JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

SGA Commencement 2015

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

From: Jill Williams <jillwilliams@jhu.edu>Subject: Undergrad indoor line-upDate: May 20, 2015 9:28 AMTo: Janet Kirsch <jkirsch@jhu.edu>, destinybailey8460@gmail.com, Janice Bonsu <jbonsu1@jhu.edu>, Nick Uebele <nuebele1@jhu.edu>, Gus Sentementes <[unclear: email address]@jhu.edu>Cc: Krystle Ongoco <kongoco1@jhu.edu>, Dan Luperchio <dal@jhu.edu>, Dennis O'Shea <droic@jhu.edu>, Ian Bottiglieri (ibottiglieri@featsinc.com) ibottiglieri@featsinc.com, Kimberly Willis <kwillis@jhu.edu>, Kirsten Lavin <klavin@jhu.edu>, Daniel Trahey (danieltrahey@gmail.com) danieltrahey@gmail.com, Brittany Claridge <bclaridge@jhu.edu>, Laura Sauveterre <lsavett1@jhu.edu>, Judy Fusting <jfusting@jhu.edu>, Gail Raupach <[unclear: email address]@jhu.edu>, Mary Ellen Flaherty <mflaherty@jhu.edu>, Stephanie White <swhite67@jhu.edu>, Jennifer McKay <jmckay6@jhu.edu>, Jill Williams <jillwilliams@jhu.edu>

All-

I have attached the undergraduate Keyser Quad line-up—we are still planning to follow the normal line-up and normal schedule.

However, it looks like there is a possibility of rain tomorrow (hopefully that will change!). If it is raining tomorrow morning, we might announce that we are changing the Keyser line-up for the undergrads to an INDOOR LINE-UP. This is NOT the indoor ceremony—if we announce that undergrad line-up is moving from the quad to the below indoor locations, the ceremony will proceed as scheduled. We are simply keeping the candidates dry during line-up.

We will announce this information by 6am (go here to the green bar at the top: https://www.jhu.edu/). In the past, making this change has caused confusion so I wanted all of you to be looped in and anything you can do to help promote correct information (if we announce we are doing it) would be greatly appreciated.

In the event of rain, all Marshals and students should report to the rooms below according to Section number:

  • Mudd Lobby Band, Banner Carriers, On Stage Candidates
  • Mudd 100 Keyser Sections 1, 2
  • Mudd Atrium Keyser Sections 3, 4
  • Mudd 26 Keyser Sections 5, 6
  • Remsen 101 Keyser Sections 7, 8
  • Remsen 1 Keyser Sections 9, 10, 11, 12
  • Jenkins Hall First Floor Hallway Keyser Section 13
  • Mergenthaler 111 Keyser Sections 14, 15
  • Gilman Tunnel Keyser Sections 16, 17, 18

Please let me know if you have any questions.

Thank you!Jill

Jill M. WilliamsAssociate Director of University EventsJohns Hopkins UniversitySan Martin Center / 3400 N. Charles St.Baltimore, MD 21218(P) 410.516.7131(F) 410.516.0424

Commencement 2015

Student Wrangling

  • Get the Class of 2015 banner before Thursday.
  • I am assuming you are still having the Barton Cup winner process with the banner.
  • By 8:10 a.m. please have the Barton Cup winner, the 7 senior council members and the 2 class gift chairs (Janice Bonsu and Michelle Edelson) on Keyser Quad between [unclear: Reimsen] and MSE.
  • The procession will leave Keyser at 8:25. The students will follow the band.
  • At the steps outside Homewood Field please grab the banner. The Barton Cup winner needs to be put into the line-up in her correct location so the Registrar’s staff will work with you on that.
  • You will need to get the 9 students who are sitting on stage into the Cordish Lacrosse Building.
  • Have the students check in on the 1st floor of Cordish to get their line-up card
  • Pay attention to the PR photos being taken. Michelle McLaughlin will be coordinating that.
  • By 8:55-everyone in Cordish should be lined up for the procession on to the field.

Commencement 2015

Inclement Weather Information for Internal Faculty and Staff

  • Please do not come to campus during the delay. We encourage you to stay at your hotel or your student’s apartment, or go to breakfast.

Indoor Ceremony

  • Announcement to be made by 6 a.m.
  • KSAS and WSE bachelor candidates are each afforded two rain ceremony guest tickets. Tickets can be found at: http://web.jhu.edu/commencement/emergencyplan/
  • We cannot issue more than two guest rain tickets, but we will webcast the ceremonies so additional guests can view on their phone, computer, or tablet.
  • The ceremonies will be abbreviated and last approximately 45 minutes. And will follow the schedule below:

<table><thead><tr><th>School</th><th>Ceremony</th><th>Time</th><th>Location</th>

<th>Candidates Conferred (Divided by Major)</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td rowspan="3">KSASUndergraduates</td><td>Ceremony A</td><td>9:00 – 9:45</td><td>Shriver Hall</td><td>BA in Anthropology – East Asian Studies,BS in Molecular and Cellular Biology,BA/BS in NeuroscienceBA/BS in Physics</td></tr><tr><td>Ceremony B</td><td>10:50 – 11:35</td><td>Shriver Hall</td>

<td>BA in Economics – Political Science</td></tr><tr><td>Ceremony C</td><td>12:40 – 1:25</td><td>Shriver Hall</td>

<td>BA in Psychology – Writing Seminars</td></tr><tr><td rowspan="3">WSEUndergraduates</td><td>Ceremony 1</td><td>9:55 – 10:40</td><td>Hodson Hall</td><td>BA/BS in Biomedical Engineering, BS in Materials and Science and Engineering, BA in General Engineering</td></tr><tr><td>Ceremony 2</td><td>11:45 – 12:30</td><td>Hodson Hall</td><td>BA/BS in Applied Mathematics and Statistics, BS in Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, Environmental Engineering</td></tr><tr><td>Ceremony 3</td><td>1:35 – 2:20</td><td>Hodson Hall</td><td>BS in Civil Engineering, Computer Engineering, Electrical Engineering, Engineering Mechanics, Mechanical Engineering, BA/BS Computer Science</td></tr></tbody></table>

  • Degrees will be conferred but the graduates will not be called individually to cross the stage.
  • Due to fire code capacity, only candidates and ticketed guests will be allowed to enter the indoor ceremony sites.

Cancellation/Evacuation

  • If, at any point, the immediate forecast calls for dangerous conditions, we will cancel the ceremony and evacuate Homewood Field.
  • In the event of an evacuation, guests will be directed to the nearest exit.
  • If we evacuate, the remainder of the ceremony is cancelled. We will not reconvene, so if it is safe for you to do so, you can exit campus. If it is not safe, we will have shelter locations available until the danger has passed.

Visit the Commencement website, www.jhu.edu/commencement. If you have additional questions or concerns please email commencement@jhu.edu or call 410-516-7711. Thank you!

Commencement 2015

Inclement Weather Information for Internal Faculty and Staff

Options for staying informed about Commencement day

  • Visit the Commencement website: www.jhu.edu/commencement for updated information.
  • Download the Commencement app
    • iPhone and iPad users – search “JHU 2015” in the Apple App Store
    • Android users – search “JHU 2015” in the Google Play Store
    • Blackberry, Windows, laptop users – go to this address (omit www)https://jhu2015.gatherdigital.com
  • From the website, “Like” us on Facebook so you’ll be kept in the loop on announcements and changes.
  • Sign up for Commencement text alerts (this is separate from the JHU emergency text messaging system). After the initial “test text” that you will get when you sign up, there will only be a text sent if we are making major changes to the ceremony. You can sign up for text alerts by visiting: http://web.jhu.edu/commencement/emergencyplan/
  • If there are weather/safety concerns, we will announce any adjustment to our plan by 6 a.m. on May 21. No announcement will be made if we are proceeding as scheduled. You can receive the announcement through the JHU website: www.jhu.edu, the Commencement website www.jhu.edu/commencement, the emergency weather hotline: 410-516-7781 or 1-800-548-9004, or the Commencement text message system.

General weather notes

  • Every effort will be made to hold the ceremony as planned, rain or shine.
  • For your comfort, you are encouraged to dress for the weather.
  • If we proceed with the normal ceremony and conditions deteriorate, we may choose to abbreviate the ceremony and stop calling graduates across the stage so that we can conclude quickly and everyone can move to safety.

Alternate Weather Plans

  • If it is determined that proceeding with the ceremony as scheduled is not safe, we will announce one of the below plans.

Delay the start by two hours

  • Announcement to be made by 6 a.m.
  • The candidate lineup will move indoors to the O’Connor Recreation Center and will begin at 9:30 a.m. with a 10:40 a.m. ceremony start time on Homewood Field.
  • By 8:30 a.m., if conditions are still unsafe, we will either delay by another two hours or cancel the ceremony.
  • If the delayed ceremony can proceed, it will be a full ceremony, with all bachelor’s degree candidates called by name to cross the stage.
  • Please do not come to campus during the delay.

Delay the start by four hours

  • Announcement to be made by 6 a.m. (or 8:30 a.m. if we originally announced a two-hour delay).
  • The candidate lineup will move indoors to the Recreation Center and will begin at 11:30 a.m. with a 12:40 p.m. ceremony start time on Homewood Field.
  • If we get close to the lineup time and the conditions are still unsafe, we will cancel the ceremony.
  • If the delayed ceremony can proceed, it will be a full ceremony, with all bachelor’s degree candidates called by name to cross the stage.

Commencement & Graduation Committee MeetingWednesday, May 13, 2015

I. Introductions and Contact List Updates

II. Commencement Speaker and Honorary Degree Recipients

III. Logistics

  • Logistics team final review meeting following this meeting
  • Registrar’s Office, Wednesday and Friday ceremonies-please keep us updated on your set-up changes.
  • Streamers to close the ceremony again (even in a delay)
  • Events centered around graduation-please let our office know of any departmental receptions or other events.
  • Cheat Sheets
  • University Parkway (eastbound) will be closed on Thursday until 4pm
  • Shuttles to and from San Martin and to and from Reception
  • Ceremony Webcasting
  • Readers
    • Namecoach: https://www.name-coach.com/record/63988
      • New name pronunciation service that we are testing this year.
  • Trustees at other ceremonies:
    • Jay Lenow
      • PhD Hooding (Wed)
      • Nursing (Thurs)
      • Peabody (Thurs)
      • KSAS Masters (Fri)
    • David Yaffe
      • SOE (Wed)

IV. Emergency/Evacuation Plans

  • Please see all the inclement weather info on the commencement website.
  • Review document
  • Wed pm and Fri am
    • The same evacuation plan will be in place for your ceremony. Homewood Incident Command will be in the Press box and will take over if the weather seems threatening.
    • Dangerous weather, ceremony moved into the Robert Scott Gym.

V. Texting and Ticketing

  • You can sign up for text alerts now at: www.HUCommencementTickets.com
  • Homewood bachelors will be able to print their indoor ceremony tickets now.

VI. Communications

  • Registrar’s office sent their final update to candidates.
  • Download the app

VII. Social Media

  • 940 “likes” on Facebook (175 more than 2014)
  • “Who are you grateful to?” video contest through Facebook.
  • Social Media plans week/day of—@HUCommencement and #jhu2015

VIII. Feats Update-Barbara McCort

IX. Registrar’s Office-Gail Rauenzahn

X. Volunteers

XI. Other Ceremonies on Homewood Field:

A. School of Engineering-Joyce Richardson.B. PhD Hooding Ceremony-Sherri GreenC. School of Arts & Sciences, Advanced Academic Programs-Greg Martínez

XII. Additional Reports

The University wide Commencement Ceremony is on Thursday, May 21 at 8:40 a.m.

Tuesday, April 14, 2015 at 10:52:34 AM Eastern Daylight Time

Subject: RE: Commencement Seating for Class CouncilDate: Monday, April 13, 2015 at 9:16:17 AM Eastern Daylight TimeFrom: Jill WilliamsTo: Destiny BaileyCC: Robert Turning

Hi Destiny,

There are no tickets for general admission for the ceremony so seniors can have as many guests as they would like. The only reason this would not be the case is if we need to move indoors to the 6 45 minute ceremonies. We would only do this in the event of dangerous weather. If this happens then each senior only gets 2 tickets to their specific indoor ceremony. http://web.jhu.edu/commencement/emergencyplan

In early May, I will provide Rob Turning with 42 tickets in the special reserved seating section for the senior class council members to divide up (works out to be 6 per but some will likely have less and some will have more). That section is already at capacity this year so I cannot provide additional tickets. You all are certainly welcome to use fewer than 6 tickets each to accommodate more families (like the senior SGA exec board members). Janice will get tickets in this section because she is the co-chair of the senior class gift campaign-those will be separate from the ones that I will provide to Rob.

Let me know if you have other questions.

Best,Jill

From: Destiny Bailey [mailto:destinybailey8460@gmail.com]Sent: Sunday, April 12, 2015 10:16 PMTo: Jill WilliamsCc: sga-seniors@lists.johnshopkins.eduSubject: Commencement Seating for Class Council

Hi Ms. Williams,

How have you been? Momentum is really starting to build for Commencement and all of the awesome things that come along with it! I have a couple of questions in regards to seating:

  1. In general, does any senior student need to request or reserve seating for their family- no matter how many members are attending?
  2. Is there a special seating arrangement for the family of the Senior Class Council and Senior SGA Executive Board members?

Thank you so much and I hope you have an amazing week!

Sincerely,

Destiny

--

Destiny Bailey

Tuesday, April 14, 2015 at 10:52:25 AM Eastern Daylight Time

Subject: Commencement detailsDate: Thursday, March 12, 2015 at 2:11:06 PM Eastern Daylight TimeFrom: Jill WilliamsTo: 'destinybailey8460@gmail.com'CC: Janet Kirsch, Robert Turning, Jill Williams

Hi Destiny!

I have a couple of updates for you,

  1. I am expecting that we will be able to announce the commencement speaker the week after spring break. We are finalizing things now and then will work on a video message similar to the one we did last year for Susan. I am working with the communications office now and my hope is that you would be able to send out the video announcement to the seniors first, if you want to. It will be closely followed by me announcing it on commencement social media and then The Hub picking it up. Our goal is to roll this out on Monday the 23rd, but last year we ended up pushing it to Tuesday because there were a ton of other announcements that day. Let me know if you think this plan sounds good or if you have another suggestion.
  2. In the past, there has been a commencement breakfast that the senior council organized. If you’d like, I have arranged for that breakfast to be in the Gilman Atrium. That would give you all a little more room than what Homewood Museum can provide but still keep you close to the candidate line-up. Also, when I send the itinerary of events to the speaker-would you like me to include this breakfast on that?
  3. During the ceremony, you will get to speak. In addition to your remarks, you will co-present the alumni teaching awards and introduce the speaker—are you good with all of this? I attached Sean’s remarks from last year. I will draft the alumni teaching part but you will write your remarks and your intro of the speaker. Your speech needs to be 3 minutes or less. Your intro of the speaker should be about a minute—I will send you the speaker’s bio once the announcement has been made. I need to get your draft remarks and your speaker intro by Monday, May 4, please. I am happy to look over anything you are working on and give you feedback and suggestions or I can stay out of it until you get me a draft on May 4. Also, I’d love it if the #jhu2015 could be included in your remarks—but it is perfectly fine if you are not comfortable with including that.
  4. The week of commencement-Tuesday or Wednesday, I would like to work with you on having an email go out to seniors from you. Some seniors get a little panicked and so this communication has turned out to be very helpful. Does that sound okay?
  5. Your rehearsal will be on Tuesday, May 19 from 4:00-4:45 at Homewood Field. Please let me know as soon as possible if you have any issues with this time.

Jill M. Williams

Associate Director of University Events

Johns Hopkins UniversitySan Martin Center / 3400 N. Charles St.

Baltimore, MD 21218(P) 410.516.7131(F) 410.516.0424

From: Jill Williams jillwilliams@jhu.eduSubject: Ed Catmull at breakfastDate: May 18, 2015 at 9:14 AMTo: Janet Kirsch jkirsch@jhu.edu, Michelle McLaughlin mmclau10@jhu.edu

Hi Janet!

I wanted to connect you with Michelle McLaughlin. Michelle will be bringing Ed Catmull to the breakfast on Thursday morning. The details of his moves in the morning are listed below. When Michelle arrives with Ed, who will be the one helping to introduce the students to him—will that be you? Michelle just wants to connect with that person so this is done in an organized way.

Thank you!

Jill

Ed Catmull

Michelle McLaughlin (973) 723-2217

Greg Bowden (443) 462-1338

Janet Kirsh (410) 446-9644

  • 7:15 Greg Bowden and his golf cart will come meet Michelle outside the Athletic Center Homewood Field entrance.
  • Michelle will have another volunteer from Cordish join her to bring Ed's luggage inside Cordish and tag it for going over to the Hopkins Club.
  • Between 7:15/7:30 Freedom Car will drop off Ed Catmull outside Homewood Field (near Cordish Lacrosse building). Freedom Car Dispatch: 410.321.5600
  • Then, Michelle and Ed Catmull need to be taken, via golf cart to the Gilman Hall Atrium.
  • Greg can depart and return to making regular runs but must be back at Gilman Hall by 8:00 a.m.
  • Around 8:00-Ed Catmull and Michelle will be transported to the Cordish Lacrosse Building. Michelle will escort him inside Cordish.

Jill M. Williams

Associate Director of University Events

Johns Hopkins UniversitySan Martin Center / 3400 N. Charles St.

Baltimore, MD 21218(P) 410.516.7131(F) 410.516.0424

Commencement Info:

Visit us on the webFollow us on: [Facebook icon] [Twitter icon] [Instagram icon]

[illegible]

ASTRA SCHEDULE

Event Summary

5/18/2015 3:24 PM

Comment:

Hi Janet,

Gilman 277 has been reserved for your use from 7 PM on May 20th to 10 AM on May 21st.

Please note that no food or beverages will be permitted in the room. Also, please restrict all activities to the assigned areas, and return the rooms to rights (presentation materials removed, boards erased, chairs straightened, etc.) prior to vacating the space.

It is recommended that you coordinate event security with the Homewood Security office at 410-516-4600.

For additional chairs or tables, contact Custodial Services (custodialservices@jhu.edu; 410-516-8393). To request A/V services, go to http://www.it.johnshopkins.edu/services/technical/customer-services/requests.html.

If you have any questions or concerns regarding this reservation or if your plans change, please contact me at 6-8307.

All the best,

Zach Cohen

ASEN Scheduling SpecialistZCohen@jhu.edu

Event Information:

  • Reservation #: [unclear: 20155184-00988]
  • Event Name: Opening Prep
  • Event Type: Event Prep
  • Date: 5/20/15 - 5/21/15
  • Status: Scheduled
  • Est. Attendance: Scheduled

Meeting Information:

Meeting NameDateTimeMeeting StatusBuildingRoomRoom Status
5/20/157:00PM - 10:00AMEndingGilman277Scheduled

Event Information

Reservation #: 20150518-00088Event Name: Q Gathering PrepEvent Type: Event PrepDates: 5/20/15 - 5/21/15Status: Scheduled

Est. Attendance:

Event Notes:

Contact Information

Janet Kirsch

Office of Student Activities

[handwritten: No phones]

[handwritten: [unclear: ... 200? ...]]

[handwritten: [unclear: Who ... my ... member ... have me]]

[handwritten: 2. Bonnie]

[handwritten: [unclear: 200? questions]]

[handwritten: Some states in need power in [illegible]]

[handwritten: [unclear: 3 ... action]]

[handwritten: - not photo ... in]

[handwritten: - individuals ... funds]

[handwritten: - elected]

[handwritten: - great [illegible]]

[handwritten: approve ...]

[handwritten: respect them]

Senior Prom- Single

ColemanKaitlyn2

Senior Prom- Single

CollierMaxwell1

Senior Prom- Single

ConnorsJoseph1

Senior Prom- Single

CorenAmanda1

Senior Prom- Single

CornblathLouise1

Senior Prom- Single

CrossBryn1

Senior Prom- Couple

CrossDevon2

Senior Prom- Single

CuaCeline1

Senior Prom- Couple

DaggettSarah2

Senior Prom- Single

DaileyHope1

Senior Prom- Single

DamAnita1

Senior Prom- Single

DarrowAmanda1

Senior Prom- Couple

DavisRachel2

Senior Prom- Couple

[unclear: Ajai]Dhawal2

Senior Prom- Single

Diaz-ReyesRebecca1

Senior Prom- Single

DiehlAlex1

Senior Prom- Single

DiRilloMegan1

Senior Prom- Couple

[unclear: Dela]Allison2

Senior Prom- Couple

BongDavid2

Senior Prom- Couple

BrodtCarolyn2

Senior Prom- Single

DuThomas1

Senior Prom- Couple

DuRobin2

Senior Prom- Couple

DunnKelly2

Edelson

Michelle1

Senior Prom- Couple

EspinozaDiego2

Senior Prom- Single

EvansLauren1

Senior Prom- Couple

FacklerAmanda2

Senior Prom- Single

FengHeather1

Senior Prom- Single

FigueroaChris1

Senior Prom- Couple

FoxSamantha2

Senior Prom- Couple

FoxwellLouis2

Senior Prom- Couple

GatehouseLara2

Senior Prom- Couple

GhoshRania2

Senior Prom- Couple

GildeaMariana2

Senior Prom- Couple

[unclear: Gilchman]Emily2

Senior Prom- Couple

GoodmanZachary2

Edwin Catmull

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Edwin Earl "Ed" Catmull (born March 31, 1945) is a computer scientist and current president of Pixar Animation Studios and Walt Disney Animation Studios (including the latter's DisneyToon Studios division).[3][4][5] As a computer scientist, Catmull has contributed to many important developments in computer graphics.[6][7]

Edwin Catmull

![Photograph of Edwin Catmull]

Born

Edwin Earl Catmull \nMarch 31, 1945 \nParkersburg, West Virginia

Nationality

American

Fields

Computer science

Institutions

Pixar \nLucasfilm \nDisneyToon Studios \nWalt Disney Animation Studios

Alma mater

University of Utah (Ph.D. Computer Science; B.S. Physics and Computer Science)

Thesis

A Subdivision Algorithm for Computer Display of Curved Surfaces \n(http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=907242) (1974)

Doctoral advisor

Robert E. Stephenson[1]

Known for

Texture mapping

Contents

  • 1 Life and career
    • 1.1 Awards
  • 2 Wage Fixing Controversy
  • 3 Bibliography
  • 4 References
  • 5 External links

Life and career

Edwin Catmull was born in Parkersburg, West Virginia.[8] His family later moved to Utah, where Catmull's father first served as principal of Granite High School, then Taylorsville High School.[9] Early in life, Catmull found inspiration in Disney movies such as Peter Pan and Pinocchio and dreamed of becoming a feature film animator. He even made primitive animation using so-called flip-books. However, he assessed his chances realistically and decided that his talents lay elsewhere. Instead of pursuing a career in the movie industry, he used his talent in math and studied physics and computer science at the University of Utah.[1] After graduating, he worked as a computer programmer at The Boeing Company in Seattle for a short period of time and also at the New York Institute of Technology, before returning to Utah to go to graduate school in fall of 1970.

Back at the university he became one of Ivan Sutherland’s students and part of the university's ARPA program,[10] sharing classes with Fred Parke, James H. Clark, John Warnock and Alan Kay. Catmull saw Sutherland's computer drawing program Sketchpad and the new field of computer graphics in general as a major fundament in the future of animation, which combined his love for both technology and animation, and decided to be a part of the revolution from the beginning. From that point, his main goal and ambition was to make a computer animated movie.[11] During his time there he made two new fundamental computer graphics discoveries: texture mapping, and bicubic patches, and invented algorithms for spatial anti-aliasing and refining subdivision surfaces. He also independently discovered Z-buffering, even though it had already been described 8 months before, by Wolfgang Straßer in his PhD thesis.[12]

In 1972 Catmull made his earliest contribution to the film industry; an animated version of his left hand which was eventually picked up by a Hollywood producer and incorporated in the 1976 movie Futureworld, the science fiction sequel to the film Westworld and the first film to use 3D computer graphics. The sequence, known simply as A Computer Animated Hand,[13] was selected for preservation in the National Film Registry of the Library of Congress in December 2011.[14]

In 1974, Catmull earned his doctorate in computer science and was hired by a company called Applicon. However, by November the same year he had been contacted by the founder of New York Institute of Technology, Alexander Schure, who offered him the position as the director of the new Computer Graphics Lab at NYIT.

In his new position, Catmull formed a talented research group working with 2D animation, mostly focusing on tools that could assist the animators in their work. Among the inventions was a paint program simply called Paint which could be seen as an early version of Disney's CAPS, the commercial animation program Tween (used in the video called 3Measure for Measure2), inspired by an experimental computer animation system created by Nestor Burtnyk and Marceli Wein, that automated the process of producing in-between frames, the animation program SoftCel and other software.

Catmull and his team eventually left 2D animation and started to concentrate on 3D computer graphics, moving into the field of motion picture production. By the end of the 70's, the Computer Graphics Lab was starting to struggle for several reasons and felt there was a lack of actual progress despite the technological development, but their efforts had attracted the attention of some big names in Hollywood. These were George Lucas at Lucasfilm and Francis Ford Coppola. Lucas approached Catmull in 1979 and asked him to head up a group to bring computer graphics, video editing, and digital audio into the entertainment field. Lucas had already made a deal with a computer company called Triple-I, and asked them to create a digital model of an X-Wing fighter from Star Wars, which they did. In 1979 Catmull became the Vice President at the seminal Industrial Light & Magic computer graphics division at Lucasfilm.[15]

Catmull–Rom spline

Catmull–Clark subdivision surface[2]

Notable awards

Academy Award (1995)IEEE John von Neumann Medal (2006)Computer History Museum Fellow (2013)

Spouse

Susan Anderson Catmull

At Lucasfilm, he helped develop digital image compositing technology used to combine multiple images in a convincing way. Later, in 1986, Steve Jobs bought Lucasfilm's digital division and founded Pixar, where Catmull became the Chief Technical Officer. At Pixar, he was a key developer of the RenderMan rendering system used in films such as Toy Story and Finding Nemo.

After Disney acquired Pixar in January 2006, Disney Chief Executive Bob Iger put Catmull and John Lasseter in charge of reinvigorating the Disney animation studios. According to a Los Angeles Times article [16], part of this effort was to allow directors more creative control as collaborators on their projects and to give them the creative freedom to use traditional animation techniques. — a reversal of former CEO Michael Eisner's decision that Disney would do only digital animation, which Catmull thought was the wrong idea of how Pixar's films did well.

In June 2007, Catmull and Lasseter were given control of DisneyToon Studios, a division of Disney Animation housed in a separate facility in Glendale. Since then, as president and chief creative officer, respectively, they have supervised three separate studios for Disney, each with its own production pipeline: Pixar, Disney Animation, and DisneyToon. While Disney Animation and DisneyToon are located in the Los Angeles area, Pixar is located over 350 miles (563 kilometers) northwest in the San Francisco Bay Area, where Catmull and Lasseter both live. Accordingly, they appointed a general manager for each studio to handle day-to-day affairs on their behalf, then began regularly commuting each week to both Pixar and Disney Animation and spending at least two days per week (usually Tuesdays and Wednesdays) at Disney Animation. [17] In November 2014, the general managers of Disney Animation and Pixar were both promoted to president, but both continued to report to Catmull, who retained the title of president of Walt Disney and Pixar Animation Studios. [18]

Awards

In 1993, the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences presented Catmull with his first Academy Scientific and Technical Award "for the development of PhotoRealistic RenderMan software which produces images used in motion pictures from 3D computer descriptions of shape and appearance". In 1995 he was inducted as a Fellow of the Association for Computing Machinery. Again in 1996, he received an Academy Scientific and Technical Award "for pioneering inventions in Digital Image Compositing". In 2001, he received an Oscar "for significant advancements to the field of motion picture rendering as exemplified in Pixar's RenderMan". In 2006, he was awarded with the IEEE John von Neumann Medal for pioneering contributions to the field of computer graphics, animation and rendering. In the 81st Academy Awards (2008, presented in February 2009), Catmull was awarded with the Gordon E. Sawyer Award, which honors "an individual in the motion picture industry whose technological contributions have brought credit to the industry".

In 2013, the Computer History Museum named him a Museum Fellow "for his pioneering work in computer graphics, animation and filmmaking". [19]

Creativity, Inc. was shortlisted for the Financial Times and Goldman Sachs Business Book of the Year Award (2014), [20] and was a selection for Mark Zuckerberg book club in March 2015. [21]

Wage Fixing Controversy

In re: High-Tech Employee Antitrust Litigation (U.S. District Court, Northern District of California 11-cv-2509 [22]) was a class-action lawsuit on behalf of over 64,000 employees of Adobe, Apple Inc., Google, Intel, Intuit, Pixar and Lucasfilm (the last two are subsidiaries of Disney) against their employer alleging that their wages were repressed due to alleged agreements between their employers not to hire employees from their competitors.[23]

During his January 24, 2013 deposition, Catmull was asked about a 2007 email he had sent former Disney chairman Dick Cook in which he criticized Robert Zemeckis's ImageMovers for paying its employees too generously.

In that email, Catmull told Cook that they’d “avoided wars up in Northern[n] California because all of the companies up here—Pixar, ILM, Dreamworks, and a couple of smaller places—have conscientiously avoided raiding each other.” He also acknowledged a secret deal between Pixar and Disney that ensured the employees of the two studios “cannot be considered to move back and forth.”

When Catmull was confronted by lawyers at the deposition about these activities, which suggest both illegal corporate behavior and possible violations of the Sherman Antitrust Act, he responded saying:[24]

Like somehow we’re hurting some employees? We’re not. While I have responsibility for the payroll, I have responsibility for the long term also. I don’t apologize for this. This was bad stuff.

Bibliography

  • Catmull, Ed; Amy Wallace (2014). Creativity Inc.: Overcoming the Unseen Forces That Stand in the Way of True Inspiration. New York: Random House. ISBN 97808012993011. OCLC 851419994. (https://www.worldcat.org/oclc/851419994).

References

  1. Catmull, Edwin Earl (1974). A subdivision algorithm for computer display of curved surfaces (http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=907242) (PhD thesis). University of Utah.
  2. Catmull, E.; Clark, J. (1978). "Recursively generated B-spline surfaces on arbitrary topological meshes" (http://www.cs.berkeley.edu/~sequin/CS284/PAPERS/CatmullClark_SDSurf.pdf) (PDF). Computer-Aided Design 10 (6): 350. doi:10.1016/0010-4485(78)90110-0 (https://dx.doi.org/10.1016%2F0010-4485%2878%2990110-0).
  3. Cook, R. L.; Carpenter, L.; Catmull, E. (1987). "The Reyes image rendering architecture" (http://excelsior.biophys.ohio-state.edu/~carlson/history/PDFs/cook-reyes.pdf) (PDF). ACM SIGGRAPH Computer Graphics 21 (4): 95. doi:10.1145/37402.37414 (https://doi.org/10.1145%2F37402.37414).
  4. Price, David P. T. (2009). The Pixar Touch (Vintage). London: Vintage. ISBN 0-307-27829-8.
  5. Michael Rubin. "Droidmaker: George Lucas and the Digital Revolution" (2005), ISBN 0-937404-67-5
  6. Edwin Catmull's publications (http://dblp.uni-trier.de/pers/hc/c/Catmull:Edwin_E.html) indexed by the DBLP Bibliography Server at the University of Trier
  7. List of publications (http://academic.research.microsoft.com/Author/28259) from Microsoft Academic Search

Harvard Business Review

COMMUNICATION

How Pixar Fosters Collective Creativity

by Ed Catmull

FROM THE SEPTEMBER 2008 ISSUE

Listen to Ed Catmull discuss managing creativity.

A few years ago, I had lunch with the head of a major motion picture studio, who declared that his central problem was not finding good people—it was finding good ideas. Since then, when giving talks, I’ve asked audiences whether they agree with him. Almost always there’s a 50/50 split, which has astounded me because I couldn’t disagree more with the studio executive. His belief is rooted in a misguided view of creativity that exaggerates the importance of the initial idea in creating an original product. And it reflects a profound misunderstanding of how to manage the large risks inherent in producing breakthroughs.

The view that good ideas are rarer and more valuable than good people is rooted in a misconception of creativity.

How Pixar Fosters Collective Creativity – HBR

When it comes to producing breakthroughs, both technological and artistic, Pixar’s track record is unique. In the early 1990s, we were known as the leading technological pioneer in the field of computer animation. Our years of R&D culminated in the release of Toy Story in 1995, the world’s first computer-animated feature film. In the following 13 years, we have released eight other films (A Bug’s Life; Toy Story 2; Monsters, Inc.; Finding Nemo; The Incredibles; Cars; Ratatouille; and WALL·E), which also have been blockbusters. Unlike most other studios, we have never bought scripts or movie ideas from the outside. All of our stories, worlds, and characters were created internally by our community of artists. And in making these films, we have continued to push the technological boundaries of computer animation, securing dozens of patents in the process.

While I’m not foolish enough to predict that we will never have a flop, I don’t think our success is largely luck. Rather, I believe our adherence to a set of principles and practices for managing creative talent and risk is responsible. Pixar is a community in the true sense of the word. We think that lasting relationships matter, and we share some basic beliefs: Talent is rare. Management’s job is not to prevent risk but to build the capability to recover when failures occur. It must be safe to tell the truth. We must constantly challenge all of our assumptions and search for the flaws that could destroy our culture. In the last two years, we’ve had a chance to test whether our principles and practices are transferable. After Pixar’s 2006 merger with the Walt Disney Company, its CEO, Bob Iger, asked me, chief creative officer John Lasseter, and other Pixar senior managers to help him revive Disney Animation Studios. The success of our efforts prompted me to share my thinking on how to build a sustainable creative organization.

What Is Creativity?

People tend to think of creativity as a mysterious solo act, and they typically reduce products to a single idea: This is a movie about toys, or dinosaurs, or love, they’ll say. However, in filmmaking and many other kinds of complex product development, creativity involves a large number of people from different disciplines working effectively together to solve a great many problems. The initial idea for the movie—what people in the movie business call “the high concept”—is merely one step in a long, arduous process that takes four to five years.

A movie contains literally tens of thousands of ideas. They’re in the form of every sentence; in the performance of each line; in the design of characters, sets, and backgrounds; in the locations of the camera; in the colors, the lighting, the pacing. The director and the other creative leaders of a production do not come up with all the ideas on their own; rather, every single member of the 200- to 250-person production group makes suggestions. Creativity must be present at every level of every artistic and technical part of the organization. The leaders sort through a mass of ideas to find the ones that fit into a coherent whole—that support the story—which is a very difficult task. It’s like an archaeological dig where you don’t know what you’re looking for or whether you will even find anything. The process is downright scary.

Taking Risks

Pixar’s customers expect to see something new every time. That’s downright scary. But if Pixar’s executives aren’t always a little scared, they’re not doing their jobs.

Then again, if we aren’t always at least a little scared, we’re not doing our job. We’re in a business whose customers want to see something new every time they go to the theater. This means we have to put ourselves at great risk. Our most recent film, WALL-E, is a robot love story set in a post-apocalyptic world full of trash. And our previous movie, Ratatouille, is about a French rat who aspires to be a chef. Talk about unexpected ideas! At the outset of making these movies, we simply didn’t know if they would work. However, since we’re supposed to offer something that isn’t obvious, we bought into somebody’s initial vision and took a chance.

To act in this fashion, we as executives have to resist our natural tendency to avoid or minimize risks, which, of course, is much easier said than done. In the movie business and plenty of others, this instinct leads executives to choose to copy successes rather than try to create something brand-new. That’s why you see so many movies that are so much alike. It also explains why a lot of films aren’t very good. If you want to be original, you have to accept the uncertainty, even when it’s uncomfortable, and have the capability to recover when your organization takes a big risk and fails. What’s the key to being able to recover? Talented people! Contrary to what the studio head asserted at lunch that day, such people are not so easy to find.

What’s equally tough, of course, is getting talented people to work effectively with one another. That takes trust and respect, which we as managers can’t mandate; they must be earned over time. What we can do is construct an environment that nurtures trusting and respectful relationships and unleashes everyone’s creativity. If we get that right, the result is a vibrant community where talented people are loyal to one another and their collective work, everyone feels that they are part of something extraordinary, and their passion and accomplishments make the community a magnet for talented people coming out of schools or working at other places. I know what I’m describing is the antithesis of the free-agency practices that prevail in the movie industry, but that’s the point: I believe that community matters.

The Roots of Our Culture

My conviction that smart people are more important than good ideas probably isn’t surprising. I’ve had the good fortune to work alongside amazing people in places that pioneered computer graphics.

At the University of Utah, my fellow graduate students included Jim Clark, who cofounded Silicon Graphics and Netscape; John Warnock, who cofounded Adobe; and Alan Kay, who developed object-oriented programming. We had ample funding (thanks to the U.S. Defense Department’s Advanced Research Projects Agency), the professors gave us free rein, and there was an exhilarating and creative exchange of ideas.

At the New York Institute of Technology, where I headed a new computer-animation laboratory, one of my first hires was Alvy Ray Smith, who made breakthroughs in computer painting. That made me realize that it’s OK to hire people who are smarter than you are.

Then George Lucas, of Star Wars fame, hired me to head a major initiative at Lucasfilm to bring computer graphics and other digital technology into films and, later, games. It was thrilling to do research within a film company that was pushing the boundaries. George didn’t try to lock up the technology for himself and allowed us to continue to publish and maintain strong academic contacts. This made it possible to attract some of the best people in the industry, including John Lasseter, then an animator from Disney, who was excited by the new possibilities of computer animation.

Last but not least, there’s Pixar, which began its life as an independent company in 1986, when Steve Jobs bought the computer division from Lucasfilm, allowing us to pursue our dream of producing computer-animated movies. Steve gave backbone to our desire for excellence and helped us form a remarkable management team. I’d like to think that Pixar captures what’s best about all the places I’ve worked. A number of us have stuck together for decades, pursuing the dream of making computer-animated films, and we still have the pleasure of working together today.

It was only when Pixar experienced a crisis during the production of Toy Story 2 that my views on how to structure and operate a creative organization began to crystallize. In 1996, while we were working on A Bug’s Life, our second movie, we started to make a sequel to Toy Story. We had enough technical leaders to start a second production, but all of our proven creative leaders—the people who had made Toy Story, including John, who was its director; writer Andrew Stanton; editor Lee Unkrich; and the late Joe Ranft, the movie’s head of story—were working on A Bug’s Life. So we had to form a new creative team of people who had never headed a movie production. We felt this was OK. After all, John, Andrew, Lee, and Joe had never led a full-length animated film production before Toy Story.

Disney, which at that time was distributing and cofinancing our films, initially encouraged us to make Toy Story 2 as a “direct to video”—a movie that would be sold only as home videos and not shown first in theaters. This was Disney’s model for keeping alive the characters of successful films, and the expectation was that both the cost and quality would be lower. We realized early on, however, that having two different standards of quality in the same studio was bad for our souls, and Disney readily agreed that the sequel should be a theatrical release. The creative leadership, though, remained the same, which turned out to be a problem.

In the early stage of making a movie, we draw storyboards (a comic-book version of the story) and then edit them together with dialogue and temporary music. These are called story reels. The first versions are very rough, but they give a sense of what the problems are, which in the beginning of all productions are many. We then iterate, and each version typically gets better and better. In the case of Toy Story 2, we had a good initial idea for a story, but the reels were not where they ought to have been by the time we started animation, and they were not improving. Making matters worse, the directors and producers were not pulling together to rise to the challenge.

Finally A Bug’s Life was finished, freeing up John, Andrew, Lee, and Joe to take over the creative leadership of Toy Story 2. Given where the production was at that point, 18 months would have been an aggressive schedule, but by then we had only eight left to deliver the film. Knowing that the company’s future depended on them, crew members worked at an incredible rate. In the end, with the new leadership, they pulled it off.

How did John and his team save the movie? The problem was not the original core concept, which they retained. The main character, a cowboy doll named Woody, is kidnapped by a toy collector who intends to ship him to a toy museum in Japan. At a critical point in the story, Woody has to decide whether to go to Japan or try to escape and go back to Andy, the boy who owned him. Well, since the movie is coming from Pixar and Disney, you know he’s going to end up back with Andy. And if you can easily predict what’s going to happen, you don’t have any drama. So the challenge was to get the audience to believe that Woody might make a different choice. The first team couldn’t figure out how to do it.

John, Andrew, Lee, and Joe solved that problem by adding several elements to show the fears toys might have that people could relate to. One is a scene they created called “Jessie’s story.” Jessie is a cowgirl doll who is going to be shipped to Japan with Woody. She wants to go, and she explains why to Woody. The audience hears her story in the emotional song “When She Loved Me”: She had been the darling of a little girl, but the girl grew up and discarded her. The reality is kids do grow up, life does change, and sometimes you have to move on. Since the audience members know the truth of this, they can see that Woody has a real choice, and this is what grabs them. It took our “A” team to add the elements that made the story work.

How Pixar Fosters Collective Creativity – HBR.

Toy Story 2 was great and became a critical and commercial success—and it was the defining moment for Pixar. It taught us an important lesson about the primacy of people over ideas: If you give a good idea to a mediocre team, they will screw it up; if you give a mediocre idea to a great team, they will either fix it or throw it away and come up with something that works.

If you give a good idea to a mediocre team, they’ll screw it up. But if you give a mediocre idea to a great team, they’ll make it work.

Toy Story 2 also taught us another important lesson: There has to be one quality bar for every film we produce. Everyone working at the studio at the time made tremendous personal sacrifices to fix Toy Story 2. We shut down all the other productions. We asked our crew to work inhumane hours, and lots of people suffered repetitive stress injuries. But by rejecting mediocrity at great pain and personal sacrifice, we made a loud statement as a community that it was unacceptable to produce some good films and some mediocre films. As a result of Toy Story 2, it became deeply ingrained in our culture that everything we touch needs to be excellent. This goes beyond movies to the DVD production and extras, and to the toys and other consumer products associated with our characters.

Of course, most executives would at least pay lip service to the notion that they need to get good people and should set their standards high. But how many understand the importance of creating an environment that supports great people and encourages them to support one another so the whole is far greater than the sum of the parts? That’s what we are striving to do. Let me share what we’ve learned so far about what works.

Power to the Creatives

Creative power in a film has to reside with the film’s creative leadership. As obvious as this might seem, it’s not true of many companies in the movie industry and, I suspect, a lot of others. We believe the creative vision propelling each movie comes from one or two people and not from either corporate executives or a development department. Our philosophy is: You get great creative people, you bet big on them, you give them enormous leeway and support, and you provide them with an environment in which they can get honest feedback from everyone.

After Toy Story 2 we changed the mission of our development department. Instead of coming up with new ideas for movies (its role at most studios), the department’s job is to assemble small incubation teams to help directors refine their own ideas to a point where they can convince John and our other senior filmmakers that those ideas have the potential to be great films. Each team typically consists of a director, a writer, some artists, and some storyboard people. The development department’s goal is to find individuals who will work effectively together. During this incubation stage, you can’t judge teams by the material they’re producing because it’s so rough—there are many problems and open questions. But you can assess whether the teams’ social dynamics are healthy and whether the teams are solving problems and making progress. Both the senior management and the development department are responsible for seeing to it that the teams function well.

To emphasize that the creative vision is what matters most, we say we are “filmmaker led.” There are really two leaders: the director and the producer. They form a strong partnership. They not only strive to make a great movie but also operate within time, budget, and people constraints. (Good artists understand the value of limits.) During production, we leave the operating decisions to the film’s leaders, and we don’t second-guess or micromanage them.

Indeed, even when a production runs into a problem, we do everything possible to provide support without undermining their authority. One way we do this is by making it possible for a director to solicit help from our “creative brain trust” of filmmakers. (This group is a pillar of our distinctive peer-based process for making movies—an important topic I’ll return to in a moment.) If this advice doesn’t suffice, we’ll sometimes add reinforcements to the production—such as a writer or codirector—to provide specific skills or improve the creative dynamics of the film’s creative leadership.

What does it take for a director to be a successful leader in this environment? Of course, our directors have to be masters at knowing how to tell a story that will translate into the medium of film. This means that they must have a unifying vision—one that will give coherence to the thousands of ideas that go into a movie—and they must be able to turn that vision into clear directives that the staff can implement. They must set people up for success by giving them all the information they need to do the job right without telling them how to do it. Each person on a film should be given creative ownership of even the smallest task.

Good directors not only possess strong analytical skills themselves but also can harness the analytical power and life experiences of their staff members. They are superb listeners and strive to understand the thinking behind every suggestion. They appreciate all contributions, regardless of where or from whom they originate, and use the best ones.

A Peer Culture

Of great importance—and something that sets us apart from other studios—is the way people at all levels support one another. Everyone is fully invested in helping everyone else turn out the best work. They really do feel that it’s all for one and one for all. Nothing exemplifies this more than our creative brain trust and our daily review process.

The brain trust.

This group consists of John and our eight directors (Andrew Stanton, Brad Bird, Pete Docter, Bob Peterson, Brenda Chapman, Lee Unkrich, Gary Rydstrom, and Brad Lewis). When a director and producer feel in need of assistance, they convene the group (and anyone else they think would be valuable) and show the current version of the work in progress. This is followed by a lively two-hour give-and-take discussion, which is all about making the movie better. There’s no ego. Nobody pulls any punches to be polite. This works because all the participants have come to trust and respect one another. They know it’s far better to learn about problems from colleagues when there’s still time to fix them than from the audience after it’s too late. The problem-solving powers of this group are immense and inspirational to watch.

Getting Real Help

Pixar’s brain trust of directors offers advice on works in progress. But the production’s leaders decide what to use and what to ignore.

After a session, it’s up to the director of the movie and his or her team to decide what to do with the advice; there are no mandatory notes, and the brain trust has no authority. This dynamic is crucial. It liberates the trust members, so they can give their unvarnished expert opinions, and it liberates the director to seek help and fully consider the advice. It took us a while to learn this. When we tried to export the brain trust model to our technical area, we found at first that it didn’t work. Eventually, I realized why: We had given these other review groups some authority. As soon as we said, “This is purely peers giving feedback to each other,” the dynamic changed, and the effectiveness of the review sessions dramatically improved.

The origin of the creative brain trust was Toy Story. During a crisis that occurred while making that film, a special relationship developed among John, Andrew, Lee, and Joe, who had remarkable and complementary skills. Since they trusted one another, they could have very intense and heated discussions; they always knew that the passion was about the story and wasn’t personal. Over time, as other people from inside and outside joined our directors’ ranks, the brain trust expanded to what it is today: a community of master filmmakers who come together when needed to help each other.

The dailies.

This practice of working together as peers is core to our culture, and it’s not limited to our directors and producers. One example is our daily reviews, or “dailies,” a process for giving and getting constant feedback in a positive way that’s based on practices John observed at Disney and Industrial Light & Magic (ILM), Lucasfilm’s special-effects company.

At Disney, only a small senior group would look at daily animation work. Dennis Muren, ILM’s legendary visual-effects supervisor, broadened the participation to include his whole special-effects crew. (John, who joined my computer group at Lucasfilm after leaving Disney, participated in these sessions while we were creating computer-animated effects for Young Sherlock Holmes.)

As we built up an animation crew for Toy Story in the early 1990s, John used what he had learned from Disney and ILM to develop our daily review process. People show work in an incomplete state to the whole animation crew, and although the director makes decisions, everyone is encouraged to comment.

Overcoming Inhibitions

There are several benefits. First, once people get over the embarrassment of showing work still in progress, they become more creative.

Showing unfinished work each day liberates people to take risks and try new things because it doesn’t have to be perfect the first time.

Second, the director or creative leads guiding the review process can communicate important points to the entire crew at the same time. Third, people learn from and inspire each other; a highly creative piece of animation will spark others to raise their game. Finally, there are no surprises at the end: When you’re done, you’re done. People’s overwhelming desire to make sure their work is “good” before they show it to others increases the possibility that their finished version won’t be what the director wants. The dailies process avoids such wasted efforts.

Technology + Art = Magic

Getting people in different disciplines to treat one another as peers is just as important as getting people within disciplines to do so. But it’s much harder. Barriers include the natural class structures that arise in organizations: There always seems to be one function that considers itself and is perceived by others to be the one the organization values the most. Then there’s the different languages spoken by different disciplines and even the physical distance between offices. In a creative business like ours, these barriers are impediments to producing great work, and therefore we must do everything we can to tear them down.

Pixar’s Operating Principles

  1. Everyone must have the freedom to communicate with anyone.
  2. It must be safe for everyone to offer ideas.

Walt Disney understood this. He believed that when continual change, or reinvention, is the norm in an organization and technology and art are together, magical things happen. A lot of people look back at Disney’s early days and

How Pixar Fosters Collective Creativity – HBR

  1. We must stay close to innovations happening in the academic community.

say, “Look at the artists!” They don’t pay attention to his technological innovations.

But he did the first sound in animation, the first color, the first compositing of animation with live action, and the first applications of xerography in animation production. He was always excited by science and technology.

At Pixar, we believe in this swirling interplay between art and technology and constantly try to use better technology at every stage of production. John coined a saying that captures this dynamic: “Technology inspires art, and art challenges the technology.” To us, those aren’t just words; they are a way of life that had to be established and still has to be constantly reinforced. Although we are a director- and producer-led meritocracy, which recognizes that talent is not spread equally among all people, we adhere to the following principles:

Everyone must have the freedom to communicate with anyone.

This means recognizing that the decision-making hierarchy and communication structure in organizations are two different things. Members of any department should be able to approach anyone in another department to solve problems without having to go through “proper” channels. It also means that managers need to learn that they don’t always have to be the first to know about something going on in their realm, and it’s OK to walk into a meeting and be surprised. The impulse to tightly control the process is understandable given the complex nature of moviemaking, but problems are almost by definition unforeseen. The most efficient way to deal with numerous problems is to trust people to work out the difficulties directly with each other without having to check for permission.

Managers need to learn that it’s OK to walk into a meeting and be surprised.

How Pixar Fosters Collective Creativity - HBR

It must be safe for everyone to offer ideas.

We’re constantly showing works in progress internally. We try to stagger who goes to which viewing to ensure that there are always fresh eyes, and everyone in the company, regardless of discipline or position, gets to go at some point. We make a concerted effort to make it safe to criticize by inviting everyone attending these showings to e-mail notes to the creative leaders that detail what they liked and didn’t like and explain why.

We must stay close to innovations happening in the academic community.

We strongly encourage our technical artists to publish their research and participate in industry conferences. Publishing may give away ideas, but it keeps us connected with the academic community. This connection is worth far more than any ideas we may have revealed. It helps us attract exceptional talent and reinforces the belief throughout the company that people are more important than ideas.

We try to break down the walls between disciplines in other ways, as well. One is a collection of in-house courses we offer, which we call Pixar University. It is responsible for training and cross-training people as they develop in their careers. But it also offers an array of optional classes—many of which I’ve taken—that give people from different disciplines the opportunity to mix and appreciate what everyone does. Some (screenplay writing, drawing, and sculpting) are directly related to our business; some (Pilates and yoga) are not. In a sculpting class will be rank novices as well as world-class sculptors who want to refine their skills. Pixar University helps reinforce the mind-set that we’re all learning and it’s fun to learn together.

Our building, which is Steve Jobs’s brainchild, is another way we try to get people from different departments to interact. Most buildings are designed for some functional purpose, but ours is structured to maximize inadvertent encounters. At its center is a large atrium, which contains the cafeteria, meeting rooms, bathrooms, and mailboxes. As a result, everyone has strong reasons to go there repeatedly during the course of the workday. It’s hard to describe just how valuable the resulting chance encounters are.

Staying on the Rails

Observing the rise and fall of computer companies during my career has affected me deeply. Many companies put together a phenomenal group of people who produced great products. They had the best engineers, exposure to the needs of customers, access to changing technology, and experienced management. Yet many made decisions at the height of their powers that were stunningly wrongheaded, and they faded into irrelevance. How could really smart people completely miss something so crucial to their survival? I remember asking myself more than once: “If we are ever successful, will we be equally blind?”

Many of the people I knew in those companies that failed were not very introspective. When Pixar became an independent company, I vowed we would be different. I realized that it’s extremely difficult for an organization to analyze itself. It is uncomfortable and hard to be objective. Systematically fighting complacency and uncovering problems when your company is successful have got to be two of the toughest management challenges there are. Clear values, constant communication, routine postmortems, and the regular injection of outsiders who will challenge the status quo aren’t enough. Strong leadership is also essential—to make sure people don’t pay lip service to the values, tune out the communications, game the processes, and automatically discount newcomers’ observations and suggestions. Here’s a sampling of what we do:

Postmortems.

The first we performed—at the end of A Bug’s Life—was successful. But the success of those that followed varied enormously. This caused me to reflect on how to get more out of them. One thing I observed was that although people learn from the postmortems, they don’t like to do them. Leaders naturally want to use the occasion to give kudos to their team members.

People in general would rather talk about what went right than what went wrong. And after spending years on a film, everybody just wants to move on. Left to their own devices, people will game the system to avoid confronting the unpleasant.

There are some simple techniques for overcoming these problems. One is to try to vary the way you do the postmortems. By definition, they’re supposed to be about lessons learned, so if you repeat the same format, you tend to find the same lessons, which isn’t productive. Another is to ask each group to list the top five things they would do again and the top five things they wouldn’t do. The balance between the positive and the negative helps make it a safer environment. In any event, employ lots of data in the review. Because we’re a creative organization, people tend to assume that much of what we do can’t be measured or analyzed. That’s wrong. Most of our processes involve activities and deliverables that can be quantified. We keep track of the rates at which things happen, how often something has to be reworked, whether a piece of work was completely finished or not when it was sent to another department, and so on. Data can show things in a neutral way, which can stimulate discussion and challenge assumptions arising from personal impressions.

Fresh blood.

Successful organizations face two challenges when bringing in new people with fresh perspectives. One is well-known—the not-invented-here syndrome. The other—the awe-of-the-institution syndrome (an issue with young new hires)—is often overlooked.

The former has not been a problem for us, thank goodness, because we have an open culture. Continually embracing change the way we do makes newcomers less threatening. Several prominent outsiders who have had a big impact on us (in terms of the exciting ideas they introduced and the strong people they attracted) were readily accepted. They include Brad Bird, who directed The Incredibles and Ratatouille; Jim Morris, who headed Industrial

How Pixar Fosters Collective Creativity - HBR

Light & Magic for years before joining Pixar as the producer of WALL-E and executive vice president of production; and Richard Hollander, a former executive of the special-effects studio Rhythm & Hues, who is leading an effort to improve our production processes.

The bigger issue for us has been getting young new hires to have the confidence to speak up. To try to remedy this, I make it a practice to speak at the orientation sessions for new hires, where I talk about the mistakes we’ve made and the lessons we’ve learned. My intent is to persuade them that we haven’t gotten it all figured out and that we want everyone to question why we’re doing something that doesn’t seem to make sense to them. We do not want people to assume that because we are successful, everything we do is right. . . .

For 20 years, I pursued a dream of making the first computer-animated film. To be honest, after that goal was realized—when we finished Toy Story—I was a bit lost. But then I realized the most exciting thing I had ever done was to help create the unique environment that allowed that film to be made. My new goal became, with John, to build a studio that had the depth, robustness, and will to keep searching for the hard truths that preserve the confluence of forces necessary to create magic. In the two years since Pixar’s merger with Disney, we’ve had the good fortune to expand that goal to include the revival of Disney Animation Studios. It has been extremely gratifying to see the principles and approaches we developed at Pixar transform this studio. But the ultimate test of whether John and I have achieved our goals is if Pixar and Disney are still producing animated films that touch world culture in a positive way long after we two, and our friends who founded and built Pixar with us, are gone.

A version of this article appeared in the September 2008 issue of Harvard Business Review.

How Pixar Fosters Collective Creativity – HBR

This article is about COMMUNICATION

⊕ FOLLOW THIS TOPIC

Related Topics: CREATIVITY | ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE | PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT | MEDIA

Comments

Leave a Comment

POST

0 COMMENTS

⌄ JOIN THE CONVERSATION

POSTING GUIDELINES

We hope the conversations that take place on HBR.org will be energetic, constructive, and thought-provoking. To comment, readers must sign in or register. And to ensure the quality of the discussion, our moderating team will review all comments and may edit them for clarity, length, and relevance. Comments that are overly promotional, mean-spirited, or off-topic may be deleted per the moderators' judgment. All postings become the property of Harvard Business Publishing.

Johns Hopkins University Office of the Registrar

THE KEYSER QUADRANGLE LINE UP AND PROCESSION FOR THE UNIVERSITY-WIDE CEREMONY 2015

THE PROCESSION

At 8:25 a.m., begin with Peabody, Nursing, WSE, and KSAS Banner Carriers, and Marshal Daviles (left line), and Marshal Verrier (right line) with the onstage candidates begin the procession from the north east corner of the Keyser Quadrangle.

Forming the right and left aisles of the procession, Marshals [illegible] and [illegible] lead Peabody and Nursing followed by Marshal Castelo leading WSE. All other Engineering groups follow Marshal Alvarez and Marshal Sanchez lead KSAS and link behind the last group of WSE. All other KSAS groups follow Marshal [illegible] and Marshal [illegible]. Marshals [illegible] lead the right and left gates (see page 2). The faculty leads, coming from the Student Athlete Lounge and Newton White Athletic Center, lead the faculty to the center gate and link behind the Keyser procession. The Principals Marshals, coming from the Cordish Lacrosse Center, lead the Readers and Stage participants and link behind the faculty. Chief Marshal Lieberman leads the President’s party to the stage and ends the procession.

ORDER OF ENTRY

The procession will leave the Keyser Quadrangle, proceed to the top of the stairway entrance of Homewood Field. STOP, wait for the signal from Feats to continue to the center gate in front of the Cordish Lacrosse Center, and the next signal to enter the field. The first followed by the undergraduate candidates. The graduate candidates march four across in degree and alphabetical order through the tower and proceed down the center aisle or down the interior side aisle or down the interior side aisle as directed by Feats to the field. The candidates march on the field; wait for the signal from Feats to process onto the field and meet the undergraduate procession at the center of the field. The left and right interior and exterior seating areas.

Marshal Mucrufess and Marshal Mark, Keyser 1, Peabody and Nursing

Marshal [illegible] and Marshal [illegible], Keyser 2, B.S. in Biomedical Eng., Mathematics followed by:

Marshal Gray and Marshal Wang

Marshal Gray and Marshal Winslow, Keyser 4, B.S. Chemical and Biomolecular Eng., Science, Electrical Eng., Engineering Mechanics

Marshal [illegible] and Marshal H. Katz, Keyser 6, B.S. Environmental Eng., Materials Science, Mechanical Eng., B.A. AM, B.A. BME, B.A. CS.

Marshal Homer and Marshal H. Katz, Keyser 8, B.S. Environmental Eng., Materials Science, Mechanical Eng., B.A. AM, B.A. BME, B.A. CS.

Marshal Arreola and Marshal Sanchez follow with KSAS, Keyser 7, Bachelors of Science in Biology and Cellular Biology followed by:

Marshal Brueffet and Marshal Rodriguez Solomon, Keyser 9, B.A. Anthropology, Archaeology, Behavioral Biology, Biology, Biophysics.

Marshal [illegible] and Marshal [illegible], Keyser 10, B.A. Chemistry, Classics, Cognitive Science, Earth and Planetary Science, East Asian Studies

Marshal [illegible] and Marshal [illegible], Keyser 11, B.A. Economics

Marshal Beatty and Marshal [illegible], Keyser 12, B.A. English, Film and Media Studies, Global Environmental Change, History, History of Art, History of Science

Marshal [illegible] and Marshal King, Keyser 13, B.A. International Studies

Marshal Nosser and Marshal Sanders, Keyser 14, B.A. Italian, Mathematics, Natural Sciences, Philosophy, Physics, Political Science

Marshal Eakin and Marshal Trullinger, Keyser 15, B.A. Psychology

Marshal Finn and Marshal White, Keyser 16, B.A. Public Health Studies A-K

Marshal Ferguson and Marshal [illegible], Keyser 17, B.A. Public Health Studies L-Z

Marshal McCartney, Keyser 18, B.A. Romance Languages, Sociology, Spanish, Writing Seminars

In the event of rain, all Marshals and students should report to the rooms below according to section number:

Room

Group

Mudd Lobby

Band, Banner Carriers

Mudd 100

On Stage Candidates

Mudd Atrium

Keyser Sections 2, 3, 4

Mudd 26

Keyser Sections 5, 6

Remsen 101

Keyser Sections 7, 8

Remsen 1

Keyser Sections 9, 10, 11, 12

Jenkins Hall First Floor Hallway

Keyser Sections 13

Jenkins Hall First Floor Hallway

Keyser Sections 14, 15

Mergenthaler First Floor

Keyser Sections 16, 17, 18

Gilman Tunnel

Keyser Sections 16, 17, 18

MARSHALS SEATING

Marshals Deveny, King, and White sit in the seats located at the far house left end (outer aisle) of the first row in the left bay of seats. Marshals King, Barrick, and Smith sit in the seats located at the far house right end (outer aisle) of the first row in the right bay of seats. Marshals Reiter and Trujillo sit in the first two seats of the first row of the center aisle. Marshals Verrier and Smedick sit in the first two seats of the center aisle. Each of these seats will be marked reserved. All marshals should stand as their groups fill the seating areas. Undergraduate marshals should save a seat for themselves along the center aisle.

Gilman Hall

  • Rm 218 — Registrar Supplies
  • Keyser 18 KSAS (76) — B.A.: Romance Languages, Sociology, Spanish, Writing Seminars
  • Keyser 17 KSAS (71) — Ferguson, Sharrar; B.A.: Public Health L-Z
  • Keyser 16 KSAS (73) — Finn, White; B.A.: Public Health A-K
  • Gilman Tunnel
  • Jenkins Hall
  • Mergenthaler Hall

4/30/15

Keyser 6 WSE (95)

[unclear: first listed name], Katz

BS: Environmental Materials Science, Mechanical;

BA: [unclear]

BA BME, BA CS

Faculty Robing

HERO

Cap & Gown Help

Krieger Hall

Rm 205

McDonald, Mohr

BA: Chemistry,

Classics,

Cognitive Science,

Earth and Planetary

Science,

East Asian Studies

Keyser 13 KSAS (87)

[unclear: Citti], King

BA: International Studies

Keyser 14 KSAS (79)

Mossier, Sanders

BA: Italian, Mathematics,

Natural Sciences, Philosophy,

Physics, Political Science

Keyser 12 KSAS (60)

[unclear: De Wolff], Friedman

BA: English, Film and Media Studies,

Global Environmental Change,

History, History of Art, History of Science

Keyser 8 KSAS (106)

Breckenridge, Ferrara

BS Neuroscience,

BA Neuroscience,

BS Physics

Keyser 9 KSAS (62)

[unclear: Bruffett], Rodriguez, Solomon

BA: Anthropology, Archaeology,

Behavioral Biology, Biology, Biophysics

Keyser 11 KSAS (83)

Beatty, Nance

BA:

Economics

To

Mudd Hall

Lobby Atrium

Rm 100

Remsen

Hall

Rm 101

Keyser 5 WSE (84)

More, Reifer

BS Civil, Computer Eng, Computer Science,

Electrical Eng, Engineering Mechanics

Keyser 7 KSAS (79)

Aranow, Sanchez

BS Molecular and Cellular Biology

Keyser 4 WSE (73)

Galey Wilson

BS Chemical and Biomolecular

Eisenhower Library

Keyser 3 WSE (122)

Jung, Wang

BS Biomedical

Keyser 2 WSE (41)

Castillo

BS Applied Mathematics

Keyser 1 (37)

Peabody (37) Nursing (0)

[unclear: Nuchenfuss], Mark

Bachelor of Music, BS

Senior Walk to

Homewood Field begins

here.

Band & Banners

On Stage

Candidates

Drinks

SW N

Sources

SGA Commencement 2015.pdf