JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

Academic Affairs 10 28

Filed in Drive as “Academic Affairs 10_28”

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

ACADEMIC AFFAIRS COMMITTEE

Meeting #01

September XX, 2018

To make this document for future meetings: Go to “File” and “Make a Copy…”

Agenda

Overview of Committee (5 min)

Duties/expectations of committee

Standing Business (5 min)

Dividing work

Miranda

https://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.jhunewsletter.com%2Farticle%2F2016%2F10%2Fthe-end-of-the-humanities-center%3Ffbclid%3DIwAR2rFioesGP7sWQ92tTGfLGT1Jbc0MQ6_eH1uVEOmQRq7Nyv2gRkXqAkAcM&h=AT3znNy1X7IWfUWmv6QzLD1wxTAlVQ7Y8kn2lDcFHqXBZuRgnWUah1uYJbuK6HOQPL53OH_UFBGOsL_tI_m3zlCs1ZOUU5tTNG7Kp3KnvcnpKc32wGWS4fzqJa5lBIDZh_DggA

Zanir

https://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.jhunewsletter.com%2Farticle%2F2016%2F10%2Fthe-end-of-the-humanities-center%3Ffbclid%3DIwAR2rFioesGP7sWQ92tTGfLGT1Jbc0MQ6_eH1uVEOmQRq7Nyv2gRkXqAkAcM&h=AT3znNy1X7IWfUWmv6QzLD1wxTAlVQ7Y8kn2lDcFHqXBZuRgnWUah1uYJbuK6HOQPL53OH_UFBGOsL_tI_m3zlCs1ZOUU5tTNG7Kp3KnvcnpKc32wGWS4fzqJa5lBIDZh_DggA

Madi

https://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.jhunewsletter.com%2Farticle%2F2016%2F11%2Fpresident-daniels-defends-university-policies%3Ffbclid%3DIwAR2m9My9I9NMXXfHFpykXwODqDOlO54Zct8vERDHBZqZX6kGvdy1qCrXROg&h=AT3znNy1X7IWfUWmv6QzLD1wxTAlVQ7Y8kn2lDcFHqXBZuRgnWUah1uYJbuK6HOQPL53OH_UFBGOsL_tI_m3zlCs1ZOUU5tTNG7Kp3KnvcnpKc32wGWS4fzqJa5lBIDZh_DggA

Matt

https://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.chronicle.com%2Farticle%2FJohns-Hopkins-Strives-to%2F100622%3Ffbclid%3DIwAR2m9My9I9NMXXfHFpykXwODqDOlO54Zct8vERDHBZqZX6kGvdy1qCrXROg&h=AT3znNy1X7IWfUWmv6QzLD1wxTAlVQ7Y8kn2lDcFHqXBZuRgnWUah1uYJbuK6HOQPL53OH_UFBGOsL_tI_m3zlCs1ZOUU5tTNG7Kp3KnvcnpKc32wGWS4fzqJa5lBIDZh_DggA

Eunice

https://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.keyreporter.org%2FPbkNews%2FPbkNews%2FDetails%2F2098.html%3Ffbclid%3DIwAR0_ObsgPxv_lM0meVUupdI0iV_OVOvV5uGZebBbNwaRMM_xqmleYOwP6mE&h=AT3znNy1X7IWfUWmv6QzLD1wxTAlVQ7Y8kn2lDcFHqXBZuRgnWUah1uYJbuK6HOQPL53OH_UFBGOsL_tI_m3zlCs1ZOUU5tTNG7Kp3KnvcnpKc32wGWS4fzqJa5lBIDZh_DggA

Fatima

https://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.insidehighered.com%2Fnews%2F2016%2F10%2F28%2Fjohns-hopkins-threatens-close-humanities-center-sparking-outcry%3Ffbclid%3DIwAR0_9qOq6Z4IGWyMqC526vr8ScLPZRDa8PWFUAdENJVboCCXfoC0_tZQ_uM&h=AT3znNy1X7IWfUWmv6QzLD1wxTAlVQ7Y8kn2lDcFHqXBZuRgnWUah1uYJbuK6HOQPL53OH_UFBGOsL_tI_m3zlCs1ZOUU5tTNG7Kp3KnvcnpKc32wGWS4fzqJa5lBIDZh_DggA

Miranda

https://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=http%3A%2F%2Fmedia.wix.com%2Fugd%2F86e56f_96f64f93431a49f0b2af595f1981195c.pdf%3Ffbclid%3DIwAR2uFNZpzW0-6x_U7gM7zxHglZg5rpbzAXy9RI3xlzV9hA73fJ9t4843Pqw&h=AT3znNy1X7IWfUWmv6QzLD1wxTAlVQ7Y8kn2lDcFHqXBZuRgnWUah1uYJbuK6HOQPL53OH_UFBGOsL_tI_m3zlCs1ZOUU5tTNG7Kp3KnvcnpKc32wGWS4fzqJa5lBIDZh_DggA

Matt

https://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=http%3A%2F%2Fmedia.wix.com%2Fugd%2F86e56f_828e08bf1fde480cab31b9fa123fdb2b.pdf%3Ffbclid%3DIwAR3pCQiiQ9_Fcob_2n7pF77Nylvd6zFpZU16WAj-PIrMRcT8D1-lKrrg148&h=AT3znNy1X7IWfUWmv6QzLD1wxTAlVQ7Y8kn2lDcFHqXBZuRgnWUah1uYJbuK6HOQPL53OH_UFBGOsL_tI_m3zlCs1ZOUU5tTNG7Kp3KnvcnpKc32wGWS4fzqJa5lBIDZh_DggA

Eunice

https://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=http%3A%2F%2Fmedia.wix.com%2Fugd%2F86e56f_2c99c70bf3554380b63494e6e90aae45.pdf%3Ffbclid%3DIwAR1GD2gwdRjIg3hijgeEKCKBGw4mQ-VplfTJoyJbkojddcyoy7-z2UdBBPA&h=AT3znNy1X7IWfUWmv6QzLD1wxTAlVQ7Y8kn2lDcFHqXBZuRgnWUah1uYJbuK6HOQPL53OH_UFBGOsL_tI_m3zlCs1ZOUU5tTNG7Kp3KnvcnpKc32wGWS4fzqJa5lBIDZh_DggA

TEMPLATE FOR RESPONSE

Quick 2 sentence summary of article

What are 3 problems that could be addressed

Cited evidence showing humanities are being treated unequally?

Article 1

Quick 2 sentence summary of article

What are 3 problems that could be addressed

Cited evidence showing humanities are being treated unequally?

Article 2 - Zanir

  1. Quick 2 sentence summary of article

What’s happened regarding the Humanities Center. Dean Wendland wants to potentially shut it down, has called for a committee to evaluate.

  1. What are 3 problems that could be addressed

a. Continuous evaluation of the humanities center

b. School’s overall emphasis on the humanities

C. School not transparent with undergraduates

  1. Cited evidence showing humanities are being treated unequally?

a. “This is the third examination of the Center in the past five years.” - first two were mandated dept or school wide routine inspections

b. “It sets a very nasty precedent if a department, although evaluated well, would be closed. I see my task in making sure whatever decision is made is based on adequate information to begin with. What has been shockingly lacking so far in the conversation is a respect for empirical facts and sound arguments,” he said. “I haven’t heard any intellectual, academic, institutional arguments that would justify dissolving a department with a rich and prominent tradition, an established reputation and solid placement record. I frankly don't know why anyone in his or her right mind would do that, and I think that if alumni, graduate students and distinguished colleagues nationwide and internationally are expressing their grave concern and consternation, this is precisely because they haven’t heard those arguments or seen those facts either.”

c.

d.

Article 4

  1. Quick 2 sentence summary of article

JHU is having difficulty keeping some of our talented professors to stay here, shown with a large number of our top humanities professors recruited away in recent years.

Harvard has wasted too much time using funds for humanities courses, that funds were eventually used for their medical school.

  1. What are 3 problems that could be addressed

a. Higher incentive for other professors to go to other schools (attempted to be addressed but failed)

  1. Cited evidence showing humanities are being treated unequally?

a. “The Johns Hopkins University, which has seen a number of its top humanities professors recruited away in the past few years, has approved several new programs to invigorate its liberal-arts departments.”

b. “Some professors had grown alarmed that the administration wasn't doing enough to retain talent.”

Article 5

  1. Quick 2 sentence summary of article
  2. What are 3 problems that could be addressed

a.

b.

c.

  1. Cited evidence showing humanities are being treated unequally?

a.

b.

c.

d.

Article 6 - Fatima

Quick 2 sentence summary of article

Hopkins is moving to close its interdisciplinary Humanities Center (not due to budget reasons), but because they fear that--even though previous surveys & reports have shown high graduate student morale--it causes some of the students “pervasive anxiety … having to do with the fear of falling between disciplinary stools when it comes to seeking jobs.”

What are 3 problems that could be addressed

Why are they trying to get rid of the Humanities Center for the sake of people ‘not confusing’ it with the Humanities Institute when the institute director himself directly agreed that he doesn’t fear any overlap of their missions?

What are they going to do with all the students (undergraduate/graduate) who rely on the Center for their studies/help?

If it does end up getting closed down, where would those funds go?

Cited evidence showing humanities are being treated unequally?

A petition with over 3200+ signatures in support of the center

“The students said they saw no conflict whatsoever between the center and the new institute, and said that the center continues to offer "courses not available anywhere else at Hopkins, be they outside of the national language concerns of other departments, or topics like religion, cinema and philosophy, critical theory across the disciplines, and other subjects that are outside the purview of traditional departments."”

“Hopkins's reasons for considering closing the center aren't totally clear, but the dean in charge of the center's fate has cited its narrow focus (a characterization its proponents challenge), among other concerns. In any case, it doesn't appear to be a budget issue.”

“There was an almost exceptionless assertion of positive comments from the students we met -- about the instruction they received, the attentiveness and helpfulness of the faculty, the opportunities provided to the students to do their own teaching, the solidarities that existed among them, and the relative freedom to pursue their special interests without the constraint of compulsory routines,” the external reviewers found.” ← so why are they trying to shut it down?

Article 5

Quick 2 sentence summary of article

After finding out that the Johns Hopkins Humanities Center may face closing, an online petition was created and signed by 4,000 students as of mid-November. President Daniels agrees that the humanities center is an integral part of campus and says that the review is “not about the humanities at large - it is about the fate of a distinct department that is undergoing significant intergenerational change.”

What are 3 problems that could be addressed

Why is the humanities center under review even after a $10 million grant?

Why do people want it closed?

What are the consequences of the humanities center closing?

Cited evidence showing humanities are being treated unequally?

“center has not provided strong programming for undergraduates, and that the center’s name indicates that its offerings are more broad than they actually are”

“Wendland wrote, are that the Center lacks a comprehensive academic mission”

may face the closing of its Humanities Center in July of next year

Article 2

  1. Quick 2 sentence summary of article

Review of Humanities at JHU, highlighting their consideration of adding a “Humanities Center Major,” and creating a seperate Institute for the Humanities

  1. What are 3 problems that could be addressed

a. (article was mostly informative rather than attempting to point out problems)

b. Is the humanities center doing enough currently that warrants the existance of the Institute for Humanities?

“The question arises because the Humanities Center regards many of the functions of the proposed Institute as falling within its purview. Many of our informants stressed that the Center already functions as a hub, bringing faculty members, graduate students and visitors from many humanities departments together for talks and seminars.”

  1. Cited evidence showing humanities are being treated unequally?

a. “The deans asked us to consider the ‘significant fall in undergraduate enrollments in the HCD over the last years.’”

“Based on the data provided, the external review committee is unable to provide answers to the fluctuations in enrollment, nor were HCD faculty able to account for them. Clearly additional study within the HCD and KSAS is called for in order to gain insight into the pattern of enrollments.”

b. Most of JHU’s peer institutions have Humanities Centers: non-departmental units charged with supporting teaching and research in the humanities, sponsoring lectures and conferences, promoting interdisciplinary work both within the humanities and beyond, hosting visiting fellows, and engaging in public outreach. The administration has begun to explore the possibility of establishing a center of this sort at Hopkins — provisionally called the Institute for the Humanities, to avoid confusion — and so a question arises about the relation between the Humanities Center and the proposed Institute.

while the Humanities Center does function in many ways as an interdisciplinary hub, it does not (and cannot) play the sort of role that non-departmental Humanities Institutes play at other universities. The HCD is a department with intellectual foci of its own.

Article 9

  1. This article is a summary of the internal review of the humanities center that covers the components that make up the humanities center. This includes the faculty, undergraduate teaching, and graduate programs.
  2. What are 3 problems that could be addressed

a. The department is comprised of only seven people total. One of the problems the department is facing is the retirement of their full time professors.

b. Is the department stretching themselves too thin and being too ambitious with their majors and cirriculum?

C. Is there a way to better the graduate program and increase the number of people in it?

  1. Cited evidence showing humanities are being treated unequally?

a. “no one seemed to know anything about the new Institute's content, structure or goals. Nor could the members of this committee answer the faculty’s questions. ”

b. “Under these circumstances, it is not surprising that we found quite a lot of resistance to the idea of the Institute. It is not been seen as a threat, but some faculty simply considered it unnecessary, as they saw that the HCD represents what the Institute is supposed to cover. “

Sources

Academic Affairs 10_28.docx