SENATE OF THE JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION
Consolidated General Body Meeting Agenda and Minutes
February 5th, 2019
7:00 PM, Charles Commons East Room
Agenda
Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)
Approval of the Agenda & Prior Minutes (1 min)
Presentation on the Public Safety Legislative Timeline (Smita Ruzicka (Dean of Student Life); Rianna Matthews-Brown (Director of University Initiatives); Mary Clapsaddle (Director of State Affairs, Government & Community Affairs); Chris Presberry (Executive Director of Campus Safety & Security); Jarron Jackson (Acting Senior Director, Campus Safety & Security)) (30 min)
Interim Study
Draft of Proposed Legislation
Proposal Summary
Community Engagement Timeline
Reports (18 min)
Executive Board Reports (4 min)
Committee Reports (7 min)
Academic Affairs — Senator Taj
Civic Engagement — President Schatmeyer, Senator Paulet
Finance — Senator Mays, Treasurer Tu
Health, Safety and Sustainability — Senator Paulet, Senator Patel
Internal Affairs — Senator Baron, Vice President Tsang
Student Organizations — President Chien, Senator Elgendi
Student Services — Senator Cai, President Schatmeyer
Class Council Reports (4 min)
Advisor Report (3 min)
New Business (65 min)
Inauguration and Committee Confirmation Vote of Junior Class Senator Claire Gorman (5 min)
Academic Affairs Co-Chairship Vote for Senator Miranda Bannister (1 min)
Co-Sponsorship & Branding Policy Bill [Link] — Senators Patel, Baron (15 min)
Commhttps://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1VcNMrDsIyNGxb0uVY9rs5tyHgSQVuMiYHXQBQUjagkU/edit#gid=0unity Sleds Bill [Link] — Senator Mollin (15 min)
Announcement from Hopkins Coalition Against ICE (10 min)
Attendance Records Discussion [Link] (10 min)
Internal Community-Building Initiative [fLink] (10 min)
Prospective Business (5 min)
Advancing Legislation
Announcements
Public Input Period
Adjournment
SGA meetings typically end around 9:00 PM. While the length of Senate meetings is not set by SGA’s guiding documents, historical averages have been as high as 3-4 hours (during the early- to mid-2010s) to as low as 1.5 hours (2017-2018).
MINUTES
Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)
Roll called
Approval of the Agenda & Prior Minutes (1 min)
Agenda Approved
Presentation on the Public Safety Legislative Timeline (Smita Ruzicka (Dean of Student Life); Rianna Matthews-Brown (Director of University Initiatives); Mary Clapsaddle (Director of State Affairs, Government & Community Affairs); Chris Presberry (Executive Director of Campus Safety & Security); Jarron Jackson (Acting Senior Director, Campus Safety & Security)) (30 min)
Interim Study
Draft of Proposed Legislation
Proposal Summary
Community Engagement Timeline
See Presentations and documents
Matthews-Brown: many meetings with students and community for their “summer” study - then wrote report from findings from those meetings; look at the appendices in the report - summarize what other colleague institutions do
President Mebrahtu - who will be a member of the hearings board for officers?
State authorized agency - requirements would be applied like a police department - police have “Bill of Rights” - up to two civilians member of the hearing board - continue to hold ourselves to be accountable - civilians must be trained - boards are established as need arises - board recommend a course of action and the officer can appeal it to a hearing board
President Schatmeyer - 3 officers from other agencies?
Yes from other law enforcement agencies. Hearing board is mandated by state law. Reference language in document.
Mary Clapsaddle: proposed legislation, they learned about issues of accountability, full acceptance of having civilians on the hearing board, subject to Baltimore City Civilian Review Board - can monitor if a disciplinary measure was fair and correct - 15 member police accountability board - would be ongoing with area police, legislation sets out training and hiring expectations - treatment of youth or in crisis, minorities, appropriate use of technology and force, language may change during the legislative process - language was only proposed by Hop, senate bill 798 was introduced into the general maryland assembly by senator Antonio Hayes, bill text is not available online but the summary is, there are other elements in the bill that address the root causes of crime, additional funding for youth works programs, additional funding for community development investments around the state, police cadet program, house version of the bill will be introduced later this week, because it’s a city specific bill, Bmore delegation will be able to look/change it first, city house members will meet to discuss and consider amendments, there will be a hearing in the committee of jurisdiction, house will be looked at by judiciary committee, will move to full chamber of senate and house for action, now that the bills have been introduced can happen at any time, session ends on April 8th by midnight, everyone can go to annapolis to testify and go to hearings, all available on MD general assembly website, how can CE educate student on contacting legislators.
Senator Forlenza - how will accountability board members be chosen?
Has not been defined in legislation - will be some nomination and consultation process, mayor gets an appointment, hopkins gets 3 appointments
MOU with baltimore police department, bill is specific to which situations JHUPD will be primary or secondary, MOU process starts after legislation has passed, nomination would not be in MOU, more internal than an MOU
How can we engage with legislation? MOU process is secondary to legislative process
Chris Presberry and Jarron Jackson - not remaining static with current security we have - more training for officers - hired a new enterprise wide training director - training for impartial and nondiscriminatory policing - prevention of profiling and implicit bias - when officers are interacting with individuals with behaviour concern/disabilities/in crisis/survivors of sexual assault - ICAT: created by PERF, de-escalation training for those in crisis, train officers to be trainers - goal is 100% trained
President Schatmeyer - who is the new trainer?
Cannot say now
Secretary Williams - timeline for 100% trained
Does not want to have a time frame and now make it
Senator Uraih - allied universal and police will have the same training?
Will be across the enterprise - part of the need of having an enterprise wide director so they are all trained the same way with the same standard
Senator Uraih - students have complaining of harassment from current security
Heard this from forums - refresher with title 9 and non-harassment measures
Senator Wellons - people with disabilities - disability is not mentioned in the language of the recommendation - will it be in the bill?
Meeting with ADA training that is specific to homewood campus
Senator Baron - ratio of allied universal to officers?
If legislation passes, 100 officers over 5 year period across all campuses - will be 60 officers on the street - other 40 are IA and supervisors - 3 officers per shift - 300 allied personnel - current security structure will remain
President Schatmeyer - apprehended and taken into custody - where are you taken
Going to lock up/central booking
Senator Mollin - what is the lock up/central booking
CBIF everyone arrested in Baltimore City is taken
Threshold for arresting students will still be the same - will be sent to student conduct
Senator Elgendi - underage drinking?
Currently there would be a conduct report - will probably stay the same - only talking about serious crime - JHUPD is afforded with more resources than BPD - not just making arrests
Senator Bhamidipati - arrest by allied officers
Scope of allied is citizens arrest
Senator Uraih - BPD has responsibility for most crimes - will anything outside of the scope of JHUPD be un-suable by Baltimore citizens
Complicated legal question
Senator Elgendi - will they have the capacity to give out fines and parking tickets
Would have the capacity but we have a parking enforcement unit anyway
Reports (18 min)
Executive Board Reports (4 min)
President
Met with Dean Wilson - student teacher interactions
Possibly academic scholarships to sponsor refugees - Baltimore refugee youth project
Calvin - comprehensive meeting - social report - introducing legislation
VP Farouk - student culture - how to engage students post college
VD Faulkner - syllabus on SIS
SAPP - see if they can go to annapolis
JHUPD - Washington post reached out to ask questions - article is out
Vice President
Winter Retreat
Thank you all for coming! We had important discussions on Who We Are and What We Want to Do. Summaries of those discussions have been emailed out.
Wellbeing Champions
Working on a 1-page concept document that Sarah Cunningham will present to her faculty consultation group of 4 faculty.
Renewable Energy Resolution
Met with Sam, Omar, Aspen and Clarissa at the end of last semester. We took a pause on working on it for the holidays, and going forward we’ll be breaking up the research into different parts and are aiming for a mid- to late-February vote on the resolution, which will call for divestment to be coupled with proportionate investments in renewable energy.
Community Council Initiative
As you might recall from the dinner with Daniels, now that we have blessings from President Daniels and Provost Kumar, it’s our hope to move forward with a more detailed proposal and conversations with folks all across the University.
After the dinner, Provost Kumar recommended we meet with him soon to discuss next actions. We will be reaching out to him soon to schedule a meeting, as well as other constituent groups who would be interested in what it would look like, including various student governments from across Hopkins.
Baltimorean Student Government Conference
Went to the first ever Baltimore Collegetown conference of different student government leaders from across the city, including institutions like Loyola, Notre Dame, UMBC, Goucher, Stevenson and Morgan State.
The conference was at Morgan State and had 50 reps from across these institutions. Talked about civic engagement and translating student government experience to the world after college.
Met a lot of really kind and passionate Loyola kids; given their proximity, we spoke about the possibility of having a joint meeting sometime this semester, given that their meetings are almost exactly the same time as ours.
Agora Governors’ Event
Exec went to the Agora Governors’ event last Monday night on the invitation of Elizabeth Smyth. Met Governor Hogan, Governor Sununu of New Hampshire, Governor Wolff of Pennsylvania.
Agora Institute Trip to Annapolis
Aspen and I are going to Annapolis with Agora on February 13th (next Wednesday) to discuss with legislators the value that Agora will bring to civic discourse for the University and the city.
Attendance Sheet
Updated, sent out.
SGA Alumni Database
Didn’t get as far on my SGA history project as I hoped; someone actually checked out our paper records from the 20th century from the Library, until JUNE, and we don’t know who it was.
But, I built an internal SGA alumni database over Break, with the current positions and fields of students who served in SGA, with full accounting for the last 5-6 years of alumni, and partial accounting going back to the 70s and 80s.
This will be the foundation of our SGA Alumni Network/Advisory Board. From medicine and public health to law and finance, we have a lot of high powered alumni.
SGA Alumni Networking Reception
Confirmed for Saturday, April 6th from 4-6 PM in the Clipper Room in Shriver, which is now re-opened. It’s officially on the Alumni Weekend page. We’re going to need your help in sending out personal invites to alumni.
Senator Boroumound - I have built a solid network of orgs in baltimore who would be willing to help with scholarships - more collaborative
Treasurer
Budget: Cont. 6231, Events 2520, Op: 0 SAC Grants 32877
Secretary
Referendum still going on - will not stop till propositions are completed - data on JHUPD will be sent out via email and be available to students/NL etc. In person voting will continue
Trustee Scheeler has offered to look over the report
Met with Loyola Rep to discuss mixed programming events with their student body
Call with SGA alum - event being planned
Committee Reports (7 min)
Academic Affairs — Senator Taj
Nominate Miranda Bannister as cochair - has done a lot of great work
Dealing with student body for incorporating someone new into the body - will be nominated in GBM
Civic Engagement — President Schatmeyer, Senator Paulet
Meet this weekend
Finance — Senator Mays, Treasurer Tu
Passed bill on agenda
Experiment with online meetings
Health, Safety and Sustainability — Senator Paulet, Senator Patel
Tobacco policy - cessation resources - expected in march - ask HR person find a contractor - meet with GRO on Feb. 11th to discuss this
Healthy Hopkins is live - on survey money - nutritional counseling - difficult to find meetings - looking to find another nutritionist
Composting - Lauren and Sam meeting with housing director
Organizing mental health summit, all HSS members attend - inviting a speaker - paid for by HMR and OMS - would be great if all senator came
Wellness wednesdays - met with Calvin - trying to engage with greek life - 3 councils - Feb. 9 - would be good to interact with other student orgs
Menstruation Products - placing boxes for distribution - meeting with reps from operations and other student orgs for sustainability
Internal Affairs — Senator Baron, Vice President Tsang
Bill coming forward
Student Organizations — President Chien, Senator Elgendi
Waiting for re registration
Working on establishing some groups
SIF is Friday
Student Services — Senator Cai, President Schatmeyer
No report
Class Council Reports (4 min)
Seniors
Hosted an event with free shirts and drinks - 200 shirts ran out within an hour - planning our senior week - sendoffs to seniors - CC meeting will be on Tuesdays
Juniors
Met on sunday - talked about a lot
Sophomores
Grants given out by next tuesday
Sophshow prizes should be out
Garden party planning has started
Sophomore week leading up to garden party
Freshmen
Sending out january email
FreshWeek - several events planned out - starting tuesday - banquet and formal are coming together - invitations where students can sign up together
Formal logistics - getting in orders
Advisor Report (3 min)
Will be getting some emails to schedule time to meet - President and Chairs
New Business (65 min)
Inauguration and Committee Confirmation Vote of Junior Class Senator Claire Gorman (5 min)
She was inaugurated!!
Motion to Appoint Senator Bannister as CoChair of Academic Affairs
She was appointed!!
Co-Sponsorship & Branding Policy Bill [Link] — Senators Patel, Baron (15 min)
Senators Presented Bill: Basically says that student groups need to market our contribution - helps our brand - added a two week period prior to event unless extenuating circumstances
Senator Bannister - will we be explaining or will they get a list of their demands?
Burden is on the senator and committee to educate student orgs who want money - will be added to template
Motion to Introduce and Approve
Passes unanimously
Community Sleds Bill [Link] — Senator Mollin (15 min)
Senator Mollin Presents - 2 sleds and 4 helmets - never any material for sleds - total $210 - marketing: when we think it’s going to snow out - secretary will go on Orca and tell people that there are sleds available - liability waiver - forward it to risk management - she’ll send it to experiential education - Section 5.c. risk management is in the process of approving waiver - if not approved the sleds won’t be bought now - people will not be allowed to use sleds without signing waiver
Senator Baron - liability waivers are not approved currently correct?
Waiting for a response from risk management so we’re still in the process
Senator Baron - why are we passing the bill now when it’s not approved?
We can table now but there is severability contingent on risk management approving the waiver
Senator Patel - conditional statement for risk management so not a problem. How do I get a sled?
Delegated to Student Services - in charge of handling sleds - storage location will be advertised on ORCA slides - authority delegated to student services - can find another solution - can work with brody
Senator Wellons - how much space is in storage closet?
There’s room
Senator Mays - are there stickers for SGA? - can we decorate the sled
Senator Bhamidipati - we were promised jackets - NIO
Senator Patel - if committee is not meeting, how do people get the sled
Up to student services
Senator Gorman - can we include cleaner for helmets
Yes
President Schatmeyer - as CoChair of SS - I’m good with the sleds
Senator Bouftas - can we use the funding for helmets for more sleds?
We can debate about it
Senator Bannister - helmets are not that necessary - also head lice
Risk management will not approve without helmets
Senator Uraih - looks good as a bill - Motion to end
Motion passes
Motion to introduce and approve
Discussion
Senator Mays - Amendment to B3 - will either add SGA stickers to sleds and helmets or SGA’s name on sleds
Senator Mollin - delegate to SS
Motion Passes
President Schatmeyer - this is a really cool idea and very tangible - commend Sam for writing this bill and taking the initiative and for all the work he has put in - something this positive and properly vetted
Secretary Williams - is there safeguards for sustainability
Sent to student services
Senator Panakam
Sustainability is important - similar to menstruation products - may just be passed around forever - what if SS isn’t here - will they be watching the sleds - some contingencies you have to think about - how can we divvy up that time?
Senator Bannister - sign out list for the sleds - you are responsible for it until it’s returned - SS does not need to be in the snow - support the bill regardless
Senator Mudrak - is there consideration to using student monitors in levering? Can they hand those out?
Senator Wellons - I can talk to them about it but SLI needs to approve it - table for now
President Schatmeyer - do not let perfect become the enemy of the good - while there are things that need to be worked out it will be okay
President Habib - would you be willing to table?
Senator Mollin - open to an amendment codifying sustainability - will be a better use if SS works on this - open to tabling it - we vote on tabling
Senator Baron - JHOC and OP rent equipment and have events - can we partner with them since they have the liability waivers completed
Senator Bannister - we should email these questions to the authors of the bill
Senator Patel - we should table
Senator Mollin - motion to table
Nays: 1111111111111111111111
Yays: 111
Senator Mollin - motion to end discussion
Vote on bill
Nays: 11111
Yays: 21
Announcement from Hopkins Coalition Against ICE (10 min)
Connor Bean:
Spoke here a couple months back - can we endorse action tomorrow - walk out and march around campus - this is an escalation from last action - did not elicit response from administration - asking Hopkins what medical training it’s providing - have not heard anything - expecting 4x as many people - 3 classes cancelled - can they get SGA endorsement?
Senator Wellons - is the route for the protest accessible
Yes
Senator Patel - who are you reaching out to for medical questions
Reaching to administrators in School of Education
Senator Uraih - you have a good base - how can we help specifically - can you send out an email to undergrad student body - flier materials can be passed out -
Senator Bannister -what does mildly destructive mean?
Loud but not in class
Motion to endorse walkout
Seconded
Senator Elgendi - how can it negatively affect us - what will the university do to us?
VP Tsang - the school has worked with previous rallies and there have been no consequences
Advisor Smith - the students can be held to conduct code
Senator Elgendi - does noise count as disruption?
Advisor Smith - if people can’t focus during a test then that can be a disruption - walking out is not a disruption
Senator Taj - is this just a walkout?
Walkout and march
Senator Taj - if there are hundreds of people that walk through brody - could we get in trouble for that, we should walk through brody
We already have too many speakers planned - there were no ramifications - had reached out to security and Moses Davis
Advisor Smith - working with Dean Davis
Senator Sharon - you wanted us to endorse it - you also mentioned distributing what does that look like?
We can give you fliers to had out
Senator Bannister - this is just as important as the Juan Obarrio protest - it’s an easy way for us to convey concern for the community - it an important walkout to be a part of - we’ve had protests go through many buildings - there were no repercussions - if you’re worried, don’t come
Senator Patel - motion to end discussion
Motion passes
Nays: 1
Abstentions: 1111
Ayes: 19
Attendance Records Discussion [Link] (10 min)
Discussed at retreat - being transparent with attendance - they are public to the general student body - does not say to what degree they must be public
Senator Patel - this is a discussion about attendance records sent to the student body
Motion to move to next week - 1 Nays 23 Ayes
Internal Community-Building Initiative [Link] (10 min)
Have people bake snacks for GBM’s, groups would be an even mix of classes
Senator Panakam - this should be on a volunteer basis - should not mandate this to senators
Senator Elgendi - great idea, we should approve it here but not make attendance mandatory
Senator Patel - can we volunteer for a specific day
Senator Uraih - if it’s optional
Senator Mollin - motion to end discussion
Passes
Prospective Business (5 min)
Advancing Legislation
Senator Patel - sga has oversight of a lot of money - suggest that we have long standing access to the money from SAC
Senator Uraih - black caucus and senior week
Senator Boroumound - FAS events
Announcements
Public Input Period
Adjournment
Motion to Adjourn
Passes
