JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

COBYReportonthe2016FallForum

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

SUMMARY REPORT ON THE 2016 FALL FORUM

~ A comprehensive analysis and summary ~

Summary Report on the 2016 Fall Forum

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Foreword: A Thank You :)

Section I: An Overview of the Forum

Planning and Advertising

Attendance

Structure and Technology

Presentations

Questions and Answers

Section II: A Summary and Analysis of the Conversation

Mental Health

Diversity and Inclusion

Section III: Recommendations for Future Forums

Expanding and Continuing the Conversation

Logistics

Technology

Additional Resources

Panopto Recording of the Forum

Forum Presentation Slides

COBY Presentation to the Senate (11/01/2016)

New SGA Website

JHU Newsletter Report on the Forum

PollEverywhere Responses

Foreword: A Thank You :)

First of all, we’d like to extend a hearty thank you to everyone who participated in the Fall Forum. Even though we weren’t able to fill up the room, we had two in-depth conversations that have provided us with meaningful recommendations for future SGA projects and innovative ways of looking at mental health and diversity.

We’d also like to thank all of the SGA members who came to the Forum. They helped keep the room bubbling with conversation and were commendably focused on making sure that everyone in the room felt welcome. We truly appreciate that SGA members were able to attend for the Forum’s entire duration, especially given that it lasted longer than most normal SGA meetings.

While we considered writing this report sooner, we knew that two groups instrumental in the two issues discussed - the Mental Health Task Force and the Homewood Council on Inclusive - would soon have updates that could be relevant to the issues at hand. Updates from those two groups are therefore included in this report as well, including updates to questions that were asked during the Q&A’s.

The report itself is split into three sections: the first on the Forum structure, the second on the Forum’s conversations, and the third on carrying forward the spirit of the Forum. If you have any questions about the report, please feel free to reach out. No matter who you are, we thoroughly hope you enjoy the report and find it useful for planning more projects, legislation, and initiatives!

Sincerely,

The JHU SGA Constitution and Bylaws Committee

AJ Tsang, Chair and Senator for the Class of 2019

Ope Olukorede, Senator for the Class of 2017

Sathvik Namburar, Senator for the Class of 2018

Akshay Bhamidipati, Senator for the Class of 2019

Rushabh Doshi, Senator for the Class of 2020

Section I: An Overview of the Forum

Planning and Advertising

The initial concepts of the Fall Forum materialized in the spring of 2016, after the executive election debate moderator failed to include any questions on diversity and inclusion, and that same moderator rejected student requests to add diversity questions to the debate. Though no official analysis into the event occurred, we posit that the event may have stemmed from a lack of a formal SGA response to the BSU demonstration on the Gilman Quad in November 2015 and a relative lack of diversity and inclusion initiatives from the SGA during the 15-16 legislative session. Moreover, we posit that the event may have been the culmination of student body dissatisfaction with the flow of information from and dialogue with the SGA.

While SGA members have tried very hard to assuage student concerns and reach out, we believed that a direct forum was the most effective means of bridging the divide and ensuring that SGA was more aware of current student concerns. As such, one senator crafted the four-part STAE Transparent Act, of which one provision specified that SGA hold a town hall at least once a semester. The bill was eventually converted into a series of initiatives, of which the Fall Forum was born.

The Executive Board initially directed the Forum’s planning and put forth the idea that the Forum should include presentations on current SGA initiatives. After the Executive Board moved to planning the Blue Jay Tailgate, the responsibility for planning the Forum was shifted back to the Constitution and Bylaws Committee (COBY), where the idea had originated.

COBY decided to re-integrate the town hall concept in the form of a Q&A after every presentation. Detailed planning for the new Forum format began in October 2016. Various schedules were proposed in order to determine the right balance between presentation time and open discussion time. Some schedules were designed to given more time to presentations, others more to discussion. Each schedule was designed to include breaks and overlap time so that discussions would not have to be cut off. For example, here are two schedules that were designed and brought to the Senate for consideration:

COBY also planned to hold the Forum in Mudd 26, a room with ambient lighting, comfortable seating, reliable technology and lots of room for presenters and the audience. To enhance the applicability of the Forum, Senator Tsang designed infographics to illuminate how the SGA functions and where to go with ideas for the SGA. Here are those infographics:

We also created a contact list to ensure that attendees could reach out to SGA members after the Forum.

To ensure that all of SGA was involved in the final decision making, a Forum “options” presentation was made to the Senate on November 1st. The Senate advised us to create a merger of the aforementioned schedules and to move forward with the two infographics. Succeeding polls were also distributed to the Senate.

After the 2016 presidential election, COBY considered adding in time to discuss how to respond. However, knowing that the election was distressing and that the Forum would occur three weeks after a restful healing period (Thanksgiving), it was decided to keep focus on JHU issues.

By the middle of November, COBY began to advertise. We designed two infographic-flyers, one to advertise the location and the other to advertise the reasons to go to the Forum.

We advertised across Facebook and had every SGA member share the event and turn their cover photos into a condensed version of the left flyer. We also printed out both and placed them in all freshmen residence halls. By the night before the Forum, our Facebook event had almost two dozen confirmed attendees (not including SGA) and many people interested. Given that we did not pay for enhanced social media advertising, we consider the number of people reached on Facebook to be fairly decent. Unfortunately, we began advertising fairly late so as not to interrupt people’s Thanksgiving Break. In retrospect, it would have been more effective to begin advertising sooner or to hold the Forum after another week of classes so that more people could be aware of the event via word of mouth.

Attendance

We estimate that there were about 10 to 15 non-SGA individuals in the room across the entire evening. Including SGA members, this number increases to 47. This was roughly comparable to the quantity of attendees at Dean Schlesinger’s October forum for engineering undergraduates, which had about a dozen students attend. However, we know that SGA forums have drawn large crowds in the past: in 2013, an emergency forum was held to discuss an egregious sexual assault at a party near campus. Additionally, annual SGA executive election debates draw audiences of around 50 to 100 people.

We believe that a number of factors contributed to the relative lack of attendees. First, the Forum was initially set for the beginning of November but was pushed back to the end of November so that SGA could first plan its annual dinner with President Daniels and the Blue Jay Tailgate. While this was logistically necessary, it also meant that the Forum would be held during the academic stress period between Thanksgiving and Finals, when students were focused on absorbing the semester’s material and attending review sessions. Moreover, we advertised fairly late and did not use platforms like Instagram, Snapchat, or quad signs.

Structure and Technology

In the end, the merged Forum schedule provided the best of both worlds. While keeping the length of the Forum to two hours, the final schedule apportioned equal time to mental health and diversity and inclusion while giving conversation time a higher priority than presentation time. Each issue would have 15 minutes for presentations, and 25 for conversation. Here is the final schedule as listed on the Forum slides:

We also harnessed technology to make the Forum as visually engaging as possible. The Forum presentation was projected onto all of Mudd 26’s screens and the overall event was recorded with Panopto viewer. Questions could even be submitted via PollEverywhere. To make things even more convenient, we furnished a clip-on mic for every speaker and every attendee asking questions.

Presentations

Each Senator or Exec member was offered a chance to present during the Forum on mental health, diversity and inclusion, or both. Chairs whose committee related to a given subject were directly asked to present. On the issue of mental health, formal presentations were conducted by Senator Sathvik Namburar, Senator Ash Panakam, and Senator AJ Tsang. On the issue of diversity and inclusion, formal presentations were conducted by Senator Tiffany Onyejiaka, Vice President Anna Du, Senator Matt Brown, Senator AJ Tsang. The topics for each presenter were as follows:

The Mental Health Task Force - Senator Tsang

The SGA Health and Safety Committee - Senator Namburar

Counseling Center Syllabus Initiative - Senator Panakam

The SGA Student Services Committee - Senator Onyejiaka

The Inclusive Innovation Space - Vice President Du

The Homewood Council on Inclusive Excellence (HCIE) - Senator Brown and Senator Tsang

Questions and Answers

Following each set of presentations, we held a Q&A period. There were two ways to ask questions: (1) in-person with a mic or (2) via the anonymous question portal. The portal, called PollEverywhere, allowed attendees to text their questions to the moderator and have them automatically appear on screen. Questions could be directed to any presentation or any member of the SGA.

Section II: A Summary and Analysis of the Conversation

Mental Health

The Forum began with a conversation on mental health, the most pressing issue on campus. Senator Namburar presented on the Health and Safety Committee’s current projects, including how they have asked Security to add the Counseling Center as a stop on the freshman security walk. Senator Tsang discussed the Mental Health Task Force and its efforts to evaluate external data from peer institutions and internal data from the school’s mental health services, and how this information will inform recommendations for reform in school policy and services infrastructure. Senator Panakam presented on the Stop the Stigma Ad Campaign and the Counseling Center syllabus addition.

After the presentations, attendees asked questions and engaged in a productive conversation with SGA members. The resultant recommendations and goals of the conversation are summarized below:

Ensure that the Task Force is accountable and that there are procedures to keep them accountable for their recommendations.

Encourage the Task Force to make sure that the Administration follows through on the recommendations it makes.

Ask the Task Force to provide information to the public as quickly as possible and to be as open as possible about how it is developing the recommendations it does.

Encourage the Task Force to:

Distinguish between concrete policies that address structural deficiencies in mental health treatment (ex: changes in Counseling Center staffing) and surface efforts that address symptoms (ex: notification emails).

Have the school administration take a stronger role in enforcing mental health protection policies among academic departments.

One critical example brought up was that of blackout dates. While SGA has lobbied for blackout dates in the past and such dates have been provided to professors, some professors have been noted to ignore these dates.

Make academic pressures more manageable by working with students and faculty to develop more agreeable assessments and learning techniques.

Hold meetings with student groups of underrepresented minorities so that they can be better informed on what is being done and what needs to be done to address mental health.

Decrease the stigma around mental health so that marginalized groups and underrepresented minorities can be more open in their discussion around mental health, especially where data is lacking.

Conduct surveys to determine which groups are most marginalized or least likely to discuss mental health.

One commenter noted significant stigma in East Asian cultures due to the fact that these cultures may not have caught up to the more progressive views in Western cultures about mental health and the biochemical imbalances that cause mental health issues.

Make SGA more proactive in soliciting feedback from marginalized groups and underrepresented minorities through more energetic ad campaigns and outreach programs.

Work with and host events with cultural student groups that represent marginalized groups and underrepresented minorities.

See if SGA can hold meetings with the aforementioned student groups where representatives of the Task Force or the Counseling Center to inspire conversation about mental health.

Connect students with student groups, especially those that may be less advertised, that provide cultural solidarity so that they may more openly or freely discuss mental health issues.

Examples include the Interasian Council, the BSU, and Greek organizations.

Continue advocating for increased resources at the Counseling Center even though they are now at full staffing.

One Counseling Center staff member attested to the fact that if students call the Counseling Center and reports they are understaffed, the Center will be more likely to adopt the view that it needs more staff.

Improve mental health by taking up additional health initiatives, such as the furnishing of feminine hygiene products and the conducting of athletic participation events (“Women in the Weight Room”)

Increase programming for queer and LGBT students, as well as those of all gender identities.

Make the recreation center a more inclusive, accessible, and comforting place for students given that it can play a large role in students’ mental health.

Move toward more inclusive language so that no one feels unwelcome in any context, whether it is the recreation center or a dining hall.

Increase transparency in the services provided to underrepresented groups in the way that has been done by SDS (Student Disability Services), which is hoping to publicize its services more broadly.

Indicate to the Administration that renewed mental health services do not substitute for the loss of covered grades.

Organize freshman group meetings for mental health in a manner similar to that for pre-med advising services.

Make sure that if Counseling Center staff is increased, it is done without leaving excess pressure on the already overburdened counseling staff (on average, a staff member sees 7 people a day and approximately 400 different students pass through the Counseling Center every week).

Encourage the Counseling Center to publicize its emergency services more.

Encourage the Counseling Center to try to keep wait times around 1-1.5 weeks during non-peak times and to be more transparent in current wait times.

Overall, the conversation on mental health indicated a clear dissatisfaction with the state of mental health on campus. Students indicated that cultural stigmas, severe academic stresses, and opaque communication were inhibiting their ability to receive the mental health services they required. Furthermore, there are discrepancies between the reported experience of students and the reported experience of staff. While staff report that enough resources exist, everyday feedback suggests that this is not the case, at least in the eyes of students. On balance, this demonstrates that stigma around mental health and that the negative perception of mental health services constitute some of the largest barriers to resolving the issue.

In response to some of the aforementioned points, we now know that the Task Force is developing a successor organization to continue its work after its final report is published at the end of the year. We also know that President Daniels told the Newsletter that he is committed to follow through on the Task Force’s recommendations as long as they are within the realm of the university’s financial capacity. Conversations with the Counseling Center imply that open appointments are generally available within a week, but misalignments in its schedule openings and students’ own schedules result in higher average wait times.

Diversity and Inclusion

After a five minute break for refreshments, the Forum reconvened to discuss diversity and inclusion. Senator Onyejiaka discussed the upcoming Sanctuary Campus resolution and the Humanities Center resolution. Vice President Du discussed the inclusive innovation space in Remington that will encourage tech innovation among undergraduates, and Senators Brown and Tsang discussed the nascent work of the Homewood Council on Inclusive Excellence (HCIE), the third such incarnation on the Homewood campus since the 1990s.

Afterwards, attendees asked questions and engaged in a progressive conversation with SGA members. The resultant recommendations and goals of the conversation are summarized below:

Grow diversity training to include all classes, not just freshmen.

Conduct pre- and post- surveys to cement the impact of the training.

Avoid resistance to mandatory attendance by figuring out how to make diversity training a more voluntary act where students recognize that it is important for maintaining a healthy community.

Consider conducting the trainings during Freshman Orientation rather than during the school year, when students aren’t able to focus on the issue as much.

Integrate more concrete definitions of marginalized and underrepresented identities as well as more concrete discussions about intent vs. impact.

Encourage the Administration to advance diversity and inclusion as a cause of merit equal to that of “academic freedom.”

Urge the HCIE to:

Develop tangible, short-term goals as soon as possible.

Outline the responsibilities of departmental diversity champions in more detail.

Include the perspectives of not only faculty, but also staff.

Release minutes online as soon as possible, especially since diversity is a public issue.

Release the time, date, and location of HCIE meetings so public input can be included.

Ameliorate retention of faculty from underrepresented minorities.

One presenter remarked that it was a bad sign that all colored faculty could be so easily named on one hand.

Motivate the Administration to endorse student goals for or methods to attain diversity and inclusion (in short, rally the Administration to directly voice its support for student voice).

Add intersectional identity data to the Roadmap to Diversity (ex: not just women and people of color, but women of color).

Administration asserts that the small number of such faculty would make it difficult to stratify data.

Students expressed concern that the omission of this data was an intent to keep the school from looking bad.

Inform students that they can contact administrators about the Roadmap as much as they seek, given that it is open to critiques.

Make student group funding contingent on whether officers attend diversity training.

One precedent for this is how all Greek groups have to undergo BIT training.

Though the idea was shot down in the past because of the young age of the diversity trainings, our speakers encouraged students to write to Dean Martinez to make it happen.

Hold student groups more accountable in general.

Prompt the SGA to attend diversity trainings so as to foster a more inclusive environment.

Stimulate more faculty to become diversity training facilitators with OMA.

Follow up with Dean Saporu to check on the status of the new unconscious bias training for faculty.

Prompt President Daniels to expedite the process of vetting diversity training so that it is more quickly offered to the student body, especially since the atmosphere/results around the trainings appear to be quite positive.

Altogether, the conversation on diversity and inclusion was focused on building diversity training for all students and unifying students and faculty in the journey towards a more inclusive Hopkins. Students expressed a strong desire to see diversity training expanded to all students at the earliest convenience. In order to achieve this, students suggested that student groups lead the way by having their presidents and vice presidents attend diversity training. Presenters also signaled that faculty would need to be a critical component of this movement. Not only would retention rates of underrepresented faculty need to be increased, but more faculty would be needed to train students in cultivating an inclusive, safe environment.

SGA Outreach: Connecting with Students

One pertinent issue that transcended both conversations was that of SGA advertising and SGA outreach to the community. As such, the summary of that part of the conversation is summarized below:

Personalize SGA outreach and develop connections outside established groups.

Encourage SGA members to branch out of their comfort zone and reach out to people they don’t know, especially those who don’t know what SGA is doing.

Encourage SGA members to attend the meetings of other student groups to communicate SGA support for other students and student identities.

Have conversations with individuals in other student groups and offer ourselves as personal points of contact for them.

Revive “What Do You Want Wednesdays,” where students could provide suggestions to SGA in exchange for an Insomnia cookie.

Increase advertising on billboards outside Brody and the Mattin Center.

Increase chalking on pathways.

Increase painting of the Blue Jay statue outside the FFC.

Maintain flyering as a method of grassroots outreach.

Increase publicity/awareness of the SGA legislative process by discussing the effects of the process (for example, tailgates sponsored by SGA or hygiene products provided by a new bill).

Venues for this publicity could include social media and official press releases to the JHU Newsletter and student body.

Enhance class council and committee outreach with surveys.

Towards the end of both discussions, the conversation moved to how SGA can connect with students. The feeling among both was that individual relationships are key, especially in the way that SGA members invest in other student groups. Rather than focus on broad outreach, students signified that SGA should focus on targeted outreach to underrepresented groups.

Section III: Recommendations for Future Forums

Expanding and Continuing the Conversation

The Constitution and Bylaws Committee is proud to say that the Forum was a successful foundation for future forums. Even with low attendance, we demonstrated that SGA forums can run smoothly and foster productive conversation. Indeed, the mere ninety minutes of conversation produced almost two dozen individual recommendations and goals.

We strongly recommend that SGA continue the tradition of semesterly forums. For the next, we recommend that a 2017 Spring Forum be held on either March 7th or March 14th, 2017, right before Spring Break. Since we specifically left out school spirit in the fall to maximize time for mental health and diversity, school spirit should be a topic in the spring. We recommend that Senator Andrew Phipps and President Syed Hossain lead that section in the spring.

Of course, we will still include updates on mental health and diversity in the Spring Forum: after all, the goal of these forums is to not only be a channel of dialogue, but a beacon of progress.

Logistics

We have several suggestions to make the next Forum more efficient. The first is to increase the number of people operating the technology at the front of the room. We should have one person operating the computer, one person taking notes or minutes, and at least two people ready to give out mics to audience members. One SGA member should also be a courier during the Forum so that forgotten items and refreshments can be retrieved.

Food and refreshments should be hidden until the intermission so that students do not take food and then leave at the beginning of the Forum, and so that the food is not inadvertently eaten too early.

A dress rehearsal should be mandated so that speakers know what to say and have an idea of the pressures that may arise during the Forum. Reference material should be handed out at the beginning so people who leave early can still have that information.

Advertising must begin at least two weeks prior to the event. Flyers should be put up at least a week ahead of time, and in both freshman and sophomore residence halls. Flyers in academic halls would aid us too. Quad signs should be designed a month in advance and printed for the week of the event. Social media should be flooded about a week in advance and kept at a constant simmer. Faculty should be notified and invited; one Senator even suggested we invite Provost Kumar given his personability.

Technology

A classroom of the same size should be kept, but each screen should be made to display something different: one should display the presentation, another the notes, and a third the live question stream.

The question livestream should be monitored so that inappropriate questions can be removed. All speakers - presenters or audience members - should speak from a mic. Otherwise, the Panopto recorder will be unable to hear them.

Additional Resources

Panopto Recording of the Event

https://jh.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Viewer.aspx?id=892fca46-f1b4-4ab5-a9ff-b0d0fde2b98c

Forum Presentation Slides

https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1CO5whCl8FYHoaCPIsp4JH25yzX1RVbp0Vt2bBt0pVuk/edit?usp=sharing

COBY Presentation to the Senate (11/01/2016)

https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1IAgDUlwVVDtnwTP8fH3Ebee7sM_LUVkcrxIpsm9WhxY/edit?usp=sharing

New SGA Website Sample

https://jhustudentgov.wordpress.com

JHU Newsletter Report on the Forum

http://www.jhunewsletter.com/2016/12/01/sga-forum-addresses-mental-health-diversity/

Sources

COBYReportonthe2016FallForum.docx