JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

Senate Meeting #11 (12 4 18)

Filed in Drive as “Senate Meeting #11 (12_4_18)”

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

SENATE OF THE JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION

Consolidated General Body Meeting Agenda and Minutes

December 4th, 2018

7:00 PM, Charles Commons East Room

Agendas are set by the Executive Vice President and circulated by the Executive Secretary. Questions regarding this agenda can thus be directed to AJ Tsang (atsang4@jhu.edu) and Aspen Williams (awill230@jhu.edu).

Agenda

Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)

Approval of the Agenda & Prior Minutes (1 min)

New Business I (40 min)

Guest Presentations (40 min)

Homewood Outreach Programs Tour [Link] — Salem Reiner (25 min)

Sexual Assault Solidarity Petition [Group Petition Link] [Individual Petition Link] — Senator Bannister, Lukas Mackinney (15 min)

Reports (18 min)

Executive Board Reports (4 min)

Committee Reports (7 min)

Academic Affairs — Senator Taj

Civic Engagement — President Schatmeyer, Senator Paulet

Finance — Senator Mays, Treasurer Tu

Health, Safety and Sustainability — Senator Paulet, Senator Patel

Internal Affairs — Senator Baron, Vice President Tsang

Student Organizations — President Chien, Senator Elgendi

Student Services — Senator Cai, President Schatmeyer

Class Council Reports (4 min)

Advisor Report (3 min)

New Business II (110 min)

Legislation (70 min)

Title IX Policy Resolution [Link] — Senators Wellons & Bannister (15 min)

Transgender and Gender Nonconforming Solidarity Resolution [Link] — Exec. Secretary Williams (15 min)

Spring Fair Fireworks Funding Bill [Link] — Exec. Secretary Williams, with guests Sofya Freyman and Meera McClane (15 min)

SASH Dil Se Funding Bill [Link] — Senator Patel (15 min)

Fu Funding Bill Discussion (No Vote) [Link] — Senator Mays, Senator Emeritus Fang (10 min)

Judiciary Confirmation Vote (10 min)

SGA Culture Discussion [Link] (30 min)

Prospective Business (5 min)

Advancing Legislation

Announcements

Public Input Period

Adjournment (ESTIMATED 10:15 PM, ACTUAL 9:48 PM)

Time-length and adjournment estimates are provided for the benefit of guests at Senate meetings. However, SGA meetings are always slated to extend until at least 9:00 PM and SGA members are expected to remain in the Senate chamber until official adjournment by motion, whether before or after the adjournment estimate.

ADDENDUM A: RECOMMENDED DISCUSSION FORMAT

Guest Presentations (25 min)

Sexual Assault Solidarity Petition [Petition Link] — Senator Bannister, Lukas Mackinney (15 min)

Presentation from Miranda (1 min)

Presentation from Lukas (5 min)

Discussion (recommended 9 min mod, 45 sec speaking times)

Vote on Signing

Homewood Outreach Programs Tour — Salem Reiner (10 min)

N/A

Legislation (85 min)

Title IX Policy Resolution [Link] — Senators Wellons & Bannister (15 min)

Reading Period (1 min)

Presentation (3 min)

Q&A (6 min)

Discussion (recommended 5 min mod, 30 sec speaking times)

Vote

Transgender and Gender Nonconforming Solidarity Resolution [Link] — Exec. Secretary Williams (15 min)

Reading Period (1 min)

Presentation (3 min)

Q&A (3 min)

Discussion (recommended 8 min mod, 30 sec speaking times)

Vote

Spring Fair Fireworks Funding Bill [Link] — Exec. Secretary Williams, with guests Sofya Freyman and Meera McClane (15 min)

Reading Period (1 min)

Treasurer Report (1 min)

Presentation (3 min)

Q&A (3 min)

Discussion (recommended 8 min mod, 30 sec speaking times)

Vote

SASH Dil Se Funding Bill [Link] — Sen. Patel (15 min)

Reading Period (1 min)

Presentation (3 min)

Q&A (3 min)

Discussion (recommended 8 min mod, 30 sec speaking times)

Vote

Fu Funding Bill Discussion (No Vote) [Link] — Senator Mays, Senator Emeritus Fang (10 min)

Reading Period (1 min)

Presentation (3 min)

Q&A (3 min)

Discussion (recommended 8 min mod, 30 sec speaking times)

Judiciary Confirmation Vote (10 min)

Presentation of Final Nominees (5 min)

Discussion (recommended 5 min mod caucus with 30 sec speaking times)

SGA Culture Discussion [Link] (30 min)

Round Robins for all

MINUTES

Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)

Role Taken

Approval of the Agenda & Prior Minutes (1 min)

Approved

New Business I (40 min)

Guest Presentations (40 min)

Homewood Outreach Programs Tour [Link] — Salem Reiner (25 min)

See link - Salem gave presentation

SGA sign up for tour!

Anchor institutions - place based and sticky capital

Deliberate strategy - need direction from upper admin

Had the luxury of being proactive and not reactive

Incorporate many neighborhoods around JHU

Work to build social capital

About 250 permanently affordable homes

Sexual Assault Solidarity Petition [Group Petition Link] [Individual Petition Link] — Senator Bannister, Lukas Mackinney (15 min)

Lucas, Cas, and Talia are presenting

Senator Bannister - here to address assault by a professor at school - coalition has been given permission to release information and has taken no steps without consulting a survivor - 7 witnesses came forward - a lot of witnesses were unaffiliated with the university but still testified - OIE didn’t really follow through on interviews - ruled it harassment - legal concerns: consulted a lot of lawyers about libel laws - SGA cannot be sued if we sign on - one attorney advised Christine Blasey Ford - may not be able to answer questions for confidentiality - our constitution states that we are here to protect and help students

Presentors:

Talia - PhD student in anthropology - have non hop partners working with them - take a survivor centered approach - everything has been approved by the survivor - SGA and their coalition do not need to worry about a defamation suit - no legal risk - 1,000 signatures and other endorsements of petition - this is a faculty that teaches undergraduates and puts members of our community at harm - public safety issue that needs to be brought attention

What happened and the concerns

May 4th, Juan Obarrio assaulted a visiting grad student at a bar - gave account of assault - other women in the department had experienced conduct issues but didn’t report do to fear of retaliation - when the case was brought forward, there were many mishandlings - named off mishandlings that can be found in petition - linked to a larger pattern of inappropriate behaviour - survivors and witnesses had to retell stories many times - lack of communication and transparency from department and school - put witnesses in a very difficult situation - asking for tenure to be revoked and for JHU to take seriously what has happened - JHU has a number of mishandling OIE complaints - changes were more cosmetic - trying to make the school safer for everyone

What coalition wants

Tenure revoked - transparency and accountability from OIE - improving mental health resources for survivors - better systems for survivors - there’s a need to take seriously anonymous complaints - comply with current standing rules and procedures - public statement issued denouncing Juan Obarrio’s actions and stating that JHU will comply with demands

So what

We need to stand together as a campus to support survivors

Senator Murak - were there reports given to OIE about the professor before this event?

There is an anonymous complaint mechanism but they were not investigated - other women did not report - they do not investigate anonymous complaints - wouldn’t incorporate previous information into the report

Discussion - no discussion

Senator Bannister - motion to sign the letter

Motion passes

Reports (18 min)

Executive Board Reports (4 min)

President

VP and Secretary

Daniels Dinner Feedback

Incredible. Advocated more and harder than in the 4 years I’ve gone to them.

Community Council Initiative

Now that we have blessings from President Daniels and Provost Kumar, it’s our hope to move forward with a more detailed proposal and conversations with folks all across the University. After the dinner, Provost Kumar recommended we meet with him soon to discuss next actions.

Renewable Energy Resolution

Meeting with Sam, Omar, Aspen and Clarissa tomorrow (Wednesday) at 8:30 PM in Gilman Atrium. If you’re interested in working with us, you are also more than welcome to come.

Baltimorean Student Government Conference

There will be a conference of student governments across Baltimore on Saturday, January 27th (last Saturday of Intersession). It’s our hope everyone can go!

As mentioned, I’m hoping to make a presentation there on sustainable advocacy through impactful legislation. I would love folks’ feedback on it this week and if someone would like to help out or present too, would very much welcome that.

Dimensions of Connection (APTT Conference)

Went well

SGA Alumni Advisory Board

Official invitation email sent out to start planning for structure and format. Concept document HERE.

JOINT SECTION WITH ASPEN:

SGA Alumni Reception

Working with Adelaide Morphett to host this during Alumni Weekend in the spring. Slated for Saturday, April 6th from 4-6 PM. Reserve your calendars NOW!

Faculty Assembly Presentation

Presented at this semester’s Faculty Assembly meeting with Aspen. Talked about public safety, Title IX, student center, community council.

Title IX - they were also concerned about lag times. Community council - recommended it be university-wide, similar to Daniels.

For your information, leaders are: Kristin Cook-Gailloud (President, GRLL Department); Julie Reiser (Vice President, CLE); Sunita Thyagarajan (Secretary, Chemistry). They shift up each year.

They discussed interesting things like book monopoly from Barnes and Noble, and how even they don’t like it. They’re experimenting with more online engagement.

We have an invitation to their spring meeting.

Treasurer

Committee Reports (7 min)

Academic Affairs — Senator Taj

Civic Engagement — President Schatmeyer, Senator Paulet

Finance — Senator Mays, Treasurer Tu

Health, Safety and Sustainability — Senator Paulet, Senator Patel

Internal Affairs — Senator Baron, Vice President Tsang

Student Organizations — President Chien, Senator Elgendi

Student Services — Senator Cai, President Schatmeyer

Class Council Reports (4 min)

Advisor Report (3 min)

New Business II (110 min)

Legislation (70 min)

Title IX Policy Resolution [Link] — Senators Wellons & Bannister (15 min)

Senator Bannister

You’ve already heard us speak to Daniels so this is a follow up - many issues with OIE and the punishments or lack thereof for those who commit sexual assault - processes are opaque - no way to know if a crime will be punished

Senator Wellons

Spoke at Daniels’ Dinner - OIE as we’ve seen needs to be fixed - it’s a broken institution at this school - in several sexual assault documentaries JHU is mentioned, especially in hunting ground - said there was no need for new staff at dinner - OIE said that they are understaffed to address concerns about timeliness - very few cases are completed before the federal recommendation of time - burden of proof is too high at this school - would highly raise the bar of how survivors are treated - there is a lot of disrespect and not trauma informed people at the office - people at the office are stressed because of their job - have said they are very overworked

Q&A

Senator Bhamidipati - Daniels said there is a project management issue - were you able to find out what it meant by inefficient process?

When Daniels arrived there were no records - this was the first report of the kind - there was no standard for the office or university - told the title IX office that they need to raise the standard to a high level - investigating details that are dilatory and not looking at relevant details - will miss bigger pieces of evidence but will analyze small details - process should be streamlined and agree that there shouldn’t be too many bodies in the room - OIE always says they need more people - want more staff hires - amount of reports OIE got in 2016 was 240 - went up to 410 - will continue to grow as stigma decreases - these offices will continue to investigate reports - will see an increased workload

Senator Armstrong - President Daniels said we need to reconcile process and streamlining - how to peer institution behave compared to JHU

On procedure a preponderance of evidence - but we tend to go into too many details that increase burden of proof - not the practice and outside law firm investigated our procedures and we are going beyond the process needed - there needs to be a fair and thorough investigation but needs to be fair for everyone - want it to be thorough but want to see a roadmap for how they will be streamlined - want a deadline for when those procedures will be introduced

Discussion with Mod Caucus

Senator Elgendi

Ongoing problem and solutions are not going well - did not get best results from dinner - no brainer to say yes to this

Senator Murak

If we can learn anything from SC - it takes a lot of consistent pressure from SGA and other bodies - this is a serious issue here at Hop and it’s got to change

Senator Bannister

Was very moved when she went to the meeting for the coalition - same issues that SGA is trying to address - more than 6 months of investigation - wants something done about long investigations

President Schatmeyer

Deadline in resolution - asking that the change be made in two years

Senator Lloyd

In full support of resolution and would also like to sponsor - what are next steps? What peer benchmarking is there?

Senator Wellons

Looked at peer institutions - next steps are tbd - working with Daniels, JHToo protest, working with SARU

This is obviously about the survivors but also the timeline is really important - important for respondents also for many years

Senator Panakam

Encourage people to ask more detailed questions - motion to end mod caucus

Motion passes unanimously

Motion to vote

Motion approved

Transgender and Gender Nonconforming Solidarity Resolution [Link] — Exec. Secretary Williams (15 min)

Senator Murak - set up guidelines for how we can do this?

Yes

Senator Armstrong

Non gender conforming people are not protected?

No

Mod Caucus

Senator Bannister

Very basic human rights that are guaranteed under the laws that are no longer protected - important for dignity

Senator Armstrong

Can they still be protect under Title VII

No

Senator Panakam - motion to end mod caucus

Passes

Motion to vote

Passes unanimously

Spring Fair Fireworks Funding Bill [Link] — Exec. Secretary Williams, with guests Sofya Freyman and Meera McClane (15 min)

See link for presentation

POI Senator Mollin - what is the remaining budget - will save for later

Senator Mollin - were going to fund it last year but didn’t - how did you get the money?

Someone was willing to donate money for fireworks

Senator Mollin - do we always fun fireworks?

No we encountered new expenses - budget doesn’t change

Senator Mollin - motion for treasury report after reading period

Contingency - about 6k

Events 4,020

If we pass all three bills - there will be about 6k left

POI - started with 8765 in contingency, events 9700

President Schatmeyer motion to presentation

Senator Mollin - is it during passover?

Possibly? Needs to be taken into account

Senator Lucas - what time does it start?

At night

President Schatmeyer - how many people are there?

Upwards of 200

Discussion 1 minute speaking times 4 minutes

Senator Mollin

  1. this is the kind of bill we should be supporting - addresses most of student body - we are running low on money - in terms of looking at bills - we need to make sure the events we fund impact the entire student body as much as possible

Senator Lloyd

Given monetary concerns - we should look at bills we have now an in the spring semester and think about which ones will have a new student impact - we should cater to smaller groups that we don’t consider - SF will still be a strong event - reaches a lot of people - another cultural group may come along - that should be the priority

Senator Bannister

Would not vote in favor of pizza - can look at bills that are better for larger groups that reach a broader width of people - should not punish bill on floor - follows MHTF to help students on campus with enjoying the school

Senator Forlenza

Explain severability

If we get enough money to pay off fair stuff - money goes back to SGA

POI - what other subsects of out budget are there?

Operations - are we in debt? Can be used for retreats - budget is different this year - SAC cannot fund springfair - SGA elections are just for elections

POI - if this doesn’t get approved what happens?

President Schatmeyer

SF has been working really hard to make money - revenue generating events need to make a lot more money - not an issue of financial mismanagement - many programming boards are in debt - an event that involves the entire community

Senator Wellons

Something to consider - a lot of people have sensory disabilities - can we limit this and have CC pitch in

Motion to extend mod caucus - 1 minute 3 people

Senator Armstrong - financial powerhouse with a lot of ways to get donations - should fund grassroots student orgs - SF is inclusive and a good event - money can be better spent

Treasurer Tu - SAC can help a lot of Student groups with funding but cannot help SF - other storgs can reach out to SAC

Senator Bhamidipati

Would be really ironic to have Hop divest from fossil fuels but have fireworks - community generated by fireworks - having another fireworks event adds benefit

Senator Elgendi

Every year the fireworks are well attended - helps a lot of people on campus - not niche, for everyone - its our job to cater to our students and give them the best experience at Hop

POI President Chien - branding question

Extend Mod 1 minute 3 speakers

Will SGA have marketing purposes - yes friendly

Vote passes 11 to 3

SASH Dil Se Funding Bill [Link] — Senator Patel (15 min)

Senator Patel - packed Shriver hall - other people come in from other parts of the country - in terms of accounting - will apply for a SAC grant - will be on Med Campus - will hire an electrician to do lighting - 1,015

Senator Elgendi - can OMA help? Will being on med campus affect attendance

Cannot say about OMA - did not affect attendance

Senator Wellons - applying for 1k from SAC but that hasn’t worked yet

This covers the things mentioned in the bill

President Chien - cannot exceed 1k for SAC grants

Treasurer Tu - can apply for any amount from SAC

President Chien - can I ask if SAC is considering this? SGA has jurisdiction over SAC - if you guys agree to pass the bill does SAC have to pass - monthly grant budget is 8k now - can be very flexible -

POI Senator Murak - is there any way that SGA can compel SAC to fund this?

Nothing bars us but it’s an issue ethically - can write informal letters to SAC

Senator Wellons - motion to table until they hear back from the SAC grant?

Senator Patel? - has SAC ever approved a grant above 2k?

Treasurer Tu - yes and we have a lot of money

Discussion to table

Senator Mollin - let’s postpone

Motion to vote to table - tabled unanimously

Fu Funding Bill Discussion (No Vote) [Link] — Senator Mays, Senator Emeritus Fang (10 min)

Speakers - have been in contact with Wang Fu - will do a tour of their new series - need a lot of help for funding - series is about asians and social issues they face - first time she’s seen asians in the series - talks about a lot of social issues faced by asians - helpful to non-asian allies - would be doing a half hour discussion and Q&A - would be a 3 hour event - pioneering production for asian groups - reserved shriver for it already - would be during march 1st - OMA is doing a concurrent campaign - time sensitive because they haven’t given them a definite yes or no - also applying to SAC

President Schatmeyer - if we aren’t voting why are we discussing?

To give IAC the ability to discuss

Judiciary Confirmation Vote (10 min)

Presented Nominees

All nominees went through a rigid process - all individuals were deemed qualified by all interviewers

President Schatmeyer - first time going over judicial nominees - applause to AJ for conducting such a good process - snaps for IA

Motion to move into voting procedure - Senator Bannister

1st candidate - passed

2nd candidate - passed with 1 abstention

3rd candidate - passed with 1 abstention

4th candidate - passed

SGA Culture Discussion [Link] (30 min)

See presentation

Want to hit the reset button

Senator Bannister - at one SGA event - was very offended by a male senator when he said he doesn’t like settings where there are women - was very offended

Senator Bannister - does not like how Senator Emeritus Maya was attacked for an obnoxious amount of time

President Chien - close session?

No

Senator Panakam - a lot of emotion in sga meetings - SGA is an elected body and we should act in a dignified manner - passion is translated into unhealthy, unprofessional means - reduce the emotion and increase intellect - it’s okay to disagree - when there’s a dissenting opinion we don’t have to attack it - don’t really have good discussion - there’s a lot of emotion - this is a professional study body - we need to act professional

Senator Wellons - we’ve talked about this quite a few times but nothing really changes - this is seriously infringing on people’s want to participate - there are not a lot of people in the room now - SGA has potentially been a toxic place - was embarrassed to be a part of this body - not proud of it because sees body as a place that can and should do better - very little respect for each other - there has been very little change - peers may not be here next year

President Schatmeyer - tired so thoughts might not be coherent - we have had vastly different experiences on SGA - all bring different things to the body - we can all work on collaborating better before GBM and in general - before this year, the SGA groupme wasn’t used - other group chats are very active and can be productive - involving other people you wouldn’t normally want to involve in the legislative process - has made 7 other really good friends because of this - personally proud to be a part of this SGA - proud of the legislation put forward - has learned a lot

Senator Bannister - proud to be in SGA - we can grow a lot as a body - pleasant surprise that both petition and resolution passed unanimously - saw us treat a black female speaker the way we wouldn’t treat a white male speaker - cut her off while she was answering the questions they posed to her - lack of self awareness - never scrutinized a bill to that extent - nobody could see that she was being treated differently afterwards - should have never put her through that

Senator Elgendi - we should all have respect for others - if someone feels disrespected it’s on all of us - we need to be helpful - with the groupme - is it formal? Very proud to be in this SGA

Senator Lucas - since freshman year - love SGA - nonSGA friends make fun of him for spending so much time in SGA - we need to be able to be friends - can lead to lapses in productive discussion - for soph class personally - we’re not seen as a family like other organizations - would it be a bad thing if people wanted to be on SGA - need to be friends more

Senator Lloyd - issue with disrespecting speakers - wants to apologize if he did anything - it’s important to be cognizant of how we approach speakers - would say SGA this semester has been one of the best experiences on this campus - has loved working with us - overall SGA is a strong body - it’s important that we pay attention to how we treat other people - if you feel disrespected you need to speak up that instant

Senator Panakam - one thing that’s been brought up is that underclassmen don’t have mentorship from upperclassmen - there’s been a lot of turnover - only a few senators have been here - more than happy to help people come into their roots - always really busy - we forget to make connections - reach out to people who you are interested in being mentored by - definitely agree we should be friends - during GBM we need to maintain a level of professionality to be respectful - there is a level of inefficiency that we need to work through

Senator Forlenza - the impact of what we do comes off bad but can be unintentional - while people are treated poorly we don’t mean to do bad things

VP Tsang - a lot of people go to AJ and no one here is a bad person - it breaks his heart to tear people apart in SGA

President Schatmeyer - we all really love this school for different reasons - something compelled us to give back especially those who voted us in - we put in so much time - we’re doing it for a reason - structural - when GBM’s become contentious it’s because we’re tired - lessening the time burden that SGA is - it’s unfair to ask

President Chien - echoing mentorship - please talk to me if you want to talk - wants to be a good mentor and a good example - off of institutional memory - this is the first time we’ve talked about this as a body - represents great progress - there have been examples of sexism and racism - yet no one has brought it up before now - we need to make sure we translate that discussion into action - wish more people were here to listen to that

Senator Parmar - culture has focused on attacking - discussion is to be had between three people and a lot of people stay silent - if she has a question doesn’t want to be called out for being sexist and racist - intent is important

Senator Lucas - despite all the time we put into SGA - when you represent people it’s a thankless job - people may look for reasons to say bad things - we do a really good job

Senator Bannister - found it upsetting to be speaking at Daniels dinner to have him interrupt during the OIE discussion - thinks we need to be better with how we treat women - people were talking about the mansplaining and being cut off

Senator Patel - thinks this discussion has been great - motion to adjourn

Motion passes

Prospective Business (5 min)

Advancing Legislation

Announcements

Public Input Period

Adjournment (ESTIMATED 10:15 PM, ACTUAL X:XX PM)

Sources

Senate Meeting #11 (12_4_18).docx