Exec Transition Training Module #4
Diplomatic Relationships
Overarching Student Representative Bodies on Homewood
Multicultural Leadership Council (MLC)
https://studentaffairs.jhu.edu/oma/initiatives/multicultural-leadership-council/
The Multicultural Leadership Council (MLC) is a council of student body that oversees 35+ culturally-based undergraduate student organizations at Johns Hopkins University. The MLC seeks to increase visibility of these organizations, explore identity development and cultural growth, and foster an inclusive sense of community. Through monthly meetings, leaders come together as a way to engage with each other and further develop their leadership as it relates to their cultural identities. The executive board serves as a resource to all groups within MLC through relationship building, cross-cultural collaboration efforts, and providing grants.
The MLC meets once a month, on the first Wednesday of every month from 6–8 p.m. The Executive Board meets every other Wednesday from 6–8 p.m.
For more information, please contact the MLC at themlcjhu@gmail.com.
Student Athletic Advisory Committee (SAAC)
https://hopkinssports.com/sports/2018/6/15/johns-hopkins-student-athlete-advisory-committee-saac.aspx
The Johns Hopkins University Student-Athlete Advisory Committee (SAAC) is a student run organization that serves as the voice of over 600 varsity student athletes. Our purpose is fourfold:
1.) to provide insight and feedback to the athletic department, centennial conference, and NCAA regarding the student athlete experience;
2.) to improve visibility and school spirit;
3.) to promote and provide opportunities for service and community involvement;
4.) to increase programming for student-athletes.
Additional Overarching Representative Bodies
Sustainability Coalition (Run by constituent groups)
Mental Health Student Group Coalition (Run by constituent groups)
Ethics & Conduct Board (Run by the Office of Student Conduct)
https://studentaffairs.jhu.edu/student-life/student-conduct/resources-conduct-ethics/
Alumni Student Ambassadors (Run by Alumni Relations)
Senior Gift Committee (Run by Development)
Peer Student Governments (across all of Hopkins)
Graduate Representative Organization (GRO)
Peabody General Assembly (PGA)
Bloomberg Student Assembly
Medical Student Senate
Nursing Student Senate
SAIS SGA
Carey Business SGA
SGA Relationships w/ Administrators & Offices
Principal Administrative Officers & Deans
https://www.jhu.edu/assets/uploads/2016/01/org_chart.pdf
President’s Cabinet
https://president.jhu.edu/university-leadership/
Kerry A. Ates, Vice President and Chief of Staff
Heidi E. Conway, Vice President for Human Resources
Daniel G. Ennis, Senior Vice President for Finance and Administration
Helene T. Grady, Vice President for Planning and Budget
Melissa Hyatt, Vice President for Security
Sunil Kumar, Provost and Senior Vice President for Academic Affairs
Thomas S. Lewis, Vice President for Government and Community Affairs
Maureen S. Marsh, Secretary of the Board of Trustees
Robert A. McLean, Vice President for Facilities and Real Estate
Jason T. Perlioni, Vice President, Investments and Chief Investment Officer
Paul Pineau, Vice President and General Counsel
Stephanie L. Reel, Vice Provost for Information Technology and Chief Information Officer
Susan Ridge, Vice President for Communications
Stephen M. Ruckman, Senior Adviser to the President for Policy
Fritz W. Schroeder, Vice President for Development and Alumni Relations
Christy Wyskiel, Senior Adviser to the President for Enterprise Development
Deans & Directors
https://president.jhu.edu/university-leadership/
Christopher C. Morphew, Dean of the School of Education
Fred Bronstein, Dean of the Peabody Institute
Patricia M. Davidson, Dean of the School of Nursing
Bernard T. Ferrari, Dean of the Carey Business School
Ellen J. MacKenzie, Dean of the Bloomberg School of Public Health
Vali R. Nasr, Dean of the Paul H. Nitze School of Advanced International Studies
Paul B. Rothman, Frances Watt Baker and Lenox D. Baker Jr. Dean of the School of Medicine
T.E. Schlesinger, Benjamin T. Rome Dean of the G.W.C. Whiting School of Engineering
Ralph D. Semmel, Director of the Applied Physics Laboratory
Amy Shelton, Interim Executive Director of the Center for Talented Youth
Winston Tabb, Sheridan Dean of University Libraries and Museums
Beverly Wendland, James B. Knapp Dean of the Zanvyl Krieger School of Arts and Sciences
Finance & Administration
http://web.jhu.edu/administration/finance/structure/index.html
Office of the Provost & Subsidiaries
https://provost.jhu.edu
https://provost.jhu.edu/people/
Board of Trustees
http://trustees.jhu.edu
Student Affairs
https://studentaffairs.jhu.edu
Dean of Student Life
(DOSL) (Homewood)
https://studentaffairs.jhu.edu/student-life/staff
Institutional Councils, Committees, and Working Groups
Diversity Leadership Council (DLC)
The Diversity Leadership Council, established in 1997, identifies faculty, staff, and students to serve on the DLC. Our council advises the president and senior leadership on diversity issues and is charged to:
Recommend and promote policies, programs and other initiatives that will attract and retain a diverse mix of faculty, staff and students;
Examine formal and informal structures and processes that inhibit Johns Hopkins from being more inclusive and recommend changes that foster greater inclusion;
Promote diversity awareness education across Johns Hopkins;
Foster partnerships with Baltimore community leaders to encourage greater community involvement by various divisions of Johns Hopkins Institutions.
SGA has 2 reps on the DLC through means of their own independent application: AJ Tsang and Anthony Boutros.
Homewood Council on Inclusive Excellence (HCIE)
https://hcie.jhu.edu
The Homewood Council on Inclusive Excellence advises the Homewood deans on matters of diversity, advocates for policies that foster an inclusive climate, identifies current practices that pose barriers to the engagement and success of underrepresented constituents, increases awareness of best practices, and implements innovations that advance our diversity goals outlined in the Roadmap. Additionally, the council collaborates with related committees across the university (i.e., Diversity Leadership Council, Committee on the Status of Women, Homewood Student Affairs) to support programming that builds community.
SGA has 3 reps on HCIE through means of their own independent application: AJ Tsang, Kiana Boroumand, and Madelynn Wellons.
Sexual Violence Advisory Committee (SVAC)
https://sexualassault.jhu.edu/advisory-committee/index.html
The Provost’s Sexual Violence Advisory Committee (SVAC) serves to provide community input and advice to the provost on matters pertaining to education, training, and other preventive measures; reporting; policies and procedures; and community engagement. The SVAC shall not have responsibility for, or advise on, the investigation or adjudication of specific cases and incidents or day-to-day operations. The SVAC will be supported and informed by an operations group from student affairs, institutional equity, security, and general counsel, and other offices as necessary, who will provide information on current university policies, practices, and programs and assist with the development of benchmarking information.
The SVAC is composed of interested individuals who are appointed by the provost. It is broadly representative of the university community, with students, faculty, and staff from throughout the various schools. Initial appointments to the SVAC are for two years and members can be re-appointed. Students must be currently enrolled at the university to serve on the SVAC.
SGA does not have a specific rep on SVAC but there are students on SVAC.
Hopkins Student Center Advisory Committee (HSCAC)
https://studentaffairs.jhu.edu/viceprovost/student-center/
Charge:
Offer perspectives on the best and most innovative means through which the student center can advance our campus community and foster life-long school spirit
As the planning process moves forward, help ensure that we thoughtfully identify and include programming in the Hopkins Student Center that reflects our students’ interests and needs
Assist our design team in developing inclusive spaces that invite connection and collaboration for the entire Hopkins community
Explore how our Hopkins Student Center can serve not only as a hub of activity but also as a welcoming, dynamic and engaging entrance to our campus from Charles Village
Engage with fellow University community members to seek their ideas, input and feedback
SGA has a rep on HSCAC (Claire Gorman).
Provost’s Advisory Team on Healthcare (PATH) for Graduate Students & Post-Docs
The PhD Education Student Advisory Committee is a new, university-wide committee that is being launched in the fall of 2018. It will be comprised of PhD students from across JHU. The PhD student advisory committee will provide guidance to the Vice Provost for Graduate and Professional Education, offering student perspectives on a variety of ongoing initiatives and issues relevant to PhD education at Johns Hopkins. Issues to be discussed, for example, will include best practices for PhD student mentoring, building professional development opportunities for PhD students, university-wide requirements for the PhD, and ways to further foster an inclusive climate.
SGA has a rep on PATH (Pavan Patel).
Student Advisory Committee for Security (SACS)
The Student Advisory Committee for Security advises the Vice President for Security on a range of issues involving safety and security from the student perspective. The board is comprised of student representatives from across Johns Hopkins University campuses and meets monthly with the Vice President for Security and Vice Provost for Student Affairs to provide feedback, share concerns of fellow students, and offer ideas for improving security.
The Advisory Committee is comprised of 15 members, including 10 representatives from designated student groups/organizations and 5 at-large members.
SGA has a rep on SACS. (Mo Elgendi)
PhD Education Student Advisory Committee
The PhD Education Student Advisory Committee is a new, university-wide committee that is being launched in the fall of 2018. It will be comprised of PhD students from across JHU. The PhD student advisory committee will provide guidance to the Vice Provost for Graduate and Professional Education, offering student perspectives on a variety of ongoing initiatives and issues relevant to PhD education at Johns Hopkins. Issues to be discussed, for example, will include best practices for PhD student mentoring, building professional development opportunities for PhD students, university-wide requirements for the PhD, and ways to further foster an inclusive climate.
SGA does not have a rep on this committee.
Other Bodies & Working Groups
Homewood Wellbeing Working Group
And there should be one at each campus too
Faculty Tenure Advisory Committee
https://hub.jhu.edu/2019/04/02/faculty-tenure-advisory-committee-message/
Faculty Mental Health Working Group
Led by Sarah Cunningham
Tobacco Working Group
Led by Meredith Stewart
Former Institutional Councils, Committees
Mental Health Task Force (2016-2018)
https://provost.jhu.edu/about/mental-health-task-force/
Non-Student Representative Bodies on Homewood
Women Faculty Forum at Homewood
The Women Faculty Forum at Homewood is a group of Hopkins faculty of all genders who work together to:
expand collaboration and leadership opportunities for women
advocate for equitable practices and policies, including those pertaining to work/life mix, for all faculty
continue to address gender equity issues and challenges to the full participation of women faculty at Hopkins
https://womenfacultyforum.wordpress.com
Contact:
Co-Chair: Dr. Anne-Elizabeth Brodsky
Co-Chair: Professor Karen Fleming
Homewood Faculty Assembly (HFA)
https://facultyassembly.jhu.edu
The Homewood Faculty Assembly provides a forum for the faculty to discuss and make recommendations concerning matters pertaining to the purposes and functioning of the University.
The Steering Committee is made up of three officers: a chair, a vice chair, and a secretary. Each is elected for a three-year term. Their positions rotate every year, which means the secretary becomes vice chair, the vice chair becomes chair, etc.
Contact
Chair: Kristin Cook-Gailloud
Vice Chair: Julie Reiser
Secretary: Sunita Thyagarajan
Homewood Academic Council (HAC)
https://academiccouncil.jhu.edu (Contact: Deans Wendland and Schlesinger)
First, the Academic Council will review all candidates for faculty appointments and promotions, and will recommend for appointment or promotion those candidates it approves.
Second, the Academic Council will review all proposals for new degrees and new majors and minors in the Krieger and Whiting Schools, and will consider all matters of curricular and instructional policy that, in the Council’s judgment, have a significant bearing on the quality of the Schools’ academic programs.
Third, the Academic Council will conduct periodic reviews of all departments in the Krieger and Whiting Schools; at the Council’s discretion, it will also review centers, institutes, and administrative units that in its judgment, have a significant influence on the quality of the Schools’ academic programs.
Fourth, the Academic Council will advise the Deans, the Provost and the President on academically important questions of institutional policy and strategy.
Fifth, the Academic Council will review all candidates for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in all academic units of the Johns Hopkins University, and will recommend the awarding of this degree to those candidates it approves.
Sixth, in accordance with the relevant policies and procedures, the Academic Council will consider cases of alleged academic misconduct, faculty discipline, and appeals from negative promotion decisions, and will take action as necessary.
Seventh, the Academic Council will advise the administration regarding academic grievances that are brought before the Council by the Deans, the Provost, or the President; or that are brought to the Council’s attention by its subcommittees or, in what it deems to be extraordinary cases, by members of the faculty.
Curriculum Committees (from HAC)
https://academiccouncil.jhu.edu/members-committees/standing-committees/curriculum-committees/
The KSAS & WSE Curriculum Committees are charged with fostering the enhancement of the undergraduate curriculum, giving special consideration to interdepartmental programs and general distribution requirements. They review existing and proposed undergraduate programs and bring recommendations of policy to the Academic Council subcommittee on Academic Affairs.
SGA appoints students to the KSAS and WSE Curriculum Committees at the start of each academic year.
Contact:
Dean Wendland (KSAS)
Dean Schlesinger (WSE)
SGA Diplomatic Strategies & Pitfalls
Collaboration, not Competition!
Collaboration - GOOD
Work with administration, work with faculty, work with student groups
What does collaboration look like?
Proactive communication
Shared decision making
Listening and hearing
Competition - YIKE
Pitting admins against each other
Ex: Jack Bartholet, Dean Tiffany Sanchez and Dean Tammy Saunders
Condemning an office, student group w/o reason or logic, or for the sake of politics
Examples of Collaboration
Deciding how to reform student organizations policy through a series of listening sessions or open fora
Hosting a lunch with an administrator to draft a new policy or brainstorm solutions to an issue
Positive Framing
What is positive framing?
Describing an issue in a way that:
Seems calm and optimistic
Presents the opportunity for learning and growth
Opens the door to solutions, change, or reform
Invites others to join the cause
Not describing an issue in a way that:
Derides or blames others
Forecloses a resolution to the situation
Examples:
“I understand that your student group is in debt. I think it might be helpful for us to go talk with SLI about recent transactions with your account(s).”
“The administration recently announced a new policy. The policy raises a fair amount of concerns, so it’s important we work together to include student voice in its implementation.”
Active/Reflective Listening
What is active/reflective listening?
Absorbing others’ words, then repeating back a paraphrased or summarized version to indicate you understand what they mean
Great to make sure you’re actually understanding
Helps the other person feel heard, even if you don’t agree with them
Examples:
Person A: I’m feeling really stressed about my midterm on Monday.
Person B: It sounds like your exam on Monday is causing you some stress.
Person A: You stepped on my dog! I think you’re a terrible person!
Person B: I feel like you might be upset that I injured your dog.
Targeted Questioning
Start asking questions in an open-ended way, then become more close-ended if needed.
Seek to understand intentions (the “why”) before concluding the implications of an action (the “what”).
Accountability & Accurate Asks
Recognize who is actually accountable/responsible for an issue
Make sure your “asks” or requests align with the administrator you’re talking to
Use JHU websites to be aware of what an office or admin does before you talk to them
This will help prevent you from being bounced around
Good Research
Know your facts.
Use:
JHU’s own statistics and reports
Academic articles
Governmental reports
Graphs and tables
Comparisons to COFHE institutions
Exemplars
Do not:
Cherry pick
Skew data
Humanity
Recognize the humanity of other people and administrators
Try to understand others’ perspectives before dismissing or arguing with an idea
Don’t bring preconceived notions about someone into a meeting / don’t let others’ gossip about someone influence how you see someone
Check implicit bias
Addressing Crises
Stay calm
Identify:
What the problem is
Where the problem is coming from
Who you need to contact
What immediate steps you need to do to mitigate damage
What long-term steps you need to take for preventive measures
Communication & Information Flow
Overcommunication is better than undercommunication
That said:
Don’t overwhelm people with information
Focus your information on those facts that are most relevant to the person you are talking to
Ex: You’re describing faculty tenure to a student, in 30 seconds. You would be better off saying, “Tenure is when a professor has been permanently hired for their research output,” rather than saying “Tenure is granted by the Academic Council to professors after a thorough review process by a subcommittee of 2-3 already tenured professors.”
Admin Meetings - Formal
Regular meetings, meetings on a specific topic
Ex: meetings with Kevin Shollenberger
These tend to be a little more transactional, utilitarian
Admin Meetings - Informal
Not every meeting you’ll have with admins are formal!
Ex: Coffee chats, drop-in’s, conversation
Focus on the admin as a person, as a member of the Hopkins community, more than their operational duties/specific role or job
Don’t be transaction or utilitarian!
Ask questions about the admin’s perspective on the University
Agenda & Notes
Agendas
You don’t need an agenda for every meeting. Really. It’s as overbearing as having too many meetings.
Rule of Thumb:
Agenda: meetings on a specific topic, regular meetings, meetings called by you
No agenda: coffees, walks, run-ins, meetings called by an admin
Notes
Take notes for formal meetings
Don’t take notes for informal meetings
Fora
Good for:
Issues with lots of public interest
Issues where folks need to feel heard
Issues where public opinion is divergent or skewed
Issues where we need ideas, brainstorming
Not good for:
Issues where there’s already lots of agreement, and a fora might just amplify the vortex of opinion
Issues where raw emotion might overpower effective brainstorming, policymaking
Listening Sessions/Focus Groups
Good for:
Issues with smaller, moderate levels of interest
Issues where a specific constituency is affected
Issues where we need to hash out specific solutions, remedies
Not good for:
Issues where lots of constituencies need to pitch in their voice
Issues where opinion is divergent/skewed
Roundtables
Halfway between fora and listening sessions!
Good for:
Formal communications
Calendar invites
Announcements
Long updates (100+ words)
Not good for:
Conversational matters (where you expect lots of back and forth)
Text
Good for:
Mundane, simple issues
Situations where you expect lots of back and forth
Not good for:
Issues that will require lots of dialogue, negotiation
Phone Calls
Good for:
Issues where you need an immediate response, and also discussion
Confidential conversations (so be mindful of where you have phone calls!)
Not good for:
Issues where need to look at a common document
Social Media
Good for:
Broadcasting announcements
Hearing general feedback
Not good for:
Hearing representative feedback, if done poorly
Should I do it in person or online?
In-person:
Pretty much all legislative deliberations
Any work where you need to see/work on a document at the same time w/ more than 2-3 people
Decisions with lots of nuance, specifics
Votes where discussion could influence opinion
Online:
Logistical decisions
Scheduling
Decisions that are simple, only need a yes/no answer
Emergency Protocols
Who to go to in emergencies (the chain of response)
Calvin (main advisor) - calling is best if urgent, email is fine otherwise.
Council advisor (if class-specific)
Smita (Dean of Student Life)
Kevin (Vice Provost of Student Affairs)
Scenarios
Scenario Set #1 - Rallying Entities & Obtaining Information
The University releases the first draft of its MOU in August 2019. The MOU does not include any mention of students. What could you do?
A Writing Sems professors is under investigation. The academic Deans announce that the entire Department of Writing Sems is going to be reviewed. Writing Sems students come to you. What could you do?
Rumor has it that the school will soon announce that the student center will also include part of the Merrick Barn footprint. What could you do?
Peabody and East Baltimore campus students announce that their healthcare plans are no longer working for some reason. Some students are planning a protest on Homewood. What could you do?
Scenario Set #2 - Communications
The office of President Daniels/Provost Kumar reaches out to discuss a new civic engagement initiative. Who would you most likely be in contact with? What are some of the key questions you might want to account for?
A Senator is interested in (pick one) case management/conduct process. What level of admin is most relevant? Who would you connect them with?
You want to know more information about the impact of the Student Services Excellence Initiative (SSEI) on course registration. Who would you email, how would you frame the email, and what would you include in the email?
Scenario Set #3 - Meeting Prep
You’re conducting a training for new senators. Walk us through what you’d tell them about how to plan, set up, and prepare for meetings with administrators.
A Senator, inspired by a protest of students in one of the Engineering departments, wants to work with Facilities on renovations to Latrobe Hall. What could you do to help the Senator/help them set up and plan for appropriate meetings?
The Blue Jay Shuttle system is experiencing major delays. A Senator is very worried for their constituents but doesn’t know much about transportation policy. What could you do to support them?
Scenario Set #4 - Diplomatic Relations
You’re in a meeting with Kevin and Smita, raising concerns we’ve brought forward about student orgs from our peers at the med school. What would be appropriate questions to ask each of them, in relation to the information we’ve brought forward?
You’re in a meeting with an administrator in Homewood Student Affairs. You’ve brought along a student/SGA member who is less knowledgeable about the subject at hand and is about to start shouting at the administrator. What could you do?
It’s November 2019, on the eve of Thanksgiving Break. SGA’s been asked to mediate a two-month long, double sit-in in Garland between students protesting faculty apathy for mental health in the classroom, and faculty protesting discrimination from University leadership. What could you do?
Scenario Set #5 - Addressing a Crisis
At an open forum hosted by SGA, a student accuses an SGA member of having engaged in a violation of OIE policy. What do you do?
SGA is hosting a late-night event at the Lab. It’s 2 AM on a Friday. A fight breaks out and someone collapses and isn’t breathing. What do you do?
Oh no, the stock market crashed to 1920s levels and the country experienced 670% inflation in the course of six months. You just learned that the Parents’ Fund is cutting SAC’s allocatable funding to $100,000. What could you do?
It’s been announced that SGA is being sued for violating a student group’s first amendment rights. What do you do?
Further reading, if you dare
“The Dark Side of the Force…”
“The dark side is a pathway to many abilities some consider to be...unnatural.”
A somewhat manipulative book with a few good tips on human nature: https://images.kw.com/docs/2/1/2/212345/1285134779158_htwfaip.pdf (Dale Carnegie’s “How to Win Friends & Influence People”)
Sources
Exec Transition Training Module #4 - Diplomatic Relationships.pptx
