JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

Senate Meeting #16 (3 6 18)

Filed in Drive as “Senate Meeting #16 (3_6_18)”

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

SENATE OF THE JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY STUDENT GOVERNMENT ASSOCIATION

Consolidated General Body Meeting Agenda and Minutes

March 6th, 2018

7:00 PM to 9:00 PM, Charles Commons East Room

Agenda

Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)

Approval of the Agenda & Prior Minutes (1 min)

Presentations (35 min)

JHU Commission on the Status of Women and Vision 2020 [Report Card Link] — Dr. Anne-Elizabeth Brodsky, Senior Lecturer in Writing Seminars (15 min)

Free Expression Guidelines Q&A — Dr. Moses Davis, Associate Dean of Diversity and Inclusion (15 min)

Alumna of Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School (5 min)

New Business (Acceded by Motion, 65 minutes)

CSE Constitution Follow-Up and Ratification [Link] — Howard Senior, Chris Pak (15 min)

STRUT Fashion Show Funding Bill [Link] — Former Senator Liam Haviv, President Boutros, Vice President Tsang (10 min)

Zachary Steinberg Memorial Tournament Funding Bill [Link] — Senator Williams, President Schatmeyer (10 min)

SHIP Funding Bill [Link] — President Schatmeyer (10 min)

Tobacco Survey Funding Bill [Link] — Senator Williams (10 min)

Humari Awaaz Funding Bill [Link] — Secretary Doshi (10 min)

EMERGENCY DISCUSSION: Administration’s Police Force Proposal (15 min)

Objective: Determine questions for next week’s visit from Provost Kumar, Director Presberry, and Vice Provost Shollenberger.

Reports (16 min) — IF 8:45 OR EARLIER, ELSE SKIP; THIS SECTION DELAYED DUE TO JHU POLICE FORCE CRISIS

Executive Board Reports (2 min)

Committee Reports (7 min)

Academic Affairs — Senator Teka

Civic Engagement — President Boutros

Finance — Senator Mansuria

Health, Safety and Sustainability — President Panakam

Internal Affairs — President Boutros/Senator Chien (Co-chairs)

Student Organizations — Senator Chien

Student Services — Senator Cigarroa

Class Councils Reports (4 min)

Advisor Report (3 min)

Prospective Business (5 min)

Advancing Legislation

Student Center Resolution & Op-Ed [Resolution Link / Op-Ed Link] — Vice President Tsang, Senator Cigarroa and President Schatmeyer

Parkland Solidarity Resolution [Resolution Link / Presentation Link] — Vice President Tsang, President Boutros, Senators Williams and Paulet

Announcements

Public Input Period

Adjournment — ESTIMATED 9:00 PM, ACTUAL 9:25 PM (CLOSED SESSION AT 8:55 PM)

Minutes

Call to Order & Roll Call (1 min)

Approval of the Agenda & Prior Minutes (1 min)

Presentations (35 min)

JHU Commission on the Status of Women and Vision 2020 [Report Card Link] — Dr. Anne-Elizabeth Brodsky, Senior Lecturer in Writing Seminars (15 min)

Blog ties in issues/topics that ties in Hopkins community with gender/cultural topics

Report card provides comprehensive overview of 800+ page report on Vision 2020 - what has been implemented and what has not

Maternity Leave has been addressed - everything else has not. For example, childcare at the Y has 30 empty spots for Hopkins affiliates that are not being used.

Discussion

How can SGA help?

Engage students to raise student interest

Be observant of professor behavior in terms of discrimination

Connect with other Hopkins organizations that deal with gender issues

Free Expression Guidelines Q&A — Dr. Moses Davis, Associate Dean of Diversity and Inclusion (15 min)

Q: We have concerns about having guidelines on something like free expression. It leaves a lot of leeway for the administration to say what is and what is not a right protest. Concerns about clauses about disrupting academic or public spaces.

Students have a right to protest, but other students also have a right to learn. For example, protesting in a classroom. Another example - if a student organization reserved the beach for an event and another group decided to protest, it would be unfair to the first group.

Q. Need to address fact that reserving a school space can only be done by a student organization with 10 business days.

He will get back to us after doing some research.

Q: Could we do something like a “die in” protest?

Yes. Use me as a resource for the protest but you are not required to register this. You can use me to figure out logistical issues and help figure out things to watch out for.

Kwame: We need real action/response from the school after a “real” protest to show that they are serious. We need trust to be earned instead of false promises.

Clarissa: What are the repercussions of violating the guidelines? When we hear guidelines, we hear rules and not suggestions.

We are not looking for ways to penalize students for having a voice. They are actual guidelines, not rules.

Noh: Vagueness of article hurts the article. There is no clear pro-protest aspect of it for students. Having a more clear, concise and beneficial (to students) guideline will help.

Tatiana: We speak for both current and future students. This sets a precedent and while Moses Davis may be pro-protest, someone down the line may be anti-protest and may hurt students.

Kush: Reminds me of branding guidelines. You can’t have guidelines without consequences. Having guidelines about how to have a protest seems intrinsically problematic.

Moses: Will take all comments into consideration. Please use me as a resource or e-mail me with any concerns or suggestions.

Alumna of Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School (5 min)

Interested in making a (printed) banner that expresses Hopkins support for MSD. If anyone is interested, should reach out and work as a group.

EMERGENCY DISCUSSION: Administration’s Police Force Proposal (15 min)

Objective: Determine questions for next week’s visit from Provost Kumar, Director Presberry, and Vice Provost Shollenberger.

Motion to have a closed discussion passed

New Business (65 min)

CSE Constitution Follow-Up and Ratification [Link] — Howard Senior, Chris Pak (15 min)

Changes:

Clarified Art. 2 about membership - made more discrete positions (see below for actual positions)

Art. 3 - Elected to go with registrar's definition for second or first year (to eliminate ambiguous language)

Art. 6 - Implementation of the electoral result. Using plurality vote method to decrease the amount of time necessary of a runoff.

Transitioning to a ranked ballot method. We are now giving people the opportunity to rank candidates (do not have to rank all candidates, can write-in a candidate). Eliminates possibility of a runoff. Guarantees that we do not need to hold multiple elections.

Modified version of process for senatorial election procedures: Droop quota

Each voter gets one vote, rank which senator they like from most to least. If any candidates exceed this quota, then they are elected to office. If no one has exceeded the quota, then we use the IRV method to eliminate based on lowest rank.

Art. 7 - should any part of constitution be ruled unconstitutional, it is severable but the rest of the constitution remains in effect. Any CSE decisions are “common law”

Open to candidates to send delegations (1 person) to the vote counting process to figure out exactly what is going on.

Discussion:

When the e-mail goes out that shows how many votes each candidate got, how will this work?

Depending on how many times to process has iterated, you will arrive at a final percentage (% of people who have expressed interest in the candidate)

What are the discrete positions that have been clarified?

Chairman of committee - lias with SGA (in the future) and deal with SLI

Vice-chair - stands in for chair

Secretary - takes notes

Treasurer - SLI for funding purposes

Kwame: How can we make sure that people are actually ranking the candidates (and not just picking one person)?

Found video that explains process that can be included in voting platform

Constitution has been passed 15-1.

STRUT Fashion Show Funding Bill [Link] — Former Senator Liam Haviv, President Boutros, Vice President Tsang (10 min)

IDEAL - each chapter does media, campus programming, community engagement. Want to build a civic engagement program for students at Druid High and other community partners. Want this program to establish something within larger Baltimore city proper that will be built for and by these students.

Saran is doing a lot of incredible work with young girls and boys to build their confidence. In particular, STRUT is a way for young girls/boys to gain confidence, raise funds, and to increase community respect for this organization

Need SGA support for IDEAL, and to fund fashion show with $173.37 (3/10 7-10 PM). IDEAL will pay for transportation.

Discussion:

In the future, please send in finance bills with advance notice so they have adequate time to discuss the bill before meeting.

Bill has been passed.

Zachary Steinberg Memorial Tournament Funding Bill [Link] — Senator Williams, President Schatmeyer (10 min)

JSA has reached out to SGA to fund memorial basketball tournament. Ask that we pay for water bottles for the teams and to give out ($342.00).

Bill has been passed.

SHIP Funding Bill [Link] — President Schatmeyer (10 min)

Hosting a competition to come together in teams of ten to measure how much water and energy can be conserved through SaveOhno. Want to have prizes (Patagonias - $500).

Kush: Finance does not currently recommend passing this bill. $50 Patagonias for ten people is not a proper use of SGA funds.

Motion to table bill has been approved.

Hopkins Kicks Butts Funding Bill [Link] — Senator Williams (10 min)

Consistent criticisms - no empirical data to gauge student body opinion. One of the pushes is to determine what the student body’s perspectives are in an IPV manner. Want to have student body to vote on policies they like the most (after doing research with peer schools). Bill will support a survey to have this data.

Motion to table bill has been approved.

Humari Awaaz Funding Bill [Link] — Secretary Doshi (10 min)

Reports (16 min) — IF 8:45 OR EARLIER, ELSE SKIP; THIS SECTION DELAYED DUE TO JHU POLICE FORCE CRISIS

Executive Board Reports (2 min)

Noh:

AJ:

Mi:

Rushabh:

Committee Reports (7 min)

Academic Affairs — Senator Teka

Civic Engagement — President Boutros

Finance — Senator Mansuria

Health, Safety and Sustainability — President Panakam

Internal Affairs — President Boutros/Senator Chien (Co-chairs)

Student Organizations — Senator Chien

Student Services — Senator Cigarroa

Class Councils Reports (4 min)

Seniors:

Juniors:

Sophomores:

Freshmen:

Advisor Report (3 min)

Prospective Business (5 min)

Advancing Legislation

Student Center Resolution & Op-Ed [Resolution Link / Op-Ed Link] — Vice President Tsang, Senator Cigarroa and President Schatmeyer

Parkland Solidarity Resolution [Resolution Link / Presentation Link] — Vice President Tsang, President Boutros, Senators Williams and Paulet

Announcements

Public Input Period

Adjournment — ESTIMATED 9:00 PM

Sources

Senate Meeting #16 (3_6_18).docx