University Student Advisory CouncilNovember 5, 1990
Meeting Notes
Attending: Dr. Wolman, Chair: Mmes. Cummings, Hawkins, Revis, and Schneck; Messrs. El Chami, Huff, Nelson, Orobaton, and Rudge; Mr. Hall and Dr. McClain.
Guest: Dr. Richardson.
The meeting began at 5:30 P.M.
Dr. Wolman said that he was pleased that every member of the Council could attend. He asked everyone to introduce him/herself. He added that he was especially pleased that President Richardson was able to be with the Council. Before asking Dr. Richardson to make his remarks, Dr. Wolman asked Dr. McClain to review briefly the origins of the Council and its work during its first year and a half of meetings.
Dr. McClain explained that the Council was established in response to student concerns that they were not part of the Five-Year Plan consultative process. In the winter of 1988, Dr. Lombardi met with a number of students and agreed to establish a University-wide student group. The resulting Council had its first meeting in the early spring of 1988.
Since then, the Council has spent a great deal of time going over the budget making process. Recently, however, the Council turned its attention to other issues. For example, it asked for a review of the University's student health insurance policies - a project that has been underway since December 1989. The Council has also provided a mechanism for the student representatives to talk about other mutually interesting activities and issues, such as recycling.
Dr. Wolman then asked President Richardson for whatever remarks he wished to make before the Council.
Dr. Richardson said he appreciated the opportunity to speak to the Council. He has already had the chance to meet with students in several of the divisions. He commented that he thought that, while the main focus of the Council might still be on the financial planning process, the idea of any item being open for discussion by the Council was very worthwhile.
He said that he found the general atmosphere at the University to be very welcoming. He has been able to visit each division, and he has concentrated on ways to bring divisions closer together. Dr. Richardson remarked that he fully supported the Five-Year Plan process and said this at this first news conference after he was chosen as President. In terms of the University's financial situation, the difficult times that generated the original Plan are not unique. Other institutions - Stanford, Dartmouth, Cornell - are going through the same kind of analysis and planning reflected in the Hopkins Plan. In the current situation, all of higher education is facing the implications of a national economic recession. We already know, for example, that the University's energy costs will be higher this year. It is important, though, that the immediate specifics of a recessionary climate be kept separate from the longer-range thinking about the University. We can emerge stronger from the recession if the University acts with prudence and a sense of its mission.
In terms of more concrete activities since he arrived, Dr. Richardson said that Peabody was high on his agenda when he arrived July 1st; and, of course, he had been well aware of the Peabody situation throughout the spring. It represented a very interesting collaboration among the State, private philanthropy, and the University. He reviewed the features of the State legislation in support of Peabody and of the fund-raising efforts that were necessary to fulfill the conditions of the legislation. Just before the September 15th deadline, when $15 million in outside support had to be raised, the total of about $11 million had been achieved. Dr. Richardson said that he proposed to the Trustees that the University pledge its endowment to make up the difference - and the Trustees approved this proposal. By September 15th, the outside support had climbed to about $12.5 million, so that the University's obligation was $2.5 million. The University will have the next five years to raise this amount from private donors.
Dr. Richardson then mentioned that a number of divisions were taking initial steps to curtail expenditures during this fiscal year. The Nitze School, the School of Medicine administration, and University administration have all, for example, instituted hiring freezes.
In terms of the Plan process, all of the divisions have been asked to put their fiscal projections in the context of a broader strategic plan.
Dr. Richardson asked if the students had any questions they would like to ask of him.
Dr. Wolman said it might be useful if each of the students mentioned what was of concern to the students in their respective divisions.
Dr. Richardson asked Mr. Nelson if he could help him understand the apparent discrepancy between students and alumni who said that their undergraduate education and experience were very positive and those who said that the quality of undergraduate life was not all that good.
Mr. Nelson said that there were a number of factors and concerns on the minds of the undergraduate students: many students complained about large class size, a concern which was well stated in the recent Howard Committee report; the problem with constant tuition increases, i.e., will there be another $1000 increase for next year? and, if so, what is the money for?; the recent departure of several faculty from the French department; security around the Homewood campus; additional student involvement in academic matters, such as curricular development; space for student activities. On the other hand, Mr. Nelson pointed out that Dr. Richardson's open style and initiatives to meet with students has had a very positive effect. He added that student involvement in the presidential and provost's searches were very welcome. Finally, he said that the apartment house renovations were a good
University Student Advisory Council
December 3, 1990
<u>Meeting Notes</u>
Attending: Dr. Wolman, Chair; Mmes. [illegible] Orobaton, and Rudge; Mr. [illegible]
[illegible]
move for the students although there are mixed feelings about a sophomore residence requirement.
Ms. Schneck said that the Homewood Academic Computing Center costs were becoming a severe problem for students. She said that the charged costs were too high and that student accounts were used up very quickly. Mr. El Chami said this was a similar problem for graduate students. Dr. Wolman said that he would check into this.
Ms. Cummings said that she wanted to return to the question about discrepancy in views that Dr. Richardson had asked of Mr. Nelson. As a medical student, she said that Hopkins was a place of many traditions and that, generally, it was a privilege to be at Hopkins. High expectations also contribute to recognition that there is room for improvement, and it is important that the lines of communication between students and the administration be kept open.
Mr. Orobaton said that students should be more involved in decision making. It was very useful now to have a student representative on the Hygiene and Public Health Committee of the Whole. At the School, they have also started a class liaison program, whereby a student can meet with a course faculty member periodically to suggest changes or other ideas from the students to the faculty member. Other issues for Hygiene and Public Health students are: understanding the cost evaluation system in terms of the School's finances; child care for students, the very bad living conditions in Reed Hall, recycling efforts, community outreach, and investments in tobacco products companies.
On the latter, Dr. Richardson said that an ad hoc committee of the Trustee Finance Committee has been formed to review this issue. He expected that it will have its report by the Board's February meeting. He added that the entire University should have a smoke-free work place policy in effect by June 1st; the East Baltimore campus has had this policy for some time now.
Ms. Hawkins said that there remain some problems with the smoke-free work place policy in East Baltimore, particularly with individuals smoking outside the various building entrances. Other concerns at the School of Nursing are: financial aid for part-time students, the lack of minority faculty, and the cost of malpractice insurance for graduate students. Dr. McClain suggested that she discuss the malpractice insurance issue with Mr. James Grant, the Business Officer for the School.
Ms. Cummings said that tuition increases and medical school debt were serious issues facing Medicine students.
Dr. Richardson said that this was an important issue. Although, in some schools, tuition is a small part of the overall budget, it is still a key revenue source since it represents unrestricted funds to be used in general support within the school. He noted that universities use the Higher Education Price Index (HEPI), rather than the Consumer Price Index (CPI) in analyzing their financial condition. Generally, HEPI exceeds the CPI. This is due to faculty salary increases; during the 1980s much of higher education spent money on faculty salaries to repair the damage done during the 1970s when faculty salaries lagged behind. In addition, other aspects of university finances tend to be quite high, such as laboratory equipment. At Hopkins, increase in tuition are usually matched by similar percentage increases in the amount of financial aid available.
Dr. Wolman said that at a recent meeting with Dean Johns the issue of student debt had arisen. The Dean is well aware of the issue and of how serious it is, both for current students and also in terms of attracting future students into the School.
Mr. Nelson said that in terms of budget understanding, he had recently met with Dean VandeLinde for three hours to go over in detail the Whiting School's budget. He said he found the review very helpful and will do the same with Dean Armstrong in the near future. He added two more items to his list of student issues and concerns on the Homewood campus. He said that the ROTC and Department of Defense policy of not commissioning homosexuals was controversial, since it conflicted with the University's non-discrimination guidelines. The President has appointed a committee to review this matter. The second issue was that of faculty teaching. The Student Council is initiating a faculty appreciation program for late February-early March.
Mr. El Chami said that the graduate students remained concerned about the original Plan's provision for a 10% cut in the number of Arts and Sciences faculty. He said that the cut should not be an across-the-board one, but should be done selectively.
Dr. Richardson reported that he has had many meetings with Dean Armstrong about departmental strategies within the School. There has emerged a better understanding of the faculty numbers within the School and how best to achieve the goals of the Plan. Obviously, the Dean still needs to consult more extensively with chairs and others before the full outlines of his plans are put into effect.
Mr. El Chami said that the increase in the number of undergraduates and the decrease in faculty have put added pressures on graduate teaching assistants. In Economics, for example, where TAs previously taught class sections of 25 students, they now have sections of 45 to 55 students. This decreases the quality of classroom teaching and discussions.
Dr. Richardson asked whether all of the shift in class sizes was due to more students or also to shifts in student interests. Mr. El Chami said both were factors, particularly in Political Science and in Economics.
Ms. Revis said that the new building at Peabody has greatly enhanced the available facilities. Leakin Hall and the dorms have also been renovated. The conductor search continues. There has been a very good increase in the number of entering students. The registration process this year was handled poorly. Safety in the surrounding neighborhood remains a problem and seems to be more so this year. The students would still like to see an increase in the shuttle bus hours, especially on the weekends. Recycling efforts have been started. And, Peabody also has a faculty appreciation program.
Mr. Orobaton commented that Hygiene and Public Health also has a faculty appreciation program.
Mr. Nuff asked if there was an update on the student questionnaire circulated last spring. Dr. McClain said that the results were being collated now and that a report should be ready soon.
Mr. Nuff asked Dr. Richardson if he would comment on the School of Continuing Studies and, specifically, on the M.A.S. program and any plans for a business school program.
Dr. Richardson said that he considered the School to be one of the treasures of the University. He has a high regard for the M.A.S. program, but does not believe a full-scale, day business school is needed at Hopkins. He said he would like to see an international executive program established within the institution.
Mr. Rudge said that while budget matters were of concern to the Nitze School students, they had little or no access to this information. He asked if it were true that the School was about 70% tuition dependent. Dr. Richardson said that this seemed a reasonable figure, since the School did not have a large grant and contract base (with attendant indirect cost recoveries) nor a large endowment. Therefore, tuition and fees would probably be the largest single revenue source for the School.
Mr. Rudge distributed a report, _The Second Annual Presentation to the SAIS Advisory Council_, prepared by the School's Student Government Association. He said that financial aid, access to a student health facility, the need for an Eastern European concentration, and the relationship of the Nanjing Center to the School were among the student concerns and issues.
Mr. Orobaton asked with whom he should speak about the Reed Hall situation. Dr. Wolman said he would check into this and get back to him with the right information.
The meeting ended at 7:30 P.M.
SMc:smy
Sources
IMG_2581.HEIC · IMG_2582.HEIC · IMG_2583.HEIC · IMG_2584.HEIC · IMG_2585.HEIC
