JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

PRDC-Smoking

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

SGA PRDC

Research Findings

Smoking Policy Enforcement

October 27, 2018

Midflight Summary

Recent attention—from SGA bills to JHU Newsletter articles—have reemphasized the important role that smoking policy plays in making JHU a healthier environment. The Consortium on Financing Higher Education (COFHE), in which JHU is a member of, provides good comparisons for campuses enforcing similar smoking policies.

For the most part, we found that compliance of smoking policy is very high on similar university campuses. When they do run into barriers, the issues tend to be one of the following:

Not knowing about or being able to find policy information that already exists

Perceptions of unfair implementation (lack of accommodation) or unduly punishment

Understanding who handles enforcement (Residential Life? Security?, etc.)

Not understanding the terminology used (vagueness/outdated info)

We identified four key themes for our recommendations:

Prioritize promoting existing statewide smoking regulations (such as the Clean Indoor Air Act of Maryland)

Address common questions and preconceived notions of existing policy

Use plain and clear language

Make the policy information accessible and feel easy to use

In general we would recommend improving the usability and findability of existing policy rather than creating new ones.

Though 25% of campuses nationwide have gone smoke-free, only about 10% of COFHE schools have done so. COFE campuses that are smoke free include Barnard College & Columbia University (NY), Colby College (ME), Emory University (GA), Grinnell College (IA), Harvard’s Schools of Public Health, Medicine, Dental Medicine, and the Kennedy School (MA), Hope College (MI), Stanford University’s Medical School (CA), University of Rochester’s School of Medicine and Dentistry (NY), Washington University in St. Louis (MO).

What we recommend

1. Use plain language

1.1. Introduce the policy in a way that is easily understandable.

The description on the university-level policies page defines what the smoking policy is. However, a fully precise description may not be understandable by the general public. When deciding between precision and understandability, err on the side of understandability. Test the proposed content to ensure that people understand it. Different options on “No Tobacco Policy” or “Smoke-Free Policy” may confuse people so synthesizing information would be optimal

Priority: Medium | Feasibility: High

1.2. Provide easily accessible and up to date information.

Current results on search engines online have yielded JHU policy published on 1998. The actual policy information is not easily accessible since those interested do not know where to go for this information nor should we expect them to trust information that is so outdated. There are multiple links to tobacco and safety, but it may not be clear to people how it will directly affect them or where to find the most authoritative information.

Priority: Medium | Feasibility: Medium
Very obviously outdated and not authoritative source comes up when searching for Hopkins’ smoking policy.

Sources

PRDC-Smoking.docx