JHU Private Police Proposal Forum
Tuesday, March 13th, 2018 | 8:00 PM | Charles Commons Salons B & C
Transcript
Note: The recording of this forum can be found here at the SGA website. For clarity, light grammatical edits have been made to this text. With the exception of Noh Mebrahtu and AJ Tsang, who moderated the forum, student identities are kept anonymous within this transcript. If you have questions, comments, concerns, or editorial revisions about this transcript, please feel free to reach out to AJ, who typed up the transcript, at atsang4@jhu.edu!
[Recording begins approximately 2 minutes into the forum, at the end of Special Advisor Hitchcock’s introduction.]
Special Advisor Hitchcock: … I just joined the Administration about 2-3 years ago, after serving 30 years in government.
Provost Kumar:
First of all, I’m delighted we have an opportunity to speak and I wanted to talk about process up to now and current steps. So while the email may have appeared somewhat out of the blue, it was not a step that the administration took lightly. In particular, there has been an increase in serious crime in both East Baltimore and the Homewood Campus in the last 6 months. One statistic which is Homewood-specific, is that there have been 18 armed robberies since September and 12 of those were staff or students or faculty. Second, was a kind of tour that President Daniels and a team of senior leadership undertook of peer schools to take a look at their full security portfolio, and it became clear that among peers and public universities in the city, we were successful in not having a police force of our own, but this was clearly a kind of anomalous position among our peers. Finally, we sought counsel on best practice, how to do this and I’m sure that we will hear many of your concerns today that we feel are quite valid and something we should pay close attention to. So we did see counsel on best practices.
The legislative calendar in Maryland is short and takes place on an annual cycle, so it was decided we should not wait another full year to get this enabling step in motion. Legislation is the beginning of process in that there’s a lot that needs to be decided going forward, and we intend to make decisions in consultation with faculty, staff, students, community and neighbors, like how to staff the police force. A potential misconception is that this is an extension of BPD, but this is our police force and our employees. How we staff and select and train officers on issues like cultural sensitivity, community policing, these are all important, as we need to have a police force that aligns with our standards and values. We would not put one together that does not align with our values. We would want accountability and strong civil oversight. Structuring the force going forward is something we will pay fair attention to. The point to emphasize is the nature of police force we want to stand up. It needs to address unique needs of the University. We are looking to peers to learn from them and get their thoughts on things that have worked for them, not worked for them, best practices, etc. In particular, we want to make sure that our values are reflected in the police force, and that the force is trained to a higher level; for example, to the accreditation body of national university police forces and not local standards. We are looking to exceed Maryland standards in training, etc. and to add on training of our own. We expect them to be subject to fairly transparent oversight and disciplinary procedures.
Finally, I’d like to emphasize that this move is not at expense of other, much needed investments. A question that might have occurred is where resources will come from. One way in which we respond to incidents and provide additional safety and security, is to use a floating group of off duty officers as our spare capacity, and this is the force we want to draw down in favor of a police force recruited and trained by us, and answerable to policies of the University and the University community. We intend to start small with handpicked officers, and intend that this investment will be made complementary to others, like mental health and in commitments to the community itself, like Baltimore Local, which is a commitment to source local workers. We reiterate that we didn’t take this step lightly, as we didn’t have to do this until now, but with the increase in crime and our position vis a vis our peers, we believe there is enough best practice to give confidence that we can stand up a force that will serve the community and all members of community well.
Noh Mebrahtu, SGA President: I’d like to ask for everyone to project, because the mic is having issues.
AJ Tsang, SGA Vice President: Hold the mic perpendicular to your mouth, almost at an exact 90 degree angle!
Vice Provost Shollenberger: We were initially all going to do statements after Provost Kumar’s opening, but we want this to be a dialogue and open it up for questions.
AJ Tsang: Hi everyone, we have two tables, 1 for questions (Q’s) and 1 for comments (C’s). Line up at the table that most suits your speech! And then we’ll alternate between questions and comments!
Student: My big concern is how the private police force will affect sexual assault policy and things like no-questions transport to Mercy, and interactions between Security and the Office of Institutional Equity (OIE).
Provost Kumar: We expect OIE to operate independently as it does today. Expect that as today, the complainant has the right to choose whether or not they want to complain to a law enforcement officer. JHU’s police officers will be sworn, which means they become part of a law enforcement body and our internal policies that give discretion as to whether or not you can process a complaint with law enforcement. That discretion will remain.
Vice Provost Shollenberger: This won’t change from our current arrangement with Public Safety. If a student wants transportation to a hospital or other facility, we would do that without questions. It is up to the complainant if they want to file a formal complaint either with OIE or with the police.
Provost Kumar: That said, Title IX requires a responsible employee statute and that will continue to be enforced.
Student: Thanks for hosting. I’m a senior. Provost Kumar, you cited statistics on crime and used a data point of 18 instances of armed robberies. In visits to peer institutions, do you have statistics on the impact of university police on crime rates in their areas?
Provost Kumar: I’ll give 1 example from UPenn, an interesting cautionary tale. UPenn has had a police department for 40 years, and in the mid-90s had a series of very violent crimes. They brought in the thoughtful head of a police force, out of the Philadelphia Police Department, and on her watch, there was been a significant decrease in crime. Part of that is hedging, in that overall crime in cities went down as well. So we can’t attribute causation to the police force. One thing we liked about Penn was what happened with this revamping, was there was an increase in professionalization and community relations, and an emphasis on making connections to the community to the point where it not only resulted overall in crime reduction, which attributed to the city’s own improvement, but also to better relations with the community. The lesson is this is situation is that where if done right, and I’m not minimizing the part ‘if done right’, this can be valuable.
Student: When you started, you wanted a dialogue. That’s my question - how long has a dialogue been going on? We found out on March 5th, and we spoke to several community groups, including 8 on the petition, and none had prior knowledge of this. Is this dialogue retrospective, or is this something that has happened before?
Provost Kumar: That is a fair point. We didn’t reach out to SGA before the legislation was supported by Hopkins. That said, legislation is an enabling step. It does not mean that we have fully-thought through, baked solutions. There is a lot more that remains to be done, and it will take several months to a year before we see police officers on campus. That’s the part where we would like to consult, and this is indeed, done the right way.
Student: But the point is that you needed an enabling step, before consulting everyone, and the decision was made, so this is about what kind of police force, not about what we want. So you didn’t actually ask for community input. You took the enabling step and now there’s dialogue, but we don’t want to have that dialogue [to have a police force].
Student: I’m going to pick up where she left off. I’ve been in touch with community groups around campus, and there seem to be different narratives about communication. Senator Conway, the sponsor in the Senate, says she was in contact with community organizations outside Hopkins and that she had been in dialogue with them. However, people in Charles Village and Remington and Better Waverly and care communities in Middle East and East Baltimore, they said that the first they heard of the legislation was when we heard about it on Monday [March 5th]. Can you clarify what the process looked like and if you know about it on House and Senate side?
Special Advisor Hitchcock: Let me be very clear that this is enabling legislation that will take a bit of time because there has to be an MOU between either the Mayor and police commissioner and this institution, and it is envisioned that in this period of time there will be significant dialogue between the institution and the community and that we, in that engagement, we would absolutely consider wishes of the community and the input of community.
Let me set the scene: in my office, we are the government and community relations folks. We have a person that represents us in East Baltimore, one around Homewood, and one at Bayview. There was no communication with them prior to the one you received. We literally aligned our communication with them with the notice that came from the President to faculty, students, and the internal community so that at the point he communicated with you, we hit the send button with our network of community organizations. How does that look? We have our list of community organizations, and there are people in the community, presidents of associations who received notices, and we followed up with personal, 1-on-1 calls with them. We have a layout of community association meetings that we are going to go to. We can only tell you that we are receiving that dialogue, that feedback, and it’ll be ongoing, this is what we do all day everyday, we have engagement on a number of levels. This is no different from the kind of engagement we like to have with colleagues. I don’t know who you’ve talked to, but we could compare notes.
Student: Is the list public?
Special Advisor Hitchcock: Yes, there is list of associations around campus. Those are people we have contact with.
Student: Do you have examples?
Special Advisor Hitchcock: Abell, North Charles, we have a list of 64. My Homewood people deal with Homewood, Michael Thomas with East Baltimore. We had a couple of neighborhood association folks show up at the meeting earlier today. As you can imagine, they have a wide range of issues that they’re concerned about, and want to articulate about, so we’re listening.
Student: My first question is about the boundaries related to community engagement, and that is: where does Hopkins end and the community begin? You know more than me that we have so many locations across city, that it’s unclear how the private force will be distributed, and whether it’s accountable to the University administration or University community, which means it won’t be accountable to the greater community which it will also have access to.
Provost Kumar: In terms of accountability, I did not construe my statement as being exclusionary of people from the patrol zone. One thing that you have probably seen, as you have seen from campus security cars, is that they do go beyond our property. One would expect that our police officers would patrol beyond and be part of our system and have input. That’s part of the MOU with the Mayor’s office because the Mayor will decide in conjunction, where will BPD lines end and ours begin. That will have to be an iterative process where we need internal input but also guidance from the city.
Director Presberry: Just so we know what current patrol boundaries are: Hopkins’ Homewood campus is unique because when you see we send alerts out, we refer to them in different ways, one of them being if the incident is immediately on campus or in the patrol area. The patrol area’s boundaries are: to the south, 27th street; to the north, University Parkway; to the west, San Martin Drive; and to the east, it’s Abell. So as the Provost said, that is something we would have to actually discuss and negotiate about, but that’s our current patrol area for now.
Student: To follow up, where are those 18 armed robberies you talked about, distributed within homewood proper or in the extended boundary?
Director Presberry: The 18 have taken place on the outskirts of the patrol boundaries. So some are on Guilford, some on 27th, some on Maryland Avenue, some in the area of 33rd. All are mostly outside the patrol zone, or right on the outskirts.
Student: And the private police force wouldn’t have control over where those happen?
Provost Kumar: We would need decide boundaries.
Student: But if boundaries are where they are, then the 18 points of crime would mean the police wouldn’t have jurisdiction?
Director Presberry: If the police force existed today, with the boundaries today, they would be in patrol area today. Going forward, we would need discuss with the city about this.
Student: This needs to be a more democratic process that involves the community. This discussion isn’t enough in terms of them being listened to. There needs to be voting, some other form that needs to happen when the police are here. My second question, for Provost Kumar: at the beginning of year, when you talked about academic freedom and you encouraged us to be civically engaged and participate in politics, you said that anyone on campus would be respected if they spoke with research and facts. With that in mind, what are the research and facts? What body of social science literature shows that a private police force targets areas that are problematic?
Provost Kumar: Fair point. We are going to put up FAQs on the web that essentially include peer statistics, historical trends, etc. We’ve done our consultation, we just need permission from who we get data from. Expect that we will have concrete answers to your questions. We just want to bring up the point that this is not complete dispositive. Your question is valid. The point is, this increases for the University, the responsibility of the University. To have the law enforcement body that you have said come up, we will have bigger responsibilities. It is indeed true that we were internally skeptical before we got to this decision, and we are consulting deeply, looking at presentations from peers, and we need to make public something from all of this, which we will.
Student: Do you have dates? Why does this come after reaching out to legislators to change state law?
Provost Kumar: This was part of a private dialogue with other schools. We don’t have an answer. We are not trying to put you off. This is something we should be held accountable for. This is a valid question, and we will have something.
Student: We would like another forum after the data is released as we can analyze it as we do in all our classes to see if it is statistically, methodologically valid.
Provost Kumar: I agree.
Student: I may be the only student who agrees with this. For background: last semester, I was robbed at gunpoint outside of the patrol area in Baltimore. A guy came up to me, said he had a weapon, and wanted my wallet. To tell you the full truth – my first concern was not calling 911, it was calling campus security, since it was on the back of my card. I called 911 because I wasn’t an idiot, but I knew that as a Hopkins student, Hopkins Security would take care of me more than BPD. There’s tons to be said about policies and procedures, but I think that as a Hopkins student, I would rather be patrolled by Hopkins people trained by Hopkins than by BPD, which isn’t the best trained in the country. The opportunity to build a new police force is a better opportunity than continuing to work with BPD.
Student: But that would require an MOU with BPD, so it would actually strengthen our relationship with BPD.
Provost Kumar: The MOU is essential between any two law enforcement agencies. It is necessary.
Student: [In response to student above] I’m sorry that happened to you, that sounds like a horrible experience, and how you feel is valid, but we need to think about priorities. As someone from Baltimore and raised here my entire life, everyone I care for is in Baltimore. Is their safety JHU’s highest priority? It is not common to be held at gunpoint, and the safety of Baltimore is high. I’m not concerned about central, north Baltimore where Hopkins is, because that’s not where homicides are. When I think of crime, I think of guns, and that’s not where Hopkins is. We need to think about the priorities of safety. The police have a history of discriminating against people of color, against LGBTQ folks, against all minority identities, so I just feel like that needs to be centered in this conversation.
Student: In response to another question, that the concept of a private police force would strengthen community relationships: I think it’s safe to say that this school and BPD already don’t have the best relationship with the larger Baltimore community. So on a theoretical level, how would a private police force better relationships to the wider Baltimore community, and could you expand on how this private police force would engage with the BPD, which is the worst?
Provost Kumar: Let me answer the second question first, and then I’ll speak on first question. On the second one, if you look at how peers have done it, they tend to recruit independent of the city police department. They tend to train – even if training partly with the police department, they tend to have much more stringent selectivity criteria. For example, at one of peer institutions, every prospective officer is put through scenario planning about discrimination. They are showed complex situations to see what the candidate will do. So the MOU is a transactional document that tells you what we will do, what BPD will do, and where boundaries are.
Student: So the school would craft a police department to fit its own values? That sounds good and benevolent from you, but the reality is that this is a private institution and that closes the door to any accountability from us, first off, but also from people outside of the Homewood community, whom this private police force would absolutely affect. Does that not worry anybody?
Provost Kumar: if it were true that the police force would not be accountable, then it wouldn’t be effective. So accountability goes hand in hand. Without trust, you can’t have it.
Student: But what are the mechanisms of accountability?
Provost Kumar: The mechanisms that peers have, is a community hosting. They have body hosting that looks at its ??? and handles audits of how well the force is operating on a very periodic basis.
Student: Would Hopkins be included in this?
Provost Kumar: if you look at peers, this is reflective of a wide variety of staff, students, and neighbors.
Student: One more final thing: I think that the concept is similar to a civilian review board, and it’s great, but you guys dropped this when we were studying for midterms, and during 2 of the busiest academic weeks. Frankly, I’m super impressed that we have this many people out here tonight, because this is new and there’s a lot of energy. If this becomes an institution, how will you get kids out of C-level to review complaints about the private police department? The school already has issues getting kids riled up about political issues, and with having a civilian review board, I don’t see how you can keep that continuous over the years, over the long run.
Student: I think to respond in part to a few comments that have been made, a lot is not that crime isn’t happening. I also want to point out that many of the people in this room are women, so many people in here are victims of sexual assault, which is a partially overlooked component of crime statistics because it’s underreported by victims at universities. There’s lots of social science research on this, this researchable question: do police reduce crime? Most often, there’s no relationship between the introduction of police and crime rates.
Student: My question is: would the administration be open to re-opening the issue if we conducted a referendum to evaluate student opinion? I’m appalled that student opinion has yet to be researched before publishing the initiative. Is the initiative itself actually open to change based on our input? Are students enough of a priority for our discontent to reverse this initiative? I ask as an SGA senator, because a referendum would go through our SGA processes.
Provost Kumar: I can’t see this as a yes/no referendum because this is in Annapolis. If this is a structured survey by which we can seek input, then SGA would be the vehicle by which we would seek input. A broad-based survey to seek input is probably the right way to go. Whether it’s a yes/no referendum to reverse what’s going on, I don’t think that’s feasible, because it’s in the hand of legislators now. There’s a process by which –
Student: We’re already doing that [talking to legislators]. You’re the ones that put it in Annapolis in the first place.
Student: Can we take it [the bill] out [of Annapolis]?
Provost Kumar: Seeking structure through SGA is valid.
Student: [Motioning to students in crowd] Would you come out and vote?
Students in crowd: Yes!
Student: Hi, I’m an RA and a junior here. One of my experiences as an RA is dealing with Security, where they take control of a situation and don’t give students a chance to protest. I’ve never seen any discipline come out of that. I also don’t feel like satisfactory answers have been given. If Hopkins police come into my dorm, turning around my stuff, and say ‘go wait in the hallway’, what do I tell my students?
Vice Provost Shollenberger: You’re saying currently, that Security has stopped students from protesting?
Student: No, there are situations where Security has entered a dorm where they weren’t supposed to, and students said they couldn’t do that, but Security told students to just leave. There are abuses of power. That was never addressed. I want to see how that would be addressed with the police force.
Director Presberry: Anybody can file a complaint, and there are various ways to do so. You can come right to me during the course of the week. You can email me, and there is a security website and you can make a complaint there. There are many ways to make a complaint. Once we are aware, we investigate. Complaints are not investigated by an officer, but rather they are investigated by myself, a director, or a commander. Once we do that investigation, then there is discipline, and let me tell you along the way, there’s in-house discussion. We do consult with HR [Human Resources] as well as General Counsel. So where we do receive complaints, we act on it. In reference to the police department, it would work the same way. Any complaint made by anyone will be investigated.
Student: That’s a good answer. I’ve spoken with a lot of students, and many feel uncomfortable expressing their support for this. There are some students who think this is a good idea, but think it needs to go through the right process. I hope you listen to everything people have to say. Once it [the police force] becomes institution, it won’t go away, so please do it right the first time.
Student: Y’all have said this legislation is an enabling step to allow the University to create a private police force. However, this is the only step anyone outside Hopkins administration has a voice in this, a decision that will affect lives, students, and the community. Why didn’t you let anyone know this was an initiative that would be introduced, now that there is a short timeframe, and people will not be able to voice their full opinions and ideas?
Provost Kumar: The question of why is not moot, but on other hand, for me the how is the most important question.
Student: No, the question is why. We don’t want a private police force. Many of us do not want a private police force. We are not interested in how it’ll be implemented; we don’t want it at all.
Provost Kumar: I hear you.
[Prolonged silence in recording]
Student: I’m a freshman. I have two comments. One, he asked why we were not involved in the discussion. Two, you didn’t answer the question. On my first comment, many freshmen here have an issue with the emails sent about robberies. They are vague. When there are emails, I correspond to descriptions most of time. The BPD is not known to be rational, so I don’t feel safe with BPD being on campus, because with me corresponding to descriptions in the robberies, I don’t want to be arrested or have anything to do with officers. Second of all, you said that this decision is final, so it would be fair if President Daniels would be part of these discussions since he was the one who sent out the email to start this discussion, so he can answer as to why no one was consulted about this sooner.
[snaps in crowd]
Provost Kumar: On why, let me give a partial answer. The answer is the legislative calendar runs in Maryland for a very short period of time – 90 days. If we were to postpone, we would postpone by a whole year. So even though we have been in peer reviews over several months, if the final decision had to be made, we would have had to wait a whole year. That was one of the reasons why we moved forward. I know this is not a complete answer, it is partial.
Provost Kumar to Special Advisor Hitchcock: Would you like to add on an answer?
Special Advisor Hitchcock: No, that is the answer.
Student: But if we wait a year, is that the answer?
Student: You say there’s a dialogue, and then you say there’s just a dialogue about how it’s going to happen, so there’s a discrepancy here?
Student: Last night, the Baltimore City Council passed resolution saying that if this law was passed, the University have to go through the city to create a police force. Does this mean that in creating a new police department, you will ignore what the city has to say, and that you will just go for the City Council and just go through them?
Special Advisor Hitchcock: No, absolutely not. We are in dialogue with the City Council.
Student: So why did the City Council pass a resolution against it?
Special Advisor Hitchcock: You have to understand the context. There are some on the City Council who want to take control of the Baltimore City Police Department away from the state. This is part of the rub between state government and city government. We went through years of us trying to do that with the school system and finally this year, legislation was passed, so this is part of a continuing issue for the Baltimore City Council, and this is taking control of the police department from the state, and so the resolution says that if there is going to be passage of those bills, they want to ensure that Baltimore City Council has input in the MOU, and they will.
Student: The city does not control the police force. Are we trying to expand the number of departments not under control of the city?
Special Advisory Hitchcock: No. Say that again?
Student: The resolution is part of the fight between city and state for the police force. Is this assuming the resolution is not going to be adopted, because the state has an interest in controlling the police force?
Special Advisor Hitchcock: The state has control over all local police departments in the state of Maryland, so this is pulling out something that doesn’t exist.
Student: But the University wants to bypass the City Council, go to the State Legislature?
Special Advisor Hitchcock: No. The University does not want to bypass City Council. If we want to talk past each other, I want to be responsive to what your question is. As far as input, the institution has no intent to bypass City Council. We will seek their input as we always do, and we’ve been in dialogue with members of City Council to communicate that very clearly.
Student: What if City Council doesn’t want it?
Special Advisor Hitchcock: The City Council hasn’t said that. I can’t answer that: what I know is that they passed a resolution that if there is a passage of this legislation, they want to ensure City Council has input, and that is the input they’re sending to Annapolis, and that is the message they’ve sent to us.
Student: What if City Council doesn’t want Hopkins to have a police force? What will Hopkins do?
Special Advisor Hitchcock: I can’t answer a hypothetical because I can’t anticipate what will happen.
Student: But it could happen.
AJ Tsang: Make sure if you want to give a comment or question, please get in line because people have been waiting for a long time.
Student: I want to talk about sexual assault and I want to talk about disabilities. I’ve been standing here for 10 minutes; I can’t hear you. You’re not making an effort to speak louder, and expanding on that, on disability, the amount of ableist stuff I’ve gotten from professors is ridiculous. Police target people with minority identities, and that includes disabled people. Look it up. I’ve walked into a 200-person lecture hall, and the professor asks my name, and I raise my hand and he goes, “See me after class.” I walked up after class, with everyone looking at me. The professor wanted to talk about my disability. I had to sit with him and walk him through 30 minutes of how to fill out an online form just to give me a disability accommodation, even though it was like an easy online quiz. This has been a common theme. The head of my major department sat across from me 2 weeks ago, and said “I feel disabled too.” [Crowd cries out] The head of the disability services department was just unlawfully fired for voluntarily seeking care. My question is: why are you putting in the long and arduous effort it takes to pass anything through government, but you haven’t made it mandatory for professors to go through sensitivity training, and understand at a basic level, how to accommodate students with disabilities?
Vice Provost Shollenberger: We just recently had consultants come in to review our overall disability services and how we can better serve students, so that report is being reviewed and we’re looking to enhance our services for students with disabilities.
Provost Kumar: As we brought up earlier, faculty are required to do a training module.
Student: That’s not true.
Provost Kumar: No, but [the module is] on discrimination as a whole. There was a comment made that we are pushing for compliance, or enough compliance. Finally, on the resource allocation question, as mentioned in my own remarks, I don’t view this as ??? because we want rest of this to be ???. We want to adopt best practice in all student services as soon as we can.
Student: Sensitivity training is actually required for professors when they first come in, but not every year. The professor who said that to me, who called me out in front of lecture, he’s a tenured professor and number 2 in the Math Department. He hasn’t been to training in decades, or at least 5 years. How do you talk about this? The question I’m asking is that there’s 5 of you here in this big lecture hall. You announced this last week, you’re here now, and there’s clearly been a lot of effort put into this. Yet I’ve never heard of anything like this, in the past 4 years, about disability accommodations, about improving those accommodations, about making things more accessible. It’s not about how much money you’re putting in, it’s about where your effort is going. If it’s about students being made safer, why can’t I sit in lecture and not feel ashamed? At least I know how to advocate for myself – how about people who don’t?
Student: The office for SDS (Student Disabilities Services) is a literal closet, and there’s no room for students to take tests. We’ve had conversations for a year and nothing’s happened.
Student: I take every exam in the Career Center. The administrators there are wonderful, but they are overcapacity. You fired the head of the SDS office against law, and he was the best person I knew here. I sat across a table from him, and I said this school sucks the living soul out of you. He said, “I wish you could be the first person sitting in that chair to say that to me.”
Provost Kumar: We did this with care.
Student: He was the best person I knew. He was a better ally to me than even some of the friends I have.
Provost Kumar: That said, I hear you. One of the reasons we did change was to improve services on the 3rd floor of Garland, where space is a perpetual problem for all services that are there. We are looking for places to expand. We want to reassure you of our efforts on this. I realize that in the past, it hasn’t been what it should be, and that’s what we are trying to improve.
Noh Mebrahtu: Perhaps we can move discussion to another issue. I’m sorry about that.
Student: I just want a yes or no. If we had a Hopkins private police force, can you give us a guarantee right now, that they wouldn’t cooperate with ICE [Immigration and Customs Enforcement] and wouldn’t cooperate in targeting undocumented students and undocumented Baltimorean residents?
Provost Kumar: It is not our intent to do that. I do not single handedly control where we will end with MOU. As President Daniels has mentioned, it is not our intent to help ICE in its efforts, and so all I can say is that it is not our intent to do so. As federal officers can come on campus now, that part we don’t control.
Student: It’s not your intent, but you can’t guarantee it won’t happen?
Student: If someone’s deported, we don’t care about your intent.
Special Advisor Hitchcock: This came up at a previous forum. There was a faculty member who read the statement from President Daniels in September 2017, who said we will not do that.
Provost Kumar: We intend to be what you call a sanctuary campus. What I can’t guarantee is how the federal government will treat sanctuary campuses going forward.
Special Advisor Hitchcock: I think we should get September 2017 email, pretty explicit.
Student: I read the email, but it doesn’t talk about a private police force going after Baltimore’s residents.
Student: In November, there was career fair with border patrol agents with guns advocating for students to join, so I don’t know how strongly the administration will stick to that statement, because it’s clearly broken its promises before.
Student: I’m speaking on behalf of DSAGA, as a member of its board. DSAGA stands for Diversity Sexuality and Gender Alliance. We are strongly against the implementation of a police force, specifically a private police force on campus. We live in a time when 48 percent of anti-LGBTQ crime survivors experience police misconduct. 46 percent of transgender people are not comfortable speaking to the police for fear of retaliation. This has been seen multiple times, like at Georgia Tech, when a transgender student was killed on campus. We also know that a third to one half of people killed by police have disabilities. People of color are disproportionately affected by injustice. You say that private police are supposed to serve and protect us, but they can’t do so because they are the same people are committing injustices against people who experience injustice every day of their lives. If they [the police] can’t protect us, who will?
Student: How much is it going to cost to do this?
Provost Kumar: The overall security footprint in Homewood is around 20 million dollars. That’s our current, substantiated amount, and that amount is dependent on resource allocation. A substantial amount of that is what we use as floating capacity, which is off duty BPD officers who make up a portion of the current force. And that is the resource pool from which we initially intend to build this [private police force]. We don’t see this as a change in the current security footprint of permanent employees or contract employees with Allied Universal. This would be on top of that, but would take place of the ad hoc basis [officers], and would professional version of that. We do not expect to see an increase in the 20 million dollar annual operating cost.
Student: What do you meant that you’re working on a pool of off-duty officers?
Provost Kumar: That’s what we currently use, off duty BPD officers, and that pool is on an ad-hoc basis, which will be replaced by the lone professional force, so the amount spent will remain the same.
Student: That would be enough to train new police?
Provost Kumar: We intend to start quite small. 20 million is the limit of what we can spend, and we don’t expect to change that.
Student: But if a cop shoots someone, then you have to include that in budget, pay for a settlement, add to it.
Provost Kumar: if that were to come to pass.
Student: What if it’s a 5 million settlement? Where will it come from? You don’t know how much it will cost.
Student: I’m a freshman. I have 1 quick comment. I’m confused about the principles Hopkins is operating on right now. We had a rapid and vibrant show of student opposition to the police force. To my understanding, it’s infrequent for that scale of demonstration to happen at Hopkins. We had faculty, had a huge group of student leaders opposed, forming a coalition in opposition. We had a lot of community members expressing their concerns about Hopkins getting involved in their jurisdiction. When we review other private police forces, like at U-Chicago, which has similar settings and various dynamics similar to Hopkins, reviews of those forces show unsatisfactory accountability and transparency due to it being private institutions. In light of all we know to be true about discriminatory practices of police, we have the statistics to prove this, including for BPD. We’ve also heard lot of facts from students. So in light of those factors, which are what we propose to be based on, I’m just confused as to how Hopkins administration is justified in this policy which is very clearly in direct opposition to people it affects, mainly us and the community? And especially in light of what we just learned, if we had a student referendum which opposed it [a private police force], would it have no effect on policy? I’m confused about Hopkins and the message it wants to get across to students.
Student: I don’t have a question. I just made this comment in SGA two weeks ago. Panels like this, where you ask for community feedback, don’t mean anything when we know what we’re doing won’t do anything. Had you waited that year, you would not have spent money going on trips, researching, putting your legislative foot to the bill. Someone from Hopkins ???. What it looks like to us, is that you timed this perfectly so that when the bill hit ground, even the Legislature was surprised and couldn’t be opposed quickly. It looks like this was directly strategized to pass. As a result, this is the only step that we could have to stop this from happening. If you talked about ??? . complaints, nothing happens. When Hopkins wants something to happen, Hopkins does it. If you can’t even tell me why you didn’t talk to community partners, there’s no point in us talking in this room. It’s a waste of all our time, it’s all for show.
[loud claps]
If you want to have a police force, you will have it, through lobbyists presenting and knowing the political landscape where you’ve visited other schools. You want this. This is reactionary to what parents say, when they say they don’t want to send their kids here, lower Hopkins’ ranking. This is about what people see and hear about Hopkins. You are responding to parents saying that Baltimore is like World War Three. We know there’s people in your ear, people pressuring you. We just want to let you know so we can stop wasting our time. If it’s going to happen, it’ll happen, and we’ll all just sit here for 30 minutes and no one will be able to respond to questions in effective way, we just don’t know, then we are wasting each other’s time, and wasting energy. We could have been figuring out how to organize in Annapolis. This was a waste of our time if you can’t explain why you didn’t talk to people in the community, because people in the community don’t want this.
[loud claps]
You’re like a corporation. Like UnderArmour, you find community partners willing to bend to what you want, and you say you’ve talked to them, but you ignore other community partners. This happens with corporations all over the place.
I just don’t know what we’re doing with this time. How are you taking in this feedback? How are you listening to us? If you are already backing funds with research, what are we doing here? Are you just showing face? Is this actually going to make a difference? Are you just going to disregard and go forward, because there’s already a lot of financial support? If that’s not what you intend, and it wasn’t supposed to be shady, then that’s what perception is. Perception is bigger than reality. But when y’all go about this anyway, that’s what we’re going to look at and see.
We’re just wasting each other’s time with panels and forums. You say we should protest in Annapolis, but you already put money behind it. You didn’t talk to us. That makes me as a student feel not listened to, that as long as I’m a student, protest is only acceptable when university can capture and capitalize on it, but not when I protest against what the University wants to do.
You have issues with security guards sexually harassing students, profiling black students, but you should put money into improving current force better. If you want to make things better with a police force, you have to prove you care about black students and minorities even now. Going through OIE is a long, tenuous process. It’s just not helpful. I would much rather see improvements to policies we have, actual fact we have going on, rather than just pushing legislation for a private police force. That may not be everyone’s opinion, but that’s what we’re seeing.
No disrespect for any of y’all. I don’t want to seem like I’m yelling and screaming, but we are fed up with community forums and panels. Our opinions aren’t weighted heavily. All we know is that Hopkins will do what it wants to do when it wants to.
[loud claps]
Student: I had 2 questions. You talked a lot about research on other universities and wanting to model it after U-Chicago, U-Penn, schools in Philadelphia, and you said public universities, which are already allowed to have private police in Baltimore. Let me know if this a preemptive question – since all of those other universities are CALEA accredited. CALEA is the commission on accreditation for law enforcement agencies. Accreditation from them would limit civil liability by making it harder for plaintiffs to sustain their claim. It would limit anyone’s ability to file civil lawsuits against infractions of Hopkins police. And so my question is, would Hopkins police have armed officers and/or be CALEA-accredited?
Provost Kumar: In regards to CALEA, we have thought about it. We want to meet state law first, but we want to exceed state law. CALEA has some advantages, but it is not intended to be membered because of the civil liability. To the other question, we expect that some of officers will be armed, but we will be very careful as to where they can be. Current policies for examples, are that they cannot be in buildings, and so we will see how policy will be applied. Similarly, in many care areas of the hospital, we currently do not permit as a matter to post armed officers. How that will continue going forward has to be thought about.
Student: Second question. In the House bill, and Senate bill, it says campus police officers would be authorized to use powers of BPD on all grounds of the institution of higher education. Does that mean that legally, a Hopkins police officer could make any arrest on property owned, leased, operated by, or under the control of Hopkins? I’m aware a lot of property that Hopkins owns in Baltimore isn’t even disclosed to public or generally put out there. How could you? I know Daniels did send email saying that the Hopkins police force would patrol on Homewood and East Baltimore. But I don’t trust word of the email. It’s not a signed social contract. How could you ensure this wouldn’t spiral into a Hopkins police force that makes arrests all around Baltimore? How could you make guarantees I wouldn’t be arrested randomly where Hopkins owned a property? How would you facilitate dialogue with the student body and wider Baltimore community to ensure you wouldn’t just randomly expand.
Provost Kumar: If at end of the end of the day, you don’t feel safe and secure, this is an exercise in futility. If at end of the day, this makes students feel less secure, less welcome, compromises our values, it’s an exercise in futility. We know. I don’t know how to say this other than an old fashioned phrase. I got into this business of teaching because I like people like you, and I enjoy teaching. And I personally – as does President Daniels, who with the greatest of caution – will not lose vision of what we are setting out to do, which is to make our overall safety and security and welcoming nature of our campus, better. It is not our intent to give that up. So to your question of how this will not get out of hand, we will absolutely pay attention to it.
Student: Would that include giving more advance notice about decisions, changes in patrol areas?
Provost Kumar: I may look dense, but the point is not lost on me. I hear you. I hear you.
Student: But what will you do about it?
[Prolonged silence in recording]
Student: I’m asking a question that should tie together concerns that students have reiterated and should perhaps also build off of. I just don’t understand why if we have 20 million to allot to the security footprint, then why are you here, why you are talking about wellbeing? I’ll tell you about students of color – we don’t need more police. We need faculty of color, more resources for mental health, more counselors of color in counseling center. They [the Counseling Center] have 1500 students going in the last year. That was what was published in the Task Force report. They are understaffed. We as students of color should not have to go to other psychiatrists and pay a crap ton of money for other forms of support we need because we’re not getting that on campus.
We don’t have mentors that look like us. My first black professor was in the Africana Studies Center. Why do I have to take a class there to have a black professor? It clearly sounds like you won’t listen to us about not having a police force, so is there going to be a centralized accountability system to report abuses of police? Especially something catered to how we know officers discriminate against minority groups?
Will there be accountability? We need resources allocated to that. We don’t need a police force. We need more faculty of color, more resources to mental health, and we don’t have a student center – we don’t. We hang out in the library and so that’s really frustrating because we don’t have a sense of community. There are lots of students that are stressed. Recently, an article in the News-Letter said that we are swimming in the Olympics of suffering. Voices like that are really important and they’re not the only one. 20 million could be allocated to addressing that, or at least some of that budget could be to that. That would be much more productive, if you want to prioritize safety and happiness, and that’s what we want. We don’t want more police. We want a student center, and faculty of color. We want better SDS accommodations, and we need our professors and TAs to have mandatory training for how to deal with students in a culturally concordant manner.
Provost Kumar: That’s something we just put out with the Task Force report. We need to increase counseling. We have a group working on the fact that access to mental health professionals is getting increasingly scarce, to your point. We will investigate it.
Student: The Task Force report puts out recommendations, recognizes queer students and POC students more likely to suffer from mental health issues, but doesn’t delineate steps to account for that? Why aren’t there immediate steps and requirements?
Provost Kumar: The immediate next step is to identify. There are 3 steps conceptually needed. The first is to designate somebody whose job it is to make that happen, somebody in charge of mental wellbeing at the university. The second is to expand resources on the counseling side. That is taking place. Third, our training – we have a grant that will allow us to start ???. The reason we put the report out was to have a person whose job it is to identify and expand resources, so the point is well taken, and it’s not something we’re not thinking of.
Noh Mebrahtu: To respect everyone’s time, everyone currently standing will be the last group to speak, to keep this on pace.
AJ Tsang: If perhaps we could have everyone standing say their comments at once, then we can have responses? [Crowd murmurs] Ah, no worries, never mind. It’s okay.
Student: If officers can carry guns, but if BPD officers don’t adequately prepare them, how will Hopkins regulate the discharge of weapons?
Provost Kumar: Let me give you an example of a peer institution. If you draw your pepper spray, your holster has sensor that draws data and a review board gets it. The officer is then expected to explain every draw of their weapon. That’s the level we want to have. That technology does exist, and we intend to allow it.
Student: What university?
Provost Kumar: The University of Rochester.
Student: That just sounds like it’s going to happen, so you’re going to have to investigate it. It doesn’t sound like you’re going to have training.
Student: I have a google spreadsheet, and it’s appropriate to do this, I can think of 60-70 people assaulted at this school. If I asked around, put a day into it, I could accumulate a list of hundreds of people. Now, we have 100+ people, including women and students of color. This is a room of students that are more likely to be targeted. Every single person here has been more or less against this. There was one person in favor of it, but he was a white person.
In the summer of 2016, a football player beat his girlfriend to death and was arrested, but there was no report. We got 2 reports of sexual assault in the last week after this resolution came out. You didn’t even list 3003 North Charles, the Homewood Apartments Building.
Where is the attorney here? Her job is to keep things on the down low. The only time I’ve ever seen administrators come out [is when] deans make announcements. I know this because I’ve been organizing on this campus, and I know people who have, and they get mad at this. I suppose I found my place among the people angry at administration who just wanted to be listened to.
Why do I know hundreds of people who have been assaulted? It’s because the attorney’s job is to keep things on the down low, and not let things reach the news. This is all happening at fraternities. I saw it every day; it was disgusting. A lot of people are being taken advantage of, are with fraternity people, and don’t know what’s happening because they’re socialized into it. They don’t know it’s their fault.
The number of reports not sent out, because of Title IX trauma, is like literal trauma that is often even worse than the initial trauma. People aren’t reporting and beyond that, a lot of people wouldn’t even think to report, because they don’t think anything wrong happened or that it’s not their fault. But this is a fraternity problem. There are hundreds of studies. Pike was only shut down when the nation heard about it, same as SAE [Sigma Alpha Epsilon]. Why are you doing this right now, but didn’t abolish fraternities 10 years ago, or 100 years ago when it was still going on? All the people who have been hurt on this campus, are not hurt by any Baltimorean, not by any person with a gun – and sorry about people held at gunpoint; we’re in a city, that’s what happens, we’re not a block away from being shot on the street.
But what are you going to do about fraternities? Why are there no restrictions? They are still having fun, still underground, still throwing parties and are just less regulated. What are you going to do that about, and not doing anything about frats and yet you’re making a police force when the actual danger is actual Hopkins students or other guys like you letting it happen? You see our articles in the News-Letter, you see national news, you see how fraternities are a huge danger. And we’re talking about IFC fraternities.
[Crowd snaps]
Vice Provost Shollenberger: I do think we’re working with fraternities and sororities to do training and awareness. I appreciate that we have a lot more to do, but I also think there’s a lot we have implemented to date. One of the things we do also struggle with is fraternities and sororities that are underground, and we are trying to look at how we can hold students accountable, when they violate our student conduct code.
Student: Try to pass a law, take it to Annapolis. It seems like y’all don’t really care.
Student: I have a follow-up question. I asked why you didn’t tell us about this until March 5th, and you said this was a long process. Why during the several month process did you not think about reasons, about how you would respond, about specifics for the private police force? All without consulting us? Why? I didn’t get a satisfactory answer. I have organizations I am representing, and I’m feeling like my question isn’t be responded to. If this is a several months-long process, why weren’t we told in advance? The legislative window ends April 10th. This process started while ago. If this is several months in the making, why are we only being told now?
Provost Kumar: First, I want to say I’m not disrespecting anybody. This goes back to the earlier point: with perception after the fact of a sequence of events, things look different. In particular, the consultation process that led to the leadership of the University, to come to the conclusion it did, happened to coincide with getting very close to where the bill can be produced. So even though the legislative process goes through a long process, there’s a last date that a new bill can be introduced. It got relatively close to that, and at that time, we also had to make sure and in fact, had wanted to make sure that the Mayor was actually not just in favor, but would want this to happen. We did not want to do this in a way that would undercut the city of Baltimore in any way, so consequently it had to come together. All of these ended up as a kind of confluence that occurred relatively close to the last day for introducing new legislation. Now, I realize that one of the reasons I did not want to answer this in the first place, was all of this. But I can only tell you what transpire.
Student: What specifically are each of you going to do to show us that our voices are being heard? For example, my parents tell me to do things, but I don’t. So what will you do to show that we are being heard, and that you will do things with our ideas in mind?
Provost Kumar: First, the facts that led to this. Second, we do need to consult if the legislation passes. If the legislation passes, we will consult as to what would be the kind of process by which the structure, standards, and accountability of governance of the force would be. We will consult on that. We will consult with you. We will consult – we have faculty in school of public health, Krieger, who study these issues. We will consult with them. We already have consulted with them and will continue to. We will show them data and come up with what is the next step. So I am guaranteeing, not hedging, that we will talk. We will talk and perhaps survey the student body as to what are things that are concerns, what needs are, etc., and make sure there’s a systematic process by which your input goes into how this process moves forward.
Student: You talked a lot about student wellbeing. You talked a lot about evidence and data. I will be talking about sexual assault. If anyone would like to leave the room for personal reasons, please feel welcome to.
According to a 2010 Cato Institute review, the most commonly reported concern about police is the use of excessive force. The second is sexual misconduct. A 2010 investigation by Baltimore of reviews of court records and media, found that an officer was accused of sexual misconduct every 5 days. How will you reconcile that we are bringing in an inherent power structure to campus, where they have guns and power, and you are giving them the strength they may need to commit these acts of misconduct and not have an accountability structure for them? To have an accountability structure, we need to be able to file complaints, but unfortunately we need things to happen first to have complaints.
Truthfully, I cannot fathom the idea of having a private police force on this campus, because a fifth of arrests related to sexual misconduct involve rape, another fifth involve forcible fondling, and half are when police are on-duty and half are when police are off-duty. We can’t talk about student wellbeing without bringing this up. We are putting more students at more vulnerability and risk for bad experiences. I do not think that’s appropriate in any direction.
[Crowd claps]
Provost Kumar: Your point is well taken and in particular, this is where selection, training, and monitoring and accountability comes in. Again, I’d like to reassure you that if we brought in people who made our student body feel less secure, then ???. While your statistics are accurate, they represent ???. The key is 15-25 people that you can handpick, where you can be reasonably confident as a University, beyond reasonably confident, that it will never happen. Are there individuals? Yes. And in return for safety alone, I don’t see this as an acceptable tradeoff. So we have to absolutely certain.
Student: We’ve talked a lot about how the University will handpick officers and go through expensive training, but we have problems with Security already being intrusive in taking students to mercy, dealing with sexual misconduct, and I don’t trust the University to put in action behind data.
Student: So I know you may not have much of a response, but seriously consider the effects of this and everything said today. Everyone’s made good points today.
Noh Mebrahtu: Just to let everyone know, we have to vacate the premises by 10 PM. We have 12 minutes, so please keep questions and answers concise.
Student: A couple questions. A friend of mine came up from Haiti, and brought up the state of security in America. Going off of one of the earlier comments, one of the first questions is training: who will be training them? And if it is by currently established police academy, they already have enough problems, and within those biases they are trained to react instead of do loops. How are we, who have no experience with the police force or in building a different police force, going to be trained to do something different that hasn’t been done before? [Crowd claps]
Provost Kumar: I think that if you look at some of our peers, they have given additional training modules. One of the things they do is a much longer probationary period where the officer is shadowed by somebody to see how they react on the job, and monitoring, de-escalation training, how they interact with community, etc. If you’re thinking of a few thousand people of a city, and the kind of investment in their training, versus a few tens or even smaller, a couple dozen police officers, the level of training and monitoring you can provide is significantly different. The question we should ask is for 25-40 people (and I’m not claiming these are different numbers), how much training can we provide? At that scale, we believe we can provide significantly more training and selective training. Your concern is valid, but on scale, the difference between city police and what we are talking about makes a difference.
Student: I worked on research team recently, and the person in charge of it was able to say numbers to work better in their favor. How can we be sure that numbers about success, are actually what is being implemented versus talking to people where it’s implemented and getting student feedback on what is happening where they’re at?
Provost Kumar: Fair point. In particular, we have to look to where there’s student newspapers, where there’s past issues where this has come up on campus.
Student: Under training – it’s likely this will be passed based on the effort put into it. On a precautionary note, can you make it so part of the training that these people would go through is an intensive psych workup so that if they are armed, they are evaluated in every way, shape and form, so much so that they don’t even want to be officers anymore? If this person is armed – and I don’t think adding more guns to a country with gun control problems, with 13,000 shootings this year alone –there’s no doubt about the character in how our safety is being controlled. Can you make sure this happens?
Provost Kumar: Indeed. In other places, one of the things we saw over and over again was that when in doubt, ???. This isn’t about making sure there’s enough people wearing badges. It’s about making sure there’s the right people wearing badges.
Director Presberry: Just to add to that, through the state of Maryland, in order to be a police officer, you have to be certified through State of Maryland, so certain things are required in the pre-recruitment phase. One of them is that that they have to have psych evaluations.
Student: But do you believe the police in Maryland are fit? For example, when the drug task force was convicted?
Director Presberry: I can’t speak for BPD. She asked a question so I’m answering it. That is a requirement through the state of Maryland, that they do receive a psych evaluation, and also background checks, and they have to have a medical examination. It’s a very in-depth system in order to make sure that you are putting things right.
Student: What I’m asking, is can you go a step further?
Provost Kumar: Indeed. Absolutely, without question.
Student: One last thing. Since I said before that this is going to pass because of how much effort has been put into it, instead of being happy in the way people handle situations, will you also look into other methods? Part of training should also be if you see 2 people in heated argument, how do you function as a mediator, so you don’t count how many times pepper spray is pulled out, and so instead they’re there to say not what to do, but say ‘we are here to help you’?
Special Advisor Hitchcock: What you are saying is de-escalation.
Noh Mebrahtu: Hi everyone, could you please say questions at once?
Student: I would just like to say that it is hilarious that you rushed to get this in before the legislative deadline, because it confirms to me that the governor whose desk you want this to cross is Larry Hogan’s. I think you know that any of the progressive Democratic candidates for governor will tell you to pump sand. I want to know whether you are personally mentally prepared for that these officers are somewhat likely to kill one of your students [Crowd claps]. In the past year, Georgia Tech police killed a student, killed a suicidal student. The student called police on themselves, went to the street with a small pocket knife, and officers dozens of feet away shot him, like sociopaths. That’s what sociopaths do. That is what giving police weapons does to them. I really am boggled to wonder whether you realize the impact that this has on anybody that has any sort of divergent mental health, any sort of non-normative mental health. As we’ve seen in the DOJ [Department of Justice] report on BPD, they have a section on how BPD deals with mental health problems: people get injured and go to jail. This is a huge problem with police. I barely trust campus police to show up to help a friend with mental health issues. I wouldn’t trust them at all if they had a gun. I would not trust them zero, whatsoever. Are you prepared for the fact that you are completely removing the capability for police to properly empathize with students, and not escalate into injuries or deaths?
Student: A lot have mentioned this, but I want to really emphasize that what we’re saying here today, is not that we’re asking questions and you giving answers. We want you to take notes and take them not just to your bedside table, but to take them and use them. There are other issues besides private police that you haven’t addressed. There are other crimes on campus, like assaults, and many go unreported. The students here do not at all feel represented by the University in this matter, which you can see in your survey and report. We do not feel like you have our backs, especially minority students. If you want to promote our safety, why are our concerns not properly addressed? We’ve been getting emails this week about the anonymous climate survey, but if there’s not enough education for a safe environment, how can we has a student body feel that you will address abuses by officers?
Student: Will cops be required to wear body cameras? Can you each look me in the eye and tell me that racial profiling of students won’t be an issue?
Provost Kumar: On the body camera issue, the answer is almost certainly yes. Just like we want to have all kinds of technology, there will be racial profiling if there’s one bad apple, yes.
Student: How will we know the bad apple? Won’t you try to actively prevent the bad apple?
Provost Kumar: No, if you look at the 20 million dollars for Allied Universal guards. What I’m trying to get at is that there have been complaints about the security force that there is racial profiling going on. For police, we would try to the utmost ability, we will get them ???. Much more training is needed for this smaller force, and again, not all of them will be armed at all times. Because of the risk involved, we do not expect what is happening elsewhere to be reflected in our police force. That much I can tell you. If I did not honestly believe that, I would not be in favor of this. I believe that the safety of our entire community will improve by having this police force.
Student: It seems like when campus security racially profiles, it’s an inconvenience, but when police profile, that could be a life. [Crowd claps]
Noh Mebrahtu: We have reached the end of tonight’s forum. Before we leave, I was going to say a comment reiterating everything. Personally, I don’t want a police force on campus because I’ve never had a good interaction with police, and I get very scared around them. To know there’s police on campus with guns, I won’t feel safe and I feel like I will always feel threatened or in danger every time I come to my classes, at 9 AM or 10AM, and when I study at Brody until 3 AM. You see these emails – 18 year old black male – that’s me. I feel that one day, I’m going to feel profiled. I’m going to feel contained for no reason in that they might not think I go here. That’s what I want to leave with you. That’s what I want you to take into consideration.
Thank you everybody that came. We really appreciate you and appreciate the time of Provost Kumar and everyone else coming.
Student: Anyone interested in getting involved in organizing against the private police force, please let me know!
Student: In addition, tomorrow at 10 AM, as we ended with a discussion on guns, we will be standing in solidarity with the 17 students in murdered in Parkland. We will also be standing in solidarity of thousands murdered since Columbine and before, and this directly relates to the conversation today, because it will impact us soon.
Student: Where?
Student: In front of Gilman, 10 to 10:17 AM.
[Open chatter for 3 minutes, then recording ends.]
