JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

Chinese Student Association Investigation Summary

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

Student Government Association Student Organizations Committee Chinese Student Association Investigation Report Date: 5/4/17 Report Compiled By: Senator J. Brown

I. Introduction

a. The Student Organizations committee of the Student Government Association

(SGA) received an anonymous complaint filed against the Chinese Student Association. The complainant alleges that CSA conducted the following actions:

i. Biased recruitment of Board Members ii. Improper use of SAC and other university funding

  1. Includes purchases to supermarkets and dining at restaurants iii. Lack of inclusive event/ exclusive member only
  2. Iron Chef Event on April 8 II. Findings

a. Initial meeting with two CSA representatives on Monday, May 1 to discuss the allegation made; meeting lasted for approximately 15 minutes.

i. Conversation involved understanding CSA’s general membership process, finding who oversees club finances and a list of events that occurred around the semester

  1. Recruitment process involves the following:

a. After SAC, has application season after first GBM; shares info about joining; sent out application; interview usually 15 mins, hosted by recruitment chair; usually narrows down to 15 people freshmen and sophomores; email list is from SAC fair so that’s how they get recruits

  1. Financial Officers are:

a. Ting Fang tfang4@jhu.edu

b. Wen Wen Teh wenwenteh@jhu.edu

  1. Events (Year Long)

a. First General Body Meeting: Had general body meeting for board members to get to know general members

b. Mid-Autumn menu: Cultural event for board members to get to know general student body; approximately 100 students attended

c. Dim Sim night at Bamboo Café

d. Dumpling night: general study body can make dumplings; members can help

e. Lunar New Year: 300-400 attended in glass pav; provides catered food and performances from other student group Humming Jay Lion Dance, TASA all performed; semiformal

f. Iron Chef: Have people submit dishes and judges critique dishes; prize for winning other ii. Conclusion: I did not have the complaint in my email and waited for Senator Muniz’s email to discern if this matter required a further interview. Once that information was gained, I requested a second interview.

b. Second meeting with CSA occurred on Thursday, May 4 with incoming and outgoing leadership offices in attendance. These individuals included Elizabeth Daugherty, Co-President, Vanessa Phuong, Co-President, Victoria Lui, Vice

President, Ting Fang, Co-Treasurer and Co-Vice president (2017-2018), Grace Duan, Secretary and Co-President (2017-2018), Wen Wen Ten, Co-Treasurer and Co-President (2017-2018)

i. During this meeting, CSA responded to the allegations made in the complaint. The meeting lasted approximately 30 minutes, beginning at 10:25pm and ending at 10:55pm. CSA shared with me a google link to their files, which I will present to the committee during our meeting on Friday, May 5. Below is a near verbatim dictation of the remarks made by CSA members.

  1. Recruitment: 1 We have thorough recruitment process in the beginning of the year. It involves a written application and interview. CSA has notes from interviews and reactions to candidates if the committee requests this information. They want it to be known that CSA does not have a biased recruitment policy. CSA clarified the definition of “board.” The organization defines board as its 50 group members, which includes its leadership positions. 2 General board members are asked to attend bi-weekly meetings, helps execute events, plan logistics, helps with cooking, making sure events run smoothly (staffing events). CSA defines the “general body” as anyone who comes to events. For example, as an attendant of the Lunar New Year event, the CSA would denote Senator J. Brown as a general body member. Regarding the recruitment of board members, CSA’s current leadership does not vote alone on new general board members. Anyone on the general board is eligible to vote.

Further, all applicants who submit complete applications receive an interview. To make the process as fair as possible, if a current board members knows a prospective new board member, that board member is not allowed to interview the perspective general board member. Applicants are chosen based on their interest in CSA and potential for future leadership roles in the organization. CSA is not sure why the complainant would make this charge. The representatives argue that the close relationship of the general body maybe what the student is referring, but that this in no one impacts the organization’s recruiting practices.

The CSA’s general board is close, extremely close. This dynamic occurs year to year and is not unique to this year’s organization’s members. In fact, the representative said that CSA general board members often reject students they personally know and are friends with if those individuals are not a good fit for the organization.

  1. Funding: Most of the organization’s events are open to the public. For example, the Lunar New Year Banquet is one of the 1 CSA offered a long document detailing its intake process for new general board members. I will share the information with the committee. 2 General Board Member = General Body Member for Chinese Student Association largest cultural events on the Homewood Campus. The representatives expressed that university funds are only used on events that are open to the public. These events include dumpling night and mid-autumn festival. In response to the claim of funding use for exclusive events, the CSA reps believe this is a misunderstanding. One time a year, there is a closed event that is CSA’s new members’ orientation. For any offcampus events, such as a trip to a restaurant university funds are not used. General board members are asked to use their own funds for off campus purchases that do not benefit the overall mission of the organization. Off campus events usually occur within CSA’s family system, which is an internal bonding program between CSA members. CSA leadership encourages all general board members to attend these events as families, but are instructed not to use university funds. Sometime, after large events, CSA host events closed to general board members only.

These events occur off campus and are not subsided using university funds. The CSA reps said they could see how someone could make allegations of this kind. Sometimes general board members say they’re going off campus “with CSA”, but what they really mean is that their family is bonding and not an official CSA event or initiative.

  1. Purchases:3 Some CSA events require a lot of cooking, so the organization travels to H-mart. These trips are not frequent and only occur for major events. On these trips, CSA leadership opens van space to general board members who would like to go food shopping to make transportation for those members easier.

However, these members purchase personal items, but only using personal funds. Only, Ting goes to see Jackie Morton, no one else in the organization. All purchases must be approved by Ting before going to Jackie. The culinary committee handles all food items brought with university funds and oversees making sure those items are at events.4

  1. KBBQ: The CSA reps believe that these allegations are untrue.

In fact, they expressed surprise when notified of this claim. They said that CSA not been to KBBQ restaurants this year. These 3 CSA sent a comprehensive spreadsheet detailing its budget and event information for academic year 16-

  1. Here’s a link : https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/10CoYhX7Zck6xSNVAhccsHXinux0sE1OU9SWIZE6css/edit#gid=0
  2. There is no listing of a Korean BBQ restaurant on the CSA’s budget and event information spreadsheet. Food purchases include two purchases for Hunan Taste used for Welcome Back Informational Meeting totaling $417.88 (reimbursed to David Cui and Andrew Gu); China Work for the first general body meeting totaling $318 and another purchase at China Wok for the Lunar New Year Banquet totaling $1735 (both purchased with a university card); 10 purchases to Great Wall: one for the mid-autumn festival ($135.04), another single purchase for first new member meeting ($69.34); one purchase made for Dim Sum Night ($87.06); three purchases made for Dumpling Night ($326.69); one purchase for Noodle Night ($68.44); three purchases for Lunar New Year Banquet ($194.84); All of these purchase at Great Wall are listed as reimbursement transactions.

allegations could have come from a misunderstanding. Although the organization has not dined at a KBBQ restaurant, it catered food for new member informational session. However, this event did not exceed $30 per person and is listed in the organization’s budget. Also, Jackie approved the purchases. CSA is not the only group who has food at events. The reps said they never use university funding for dinner and make it clear that off campus events are not subsidized by the organization.

  1. Cooking Competition: The complainant is referring to Iron Chef, an event held on April 8. CSA reps said that the event was open to anyone to sample the food, vote in the judging process, listen to a cultural presentation and win a CSA t-shirts. The reps added that their t-shirts were purchased using a grant the organization received from the Johns Hopkins Federal Credit Union. 100 tshirts were given out to the general body members at Iron Chef.

In a clarification email, CSA said that the organization’s sweatshirts for the event was purchased using a pool of money gathered by board members and not purchased with university’s funds. General body members received an opportunity to win culture-related trivia prizes, but the prizes did not include CSA sweatshirts. Sweatshirts are given to general board members only. Again, this purchase was not made using university funds.

The reps admitted to not allowing to participate in cooking the food for this year. Previously, cooking has been open to the public, but due to time constraints regarding promotion, it was easier for CSA to have board members form teams to cook food.

Historically, interest is lower than they’d like. If groups went over a certain monetary limit, the groups paid out their own pocket. 5 Otherwise, university funds were used to purchase ingredients for this event. General body members had food and drinks and won trivia related prizes. The event was interactive.

The reps said for us to look at their Facebook page for photos as well as three photos in the folder on the google drive.6 All board members cooked for event attendees. General board members did not win any free food. CSA reps also said that general board members did not eat any food because the event had a larger than expected turnout. III. Comments

a. During this investigation, the CSA reps have been extremely cooperative. They have accommodated my schedule to ensure that the organization’s name is cleared of any claims that the complainant made. The leadership of CSA is passionate and committed educating our community and promoting Chinese culture on the 5 Purchases can be found in the spreadsheet

  1. https://www.facebook.com/pg/jhuCSA/photos/?tab=album&album_id=1802988876588432

Homewood Campus. They came with thorough documentation that is available via google doc, which will be shared with the Student Organization committee.

b. I think the group needs to make clear the distinction between “general body” and “general board” members. This lack of distinction caused confusion when reading the complaint that we received. I thought the complainant made these claims against the executive leadership board, but it appears that these claims were made against the larger 50-person general board. CSA’s problem seems to be its close-knit community. I think that there is a genuine friendship between general board members that can isolate perspective or floating members of the organization. This relationship may cause negative perceptions of the organization from outside members. The reps that I spoke with all seem extremely comfortable around each other and seem to understand the inner workings of the organization. They often finished each other’s sentences.

c. I reviewed the club’s budget and event spreadsheet and could not find anything improper. IV. Conclusion/Recommendation

a. I recommend to re-approve the Chinese Student Association. However, I would like for the committee to go through the documents to make a final verdict.

Opening Current Balance 4821.25 Balance: (calculated): 559.88 Official SAC Balance as of [date]:

Financial Person Who Date of Type of Date of Notes (number of attendees at Amount Place Event Description Officer Received?

Paid Transaction Transaction Submission an event) Approval -500 N/A Lunar New Year Banquet Spring 2016 SLPG Transfer N/A Welcome Back Informational 214.88 David Cui 09-03-16 Hunan Taste Catering Reimbursement 09-06-16 Ting Fang Yes 30 people (board members Meeting only, Welcome Back Welcome Back Informational 203 Andrew Gu 09-03-16 Hunan Taste Catering Reimbursement 09-06-16 Ting Fang Yes Informational Meeting) Meeting 22.43 Victoria Lui 09-03-2016 H Mart Student Involvment Fair Candy Reimbursement 09-06-16 Ting Fang Yes 83.4 Ziwei Chen 09/03/2016 H Mart Mid-Autumn Festival Candy and snacks Reimbursement 09-06-16 Ting Fang Yes 40 people (not including board, 135.04 David Cui 09-03-2016 Great Wall Mid-Autumn Festival Mooncakes Reimbursement 09-06-16 Ting Fang Yes Mid-Autumn Festival) 49.83 Jacob Wei 09-03-2016 H Mart First General Body Meeting Snacks and supplies Reimbursement 09-12-16 Ting Fang Yes 53.3 Grace Duan 09-12-2016 CVS First General Body Meeting Drinks, plates, and utensils Reimbursement 09-13-16 Ting Fang Yes 100 people (not including University 318 N/A 09-08-2016 China Wok First General Body Meeting Food 09-08-16 N/A N/A board, GBM) Credit Card Elizabeth 24.84 09-16-2016 CVS Mid-Autumn Festival Drinks, plates, and utensils Reimbursement 09-19-2016 Ting Fang Yes Daugherty 50 people (17 new board members + 33 returning board 69.34 David Cui 09-24-2016 Great Wall First New Member Meeting Dumpling Ingredients Reimbursement 09-26-2016 Ting Fang Yes members, First New Member Meeting) Elizabeth Riverside 605 09-30-2016 New Member Orientation Catering Reimbursement 09-03-2016 TIng Fang Yes Daugherty Hotpot Elizabeth 43 people (17 new members 26 18.82 09-29-2016 CVS New Member Orientation Drinks and cups Reimbursement 09-03-2016 Ting Fang Yes returning board members, New Daugherty Member Orientation) 42.66 Bryan Li 09-29-2016 Giant New Member Orientation Ground Pork for Dumplings Reimbursement 11-15-2016 Ting Fang Yes 87.74 David Cui 09-30-2016 Costco New Member Orientation Food, plates, and utensils Reimbursement 09-03-2016 Ting Fang Yes 349.95 N/A September Van Charges Transfer N/A University 343.85 N/A 10-13-2016 Zhong Shan Dim Sum Tea House Catering 10-13-2016 N/A N/A Credit Card 87.06 Bryan Li 10-14-2016 Great Wall Dim Sum Tea House Dim Sum Reimbursement 10-20-2016 Ting Fang Yes 222 people (including some board members, Dim Sum Tea 16.25 Yunfan Zhao 10-15-2016 CVS Dim Sum Tea House Cups and Sponges Reimbursement 10-20-2016 Ting Fang Yes House) 7.38 Kevin Zhu 10-15-16 Eddie's Dim Sum Tea House Cups Reimbursement 10-20-2016 Ting Fang Yes 7.39 Kevin Zhu 10-15-2016 Eddie's Dim Sum Tea House Cups Reimbursement 10-20-2016 Ting Fang Yes 195.15 Stephanie Hao 10-28-2016 Great Wall Dumpling Night Ingredients Reimbursement 11-15-2016 Ting Fang Yes 100.58 Ziwei Chen 10-14-2016 Great Wall Dim Sum Tea House Ingredients Reimbursement 11-15-2016 Ting Fang Yes 150 people (not including board 32.8 Cindy Yuan 10-28-2016 H-Mart Dumpling Night Drinks and Plates Reimbursement 11-15-2016 Ting Fang Yes members, Dumpling Night) 144.45 N/A October Van Charges Transfer N/A 21.2 Yunfan Zhao 11-01-2016 Amazon Dumpling Night Pocky for Prizes Reimbursement 11-15-2016 Ting Fang Yes 21.54 Ting Fang 11-05-2016 CVS Dumpling Night Bowls and Clorox Wipes Reimbursement 11-15-2016 Wen Wen Teh Yes 38.53 Andrew Gu 10-26-2016 Amazon Meet and Greet Panda Door Prizes Reimbursement 11-15-2016 Ting Fang No Resubmitted on 4/27/2017 30.24 David Cui 10-10-2016 Amazon Meet and Greet Panda Door Prizes Reimbursement 11-15-2016 Ting Fang Yes 30.96 David Cui 11/04/2016 Great Wall Dumpling Night Gas for Burners Reimbursement 11-15-2016 TIng Fang Yes 35.65 David Cui 11-10-2016 Giant Meet and Greet Ingredients Reimbursement 11-15-2016 Ting Fang Yes 30 people (not including board 23.79 David Cui 11-10-2016 Party City Meet and Greet Supplies Reimbursement 11-15-2016 Ting Fang Yes members, Meet and Greet) approximately 150 people (not 68.44 David Cui 11-09-2016 Great Wall TASA's Noodle Night Ingredients Reimbursement 11-15-2016 Ting Fang Yes including board members, TASA's Noodle night) 18.58 November Van Transfer 11.27 Fall Copier Transfer N/A N/A 29.3 January Van Transfer -900 Alumni Association Grant Transfer N/A Wen Wen Teh N/A

-273.59 N/A Dongzhi Festival November SAC Transfer N/A Wen Wen Teh N/A University 91.97 N/A 02-03-17 Amazon Lunar New Year Banquet Wire Racks, kerosene, pans N/A Ting Fang N/A Credit Card University 1735 N/A China Wok Lunar New Year Banquet Catering N/A Ting Fang N/A Credit Card University 116.6 N/A 02-01-2017 Amazon Lunar New Year Banquet Wristbands, Trivia Prizes (part II) N/A Ting Fang N/A Credit Card Vanessa 79.98 02-02-2017 Target Lunar New Year Banquet Helium Tanks (2) Reimbursement 03-01-2017 Ting Fang No Phuong 300 people (not including board members, Lunar New Year 65.94 David Cui 02-02-2017 CostCo Lunar New Year Banquet Silverware, Plateware, Cups Reimbursement 03-01-2017 Ting Fang Yes Banquet) University 88.11 N/A 02-07-17 Amazon Lunar New Year Banquet Food Warmer, flowers, tea bags N/A Ting Fang N/A Credit Card University 181.98 N/A 02-07-17 Amazon Lunar New Year Banquet Flowers and Wire Rack N/A Ting Fang N/A Credit Card Elizabeth 54.36 02-07-17 Giant Lunar New Year Banquet Drinks Reimbursement 03-01-2017 Ting Fang Yes Daugherty 29 David Cui 02-02-17 Dollar Tree Lunar New Year Banquet Tablecloths Reimbursement 03-01-2017 Ting Fang Yes -500 N/A Hotpot Event January SAC Transfer N/A Wen Wen Teh N/A 97.4 Ziwei Chen 02-05-2017 Great Wall Lunar New Year Banquet Ingredients Reimbursement 03-01-2017 Ting Fang No 92.67 Ziwei Chen 02-05-2017 Great Wall Lunar New Year Banquet Ingredients Reimbursement 03-01-2017 Ting Fang No 4.77 Ziwei Chen 02-05-2017 Great Wall Lunar New Year Banquet Ingredients Reimbursement 03-01-2017 Ting Fang No 44.94 Yunfan Zhao 01-24-2017 Yamibuy Lunar New Year Banquet Pocky for Prizes Reimbursement 03-01-2017 Ting Fang Yes 10 Yunfan Zhao 02-05-2017 Amazon Lunar New Year Banquet Trivia Prizes Reimbursement 03-01-2017 Ting Fang Yes 10 Kevin Zhu 02-08-2017 Etsy Lunar New Year Banquet Trivia Prizes Reimbursement 03-01-2017 Ting Fang Yes 9.99 Kevin Zhu 02-10-2017 CVS Lunar New Year Banquet Masking Tape Reimbursement 03-01-2017 TIng Fang Yes Elizabeth 20 people (not including board 71.34 03-05-2017 H-Mart Crafts of China Snacks Reimbursement 04-19-2017 Ting Fang Yes Daugherty members, Crafts of China) -353.74 N/A Qing Ming Festival March SAC Transfer N/A Wen Wen Teh No Elizabeth Book Store 19.08 03-09-2017 Iron Chef Cookbook Reimbursement 04-19-2017 Ting Fang Yes Daugherty Next Door University 39.89 N/A 04-03-2017 Amazon Iron Chef Trivia Prizes N/A Ting Fang N/A Credit Card 14.95 Bertha Hu 04-05-2017 Amazon Iron Chef Ingredients Reimbursement 04-19-2017 Ting Fang No 12.54 Nathan Xu 03-30-2017 Amazon Iron Chef Ingredients Reimbursement 04-21-2017 Ting Fang No 10.15 Grace Duan 04-08-2017 Giant Iron Chef Ingredients Reimbursement 04-19-2017 Ting Fang No 18.83 Grace Duan 04-08-2017 CVS Iron Chef Soda, Tea, Water Reimbursement 04-19-2017 Ting Fang No 150 people (not including board members, Iron Chef) 29.85 Grace Duan 04-01-2017 H Mart Iron Chef Ingredients Reimbursement 04-19-2017 Ting Fang No 27.95 Jacob Wei 04-01-2017 H Mart Iron Chef Ingredients Reimbursement 04-19-2017 Ting Fang No 40 Ziwei Chen 04-06-2017 H Mart Iron Chef Ingredients Reimbursement 04-19-2017 Ting Fang No 40 Wei Wen 04-06-2017 H Mart Iron Chef Ingredients Reimbursement 04-19-2017 Ting Fang No 33.44 Amy Yu 04-06-2017 H Mart Iron Chef Ingredients Reimbursement 04-19-2017 Ting Fang No 57.24 Grace Duan 04-06-2017 H Mart Iron Chef Ingredients Reimbursement 04-19-2017 Ting Fang No 40 Andrew Gu 04-08-2017 Giant Iron Chef Ingredients Reimbursement 04-27-2017 Ting Fang No 200 people (not including board members, TASA Night Market) || 78.09 Ronald Wang 04-06-2017 H Mart TASA Night Market Ingredients Reimbursement 04-21-2017 Ting Fang No TASA reimbursing for $48.03 (total is 126.12)

EXECUTIVE BOARD

Presidents (2) Vice President (traditionally 2, but only one this year because the second one stepped down) Secretary (1) Treasurers (2)

CHAIRS

Culinary (2) Recruitment (2) Programming & Heritage (2) Publicity (2) Webmaster (1) Social (2) Historian (1)

GENERAL

Tell us a little more about yourself. -Hobbies, interests, passions How did you hear about us? What do you know about CSA? *Why do you want to join CSA? -Most important question, a member’s activity in future years is predicted by their reason for joining CSA.

Why are you interested in Chinese culture?

Have you met any of the board members yet? How well do you know them? CSA meets on Thursday nights at 8(9?) and holds events mainly the weekends, how free are you during those times?

DETERMINING LEADERSHIP SKILLS AND POTENTIAL COMMITTEES

What do you see yourself doing in CSA?

What role do you normally take in a group environment?

What are your strengths?

What are your weaknesses?

Do you plan on studying abroad?

Do you plan on rushing (Greek/academic/professional) You have a friend who knows very little about Chinese/Asian culture but wants to learn more.

What do you do?

If you could be a tool in a toolbox, which one you be and why? CREATIVE QUESTIONS FOR PERSONALITY ASSESSMENT (Choose ~2) Share a memorable experience with us.

If you could rule the world for a day what would you do?

If you could have dinner with any two people, dead or alive, who would they be?

Who is your hero and why?

What’s something you’ve done that you’re proud of?

Tell us about the best gift you've ever received.

If you could live anywhere in the world where would you live and why?

Are you a hunter or a gatherer?

Cultural/culinary questions What’s your go to dish to impress someone and why?

How much do you know about cooking?

Can you speak Chinese, and if so, how well? (this is important for catering and ordering purposes) Historian/Publicity Do you have your own camera? If not, have you completed the camera equipment training at the DMC?

Do you know how to use Photoshop or another type of picture editing software?

Webmaster Do you know how to code? If so, which languages?

Have you ever created or managed a website?

Treasury Have you ever worked with finances or accounting?

What aspect of treasury interests you the most?

What does money mean to you?

On a scale of 1 - 10, how ethical would you rate yourself?

To be honest, a perfect Treasurer is a solid 7. Loyalty over ethics lol. -David What is one thing you want to do before you graduate Hopkins?

CONCLUDING QUESTIONS

Do you have any questions for us?

Do you have anything else you’d like for us to know?

Sources

Chinese Student Association Investigation Summary.pdf