SENATE OF THE JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION
Consolidated General Body Meeting Agenda and Minutes
October 15, 2019
7:00 PM to 9:00 PM, Charles Commons East Room
Agenda
Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)
Reports (15 min)
Executive Board Reports (4 min)
Committee Reports (7 min)
Academic Affairs — Senator Shajihan
Civic Engagement — President Mudrak
Finance — Senator Mays
Health, Safety, and Sustainability — Senator Gorman, Senator Lee
Internal Affairs — Senator Al-Jabi-Lopez
Student Organizations — Senator McAdams
Student Services — Senator Ali
Class Council Reports (4 min)
Advisor Report (3 min)
New Business (50 min)
Committee Confirmations [Link]—Vice President Chien (5 min)
Confirmation of a Member-at-Large of the Civic Engagement Committee [Link]—President Mudrak (5 min)
Reproductive Health & Emergency Contraception Survey Bill [Link]—Senator Lee (10 min)
Activism Fair Reimbursement Bill [Link]—President Mudrak (10 min)
Animal Testing Resolution [Link]—Senator Weidgenant (10 min)
SGA Gun Safety Forum Invitations [Link]—President Patel (10 min)
Prospective Business (5 min)
Advancing Legislation
Announcements
Public Input Period
Closed Session (5 min)
Adjournment (ESTIMATED 8:10 PM)
Time-length and adjournment estimates are provided for the benefit of guests at Senate meetings. However, SGA meetings are always slated to extend until 9:00 PM and SGA members are expected to remain in the Senate chamber until official adjournment by motion, whether before or after the adjournment estimate.
Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)
Reports (15 min)
Executive Board Reports (4 min)
VP Chien: Admin reception next week instead of meeting
Exec Parmar: collate stuff for One SGA Bill, committees
Committee Reports (7 min)
Academic Affairs — Senator Shajihan
Jesse Martin, Ariane Kelly meeting to work on PILOT
Everyone meet after GBM
Civic Engagement — President Mudrak
Conformation of member at large, animal testing, reimbursement for soph class council
Finance — Senator Mays
Passed bill
Health, Safety, and Sustainability — Senator Gorman, Senator Lee
Have wellness week soon
Lana = climate, Chanel = sex week
Internal Affairs — Senator Al-Jabi-Lopez
nothing
Student Organizations — Senator McAdams
Financial module + discussing concerns about audit
Student Services — Senator Ali
Not present
Class Council Reports (4 min)
Pavan - senator taking leave of absence from university, so sending out application
Isaac - halloween party, mid-game football event, so fri following this one, giving out pizza, have raffle
Nathan - reverse trick or treat, social media, email, Garden Party
Breanna - social media, email, Halloween, rented room
Advisor Report (3 min)
Architects for stu center = 4-5 tmrw, first w architects, second = orgs part
Required trainings roll out in next week or so, REQUIRED, completed online, share w constituents
Finance module after fall break
New Business (50 min)
Committee Confirmations [Link]—Vice President Chien (5 min)
Confirmation of a Member-at-Large of the Civic Engagement Committee [Link]—President Mudrak (5 min)
Reproductive Health & Emergency Contraception Survey Bill [Link]—Senator Lee (10 min)
Withdrawn
Activism Fair Reimbursement Bill [Link]—President Mudrak (10 min)
Kahmil - motion to vote
Voting -
Ay - unanimous
Nay -
Animal Testing Resolution [Link]—Senator Weidgenant (10 min)
Lana -
Recently 4.25 million to universities to reduce / elim animal testing
We received $850,000
Less human relevant, less effective, very costly
EPA takes away 30% of testing, elim it by 2035
Chase - 10 min mod caucus w 30 sec speaking times
System probably internal bc federal govt, so in case of audit
Lana -
Doesn’t include birds, fish, or mice
Info public to ensure Hopkins is making things public
Nathan -
Commend Lana for work
Addressed all of our points, concerns -- has been through ringer w our committee
Kahmil -
Amend def of animal for consistency sake
Lana -
Going by EPA reduction in testing
Jake -
30% - is that realistic or optimistic guideline?
Lana -
That is the timeline from EPA, so also to other peer institutions and they also follow this
Kahmil -
What are implications of this? Potential conflicts -- student protest
Lana -
Just saying we believe that we should move towards other alternatives, not giving a strong statement
Chase -
EPA not as high as NIH
Lana -
Not just responding but also
Pritika -
Alternatives
Lana -
In vitro models, technology based on how human body works, rather than using model
Pavan -
In vitro then in vivo, so taking stage out dec scientific research, out of vital stage of process
Lana -
Timeline for this reason, in vitro can happen ultimately
Elquis -
Very optimistic standard
Chase -
850,000 vs 2.1 million -- mice = cheap-ish alternative
Lana -
Center for alternatives to animal testing at Hopkins, so given recent progress, looking at future of science
Adelle - point of order, more of Q+A than mod caucus
Katie - 2 min caucus, 30 sec
Don’t believe should be alternative funding JHU gets -- however much given not that much, but by accepting money, uphold principles that Lana has set out
Will -
Optimism = stubborn view, should strive for it, not going to get perfect goal, but should be taken into account
EPA on timeline, so have to follow / should follow
Tobi -
No harm in passing this resolution
Leaders in research, so should try to move to better methods
Chase -
Not sure something SGA should be saying, fed agencies already doing this at the end of the day
Also will try to strive for the best way to pursue research
Jake -
Conflict only on second part, extension / recognition of EPA policy
Want numbers to be published, or just comply w/ EPA funding, not doing rn, only sticking point, so remove that and move forward
Isaac -
Could we get student survey data to compound resolution, just to attach with the resolution?
Chase -
Given amount of research, declaring position without asking = hasty, should get some more info from student body as a whole before taking position
Talal -
In support of animal research if in compliance, so don’t need a need, seeing what it has done esp at this university
Evan - extend by 5 min, 30 sec
Don’t think we need to have data on every resolution or this one, if rep ppl who voted for us, our opinions should be representative of the body that voted for us
Kahmil -
Def need for survey - exactly kind of instance where can use PRDC
Importance of research to stus here -- bc seems liberal, that’s what we should move with
Talal -
Were elected, should rep but don’t think this is something we can voice our opinions on
Elquis -
Understand ethos, not perfect, has it’s flaws, mechanistically, not perfect, but very useful nonetheless
Should be a poll
Jake -
Reiterate - second half = problem, just pass first part of it
Survey on second half, leave door open for second
Lana -
Open to doing a survey -- wouldn’t be necessary, but would be open to doing a resolution
EPA funding not the most successful motivator in the past
Isaac - motion to end mod caucus
Chase - motion to table for 3 weeks (to complete the survey), Kahmil seconded that (23) - 19 to 4
Ay - 4
Nay - 19
Evan - table bill (11-10-2)
Ay - 11
Nay - 10
Abstain - 2
SGA Gun Safety Forum Invitations [Link]—President Patel (10 min)
Pavan -
Initiate conversation w leaders in the field (sending invitations to this list)
Undergrads that are trying to be on the frontlines of activism should be able to communicate w those who are legislating on this today
Anthony - 10 min, 30 sec speaking times
Question = if stim discussion, will be pretty similar bc all on same side of the issue
Bring in some conservatives also, what was rationale
Pavan -
Good point - too homogenous, reason = fighting for more gun control, can get in touch without cold calling
If have ideas, open to adding them as well
Elquis -
Don’t have to be conservative (pro-gun liberal groups)
Believe in 2nd amendment
Calvin -
Uni perspective, have to make opportunity available for all running for office
Government affairs and general council
Nathan -
Know that civic engagement was not informed about this, haven’t had the chance to look through this
Want to be careful of this at this institution
Adelle -
Agree w Nathan
Purpose mass shooting = impt, but in Baltimore, so daily lives, regular citizens also worry about this
Invite some of them? lots of snaps
Kahmil -
Pavan’s event, just wants an approval from SGA
Looks like an opportunity to facilitate positive public media for them at the expense of father of victim here
Pavan -
Don’t need SGA approval for smaller groups
Need SGA for that
Dr. Sakran suggested these ppl bc has connections, good friends w father
Emma -
Name is pretty general, school shootings = really small amount
If school shootings, call it that
Anthony -
Control vs safety
Don’t need candidates for safety but control = legislators also
Talal -
Control = politically driven, safety = not
Baltimore comm and probs, not talking about gun safety in Baltimore = bad
Pavan -
Great points, none opposed to, but don’t need SGA letterhead to get them, but for these do need
Nathan -
Motion to close, Adelle seconds
Chase -
Already discussed it overall, so why tabled
Nathan - move to Civic Engagement committee (6-17)
Ay - 111111
Nay - 111111111
Chase - vote (5-18)
Ay - 5
Nay - 18
Prospective Business (5 min)
Advancing Legislation
Will - SAC to amend Chase’s recent bill
Weird pressure for SAC members to work w/ the Finance committee (voting w/ ppl who can remove them -- pretty easily)
⅔ within all of SAC, ⅔ within Senate to cut from SAC
Anthony - special forum act
Submit to SGA and we will provide facilitated discussion
Chanel - Wellness Wednesday
Lana - Climate Emergency, what should be done
Mariam - Sexual Assault Survivors
Announcements
Adelle - VP for Hop Dems, debate watch party in Mudd 26 (before or after Kenan) -- hopefully food
Chanel - WINGS co-hosting rally in DC
Emma - Oct 26-28 American policy in Middle East, impt speakers, if want full list, online → just got code to register for free, transport covered (DC)
Calvin - Happy Fall Break!! (soon)
Public Input Period
Closed Session (5 min)
Adjournment (ESTIMATED 8:10 PM)
