JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

Draft of the Johns Hopkins University Undergraduate Judicial Code - Susan Weissfeld

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

[handwritten: Susan Weissfeld]

DRAFT OF THE JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY UNDERGRADUATE JUDICIAL CODE

I. PREAMBLE

It is the intention of the undergraduate students of the School of Arts and Sciences and the G.W.C. Whiting School of Engineering of The Johns Hopkins University to create and maintain a judicial code. The judicial code is intended to provide members of the academic community with a forum for airing and resolving their grievances against students.

II. JURISDICTION

This code applies to the undergraduates of the School of Arts and Sciences and the G.W.C. Whiting School of Engineering of The Johns Hopkins University. This code pertains to offenses committed on University property, off University property but against members of the University community, and off campus criminal offenses allegedly committed by a student. A member of the University community shall be defined as either a full or part-time student registered in the University or an employee of the University.

Disciplinary action concerning alleged misconduct involving the possession or use of firearms or explosive substances on campus or their illegal possession off campus, sale of illegal drugs, arson, or violent conduct that has seriously threatened the life or safety of another person, as well as allegations of student misconduct during the summer months, shall be the sole responsibility of the Dean of the Homewood Faculties or his designee.

The judicial code is to be in effect during the spring and fall academic semesters as well as the intersession mini-semester and is to be jointly administered by the Judicial Board of the Student Council and the Director of Student Activities [hereinafter "Director"]. The Judicial Board shall be the [handwritten: Code provider] sole University forum for airing disputes over which [handwritten: the Code] has jurisdiction.

[handwritten: S]

III. PROCEDURE

A. Procedure for certifying a charge:

  1. Any person who believes that conduct warranting disciplinary action has been committed by a student may file a written complaint against the student with the Director of Student Activities, or his designee.
  2. A written complaint must be submitted within either:

a. fifteen (15) calendar days from the date of the commission of the alleged offense, or

b. fifteen (15) calendar days from the date of discovery of the alleged offense or the identity of the offender.

  1. The complaint must contain the following information:

a. name and address of the complainant

b. name of the student(s) charged with misconduct

c. a specific and factual statement of the misconduct, including a description of the damage or injury.

  1. The Director shall mail or deliver notification to a student against whom a charge has been made within three (3) calendar days following the date of receipt of the complaint.
  2. Notice must be served by either:

a. hand delivery, or

b. certified mail, return receipt requested.

  1. Notice shall contain:

a. a copy of the complaint including the name of the complainant;

b. copies of documentary evidence supporting the charge, if any.

If any new documentary evidence is obtained after notice is served but prior to the [handwritten: hearing (JP)] rendering of a final decision, a copy shall be given promptly to the student charged, but no less than [handwritten: /]72 hours before the hearing:

c. a copy of the judicial code;

d. notice that all parties have a right to an advisor who is a member of the University community to assist in the preparation of the case, but an attorney may not represent either the complainant or the student charged in proceedings before the Judicial Board;

e. time, date and place of a scheduled hearing to consider the complaint.

  1. Objections to jurisdiction over offenses may be submitted to the Director. If the Director determines the offense is not one which falls within the code's jurisdiction he shall terminate the matter and inform both parties.
  2. The Judicial Board shall maintain a log of complaints, chronologically numbered but lacking personal identifying information, with information as to whether the conduct giving rise to the complaint was considered as within the ambit of this code and the jurisdiction of the Judicial Board.
  3. The accused shall have the option to have his case heard before the Judicial Board or the Director. If the student charged selects the Judicial Board to hear his case, the Director shall convene the board.

IV. PROCEDURE FOR HEARING THE CASE BEFORE THE DIRECTOR

A. If the student charged selects the Director to hear the case, then the following procedures shall be followed:

  1. The hearing shall be closed unless the accused files a written request for a public hearing with the Director. Cases of sexual misconduct shall remain closed. The complainant shall be notified as to whether a hearing is to be closed or open.
  2. All hearings shall be taped and both parties will be given access to the tape upon request.
  3. At the commencement of a hearing the Director shall read the charges after which time the student shall indicate whether he admits or denies the charge.
  4. The Director shall receive all evidence and hear all testimony of the parties and the witnesses at a hearing at which the complainant shall first present his complaint and supporting evidence. Thereafter, the student charged shall be given an opportunity to rebut the complaint or present evidence of mitigating circumstances.
  5. The Director and the parties shall have the opportunity to question all witnesses.
  6. The Director shall render a decision after hearing all evidence offered by the parties.
  7. The Director shall notify the parties of his decision either:

a. At the close of the hearing, to be subsequently confirmed in writing, or

b. By letter within 7 calendar days following the date of the hearing.

  1. The Director shall notify the Dean of Academic Services of the verdict. [handwritten: “Academic,” with an arrow pointing toward “Academic Services”]
  2. [handwritten: The Dir may also [unclear: rec] sanctions to Dean Services]

V. PROCEDURE FOR CASES BEFORE THE JUDICIAL BOARD

A. The membership of the Board

  1. Thirteen members will be selected by the Student Council, normally during the previous academic year, according to the selection process for the Student Council committees. Members shall serve one year and may be reappointed.
  2. The Student Council shall select students to fill vacancies on the Board. [handwritten: According to Section 5A1,]
  3. The Board shall select a chairperson from among its members.

B. Composition of the Hearing Panel

  1. The Chair shall prepare a list of Judicial Board members at the beginning of the academic year.
  2. A Hearing Panel shall be convened by selecting the first five names on the list. The Presiding Official shall be the next person on the list. Every member of the Panel, including the Presiding Official, should [handwritten: be] have no bias or personal interest in the matter.

a. A member of the Panel, the student charged, or the complainant may challenge the impartiality of a member.

b. The Panel shall hear the charges of bias and must decide whether the voting member should retain his seat. A majority of voting members of the panel may remove a fellow member on the basis of bias. The member challenged shall recuse himself from voting on his disqualification. The Presiding Officer shall vote on the question of bias. A new member shall be appointed to replace a disqualified member.

shall first present his complaint and supporting evidence and the student charged shall then be given an opportunity to rebut the complaint or present evidence of mitigating circumstances.

  1. Panel members and the parties shall have the opportunity to examine all the witnesses.
  2. Members of the Hearing Panel shall not discuss the cases with persons not on the Panel.
  3. The student charged may be found guilty by a vote of four out of five members. The verdict shall be accompanied by a written opinion stating the basis for the decision reached by the Panel and any dissenting opinion. The entire record shall be forwarded to the Dean of Academic Services.

[handwritten: 9. The hearing panel may rec. sanctions to Dean Ac. Services]

VI. SANCTIONS

A. The Dean of Academic Services is responsible for determining and implementing the sanction and shall meet with the student to be disciplined before choosing a sanction. All sanctions shall reflect the severity of the offense. The Dean is urged to take into [handwritten: arrow pointing to “into”] consideration the sanctions recommended by the Hearing Panel or the Director of Student Activities.

B. The following sanctions may be imposed:

  1. Oral or written reprimand.
  2. University probation for a specified period of time. The Dean may warn that repetition of the violation may warrant the imposition of additional sanctions.
  3. Compensatory payments, including the payment of fines, financial restitution or the performance of services. The Dean and the student disciplined shall decide upon a time-table for repayment.
  4. Students may obtain a copy of the JHU policy on the confidentiality of student records by consulting the December issue of the Johns Hopkins Gazette or requesting a copy of the policy from the Dean of Academic Services.

B. Maintenance of Judicial Board Records

*1. All judicial proceedings shall be tape-recorded. The recordings shall be preserved in the office of the General Counsel until the expiration of the applicable statute of limitations, after which they shall be destroyed.

  1. The Judicial Board shall maintain a summary of all cases brought before it. The summaries shall contain the following information only:

a. the charge;

b. the verdict;

c. the penalties invoked;

d. description of any appeal and its final decision;

e. Summaries of cases shall not contain the identity of the accused but shall be numbered chronologically.

  1. If a student is suspended or expelled from the University, such penalties shall remain a part of the student's permanent academic record. A record of proceedings under the judicial code which resulted in the student's suspension or expulsion shall be permanently retained in the Office of the General Counsel.

C. Access to records of Judicial Proceedings

  1. A student has the right to inspect his Judicial Board file. A written request to inspect the records shall be submitted to the Director after which a mutually convenient time for such an inspection shall be determined.
  2. A student's Judicial Board record is confidential pursuant to the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act of 1974.

D. Challenges to the content of a student's record may be made in accordance with the provisions of the University's policy regarding student records.

IX. AMENDMENTS

Amendments to this Judicial Code shall be approved by a three quarters vote of the Student Council, by a majority vote of a student referendum, and by the Board of Trustees of the University.

X. DURATION OF THE STUDENT JUDICIAL CODE

A. This code shall become effective September 1, 1981 and shall remain in effect until the end of the Spring, 1986 academic semester.

B. A review of this code shall begin during the fall semester, 1985 by the Student Council and the Dean of Academic Services and a report shall be presented to the Student Council no later than the beginning of the spring semester, 1986.

[handwritten: XI. In the event of a vacancy by Admin. of JHU, A/S thereof to any part, V.P., id. or an officer, shall be construed as referring to a successor of an officer of bearing equal or substantially similar [illegible].]

XI. STANDING OF THE JUDICIAL BOARD

The Judicial Board is an independent committee of the Student Council.

The Student Council may not interfere with the activities or decisions of the Judicial Board.

Sources

IMG_2487.HEIC · IMG_2488.HEIC · IMG_2489.HEIC · IMG_2490.HEIC · IMG_2491.HEIC · IMG_2492.HEIC · IMG_2493.HEIC · IMG_2494.HEIC