SENATE OF THE JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION
Consolidated General Body Meeting Agenda and Minutes
April 9th, 2019
7:00 PM, Charles Commons East Room
Agendas are set by the Executive Vice President and circulated by the Executive Secretary. Questions regarding the agenda can be directed to Vice President Miranda Bannister (mbannis2@jhu.edu) and Secretary Aspen Williams (awill230@jhu.edu).
Agenda
Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)
Approval of the Agenda & Prior Minutes (1 min)
Reports [SKIPPED — READ IN MINUTES]
New Business (75 min)
JHOC Movie Night Bill [Link] — Senator Gorman (5 min) (Visitors are coming)
Private Police Force Resolution [Link] — Senator Forlenza (20 min)
Sit-In Support Resolution [Link] — Senator Mollin and Senator Boroumand (20 min)
Long-Term Ad-Hoc Committee on Student Center Bill [Link] — Executive President Tsang (5 min)
Campus Idling Resolution [Link] — Senator Mollin (20 min)
Sophomore Class Senator Confirmation — Senator Mollin (5 min)
Prospective Business (5 min)
Advancing Legislation
Announcements
Public Input Period
Adjournment
MINUTES
Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)
Approval of the Agenda & Prior Minutes (1 min)
Reports [SKIP]
Executive Board Reports (4 min)
President Tsang
Community Council Initiative
We met with Provost Kumar last Wednesday to talk further about his perspective on the concept. Supports in spirit, wants to see details about how we can account for perspectives of each campus.
Met with the Bloomberg Student Assembly this afternoon…
Monthly Meeting w/ Vice Provost Shollenberger last Friday
We had our monthly meeting with VP Shollenberger last Friday. One of the points we touched on is the sit-in in Garland. They indicated that, at present, they’re not planning on moving or doing anything to the folks there, and are accounting for health/safety and fire code. The only time they would do anything is if there’s a Code of Conduct issue.
Weekly Exec Meeting Yesterday
Updates on the student center: they’re looping in all offices and departments currently in Mattin to the conversations. Conversations about staff will happen over summer, students in the fall. Folks in Mattin will be moved by summer 2021. All resources currently in Mattin will have a home during and after construction of the student center, in equal. Whether they are in the student center is a separate question, but there will be the potential to build new buildings (possibly in parallel to the student center) do this.
We’re also determining SGA’s set of annual DOSL awards.
Student Affairs is supporting the students at the sit-in in terms of ensuring health and safety.
Faculty Assembly Meeting
Attended yesterday’s spring semester Faculty Assembly meeting with Aspen and Pritika. Meeting had high turnout, filling all of Levering Arellano, as they were discussing the University police proposal.
We presented on the Community Council initiative and updates about SGA across the board, including civic engagement, the student center, and academic affairs.
SGA FY20 Budget
Meeting tomorrow to clarify budgets for both Senate/Exec and SAC.
SGA Alumni Reception
Went great! We had 15-20 alumni attend, and will be entering their info into our alumni database soon. Alumni were usually from the 60s or more recent alumni. Among other things, we learned that some SGA members did participate in some of the protests during the 1960s and that Michael Bloomberg was Student Council President from 1963 to 1964.
Student Center Long-Term Ad-Hoc Committee Bill
Going to the floor in a few moments.
Ethics Board Nominees
Ethics Board will be bringing forward nominees for us to confirm.
SGA/News-Letter Correspondents Dinner
Going back to an idea with its origins in the 2017 Exec election, I spoke with Rudy Malcolm and Diva Parekh about having an experimental SGA/News-Letter Correspondents Dinner, just like the old White House version, before the end of the year. I will personally bankroll some of it!
Surprise Next Week
I have a surprise announcement next week…
Vice President Bannister
AJ’s report above is pretty comprehensive, so I’ll just add a couple things thing about our exec meeting this past Monday.
Calvin mentioned that SLI is looking into how it can support the health and wellbeing of the students in Garland.
We came up with specific criteria/ rubrics for how we would determine the recipients of the SGA awards to give everyone an equal chance and reduce subjectivity.
Chairs, write your transition documents for this coming Sunday
Secretary Williams
Organized gdrive to send to archives
Met with the Sit-in coalition to see how SGA can help them
Presented at HFA
Committee Reports (7 min)
Academic Affairs — Senator Taj
No update
Civic Engagement — Senator Boroumand, Senator Mudrak
Civic Engagement has two resolutions on the floor tonight re: the sit in and private police. We will also be participating in the Earth Day Beyond the Nest event to talk about divestment and the referendum.
Finance — Senator Mays, Treasurer Tu
Health, Safety and Sustainability — Senator Mollin, Senator Patel
Healthy Hopkins Initiative - collecting survey data to measure utilization of program, satisfaction of the program, and effectiveness in improving student well-being. This will culminate in a report to the Dean of Student Life and Director of Athletics.
Tobacco policy - waiting to hear more details about the implementation team
Wellness Week completed. Thanks to Claire and those who helped out for putting on so many great events
Engine idling Bill - sam will be presenting later today
SaveOhno - team sustainability competition (funded by us) is starting April 22nd! Get your friends to sign up, and if you want to participate, make an account and join SGreenA!
Internal Affairs — Senator Baron, Vice President Bannister
No new updates
Student Organizations — President Chien, Senator Elgendi
Thanks to everyone, only 4 out of over over 200 SGA-recognized student orgs did not re-register. The committee will be busy reviewing them. We are also overhauling our entire review process for Fall 2019 in an effort to throughly examine all orgs on campus. Part of this, which we also discussed, will be reforms in supporting the many nebulously supported academic department-recognized groups on campus. Finally, we considered questions about what student entrepreneurship without being a recognized student org looks like.)
Student Services — Senator Cai, President Schatmeyer
No update
Class Council Reports (4 min)
Seniors:
Juniors: BOAT CRUISE. Had class registration breakfast Monday. We’re also figuring out how to blow through our piles of cash, I mean, use the rest of our budget responsibly in benefit of the Junior Class.
Sophomores: Class of 2021 had a phenomenal garden party, working on our last couple of programming including a networking event with the career center and a terrarium making event with the HOP
Freshmen:
Advisor Report (3 min)
New Business (75 min)
Sophomore Class Senator Confirmation — President Schatmeyer (5 min)
Prez of college dems, int in civic engagement
Good grasp of initiatives working on
Hope to confirm
Motion to vote
Voting procedure: unanimous confirmed
Private Police Force Resolution [Link] — Senator Forlenza (20 min)
Senator Forlenza - stats on harms of police force, referendum, Columbia/other schools, hope y’all read the bill, if PF in place, want student voice for it, majority against it, specific procedures publicized on how to go against it
President Chien - motion for mod caucus 45 secs, x mins
My roommate robbed at gunpoint, still voting yes for this resolution
Shivam comfortable sharing story and that squo unacceptable
PPF not answer to this
Senator Baron - Security would’ve helped?
President Chien - robbed at Guilford outside jurisdiction
President Schatmeyer -
Broad based student support for this
Over 75% oppose it, representative body, should be in line with that
Passed by legislators w less voter turnout than we had
Ppl don’t want it, I don’t think we should either
Senator Baron - yield to Calvin
Was legislative body elected at lower rate than ours?
Senator Gianni
Do security not
Senator Gorman
Senator Madelynn: wholly against this idea, ppl with disabilities (50% have disability)
No training w this, least violent person I know
High rates of mental health in homeless population
Senator Panakam
More direct language in resolution
Senator Forlenza
Wording worked out beforehand
Senator Armstrong
Dialog about issue has been quite skewed
Makes it seem like every individual agrees/not agrees with PPF
Don’t want to support a resolution that has less interaction than 50%
Senator Uriah
Even last year, lots opposed, everyone who was vocal against it
Have pushed referendum a lot
Hard to get support, but all the ones who were motivated to vote were against it
Senator Mudrak
Mindful, taking a stance on something yet to take stance on
Have concerns about this but politically, hardline stance, what does this sound like
Hopkins will have MOU and have private police dept
Diff ways to correct issues ppl have been raising
Senator Kiana
Yesterday HFA almost unanimously voted against PPF
When faculty say no, stu gov should not be the ones to say no
Senator Gorman
Nathan’s point resolved by a clause
Want to say no and then try to fix it if it happens
Senator Uriah
Incorrect to assume that we will stop fighting this
Ppl within community still opposing this
We’re coming from place of privilege but most ppl don’t agree w this
Senator Armstrong
Should not pass unanimously just to represent the student body and the way the 30% of people voted
Voting procedure
Roll call: Passes with a vote of 13 yays - 4 nays -1 abstain
Sit-In Support Resolution [Link] — Senator Mollin and Senator Boroumand (20 min)
Senator Kiana
Unionize bc Hop has history of union busting
Have had discussions about/taken decisions on these issues
Rep students, given the obligation of making sure everyone’s voice heard
Senator Mollin
Back up students who fight for same things
Just passed resolutions about stuff they did
Recording stu as they sleep - wtf
Sign in w Jcard → retaliation?
Right to free speech without being prosecuted
Have ways to prosecute under student code of conduct
Disrupting events not respected under free speech, not fair
President Chien
Mod caucus 30 secs, 5 min
Senator Mudrak
Why not to Shollenberger?
Senator Baron
Board of trustees - sounds like just pushing it in there
Senator Schatmeyer - yield to smollin
Nice to endorse everything but open to taking it out, would like to see it in but can take it out
Thoughts, questions, concerns?!
President Habib
Request amnesty - what is that/what is punishment?
Kiana: free of disciplinary action, one of the goals of resolution
Senator Uriah
Board of trustees has been discussed, don’t know what diff is now
If PPF passes, only accountable to board of trustees, not us or community
Senator Armstrong
Referring to harassing others?
Jenn: tours crashed by ppl members of sit in and brunch for alumns and ppl getting awards, very disrespectful
President Schatmeyer
Harassment of students of color or breakfast hmm
Issues really impt, not equitable things
Senator Armstrong
Opposite to the language in the bill
Actions Jenn brought up contrary to that statement
Senator Uriah
One of alumni asked black stu if stu here
Security grabbed stu w flowers as they were trying to get in
Can’t hold stu and officers to diff standard
Senator Barron
Have videos where Daniels trying to talk and they talked over him
Should’ve had a message but just chanting
Not explaining just chanting
Alumni who don’t go to hop now
Senator Uriah
POI: did demands get listed
Prez AJ - chanted and Daniels gave them opportunity to take stage for little bit, later, Ruzicka said events on hold for little bit, for time, knocked on glass for little bit
Extend mod caucus
Extended - cool
Senator Uriah
Getting nitpicky/having issues w disruption
Weeds of what is socially acceptable
Bill as whole though bc just wording, unless ready to pass
Senator Mollin
As Madi said, cause social attention for admin attention
Vacuuming floor every day
V nice to admin
If they can speak, cool beans
Public input period if we want
Senator Baron
V uncomfy saying these are courteous, events show nah
Not all courteous
President Patel
Thanks Sam for writing, putting this together
Senator Kiana
Don’t forget females in the room!!
Senator Panakam
No real criticisms
Explicitly espoused
Senator Mudrak
Came in thinking in favor but concerned to separate harassment and normal
5 min Q+A w the protest peeps
Senator Gianni - POO: back and forth let’s be friends
Senator Forlenza - What exactly doing wrong bro?
Dean Ruzicka said not following directions, health and safety, etc
Senator Uriah - respectful?
Told to be respectful, not taking up too much space, initially outside, not blocking pathways, doorways, etc
Ppl have been strict with cleanup garbage, vacuuming bc living there but not gross
Conscious of impact having on building as a whole
Contact w security and admin: record all convos, ev of how we are talking to them
If seen video, a lot of disrespect on basis of race towards students
Think handled it fairly well
Daniels told us democracy is knowing when decision has been made
Civil disobedience = breaking/pushing rules to go against stakes of uni, so what appears to be disrespect is a cry to be heard
Senator Panakam - highlight disrespect of stu of color
When stu entered, alumn came up to stu of color saying “do u even go here bro?” and they said why does it matter do I not have right to be here, and he continued same q and scrambled to find other rhetoric to remove credibility to their right to be in that space
Senator Baron extends by 3 mins - Public image and how to display self? Why disrupt tours?
Lots of stus here told idealized perception of what hop is like, disservice to not be told, pre-frosh deserve to know, would have had a large impact on decision, would’ve changed my decision
Take all of what doing w stus as disruptive is dismantling the purpose, is not disruptive
Said same stuff at BSU events, answering qs during tour is the same thing
Have gone to Annapolis multiple times also, same content, never seen as appropriate bc it’s the truth
President Chien - how can SGA support you?
At least heard and supported, don’t feel heard → continued disobedience
Perspective is understood, even just being in this room, entire ideology is not completely understood
Need to learn more about why/what/where/how
Not just fighting to fight
Also stus, want an education
Them to us Q + A
Senator Mudrak (the “blonde” one)
“Eric? Or me?” “is eric blonde?!”
Don’t want to get into back and forth but struggle to see how knocking on windows is necessary to get voice heard
Respect university events
Would voice be heard by right ppl? - I mean yeah
Not making big scene works and is equally effective
Some videos or more aggressive/uneasy interactions
Protestor 1
Severity of it? Is it really understood?
At worst, cost us some of our lives
What can we do to have these issues resonate?
We want to be stus here, hard for us, stus already escorted off premises that they live at by BPD
We’re really desperate here
Senator Mo
I understand what’s at stake, affects me too, as others
In general, not sure that everyone understands, not gonna affect me why should I care
Pros and cons need to be more publicized, more FB posts
Talking from hearts resonates more rather than protest that don’t know what about
Senator Mollin - motion to vote (15-2-0) motion passes
Roll call: (12-3-2) pass
Long-Term Ad-Hoc Committee on Student Center Bill [Link] — Executive President Tsang (5 min)
President Tsang - primary representatives
Want to have access to admin
SGA as platform on stu center stuff
Accountable to admin
2024 stu center
No other bc strained resources, interest already (4), lots of support
Arts gc 100
SGA rep
Advisory committee = small, vs ours is safe space (tone policing = no)
President Baron -
Already so many committees, hard to retain membership
Not gonna be here but another committee causes more probs
President Tsang
Have to have membership guaranteed before and most members will be here next year
What kind of faucets go into stu center
Getting more broad info
Senator Uriah
Will this body have any actual authority/Do they want this??
Already have stus here already
And are they required to listen
Prez Tsang
One of cochairs of ad hoc on overall advisory, so feedback goes directly to advisory committee
One of the charges is stu feedback across uni so way to get stu voice
Miranda absorbed time
Voting procedure
Move into voting procedure
Voting - PASS
Ay: 11111111111 (13)
Nay: 111 (3)
Abstain: 1 (1)
Campus Idling Resolution [Link] — Senator Mollin (20 min)
Senator Mollin - chuckles uncomfortably
Police vehicles on campus but like can’t solve
Admin can ignore everything but impt start to convo
Blue Jay shuttle ppl warm by white paper stuff
Timeline: moved back a lot but impt to have some idea
Want this to happen N O W
Talked to some peeps, no response, sad tweet
I did some stuff y’all said, and some stuff I wanted
Q+A+caucus, whatever?
Senator Armstrong - 5 min, 30 secs
Good change of lingo -- cool
Senator Baron - end of spring 2020, not possible
Saying do it more long term
Spring 2021?
Spring 2022?
Senator Mudrak - why feasibility study just police not all?
Can do feasibility study, not opposed to that
Senator Armstrong - mentioned willing to consider other studies, friendly amendment?
Not literally every, just black minivan things, idea is that it isn’t everything
President Habib - switching alternatives, when, cost, who does study?
When = admin if they accept proposal, start convo = purpose, not in existence
Not much else to say: Spring ‘22 for timeframe
“Sups unprocedural dude” - VP Bannister
Vote
Unanimously passes (congrats smollin!)
JHOC Movie Night Bill [Link] — Senator Gorman (5 min)
Senator Mudrak - $250 - too expensive?
No cheaper alternative, specific equipment
Senator Baron - good event, brings lots of ppl to Beach
Senator Mudrak - rain plan
Motion to vote
Voting procedure
Vote
Bill passes
Prospective Business (5 min)
Advancing Legislation
Announcements
Smollin
“I have several”
Come see me run in circles → cool brooo
Wolman movie theater
24th: recycling/equity fair, lots of stu groups, diff facets of it, no giveaways bc not sustainable
VP
Chairs meeting this saturday pls have transition docs
Patel
Movie night w Sig Chi, ResLife, Athletics
Nathan
Special elections
Absentee ballot mb
Smollin again
Thinking
Veep
V dense bills, glad y’all read
Hard w some hiccups but thanks for being patient
Smollin’s back
THE SLEDS ARE HERE!! (just in time for april lol)
Jenn
Not too long winded so gj dudes
Mo
Go check out sit in
Public Input Period
Adjournment
