JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

Health, Generally

You are viewing the latest version.
  • “A surprising 30% of the senior women had experienced unwanted intercourse; 42% of the women had experienced only wanted intercourse; 28% had no sexual intercourse. The median number of unwanted intercourse experiences was four. For over half the respondents, the partner was a casual date known a short time; for about one-third he was a fiance or steady boyfriend; for the remainder he was a friend they knew well.” (Lewin, 1985)
  • “We see that many negative reactions are anticipated from the man if the woman refuses. If the woman agrees, only 4% of our respondents consider it very likely that the man would have more respect for the woman afterwards.” (Lewin, 1985)
  • “The sample splits into two roughly equal groups with regard to their own feelings if they accept the man: about half would be ashamed and angry, the other half pleased and expecting positive feelings from the man. The woman who feels ashamed is also angry (Kendall’s rank-order correlation, tau = .84), concerned about her reputation (Pearson correlation, r = .65), not fond of the man (tau = - .70), and not in love with him (tau = - .30). The woman who feels pleased also expects the man to be fond of her (Pearson r = .47), expects it to be 'somewhat' or 'very' likely that the man has more respect for her (r = .4?), and finds it 'somewhat likely' that the man will be in love with her (r = .31).” (Lewin, 1985)
  • “If we perform a 'hedonic calculus' or cost-benefit analysis with these figures, as recommended by exchange theorists, we see that the lowest ratio of negative to positive feelings results if the woman accepts. If the woman includes the man’s feelings in her hedonic calculus, the 'cost-benefit' superiority of accepting becomes enormous in spite of the fact that the woman’s own feelings about accepting are predominantly negative. This cost-benefit analysis gives us an important insight into the genesis of unwanted intercourse.” (Lewin, 1985)
  • “About one-quarter of our group had a 'double bind' or 'you’re damned if you do and you’re damned if you don’t' expectation: Both stories had negative outcomes. These are predominantly the same people who reported on the questionnaire that they would be angry if they refused, concerned that they hurt the man, expect the man to be angry, to lose his self esteem, to no longer wish to see the woman, and to think her frigid if she says no, but to have less respect for her if she says yes. These'“angry refusers' expect that they would be in love with the man after they accepted but that he would not be in love with them.” (Lewin, 1985)
  • “Negative-negative outcome stories were written by 54% of those subjects who reported that they had actually experienced unwanted intercourse in their own lives. In contrast, only 18% of those subjects who had been asked to have sex but who refused showed the negative-negative pattern (χ² = 4.65, p < .05). We see that those who have experienced unwanted intercourse are particularly likely to take the 'damned either way' viewpoint.” (Lewin, 1985)
  • “I felt that I had to go through with the complete sexual act because of a feeling of pressure I felt by the male. In a way I felt perhaps I would let him down and as a result he would like me less. . . in fact he never spoke to me after the experience. . . I should have been as selfish as he was.” (Lewin, 1985)
  • “Women might feel pressured to refuse sex—even sex that they desire—to avoid negative social repercussions (Hamilton & Armstrong, 2009). If a woman refuses a man’s sexual advances, he might assume she is refusing for appearance’s sake (Muehlenhard, 2011; Osman, 2007; Osman & Davis, 1999), or he might assume that she will eventually give in, and he might feel justified continuing his advances (Jozkowski & Hunt, 2014). Men might pursue sex—even sex that they do not desire—to appear more masculine (Pascoe, 2005; Sweeney, 2014; Wiederman, 2005).” (Muehlenhard et al., 2016, p. 460)
  • “Many underage women are given alcohol by older male students, resulting in a situation where intoxicated young women feel beholden to older, more experienced men (Armstrong et al., 2006). Underage students drink alcohol less often than their older peers, but when they do drink, they are more likely to binge drink (defined as consuming at least four [for women] or five [for men] alcoholic drinks in a row; Wechsler et al., 2002).” (Muehlenhard et al., 2016, p. 461)
  • “Compared with sober women, intoxicated women showed less awareness of, and less discomfort with, sexual assault risk cues in hypothetical dating scenarios, especially more ambiguous risk cues. Even at fairly low doses, alcohol can decrease women’s ability to detect signs that the situation is becoming risky.” (Muehlenhard et al., 2016, p. 461)
  • “They asked students to imagine themselves in a dating situation in which one partner initially refuses sex but sex eventually happens and then to write about what they think happened between those two points. Beres et al. (2014) had anticipated that students would write about miscommunication, but instead most of them wrote about uncertainty; in these stories, 'the woman felt some desire for a sexual relationship with the man, but there were also uncertainties or other feelings that prevented her from agreeing to the original physical demand or verbal request' (p. 769). In these accounts the woman’s uncertainty was resolved prior to having sex, usually through conversation, a more gradual increase in physical intimacy, or self-reflection.” (Muehlenhard et al., 2016, p. 464)
  • “Hall (1998) asked a sample of U.S. college students to complete a questionnaire about their most recent sexual encounter “wherein they indicated ‘yes’” to engaging in the sexual activity. Participants were asked how they had indicated yes: verbally, nonverbally, or both. Most (61%) reported having consented to the sexual encounter both verbally and nonverbally; some (28%) reported having consented only nonverbally; few (11%) reported having consented only verbally. Those who consented nonverbally reported doing so in multiple ways, including getting closer, kissing, caressing, touching intimately, smiling, and not moving away. There were only a few significant gender differences in ways of showing consent: More women than men reported showing consent by hugging and caressing (72% versus 64%) and by not moving away (59% versus 48%).” (Muehlenhard et al., 2016, pp. 467–468)
  • “Hall (1998) also asked whether participants had “specifically indicated” consent for various sexual behaviors in which they had engaged. The behaviors most likely to have received specific consent were penile–vaginal intercourse (PVI), receiving oral sex, and anal sex (in contrast, kissing, hugging, and breast and genital touching were less likely to receive specific consent). Consent for specific behaviors was usually given nonverbally. The sexual behavior most likely to have received verbal consent was PVI, although even for PVI, nonverbal consent was more common than verbal consent. Among women, consenting verbally was more common for first-time PVI experiences with a partner than for subsequent experiences; men did not show this pattern. Hall concluded that “much of the sexual activity of college students proceeds without much verbal permission granting,” relying instead on nonverbal permission. Interestingly, both women and men reported that they most frequently showed their consent by not resisting their partners’ advances. They reported using direct verbal and direct nonverbal expressions of consent least frequently.” (Muehlenhard et al., 2016, p. 468)
  • “Paradoxically, participants’ interpretations of these behaviors (i.e., the extent to which they rated the behaviors as indicative of their own and their partner’s consent) were inversely related to how often they reported using these behaviors to show consent in real-life situations. For example, making no response was rated as the most frequent way of expressing consent but as least indicative of consent. Directly expressing consent either nonverbally or verbally was rated as the least frequent way of expressing consent but as most indicative of consent. We return to this paradox later.” (Muehlenhard et al., 2016, p. 468)
  • “Using open-ended questionnaires, Jozkowski, Peterson, Sanders, Dennis, and Reece (2014) asked U.S. college students to “imagine you are with another person and sexual activity may occur. During the encounter, if you were willing to engage in sex with your partner, how would you let your partner know?” (p. 908). Inductive coding was used to identify emerging themes. Men most frequently reported that they would use nonverbal cues (reported by 48% of the men), followed by verbal cues (32%), verbal and nonverbal cues (12%), and just letting it happen/not saying no (2%). Some men and women regarded men’s consent cues as irrelevant, however, because they assumed that men always consent. Surprisingly, women most frequently reported that they would express their willingness using verbal cues (reported by 50% of the women), followed by verbal and nonverbal cues (23%), just letting it happen/not saying no (14%), and nonverbal cues (10%). This reported reliance on verbal cues to express consent differed from the results of other studies. Subsequent analyses (Jozkowski & Peterson, 2013) showed that almost all of the verbal-consent-only women had imagined responding to a verbal request for sex (e.g., “After he asks me, then I would say yes,” Jozkowski & Peterson, 2013, p. 519). These results might not generalize to situations involving other ways of initiating. It is also possible that the women were using language figuratively rather than literally—that is, they might have been imagining saying yes through nonverbal means (similar to Hall’s [1998], asking participants if they had said yes verbally, nonverbally, or both).” (Muehlenhard et al., 2016, p. 469)
  • “Participants were also asked how they would let their partner know if they were not willing to engage in sex (Jozkowski, Peterson, et al., 2014). Most women (86%) and men (71%) wrote that they would communicate nonconsent verbally (with or without additional nonverbal cues); refusing verbally was reported more often than consenting verbally.” (Muehlenhard et al., 2016, p. 469)
  • “Several studies used focus groups to ask participants how they would refuse sex. Kitzinger and Frith (1999) asked English female high school and university students how they would refuse sex. Many of the young women reported that it was difficult to refuse directly because it might seem awkward or rude or might hurt their partner’s feelings. Some even went ahead with unwanted sexual activity to avoid refusing. A few stated that a direct verbal no was the easiest and most effective way to refuse, but some also acknowledged that it was awkward and embarrassing. Many reported softening their refusals by offering delayed acceptances (e.g., 'I’m not ready yet') rather than unqualified refusals; by offering palliatives (e.g., 'I do like you but…'); or by offering excuses, especially excuses that involved an inability to have sex (e.g., illness, menstruation) rather than an unwillingness to have sex.” (Muehlenhard et al., 2016, p. 469)
  • “When partners communicate consent to engage in a sexual encounter, their communication often follows a sexual script (i.e., a set of cultural guidelines for appropriate sexual behavior and how to progress in a sexual encounter; Gagnon & Simon, 2009) in which an actual verbalization of consent to sex is largely absent (Beres, 2007; Edgar & Fitzpatrick, 1993).” (Jozkowski et al., 2014, p. 905)
  • “Traditional scripts seem to suggest that consent is primarily communicated by women and interpreted by men. Despite these stereotypes, research suggests that women do initiate sex and men do offer consent (or nonconsent) to engage in sexual activity (e.g., O'Sullivan & Byers, 1992). In one study, more than half of men reported being in a situation in which a woman attempted to have sexual contact with him because she overestimated his level of sexual desire (Anderson & Sorenson, 1999), and research suggests that women do sometimes coerce or force men into sex (e.g., Struckman-Johnson, Struckman-Johnson, & Anderson, 2003).” (Jozkowski et al., 2014)
  • “Hall (1998) assessed how U.S. college students indicated their own consent to sexual activity at their most recent sexual encounter by providing students with a list of sexual behaviors and asking them how they communicated permission to have sex, giving two options: verbal cues or nonverbal cues. He found that most students indicated consent to each behavior nonverbally. There were no significant differences between men and women in their use of verbal versus nonverbal cues (Hall, 1998). Such findings indicate that students in general, regardless of gender, were not likely to verbalize consent. Hall (1998) also found that students were more likely to indicate verbal consent for more intimate behaviors (i.e., intercourse behaviors) compared to what he considered less intimate behaviors such as kissing, manual sex (i.e., touching/stimulating of genitals), and oral sex, suggesting that consent varies based on the type of behavior being initiated. However, because Hall (1998) presented students with only verbal or nonverbal options for indicators of consent, there is still a great deal of information researchers do not know about how college students express consent.” (Jozkowski et al., 2014)
  • “Hickman and Muehlenhard (1999) found gender differences in the use of verbal and nonverbal indicators of consent. Using a sample of U.S. college students, they asked participants to rate the extent to which they used 34 different behaviors to indicate sexual consent. Women reported using more indirect verbal signals of consent than men, and men reported using more indirect nonverbal signals than women; however, the indicator of consent used most by both men and women was 'no response' (i.e., a lack of refusal or resistance).” (Jozkowski et al., 2014)
  • “There is a substantial literature suggesting that miscommunication about sexual consent may contribute to sexual aggression. Specifically, research findings suggest that men overinterpret women's interest in sex (e.g., Abbey, 1982, 1987), men interpret women's refusal of sex as simply 'token resistance' (i.e., saying no but meaning yes; e.g., Osman, 2003), and women are sometimes too frightened, embarrassed, or confused to directly communicate their consent (e.g., Hickman & Muehlenhard, 1999).” (Jozkowski et al., 2014)
  • “As illustrated in Table 2, male and female participants provided similar responses for the questions related to definitions of consent. There were no statistical gender differences regarding how consent was defined χ²(14, N = 179) = 13.01 (p = .43).” (Jozkowski et al., 2014, p. 909)
  • “Based on comparisons of the first two categories listed in Table 3 (representing verbal and nonverbal indicators of consent), contrary to our hypothesis, participants were overall more likely to endorse verbal than nonverbal indicators of consent, χ²(9, N = 161) = 15.10, p < .022, and nonconsent, χ²(2, N = 183) = 7.27, p < .001.” (Jozkowski et al., 2014, p. 910)
  • “Fisher's tests revealed that, consistent with our hypotheses, men were more likely than women to use nonverbal cues (e.g., 'I would indicate that I wanted to have sex through my body language'; 'I wouldn't progress any further in sexual activity') to indicate their consent and nonconsent to engage in sexual activity, whereas women were more likely than men to indicate consent via verbal cues (e.g., 'I would tell my partner that I wanted to have sex').” (Jozkowski et al., 2014, p. 910)
  • “When examining the content of the responses coded as verbal indicators of consent more specifically, men frequently reported telling their partner they were 'going to engage in sexual activity with them,' whereas women frequently reported that they would 'respond yes to being asked if it was okay to engage in sexual activity.' Women were also more likely to report using a combination of verbal and nonverbal cues to indicate consent to sexual activity compared to men (e.g., 'I would say I wanted to have sex with him and continue to kiss and touch'), although in general, participants indicated this response infrequently. Women also more frequently reported just letting the sexual activity happen or not saying no to the sexual activity as compared to men (e.g., 'I wouldn't stop his advances or say no'; 'I would just let it happen'), though the number of participants who indicated this response was too low to conduct statistical analyses.” (Jozkowski et al., 2014, p. 910)
  • “Based on comparisons of verbal and nonverbal indicators of consent, consistent with our hypothesis, participants were overall more likely to use nonverbal than verbal indicators to interpret their partners' consent, χ²(6, N = 173) = 3.18, p < .05, and more likely to use verbal than a combination of verbal and nonverbal cues to interpret their partners' nonconsent, χ²(4, N = 80) = 8.65, p < .05.” (Jozkowski et al., 2014, p. 911)
  • “As shown in Table 3, consistent with our hypothesis, men were far more likely than women to assume consent to sexual activity via nonverbal cues exclusively; indeed, this was by far the most common strategy reported by men (e.g., 'If she was kissing me back and seemed into it, I would figure she wanted to'; 'I can tell by her nonverbal if she was kissing or touching me, if she danced with me, etc.'; 'If we are making eye contact'). Also, consistent with our hypothesis, women were more likely than men to rely on verbal cues to interpret their partners' consent (e.g., 'If he said he was going to get a condom or asked me if wanted to have sex'); only about 10% of men indicated that they would look for verbal cues to interpret their partners' consent to engage in sexual activity, compared to nearly 30% of women.” (Jozkowski et al., 2014)
  • “Upon closer examination of the content of participants' responses coded as verbal cues, men reported interpreting consent from their partners by saying that they would 'ask if she was willing to engage in sexual activity and being told yes,' whereas women frequently reported that they interpreted consent when their partner 'asked them if they were interested in having sex and they had the opportunity to respond' (both coded as verbal cues), implying that women interpreted that their partner was consenting to sex if he was asking for sex.” (Jozkowski et al., 2014)
  • “In regard to nonconsent, again, there was an overall gender difference, with follow-up tests providing support for our hypotheses. Men were more likely than women to look for nonverbal cues from their partners to indicate nonconsent to sexual activity (e.g., 'If she just did not seem into it, wasn't making eye contact, pushed me away, or didn't want to be touched'). Women were more likely than men to utilize a combination of verbal and nonverbal cues from their partner to indicate nonconsent (e.g., 'If he said he didn't want to or was tired and got up and left').” (Jozkowski et al., 2014)
  • “However, analyses of how participants actually communicated and interpreted consent suggested that many college students, despite defining consent as an explicit communication of agreement, often use consent signals that are less clear than providing explicit permission or saying yes.” (Jozkowski et al., 2014)
  • “College students may default to utilizing nonverbal cues to interpret a partner's consent more frequently than verbal cues for several reasons, including (a) cultural endorsements of such scripts influence college students' conceptualizations of sex communication, (b) college students may feel uncomfortable asking their partners for explicit verbal consent or believe that it ruins the mood, or (c) it may be the expectation of college students that consent to sex is implied unless otherwise specified.” (Jozkowski et al., 2014)
  • “One might assume that people would look for the same kinds of cues from partners that they themselves would use to indicate consent to sex, yet current findings demonstrate this is not necessarily the case. There may be a disjuncture between what participants say they do and what they say their partner does. That is, individuals may believe that they express consent verbally but in actual sexual situations tend to fall back on nonverbal indicators. Likewise, individuals may think they are communicating consent verbally (and thus report doing so on our survey) but their verbal communications may be tentative, indirect, or difficult to interpret; thus, their partners end up relying more heavily on nonverbal cues. It is also possible that, when you ask someone how they indicate consent, they may think in terms of what they intentionally do to indicate consent or nonconsent, but aspects of communication (perhaps nonverbal or paralinguistic) might not be so intentionally 'controlled.' When answering a question on a survey about communicating consent or nonconsent, participants may respond with the more intentional aspects of their communication repertoire rather than the immediate 'uncontrolled' response in which they may be more likely to engage during the encounter itself.” (Jozkowski et al., 2014)
  • “Perhaps men—especially men who accept the stereotypes of men as sexual initiators and women as sexual gatekeepers may not verbally ask for consent because they assume that they are responsible for advancing the sexual interaction and women are responsible for clearly communicating nonconsent.” (Jozkowski et al., 2014)
  • “Previous research (Abbey, McAuslan, & Ross, 1998; Abbey, Ross, McDuffie, & McAuslan, 1996; Donat & Bondurant, 2003; Haselton, 2003; Lindgren, Parkhill, George, and Hendershot, 2008; Malamuth & Brown, 1994) has indicated that men tend to perceive women's friendly behavior as more sexual than women would interpret the same behavior or than women intended the friendliness to imply. Men in the current study relied on nonverbal cues as indicators of consent. This is important to note in light of the previous research on sexual misinterpretation, as it raises the possibility that men's interpretation of women's nonverbal cues of consent may sometimes be inaccurate. It may be the case that a man might think that a woman is giving him signals of consent, when in fact she does not intend to consent to engage in sexual activity; this type of miscommunication could lead to sex that the woman perceives as unwanted or coercive. We are not the first to reveal the potential for miscommunication resulting in unwanted or coercive sex (or potentially sexual assault). For example, some researchers (DeSouza & Hutz, 1996; Fisher & Walters, 2003; Henningsen, Henningsen, & Valde, 2006; Johnson, Stockdale, & Saal, 1991) have found that men overestimate women's interest in sex, while others have discussed miscommunication between men and women in regard to sex resulting in unwanted sex, coercive sex, or potentially sexual assault (Crawford, 1995; Kitzinger & Frith, 1999).” (Jozkowski et al., 2014)
  • “Previous research indicates that women may not want to engage in sexual activity but may not communicate their nonagreement to engage in the activity because they do not want to upset their partner, make him think that they are not interested, or seem like a tease, especially if they are romantically interested (Walker, 1997). As such, women may tolerate a certain level of sexual activity, even surpassing a level of intimacy with which they are comfortable, hoping that men will stop at that behavior rather than progressing to more intimate behaviors such as sexual intercourse. However, given the current findings, men may interpret that silence as permission or consent to continue to engage in increasingly more intimate behaviors and perhaps even sexual intercourse. Furthermore, some men may also interpret a woman's refusals, either verbal or nonverbal, as token resistance, even if the refusals are genuine, and continue to progress in sexual behavior, resulting in intercourse. Both situations could result in a man unintentionally having sex with an unwilling woman without him realizing that she was not consenting to the sexual activity. Although such events might not result in legal charges of sexual assault, miscalculating a woman's interest in sex and having sex with her against her will could have a negative impact on the woman (Shotland & Hunter, 1995) and could be defined as sexual assault (Koss, Gidycz, & Wisniewski, 1987; Koss & Oros, 1982).” (Jozkowski et al., 2014)
  • “Current findings seem to mirror this perception, as students indicated using more verbal consent cues, a more explicit form of consent, for intercourse behaviors than for fooling around/touching and more nonverbal consent cues for fooling around/intimate touching than for intercourse.” (Jozkowski et al., 2014)
  • “Teen dating abuse victimization and perpetration are prevalent for both boys and girls and result in serious consequences [1–3]. Consequences identified from longitudinal studies include binge-eating, cigarette smoking, marijuana and other illicit substance use, antisocial behavior, depression, and suicide ideation and attempts [4 – 6].” (Foshee et al., 2012)
  • “FSD was effective in promoting changes in the family context conducive to continued discussion about teen dating abuse, thus providing a foundation for preventing teen dating abuse over time. It was also effective in decreasing teen acceptance of dating abuse, a key construct explaining the effects of other effective dating abuse prevention programs [31,36], and in preventing dating abuse victimization.” (Foshee et al., 2012)
  • “Humphreys (2007) also found gender differences in his study of college students' perceptions of consent during fictitious scenarios. When assessing the scenarios, men more frequently perceived the sex as more consensual, acceptable, and clear, regardless of the relationship status of the characters, compared to the women in the sample.” (Jozkowski & Peterson, 2013)
  • “In fact, some participants overtly stated responses consistent with the traditional sexual script. For example, in response to the question about indicating consent to engage in sexual activity, a female participant stated, 'I wouldn't indicate my willingness without being asked. I am a female and I believe the male should always chase the female. After he asks me, then I would say yes.' Similarly, another female participant wrote, 'I would let my partner advance. He is the guy, he should make the first move.' Men also endorsed their role as sexual initiator, as exemplified in this quote from a male participant: 'I would initiate foreplay; it's expected since I'm the guy. If she seemed into it, then I would ask her if she wanted to.' (Jozkowski & Peterson, 2013, p. 519)ReferencesFoshee, V. A., McNaughton Reyes, H. L., Ennett, S. T., Cance, J. D., Bauman, K. E., & Bowling, J. M. (2012). Assessing the effects of Families for Safe Dates, a family-based teen dating abuse prevention program. Journal of Adolescent Health, 51(4), 349–356. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jadohealth.2011.12.029Jozkowski, K. N., & Peterson, Z. D. (2013). College students and sexual consent: Unique insights. The Journal of Sex Research, 50(6), 517–523. https://doi.org/10.1080/00224499.2012.700739Jozkowski, K. N., Peterson, Z. D., Sanders, S. A., Dennis, B., & Reece, M. (2014). Gender differences in heterosexual college students’ conceptualizations and indicators of sexual consent: Implications for contemporary sexual assault prevention education. The Journal of Sex Research, 51(8), 904–916. https://doi.org/10.1080/00224499.2013.792326Lewin, M. (1985). Unwanted intercourse: The difficulty of saying no. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 9(2), 184–192. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1471-6402.1985.tb00871.xMuehlenhard, C. L., Humphreys, T. P., Jozkowski, K. N., & Peterson, Z. D. (2016). The complexities of sexual consent among college students: A conceptual and empirical review. The Journal of Sex Research, 53(4–5), 457–487. https://doi.org/10.1080/00224499.2016.1146651