JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

Final Report on Tobacco Survey Data

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

Summary Report on Tobacco-Usage Survey Data Johns Hopkins University Student Government Association Office of the Executive Vice President, AJ Tsang April 24th, 2018 Introduction and Context The SGA has been considering smoking policy on campus for several years. Current efforts to shape smoking policy can be traced to 2018 Class Senator Sathvik Namburar, who called for the creation of a smoke-free campus as the chair of the Health and Safety Committee. Upon his retirement from SGA, efforts to address smoking on campus were transitioned to Executive Secretary Rushabh Doshi. In Fall 2017, two resolutions were then brought forth on this matter. The first called for the creation of smoking cessation resolutions; this resolution passed. The second called for the creation of a smoke-free campus policy; this resolution was indefinitely tabled and was not brought back during the 2017-2018 legislative session.

One major concern for the tabling of the second resolution was the fact that not enough data had been collected on student views of smoking. The last student referendum on smoking policy occurred in 2013, when no current undergraduates had begun matriculating into Hopkins. As such, it was considered critical for more recent data to be acquired. This survey was created to address that need.

Methodology and Representativeness The survey was written by student affiliates of CHEW, checked for non-objective language by CHEW staff member Julia Greenspan, and posted to Hopkins Groups by Executive Vice President AJ Tsang. The survey was released on Monday, April 23rd at 9:30 AM via an all-school email sent by Executive President Noh Mebrahtu. No other individuals within or without SGA disseminated the survey via personal message. As such, the survey was open and publicly available to all JHU undergraduates without preference towards or exclusion of any student populations or subsets of populations.

Data analysis and report composition were conducted by Vice President AJ Tsang. First, data was downloaded from Hopkins Groups, taking care to divest all data points of identifying information.

The raw data point spreadsheet was then analyzed using COUNTIF functions on excel to tally votes for each option in the survey. Summary data charts were created to represent student opinion on each question. Finally, this report was composed.

Statistically, this survey maintained internal and external validity to the furthest extent possible.

Internally, the survey questions were screened for bias and there were no significant differences in response rates between classes. In addition, the number of responses from the student body - 619 in total - allows for reasonable statistical analysis. Thus, the survey maintains external validity and applicability to the student body’s overall viewpoint on smoking policy on the Homewood campus.

It is important to note that a previous and identical survey, conducted by the Hopkins Kicks Butts student organization via Google Forms, was not included in this survey data. The data of the earlier survey was excluded for two reasons. First, according to the Office of Student Leadership and Involvement, Hopkins administrators only consider JHED-authenticated data on Hopkins Groups as being fully representative of the student body’s opinion. Second, the previous Google survey was not demographically representative of the student body, with class-age cohorts severely disproportionate to the student body at-large.

Results 622 students responded to the survey. Of those 622 students, 140 were in the Class of 2018, 165 were in the Class of 2019, 143 were in the Class of 2020, and 170 were in the Class of 2021.

Figure 1: Survey Population by Class Figure 2: International Student Composition of Survey

Figure 3A: Traditional Tobacco Usage Rates Among Undergraduates (All-Time) Figure 3B: Traditional Tobacco Usage Rates Among Undergraduates (Last 30 Days)

Figure 3C: Traditional Tobacco Usage Frequency Among Undergraduates (Last 30 Days) Figure 4A: Undergraduate Awareness of Traditional Tobacco Policy on Campus Figure 4B: Undergraduate Opinion on Traditional Tobacco Usage Restrictions on Campus Mean: 4.09

Figure 4C: Concatenated Support or Opposition to Restrictions on Traditional Tobacco Usage Figure 4D: Undergraduate Opinion on Traditional Tobacco Policy on Campus Figure 5A: Alternative Tobacco Usage Frequency Among Undergraduates (Last 30 Days)

Figure 5B: Undergraduate Awareness of Alternative Tobacco Policy on Campus Figure 5C: Undergraduate Opinion on Alternative Tobacco Usage Restrictions on Campus Mean: 3.71 Figure 5D: Concatenated Support or Opposition to Restrictions on Alternative Tobacco Usage

Figure 5D: Undergraduate Opinion on Alternative Tobacco Policy on Campus Figure 6: Undergraduate Perceptions of Enforcement of Existing Tobacco Policy on Campus Figure 7: Undergraduate Support for Tobacco/Smoking Cessation Programs for JHU Affiliates

The raw data spreadsheet used to compose these charts is available on the JHU SGA website. In accordance with federal and state privacy laws, all personally identifying data has been expunged from that spreadsheet.

Open Commentary Section Overarching themes in the open commentary section included:

• Concerns about second-hand smoke and corresponding harm to vulnerable or at-risk populations, such as students with allergies, asthma, COPD, or other cardiovascular health issues • Development of cancer, COPD, asthma, and other cardiovascular diseases due to secondhand smoke • High concentrations of second-hand smoke along major pathways into buildings, such as the MSE Library, Brody Learning Commons, and Gilman Hall • Effects of second-hand smoke on studying and academic performance • Diffusion of smoke from external airways to internal areas of buildings • Lack of enforcement of existing policy by Security and faculty members • Difficulty in enforcing any smoking policy, and ignorance of existing policy • Need to reduce litter from smoking by providing cigarette trash receptacles • Lack of awareness of tobacco alternatives or cessation resources • Mental health factors that may contribute to the use of smoking as “stress relief” • Addiction to smoking and how best to help/support smokers, especially if smokers are friends or classmates • Contradictions between JHU’s smoking policy and its commitment to public health and biomedical research Additional, but less prevalent themes in the open commentary section included:

• Disparities between smoking policy at JHU and peer institutions • Ostracizing/stigmatization of smokers, indifference towards the factors that contribute to smoking behaviors, or ignorance of cultural reasons for smoking • Personal liberty in regards to one’s life choices and body • Regulation of private activities of students and JHU affiliates • Potential indifference towards or lack of awareness regarding health effects of second-hand smoke, among those who smoke Emerging questions from the open commentary section included:

• If designated smoking areas were used, where would they be located? • What is the University’s goal in creating a smoking policy: to regulate smoking and/or to help smokers?

Certification The certification of this report places the seal of the SGA unto this report and confirms the accompanying survey’s statistical legitimacy and representativeness. This report, in accordance with its purview and office of origin, does not take an official stance on the opinion of the student body and only offers its statistical findings as an informative measure for SGA members to develop a recommendation for prospective smoking policies on the Homewood campus.

Be it certified, this 24th day of April, 2018:

AJ Tsang, JHU SGA Executive Vice President

Sources

Final Report on Tobacco Survey Data.pdf