JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

Cavlin s SLI criteria for SO Review

Filed in Drive as “Cavlin_s SLI criteria for SO Review”

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

Hey William,

Here is a lot of the information that may be helpful in explaining why we are engaging in the process and what student orgs should expect from the broader review process.

  1. How SLI, SAC, and CSO interface - SAC and CSO are committees within the Student Government Association. As the director of SLI, I serve as the primary advisor to SGA. Several of the committees have content advisors that are staff in SLI. I want to again emphasize, SLI was in the process of reviewing student organizations, irrespective of CSO’s decision to place a moratorium on recognition of student organizations earlier this semester. SGA only has direct responsibility, as a recognition entity, for approximately 160 organizations while SLI manages over 400 organizations. How is money distributed - The Student Activities Committee (SAC) is responsible for annual and monthly allocations for the 160+ organizations that are governed by SGA. SLI’s role is the management of those funds with respect to student organizations that are recognized by SGA and DOSL once they have been allocated. Groups that are affiliated with other supporting entities (Academic departments, CSC, Sports Clubs, etc.) receive their funding from those supporting entities.
  2. What was the immediate impetus for the audits? As you may be aware, I took over the position of director of Student Leadership and Involvement in February of this year. I took some time to review the feedback students have shared about their experience with the office. Based on the feedback SLI and DOSL has received over the last couple of years, and the charge of SLI to manage the 400+ student organizations on campus, we have engaged in this review process to understand where we have gaps and where we can improve support. We need to understand our organizational structure and how it is or is not supporting our ultimate mission to work collaboratively with students to develop programs, organizations, and spaces that promote individual growth and cultivate inclusive communities.

The purpose of the review is to: 1) determine if organizations are in compliance with University, DOSL, and SGA policies, as well as Parent’s Fund goals and objectives; 2) determine if our current structure is adequate to support our student organizations; 3) clarify the relationship between recognition and support entities; 4) align JHU’s support for student organizations with best practices; and 5) determine what support organizations’ need as they create a thriving and inclusive community.

  1. When will new groups be able to form? I will refer you to the Committee on Student Organizations (CSO), as that committee made the decision to freeze recognition on new student organizations. CSO’s decision has no bearing on other support entities’ ability to recognize and support student organizations. SLI has received new student organization applications from other support entities and those organizations are in the process of receiving support and recognition at the University. Based on the CSO’s last message they will reevaluate their decision in the spring semester. For clarity, SLI is not a recognition entity, our role is to support all students and all student organizations. SLI does not, and has not recognized or denied a student organization’s ability to operate at the University.
  2. What is the purpose of reviewing these criteria (e.g., Recognition Entity, Categorization, Funding, Mission/Purpose, etc.)? SLI is responsible for the management of all 400+ student organizations, specifically through determining viability, compliance with University policy, student organization event registration, and organization budget transactions. It has become clear while reviewing Hopkins Groups information that we are missing vital information for many groups that is critical in assisting SLI, SGA, and other supporting entities in the management of student organizations. Additionally, it has become clear that supporting entities are not aware of all of the University policy impacting student organizations. This leads to conflicting information and confusion of student organization members depending on where they get the information from.

Supporting Entity (Department, Division, Academic Unit, etc.) – The purpose is to confirm that the area is actually supporting the organization. We have learned that sometimes organizations believe they have support (or “recognition”) from an area, department, office, etc., only to find out that the department has a different understanding of what their relationship and responsibilities are with respect to the management of the student organization. The goal is to confirm support for all student organizations. Additionally, we want to educate supporting entities on what policies impact student organizations so they can best support those organization. The goal is to provide transparency so student organization are not receiving different information based on where they receive their support.

Categorization (Cultural, Performing Arts, Advocacy, etc.) – The purpose is to determine if groups are listed in the appropriate category based on how they function and what activities they engage in. Additionally, we want to figure out if the categories we have make sense structurally.

Funding (Charter Group, SAC, SAAC, Academic Unit, etc.) – SLI has a major responsibility to student organizations to process transactions, however, we may not have the correct budget numbers, we may not know the appropriate budget manager, funding process, etc., and we want to make sure we can best support organizations regardless of where the budget/funding lives.

Mission/Purpose (Does the group’s activities still align?) – During a preliminary review, we have discovered that at least 30 student organizations do not have a constitution, bylaws, or guiding document, which is required in order to maintain recognition. Students are reviewing all documents to understand organization’s mission/purpose and will hold individual interviews to confirm that organization’s activities are still in line with their stated mission/purpose.

Recruitment Practices (Open to all students, application process, audition, etc.) We want to determine how organizations are engaging new members and if their process is in alignment with University policy. This is especially important when we consider the organization’s funding source. The Expectations of Student Organizations and SGA Constitution and Bylaws outline what process student organizations can engage in with regard to recruitment of new members.

Advisor – We need to determine which student organizations have advisors, and of those that have stated they have an advisor, are actually serving in those roles. Again our goal is provide education and transparency so advisors can provide the best support possible for their respective student organizations.

Duplicate Organizations – The creation of duplicate organizations is antithetical to the goal of creating inclusive communities and places a strain on already limited resources. Our goal is to understand what types of organizations exist so as recognition and support entities are thinking about supporting new student organization we have a comprehensive list of what organizations are on campus and what purpose they serve. This will help future supporting or recognition entities from creating duplicate organizations.

Roster – Student organizations are required to have at least 10 members to maintain their recognition status. SLI will wipe all rosters in January and work with groups to confirm membership ahead of re-registration in the spring semester.

  1. Last spring, Dean Ruzicka mentioned that her office is working on a program to help student groups track their funds and budget records and that she hopes to provide student groups with monthly budget updates. She also stated that she intends to improve internal reporting systems, accounting systems, and budget staff trainings. Is SLI continuing this work during the audits? Yes, SAC and DOSL funded groups have already begun receiving monthly updates within their Hopkins Groups accounts from SLI. The next update will happen during the week of 10/7/2019. Please note, the updates only apply to groups that are managed financially through SLI. CSC, Sports Clubs, Academic Groups receive their updates through their supporting entities. Additionally, SLI is working with Scheduling Events Services to create a single platform for students to submit event registration. Again responding to student feedback from the last couple of years.
  2. Is SLI expanding its staff and/or implementing more efficient budget structures, as Dean Ruzicka also mentioned? Yes, it is our goal to transition to the financial module in Hopkins Groups this semester. The financial module will streamline purchase and budget requests for student organizations. SLI has been testing the module since August. So far the results are positive. Now that the allocations have been released, and student organizations are making transactions, we are working to make sure the module is user friendly. We want to make sure we can train students and faculty/staff appropriately on how to effectively use the financial module’s features once it is released. With regard to increased staff, Homewood Student Affairs (HSA) has hired a new financial analyst to coordinate financial processes for all 350 student organizations within HSA. We continue to work on more efficient structures to process transactions. As a result of those efforts, student budgets were released a month earlier than in previous years and the SGA/SAC received a 6% increase in funding to support student organizations for the first time in over 10 years.
  3. How will SLI and SGA interface during these audits? Student Leadership Consultants (SLI student staff) and members of the CSO (SGA) are working together to review organizations. Once they have completed all the document reviews, they will interview student organization leaders and discuss the criteria outlined above. After those interviews, the SLCs and members of the Committee on Student Orgs will be compiling the information and providing recommendations to SLI, the Dean of Student Life and SGA on the best way to recognize and support undergraduate student organizations moving forward.

Timeline:

September - Initial review of Guiding Documents

October – Deep dive into guiding documents to determine if the group has a mission/purpose, organization structure, recruitment practices, etc.

November – Finalize information and prepare to share findings with individual groups and invite them for a meeting to discuss with CSO/SLC’s

Confirm and gain a better understanding of the following:

Supporting Entity (Department, Division, Academic Unit, etc.)

Categorization (Cultural, Performing Arts, Advocacy, etc.)

Funding (Charter Group, SAC, SAAC, Academic Unit, etc.)

Mission/Purpose (Does the group’s activities still align?)

Membership Requirement/Recruitment Practices (Open to all students, application process, audition, etc.)

Officer Elections

Financial Responsibilities

Advisor Information

Duplicate Organizations

December-February – Meetings with groups and compiling information. Contacting departments and advisors to confirm support for all organization.

January – Wiping all organization rosters and working with them to input their active membership

February – Recommendations from SLC’s and CSO’s

Sharing all pertinent information with organizations ahead of the re-registration process for spring semester.

March – Organization re-registration

I know this is a lot of information. Please let me know if you have any questions or concerns or suggestion to how we might execute this process. I look forward to working with you.

Sources

Cavlin_s SLI criteria for SO Review.docx