Committee on Student Organizations
Meeting Minutes
2/24/17
Attendance:
Present: Pepe, Akshay, Meghna, JB, AJ, Kenneth, Mi, Phipps, Edo
Absent:
Excused: Kwame
Debrief on JHU-GMI (Pepe)- 10min
Group we denied last semester; group wants to start public health initiatives in the community; larger organization that we thought was a grad student org and Clifton’s recommendation was that the org would be redundant to exist on its own
More complicated than we thought
GMI is a Bloomberg initiative that was started with faculty and grad students/ not a student group, has a student interest group through BSPH
More apparent that our idea of group was not what it is
Group wasn’t very clear in the interview; Pepe asked group to contact BSPH
Student contacted grad student, org is not established; not much of a structure; faculty member do research under initiatives name, clear that it’s not a well established org atbsph
Pepe: Wouldn’t be appropriate to have them exist through blOOMBERG
May have to reevaluate this group; might motion to repeal discussion to clarify questions/doubts
Look at notes from group’s interview and minutes
No timeline, but Pepe wanted to table motion until meeting with SO committee
Might come up at meeting next week
Pepe advised them on consulting with PH department
Group is leaning towards creating an org
Review email draft for accepted student groups (Meghna, Edo)- 5min
Draft is in the drive
Added other sources for funding (Res Life, CHEW)
Edo: wanted to look at how SGA can funding
Remove room reservation (not our purpose after group approval)
Pepe: Include link to SGA website and point of contact for information (chair of finance committee)
Pepe: Remove provisional group section; no longer relevant
Reformat document and then pepe will send list of Fall 16 approved groups to send approval doc
Discuss logistics for current group evaluation process (Pepe)- 15min
Words from Aj and Kenny about issues with what was passed last week
AJ: Main concern is developing a solid rubric for eval groups; numerical threshold to set if groups meet criteria 1-5
Akshay: Against numerical threshold; always will be groups who do not fit into our cats.; acapella group would not have met threshold guidelines
AJ: Students want a solid idea
Akshay: For a rubric but against a threshold, decision should be left with us
Phipps: Hard to quantify what a “5” would be; rubric is a good idea
Pepe: Rubric was established last semester; had numeric values; was useful; allowed us to compare percentages, but might not be appropriate this semester for one senator to handle; are we looking for same criteria as new groups for existing groups?
Started with unique mission and plan to establish it/ have groups restate their mission statement/what is your group supposed to do on campus
Will help us figure out what we want in re-registration tab
Add events that your group has done/ add future events that match your mission
Unique experience for members is redundant
Specify which events were member specifics and for the non members
Kirsten: Discovered is that any change we make is gonna have a disproportionate response; not 100% confident of what is happening with all the different groups; discussed in cats. Coordinator meeting goals for this year and next year, will ask question for what they want to know; fear that moving too fast without criteria and guidelines, we’ll have a pretty big backlash; discussion on Tuesday night was great, but made me think that putting groups on notice may be better; evaluations with re-registration; do not mess around with groups funding; maybe put them back on provisional status; provide and set expectations
Pepe: Agrees with Kirsten, but concerned about long term drive of other SGAs
Kirsten: doesn’t want SO to shoot ourselves in the foot
Pepe: Agrees, going through process and collecting information is what is important; thinks that we will find an extreme cases that we won't find ops
Kirsten: and that’s where you say “we’re flagging you”; you’d need to establish that; but just put groups on notice
Phipps: Pepe’s message was misinterpreted
Kenny: If student groups do not respond, SAC denies their request for funding, but they are allowed to reapply; hate to penalize student groups;
Phipps: What is a step in between that?
Kirsten: Freeze their finances
Kenny: SAC will re-write guidelines
Kenny: No problem w/holding funding; wants to know which groups are being withheld to predict how much is left in the monthly budget; funds might not get transferred over until September October;idea is great; red flagging groups is appropriate; only 175 groups ask for grants; if they don’t need funding then why not flag them
Pepe: Haven’t really established a provisional group
JB: We did it my freshmen year
Pepe: If we red flag a group as provisional, we can red flag them
Kenny: How would the group function if they need funding that year?
Pepe: alot of groups function without SAC grants; AJ is running a student group without SAC grant
Kirsten: Issues lay with SAC; outgoing SAC body inherits that issues from last year; several groups that didn’t submit everything on time others had things lost in the works; not all the fault of SAC
Pepe: Always student groups that send in re-registration late; how do we deal with that; agree that this is a concern
Kirsten: if they don’t meet the deadline, then they don’t have to be re-registered
Pepe: including SO in re-registration process through the application
Kenny: If SO gets data, then SAC could use that info for funding requests
Pepe: Application review can be done within a month; should work with CMC to have groups re-register but also make decision on groups that do not submit registration
Kirsten: Part of what is more comforting is knowing what we want in the re-registration form;
Pepe: Vision for it has been discussing extremes; not enough in place to look at every detail right now; we have to start somewhere; if extreme cases come up, not unrealistic to discuss groups
Kirsten: Taking CSC question for all groups; instance where group volunteers with children, if they don’t have the proper training, they’d be flagged.
Pepe: I can see how it comes off scary that we’re doing evaluations
Kirsten: Change reimbursement policy and groups caused a stir; Hopkins groups is being updated with a financial request station; different approval level; Treasurer can approve; SAC can approve
Pepe: What else should we add
Akshay: Persuade groups to combine organizations; a couple of groups have similar ideas
Kenny: If we deem an entity provisional, SAC can still recognize group; could grow monthly grant, but cut off annual grant for group; will shrink annual budget, but can group monthly budget; groups will have to compete, but it’s an idea; will allow group to reform, increase membership; doesn’t go against bylaws amendment; moreso to get groups to realize that we’re doing an internal shift to increase transparency and efficiency
JB: Having SAC and SO work together; great to pair with a senator
Kenny: Pairing with a senator would be a great idea
JB: Making anything we do this semester a test run
Phipps: Making application easier
Kirsten: Hopkins groups will be cleared every year
Kirsten: might have to do some work wit getting information to senate
Pepe: Bylaws makes it clear that groups can be derecognized but not affected annual grant; decision to derecognize group should be appealable, but maybe it should be final?
Phipps: Maybe this makes sense?
Akhay: We have 1/3rd of the Senate;
JB: Maybe making a public transition document
Troubleshooting issues/strengths of Hopkins Groups (JB, Mi, Phipps)- 10min
Tabling until next meeting
Discuss updates on funding tiers initiative (Kwame, Dean, Akshay, Trevor)- 15min
Tabling until next meeting
Go over group category assignments (Pepe)- 5min
Tabling until the process is closer; probably before SPring Break
New Meeting Time: Fridays at 4:30
