Semester Report: Honor Code at Hopkins
Student Council Ad-hoc Committee on the Honor Code
Introduction
Since the beginning of the semester, the ad-hoc committee has been meeting regularly each week (Mondays at 9 pm) and discussing various topics pertaining to the reestablishment of an honor code here at Johns Hopkins. It has been taken for granted since the first meeting that such a reappearance is desirable, for a number of reasons including increasing community, school, and personal pride, enhancing the atmosphere or "human climate," easing tension and promoting camaraderie, and eventually allowing self-scheduled exams.
The committee set as its initial goal generating a groundswell of support in favor of an honor code and establishing a timetable of reforms and steps to be taken in order to replace the current Ethics Board with an Honor Board or Court. This Court would consist entirely of students and remove faculty from having the sole responsibility and ability to file complaints. Finally, the committee wanted to draft a proposal by the end of the semester and either hold a referendum or circulate petitions as a mechanism for legitimizing the reestablishment of the Honor Code.
This was, in time, revised to focus mainly on educating the student body about the issues surrounding the reestablishment of an honor code and stimulating debate among students, with the goal of holding an open forum next semester. After a joint meeting with members of the Ethics Board (March 7), a division of duty was established such that the Ethics Board, in revising its Constitution, would implement phase I of the reform process. The committee, in turn, would handle publicity, implementation, feasibility, and education. It was felt that a gradual transition, modifying the Ethics Board back into the Honor Court it had replaced, would be more beneficial and less disruptive than abolishing the current system and establishing a new one.
Mechanisms of the Honor System
During the semester, we have been able to compare the present system with the former Johns Hopkins Honor Code as well as those of other schools such as Princeton, Haverford, Smith, and the University of Virginia. Some research was obtained on the prevalence of honor codes in U.S. colleges and universities; of the 94 schools surveyed, 32 had Honor Codes which incorporated at least three of the following criteria:
- Obligation to turn in offenders
- Unproctored exams
- Signing an honor pledge
- Trial by peers
In addition, during the committee’s earliest discussions, several key issues were identified which would have to be considered in any final proposal. Though by no means exclusive, among these issues were:
that Student Advisors and Group Leaders should have some background in their training relevant to the goals of Student Council in reviving the Honor Code and that this would be part of the first phase. Familiarity with Council recommendations and the benefits of an honor system, perhaps tied in with a genuine sense of school pride, could be discussed with freshmen upon their arrival and even before, via informational mailings by Orientation in the freshman information packet. Obviously, this would not require full knowledge of the details of implementation; such a step would be premature if taken before a general student consensus in favor of the honor system were obtained. But it is necessary, we believe, to stave off offhand comments like "it will never work," "they aren’t really serious," or the like, for it is at this time that students are most impressionable and enthusiastic; faith in the workability of the honor system must be instilled from the start for any future progress to be made.
In addition, the use of Housemasters as an influence cannot be underestimated. As the freshmen’s most consistent contact with the University after their arrival, many new students take their cues about the stringency of regulations and acceptable behavior from their Housemasters. While not implying that freshmen have no identity distinct from that developed in freshman year, or that they are solely reliant on their Housemaster in adjusting as a student in a new environment (such a conclusion would be unduly naive on our part and insulting to freshmen as a whole), our goal would be to instill a sense of seriousness in the Housemasters with respect to the honor system and convince them of its value in redirecting the attitudes of students in their houses. Further, while we would like to avoid turning Orientation into a morals and ethics seminar, we feel that students should be made aware of their responsibility for their actions with respect to ethics violations and cheating, in particular the idea that such behavior is intolerable and has only negative repercussions for all involved. Finally, this raises another point the Committee discussed, the question of time.
Time and Phasing Schedule
In consideration of the changes in student attitudes necessary in order for the system to function with maximum efficiency, it was felt that in reviving the honor system we would have to return to a longer time scale than the optimistic one presented at the beginning of the semester. It now appears that a minimum of 4 years, or the time of complete student turnover, would be necessary for maximum effectiveness, although it is true that, with student and Council support, such a system could begin operating in as few as one or two years. For this reason, we present a phased plan of implementation, one which will gradually increase the level of student responsibility for maintaining the atmosphere and tenets of the honor system and at the same time gradually relieve faculty of the same responsibility. A change in student philosophy would be encouraged during this time, such that any students still reticent about "ratting on their friends" would instead begin to see cheating as an offense just as unjustifiable as vandalism or breaking the faith implicit in a friendship. For in implementing the honor system, it must be remembered that students who sign an honor pledge sign an agreement of good faith and trust with their fellow students; a violation of such trust should not be seen as understandable, but as intolerable.
Unanswered Questions
As yet, there are still many unanswered questions as to feasability and general student consensus on the re-establishment of the honor system. While many seem to believe it is a good idea, much of the criticism focuses along the lines of "too idealistic" or a lack of faith in the ability of students to trust one another. It is the committee’s hope that these questions can be addressed in-depth next semester, both informally and perhaps even in Council. Posters to stimulate discussion and student consideration of the problems of cheating and possible solutions have been printed up and are ready for posting on campus next semester.
Publicity, as has been mentioned before, is the key. If enough emotion can be stimulated, and the students feel a genuine interest in the goals we believe that an honor system can help this campus reach, then and only then can a full exchange of ideas and constructive debate take place. For this reason, and because of the fact that we feel our job is less than complete, the committee would like to request establishment as a permanent standing committee of the Student Council, until such time as its utility and function are fulfilled.
Committee Members
Steve Basta
Anne BaughmanJeffrey S. DeCagna
Damien Doute
David Hannan
Erica Gum
Bill Henry
Ty Hyderally
Jonathan Roberts
Lora Sims
Respectfully submitted,
[handwritten: David B. Gitlitz]
David B. Gitlitz
Preliminary Phasing Plan: Honor System Re-establishment
Phase I
- Ethics Board Constitution amendments considered and adopted
- Orientation: awareness of advisors and housemasters
- Public education & debate
- Open forum
Phase II
- Pre-frosh & applicants exposed through prospectus and honor pledge on application
- Orientation: formal incorporation of honor system into program
Phase III
- Removal of faculty from Ethics Board
- Student responsibility for trials of honor violations
- Adoption of formal rules of procedure for Honor Court
Phase IV
- Full implementation: unproctored exams
- Obligation to turn in offenders, including one’s self
Sources
IMG_2721.HEIC · IMG_2722.HEIC · IMG_2723.HEIC · IMG_2724.HEIC
