KSAS Senate Shared Undergraduate Committee Meeting
Monday, November 9, 202612:00 PM – 1:00 PM
Faculty Members in Attendance:Aliza Watters (Presiding Officer) (KSAS Dean’s Office Associate Dean, Undergraduate Curriculum)Jesse Rosenthal (Co-Chair) (English, KSAS Faculty Senator)Michael Bader (Sociology, Associate Professor)Danielle Evans (Writing Seminars, KSAS Faculty Senator)James Loeffler (History, Professor)Jesse Appel
SGA Members in Attendance: Boyi Chen, Aishani Garg
Points of Discussion
- Faculty Survey on Grade Inflation
- AI in Classrooms
1. Faculty Survey on Grade Inflation (Grade Compression) (45 minutes of discussion)
- Anonymous survey sent to all KSAS faculty members
- What Hopkins knows about grade compression:
- Grades have gone up over the years nationally
- There is a federal request to consider grade compression
- Other peer institutions (i.e. Harvard) have talked vocally about grade compression
- Note - Harvard didn’t have a survey, it seems like they wanted a certain answer?
- Goal(s) for the survey - to discern:
- Is grade compression an issue at Hopkins?
- Are students given the grades faculty believe they should be given?
- Have personal grading factors changed? Is there discomfort in the fact that it has changed? Is there peer pressure from other faculty members?
- Have the caliber of students / student preparations improved? If everyone is prepared, then of course there will be higher grades (technically an inflation)
- How will changes look across different departments? Would applying the same standard across all disciplines work? Is intervention helpful?
- Question from us as student representatives:
- How will this affect the student experience?
- This survey is only to gather opinion and have a concrete thing to analyze, not being reactive. Things may change and things may not, but they need data
- Student input will be taken for things that affect us
- How will this affect the student experience?
2. AI in Classrooms (10 minutes of discussion)
- How do students currently use AI? (topic for other committee)
- How should professors write AI policies on syllabi?
- Blanket policies?
- Give faculty prewritten options to consider
- What are the consequences when an assignment is flagged for AI?
- Is there consistency between departments?
- Is this a policy (course) violation or ethics violation (academic dishonesty)?
- What is it that you're trying to teach in your classes?
- Not what you do, but why you do it?
- Making goals for the class more clear for undergraduate students?
- Opinion - A specialized department that looks at ALL violations that are enforced consistently
- Professors didn’t go into teaching to become cops
- How is language flagged? What checking system is being used?
Next meeting: December 7
Notes from GBM
- Why only survey faculty? Why not survey the graduate students and TAs who do the grading, and the undergraduates that this would affect?
- BC - Parallel survey on the student side
- BC - Will ask about grad students and TAs who grade
- Need discussion based on what Harvard has (capped %)
- BC - Any discussion like this should be done post-survey
- Is there a way to get more students involved?
- Parallel survey, fear of data rejection
- BC - Can potentially work with faculty to design this survey so they’re happy with it
- BC - Will bring this up to the KSAS Student Advisory Board for their next meeting
- Parallel survey, fear of data rejection
