JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

SGA Judiciary Phase II Application (Responses)

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

## Form Responses 1
| Timestamp | Name & JHU Email | Do you plan to run for SGA Senate in your time at Hopkins? | Why do you seek to be on the Judiciary? | A student group called "Embrace Every E-Cig" with the mission to "defend the rights of smokers" has been denied approval by the SGA because of public health, public safety, and non-inclusivity concerns. The student group has appealed its denial to the SGA Judiciary. How do you rule on this hypothetical situation? Please write a 300-500 word opinion to reflect your ruling. | Do you have any questions? |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 2018-01-31 12:42:28.790000 | Aaron Pultman, apultma1@jhu.edu | No | There are two main reasons that I would like to be on the Judiciary. The first is my belief in the importance of institutions and the rules that govern them. As the child of two lawyers, I was raised to appreciate the vital role rules play in our society from the highest levels of government to our University. Consequently, I would like to help maintain the integrity and efficacy of the rules of our student government. The second reason I would like to join the Judiciary is my strong sense of giving back. My time so far at this University has presented me with fantastic opportunities. As a result, I feel the need to give back to the University in some way. I believe my talents are well-suited to the judiciary and it is the place where I could provide the most valuable service to the University. | When adjudicating a case I would of course need to evaluate all the pertinent facts so I will evaluate this hypothetical case based on the given information while acknowledging that I may be missing information which would affect my decision. In this particular case, I would rule in favor of the group “Embrace Every E-Cig” over SGA based on clause six of the SGA constitution’s bill of rights. Clause six states that “students have a right to free speech in all matters relating to the SGA. The spirit of this sentiment shall be extended to all student activities on the Homewood campus.” The phrasing of this right is extremely robust and expansive and gives wide license to student groups in their speech. Consequently, to reject the formation of a group, thereby suppressing their speech, SGA must overcome a tremendous obstacle and sufficiently demonstrate why the group’s rights should be trumped. In this case, I am unconvinced that SGA has met its obligation in this area. The fact that the group represents only a subset of the student body does not make it inherently exclusive and certainly does to rise to the level of warranting a suppression of their speech. While I do believe that issues of public health can overcome the right to free speech, a serious and credible threat to the health of students must be demonstrated. In this particular case, I remain unconvinced that a group representing the interests of smokers presents a public health concern serious enough to warrant the erosion of their rights. I believe that his case is quite similar to the 2013 case of Voice for Life Vs. SGA. In that case, the court overturned SGA’s denial of recognition to Voice for Life based on the free speech right in the SGA constitution. The result of that case is illuminating for this hypothetical case. Based on the information given, the 2013 precedent, and the SGA constitution I would rule for “Embrace Every E-Cig” and overturn SGA’s decision. To deny them approval would be violating the “spirit of this sentiment” that the constitution says, “shall be extended to all student activities on the Homewood Campus.” | None at this time |
| 2018-02-05 02:32:17.699000 | Name: Ivan Zhang JHU Email: izhang4@jhu.edu | No, As a Judiciary Justice, I would not run for SGA Senate. Outside of being a Justice, however, I might consider running if I saw sufficient opportunity for me to join SGA and make a difference within the Hopkins community that way. | I seek to be on the Judiciary because I am a qualified, experienced individual that will bring a level-headed, analytical, and detailed approach to upholding the SGA Constitution and serving the student body. I have already been vetted and approved by the SGA for both the Academic Ethics and Student Conduct boards, both of which have given me student council and leadership experience while also strengthening my deliberation and analysis skills through training modules led by Associate Dean of Student Conduct Saunders. To add on top of that, I have taken legal writing classes which have exposed me to the legal process, including professional briefs and summary judgment drafting as well as legal document review and proofreading. I am also an active member of the JHU Debate Council and am well-versed on policy issues, having strengthened my ability to express my opinions in a clear concise manner and communicate and collaborate as a group to establish consensus and implement policy. / /I seek to be on the Judiciary because I am eager and willing to work hard, commit myself, and learn while serving the Johns Hopkins community. I have read and reviewed completely what is expected of me and what I would be responsible for as outlined by the rules of judiciary, and I am ready to uphold my duty in all steps of the judiciary process, from reviewing petitions for a writ of certiorari to approving Amicus Curiae briefs as necessary for hearings to listening to and evaluating oral arguments and testimonies to deliberate with my fellow Justices and the Chief Justice to make the best decisions and rulings on cases. Also, I am excited to learn about and take advantage of all of the opportunities I will have as a Justice to advise the Senate and Executive Board on campus issues and case rulings. / /Most of all, I seek to be on the Judiciary because of my passion for and interest in serving our student body. As a member of SGA, my goal is to improve Hopkins institutions for everyone, be that by ruling on cases, enforcing election regulations, or advising the rest of SGA on issues of constitutionality as a whole. I have a very clear, rational, and fair mindset, and I want to use that mindset to better our campus community. / | Fundamentally, I believe the SGA Constitution establishes the right to free speech for every JHU student. Specifically, in this case, the right to create a pro-smoking advocacy group is outlined by point 6 of the Bill of Rights within the SGA Constitution, which states that students have the right to “free speech in all matters relating to the SGA, which extends to all student activities on the Homewood campus”. From this, I would assume the right to student group formation with compliance to university rules, which seems to be the case for “Embrace Every E-Cig”. (It seems that past SGA resolutions would also agree with this sentiment, as S.R-5, “A Resolution Regarding Smoking on the Homewood Campus”, also argued that preventing pro-smoking events would be an unfair violation of free speech.) // Furthermore, I have not found reasons from the Constitution or Bylaws that specifically point to justifiable reasons for student group denial beyond direct violation of university policy. Thus, unless the Committee on Student Organizations can sufficiently demonstrate that this new group would violate university policy, the Judiciary ought to overturn the denial. While I would imagine that it might be possible for the Committee on Student Organizations to prove that “Embrace Every E-Cig” could cause indirect harm to the student body, past SGA resolutions have already taken sufficient action to directly reduce the negative presence of smoking on campus (see S.R-5, “A Resolution Regarding Smoking on the Homewood Campus”, where smoking zones were increased to 23-30 feet away instead of 10 feet), and new studies or evidence would have to be introduced and accepted to justify ruling against past resolutions. / / Finally, even if student health and public safety were of utmost concern over free speech, there are better, more proactive ways for the SGA to pursue a reduction in smoking among the student body. For example, the recent SGA-R-1718.02 SGA Smoke-Cessation Resolution, which outlines goals to actively strengthen and encourage university anti-smoking campaigns, justly achieves that purpose without silencing or suppressing student expression. / / Because of the aforementioned reasons, I would rule this SGA decision to be an unconstitutional violation of student free speech, and I would rule to overturn the SGA denial of approval for “Embrace Every E-Cig”. / | What is the term length for SGA Judiciary Justices? The Rules of the Judiciary say 1 year; the SGA Constitution says until graduation or resignation. / / How are Judiciary meetings structured and organized, and what opportunities are there for Justices to take a more active role in supporting the Senate and the Executive Board? / / What kind of guidance and mentorship can the Justices expect from university administrators? |
| 2018-02-05 05:04:48.420000 | Lyle Anthony Carrera - lcarrer1@jhu.edu | I am currently not planning to run for the Sophomore Class Council. However, should circumstances in my personal life and/or on campus change, I may consider running then or in the future. | While a responsive legislature is important insofar as it reflects the will of the people who have entrusted them with decision-making power, a robust judiciary is necessary to ensure that the core principles of a just state are maintained throughout the ebbs and flows of popular sovereignty. It would be an insurmountable honor to be charged with the maintenance of the ideals of self-governance, student unity, the representation of student interests, and the exchange of ideas that our Student Government Association guides itself on and has outlined in the Preamble to its Constitution. Additionally, I’ve taken an interest in American constitutional law over the past few years, having competed for my school’s team in the annual We the People constitutional law and ethics speech competition and having joined the newly-formed JHU Undergraduate Law Review. I’ve often caught myself pondering how I’d rule in certain cases; there would be no better way to further my hobby/studies while impacting my school than to serve on the Judiciary. | The actions of the JHU Student Government Association (“SGA”, the Respondent) towards Embrace Every E-Cig (“EEE”, the Petitioner) violates Article VIII, Section Two, Clause 2 of the SGA Constitution and thus are reversed. / / It is my view that questions such as these are critical to upholding academic freedom -- recently described in part as the right “to participate in debate on and off campus, and to invite others to do the same, all without fear of restraint or penalty”. However, we must ensure that speech is not used to harass, defame, or threaten others. This was the doctrine established in Voice for Life v. SGA (2013), in which it was found that, in the light of findings by JHU’s Office of Institutional Equity that VFL, an anti-abortion student advocacy group, was not planning to engage in actions that would constitute harassment, the SGA was in the wrong to reject VFL’s application to be an officially-recognized organization. / / Therefore, in reaching this ruling, it seemed fit to consider whether the causes of concern for the SGA are valid and, if they are, how they interact with both the letter and the spirit of the SGA Constitution. The findings are as follows: / / (a) In the sphere of public health and safety, the primary concern is the emission of secondhand smoke. Note that despite the name “Embrace Every E-Cig”, the Petitioner’s stated mission is to “protect the rights of smokers” in general. Regardless of which method of tobacco use EEE intends to protect, it does not follow that mere advocacy threatens the public health of the Homewood Campus. Such protections could include ensuring “[t]he provenance of resources needed to cope with reduced smoking volume” outlined in SGA-R-1718.02 (the “SGA Smoke-Cessation Resolution”, 2017) or lobbying for designated smoking areas on campus, neither of which necessarily impact air quality. Because of this, even considering the possibly-misleading interaction between EEE’s name and its stated mission, I find in favor of the Petitioner on the matters of public health and safety. / / (b) On the matter of inclusivity, I understand that certain respiratory conditions may be exacerbated by a decrease in air quality. However, I reiterate that the broad mission statement of EEE does not necessarily promote the unfettered right to smoke across the Homewood Campus. It would thusly be within the rights of the SGA to refuse such advocacy. The mere existence of EEE, however, is not, so I find in favor of the Petitioner on the matter of inclusivity. / / (c) Note that Article VIII, Section Two, Clause 2 of the SGA Constitution specifically states that a group’s “right to expression” may only be restricted “if their conduct violates university regulations or local, state or federal laws.” Advocacy does not do either. Therefore, in keeping with the precedent set in VFL v. SGA, I find in favor in the Petitioner on the matter of freedom of expression and assembly. / / In accordance with the above findings, the SGA shall officially recognize Embrace Every E-Cig as a student organization. | How much of an influence would a member of the Judiciary have on amending/rewriting the SGA Constitution? I find that the focus on positive rights in Article I makes for a less robust protection of student rights when compared to the sole example of a negative right present in Article VIII, Section Two, Clause 2. |
## Sources
SGA Judiciary Phase II Application (Responses).xlsx