Senate
of the
Student Government Association
of
The Johns Hopkins University
{ S. Resolution 18-19, 05 }
A Resolution Calling for Johns Hopkins to Reform the Office of Institutional Equity
Introduced By: Senator Miranda Bannister of the Junior Class and Senator Madelynn Wellons of the Junior Class and considered this 4th day of December in the Year 2018
Sponsored By: Senator Jennifer Baron of the Senior Class
Senator Kiana Boroumand of the Junior Class
Senator Fatima Bouftas of the Senior Class
President Dean Chien of the Junior Class
Senator Pavan Patel of the Junior Class
Senator Mohamed T. El Gendi of the Junior Class
Vice President AJ Tsang of the Executive Board
Secretary Aspen Williams of the Executive Board
President Noh Mebrahtu of the Executive Board
Senator Ash Panakam of the Senior Class
Senator Nathan Mudrak of the Freshman Class
President Sam Schatmeyer of the Sophomore Class
Senator Alex Forlenza of the Freshman Class
Senator Pritika Parmar of the Freshman Class
Senator Mehak Ali of the Freshman Class
Senator Omar Lloyd of the Junior Class
Senator akshay Bhamidipati of the Senior Class
Referred to the senate by WAIVED which recommends its N/A by a vote of N/A to N/A.
Whereas Section II of the Johns Hopkins Undergraduate Student Government Association’s Constitution states, “The purpose of the SGA is to protect and improve the rights, opportunities, and quality of life for every undergraduate student at the Johns Hopkins University;”
Whereas this resolution refers to the Office of Institutional Equity’s Annual Report of 2017,
Whereas there were 275 cases of sexual misconduct reported to OIE in 2017, few respondents were expelled or removed from the space of those whom they harmed;
Respondents in many fully investigated and closed cases faced alternative punishments, ranging from suspension to mandated counseling;
Only one case closed in 2017 resulted in expulsion;
This calls to question whether or not Johns Hopkins University regards sexual assault or rape as sufficient grounds to expel or even suspend a respondent when there is a preponderance of evidence against them.
Whereas the federal standard set by Title IX seeks for schools to investigate and close cases within 60 days of their being reported, OIE fails to do so in the vast majority of cases that it formally investigates;
The average time it takes to for OIE to close an investigation is 128 days, with a median time of 105 days.
This does not account for those cases which are ongoing and yet to be factored into averages; once factored in, it will show OIE takes far longer than an average of 128 days.
In 2017 OIE closed 27 investigations after formal investigation that were brought forward the former year with an average time of 264 days and a median time of 244 days, which is a clear violation of Title Nine.
Whereas OIE has officially recognized its need for more staff, writing in its own Annual Report (2017), “Although more than half our cases are closed in four months or less, we recognize the need to streamline the process—including simplifying our reports and adding staff to address concerns about timeliness—while continuing our thorough and deliberate approach”;
Whereas multiple members of the Hopkins Administration have denied the need to increase OIE’s staff, in contradiction of OIE’s own assessment in the Annual Report (2017);
Whereas OIE must also streamline its process of investigation in order to reduce wait times;
OIE has also recognized its need to streamline the process and expedite its investigative procedures, saying, “we recognize the need to streamline the process—including simplifying our reports and adding staff to address concerns about timeliness—while continuing our thorough and deliberate approach.”
It’s current procedures currently places a higher burden of proof upon complainants than simply demonstrating a preponderance of evidence.
Whereas unnecessarily long wait times force survivors to endure an emotionally taxing process, risk causing retraumatization and infringe on a student’s education;
Whereas many survivors face trauma from the process of reporting itself;
Whereas long wait times allow serious sexual predators to remain on our campus for more months than necessary;
Whereas the number of reports that OIE receives are increasing year by year, necessitating the growth of the office and the swift reform of procedures;
While OIE received 241 cases in 2016, it received 410 in 2017;
Vice Provost Kumar stated to SGA on November 27th, 2018 that he anticipates a growth in these numbers in the coming calendar year;
Be It Further Resolved that OIE must show its willingness to punish sexual assault and crime on this campus by determining more serious consequences and punishments to respondents against whom there is a preponderance of evidence.
Be It Further Resolved that transparency about how Review Boards determine repercussions and punishments is necessary in order for the student body to understand why respondents with a preponderance of evidence against them face mild punishments in many cases, as the Office of Institutional Equity’s Annual Report of 2017 demonstrates.
Be It Further Resolved that the President Ronald Daniels’ Administration acknowledge the Office of Institutional Equity’s claim in its Annual Report of 2017 that need more staffing in order to streamline the process of investigation and reduce wait times.
Be It Further Resolved that the Administration should add a minimum net gain of seven full time employees in the next calendar year, these being five investigators and two employees under the Vice Provost of Institutional Equity.
Be It Further Resolved that the University set a deadline of no more than two years since the passage of this resolution by when OIE must reduce its average wait-times on cases from the to the sixty days stipulated in Title IX.
Be It Further Resolved that a copy of this resolution be transmitted to President Ronald J. Daniels, Provost Sunil Kumar, Vice Provost Kevin Shollenberger, and Associate Dean Moses Davis.
ADDENDUM A — DEFINITIONS
SGA — The term “SGA” shall refer to the Student Government Association of The Johns Hopkins University.
JHU, Hopkins — The terms “JHU” and “Hopkins” shall refer to the Johns Hopkins University.
OIE — The term “OIE” shall refer to the Johns Hopkins Office of Institutional Equity
Title Nine — The term “Title Nine” shall refer to Public Law No. 92‑318, 86 Stat. 235, otherwise known as the Patsy T. Mink Equal Opportunity in Education Act.
A preponderance of evidence - The term “preponderance of evidence” refers to the evidence required for an outcome in OIE, which depends upon convincing evidence and its probable truth or accuracy, and not on the amount of evidence
Report — According to OIE’s Annual Report of 2017, “Any information brought to OIE may constitute an allegation of sexual misconduct and/or protected category–based discrimination and harassment, including from a complainant, a designated university responsible employee, or a third party. This bill will deal with reports of sexual misconduct.”
Case — According to OIE, “A report becomes an OIE case when it is determined that (1) OIE has authority over the subject matter of the report and the respondent; (2) a complainant is engaged and requests some type of university response, or the information indicates that a response is needed even without their engagement; and (3) OIE has or is able to gather sufficient additional information.”
Formal Investigation — The term formal “formal investigation” is explained thus by OIE’s Annual Report of 2017: “A case will typically proceed to a formal investigation when (1) it could constitute a violation of a policy under OIE authority; (2) a complainant is engaged and wishes to proceed with formal investigation (or, in rare cases, when OIE has a responsibility to take further action even without the complainant’s agreement); and (3) OIE has sufficient information to proceed with an investigation. The investigation will determine whether there has been a violation of policy.”
Survivor — The term “survivor” refers to a person who has experienced sexual assault.
Respondent — The term “respondent” refers to the party about whom a report was made. For the sake of this resolution, it will refer to a person alleged to have committed sexual misconduct not protected-class discrimination and harassment.
Complainant —The term “complainant” refers to the reporting party. For the sake of this resolution it refers to the alleged victim of sexual misconduct, whether reported by the alleged victim or a third party, not the alleged victim of other protected-class discrimination and harassment.
Review Board — The term “Review Board” refers to the three-person group which assess the final report from OIE on a case and determine sanctions. According to OIE’s Annual Report, “After a formal investigation, OIE’s final report provides either a finding on whether there has been a recommendation of such a finding (in cases of sexual misconduct). The report is given to a three-person resolution panel organized by Student Affairs, if the respondent is a student with a recommendation for action if needed.”
