Making a Difference
AJ Tsang
Executive Vice President
Johns Hopkins Student Government
We are a “policy-minded SGA.” But what is policy?
Law and legislation?
Literature?
Art?
Music?
History?
Science?
Data?
Pure bliss?
Mint-coffee-cookie dough (my favorite) ice cream?
All of the above?
Courtesy of the Smithsonian Hirshorn Museum.
Policy goes beyond paper.
It’s a collection of ways for you to raise your voice, and that of the student body.
On a large scale, we thus call our SGA a “policy-minded student government.”
Examples of Policy
Legislation (~30% of our time)
Resolutions that state beliefs, bills that allocate resources
Conversations and Dialogue (~30% of our time)
Speaking to key stakeholders (students, faculty, staff, administrators) and eliciting action from them
Action (~30% of our time)
Creating a new program or initiative, improving an existing one
Regulation
Ensuring existing programs run smoothly
Decision-Making
The act of making a choice on how to act in a situation
A Framework for Catalyzing Change
Identify the issue.
What is our problem? What is its saliency? What is its tangibility and addressability?
Consider the stakeholders involved.
Who are our key players? Who will be affected by our actions?
Design an intervention (a project, a program, legislation, etc.)
What intervention are we implementing? Where are we intervening? Is our intervention genuinely impactful and sustainable? Will it make a difference?
Mobilize resources.
What materials, funding, and timeframe do we need to mobilize?
Implement and Evaluate.
How will our intervention unfold? How will we evaluate it, then go back and improve on our successive efforts?
Along the way:
Catalogue!
Thoroughly document progress at every step of the way, that way information and thought processes are available for reference.
Communicate!
Talk to students in and outside SGA, faculty, staff and admins to gather their thoughts.
Conceptualize!
Make visuals, graphics, or presentations so as to easily draw out key points for SGA members, key stakeholders, and the community.
Adapt!
Always be ready to make changes as new information comes in.
Case Studies
Case Study: Sexual Assault (2014 to present)
Issue: JHU covers up a rape in early 2014. A second rape in late ‘14 invokes an SGA response.
Stakeholders: Students, administration, Title IX office, greater Baltimore community.
Intervention: SGA holds an emergency forum, joins the SVWG, and works to promote the Provost’s It’s On Us survey.
Mobilize resources: SGA’s efforts invoke the school to develop mandatory BIT training and new party policies.
Implement/evaluate: Today, the school has made some progress but there’s more work to do.
Courtesy of the JHU News-Letter.
Case Study: Mental Health (2015 to present)
Issue: President Plush resigns, sparks increased attention on mental health.
Stakeholders: Students, staff, faculty across all 9 campuses.
Intervention: SGA inspires Admin to create Task Force that designs solutions.
Mobilize resources: Task Force changes into a Standing Committee (Fall ‘17) to implement recommendations.
Implement/evaluate: Standing Committee will implement changes over the course of the coming years and evaluate their effectiveness.
Courtesy of the JHU News-Letter.
Case Study: Divestment (2013 to present)
Issue: University investments in fossil fuels threaten the environment.
Stakeholders: Students, Board of Trustees, Administration, etc.
Intervention: SGA passes resolution in support of student groups fighting for divestment.
Mobilize resources: School organizes divestment forum.
Implement/evaluate: JHU will announcement divestment decision on September 5th, 2017.
Courtesy of the JHU News-Letter.
Case Study: Student Orgs (2016 to 2017)
Issue: Student organization accreditation process requires reform.
Stakeholders: Students, student groups, SLI.
Intervention: Student Orgs committee makes improvements to the SGA Bylaws in regards to student organizations.
Mobilize resources: StOrgs works with SLI to communicate new policies to student orgs.
Implement/evaluate: Completed reforms go into effect in the fall of 2017.
Courtesy of Her Campus.
Legislation
Why a specific focus on legislation?
Other skills develop naturally over time, in council and committee.
Legislation takes more time and energy, so we’re going to devote a special section of this workshop to learning about it.
What does legislation look like in our SGA?
Resolutions (~20% of legislative output)
Expressions of belief, solidarity, support and voice on direct behalf of the student body
Bills (~80% of legislative output)
Tangible policies allocating funding, resources, time and energy into specific projects, programs and initiatives
Resolutions
Structure:
A series of 6-12 Whereas clauses delineating the context of a situation, followed by a Be It Resolved statement that calls for action from specific stakeholders
Simple Example:
Whereas, the Great Barrier Reef is a coral reef system located off the coast of Australia;
Whereas, ocean acidification rates threaten to bleach all of the Reef by 2100, if not earlier;
Therefore, be it resolved by the JHU SGA that President Daniels commit $18.76 million of endowment to the establishment of a Marine Preservation Institute.
Whereas clauses usually discuss:
Status quo, upcoming action or interventions, relevant data, moral duty, saliency to the student body, Hopkins community, and/or world
Be It Resolved statements usually discuss:
Visible actions, funding (beyond that SGA can provide), program/policy development, public statements
Bills
Structure:
A series of structured and sub-structured sections specifying resource allocations, plus procedural sections on findings, purposes and severability
Two Simple Examples:
A Bill Funding an Event
Section on Funding
Section on Logistics
Section on Marketing
- Section on Findings, Resources, and Severability
A Bill Establishing an Open Student Assembly
Section on Marketing and Application Process
Section on Meeting Logistics
- Section on Findings, Resources, and Severability
Sections usually discuss:
Findings and Purposes: status quo, relevant data, saliency to the student body/Hopkins community/world
All else, as relevant: upcoming actions, SGA funding, program/policy development, marketing plans, logistical plans
Language
Formal, academic language
Feel free to be audacious, especially in resolutions:
“We assert the profundity of the student experience in our calls for reform.”
“We find the matter to be of critical import for the contemporary student body.”
Tailor to match your audience
Ex: Resolution for administration vs. Resolution for mayor
Bringing Legislation Forward
Focus on the content. Make sure research is accurate. Account for all key stakeholders and incorporates their opinions/concerns.
Once comfortable with your content, plug it into the appropriate template and collect 2 or more co-sponsors.
Use serif-style fonts (ones that look like this)
Use the gold-blue JHU seal (no University seals)
Upload to the Vice President’s online form, who will send it to committee.
Meet with the committee to address concerns/amend the legislation.
Send back to the Vice President, who will put the legislation on the agenda for the next meeting.
Introduce your legislation to SGA.
Legislation & Presentation Submission Form:
And above all...
This is a learning process.
There will be more opportunities to learn more.
No one is expected to be an expert.
Don’t worry if the first tries are tough. Even if someone looks like they live and breathe this stuff, remember they might have had years to practice.
Change takes time, and often outlives us.
You can always reach out for help.
Group Activity:
Let’s Make Policy & Write Legislation!
Reference Material
Helpful References
Resolution Template - LINK
Bill Template - LINK
Real-Life Bill Example - LINK
