Senate
of the
Student Government Association
of
The Johns Hopkins University
{ S. Resolution 22-23, 01 }
A Resolution Expressing Student Government Support for the Right to Choose and the Liberty of Bodily Autonomy
Introduced By: Senator Jackson Morris of the Class of 2025
First considered this 5th day of September in the Year 2022
Next considered this 13th day of September in the Year 2022
Sponsored By: Senator Mufasa Cruz Moreno of the class of 2024
Senator Sophie Liu of the Class of 2023
Committee Consideration Waived by Vice President Kobi Khong
Whereas on June 24th 2022, the United States Supreme Court, in a 5-4 decision on Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, overturned the right to an elective abortion procedure established by Roe v. Wade via the Fourteenth Amendment and upheld in Casey v. Planned Parenthood; and
Whereas according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 629,898 legal abortions were administered in the U.S. in 2019; according to the Guttmacher Institute approximately 29,800 legal abortions were administered in the state of Maryland in 2017; and
Whereas the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists states that abortion is “an essential component of comprehensive, evidence-based health care” and that “individuals seeking abortion must be afforded privacy, dignity, respect, and support, and should be able to make their medical decisions without undue interference by outside parties”; and
Whereas as of September 9th 2022, 12 states have enacted or revived pre-Roe laws banning all abortions in the state, most with no exceptions for cases of rape or incest, and 14 states have pending bans or extreme restrictions on elective abortion; of special note are Maryland-adjacent West Virginia (total ban and criminalization of providers), Virginia (potential restrictions), and Pennsylvania (potential restrictions), where pregnant individuals seeking a legal abortion would be forced to travel to another state; and
Whereas Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health Dean Ellen MacKenzie and School of Nursing Dean Sarah L. Szanton published a joint op-ed on April 4th discussing the vital importance of abortion to public health, including that the denial of abortion has been correlated to increased domestic violence, higher occurrence of financial hardships such as bankruptcy and eviction, and “irreparable harms” that include poor maternal bonding and neglect of unplanned children that are born after a denial of abortion; and
Whereas Johns Hopkins University and Medicine staff released a joint response within hours of the Supreme Court decision announcement, underscoring the importance of safe, legal abortion to evidence-based healthcare and affirming a commitment to providing “the same full range of services and support that we do today in accordance with legal requirements”; and
Whereas Maryland HB937 (the Abortion Care Access Act) was passed into law on April 9th, 2022, modifying existing law that stated only a physician could perform an abortion to allow non-physician qualified providers to perform abortions; and creating a training program to increase the number of individuals trained and licensed to provide abortions; and
Whereas Johns Hopkins University has a reputation for its strong undergraduate pre-health programs and many of the University’s students go on to become leaders in the medical community and thus have a responsibility to speak out when the rights of patients and providers are threatened;
Whereas the preamble of the Declaration of Independence states that among the unalienable rights of the governed are “Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness”; and State abortion bans infringe upon each principle, violating the spirit of the Due Process clause of the fourteenth amendment to the U.S. Constitution which states that no “state [shall] deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law.”
Whereas the right to life is violated by the prohibition of abortion: Between 1998 and 2005, the comparative ratio of maternal deaths per 100,000 live births to 100,000 abortions in the U.S. was about 14:1. By forcing a woman to carry her baby to full term, state laws that completely ban abortion impose an undue burden on her right to life by raising her likelihood of death fourteen-fold as well as risk of permanent disability without any choice in the matter. Medical exceptions to abortion bans when the mother’s life is at risk are superficial; because of the punitive nature of abortion prohibitions (Idaho has made abortion outside of its narrow range of exceptions a felony punishable by “no less than 2 years… in prison”), providers are likely to hesitate or refuse to administer treatment, even when their professional judgement leads them to believe an abortion is medically necessary, because they do not want to be imprisoned if the state does not agree with their conclusion.
Whereas the right to liberty is violated by the prohibition of abortion: Any plausible route of enforcement will violate the spirit of the privacy rule of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), endangering the medical privacy of a patient and the confidentiality that the doctor-patient relationship rests upon.
Freedom over one’s own bodily autonomy represents a basic degree of liberty that is unalienable not because it is enshrined in a constitution or declaration, but simply because it is inherent to human life. Just as one has a right not to seek an abortion and give birth to new life, and cannot be compelled otherwise by the whims of private interests or the agenda of the U.S. government, the existence and availability of safe methods of contraception and abortion throughout the U.S. grant a right not to undergo pregnancy. Consider that about 60% of women who receive an abortion have already undergone one or more live births. This statistic emphasizes the necessity of abortion to family planning– many women and couples cannot financially, emotionally, or physically support another pregnancy and/or child and abortion is the last resort to prevent such a scenario.
In addition, the necessity of abortion stands to appreciate, rather than diminish, in the aftermath of Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization: In his concurring opinion, Justice Clarence Thomas stated that “[The Supreme Court] should reconsider all of this Court’s substantive due process precedents, including Griswold”, where Griswold v. Connecticut was the Supreme Court case in 1965 that established a right to contraception via the Due Process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Justice Thomas explicitly advocates for a rollback of the right, calling Griswold, Lawrence, and Obergefell (all decided by the aforementioned clause) “‘demonstrably erroneous’” and that “[the Court has] a duty to ‘correct the error’ established in those precedents”. Should Griswold be overruled, or the rights it secured threatened, abortion would become even more necessary to ensure that pregnancy and birth are a freely explored (not forced) right of women.
Whereas the right to the pursuit of happiness is violated by the prohibition of abortion: state laws prohibiting abortion fail to take note of the social mores in certain communities in the U.S. surrounding sex and virtually all types of pregnancy outside of marriage. There are women who have historically, presently, and will continue to be cut off or wholly disowned by members of their family if they are found to be pregnant. State laws prohibiting abortion fail to account for the lack of paid maternity (and paternity) leave in the United States; without this necessary stipend to help new mothers physically recover and bond with their child, women in precarious financial situations will need to either forfeit their health or savings to provide for a child that they never meant to have. While both of these injustices are regrettable in their current state, they will be exacerbated by abortion bans.
The decision will also negatively impact the ability of women to freely pursue their passions in the United States. A woman who receives a promotion which requires her to move to Missouri or a woman who receives a scholarship to attend college in Texas may relinquish these opportunities or do so at the cost of her reproductive healthcare freedom. The prohibition of abortion acts as an uneven impediment to the career and lifestyle choices of women, especially poorer women and minorites, who are less likely to have the resources available to travel to a state that allows abortion.
Therefore, Be It Resolved that the Johns Hopkins Student Government Association affirms its support for safe and legal abortion, and opposes state bans and undue restrictions on abortion. We especially condemn the criminalization of providers and abortion seekers, as it imposes an undue burden on both parties that forces them to choose between administrating or receiving proper care and criminal penalties, and will regardless hinder the physician’s best judgement.
Be It Further Resolved that the Johns Hopkins Student Government Association calls on the General Assembly of Maryland and Governor’s Office to pass legislation that will prevent Maryland law enforcement from cooperating with the law enforcement of other states when an investigation or proceedings are against a qualified provider or patient for legally protected health care activity that would be entirely lawful if the action occurred in the state of Maryland and prevent extradition to other states for such acts, as well as preventing other states from prosecuting residents who receive an abortion in Maryland (see Mass. H.4390 §§14, 18, 32, 34, 36 for existing legislation to this effect).
Be It Further Resolved that the Johns Hopkins Student Government Association calls on the U.S. Congress to pass a federal law protecting legal abortion in the first two trimesters and in all cases when deemed necessary for the patient’s health by a licensed physician,
Be It Further Resolved that the Johns Hopkins Student Government Association calls on the U.S. Congress to proactively pass a federal law recognizing the right to conception, the right to private and consensual intimacy between adults, and the right to same-sex marriage should Griswold v. Connecticut, Lawrence v. Texas, or Obergefell v. Hodges be overturned or circumvented.
Be It Further Resolved that a copy of this resolution be transmitted to:
Governor Lawrence Hogan;
State Senator Mary Washington;
State Representatives Curt Anderson, Regina T. Boyce, Maggie McIntosh;
Senators Chris Van Hollen and Ben Cardin;
Representative Kweisi Mfume;
The Resolution hereby PASSES by a vote of 26 to 0 with 0 abstentions.
Upon adoption, we have hereunto set our hands and caused the seal of the Senate to be affixed to this resolution indicating the senate’s assent and thus officially designating the resolution’s adoption as the position and will of the Senate and the Student Body of The Johns Hopkins University.
Signatures of Enactment:
Breanna Soldatelli
Executive President of the Johns Hopkins SGA
Kobi Khong
President of the Senate
Executive Vice President of the Johns Hopkins SGA
Elaina Regier
Executive Secretary of the Johns Hopkins SGA
Kya Nicholson
Executive Treasurer of the Johns Hopkins SGA
Signatures of Ceremony:
Jackson Morris
Introducer of the Bill
Mufasa Cruz Moreno
Co-Sponsor of the Bill
Sophie Liu
Co-Sponsor of the Bill
