JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

Mid-Semester Course Evaluations Resolution

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

Senate

of the

Student Government Association

of

Johns Hopkins University

{S. Resolution 20-21, 06}

A Resolution Formally Calling for an

Establishment of a Mid Semester Course Evaluation Procedure

Introduced By: Senator Veda Chanda and Senator Raj Bhatt

Considered this 9th Day of March in the Year 2021

Sponsored By: Senator Subha Bhatta of the Class 2022 &

Senator Ananya Kalahasti of the Class 2021

Referred to the Senate by the Committee on Academic Affairs which recommends its Passage by a vote of 5 to 0.

Whereas Hopkins wants to provide an improved classroom experience for students concerning academics and course assessment amid reports of unsatisfactory experiences regarding education at the university and foster the “intellectual passion of our extraordinarily talented faculty and students”, and

Whereas the end of semester evaluation system was conceived in the year 2011, and did not account for online learning circumstances or changing academic needs, and

Whereas with the present end of semester evaluation system, students are finding it difficult to see transparency in the process that Johns Hopkins administration utilizes in order to enact changes in departments and improve the quality of classes over time, and

Whereas the usage of mid semester course evaluations as a teaching tool are backed by significant research and reputable institutions and have shown to help improve a professor’s teaching styles and overall course satisfaction over end of semester course evaluations, and

Whereas similar mandates have been enacted at similar universities and academic institutions, including Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Vanderbilt and UNC, all of which have published industry research on the importance of student-submitted course evaluations, as well as articles in student run news networks on the important role their students play in completing these course evaluations, and

Whereas the Johns Hopkins University Whiting School of Engineering, Carey Business School and certain classes both inside and outside the department within Hopkins have already opted to hold mid-semester evaluations as a component of their feedback collection, not limited to unaccounted for, independent evaluation methods utilized by professors as a result of the lack of guidance from the administration, and

Whereas mid-semester evaluation templates already exist, generated by the Johns Hopkins University Center for Educational Resources (Ex. Template 1, Template 2) and within the SGA Committee on Academic Affairs

Whereas student preferences and circumstances surrounding learning strategies varies with each semester, and students show vocal support to adjustments in classes while they are taking the course so as to better accommodate their dynamic needs and maximize their course experience, and

Whereas students are forced to bring forward feedback individually and directly to the professor, including grievances and potential conflicts of interest, and would benefit greatly from having an organized, anonymous and less direct system with which to voice concerns during the semester, and

Whereas hosting all teaching assessment tools as an end of semester evaluation presents a bottleneck in time for both professors and students who are in the midst of grading, planning for the next semester, preparing for final exams and projects, or otherwise preparing for term break or the next academic semester, and

Whereas students taking end of semester evaluations are less likely to complete them thoroughly when they are distributed at the end of the course term, when said students can no longer reap the numerous benefits from these teaching tools in providing changes and improvements to the course, and professors/TAs are less likely to implement effective change once winter/summer break has started, and

Whereas faculty themselves would benefit greatly from having an organized repository of evaluations and feedback that shine light on opportunities they may take to improve the course, or needs that the university must step-up in order to fulfill said need.


Therefore, be it resolved that the current Office of the Registrar return to providing qualitative data from course evaluations as an integral part in choosing courses and professors that most align with those students’ academic interests, and

Be it further resolved that a mid semester evaluation system should be developed and implemented that satisfies the following criteria in order to be most effective:

Based on honest, student-sourced feedback, as opposed to inter-faculty or third party assessments, which sacrifice open communication and authenticity in order to mandate impersonal responses which may not be as useful,

Providing a balance of open-response and numerical questions, so that students have the opportunity to adequately voice comments and concerns with the course.

Utilizing an appropriate set of questions developed in collaboration with the Student Government Association Committee on Academic Affairs, and

Organized, stored and managed by each department to evaluate students’ progress and professor’s teaching effectiveness throughout the semester

Be it further recommended that the new LMS Steering Committee joined by student representative and SGA senator, Jenny Chen, as well as the developers of the new AEFIS system implement a feature for mid-semester feedback collection into their respective platforms, and

Be it further recommended that each department collect mid-semester feedback in ways that are more appropriate for their field of study in terms of the questions asked. Each department should have the flexibility to coordinate and communicate the implementation of this mid-semester evaluation and feedback system in the strongest way that benefits students within that major. This provisions multiple methods, including short forms allowing for comments and suggestions, or more extensive means than as stipulated in the current end of semester feedback form, and

Be it further recommended that the proposed mid-semester evaluation system is utilized during a median part of the semester and left open for the period of at least a week, with extensions contingent upon the professor’s discretion. Professors are strongly recommended to allocate a period of class time to present the feedback given and address any outstanding concern, or to provide the opportunity for further discussion if needed outside of instructional hours, and

Be it further recommended that the feedback that is garnered from the evaluation system is utilized in some meaningful way to improve the course for students and enact changes that allow for enhanced and streamlined teaching for the professor.

Be it further resolved that a copy of this resolution be transmitted to:

Provost and Senior Vice President of Academic Affairs, Sunil Kumar

Vice Dean of the Krieger School of Arts and Sciences for Undergraduate Education, Joel Schildbach

Vice Dean of the Whiting School of Engineering for Undergraduate Education, Michael Falk

Executive Vice Provost for Academic Affairs, Stephen Gange

Associate Vice Provost for Education, Janet Schreck

Dean of the Krieger School of Arts and Sciences, Christopher S. Celenza

Dean of the Whiting School of Engineering, Ed Schlesinger

Deputy University Registrar, Craig Smith

Associate Registrar for Catalogue, Course and Classroom Scheduling, Courtney Resnick

Appropriate Department Chairs within KSAS and WSE


The Resolution hereby PASSED by a vote of 21 to 0 with 0 abstentions.

Upon adoption, we have hereunto set our hands and caused the seal of the Senate to be affixed to this resolution indicating the senate’s assent and thus officially designating the resolution’s adoption as the position and will of the Senate and the Student Body of The Johns Hopkins University..

Signatures of Enactment:


Sam Mollin

Executive President of the Johns Hopkins SGA


Mehak Ali

President of the Senate

Executive Vice President of the Johns Hopkins SGA


Breanna Soldatelli

Executive Secretary of the Johns Hopkins SGA


Addy Perlman

Executive Treasurer of the Johns Hopkins SGA

Signatures of Ceremony:


Veda Chanda

Co-Chair on the Committee of Academic Affairs

Senator of the Class of 2022


Raj Bhatt

Senator of the Class of 2024

Sources

Mid-Semester Course Evaluations Resolution.docx