JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

Senate Meeting #10 (11 13 18)

Filed in Drive as “Senate Meeting #10 (11_13_18)”

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

SENATE OF THE JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION

Consolidated General Body Meeting Agenda and Minutes

November 13th, 2018

7:00 PM, Charles Commons East Room

Preceded by SGA-hosted livestream of forum on community policing at 6:00 PM in Charles Commons Salon B and C.

Agenda

Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)

Approval of the Agenda & Prior Minutes (1 min)

Kahoot (10 min)

Reports (18 min)

Executive Board Reports (4 min)

Committee Reports (7 min)

Academic Affairs — Senator Taj

Civic Engagement — President Schatmeyer, Senator Paulet

Finance — Senator Mays, Treasurer Tu

Health, Safety and Sustainability — Senator Paulet, Senator Patel

Internal Affairs — Senator Baron, Vice President Tsang

Student Organizations — President Chien, Senator Elgendi

Student Services — Senator Cai, President Schatmeyer

Class Council Reports (4 min)

Advisor Report (3 min)

New Business (80 min)

TRU ICE Letter Presentation [Letter] (10 min)

African Fashion Show Funding Bill [Link] (15 min)

Culture Festival Funding Bill [Link] [Slideshow] (15 min)

TRU ICE Letter Discussion (10 min)

Daniels Dinner Practice Presentations (30 min)

Prospective Business (5 min)

Advancing Legislation

Announcements

Public Input Period

Adjournment (ESTIMATED 9:00 PM, ACTUAL 8:59 PM)

Time-length and adjournment estimates are provided for the benefit of guests at Senate meetings. However, SGA meetings are always slated to extend until 9:00 PM and SGA members are expected to remain in the Senate chamber until official adjournment by motion, whether before or after the adjournment estimate.

Recommended Discussion Systems

GRO ICE Letter Discussion (10 min)

9-min mod with 45 sec speaking times (6 min)

Motion to sign SGA to the letter (1 min)

African Fashion Show Funding Bill [Link] (15 min)

Introduction (5 min)

Q & A (5 min)

Motion to Introduce and Approve

5-min mod with 30 sec speaking times (5 min)

Culture Festival Funding Bill [Link] (15 min)

Introduction (5 min)

Q & A (5 min)

Motion to Introduce and Approve

5-min mod with 30 sec speaking times (5 min)

MINUTES

Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)

Roll Called

Approval of the Agenda & Prior Minutes (1 min)

Reports (18 min)

Executive Board Reports (4 min)

President

Optional wholesome social events

VP

Student Center Capital Development Proposal

Met with Brittany Shaff last Tuesday.

Shift capital proposal to engagement proposal to tie in donor support from young alumni, work with Annual Giving on senior donations and let President’s office take the lead on seeking large donors.

Rendering competition.

Daniels Dinner Briefing Doc

Thanks to everyone who worked on these! Will be selecting final topics today.

Trustee Scheeler Dinner

Had dinner with Trustee Scheeler a couple weeks ago. Discussed mental health, divestment, current events.

Renewable Energy Investment Resolution

On the advice of a few alumni at the Senior Symposium who worked on the divestment initiative in their time at Hopkins, and then proceeded into fields like law or finance, we’d like to attempt a resolution that calls for renewable energy investment in the university. In the original SGA resolution two years ago, we included renewable energy investment clauses but that wasn’t the main goal of the resolution. This time, we’d like to make it the main objective of the resolution, which is important to accelerate the energy transition on a global level. Timeframe: Early Spring, to give time to meet with Sam and Clarissa, and for the PRDC to conduct a stock-portfolio analysis.

SGA Alumni Advisory Board

Spoke with former SGA members Janice Bonsu, Liam Haviv, Adelaide Morphett, and Tiffany Yang last weekend at the Senior Symposium. They are all on board with the idea of creating an SGA Alumni Advisory Board. The Board would hold one teleconference with SGA each semester to talk about current initiatives, solicit alumni perspective and advice on those initiatives, learn more about SGA history, and connect current SGA members with alumni.

Also working with Adelaide to host an SGA alumni and current SGA member reception at Homecoming in early April.

SGA Homecoming Event

Teleconference tomorrow morning.

Community Council Proposal

Description.

Wellbeing Champions Proposal

Description.

Secretary

Send referendum to 5 friends

FERPA

GDrives (with attendance)

Salem and around campus tour

Alumni meetup

Treasurer

About 6k in contingency and events each

Committee Reports (7 min)

Academic Affairs — Senator Taj

Working on resolution to point out the school’s apathy about the humanities - want SGA to support the humanities

Civic Engagement — President Schatmeyer, Senator Paulet

Reorienting

Work done in the past - work with center on student elections

More direct service groups

Redo rise up rally

Finance — Senator Mays, Treasurer Tu

Passed bills

Health, Safety and Sustainability — Senator Paulet, Senator Patel

Placed order for wellness wednesday

Got videos from cmc

Internal Affairs — Senator Baron, Vice President Tsang

4 judiciary hearings - full floor vote on December 4th for confirmations

Student Organizations — President Chien, Senator Elgendi

Started voting on groups

Finished half

Student Services — Senator Cai, President Schatmeyer

Did not meet last week

Had a meeting with Dean Wilson about free printing

Class Council Reports (4 min)

Seniors

Dec. 9th event → giving away shirts or beanies

May partner with other organizations

Juniors

Have a lot more money than they thought they had

Giveaway on Dec. 9th → with seniors?

Assassin is going well

Sophomores

Submissions for grant program are rolling in

Sophshow is in the works

21Takeoff if going well

Met with off campus housing

Freshmen

Trying to have an end of semester study break

Formal in the spring

KSHO meeting - expressed interest in providing more student orgs with funding in the hopes the increase their numbers

KSHO was interested in student safety initiatives

KSHO would like SGA to organize some policing forum

Advisor Report (3 min)

No report

New Business (80 min)

GRO/TRU ICE Letter Presentation [Letter] (10 min)

See letter

Many groups drafted a response to the Daniels’ response about ICE

Coalition does not see ICE as an issue with the current US administration - but the systems itself

Misportrays what the classes actually are - its adjuncts teaching seminars - AAUP are strong defenders of academic freedom but draw the line at externally funded program - can’t claim academic freedom is boundless especially when externally funded

Response has been put forward by SAPP, TRU, GRO (tbd), etc.

100 signers on response letter so far

Daniels’ response is insufficient

GRO/TRU ICE Letter Discussion (10 min)

President Schatmeyer

Read a quote from the letter - commented on the beauty of the wording

Senator Uraih

Have you reached out to other divisions of the school?

School of medicine said that it would blow up - knew it would be controversial - the school believes this will pass - this agency should have nothing to do with the school - SoE is more difficult to speak with

President Schatmeyer

Are we signing this letter?

Discussing later

Motion for 9 minute moderated caucus with 45 second speaking times

Senator Forlenza - was here for the original SGA meeting about it - we should sign on

President Schatmeyer - TRU letter breaks down the response point by point - conveys the response in a well argued manner - we’ve already put forth a resolution - we would be moving back if we didn’t sign on

Senator Lloyd - their letter and the presentation refuted Daniels well - we should endorse it

Senator Patel - yield

Senator Murak - this is a very political move - we are doing this right before the Daniels’ dinner - don’t want it to detract from the dinner

POI - how do we motion to sign ? - we just motion to sign

Motion to end mod caucus and have round robin - 10 seconds

Senator Mays

sign

Kylie - sign

Mo - sign

Dean - sign

Sam S - yes

Eric - yield

Gianni - yield

Lots of yields and yes’s

Senator Wellons - motion to sign

5 abstentions - passes

African Fashion Show Funding Bill [Link] (15 min)

Edo came back!!

Showed a video from instagram

Asking for 1k - clothes are from designers in the area

Money goes to rent out the clothing - traditional african fabric - paying for their time to make the clothes

Solar Sister - a charity that mentors women in Uganda, Nigeria, and Tanzania to eradicate energy poverty in communities without electricity

Reaches beyond homewood - people from all over Baltimore area come to it

Senator Bannister Motion for 5 minutes Q&A

Senator Bannister - how do you pick who walks in the show

Anyone who signs up

Senator Thomas - what day is it?

December 8th

Senator Elgendi - is it every semester or year?

Every year - we did it in the spring last year because it was the pilot year - will continue to be in the fall

Senator Murak - how are we advertised

Program says thanks to SGA

President Schatmeyer - motion to end Q&A

Passed

Senator Mays - motion to introduce and approve

Senator Lloyd - will you do it again next year? And will you ask for funding again?

Yes

Senator Panakam - are you actively trying to seek out funds from other grants?

They are also going to SAC to get money

Senator Bannister - motion to end discussion

Approved

Motion passes unanimously

Culture Festival Funding Bill [Link] (15 min)

Maya is back too!

Event that brings together Hop community - people don’t know how diverse our campus is

Celebrates Hopkins diversity

MCLC and OMA have partnered

There are performances

Over 30 student groups participating - food or trivia or workshops or music

Chief Diversity Officer will speak

Funding for food costs, t-shirts, banner, colored printing of programs

Kwame Phillips didn’t want to completely fund food - so SGA is subsidizing

Senator Panakam - 300 for colored printing - what is that for?

Passport, programs

Senator Panakam - how many units are we getting? Can you go through Brody?

Doesn’t know the details

Senator Cai - How much are you paying total for this event?

Getting 1k from Kwame

Getting resources from involved student groups

Already exceeded budget from OMA

Senator Thomas - how much have you gotten from other groups?

Student groups are funding their resources but were subsidizing printing and t-shirts

Majority of these costs are requested items from student groups - has yet to be finalized

Buying t-shirts and printing fliers are a lot of the cost

Senator Thomas - it doesn’t make sense for 30 student groups to be there without funding the event

Their funding comes from the wishlist

We asked them how we can help them - have already requested what they need

Have already invested what they are going to do - don’t want to burden student groups

Senator Thomas - why can’t they raise the money?

Senator Patel - motion for 5 minute Q&A

Motion approved

Senator Patel - can you give a brief estimate of how much each stakeholder is giving

Student groups are funding their own stuff - submitting costs to Kwame - does not have access to it

Senator Murak - have you looked at what the cost difference would be between b&w or colored printing?

Haven’t considered it because we want it colored

Senator Armstrong - who is paying for wishlist items

Kwame

President Schatmeyer - likes the concept - in terms of language of funding bill, a little sparse - would like more detail in terms of where the money is going - what else is happening at event - at this point we need to commit

Senator Cai - for the idea of the event but confused about the details and the specificities - who is hosting?

All the groups are co-hosting - OMA and MCLC is helping

Senator Panakam - would you be willing to come back?

Yes can do

Senator Uraih - OMA did the passport thing for their open house - it was cumbersome - can you save money?

We don’t need to do it

Senator Thomas - can you charge the groups a participation fee - would allow for a base

Charging groups for something like this prevents people from doing it - had so many people interested there wasn’t enough room for all interested group - for a first event it’s not a good idea

Senator Bannister - motion to introduce and approve

Motion for 9 minute mod caucus with 45 second speaking times

Senator Bannister

Like the bill and support it - to address some points - students groups are putting any skin in the game - they do put in money for their own food and contribution - funding is for what they can’t cover - should be more relaxed

Senator Cai

Can you come back next time because confused

Senator Wellons

I like the bill - student groups putting in money - a lot of student groups have debt and not enough funding - Jackie won’t approve any purchases until their out of debt

President Chien

We’re not going to be here the next two weeks - we shouldn’t rush this - we need to think about it - how fast do you think you can get some of this information - recommend we move onto another point of business while you get information

Senator Patel

Motion to table to next meeting

Dilatory

Senator Thomas

Would like to clarify - am in support of the event - but we need to be better with finance - we also need to know where the money is going - you should be able to put in 20 dollars

Senator Murak

Kudos for taking this on it seems like it will be an amazing event - we are being asked 900 - would only be $30 per group - would doing this through the student groups be a better idea?

President Schatmeyer

yield

Senator Bannister

We passed bills that are ambiguous - this bill does have specifics - is there confusion between where the money is coming from externally? - would point to mental health task force recommendation #1: we should build a culture of happiness - this bill is a good way to do this - we should stop telling speaker how to do her job - this organization has a plan and has a lot of commitment

Senator Thomas

Don’t know where the financing is coming from and what we can contribute to later on - what will other student orgs be contributing

Senator Armstrong

there are so many groups and this is a good idea - because there are so many participants - there wasn’t enough consideration as to what groups can put int

Senator Cai

Budget numbers?

Treasurer Tu - we have 5,020 for events - have another 6k for contingency - we can move money around - we’ve used about 40% - and we’re not in debt

Would want to help for less money - there is a possibility for student groups to contribute - we get a lot of bills second semester

Senator Bannister - motion to extend 6 minutes?

Motion passes with one nay

Senator Bannister

We funded a tailgate bill towards pizza and posters - put money towards mens athletics - doesn’t think it was a good use of funding - this bill emphasizes culture on our campus

Senator Mays

We had too much money after first semester - it would be appropriate if we got through half of our budget by break

Senator Parmar

How many of these student groups would not be able to pay - SASH has a huge budget - for larger groups it would be less difficult

Does not know details but many groups have financial issues

Senator Lloyd

Echoing what others have said - does not think bill should pass in current state- details are not as concrete as would like - we should be focusing on finance

Senator Uraih

If you think about outreach - this is a lot of groups and would reach many people - cultural groups get no money this year - there should be more information - 90% of OMA’s events get funded last minute - we are serving Hop students

Senator Wellons

Would like to note - people need to be disrespectful - if a woman is talking about sexism and men are laughing that is despicable - this is an important event and the speaker knows what she’s talking about - the finance is extremely complicated

Senator Elgendi

This list is very diverse - if we are going to spend money on something we should do it here - our job as SGA is to represent our students - we are running out of time and we aren’t meeting - we should vote

President Schatmeyer

Had some concerns initially - we are all Hop students - you know how to manage money and they clubs do as well - ambiguity can be resolved - use the severability clause - we should pass

I am not part of everything that goes on - ambiguity is from unresponsiveness - tried to get as many details as possible - will be going to concrete things

POI - can we vote contingent - yes

Senator Murak

Two main concerns are color printing and the student groups who can help fund - want to see if we can consider a contingency statement - this would quell concerns - this is deserving of subsidization

Point of Order - last week we didn’t ask questions about printing or decoration breakdowns - there is a lost more scrutiny

President Chien - contingency amendment - pass for $650 - $15 recommended fee for student groups - $650 covers costs that can be lowered - $150 for food, $150 for banner, lower marketing to $150 - lower t-shirts to $150 - blurb sent to SGA about costs - contingent on approval of finance committee

POI - bill is now at $650?

Senator Uraih - motion to introduce and approve

Passes unanimously

Daniels Dinner Practice Presentations (30 min)

Practiced presentations for Daniels’ dinner - about 5 minutes a piece

Security

Sexual Assault

Prospective Business (5 min)

Advancing Legislation

Security - bring up Coppin States

Announcements

Public Input Period

Adjournment (ESTIMATED 8:50 PM, ACTUAL 8:59 PM)

Sources

Senate Meeting #10 (11_13_18).docx