SENATE OF THE JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION
Consolidated General Body Meeting Agenda and Minutes
October 16th, 2018
7:00 PM, Charles Commons East Room
Agenda
Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)
Approval of the Agenda & Prior Minutes (1 min)
Reports (18 min)
Executive Board Reports (4 min)
Committee Reports (7 min)
Academic Affairs — Senator Taj
Civic Engagement — President Schatmeyer, Senator Paulet
Finance — Senator Mays, Treasurer Tu
Health, Safety and Sustainability — Senator Paulet, Senator Patel
Internal Affairs — Senator Baron, Vice President Tsang
Student Organizations — President Chien, Senator Elgendi
Student Services — Senator Cai, President Schatmeyer
Class Council Reports (4 min)
Advisor Report (3 min)
New Business (105 min)
Teach for America — Osiris Mancera (10 min)
Procedural Changes [Presentation] — Vice President Tsang (20 min)
Powers, Authorities, Shared Governance: The JHU Community Council Concept [Presentation] [CPUC Website, Charter] — Vice President Tsang (25 min)
Student Center Conceptualization [Presentation] — President Schatmeyer, Senator Elgendi, Vice President Tsang (15 min)
CSE Re-confirmation Vote, Howard Senior (20 min)
President Daniels Dinner Discussion [Discussion Document] (15 min)
Prospective Business (5 min)
Advancing Legislation
Announcements
Public Input Period
Fam Reveals (if time)
Adjournment (ESTIMATED 9:15 PM, ACTUAL 8:57 PM)
Time-length and adjournment estimates are provided for the benefit of guests at Senate meetings. However, SGA meetings are always slated to extend until at least 9:00 PM and SGA members are expected to remain in the Senate chamber until official adjournment by motion, whether before or after the adjournment estimate.
SUGGESTED MODERATED CAUCUSES
Procedural Changes [Link] — Vice President Tsang (20 min)
5 minutes, 30 second speaking times
Powers, Authorities, Shared Governance: The JHU Community Council Concept [Presentation] [CPUC Website, Charter] — Vice President Tsang (25 min)
15 minutes, 45 second speaking times
President Daniels Dinner Discussion [Link] (15 min)
10 minutes, 30 second speaking times
CSE Re-confirmation Vote, Howard Senior (20 min)
15 minutes, 1 minute speaking times
Student Center Project Updates Discussion (15 min)
10 minutes, 30 second speaking times
MINUTES
Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)
Roll taken
Approval of the Agenda & Prior Minutes (1 min)
Motion passed
Reports (18 min)
Executive Board Reports (4 min)
President
Meeting with Dean Wilson
VP
Met with Elizabeth Smythe - Agora Advisory Board, will have forums with important people in the discourse world, intersession classes
PRDC - two projects are analyze success or failures of smoking policy at peer institution - provide a summary of the OIE report - personal projects - how to other unis have student protest and engage in change
Wellness wednesday - CHEW with dogs - forum on how the university structure and administration works
Wellfest next Friday on levering courtyard - confirmed 6 groups
Met with Smita to discuss student center rally - alumni involvement?
Met with alumni council to bring alumni here
Will speak with faculty and wellness champions
Secretary
1123 signatures
CMC meeting this week
Treasurer - read off budget
Seniors, Juniors and Sophomores have gotten budgets
All student groups have budgets
Committee Reports (7 min)
Academic Affairs — Senator Taj
No report
Civic Engagement — President Schatmeyer, Senator Paulet
Working with CSC for voter registration tabling (last day to register in Maryland)
Finance — Senator Mays, Treasurer Tu
No bills this week
Health, Safety and Sustainability — Senator Paulet, Senator Patel
Met with Miller Roberts - director to maintenance for res-halls - secured 250 compost bins that people can opt into in Bradford and Homewood
Internal Affairs — Senator Baron, Vice President Tsang
Selected 4 individuals for hearings and senate approval for judiciary
Hearings over the course of the month
Student Organizations — President Chien, Senator Elgendi
Finalized meeting time
Deadline has passed for new student org
Meeting on Thursday with Laura about reregistering certain student groups
Student Services — Senator Cai, President Schatmeyer
Brick rally
Dean Wilson and other admins about free printing
Class Council Reports (4 min)
Seniors
Moving Wednesday to business hours
Registration initiatives - working with senior class gift to have an event
Applications for senior week committee sent out
Juniors
Reviewed results are survey
Students care about a number of issues
Moving forward with assassin
Having stronger social media presence
Sophomores
First 21Takeoff newsletter
Finalize grant program
Met with Kwame at OMA to ask how they ran their culture show
Freshmen
Met on Friday - social media account
May be able to access old facebook page
Has yet to get budget
Discussed her role with advisor
Advisor Report (3 min)
No report
New Business (105 min)
Teach for America — Marie Draper (10 min)
Osiris from Teach for America
Senior ambassador for Teach for America - will be in Tulsa next year
Teach for America is a non-profit leadership organization that wants to eradicate education inequity - many student don’t have the opportunity to reach full potential, especially those in low income communities
More direct approach for getting college grads to participate
A lot of professional leadership training and resources to provide for students
Long term impact - many participants decide to go into fields that aren’t teaching/education - more likely to incorporate social justice issues into their work
Being involved in Teach for America can help you with your career with professional development and a large network
Programs for non juniors and seniors - early meet programs: Impact Spring Break Conference - learn more about education and network with people there - all expense paid - applications come out in winter
Rise Leadership Conference - 140-200 other students to learn soft skills
Fellowship - summer internship where you go to different regions to learn about schools and education in that area
Which school will you be teaching in and what?
Either pre-k or kindergarten in spanish
Do you pick where you go?
Matching system - you get top 3
Are you a full teacher or an assistant?
Yes full teacher, but you have coaches who assist you
Procedural Changes [Presentation] — Vice President Tsang (20 min)
See presentation above
Proposed changes to how we run GBM
Lots of discourse in the Senate - yay!
Also some tension between senators - :(
Direct approach in addressing senators one-on-one
Think of solutions to remedy this situation - potentially put in rules bill
Senator Lloyd
Will there be limit on how many people can be in a mod caucus?
Depends on the caucus itself - can be extended if need be
Senator Mollin
What’s the mechanism for responding to someone else’s comments
Right of reply for personal attacks
Senator Panakam
Not everyone gets to respond during mod caucuses - can yield time if need be - allows for people to be more respectful and more voices are heard
Senator Mollin
Can we still do round robins?
Yes
Senator Thomas
Formally sending in what you’ve learned may be unnecessary
Should be a means of reflection
Powers, Authorities, Shared Governance: The JHU Community Council Concept [Presentation] [CPUC Website, Charter] — Vice President Tsang (25 min)
See presentation and CPUC examples
Came from the student body felt - if it can’t engage the administration and meaningful change cannot occur in a tangible way
Working to put students on BoT
Working to put students on administrative bodies
Engage student in the democratic process with referendum
More admin meetings - connecting committees with admins who can help them
Students should have a say in long term trajectory of university
Princeton is a good example of the shared governance across the university
Trying to address siloing and fracturing of central university governance
CPUC has open minutes and open meetings - policy committees are split between BoT and other stakeholders - investments, rules, judicial, governance, academic
Try to engage as many stakeholders as possible
Trying to contact Princeton Student Government and their CPUC
JHU should also engage members of the Baltimore Community
Would fill a macro level gap - there are so many groups and advisory group but no macro level group that bridges councils and committees across the university
Senate thoughts:
Motion for moderated caucus - 10 minutes 30 seconds per speakers
Motion passed
Senator Lucas
What kind of organizations besides SGA would be on this committee?
VP Tsang - other representative organizations - GRO, FSA
President Schatmeyer
How could we incorporate this with a representatives on BoT and PIIAC
VP Tsang - parallel initiatives
Senator Lucas
Would we put student programming groups on?
VP Tsang - yes definitely
Senator Sharron
How would the groups and people chosen?
VP Tsang - they would be elected
Senator Paulet
Would this alleviate workload on on representative committees?
VP Tsang - yes
Senator Mollin
Would it be a good idea to move this to internal affairs or an ad hoc committee?
VP Tsang - yes we can do that
President Schatmeyer
How would this new group work with SGA?
VP Tsang - it would allow SGA have more control over university decisions - resources, priorities, investment
Senator Cai
Will we have equal representation of students and faculty?
VP Tsang - at princeton, it’s balanced equally between tenured, non tenured, other groups
Senator Thomas
What if this committee wants to implement this bill
VP Tsang - it would be a horizontally chartered and depends on the structure of the committee
Senator Mollin
Have we talked to admin any more about this? What did they say? Did CPUC have access to the president and binding authority.
VP Tsang - binding authority depends on issue, president would be a member of the committee, we have spoken to admin - exec has regular meetings with higher admins, they are in support/fascinated by the idea of the CPUC - spoken with other faculty and student groups
Senator Lucas
Could we alter it so it’s more heavily weighted towards undergrads?
VP Tsang - theoretically we can - but its important that we get support from all stakeholders - we want it to represent everyone
President Schatmeyer
President and Provost would lead - concerns me because a shared governance model should have an undergraduate rep that’s at the same level as the president or provost
VP Tsang - president chairs meetings but does not tell committee what to do specifically - exec president of sga also guaranteed the spot
Senator Thomas
Wants us to be weary of an organization that has similar authority that we do - would have more pull
Senator Paulet
Would there be a system of checks and balances where neither admin or undergrads have more or less power
VP Tsang - there’s a quota of membership from each demographic - we should split power as necessary
Senator Schatmeyer
As it stands right now - SGA has a lot of impact but little institutional authority - we should want to support a body that has more institutional power on behalf of students - should not write off idea because were giving up power
Senator Forlenza
could have SGA members on it to make up for “lost” SGA power
Senator Bhamidipati
aside from managing our budget - they would be doing everything we are doing
VP Tsang
CPUC is similar to our PIIAC not similar to our SGA - residential policy, naming - would import power to SGA instead of take it away
Senator Bhamidipati
If we can petition the admin the grant a separate body of the powers why can’t they give us that power?
VP Tsang - because hopkins is so decentralized, it would be wrong to discount voices of staff, faculty, other demographics who are not represented by SGA - they would share in long term decision making
President Schatmeyer
Main concern from Admin was that we weren’t representative enough - this new committee would be more representative or more stakeholders and would also be larger - 7 students is not enough representative - would also bring in student orgs
Motion to refer to internal affairs
Motion passed
Student Center Conceptualization [Presentation] — President Schatmeyer, Senator Elgendi, Vice President Tsang (15 min)
See presentation
Clarification of conceptualization of Brick Rally bill
Explain how it fits in with other initiatives
End of rising to the challenge as a major fundraising initiative - want student center to be the core of the next fundraising project
How can homewood stakeholders provide capital and solicit donors
Tangible letters of support from stakeholders to show to potential donors
Want to follow the path of engaging students - online campaign, videos/online campaigning, students donating a symbol or symbolic amount of money - need to strategize well
Strong encouragement to not have the rally be like a protest - have a mural community building activity to paint a brick/object demonstrating what hopkins means to them - would eventually go into student center
We definitely need to look at strategy and tactics - keep students excited about something they might not directly benefit from as students - storing bricks might not be the most practical thing but how do we get students excited and involved?
Realistically student center will not be built in the next couple years - we should work more on things that would affect the student center - how can we talk to alumni or past SGA members
Senate input:
Motion for moderated caucus - 15 speakers 1 minute - first 30 seconds for question
Motion fails
Motion for mod caucus 15 speakers 1 minute - first 30 seconds for question
Motion passes
Senator Lucas - did we definitely decide we are not going to do the rally and is the alternative the mural festival, why is admin against it. The storage of bricks is not a valid enough issue to not have the brick rally
Senator Lloyd - agrees with the dean’s reservations - it would be better to spend our time and resources to raise money and go to donors, other activities to get people to vote - go to admin. Feels like a brick rally is to build support and there is already support
President Schatmeyer - agrees with the reconceptualization - having a broader support base for such an event is really important, especially for something with so much logistics. There already is a lot of support - the biggest thing SGA can do is to show there is a lot of support.
Senator Uraih - storing bricks for years doesn’t show we’re serious and is not a smart use of resources, might get charged to repay pathways - does not want to see it
Senator Paulet - we’re not doing the brick rally? Gives our students a way to be involved in the building of the student center - for storage we have our own storage room in levering - shouldn’t keep us from pursuing this idea
VP Tsang - technically it’s up to us
Senator Elgendi - loves the brick rally but feels like we were heavily encouraged not to do it because the message might not be taken correctly - we need to look at the long run - should see how admin feels about it - brick rally is not dead, we can do whatever we want
Senator Cai - still also in favor of brick rally - conveys a different message than a painting festival - students will actually feel like their contributing.
Yield to Senator Lucas - wants to emphasize that the rally conveys a different emotions - doesn’t want to see us as an SGA that….
Senator Mollin - it’s important for us to galvanize action - won’t happen for 3-5 years at minimum, why? The university is seeking 60m in donation and university can foot the rest of the bill - why can’t the endowment go to this?
Senator Lucas - wants to emphasize that we want to galvanize action - should not yield to administration - student body wants to see us as more effective - a brick rally could change our image and be seen as more effective
Yield to Senator Elgendi - we need the 60 million from a keystone donor
President Schatmeyer - we cannot go back to original conception - there is a lot of internal divide about this and this should be big and visible enough to require the work of SGA at large - I want to make this something that SGA supports - cathartic way for students to go about student center and has more backing from the whole of SGA
Motion to continue discussion in Student Services Committee
Motion passes
CSE Re-confirmation Vote, Howard Senior (20 min)
Howard Senior presents
Appreciate being able to discuss this week
Had a lot of high profile failures over the last year
There’s a distinct lack of student engagement even if SGA if engaged in bringing students to vote in campus and further - wants to applaud those efforts - but we are experiencing student apathy in our government
Spent a lot of time with internal affairs and the committee to address concerns about lack of voter turnout - we had to tweak our approach due to a lack of student involvement - but the document is living and plastic - if any member of this body has a better idea about how to have elections
Ranked ballot system did not work as intended - would want to crowdsource ideas about voting
CSC has had a lack of members - has had trouble in recruiting and retaining members - only 3 people on a committee of 7
Puts previous failures in a different light - SGA would help to stock the committee - wants to see those recommendations from senators of who would be good on the committee
Senate questions:
Motion for mod caucus - 10 minute with 10 speakers, extra time yielded to guest
Motion for 15 minute mod caucus with 15 speakers and 1 minute speaking times and extra time yielded
Motion for round robin with 15 seconds - 12 - 9
Passes
Zanir - were a few hiccups but youre doing the collective work
Mo - want more collaboration between the two bodies
Pitika - response to email time needs to be better - would it not increase gridlock
Smollin - failure of IRV system
Omar - does not like the change to voter system - but you’ve learned your lessons
Schatme - you said that the problem in student apathy is in the election systems - its fine on a small campus
Howard - would agree that we aren’t a large university but we aren't small
Schatme - fails to see how a different voting system effects voter engagement
Akshay - why would your committee do the SGA tiebreak instead of holding another election
Howard - we are supposed to consult senate - in the spirit of incorporating the SGA and CSC on a variety of issues
Kiana - its not effective to rebuild a system that works instead of the big failures
Evan - don’t see a point in changing a voting system in which people don’t vote
Smollin - we should take into consideration the questions to other CSC members - issues with recounting and how Howard interpreted the rules - we haven’t gotten a response on why the process must be drawn out - email was sent out at the bottom of exec elections - their job is to advertise - when voting we need to take all of these things into account - Howard should anser
Howard - biggest claim was why we didn’t move back to a plurality - it was finals and did not have time to change constitution - is willing to work on proposed constitutional changes - brought to senate and IA
Motion to give Howard as much time to reply - motion passes
Howard - not here today because he has a vendetta - did not spend 8-10 hours recreating the constitution so that he could have a power trip - devoted his time to rework a system that needed chronic support - believes in SGA and why it’s important and necessary - believes it was the most effective but will admit that it was a flop - we could brainstorm ways to make it better - how 3 committee members were unable to address concerns should have shown that they need more committee members - other concerns, was less involved in freshmen elections - wants to have CSE be able to continue on in the future without having only two members this semester
Pritika - you guys have to have unanimous support to everything - if there’s three there should be more coordination
Howard - if there were 7 people moderating email they would be manning it more - will move it within CSE for unanimous approval to no longer be necessary
Motion to reconfirm 12 - 3 - 6
President Daniels Dinner Discussion [Discussion Document] (15 min)
Moved to next meeting
Fam Reveals (if time)
Prospective Business (5 min)
Advancing Legislation
Dig Deep Volleyball tournament
Amnesty Refugee Rights Resolution
Announcements
Public Input Period
Adjournment (ESTIMATED 9:15 PM, ACTUAL 8:58 PM)
