall issue an apology to the student body that details the extent of the negligence described in this section and takes accountability for their actions or lack thereof, as well as the measures they are taking to remedy the violations. They shall also detail any accountability measures that are being undertaken as a result of the decision.

If the offices of Director or Secretary are vacant, their duties will fall to the Student Body President who may delegate duties to another Executive Branch member. Any delegation of duties will be reported to the President of the Senate, Vice President of the Senate, and IA.

No part of the lists above shall be construed to infringe on the sole discretion of the Judiciary to determine fair remedies to the questions raised by this writ.

  1. 7. Conclusion

At present, the Johns Hopkins Student Government Association engages in a serious of practices that betray the trust of the student body: SGA fails to maintain an up-to-date, publicly accessible mechanism for students to inspect the minutes and proceedings of SGA; Executive Cabinet, Class Programming Council, Senate Standing Legislative Committee, Committee on Student Elections, Judiciary Board, Policy Research & Development Commission (PRDC), Communications & Marketing Commission (CMC), and other SGA meetings are not accessible to the student body; and SGA fails to record votes on an individual basis. In the absence of these transparency measures, SGA has been able to hide other violations of its guiding documents such as member truancy and committee meeting frequency. These unconstitutional practices must end.

The petitioner hopes that the parties involved will voluntarily implement the remedies provided; however, if not, the petitioner hopes that other interested parties, including sympathetic members of SGA, student organizations, and other concerned students, will consider filing an Amicus Curiae Brief in support of this writ.

  1. 8. Appendix

A permanent public link to all appendix documents is included here: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1b6wuyh5Udsiea8ohNJzJwUAfLrXgmsZZ?usp=sharing

Appendix 1: No notes.

Appendix 2: No notes.

Appendix 3: Shared in the SGA 2024-2025/112th Senate Teams.

Appendix 4: Shared in Exec + Committee Chairs Meeting group chat.

Appendix 5: Screen capture of sga.jhu.edu on February 9th, 2025.

Appendix 6: Downloaded from sga.jhu.edu on February 9th, 2025.

Appendix 7: No notes.

Appendix 8: Downloaded from sga.jhu.edu on February 8th, 2025

Appendix 9: Copied from original document on February 8th, 2025

Appendix 10: Downloaded from https://linktr.ee/jhu_sga -> Meeting Minutes on February 9th, 2025