SENATE OF THE JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION
Consolidated General Body Meeting Agenda and Minutes
October 9th, 2018
7:00 PM, Charles Commons East Room
Agenda
Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)
Approval of the Agenda & Prior Minutes (1 min)
Reports (18 min)
Executive Board Reports (4 min)
Committee Reports (7 min)
Academic Affairs — Senator Taj
Civic Engagement — President Schatmeyer, Senator Paulet
Finance — Senator Mays, Treasurer Tu
Health, Safety and Sustainability — Senator Paulet, Senator Patel
Internal Affairs — Senator Baron, Vice President Tsang
Student Organizations — President Chien, Senator Elgendi
Student Services — Senator Cai, President Schatmeyer
Class Council Reports (4 min)
Advisor Report (3 min)
New Business (115 min)
Will from Alumni Relations (10 min)
Confirmation Votes (35)
Committee Confirmation Votes (5 min)
PRDC Confirmation Votes [Link] (5 min)
SAC Confirmation Votes [Link] (5 min)
KSAS Curriculum Committee Confirmation Vote (5 min)
CSE Re-Confirmation Votes (15 min)
Legislation (50)
Semester.ly-HopHacks Funding Bill [Link] — Vice President Tsang (10 min)
IDEAL Funding Bill [Link] — Senator Chien (10 min)
Menstruation Products Funding Bill [Link] — Senator Paulet (10 min)
Brick Rally Funding Bill [Link] — Senator Elgendi (10 min)
Healthy Hopkins Funding Bill [Link] — Senator Patel (10 min)
Discussions (20) [MOVED TO FRONT OF NEXT GBM]
JHU Community Council Discussion [Link] (10 min)
President Daniels Dinner Discussion [Link] (10 min)
Prospective Business (5 min)
Advancing Legislation
Announcements
Public Input Period
Adjournment (ESTIMATED 9:30 PM, ACTUAL X:XX PM)
Time-length and adjournment estimates are provided for the benefit of guests at Senate meetings. However, SGA members are expected to remain in the Senate chamber until official adjournment by motion, whether before or after the adjournment estimate.
MINUTES
Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)
Roll call completed
Approval of the Agenda & Prior Minutes (1 min)
Approved
Reports (18 min)
Executive Board Reports (4 min)
VP Tsang
Institutional committee membership database
Website
JHU Community Council Concept
PRDC Operationalized
Faculty Wellness Campaigns
MH Faculty Forum
K-Sho and company meeting
Agora meeting scheduled for friday
All-school email sent out
Secretary Williams
Referendum! - currently at 1013
First events are tomorrow and Thursday! Please sign up!
CMC will be meeting next week to discuss more marketing materials
I’ll be sending out a form to Freshmen to get more CMC members
Dr. Torres - reach out about regular meetings with HSS
Trained first year on Saturday
Treasurer Tu
Finally have budget
Contingency - 8764.95
Operations - (1,123)
Events - 8,786
SAC - 39,907.40
SAC Operations- 500
SAC Annual Grant - 225,000
4 nominees for SAC commissioners
Annual grants to 168 student groups will be sent out tonight
Committee Reports (7 min)
Academic Affairs — Senator Taj
Krieger Nominations finalized so we can now approve
Met with the NL about unequal representation - going to pass a resolution about unequal representation
Civic Engagement — President Schatmeyer, Senator Paulet
Voter Registration!
Tabling tomorrow, Friday, Monday
Collaborating with the CSC and College Dems, College Repubs, Ideal, Discourse - plan a midterm elections watch party
Discussed OIE report that came out
Finance — Senator Mays, Treasurer Tu
Passed a few bills
Brick Rally
Ideal Semesterly outreach funding bill
Menstruation products bill
Health, Safety and Sustainability — Senator Paulet, Senator Patel
Menstruation products bill will be on the floor
Healthy Hopkins Bill
Moving forward on moving forward with community life to have indoor composting
Reached out to HERU about sharing data on community health
Internal Affairs — Senator Baron, Vice President Tsang
Meeting on judiciary nominees
Student Organizations — President Chien, Senator Elgendi
Student Orgs will be filled today!
Set a goal to create document shows what they do for the committee after us - institutional memory
Student Services — Senator Cai, President Schatmeyer
Discussed Brick Rally funding bill
Class Council Reports (4 min)
Seniors
Finally have access to the email
Working to find a class council meeting time - including commencement and class sponsor
Received budget
Juniors
Office hours are Thursdays and Sundays in Brody
Junior class priorities survey sent out - about 100 responses - good diversity of opinions - good springboard to work off of!
Class video of some kind to release on social media
Class wide game of assassin - checking with risk management
Sophomores
Meeting with resident advisors and how they can support them
Launched 21Takeoff newsletter
Launching class of 2021 grant program
Working on sophshow
Freshmen
Had training session on Saturday
Setting up meeting time with advisor
Advisor Report (3 min)
Baltimore Collegetown retreat for all SGA’s so we can meet with each other - is good since exec met with Loyola SGA last month - January 26th
Link emailed out
Thursday evening - Glow party - starts at 8
New Business (105 min)
Will Archer from Alumni Relations
Started about a year ago
Trying to bring more alumni back to campus
Alumni student grants - $62,500 across all 9 schools
50% of students who applied got a grant
Senior class council is sending students to seniors and young alumni symposium at Camden Yards
9:30-5:30 on October 27th
Senator Baron - can you send AJ a pdf of the poster to post on class pages?
Absolutely
Confirmation Votes (35)
Committee Confirmation Votes [Link] (5 min)
See link for final committees
Motion to approve
Motion passed unanimously
PRDC Confirmation Votes [Link] (5 min)
Presented the Link above with description of all nominees
Anthony Boutros, Clarissa Chen, Ramya Prabhakar, Tarek Meah, Olivia Morse, Jamie Oh, Ivy Wang, Grace Wang, Sam Bacon
Senator Patel - how will they be working with you
This weekend will have the first meeting - combinations of senate projects and individual projects
Subcommittees will have senate charged projects
2-3 week turnaround on reports
Reports can be both internal and public
Any report that becomes public has to be approved by senate first - especially recommendations
Motion to approve
Motion passed unanimously
SAC Confirmation Votes [Link] (5 min)
Received around 20 applications and Treasurer Tu interviewed all of them - cases were a part of the interview
Chase McAdams, Georgie D’Sanson, Jillian Ngo, Anum Haque
Motion to approve
Approved unanimously
KSAS Curriculum Committee Confirmation Vote (5 min)
Justin Greene, Kiley McKee, Samantha Gomez, Alanya Banner
Motion to approve
Motion unanimously - abstentions to individuals - 1 for Sam, 1 for all nominations
CSE Re-Confirmation Votes (15 min)
Rahul introduces himself
Worked to settle any conflict and make it efficient
Communicate with people running elections so they know how to run
Senator Habib - if you could go back and change one thing the last year of elections, what would you change
Switched to go into IRV voting, quickly realized that it works when you have a lot of candidates and voters, system fell apart, 5 vacant seats using that system
Has switched back to plurality vote - will keep that system
Senator Paulet - CSE chose not to allow for a runoff, what happened? Felt like it was undemocratic
Consulted with AJ, could have done a runoff election had unanimously voted for it, some members did not respond
Senator Habib - I thought we did it so it was easier for the first years
Currently the CSE is understaffed - 3 members dropped at the beginning of the year
Bahira - we’re supposed to have 7 but it’s been difficult and wants the SGA to help send out application. With what happened last semester, didn’t see the possible implications, thought there would be more voters, thought SGA would catch any issues
POI - who is on the CSE?
Rahul, Bahira, Howard
Senator Parmar - will the response to emails be faster once there are seven members?
Bahira - try to rotate who answers to emails, must agree upon things unanimously - has to wait for everyone to response
Senator Patel - did SGA give you feedback on bylaws
Howard presented to SGA - thinks it was unanimously voted on - Bahira and Rahul didn’t hear about concerns
Senator Chien - did review it in IA last year - howard presented to us and there were significant concerns, sent to floor, there were a number of questions, Howard had a difficult time explaining it
Bahira - did not know there was concern about it - only heard about the results
Senator Baron - motion to set 1 minute speaking times - motion passes with 2 nays; have they updated bylaws to reflect the changes? When would that be?
Have not changed the bylaws, were clear to first year candidates that it would be plurality, will probably be changed by the end of the month
Senator Murak - for the obligatory meetup for candidates, no one from the CSE was there, there was no pizza, no advertising, the table were not reserved
Bahira - needed to book breezeway 10 business days in advance - times set during meet and greet were during class times - was 100% our mistake - thought they didn’t need to book the event ahead of time - more for the candidates - not sure why pizza wasn't there
President Habib - walk us through what you do throughout the school year
Prepared for the election cycle - called AJ about dates, make ballots, now focusing on constitution, discuss increasing voter turnout
Senator Mollin - within bylaws - for a recount must request within 24 hours - people cannot ask for recounts since the results are put out
24 hours after results are released
Senator Mollin - someone on CSE said he could not have a recount
We were not made aware of that request
President Chien - they have a thankless job that is an independent body that runs our elections - wants to help them have a larger body
President Schatmeyer - thank you for working on senior elections so it was more democratic - would like to see more SGA involvement on CSE
Senator Paulet - wants to bring up the freshmen elections last year there was a Jewish High Holy day - jewish students were severely disadvantaged. Can you make sure they are accounted for
Bahira - had multiple info session - people could meet with CSE separately, try not to plan things on religious holidays
Rahul - set strict deadlines and restraints but people can reach out if there’s an issue if there is an extenuating circumstance
Senator Baron - motion to close speakers list - approved unanimously - some religious holidays last upwards of a week, Friday and Saturday are more difficult for Jewish people to be involved - motion to reconfirm Rahul - passes unanimously
Bahira introduces herself
Senator Patel - motion to approve - motion passes 19 - 2 - 4
Howard is not here to introduce himself
Bahira - anything that happens in the CSE is a community effort - has done the same amount of punishment among us and among SGA - probability of catching mistake would be higher in SGA - transitioning of chairs has been difficult - Rahul was sick during the change of the constitution and out of commission - Howard stepped up and we thank him for that - Howard will be there to teach new people
Motion to close speakers list passed unanimously
Senator Sharron - is there a timeline to get more people on CSE
President Chien - wants us to consider what will happen when we don’t vote him in
Senator Baron - you mentioned Howard learned from his mistakes but he did not respond to any messages during the discussion about the senior election.
Bahira - that’s how he toned himself down
Senator Armstrong - what mistake did Howard make last year?
VP Tsang - CSE approached IA about changing the bylaws. Came to SGA to present, added new clauses about runoffs, changed away from a plurality system. Tried to ashwaged Howard’s opinion and the senate. Possible to run and still lose - which is what happened.
Senator Mollin - wants to elaborate - he introduced IRV voting system - you don’t vote for 6 people but you rank but your vote only goes to one person - for all class council elections - there wasn’t a lot of turnout because it was uncontested - 3 vacancies in sophomore, 2 in junior year. Thinks Howard shouldn’t be reconfirmed is that he didn’t offer to solve the problem but instead doubled down on the results and keeping the IRV system. Didn’t want to have another election but wanted CSE to chose senators. No guarantee that he will not do that in the future. CSE should ensure student body has a voice. Mentioned previously stated questions and answers. Will promise that we will be willing to help in the process. We care about student elections too and we want it to be democratic. We will work to fill all vacancies. Want it to be a fully functioning body. Appreciates his effort but I don’t think he allows it to work. Wants it to stay in place for president and exec elections but not for senate elections.
Bahira - do you think one person should be punished for the actions of many
Senator Mollin - I think Howard specifically was an issue in the CSE and during elections. Wants to make CSE better.
VP Tsang - Howard hasn’t responded to any messages about when he can come.
Senator Taj - wants to point out he doesn’t think Howard is a bad person. Thinks Howard did not handle it well after the fact. He did not work with exec board to solve the problem after the fact. Does not like his temperment during the aftermath.
Senator Baron - we are all students and we all make mistakes - would be hypocritical is we voted against people who made elections because they didn’t go our way.
Motion to reconfirm
Motion to take from the table
Passed - 21 - 5 - 0
Bahira - I defended Howard because he was not here
Legislation
Semester.ly-HopHacks Funding Bill [Link] — Vice President Tsang (10 min)
Heads of Semester.ly
4,000 users here and the number is decreasing because of funding
2 years ago the founder graduated - they have been working to restructure - we’re originally funded by O’Connor fund - has been depleted
Here to ask for more funding
Past two semesters they have been using their personal funds - it’s getting expensive
Have been reaching out to other organizations and student groups
Wants to do course advising event based on majors - give them t-shirts - help freshmen and sophomores choose classes for the upcoming year
Habib - I love Semester.ly. How would you potentially monetize Semester.ly?
Hopkins will now manage servers. Hopkins IT works on SIS and Semester.ly together.
Senator Baron - are you working on the add to SIS button?
There was a class on it
Senator Thomas - across all campuses
Working on it
Senator Taj - motion to close speakers list - passed unanimously - he loves Semester.ly. Always on the website. On academic affairs - wants the contact information. How can SGA help you in addition to this funding?
Office of Academic Affairs - integrating learning den and pilot into Semester.ly - have people put in a box to add to to suggestions
President Schatmeyer - motion to approve
Passes unanimously
IDEAL Funding Bill [Link] — Senator Chien (10 min)
Luke from Ideal came to speak
Director of Ideal: Here and Now - national, non-profit, nonpartisan that encourages discourse. Has events on campus, newsletter and community engagement. Over the past 3.5 years, has worked on campus here and other university campuses.
Have finally been able to work with the community and community partners. Have put together a democratic approach to educate students in the Druid Heights community - educate them on what they want to learn. Designing a curriculum after school so that they can learn their role in the community.
Focus right now is to make sure students come to the after school program. Has been working on making all actions deliberate and clear so that students feel that they are welcome. Students got to see Fort McKendry for the first time. Want to encourage them to be curious about their community.
Funding is for the upcoming halloween party - wants students to feel welcome and want to come to meetings afterwards. Want it so be a lasting experience - tangible change where there are connections to these students.
Senator Bannister - age range?
Ages of 14-24 - highschool students
Senator Baron - will there be marketing materials for SGA?
Yes
Senator Patel - did you get the ideal grant
No, we’ve been paying out of pocket because we are still starting out and have not been here long enough to get the Ideal grant - currently just working on reimbursements
Motion to approve
Passes Unanimously
Brick Rally Funding Bill [Link] — Senator Elgendi (10 min)
Senator Elgendi
We’ve been talking about a student center for a long time - many students are depressed. We’ve been talking about it for so long and little movement has been made.
Student center brick rally - 310 bricks - students can sign a brick - students are “building” the student center - we’re going to do this ourselves
$307.96 for the funding
Two days later - we will place the bricks in the place
President Habib - what is the structure
Either a cube or the pyramid.
Senator Baron - Have you asked for funding from alumni office? How does one transport 310 bricks? How do you dispose of them? What happens if we’re liable for any damage?
Can ask for funding from alumni. A pickup truck will bring them from Lowes. This is not a joke. The idea of the rally to gain support for the student center to make a public statement to the board of trustees. It’s a show of support to the Student Body that SGA is doing something to fight for their student center. SGA cannot build a student center. We can’t even lobby. We have not yet spoken to facilities because it’s a demonstration. Plan to leave them out for 2 days.
Senator Murak - have you considered getting the bricks from a local organization?
We have not thought about it - Lowes is the easiest - prices are cheaper of the same from Second Chance - The original idea was to have it happen with the BoT coming up
Senator Bannister - can this be marketed on all SGA social media
Yes
Senator Elgendi - obviously some things were not taken into account. We should get permission from facilities. Can we table the voting?
Senator Paulet - where would this be? Doesn’t want to make the school less ADA compliant.
Original bricks will be signed in the levering courtyard. Would be placed in front of Garland so people can get around
Senator Baron - if you hold a protest or rally does it have to go through admin?
VP Tsang - is does not have to but to help students they have a document to regulate the protest or demonstrations - have to adhere to laws and school policies.
Kirsten - where would they be delivered? How are you transporting them? Doesn’t know if this is a cause that has to be heavy hitting. This is a cause where there is a lot of interest convergence. Is happy to see us take this up as one of SGA’s big initiatives. There is a lot of room for collaboration. Check with grounds and facilities. If something goes wrong it would detract from out cause.
Senator Mollin - Lowe’s delivers - it makes it more convenient. Time sensitive because the BoT will be there to see it. SGA will plan it out correctly. In terms of everyone supporting a student center but is hasn’t happened yet. This rally will galvanize action and add pressure. People aren’t working together as hard as possible to make it happen.
VP Tsang - Specific to location of bricks. There was an idea to put the bricks in a storage place until it is build. Will be on display in the student center. Is that still a consideration?
President Schatmeyer - when is the next BoT meeting? How long would we have to wait for the next meeting?
Next week
Every few days there are subcommittee meetings - rise to the challenge campaign is coming to a close
Senator Lucas - it is super time sensitive because of the meeting coming. Perception is that it’s brought up every few years and nothing has been done. Wants to make sure that we are not seen as ineffective. Does not want to wait for admin and BoT to decide to do it and thinks we should act now. Is there anyway we can approve the bill and amend during approvement.
VP Tsang - can have a contingent discussion
Can we move the money and use severability later?
Treasurer - you would use money from SGA contingency
Motion to close speakers list passed unanimously
Senator Bannister - there’s a tendency to overestimate what the students know. Thinks this would be very valuable as a form of protest and a form of art. Does not think liability is all the realistic. Thinks the chances are low that anyone or anything would be hurt.
Senator Thomas - agrees with the intention. Primary concern is the staff cleaning issue - SGA can arrange for that after and the timing is important. Thinks this would make a powerful statement. In regard to clean up, that needs to be thought out. We believe we’re doing a lot for the campus but the student body does not see our efforts. Our job becomes easier if the student body is backing us which cannot happen when they’re unaware of what we’re doing.
Senator Baron - thinks it would be a good idea if the bricks were cardboard or paper. It would be easier to clean up.
The comment on the cleanup is important. Timing wise it is important that this is passed tonight. We can get a plan for cleanup figured out in a week.
Cleanup is important
Motion to introduce and approve
Senator Murak - thinks there are details that have not been ironed out and we should get the details right. We’re putting out names on this and we need to focus on detail in bill.
Motion to amend bill to remove tax
Passes unanimously
15 - 3 - 1 passes
Menstruation Products Funding Bill [Link] — Senator Paulet (10 min)
Senator Paulet - SGA has been trying for a couple years to implement a sustainable program to place pads and tampons in areas with a lot of students. Wants to implement a sustainable implementation. There was confusion between us and other offices and they were not allowed. Pads and tampons had been placed in the areas and they were removed because they were not in bins and there was no signage.
HSS is a small committee - we’re doing a pilot to show the school that this is a necessity. Want to have this program continued in the future. Partnered with WINGS - need to approach menstruation from a more inclusive standpoint - will include all gender restrooms across campus. HSS will have the help of WINGS to collaborate and redistribute.
$20 for baskets to carry baskets in, zip ties, printing - already have tampons and pads so do not need to be funded
Motion to approve - passed unanimously
Healthy Hopkins Funding Bill [Link] — Senator Patel (10 min)
Finance has no recommendation
Senator Patel - wants to provide students with up to 2 personal training sessions. Has brought down cost to 1k. 40 sessions with group activities will take $200 goes to that. Will be promoting activities they already do. Making students accountable if they don’t show up. Focusing on student perception of students to make them more comfortable. Want to do outreach to promote the system.
Partnering with rec center and HellWell - met with nutritionist and peeps are both waiting for funding.
Partnering with health guardians of America
Partnerships will keep it sustainable
3 components with videos and students will answer on campus labs, will help get student buy-in. See bill and links in bill for more partnerships.
Will also discuss other resources on campus that will be discussed with everyone participating on this bill.
Senator Forlenza - what if someone has a family emergency?
People should show up to their sessions
Senator Forlenza - shouldn’t rec center be doing this work
We should be facilitating
Senator Parmar - those already paying for the session may attend. How can you fix this?
It’s available to everyone but will market in the library.
President Chien - can we motion to amend to add a box so those who have already done training will be recorded and prioritize those who have not attended training.
Will include on the form
Senator Thomas - can you place a cap on the number of sessions?
Cap is two sessions.
Motion to approve
Secretary Williams - can you make sure trainers have enough time?
Yes
Senator Lloyd - the sections are a bit messed up in formatting.
VP Tsang - will be fixed
Passes unanimously
Discussions - moved to next meeting
JHU Community Council Discussion [Link] (10 min)
President Daniels Dinner Discussion [Link] (10 min)
Prospective Business (5 min)
Advancing Legislation
Announcements
Pi Phi ArrowSpike is coming up!
Please look at bills beforehand! Address concerns in committee
Public Input Period
Adjournment (ESTIMATED 9:30 PM, ACTUAL X:XX PM)
