JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

Senate Meeting #08 (10 23 18)

Filed in Drive as “Senate Meeting #08 (10_23_18)”

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

SENATE OF THE JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION

Consolidated General Body Meeting Agenda and Minutes

October 23rd, 2018

7:00 PM, Charles Commons East Room

Agenda

Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)

Approval of the Agenda & Prior Minutes (1 min)

Reports (18 min)

Executive Board Reports (4 min)

Committee Reports (7 min)

Academic Affairs — Senator Taj

Civic Engagement — President Schatmeyer, Senator Paulet

Finance — Senator Mays, Treasurer Tu

Health, Safety and Sustainability — Senator Paulet, Senator Patel

Internal Affairs — Senator Baron, Vice President Tsang

Student Organizations — President Chien, Senator Elgendi

Student Services — Senator Cai, President Schatmeyer

Class Council Reports (4 min)

Advisor Report (3 min)

New Business (70 min)

Rules Bill Amendments [Link] — Vice President Tsang (20 min)

DIG Funding Bill [Link] — Senator Wellons (15 min)

Admin Dinner Prep Activity [Link] (15 min)

President Daniels Dinner Discussion [Discussion Document] (10 min)

ICE Decision Discussion (10 min)

Prospective Business (5 min)

Advancing Legislation

Announcements

Public Input Period

Adjournment (ESTIMATED 8:45 PM, ACTUAL 8:XX PM)

Time-length and adjournment estimates are provided for the benefit of guests at Senate meetings. However, SGA meetings are always slated to extend until at least 9:00 PM and SGA members are expected to remain in the Senate chamber until official adjournment by motion, whether before or after the adjournment estimate.

SUGGESTED MODERATED CAUCUSES

Rules Bill Amendments [Link] — Vice President Tsang (20 min)

15 min mod, 45 sec speaking times w/ 45 sec response times

DIG Funding Bill [Link] — Senator Wellons (15 min)

10 min mod, 1 min speaking times

Admin Dinner Prep Activity [Link] (15 min)

N/A

ICE Decision Discussion (10 min)

8 min mod, 30 sec speaking times

President Daniels Dinner Discussion [Discussion Document] (10 min)

8 min mod, 30 sec speaking times

BINGO LINGO À LA MANGO

  1. AJ says title of admin.
  2. Senate says who it is.
  3. AJ shows picture of who it is.
Kerrie CardenAndy WilsonBeverly WendlandAlanna ShanahanMichael Falk
Salem ReinerKim HewittBarbara SchubertSmita RuzickaKristen Wright
Toni BlackwellDana BroadnaxFREE SPOTWendy GeistSusan Ridge
Bob McLeanSunil KumarMatt TorresFarrouk DeyKevin Shollenberger
Erin YunSarah CunninghamEd SchlesingerJessica OrosEllen Mackenzie

HINT : SEVEN OF THE PEOPLE ON THIS BOARD ARE NOT GOING TO BE AT THE DINNER.

Priv PoliceSt CenterDivestMH AdvoOIECvrd GradesTrusteesConstitution
Yes3951281125312871311106313761225
No1191305333299275523210361
Total15861586158615861586158615861586
Yes %0.24905422450.80769230770.7900378310.81147540980.82660781840.67023959650.8675914250.7723833544
No %0.75094577550.19230769230.2099621690.18852459020.17339218160.32976040350.1324085750.2276166456
Total Needed2441.3657992269.841272320.563982259.2592592217.8998222735.3402322113.1298452373.605442
^ max needed^ low min^ practical min needed
Votes Needed855.365799683.8412698734.5639798673.2592593631.8998221149.340232527.129845787.6054422
% Progress0.64963636360.69872727270.68345454550.7020.71509090910.57981818180.75054545450.6681818182

MINUTES

Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)

Roll Taken

Approval of the Agenda & Prior Minutes (1 min)

Minutes Approved

Reports (18 min)

Executive Board Reports (4 min)

President

Planning on writing a resolution about mental health - spoke to President Daniels

Culture of mental health - reached out to Duke to ask about environment - close Brody at midnight?

We focus too much energy on sleepless nights and we need to change the culture around it

Vice President

This Friday is WellFest!!! Everyone is coming - there will be hot chocolate and healthy food - SGA is tabling

Community Council proposal - hopefully will have a draft by next week - plan to discuss with higher admins in nearby admins

Admin dinner in one week - across the hall - business formal

Seating for that is set

Went to a meeting with HR about a student faculty relationship policy - not reactive, best practice at peer institutions so we should have a policy - might bring HR to SGA - draft done by intersession and presented by spring

Met with Dean Ruzicka to update

Meeting with Brittany Shaft to discuss next university wide fundraising push

Meeting with trustee on Thursday evening

Treasurer

Read out remaining budget

We should not use operations since it’s in debt

SAC had first meeting - many student groups are unhappy

POI - expenses for operations - fall retreat, emails, intersga events

Senator Wellons - there have been a lot of issues with SLI and budget numbers - some groups are randomly in debt

Used to start fresh every year but now student groups are getting accumulated debt from the past few years

Secretary

Referendum at 1,592

Most contentious is student center - threshold is 2.735 - might change

DM Party - nearly 150 votes from that

FERPA Training

Committee Reports (7 min)

Academic Affairs — Senator Taj

Discussed upcoming logistics - got many articles about next week’s meetings

Civic Engagement — President Schatmeyer, Senator Paulet

Meeting is this saturday

Absentee ballot party

Brainstorming stuff to do after the elections

Finance — Senator Mays, Treasurer Tu

Passed a bill that’s going to the floor

Health, Safety and Sustainability — Senator Paulet, Senator Patel

Healthy Hopkins initiative

Compost bins meeting - they were bought

Wellness Wednesday - wellfest - doodle link in agenda for tabling Friday

Lifesize Jenga!!

Internal Affairs — Senator Baron, Vice President Tsang

Have all nominees - look for updates - referendum

Student Organizations — President Chien, Senator Elgendi

Sitting at 9 members - we need one more

It’s been difficult to get that final person - if you are at all available - come to StOrgs

Senator Armstrong - can we amend the bylaws

VP Tsang - we can amend the bylaws but we need more people regardless for the scope of the work

President Chien - we’ve made the process more efficient but we need a certain number of people to get through the documentation - it’s unreasonable to assume that StOrgs will organically have 10 members

President Mebrahtu - i scheduling an issue?

President Chien - scheduling is an issue but also getting people who are willing to do the work

President Mebrahtu - we could potentially change the bylaws to have all senators be a member

Senator Bannister - I can work remotely but I cannot make the meeting time - I will be willing to do the work

Student Services — Senator Cai, President Schatmeyer

Came up with questions for admin dinner

Have a meeting scheduled with Dean Wilson

Class Council Reports (4 min)

Seniors

Trying to have events coincide with registration for seniors

Partnering with senior class gift

Trying to have giveaways

Discuss their role in commencement in upcoming committee

Subcommittee to plan senior week - will have other seniors outside SGA

Juniors

Junior class tag is planned - posting a video to promote event

Sophomores

Looking at next edition of 21Takeoff

4 grants of $450

ASA grants

SophShow is going well

Freshmen

Meeting with advisor

Meeting with Dean Ruzicka - having lunch with her

Have email

Advisor Report (3 min)

Prep for dinners with Admins

Go to her for how to get connected

New Business (70 min)

Rules Bill Amendments [Link] — Vice President Tsang (20 min)

Questions

Senator Patel - 8.c is it two or three spaces?

An individual can reserve up to 2 mod caucuses and an individual person can reserve up to 3 spots in mod caucus

Senator Bannister - do we always need to use a mod caucus

VP Tsang - depends on the meeting and the topic of conversation

Senator Bannister - why not have a normal speakers like

VP Tsang - it encourages reading of the document

Motion to approve amendments in yellow

Motion passes

Motion to reconsider motion

Motion Passes

Senator Mollin - motion to amend - depending on how the meeting was last week, 15 seconds is not enough time to give thoughts - Motion to amend to 30 minimum second speaking time

Senator Bannister - this isn’t a mod caucus if it’s set

Senator Paulet - it would be a minimum not a set time

Senator Bannister - this could potentially end up being similar to a speaking list - it should respond to the needs of the day and should be flexible

Senator Bhamidipati - mod caucuses can prevent debate back and forth between senators - we should not mandate mod caucuses - instead use them when necessary

VP Tsang - mod caucuses would prevent back and forth which is the goal

Senator Murak - my concern from last week’s discussion - there is no way to ask questions and get answers immediately - can we set up a system like that?

VP Tsang - all discussion unless otherwise permitted by the chair - mod caucuses are the default but not the rule - suggested framework ensures order

Senator Forlenza - repeating AJ’s point

Senator Wellons - having mod caucuses in place - it’s easier to take them away then put them in place - she has not appreciated the hostility in SGA - she really appreciated the mod caucuses last week - less intimidation

Senator Mays - when the back and forth is happening it’s not productive

Senator Mollin - right now we’re just voting on the minimum 30 second speaking time - in terms of going forward is discuss the minimum - it’s a good idea because it keeps us from limiting discussion - this is a way to make mod caucuses better - propose we vote on this

Motion to end discussion - motion passes

Motion for amendment - motion carries and amendment passes

Senator Baron - motion to change 8.f to get rid of it

Friendly amendment - changed

Can we take out bullet point 8 to lowercase - yes

Senator Bannister - Nathan’s point was interested - we don’t have a formal time for questions - can we amend to establish question answer sessions that exist outside the mod caucuses

Friendly amendment - passed

VP Tsang - early expirations are allowed

Senator Lloyd - will there be a presentation period or a question and answer period outside mod caucus?

VP Tsang - yes

Senator Murak - a question and answer session before mod caucus begins would hurt discussion - can we place it within mod caucus

VP Tsang - yield your time

Senator Patel - what’s the difference between a mod caucus and Q&A

VP Tsang - detailed the differences

Motion the approve - motion passes

2 voted no

DIG Funding Bill [Link] — Senator Wellons (15 min)

Senator Wellons discusses bill - yields to guests to discuss bill

It’s an annual event - volleyball tournament for mental health awareness - has been very effective in the past and has raised upwards of $1500

FFC donates food - counseling center comes, CHEW helps - the group partners with universities around the country - students care about it a lot

The bill asks for funding for prizes and marketing budget - $480 - will be used for years to come

Mental health is a key priority - interested in passing a resolution about working with this organization - we should get involved now

Motion to approve - passes unanimously

Admin Dinner Prep Activity [Link] (15 min) - see activity below - we played bingo

BINGO LINGO À LA MANGO

  1. AJ says title of admin.
  2. Senate says who it is.
  3. AJ shows picture of who it is.
Kerrie CardenAndy WilsonBeverly WendlandAlana ShanahanMichael Falk
Salem ReinerKim HewittBarbara SchubertSmita RuzickaKristen Wright
Toni BlackwellDana BroadnaxFREE SPOTWendy GeistSusan Ridge
Bob McLeanSunil KumarMatt TorresFarrouk DeyKevin Shollenberger
Erin YunSarah CunninghamEd SchlesingerJessica OrosEllen Mackenzie

President Daniels Dinner Discussion [Discussion Document] (10 min)

We need to identify 3 core topics for the dinner with the President

Last year - mental health, civic engagement, student center

Dinner is November 27th

Motion for mod caucus - 8 minute, 30 second speaking time

Senator Wellons - sexual assault - on their own article and OIE report - there are issues in OIE that need to be dealt with - feels as if there is no plan

Senator Bannister - wants to second Senator Wellons’ point - sexual assault allegations - what is their strategy - what happened with fraternities on probation? Offices that should be responsible are not

Senator Mollin - IPCC report - if we don’t take climate action we are going to see drastic climate change

President Schatmeyer - r

Senator Baron - barricade doors - active shooter training

Senator Lucas - can we only discuss three topics?

VP Tsang - these are the big things but we can discuss other stuff

Senator Boroumand - immigrant and refugee rights on campus - ICE, Mahoney-Steel, barriers refugees face in higher education

Senator Bannister - BoT and President made the decision to wait decades after Bill Cosby was accused to revoke his honorary degree

Senator Uraih - financial aid - office is understaffed and behind

President Mebrahtu - the time we have we should use to collaborate - we don’t want to spend all time asking questions that they’re already being asked

Senator Baron - locking of doors - I’ve been in safety meetings

Senator Bannister - News-Letter article - handed off emails about sexual assault of office of OIE - the school ignores survivors and groups on campus that help survivors

Senator Lloyd - narrowing list down to topics - OIE, working towards IPCC goals, asking about divestment, and private police

Senator Mollin - we should think about which would be better for admin dinner and which would be best for President’s dinner - we can subgroup

Senator Murak - when we consider the decision - we should decide what we want to say to President Daniels - caution looking retroactively and looking forward to issues

Senator Thomas - we should be conscious about repetition in our requests - when he hands things off it’s more about liability

Decision - finalizing to 4

Motion to extend mod caucus by 5 minutes, 30 second speaking time

Senator Bannister - liked the previous list - sexual assault, private police, divestment - wants to agree with Nathan - it’s an indication about school’s perspective on sexual assault

Senator Uraih - agree with Omar’s list

Senator Elgendi - student center can be grouped with mental health - student representation and shared governance - Sexual Assault - we should talk about it

Senator Baron - will we discuss topics one more time?

VP Tsang - outline by tuesday and use admin dinner to assign document

Senator Wellons - agree with Omar’s list - in regard to sexual assault - we should talk to President Daniel’s because I’ve talked to all administrators that handle sexual assault - this is important

Senator Boroumand - Agree with this list - refugee rights would be a good 4th topic - no universities in the US have infrastructure for refugees

Senator Forlenza - put lock on door and private police under student safety

President Mebrahtu - instead of presenting a problem - we should present solutions or potential focus points - will take less time in seeing deliverables - tangibles things and deadlines

Senator Mays - with divestment - focus on university sustainability goals and speeding up timeline - since divestment is BoT issue

President Chien - motion to extend mod caucus - 6 minutes, 45 seconds - motion passes

President Chien - likes the topics - student representation and shared governance - if we want a longer lasting change we should focus on this, therefore we have broader reaching influence - whichever topics - speakers should be most passionate

President Zanir - mental health should be on the list

Senator Bannister - OIE is oftentimes a buffer for the university so they can’t hold the university accountable - failed to provide equal opportunity when a student is sexually assaulted - there are too few employees and too few resources and students struggle to get justice

Senator Mollin - civic engagement and shared governance together

Senator Baron - asking for more staff is very doable and easily deliverable. Do not think student safety is under civic engagement

Senator Thomas - can we involve the PRDC to work with Miranda to present to Daniels - if we have facts it will make a lot more progress

Senator Murak - fully behind sexual assault and shared governance - divestment is so fully in the realm of PIIAC - we might waste our time since President Daniels cannot do anything

Senator Mollin - Daniel’s has a lot of influence at BoT meetings - if we have him on board it would be good

Senator Lucas - feels like other topics are more pressing - prioritize other ones

President Habib - can we strawpoll for topics?

VP Tsang - yes, remember to volunteer to create outlines

Took strawpoll - decided on Sexual Assault, Student Safety, Civic Engagement/shared governance, Mental Health, Sustainability,

ICE Decision Discussion (10 min) - moved to committee

Prospective Business (5 min)

Advancing Legislation

Announcements

Submit a survey to students about LivSafe app (tells you what to do with an active shooter) and what students know about safety - send to 5 friends

There was a lockdown - there we highschool kids visiting, security had no idea what they were doing - we should have a better system set up - there needs to be measures in place

We had speaker in every classroom so if there was ever a shooter the whole school would know - we only get notifications - cannot barricade themselves

Brought the point up to admin - tells active shooter that everyone has been alerted

Sustainability coalition is having a fell event in the AMR 1 multipurpose room - Day2Sustainability

ADA is having a big speaker event - about stigma and visibility

Public Input Period

Adjournment (ESTIMATED 8:45 PM, ACTUAL 8:XX PM)

Existing Fams

Draft (Bold = lock)

Noh (4) / Evan (2)

Eunice (1)Kiana (1)< set

AJ (4) / Lauren (2) / Aspen (2)

Madelynn (1)Eric (1)Pritika (1)< set

Mi (4)

Kylie (1)< set

Jennifer (3)

Zanir (1)Gianni (1)< set

Akshay (3)

Omar (1)< set

Fatima (2)

Madi (1)< set

Ash (3) / Sam S. (2)

Mohamed (1)Miranda (1)< set

Dean (3) / Matt (2)

Isaac (1)Pavan (1)< set

Coco (2)

Mehak (1)Nathan (1)< set

Sam M. (2)

Alexander (1)< set

Sources

Senate Meeting #08 (10_23_18).docx