JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

S. Bill. 114.11.17.26-2 Disciplinary Mark Reform Act

You are viewing the
version.
Senate
of the
Student Government Association
of
The Johns Hopkins University
{ S. Bill. 114.11.17.26-2 }
A Bill to Amend The Procedural Rules of the Senate
Disciplinary Mark Reform Act
Introduced by: Chair of Internal Affairs Cole Liazos-Coffey
Sponsored by: WSE Senator Demarri Dosunmu and Student Body Vice President Shreemann Patel
Presented for First Reading this 15th day of November in the year 2026

SECTION 1. TITLE.

This Act may be referred to as the “Disciplinary Mark Reform Act”

SECTION 2. DEFINITIONS.

  1. SGA — The term “SGA” shall refer to the Student Government Association of The Johns Hopkins University.
  2. JHU, Hopkins - The terms “JHU” and “Hopkins” shall refer to the Johns Hopkins University.

SECTION 3. FINDINGS AND PURPOSES.

  1. FINDINGS: Whereas
    1. The Procedural Rules allow SGA members to report disciplinary infractions to the Secretary, who will then inform the Internal Affairs committee of a reported infraction.
    2. The Internal Affairs committee will then investigate and may assign disciplinary marks depending on the legitimacy and serenity of the case.
    3. A member of the SGA with three disciplinary marks against them in any given semester will be automatically subject to an impeachment trial.
    4. The Procedural Rules do not specify when or if to notify the Accused of the alleged infractions.
    5. The Procedural Rules do not include a process for overriding or modifying disciplinary marks.
    6. The Procedural Rules do not specify the scope of the impeachment trial.
    7. The Procedural Rules do not specify protected actions that senators may always take without fear of accruing a disciplinary mark.
    8. The filing of disciplinary infractions, assignment of disciplinary marks, and impeachment proceedings against/of Senator Aarshi Lamichhane between 11/03/2026 and 11/10/2026 raised serious concerns regarding the lack of detail for the current disciplinary mark system as described in the Procedural Rules, in the discretion and sole power to assign disciplinary marks granted to the Internal Affairs committee, and in the assigning of a disciplinary mark for a valid motion under Robert’s Rules.
  2. PURPOSES: Therefore, this act aims to:
    1. Update the disciplinary mark system to address the above grievances.
    2. Update the disciplinary mark system to guarantee proper notification for the Accused.
    3. Update the disciplinary mark system to allow for the overriding of disciplinary marks.
    4. Update the disciplinary mark system to clarify and narrow the scope of the impeachment trial.
    5. Update the disciplinary mark system to protect certain legitimate actions from wrongly incurring disciplinary marks.

SECTION 4. AMENDMENTS

PROCEDURAL RULES
CURRENT LANGUAGEPROPOSED LANGUAGE
10. Accountability10.1. Disciplinary Mark System10.1.1. A member of SGA may accrue disciplinary marks for not performing their duties as a senator or not following the rules set forth in the Bylaws and this Rules Bill, and is subject to investigation by the Internal Affairs. Reasons for such marks include but are not limited to:10.1.1.1. Not completing action items from a meeting10.1.1.2 Not submitting an update by the weekly deadline to the Student Body President’s Cabinet. This also applies to Cabinet members.10.1.1.3 Disclosing the contents of closed sessions or other known to be confidential information.10.1.1.4. Not submitting meeting minutes10.1.1.5. Disruptive behavior in meetings, including but not limited to speaking without permission, distracting other members, or improperly using technology10.1.1.6. Misusing SGA resources, including but not limited to abuse of email access, connections with administration, and access to SGA purchases.10.1.1.7 Any other behavioral or procedural infractions that the Internal Affairs Committee may deem as severe enough to warrant a Disciplinary Mark.10.1.2. Disciplinary marks are calculated per academic semester and do not carry over (i.e. fall and spring).10.1.3. Any SGA member may report disciplinary infractions to the Secretary, who will keep a record of the reasons for and number of marks against a senator. The Secretary will then inform the Internal Affairs committee of the reported infraction.10.1.4. Any person with conflict of interest will be removed from the investigation and related processes.10.1.5. The record of disciplinary infractions will be publicly available on the SGA website.10.1.6. Consequences10.1.6.1. After due investigation, the Internal Affairs committee may give disciplinary marks ranging from 0-3, in increments no smaller than 0.5 disciplinary marks, depending on the severity of the case.10.1.6.1.1. First, the legitimacy of the complaint necessitating disciplinary marks shall be determined through a majority vote of members of the Internal Affairs committee.10.1.6.1.2. The amount of disciplinary marks will then be assigned through a majority vote of members of the Internal Affairs committee. In the case no majority is reached, the individual shall be assigned the number of disciplinary marks equal to the lowest value which received the highest plurality of the Internal Affairs vote.10.1.6.2. A record of the disciplinary marks assigned for given infractions shall be maintained by the Internal Affairs committee to allow for standardization.10.1.7. A member of SGA with three disciplinary marks against them in any given semester will be automatically subject to an impeachment trial.10.1.7.1 For every two disciplinary marks after the first three, the member of SGA will automatically be subject to an impeachment trial.10.1.8. Disciplinary marks cannot be accrued during a medical or family emergency leave.10. Accountability10.1. Disciplinary Mark System10.1.1. A member of SGA may accrue disciplinary marks for not performing their duties as a senator member of SGA or not following the rules set forth in the Bylaws and this Rules Bill, and is subject to investigation by the Internal Affairs. Reasons for such marks include but are not limited to:10.1.1.1. Not completing action items from a meeting10.1.1.2 Not submitting an update by the weekly deadline to the Student Body President’s Cabinet. This also applies to Cabinet members.10.1.1.3 Disclosing the contents of closed sessions or other known to be confidential information.10.1.1.4. Not submitting meeting minutes10.1.1.5. Disruptive behavior in meetings, including but not limited to speaking without permission, distracting other members, or improperly using technology10.1.1.6. Misusing SGA resources, including but not limited to abuse of email access, connections with administration, and access to SGA purchases.10.1.1.7 Any other behavioral or procedural infractions that the Internal Affairs Committee may deem as severe enough to warrant a Disciplinary Mark.10.1.2. Disciplinary marks may not be assigned for actions protected or legitimized by the Constitution, Bylaws, Procedural Rules, Roberts Rules, or actions reasonably interpreted as legitimate or necessary for the functioning of the specific member of SGA or the SGA as a whole.10.1.23. Disciplinary marks are calculated per academic semester and do not carry over (i.e. fall and spring).10.1.34. Any SGA member may report disciplinary infractions to the Secretary, who will keep a record of the reasons for and number of marks against a senator member of SGA. The Secretary will then inform the entire Internal Affairs committee and the Accused of the reported infraction in a timely manner.10.1.4.1. Each accusation shall be made by 1 (one) singular member of SGA against 1 (one) singular member of SGA. Each accusation shall contain a reason for said accusation. The aforementioned information, along with the date and time the accusation was submitted, shall be recorded.10.1.4.2. A member of SGA shall not have a disciplinary infraction considered for an instance that has previously been considered.10.1.4.3. The Chair, Co-Chair, and Vice Chair of the Internal Affairs committee shall then contact the Accuser and the Accused to duly investigate the alleged infraction. This process may include personal accounts from involved parties, evidence, and any other method the Internal Affairs committee deems proper or necessary.10.1.45. Any person with conflict of interest will be removed from the investigation and related processes. This includes, but is not limited to, the Accuser and Accused.10.1.56. The record of disciplinary infractions will be publicly available on the SGA website. This record shall be updated to include the decision by the Internal Affairs committee and whether any assigned mark(s) were overturned or modified by the Senate at a later time.10.1.67. Consequences10.1.67.1. At the next Internal Affairs committee meeting after due investigation, the Internal Affairs committee may give disciplinary marks ranging from 0-3, in increments no smaller than 0.5 disciplinary marks, depending on the severity of the case.10.1.67.1.1. First, the legitimacy of the complaint necessitating disciplinary marks truthfulness of the alleged infraction shall be determined through a majority vote of members of the Internal Affairs committee.10.1.67.1.2. The amount of disciplinary marks will then be assigned through a majority vote of members of the Internal Affairs committee. In the case no majority is reached, the individual shall be assigned the number of disciplinary marks equal to the lowest value which received the highest plurality of the Internal Affairs vote.10.1.67.2. A record of the disciplinary marks assigned for given infractions shall be maintained by the Internal Affairs committee to allow for standardization.10.1.7.3. The Internal Affairs committee shall then, in a timely manner, notify the Secretary, President of the Senate, Vice President of the Senate, the Accused, and the Accuser of the disciplinary mark(s) assigned for each reported infraction, and whether an impeachment trial was triggered.10.1.7.4. At the next SGA General Body Meeting after a decision has been made regarding a reported infraction, the Chair of Internal Affairs, along with other members of the Internal Affairs Committee as the Chair sees fit, shall report to the SGA during Non-Legislative Business on the alleged infraction(s) and decision(s) reached.10.1.8. Disciplinary marks may be overturned or modified by a ⅔ (two thirds) supermajority roll call vote of the entire membership of the Senate.10.1.8.1. The overturning or modification of a disciplinary mark shall be initiated by motion. The motion may only be made by a Senator and must be seconded. The motioner must specify whether the motion will overturn or modify the disciplinary mark, and how it would modify said mark.10.1.8.1.1. The member of SGA who accrued the mark and the member of SGA who reported the infraction may not motion to overturn or modify a disciplinary mark.10.1.79. A member of SGA with three (3) disciplinary marks against them in any given semester will be automatically subject to an impeachment trial.10.1.79.1 For every two disciplinary marks after the first three, the member of SGA will automatically be subject to an impeachment trial.10.1.9.2 An impeachment trial triggered by the accrual of disciplinary marks shall be scheduled for no earlier than one week, and no later than three weeks, unless tabled by a motion of the Senate, after the accrual of the triggering mark.10.1.810. Disciplinary marks cannot be accrued for any inaction during a medical or family emergency leave.

SECTION 5. ACTION ITEMS.

  1. To be done by Secretary Honora Muratori before 11/24/2026:
    1. Amend the Procedural Rules Appropriately

The Amendment is hereby ADOPTED/LOST by a vote of X to X with X abstentions.

Upon passage, we have hereunto set our hands and caused the seal of the Senate to be affixed to this bill indicating the Senate’s assent and thus officially designated the bill’s adoption as law.

Signatures of Enactment:

__________________________________ Sumire Sumi Student Body President of the Johns Hopkins SGA
__________________________________ Shreemann Patel Student Body Vice President of the Johns Hopkins SGA
__________________________________ Jazzlyn Fernandez President of the Senate of the Johns Hopkins SGA
__________________________________ Honora Muratori Student Body Secretary of the Johns Hopkins SGA
__________________________________ Amy Xu Student Body Treasurer of the Johns Hopkins SGA
__________________________________ Grace Guan Student Body Chair of Programming for the Johns Hopkins SGA

Signatures of Ceremony:

__________________________________ Cole Liazos-Coffey Chair of Internal Affairs
__________________________________ Demarri Dosunmu WSE Senator