JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

SGA Benchmarking

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

STUDENT AFFAIRS FORUM

Associated Student Government Structures

Custom Research Brief

Research Associate

Tara Patel

Research Manager

Nalika Vasudevan

February

2013

Education Advisory Board

2445 M Street NW • Washington, DC 20037Telephone: 202-266-6400 • Facsimile: 202-266-5700 • www.educationadvisoryboard.com

LEGAL CAVEAT

The Advisory Board Company has made efforts to verify the accuracy of the information it provides to members. This report relies on data obtained from many sources, however, and The Advisory Board Company cannot guarantee the accuracy of the information provided or any analysis based thereon. In addition, The Advisory Board Company is not in the business of giving legal, medical, accounting, or other professional advice, and its reports should not be construed as professional advice; in particular, members should not rely on any legal commentary in this report as a basis for action. No assumption that any actions described herein would be permitted by applicable law or appropriate for a given member’s situation. Members are advised to consult with appropriate professionals concerning legal, medical, tax or accounting issues, before implementing any of these tactics. Neither The Advisory Board Company nor its officers, directors, trustees, employees and agents shall be liable for any claims, liabilities, or expenses relating to (i) any errors or omissions in this report, whether caused by The Advisory Board Company or any of its employees or agents, or sources; or (ii) any third party’s use of this report, or (iii) any recommendation or judgment by The Advisory Board Company or (iv) failure of member and its employees and agents to abide by the terms stated herein.

The Advisory Board Company is a registered trademark of The Advisory Board Company in the United States and other countries. Members are not permitted to use this trademark or any other Advisory Board trademark, product name, service name, trade name and logo, without the prior written consent of The Advisory Board Company. All other trademarks, product names, service names, trade names, and logos contained within these pages are the property of their respective holders. Use of other company trademarks, product names, service names, trade names, and logos or images of the same does not necessarily constitute (a) an endorsement by such company of The Advisory Board Company and its products and services, or (b) an endorsement of the company or its products or services by The Advisory Board Company. The Advisory Board Company is not affiliated with any such company.

IMPORTANT: Please read the following:

The Advisory Board Company has prepared this report for the exclusive use of its members. Each member acknowledges and agrees that this report and the information contained herein is confidential, the property of and proprietary to The Advisory Board Company. By accepting delivery of this Report, each member agrees to abide by the terms as stated herein, including the following:

  1. The Advisory Board Company owns all right, title and interest in and to this Report. Except as stated herein, no right, license, permission or interest of any kind in this Report is intended to be given, transferred to or acquired by a member. Each member is authorized to use this Report only to the extent expressly authorized herein.
  2. Each member shall not sell, license or republish this Report. Each member shall not disseminate or permit the use of, and shall take reasonable precautions to prevent such dissemination or use of, this Report by (a) any of its employees or agents (except as stated below), or (b) any third party.
  3. Each member may make this Report available solely to those of its employees and agents who (a) are registered for the workshop or membership program(s) of which this Report is a part, (b) require access to this Report in order to perform their jobs, and (c) agree not to disclose this Report to other employees or agents or any third party. Each member shall use, and shall ensure that its employees and agents use, this Report for its internal use only. Each member may make a limited number of copies, solely as adequate for use by its employees and agents in accordance with the terms herein.
  4. Each member shall not remove from this Report any confidential markings, copyright notices, and other similar indicia herein.
  5. Each member is responsible for any breach of its obligations as stated herein by any of its employees or agents.
  6. If a member is unwilling to abide by any of the foregoing obligations, then such member shall promptly return this Report and all copies thereof to The Advisory Board Company.

Table of Contents

I. Research Methodology ............................................................ 4    Project Challenge .................................................................... 4    Project Sources ......................................................................... 4    Research Parameters .................................................................... 4

II. Executive Overview ................................................................. 5    Key Observations ....................................................................... 5

III. Associated Student Government Structure .............................................. 6    Types and Organization of ASGs .......................................................... 6    ASG Composition the Selection Process ................................................... 8    Decision-making Process ................................................................. 11    ASG Advisors ............................................................................. 12

IV. Implementation ....................................................................... 13    Transition Process ........................................ Error! Bookmark not defined.    Accountability ........................................................................... 13

V. Assessment .............................................................................. 14    Metrics for Assessment ................................................................... 14    Methods for Assessment ................................................................... 15

I. Research Methodology

Project Challenge

Leadership at a member institution approached the Forum with the following questions:

  • What are the branches within the associated student government structure? What are the responsibilities of each branch?
  • What are the individual positions and responsibilities within the associated student government? How do positions represent different constituencies on campus?
  • What is the selection process for student government members?
  • What is the decision-making process for the associated student government?
  • What methods do administrators employ to hold student government members accountable?
  • What are the roles and responsibilities of full- and part-time staff members who work with the associated student government?
  • What metrics do administrators consider to evaluate their associated student government?

Project Sources

The Forum consulted the following sources for this report:

  • Advisory Board's internal and online research libraries (www.educationadvisoryboard.com)
  • Contact institution Web sites
  • National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) (http://nces.ed.gov/)

Research Parameters

The Forum interviewed student government advisors and student activities directors from five public institutions:

A Guide to Institutions Profiled in this Brief

Institution

LocationApproximate Institutional Enrollment (Undergraduate/Total)TypeClassification

University A

Mountain West2,500 / 3,300PublicMaster's Colleges and Universities (medium programs)

University B

Pacific West14,200 (all undergraduate)PublicAssociate's--Public 4-year Primarily Associate's

University C

Mountain West4,700 / 5,300PublicMaster's Colleges and Universities (medium programs)

University D

Pacific West5,400 / 6,200PublicMaster's Colleges and Universities (medium programs)

University E

Pacific West13,800 / 14,900PublicMaster's Colleges and Universities (larger programs)

Source: National Center for Education Statistics

©2013 The Advisory Board Company

Education Advisory Board

2445 M Street NW • Washington, DC 20037Telephone: 202-266-6400 • Facsimile: 202-266-5700 • www.educationadvisoryboard.com

II. Executive Overview

Key Observations

Associated student governments (ASGs) differ from traditional student governments because they participate more directly in decision-making and budgeting for student life and activities. Contacts define the term “associated” to mean frequent student government involvement with institutional, state, or system decision-making bodies such as the board of trustees, student activity fee committees, or board of regents. In contrast, traditional student governments focus solely on student-led programs, events, and representation of student concerns. Contacts observe a large presence of associated student governments in the western United States (US) and project that statewide or system-wide higher education organizations may explicitly refer to “associated student government” in their constitutions or bylaws.

ASGs reflect the US federal government structure (i.e., an executive, representative, legislative, and judicial branch) or a non-profit or corporate board structure. ASGs under both models address student concerns, approve budgets for student organizations, and oversee special projects such as sustainability or diversity initiatives. However, ASGs with a non-profit board model oversee student life programs that typically fall under the purview of the student life office. In contrast, student life administrators typically manage these programs under the federal government ASG model. ASGs with a non-profit or corporate board model consist of an elected board of seven directors that each manage a functional area (e.g., student life, business operations, diversity, etc.) and vote on ASG initiatives. Additionally, a senate serves as an advisory or research group for the board.

ASGs increase member accountability to their roles through contracts, monthly or weekly discussions about responsibilities, and salaries. ASG presidents refer to concrete responsibilities (e.g., numbers of missed meetings, number of missed deadlines, etc.) and establish deadlines for improvement with members who fail to meet expectations. ASG members at University B, University D, and University E receive yearly or hourly salaries depending on job responsibility and time devoted to ASG tasks. The student activity fee funds salaries. Salaries encourage all student demographics to apply for ASG positions since lower-income students can prioritize student government over traditional jobs.

ASG advisors or presidents conduct individual and organization performance assessments through 360 degree reviews, event summaries, and student satisfaction surveys. In a 360 degree performance review, each ASG member completes a self-evaluation and assesses a group of members with whom they frequently interact. They assess individual performance on designated responsibilities and progress towards project goals, as well as overall organization achievements and effectiveness. Event summaries determine the success of an event in meeting goals such as number of attendees. Student satisfaction surveys gauge general student concerns and allow the ASG president to identify which campus constituents (e.g., academic year, residence hall, college, etc.) are most and least engaged with ASG initiatives.

III. Associated Student Government Structure

Types and Organization of ASGs

ASGs with a Federal Government Structure Prioritize Student Concerns and Representation

ASGs at University A, University B, and University C align with a federal government structure and consist of an executive board, student senate, and judicial board. Contacts note that the federal government structure allows for large student representation because decisions depend on votes from 15 to 30 senators who represent different campus constituencies and input from an executive board. The following diagram models the ASG from University A and reflects the other ASG structures.

Federal Government Structure

Judicial BranchExecutive BoardLegislative Branch
Chief Justice2 JusticesPresident3 Vice-Presidents (VPs)Chief JusticeSecretary22 Senators
Committees: Diversity, Student Concerns, Sexual Harassment, Academic, Public Relations
• Approve constitutional amendments• Sit on student conduct boards• Ensure the constitutionality of executive board and legislative member actions*• Direct the government, oversees decision-making, and ensures commitment to the campus community• Vice-presidents or the chief justice lead committees• Ensure representation of the institution's constituents• Vote on ASG initiatives• Committees conduct research, and bring awareness to campus concerns

*The judicial branch at University B also oversees the election process. The judicial branch at University C solely manages the impeachment process for executive board members.

ASGs with a Non-Profit or Corporate Board Structure Prioritize Student Concerns, Quick Decision-Making, and Efficient Operations

The ASG at University E adheres to a non-profit or corporate board model and consists of an elected board of directors that each manage a functional area (e.g., student life, business operations, diversity, etc.) and vote on ASG initiatives. Additionally, a senate serves as an advisory or research group for the board. Each vice-president board member manages a program director that oversees a student life office, such as the women's center, disability outreach, the recycling center, and day care.

Similar ASG functions between both models include organization budget approval and oversight of projects that address student concerns. However, the non-profit board model also manages responsibilities that would typically fall under the purview of a student life office, such as a women's center or queer resource center. Contacts note that a non-profit board model allows for quicker decisions because of less input, fewer options for amendments, and

© 2013 The Advisory Board Company

Education Advisory Board

2445 M Street NW • Washington, DC 20037Telephone: 202-266-6400 • Facsimile: 202-266-5700 • www.educationadvisoryboard.com fewer rounds of voting. In addition, the board model delegates distinct responsibilities and reporting lines to the ASG president, vice-presidents, office coordinators, and student staff of student life offices (e.g., women's center, disability outreach, etc.). In contrast, a federal government model consists of several councils that manage broader areas such as sustainability and activities and consist of senators who do not directly report to a specific executive board member.

University D borrows elements from both the federal government structure and the non-profit board structure. For example, while the student senate votes on ASG initiatives, the executive board directs student initiatives such as a food pantry and book exchange.

The following diagram models University E's ASG.

Non-Profit or Corporate Board Structure

Board of Directors

President

6 Vice-presidents that oversee activities, academics, business operations, diversity, governmental affairs, and student life

14 Student Senators

  • Act as an advisory and research group for the board of directors
  • Represent student views and can initiate projects

Directors of Program Areas

(e.g., representation and engagement, sustainability, research and outreach, etc.)

  • Report to a vice-president

Coordinator of an Office

(e.g., recycle center, women's center, disability outreach center, queer resource center, equipment shop, etc.)

  • Report to a program director

Committees

(e.g., budget, steering, technology referral, etc.)

  • Represent student views
  • Consist of senators and students at large

Councils

  • Are chaired by board members and consist of program directors, office coordinators, and student employees
  • Set policies and budgets for areas such as facilities and activities

ASG Composition: the Selection Process

Senators in the Federal Government Model Represent Campus Constituencies as They Structure and Vote on ASG Initiatives

Student senators form committees to divide and streamline the workload around core areas of concern such as student organizations and campus-wide events. Student senators may also write referendums or recommendations in support of campus policies.

Student senates consist of approximately 15 senators and none of the profiled senates require that students fill senate capacity. Student senators typically represent academic years and colleges. The following table outlines representation requirements in student senates. The ASG at University D only requires a residence hall association representative, but previously required representatives who lived on- and off-campus as well as students from the College of Liberal Arts and the College of Education, the largest campus colleges. However, ASG administrators found that senators did not represent the concerns of their specific constituencies and too few students were interested in serving the ASG to ensure representation from each group.

Representation of Campus Constituencies

InstitutionNumber of SenatorsRepresentation
University A30 maximum(elected or appointed)• 4 Senators at large• 3 Senators each from the School of Arts & Letters, School of Business, School of Math, Science & Technology, School of Education (12 senators total)• 3 First-year senators• 2 Faculty senators, who cannot be faculty advisors• 2 Non-traditional student senators• 2 Senators from the School of Graduate Studies• 1 Senator from the Student Athletic Advisory Committee• 1 Senator from Activity Board• 1 Senator from Student Media• 1 Student Trustee• 1 Representative from each active, funded club
University C15 maximum• 2 First-year senators• 2 Senators from the city branch• 1 Senator from the Graduate School• 11 Second-, third-, or fourth-year senators
University D15 maximum1 Representative from the Residence Hall Association
University E14Students senators represent college and academic years
University B4No representation requirements

Vice-Presidents Manage Areas of High Student Concern, such as Sustainability, Finance, and Student Activities.

At University E, vice-presidents directly manage concrete program areas with assigned offices. For example, they oversee the sustainability program area, which includes the environmental center. In contrast, vice-presidents in the federal government model manage broader areas of student concern that are not aligned with an office or center.

Presidents at University D appoint students to all vice-president positions; presidents must appoint a vice president of business and finance but retains discretion over the titles of vice-presidents they appoint. This structure allows presidents to focus on changing areas of student concern and pursue their own student government agenda, which may vary from previous presidents. Presently, directors include public relations; state and federal affairs; multicultural affairs; student organizations, sustainability outreach, and gender and sexual diversity. The following table outlines the roles and responsibilities of executive board members in federal government ASG models.

Roles and Responsibilities of Executive Board Members in the Federal Government Model

TitleInstitutionResponsibilities
President(elected)All• Oversees ASG and presides over meetings• Serves as a liaison between ASG and institution, statewide or system-wide boards
Vice-President (VP)(elected)University C,University D• Presides over the Senate• Develops agendas and records meetings
VP of Internal Affairs(elected)University ACoordinates and oversees committees and clubs
VP of External Affairs(elected)University AServes as a liaison between the ASG and statewide organizations, such as a board of trustees
VP for Finance orBudget Officer orBusiness Manager(appointed)All• Maintains ASG ledgers• Manages ASG financial transactions• Oversees ASG funds• Advises executive board and senate on financial matters
SustainabilityCoordinator(appointed)University C,University D• Promotes and coordinates sustainability events• Oversees the sustainability account
VP for StudentAffairs and Pluralism(appointed)University BEnsures priority of student concerns and diversity of representation
Political ActionOfficer (appointed)University COversees senator election process
Student ResolutionOfficer(appointed)University CAids students through the grade appeal or student complaint process

Presidents or Vice Presidents Serve as Liaisons to Institutional Organizations or Statewide Organizations

Presidents and vice-presidents represent the student voice as they offer input and vote in governance bodies. The vice-president of external affairs at University A serves as a liaison to the board of trustees and communicates pending legislative affairs to students.

This president at University C represents and votes for the institution's ASG at the state ASG meetings, which is under the purview of the Montana Board of Regents. The ASG at University D works with the State Student Association, which consists of public schools and a few community colleges, to collectively advocate for educational issues such as tuition equity. The State Student Association organizes lobbying logistics, and the president and director of state and federal affairs serve on the board.

ASGs Fill Positions Through Election, Appointment, or Petitions

ASGs require that potential presidents and vice-presidents campaign together on a ticket to create a common platform and foster a collaborative team approach once in office.

Selection Process for ASG Members

Method and PositionsReason
ElectionPresident, vice-president, senatorsElected positions represent the voice of the student body, votes on initiatives, or external representation of the student body at institutional or statewide meetings.
Appointment by President or Vice-PresidentBudget officers, vice-presidents for specific areas, coordinatorsAppointed positions manage a specific area of student concern and require specialized skills. Contacts note that elections may eliminate qualified students who are not popular with students or who do not possess successful campaigning skills. In addition, the president or vice-president work closely with appointed positions and are more likely to manage work streams efficiently if they select their teammates.
Petition and Appointment or Internal Electioncoordinators, directors, senatorsSome positions require a petition of 50 to 100 signatures, depending on the institution, to qualify for appointment or an internal ASG election. These positions often represent student concerns but also require specialized skills and compatibility with the current ASG.

Decision-making Process

ASGs Receive Student Concerns Through Website Portals, Open Meetings, or Informal Senator Meetings

Any ASG member may initiate debate over a student concern, such as requests for more campus lighting or more campus parking. However, students at large may voice concerns through the following methods:

  • Website Portals: University D includes a link on their student website portal to a form in which students submit their concerns.
  • Open ASG Meetings: ASG senates and executive boards each meet approximately once a week. ASG senates may open their entire meetings to students at large or allocate an open forum in the beginning of each meeting.
  • Senator Meetings: Senators actively solicit student concerns from their constituent base. Senators may speak informally with students or meet with students at committee meetings.

After the ASG receives a student concern, members of the ASG conduct research and vote on initiatives. However, the length and voting members differ between the federal government and non-profit board models.

Decision Process in a Federal Government Model

  1. ASG receives student concern.
  2. Executive board or senate funnels student concern to the relevant committee or council.
  3. Relevant committee or council conducts research on the student concern.
  4. The process then proceeds according to the nature of the concern:
    • If the student concern necessitates debate or revision of ASG policies, the relevant committee or council proposes a recommendation based on research.
      • The senate hears the recommendation and may amend the proposal, ask for further research, or move to vote.
      • A simple majority in the senate passes an ASG initiative.
    • If the student concern involves lack of knowledge of existing rules or services, the committee or council communicates the relevant rule or procedure to the student.

At University E, the board of directors addresses student concerns in two week segments: the ASG conducts research in the first week and the board of directors votes and solidifies an action plan in the second week.

Decision Process in a Non-Profit Board Model

  • Week one: ASG receives student concern
    • Week one to two: Relevant senator committees conduct research and provide a recommendation, and board member develops a proposal.
      • Week two: A simple majority in board of directors passes the ASG initiative.
    • Week one to two: Board of directors provides quick notifications to students if they believe the concern does not necessitate debate or research.

ASGs Lobby for Overall ASG Budget Increases and Allocate Student Organization Fees

The president and/or vice-president of finance vote on institutional boards that budget student activities fees, such as the student activities fees committee or the board of trustees. Once the ASG receives an overall budget, the financial committee, chaired by the vice-president of finance, reviews the annual budget, allocates money for internal ASG purposes such as salaries or events, and distributes fees to organizations based on the organizations' petitions and finance committee votes.

ASG Advisors

ASG Advisors Oversee Weekly Senate and Executive Board Meetings, Answer Process Questions, and Offer General Advice

ASG advisors typically include two faculty advisors and one student affairs administrator. Advisors are often most knowledgeable about the policies and changing dynamics of student government processes because they participate in the student government longer than students who typically leave every four years. Advisors may also coordinate trainings, approve budget requests, and organize travel arrangements. Advisors do not attend individual committee or council meetings because those meetings are primarily for discussion and do not require oversight.

At University E, the Director of Student Activities manages all student program areas and provides direct support to the ASG board of directors and select committees and councils that support areas such as student activities, sustainability, and student events. Professional student affairs staff work for program areas that require expertise, such as the radio center, or involves risk, such as the outdoors center.

IV. Implementation

Transition Process

Transitions Occur Over Five to Ten Years and Depend on a Fair Election Process to Generate Student Support

Contacts suggest creating and modifying a strategic plan for the ASG over the course of five to ten years; students’ input will allow the strategic plan to reflect the changing purpose and structure of the ASG. Although all ASGs at profiled institutions have not recently transitioned to a new ASG model, contacts recommend the following strategies to transition to a new structure:

Study System or State Regulations

Consider stipulations set by statewide or system-wide boards, such as number of required monthly meetings, voting stipulations, and responsibilities of liaisons to external boards or organizations, such as the board of trustees.

Solicit General Student Opinion

Gather opinions from students at large through surveys and open forums to generate a sense of ownership of the ASG. Emphasize the role of ASG in organizational budget determinations and student life decisions. Contacts recommend that the existing student government manage the meetings, while advisors oversee and attend the meetings.

Create a Fair Election Process

Impose strict campaign funding measures to encourage participation from all student demographics and install electronic voting systems to increase response rates and prevent fraud or tampering. Contacts at University B note the first few elections determine the tone of future elections and subsequently influence general student buy-in to the ASG system.

Accountability

Increase Member Accountability Through Signed Contracts, Job Training, and Salaries

The federal government structure allows for a system of checks and balances since the judicial board can review constitutionality of actions and each branch participate in impeachment or oversight procedures of other branch members. All contacts stress that ASG presidents organize individual meetings with problematic members to discuss concrete performance objectives (e.g. numbers of missed meetings, number of missed deadlines, etc.), determine methods for improvement, and set concrete deadlines for improvement. ASGs employ meetings with ASG advisors as a last resort to allow for peer-to-peer accountability.

Methods to Increase ASG Member Accountability

Require Signed Contracts

ASG contracts detail expectations and responsibilities, and ASG advisors and presidents ensure members understand responsibilities through conversations about the contract in individual or group meetings.

Solicit Upperclass Student Members

ASGs at University E recruit third- and fourth-year students for the board of directors because these students often possess working experience with organizational boards and are therefore more knowledgeable about the time commitment.

Reinforce Duties During Interviews and Job Training

Appointed ASG members at University E undergo multiple rounds of interviews that forces applicants to consider their responsibilities, goals, and time commitment. ASG members at University B shadow their respective positions in June (one month after elections), attend a four-day leadership retreat in summer, and start job training in early July. Contacts note extensive training prepares students for responsibilities before the start of the academic year.

Compensate ASG Members

Student activity fees fund ASG member salaries, and advisors ensure timesheets accurately reflect hours worked. Contacts note that salaries prevent lower-income students from prioritizing a job over student government. At University B, all ASG members receive $12 per hour and work 16 hours or 19 hours per week depending on the position. The ASG advisor at University D determines wages with the president based on job responsibilities and distributes $100 to $900 per month to each member. At University E, ASG members receive between $6,000 to $13,000 per year depending on responsibilities and length of employment.

Award Course Credits

ASG members at University A receive course credits applicable to their major or a leadership minor. Advisors prevent members from receiving credits if they do not uphold their responsibilities.

V. Assessment

Metrics for Assessment

Measure Student Satisfaction, Project Completion Rates, and Campus Representation to Gauge ASG Success

ASG advisors, presidents, and executive board members gauge ASG success by assessing the following metrics:

  • General student satisfaction: What is the overall student satisfaction level with ASG in regards to addressing student concerns, hosting events, and managing organizations?
  • Club and organization satisfaction: What is the satisfaction level of clubs and organizations that interact with and receive funding from the ASG?
  • Member learning objectives: What learning outcomes should members attain by the mid- and end-points of their ASG careers?
  • Campus representation: Do all major campus constituents possess ASG representation? If not, what methods exist to allow constituents to easily voice concerns?
  • Project completion rate: How many projects or initiatives did the ASG complete per term? What was the success level of these projects?
  • Event attendance: How many students attended ASG-hosted events?

Methods for Assessment

Measure Individual and Organizational Performance through 360 Degree Reviews

ASG members receive an evaluation for their individual performance and participate in evaluations to gauge the overall success of the ASG's performance. ASG advisors, presidents, and executive board members execute the following methods to gather data to assess ASG success:

Methods for Assessment

Individual Performance AssessmentOrganizational Performance Assessment
360 Degree Performance ReviewsEach ASG member completes a self-evaluation and assesses a group of members with whom they frequently interact. Evaluations are based on a set of learning objectives and position goals and include Likert scale questions with areas for open-ended comments. Evaluation areas measure individual execution of position responsibilities and contribution to organizational goals. Advisors gather evaluations to ensure confidentiality, aggregate data, and deliver feedback to members in individual meetings. Advisors at University A and University E deliver general themes from feedback and focus on areas for improvement; while ASG advisors at University B deliver raw data of Likert-scale questions so students can immediately discount any outliers.360 Degree Performance Reviews
Individual performance Reviews with Advisors or PresidentsEach ASG member meets weekly or monthly with ASG advisors or the ASG president to review progress on projects and raise areas of concern. ASG advisors and presidents applaud achievements and emphasize positive feedback as well as areas for improvement.Program and Event SummariesBefore each project or event, ASG members establish concrete goals, such as participant learning outcomes or attendance. ASG members collect feedback at programs and develop program summaries to review in the ASG meeting following the program or event.Student Satisfaction SurveysASGs survey students at large. Senators conduct constituent meetings to allow constituents to ask questions and offer feedback.

© 2013 The Advisory Board Company

Education Advisory Board

2445 M Street NW • Washington, DC 20037Telephone: 202-266-6400 • Facsimile: 202-266-5700

STUDENT AFFAIRS LEADERSHIP COUNCIL

Structuring an Efficient Student Government

Custom Research Brief • November 17, 2009

EDUCATION ADVISORY BOARD

RESEARCH ASSOCIATE

Cindy Hong

RESEARCH DIRECTOR

Jennifer Yarrish

TABLE OF CONTENTS

I.    Research MethodologyII.   Executive SummaryIII.  Overview of SGAsIV.   Student Government Association ProfilesV.    Implementing Change

THE ADVISORY BOARD COMPANYWASHINGTON, D.C.

I. RESEARCH AND METHODOLOGY

Project Challenge:

Student Affairs leadership at a private University. A college approached the Council with the following questions:

  • What is the organizational framework for student government organizations?Who is represented by the student government? Which branches and committees comprise student government associations?
  • What are the eligibility requirements for serving as an executive board member?
  • How do student government organizations review their constitution and bylaws?Is there a formal review process? If so, how often does this process take place and who is involved in the review?

Sources:

During the course of the research, the Council searched the following resources to deepen our understanding of student government organizations:

  • Education Resources Information Center (ERIC) http://www.eric.ed.gov
  • The Chronicle of Higher Education http://chronicle.com
  • The American Student Government Association: : http://www.asgaonline.com
  • Council for the Advancement of Standards in Higher Education General Standards:http://www.cas.edu

Research Parameters:

  • The Council reached out to advisors of student government organizations at liberal arts colleges in the Northeast.
  • The Council also reached out to institutions that have instituted significant change to their student governments.

I. RESEARCH AND METHODOLOGY

A Guide to Institutions Contacted

InstitutionLocationClassificationStudents: Undergraduate Total
College ANortheast: Fringe townBaccalaureate Colleges--Arts & Sciences1,800 (2,150)
College BNortheast: Small cityBaccalaureate Colleges--Arts & Sciences1,800
College CNortheast: Remote townBaccalaureate Colleges--Arts & Sciences1,900
College DMid-Atlantic: Small cityBaccalaureate Colleges--Arts & Sciences1,500 (2,300)
University ANortheast: Large cityResearch Universities (high research activity)18,550 (25,850)
University BSouth: Large cityResearch Universities (high research activity)6,650 (12,100)
College ENortheast: Small cityBaccalaureate Colleges--Arts & Sciences2,748 (3,150)

II. Executive Summary

  • Student government associations at contact institutions tend to follow a typical structure including an executive branch and a legislative branch, with committees reporting to at least one of the branches. However, variations in SGA structure tend to reflect student body culture. For example, the student body decided to make all students official members of the SGA at College A in the 1960’s to reflect a communal culture. In contrast, University A’s powerful presidency reflects a need for a recognizable leader at a school where many students study off-campus for a semester or more
  • Contacts note a trade-off between SGA size and efficiency. Larger legislatures may include representatives from each residence hall as well as representatives for each class. Larger SGAs lend greater legitimacy to the student government because more students are involved in it. At the same time, larger SGAs can also slow down the deliberation process.
  • Executive boards consist of four to nine members. The size of the executive board depends on the number of vice-presidents, who oversee committees.
  • Student clubs commonly receive funding from the SGA through a rigorous application process. Contacts report that clubs must submit a written request, and then make a presentation to a budget committee. While students sometimes think this is a bureaucratic process, it reduces the number of poorly attended events.
  • Student government budgets typically fund: the SGA office, almost all student organizations, and school-wide concerts and programs. SGAs limit the funding of food, community service events, and speaking fees resources to ensure an adequate distribution of funds across all student groups.
  • To promote responsibility within the student budget committee, the SGA institutes a rigorous selection process for the committee. One strategy to preserve institutional memory from one committee to the next is to require one tenured student to be on the committee at all times.
  • Some institutions have a separate programming board to focus expertise. However, one unanticipated drawback is that student clubs sometimes do not know which group—the programming board or the budget committee—to approach for funds.
  • Media organizations are often exempt from the budgeting process to ensure that they receive steady funding. Media organizations typically receive set annual operating budgets.
  • Club sports typically do not fall under SGA purview. Contacts report that the Athletics Department oversees club sports due to its greater expertise and funds.
  • An appointed parliamentarian officially submits amendments and bills to the SGA legislature. All SGA members may submit amendments and bills to the Parliamentarian, who then present these amendments and bills to the SGA for approval.
  • Typical roles for advisors include: facilitating better communication between the SGA and the administration, providing feedback, assisting with financial processes, and ensuring compliance with university policies. Because the advisor’s influence depends on SGA receptiveness, contacts note, one tactic to increase receptiveness is to build up trust through transparent communication.

III. Overview of SGAs

Structure and Organization

Student governments range in size depending on the representation of the legislature. While smaller legislatures may have a few at-large students, larger legislatures often allot seats to each residence hall, class, and special interest constituencies such as student organizations. Contacts note that a trade-off exists between the legitimacy and democratic representation offered by larger legislatures, and the efficiency and expertise offered by smaller legislatures. Contacts recommend balancing these elements.

EfficiencyExpertise from a more dedicated legislature

Smaller legislatures

RepresentationGreater legitimacy due to greater visibility

Larger legislatures

Programming

At most contact institutions, the SGA is the steward of all student activities fees. A portion of these funds is dedicated for specific groups such as the programming board and media organizations to ensure consistent funding from year to year. The chart below depicts a typical allocation of funds.

Total SGA Budget

Allocation

Percentage

Programming Board

15%

Media Organizations

15%

Budget Committee Discretionary Funds

67%

SGA Office

3%

III. OVERVIEW OF SGAS

Role of the student budget committee

SGAs at contact institutions each have a budget committee that distributes funds to requesting student groups. Contacts indicate that one key challenge facing the formation of the SGA is ensuring fairness in the funding process for all student groups. SGAs have devised several ways to address this challenge.

Ensuring Fairness…

…by adding representation to the budget committee

University B expanded its budget committee to forty students to include representatives from each type of student group. Subcommittees of ten each focus on a specific category of club such as arts, multicultural, or political.

…by limiting expenditures

College B, College D, and University A place strict restrictions on funds requested by excluding food, community service events, and giveaways. They also value collaboration.

College E confines club spending for specifically requested items. The SGA monitors spending through an online PeopleSoft system. This allows the SGA to reclaim funds that are not spent for a designated purpose.

…by evaluating similar events against each other when considering funding

University B and College E group events into categories, such as multicultural, music, political, etc. so that events are only evaluated against other similar events.

University A creates “buckets” of funds for events of different cost. For example, one $5,000 bucket pays for all events under $100 while another $5,000 bucket pays for all events from $100-$500.

…by leveraging expertise

College E builds expertise within the budget committee by ensuring that at least one person on the committee has a semesters’ experience at all times. This is accomplished by having off-cycle elections for the committee.

III. OVERVIEW OF SGAs

Role of the advisor

SGA constitutions at contact institutions stipulate that advisors ought to provide advice to SGA members; serve as a liaison between the student government and administration, and serve as an ex-officio member at SGA meetings. In addition, constitutions also specify that advisors serve at the pleasure of the SGA. As such, the extent to which an advisor can assist the SGA depends on the SGA’s receptiveness. To increase receptiveness, advisors recommend giving the student government relatively more decision making power, while assisting with a few areas in which the SGA may need external help:

Guide the SGA on how to approach administrators

Advisors may improve SGA efficiency by guiding them toward specific administrators for their specific needs. This prevents members of the SGA from going directly to the president for all matters. University A’s SGA advisor liaises between student government members and administrators to maintain strong relations between the two groups.

Serve as a sounding board to the SGA

Contacts recommend that advisors should be open to communication with the SGA and use both formal and informal means to provide feedback when asked. The advisor at University B reports serving as a “sounding board” to the SGA. At College C the advisor meets regularly with the SGA president to provide feedback.

Review risk management

Contacts cite that risk management should be the responsibility of staff from the student activities office, not the advisor. At University A, the advisor has the responsibility of ensuring that student events are in compliance with university standards. For example, the advisor works with University A’s ski club to ensure that its members sign waivers before ski trips.

Assisting in the transition from year to year

Because it’s possible for the SGA membership to change every year, the advisor traditionally assists in the transition between SGAs. This is especially important at institutions where SGA members may leave for study abroad.

IV. STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION PROFILES

College B

The College B Student Government (CBSG) uses a representative model, characterized by a large student assembly consisting of members from each residential hall.

Background

The CBSG formerly consisted of a larger assembly with representatives from residence halls as well as representatives from each club. There was no executive council. This structure was re-examined in 2006 when some students noted that meeting decisions came to reflect the arbitrary selection of club representatives who chose to attend the meeting. Student club leaders and the CBSG worked together to condense the structure. While the student body did not object to the condensed structure, the change did alienate a population of the student body that was once more active in the student government.

College B Student Government

Organization Structure

Executive Council → Representative Assembly

Executive Council

  • President
  • VP of Student Committees
    • Committee on Committees
  • VP for Student Clubs
    • Organizational Review Board
  • Treasurer
    • Budget Committee

Representative Assembly

  • Chair
  • 5 representatives per class
  • 1 representative from each residential house and hall
  • 1 representative from among off-campus students
  • Secretary
    • Publicity Committee
  • Parliamentarian
    • Elections and Judiciary Committee

Student Government Components

Component

Description

Executive Council

• The Executive Council consists of five members, elected by the entire student body each spring, with the exception of the Parliamentarian. He/she is appointed by the Council.• Restrictions: Any member can only hold one officer position at a time• The Council appoints and heads the student committees of the CBSG• Executive Council members are not compensated for their services

Representative Assembly (RA)

• Serves as the legislative body of the CBSG.• Consists of: five representatives from each class, elected through a class-wide election; one representative for each 50 students from each residential hall, elected by each hall; one representative for each 50 off-campus students, elected by those students.• Restrictions: Must be a full-time College B student; can only hold a position in one branch

Committees

Student Committee on Committees: Consisting of seven students, responsible for selecting students for Student and Student/Faculty Committees, and for oversight of the same.Elections and Judiciary Committee: Consisting of seven students, responsible for organizing and conducting all elections run by the Student Government. It is only open to RA members.Organizational Review Board: Consisting of seven students, responsible for the approval and recognition of student clubs.

IV. STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION PROFILES

Parking Committee: Consisting of seven non-E-Council students, this committee is responsible for conducting the parking lottery, hearing parking appeals, and overseeing student parking violations.

Publicity Committee: Consisting of eight members, it's responsible for all publicity and public relations functions of the CBSG; open only to members of the RA.

Budget Committee: Consisting of seven members, responsible for disbursement and oversight of the Student Activities Fund and approving budgets for Student Government-recognized clubs.

Budget Process:

  • Step 1: In March of each year, student organizations submit budgets for the year
  • Step 2: Clubs defend budgets to the budget committee over a weekend
  • Step 3: Budget committee makes final decision on the following Monday

Restrictions on funds: Funds may not be used for alcohol, promotional merchandise, community service projects, events that are not open to the entire student body, and donations, or payments for services.

Exceptions: Student media organizations and the programming board receive fixed budget each year.

Benefits of the Structure

  • Creates a dedicated group of students who sit on the Executive Council
  • Less arbitrary decision-making

Challenges of the Structure

  • Less of a participatory government than before; clubs are no longer represented within the student government
  • Because the CBSG is now a smaller group, it has less of a presence on campus

Programs and Events

Clubs Under SGA Purview

  • The CBSG oversees all student organizations with the exception of club sports
  • Club sports fall under the purview of the Athletics Department

Programming Board

  • A separate Programming Board receives 1/3 of the student activities funds at the beginning of each year
  • It operates autonomously, granting funds for larger events

Constitution and Bylaws

Reviewers

  • Parliamentarian and Elections and Judiciary Committee (EJC)

Process

  • Members of the RA may submit bills and amendments to the EJC
  • The EJC reviews bills before presenting them to be voted on by the RA
  • The EJC performs a yearly review of the constitution.
  • The Parliamentarian may also add constitutional review any time to the EJC agenda.

Advisor

Who Serves

  • An assistant dean of students advises the CBSG.

Key Responsibilities

  • Overall, very hands-off because the CBSG typically likes to be independent
  • No formal meetings between advisor and CBSG; does not attend CBSG meetings
  • Does not having voting power on the CBSG

IV. STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION PROFILES

College D

The College D Student Government Association (SGA) uses a representative model that consists of representatives from each class, student clubs, and residential halls.

Background

College D re-structured its SGA recently to combine some overlapping entities and to create new groups to produce expertise. Some changes include eliminating a “House Council” that represented residential students and creating the programming board.

College D Student Government Association

Organization Structure

Executive Board → Legislature

Executive Board

  • President
  • VP of Public Relations
    • PR Committee
  • VP for Financial Affairs
    • Finance Committee
  • VP for Student Action
    • Student Action Committee
  • VP for Student Clubs
  • VP for Social Events
    • Social Committee
  • Secretary
  • Treasurer
  • Parliamentarian

Legislature

  • 4 Class Presidents
  • 12 At-large Representatives
  • 4 Commuter Representatives
  • Student Club Representatives
  • 5 Judicial Board Advocates
  • 1 Representative per House
  • Student Club Representatives
  • House Council VP for Marketing and Public Relations

Other bodies shown:

  • Academic Honor Board
  • Student Judicial Board

Student Government Components

Executive Board

  • The Executive Board is elected by the entire student body each spring, with the exception of the Parliamentarian. He/she is appointed by the Legislature. The parliamentarian is a non-voting member.
  • The President serves on the school wide College Council and meets monthly with the College D president.
  • The Executive Board decides the process by which committee members are chosen.
  • Restrictions: Must be a full-time undergraduate student; at least 2.5 GPA; cannot be on disciplinary probation; cannot simultaneously serve as editor-in-chief of any student publication or as director of the radio station.

Legislature

  • Consists of representatives for each class, residential house, student clubs, in addition to at-large members.
  • Restrictions: Must be a full-time undergraduate student with at least a 2.0 GPA; must be part of the constituency he/she is representing.

Academic Honor Board and Student Judicial Board

The Academic Honor Board and the Student Judicial Board shall function autonomously under the Academic Honor Board and Student Judicial Board guidelines as found in the Student Handbook and the Appendix of this Constitution.

  • Social Committee: Works with the Vice-President for Social Events and the Program

IV. STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION PROFILES

Committees

Coordinator, of Student Activities to plan social activities sponsored by the SGA. The Social Committee is composed of elected representatives from each house and any interested portion of the Legislature.

Student ActionCommittee: Plans and organizes formal student actions (e.g., petitions, protests, walkouts) as prescribed by the Legislature. Membership is open to all students and is appointed by the VP for Student Action.

Public RelationsCommittee: Composed only of members of the Legislature, the committee is responsible for publicizing SGA events and creating press releases.

FinanceCommittee: Consists of members of the Legislature who are chosen by the VP for Financial Affairs.

Budget Process:Step 1: Clubs must bring a petition for an event to the Finance CommitteeStep 2: Finance Committee makes a decision at a weekly meetingStep 3: Successful petitions are brought to the Executive Board, which grants final approvalCriteria for funds:− educational, social, cultural, or recreational value− demonstrated past performance of the club− co-sponsorship with other clubs and organizations− open to the entire student body− Does not fund food

Benefits of the Structure

• The large Executive Board prevents burn-out• The large Executive Board is more productive.

Challenges of the Structure

• The large Executive Board includes many voices; not everyone is satisfied with every decision

Clubs Covering

• The SGA does not oversee most club sports• In order to be covered by SGA funds, a club must demonstrate activity every semester

Programming Board

• This new organization receives 15% of the SGA budget at the beginning of each year to allocate for school-wide events such as concerts and formals.• Lead by the VP for social events and advised by the office for student engagement

Reviewers

• Parliamentarian

Process

Step One: Any member of the Legislature may submit a bill or amendmentStep Two: The Parliamentary presents bills to the LegislatureStep Three: The Constitution may be amended by a 2/3 majority in the LegislatureStep Four: The Constitution must be ratified by a 2/3 majority of the student body.

Who Serves

• Designated by the Associate Dean of Students• Typically a staff member from his office

Constitutional Responsibilities

• Serve as non-voting member of the Executive Board and Legislature.• Meets with the SGA President weekly while the college is in session.• Attends meetings of the Executive Board and Legislature and advise the bodies as needed.

Additional Roles

• Intra-group conflict management• Advises the SGA as to the most efficient way to approach the administration.

IV. STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION PROFILES

College C

The College C Student Government Association (SGA) uses a representative model that consists of representatives from each class and residential halls. Its unique structure also positions committees as a separate branch of government.

Background

College C has recently restructured its SGA to reflect the objectives and values of a newly implemented student affairs strategic plan. Its goals are to expand opportunities for leadership. Changes include adding class presidents to the President’s Council and replacing guidelines with broad principles for program funding requests.

College C Student Government Association (SGA)

Organization Structure

  • Executive Board
    • President
    • Vice President
    • Treasurer
    • Parliamentarian
    • Publicity Chair
    • Webmaster
    • Club Liaison
    • Administrative Assistant
  • President’s Council
    • 2 Class Presidents per class
    • 1 dorm president per residence hall
    • Director of Campus Life
    • 2 Faculty advisors
    • Invited non-voting members
  • Committees
    • Judiciary Committee
      • 5 students
      • Ex-officio: President, VP, Dir. Campus Life
    • Finance Committee
      • SGA Treasurer
      • 1 student per class

Student Government Components

Executive Board

  • All members of the Executive Board are elected, with the exception of the Administrative Assistant who is appointed by the President.
  • The Administrative Assistant is a paid position.
  • The President and Vice-President serve as student representatives to the College C Board of Trustees.
  • Restrictions: Must be a full-time undergraduate at College C; cannot be on disciplinary probation.

President’s Council (Legislature)

  • Voting members consists of all Executive Board members and representatives from each class, residence hall, and the Director of Campus Life.
  • The Council may invite advisors and other student leaders to attend meetings.
  • Restrictions: Must be a full-time undergraduate at College C.

Judiciary Committee

This committee handles academic disciplinary cases. Five students appointed by the Executive Board serve on this committee and elect their own chair.

Ad hoc committees

The SGA may host ad hoc committees on issues of current student interest. Past committees include room draw and the integration of outdoor education.

IV. STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION PROFILES

Committees

Finance Committee: This committee allocates student activities fees and is composed of the Treasurer and one student per class, whom he selects through an application process.

Budget Process:

  • Step One: Clubs file a student organization funding proposal form
  • Step Two: The Finance Committee meets with the organization’s representative.
  • Step Three: The Committee decides on funding by a majority vote

Guiding Principles for Using Funds:

  • On-campus events that’s open to the entire student body
  • Includes an educational component
  • Involves faculty and other campus constituencies
  • Involves collaboration amongst different student organizations

Exceptions: The Senior Class, student newspaper, radio, yearbook, and outing club receive yearly budgets at the beginning of the year.

Benefits of the Structure

  • The inclusion of class presidents gives the SGA a more complete representation
  • Larger number of participants provides opportunities for student leadership

Challenges of the Structure

  • Because elections are in the fall, there’s a late start to the beginning of each year.

Clubs Covered

  • All student organizations fall under the SGA for financial support
  • Clubs must prove activity each year to remain recognized. Clubs need a constitution and at least four members to be recognized.

Programming Board

  • A non-SGA-affiliated Programming Board receives a separate budget from the Office of Student Activities.
  • The Programming Board plans and oversees larger events

Constitution and Privileges

Reviewers

  • The entire President’s Council

Process

  • Step One: A constitutional referendum may be called by either a majority vote of the President’s Council or by a petition of 200 students of the student body
  • Step Two: An amendment is approved by either a unanimous vote of the President’s council, or by majority vote of the student body in a special election
  • Step Three: Ratification requires a 2/3 majority vote of the student body with at least 50% of the student body participating.

Advisor

Who Serves

  • Director of Campus Life; also advises the student media organization

Constitutional Responsibilities

  • Sits on the President’s Council

Additional Roles

  • Regularly communicates with the President and President’s Council
  • Assists the SGA to stay connected with students
  • Provides feedback to the SGA so they can set and meet goals

IV. STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION PROFILES

University A

University A’s Student Government Association (SGA) uses a representative model that consists of representatives from each class and residential halls. It uniquely includes an independent judicial branch, which hears student disciplinary cases.

Background

University A’s SGA has made an effort to create a greater presence on campus in recent years by launching a new website and soliciting student input. As such, the SGA has created new Executive Branch positions to increase the number of officers communicating with students.

University A Student Government Association (SGA)

Organization Structure

  • Executive Branch
    • President
    • VP for Student Affairs
      • Assistant VP
    • VP for Academic Affairs
      • Assistant Vp
    • VP for Administration and Public Affairs
      • Assistant VP
    • VP for Financial Affairs
      • Assistant VP
    • VP for Student Services
      • Assistant VP
    • Parliamentarian
    • Administrative Assistants
  • Student Senate
    • Secretary
    • Student Affairs Board
    • Student Center Governing Board
    • Academic Affairs Committee
    • Administration and Public Relations Committee
    • Budget Review Committee
    • Financial Affairs Committee
    • Elections Committee
    • Student Services Committee
    • At least 15 Special Interest Senators
    • University Health Services Advisory Board
    • Student Affairs Committee
  • Student Hearing Branch

Student Government Components

Component

Description

Executive Branch

- The President and Vice Presidents are elected from within the Student Senate. Presidential candidates must have Senatorial status for at least 20 weeks; Vice Presidential candidates must have Senatorial status for at least 15 weeks.- Assistant Vice Presidents are appointed by Vice-Presidents.- Vice-Presidents chair their respective committees.- The VP of Student Services serves on a university-wide board for health services and the Student Center Governing Board.- Restrictions: Must be a full-time undergraduate in good academic and judicial standing.

Student Senate (Legislature)

- Voting members are representatives of student constituencies directly elected by each respective constituency (i.e. residential hall, class, and student organizations).- Special interest senators represent large student organizations, such as a theater group.- Senators must serve on at least one SGA committee.- Restrictions: Must be a full-time undergraduate in good academic and judicial

IV. STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION PROFILES

standing

Committees

Academic Affairs: Chaired by the VP for Academic Affairs, it also includes the Assistant VP and Senators. It addresses issues that fall within the jurisdiction of the Provost.

Administration and Public Relations: Chaired by the VP for Administration and Public Relations, it also includes the Assistant VP, Secretary, and Senators. It oversees programming.

Financial Affairs: Chaired by the VP for Financial Affairs, it also includes the Assistant VP and Senators. The committee addresses financial aid, and university-wide financial issues.

University Health and Counseling Services Board: Chaired by the VP of Student Services, it comprises 4 Senators, 2 at-large students, and university administrators.

Nominations and Elections: Chaired by the Parliamentarian, this committee comprises the VP for Administration and Public Relations and Senators. It organizes and executes elections.

Student Affairs Board: Chaired by the VP for Student Affairs, it comprises four Senators and five members of student groups, plus the Associate Director for Student Activities as a non-voting member. The Board recognizes student groups and reviews changes to the Constitution.

Student Affairs Committee: Chaired by the VP for Student Affairs, this group comprises the Assistant VP for Student Affairs and Senators. The Committee liaises between students and University officials on student life issues.

Student Center Governing Board: Chaired by the VP for Student Services, the Board comprises four Senators, an Assistant VP, two at-large students, seven additional students representing various constituencies, and administrative representatives.

Student Services: Chaired by the VP for Student Services, includes an Assistant VP and Senators. The committee addresses student concerns over services such as dining and parking.

Budget Review: This committee allocates student activities fees. Chaired by the VP for Financial Affairs, it also comprises six Senators and two students at-large. The budget is divided into “brackets” of $5,000 each for events of different sizes.

Budget Process:

Step One: Clubs submit a program request six weeks before the eventStep Two: Clubs make a program request presentation to the committeeStep Three: The committee makes a decision within five days of the presentation

Criteria to Receive Funds:

  • Must be open to the entire student body
  • Community service events must be on campus to receive funds
  • Will not fund human resources or political activities endorsing a candidate

Exceptions: Some groups, including media organizations, are eligible for annual budgets.

Benefits of the Structure

  • The Executive Board consists of a group of dedicated students with student government expertise
  • Large size allows for many students to participate in SGA.

Challenges of the Structure

  • There are few checks on the President, since he is elected from within the Student Senate
  • Presidential power may create some conflicts amongst Board members.
  • Less student involvement outside official Senate roles
  • The SGA risks alienating the student body if it does not seek out student opinion

Clubs Under SGA Purview

  • All clubs except club sports fall under the purview of the SGA
  • Club sports are managed by the Athletics Department

Program—ming

Council for University Programs (CUP)

  • The CUP organizes large, school-wide events such as concerts
  • The CUP's budget also comes from student activities fees, and is budgeted at the beginning of each year.
  • Clubs may approach either the CUP or the SGA for funds.

Reviewers

  • All members of the Senate may submit legislation for review.

© 2009 The Advisory Board Company

14

IV. STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION PROFILES

Process

• Senators may submit a proposed amendment a week or more in advance of a Senate meeting to the Executive Board• The amendment is placed on the meeting agenda• Amendments are approved and put into affect with a 2/3 majority Senate vote

ADVISOR

Who Serves

• A full-time faculty member of the university• A co-advisor is appointed by the executive; must also be a full-time faculty member

Constitutional Responsibilities• Provide advice and guidance to the SGA• Serve as a liaison between the SGA and Faculty and Administration• Oversee the counting of ballots at SGA elections• Serve as ex-officio member on all SGA boards and committees; attendance is not mandatory

Additional Roles• Oversees risk management issues involving student clubs• Works with students to ensure smooth transitions between different Executive Boards

IV. IMPLEMENTING CHANGE

Several contact institutions have recently examined and restructured their student government associations. Contacts offer four key recommendations:

1. Seek student input

Advisors suggest that student input form the basis for any changes made to the SGA’s structure. Both recognized student leaders and non-SGA students should be consulted. In many cases, student leaders prompted the restructuring by identifying opportunities for increased efficiency.

2. Seek input from other campus constituencies

Administrators outside of student affairs should also be consulted because decisions may affect the entire campus. Important constituencies include faculty, the college relations office, and the controller’s office.

3. Communicate objectives

It’s important to establish clear objectives early in the procedure with everyone involved.

4. Allow ample time for the entire process

Changes in the structure of the student government may take up to a year as the appropriate constituencies are consulted and amendments are made to SGA constitutions.

Spotlight: A Task Force for Change

College D created a task force to examine ways to restructure the student government association. Task force members included: two members of the student activities office, the previous year’s SGA, non-SGA students, the controller, student life administrators, and legal counsel.

The task force hired an outside facilitator for its first meeting, when it established the clear objective of examining the club structure of College D to maximize the benefits for students.

College D’s SGA advisor recommends communicating early and inviting pro-student government administrators to join the task force.

Spotlight: Change Based on a Strategic Plan

College C revised its SGA structure to meet the goals of its new student affairs strategic plan, which calls for the broadening of leadership opportunities and civic engagement in student life. Because the plan was issued by the Office of Student Affairs, that office led the move to re-examine College C’s student organizations, including the SGA.

To communicate the objectives of College C’s student affairs strategic plan, the Office of Student Affairs took its staff on a retreat.

Staff members consulted with student leaders throughout the entire process by inviting them to meetings. The SGA advisor claims that such outreach fostered positive student response.

PROFESSIONAL SERVICES NOTE

The Advisory Board has worked to ensure the accuracy of the information it provides to its members. This project relies on data obtained from many sources, however, and The Advisory Board cannot guarantee the accuracy of the information or its analysis in all cases. Further, The Advisory Board is not engaged in rendering clinical, legal, accounting, or other professional services. Its projects should not be construed as professional advice on any particular set of facts or circumstances. Members are advised to consult with their staff and senior management, or other appropriate professionals, prior to implementing any changes based on this project. Neither The Advisory Board Company nor its programs are responsible for any claims or losses that may arise from any errors or omissions in their projects, whether caused by the Advisory Board Company or its sources.

© 2009 The Advisory Board Company, 2445 M Street, N.W., Washington, DC 20037. Any reproduction or retransmission, in whole or in part, is a violation of federal law and is strictly prohibited without the consent of the Advisory Board Company. This prohibition extends to sharing this publication with clients and/or affiliate companies. All rights reserved.

Sources

SGA Benchmarking.pdf