Parliamentary Procedure
AJ Tsang, Executive Vice President
What is parliamentary procedure?
The Varieties of Parliamentary Procedure
Parliamentary procedure is actually like a tree!
Many forms:
Westminster Form (UK and British Commonwealth)
Robert’s Rules of Order (United States)
CSN (Canada)
United Nations
Even in one form, you can achieve the same effect with different motions
What We Use
Our Bylaws specify:
Robert’s Rules of Order, 11th Edition (2003)
For your convenience, we are publishing a condensed version:
The JHU SGA Parliamentary Procedure Guide (October 2017)
Parliamentary precedence:
SGA Constitution
SGA Bylaws
SGA Rules Bill
Robert’s Rules of Order/SGA Parliamentary Procedure Guide
Imports from other forms
Translating Between Parliamentary “Languages”
The Bylaws specify Robert’s Rules, but we will recognize equivalent language from other methodologies:
Ex:
RR: “Division of the Motion” = UN: “Division of the Question”
RR: “I move to limit speaking time to 30 seconds” = UN: “I move for a moderated caucus of X minutes with 30 second speaking times.”
RR: “I move to end debate” = RR: “I move to end discussion”
We allow certain “imported” techniques - discussed in future slides.
Getting Started:
Motions and Amendments
First, quorum is needed for all SGA meetings.
Quorum is defined in Robert’s Rules as at least 50% of the seated members of a body.
This video shows how NOT to attain quorum.
Introductory Video on Motions
Types of Motions
Precedence: Privileged, Incidental, Subsidiary/Secondary, Main/Primary
Motions take priority by categorical order
Privileged
Ex: Question of room condition
Incidental
Ex: Point of order, point of information, suspend the rules, withdraw a motion
Secondary/Subsidiary
Ex: Amendments, amendments to amendments, suspend the rules
Main/Primary
Ex: Bring legislation to the floor, vote on legislation, end discussion
Unique and Useful, if Less Common, Motions
Division of the Question/Motion
Splits up the vote by section of the bill or motion
Helps pass parts of a motion without jeopardizing the whole
Refer to committee
If a matter becomes too time-consuming or requires special expertise, it can be referred to another body of the SGA
Table the matter
If a matter is taking up time but needs to be addressed, it can be tabled for specified amounts of time
Substitute (amendment derivative)
Entire motions can be substituted, if you motion to amend and completely amend the original motion
Appeal
Can reverse a motion made in bad faith or judgement
Discussion
Discussion
Do:
Begin discussion after a motion passes
Be recognized by the chair to speak
Keep a civil tone and an open mind
Speak up - this is a safe space for your thoughts
Don’t:
Speak out of turn
Interrupt or harass
Attack someone personally
Clap/snap when something fails
Voting Procedure
Voting Procedure
Automatically entered if there’s no discussion
All motions contingent on simple majority votes, with some exceptions (see reference tables)
A motion to vote defaults to voice vote, however...
We document votes, so any non-unanimous vote automatically invokes a roll call vote
Imported Techniques
Import I: Moderated Caucuses (MUN import)
How it works:
Say: “I move for a [X minute] caucus with [Y second speaking times that divide equally into the overall time], to discuss the [relevant business] on the floor.”
Creates a block of time to talk about the business, subdivided into concrete speaking slots
A speakers list is automatically opened
Ex: 10 min caucus w/ 30 sec speaking times yields 20 speakers
You can speak twice in one caucus, but this is discouraged.
Speakers are cut-off at the speaking time, keeping the meeting on track
Import I: Moderated Caucuses (Continued)
At end of caucus, the floor is open and a motion must be made to vote
If no one else wants to speak in the middle of a caucus, someone has to motion to (a) exit the caucus to the floor, and then (b) someone must motion to vote
Useful Caucus Times:
10 min w/ 30 second speaking times (20 speakers)
Good for most business
12 min w/ 45 second speaking times (16 speakers)
Good for contentious business
As a general rule of thumb:
30 second speaking times are good for easy business
45 second or 1 minute speaking times are good for contentious business
Import II: Friendly and Unfriendly Amendments (MUN Import)
After an amendment is proposed and seconded, the chair asks the motion’s original proposer (or more relevant to us, the legislation’s author) if the amendment is friendly.
If friendly: amendment automatically accepted
If unfriendly: amendment subject to normal debate and vote
Import III: Round Robin (MUN Import)
Everyone gets a chance to speak for a specific amount of time (30-45 seconds)
Good way to distribute speaking time
Inclusive of quiet opinions, tempers loud opinions
Easy Reference Tables
Source: UNC Di Phi
Source: NOAA
Group Activity: Parliamentary Party!!!
