JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

America and the Immigrant Experience - Letter to Mr. Chris Colombo, Director, Student Services

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

America and the Immigrant Experience

“Keep, ancient lands, your storied pomp!” Cries sheWith silent lips. “Give me your tired, your poor,Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me.I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”

4th December 1981

Mr. Chris Colombo

Director, Student Activities

Levering Hall, JHU

Dear Chris:

A few weeks back I had conveyed to you, in writing, some of my concerns about the Milton S. Eisenhower Symposium. I am now taking the opportunity to tender to you, and the Ad Hoc Eisenhower Review Committee appointed by the Student Coucil, my final thoughts about the Symposium. I suggest that these remarks/recommendations be considered tentative, in view of the fact that the Symposium has only recently concluded, and that wisdom comes only with retrospection. Nonetheless, even if these remarks express my immediate feelings, the Student Council and the Committee would be well-advised to give them due consideration.

The Symposium was instituted in 1967. At that time, students and younger people were very much involved in fomenting what may loosely be called 'social change'. The first few symposiums reflected the concerns of the '60s in addressing such issues as violence, urban change, and the like. The Symposium was thus given a certain momentum which it later lost and never recovered. No issue, unless it be the threat of nuclear war, is likely to create much interest in our times. The Committee appointed by the Student Coucil should bear in mind the history of the Symposium in its deliberations.

The 1981 Eisenhower Symposium, as you know, was plagued by poor attendance. The most important consideration for the chairmen should be the selection of speakers. This year the majority of the students felt that the speakers were not famous personalities or, as one person said, "big names". This feeling is adequately conveyed in one <u>Newsletter</u> article, entitled "Obscure Speakers Diminish Size of Symposium Crowds". One undergraduate was quoted to the effect that "this year there are no bona fide stars such as John Anderson. They have instead Harvard professor Orlando Patterson. Who knows Orlando Patterson?" Another student claimed he went only for the food -- as if we were serving steaks, instead of lousy cookies. These remarks are not merely demoralizing to the chairmen. Rather, they serve as an

The Johns Hopkins University

Levering Hall/SAC OfficeBaltimore, Md. 21218Tel., (301) 338-8208

The Milton S. Eisenhower Symposium 1981

Chairmen:

Vinay Lal

Tobias Steed

Rohit Bhatnagar

Mr. Chris Colombo

indicator of the intellectual interests of the average Hopkins student. The Symposium has a choice to invite either speakers who are popular, even though ill-informed, or the most knowledgeable people on a given topic. Last year -- and I keep on reverting to this example -- Norman Vincent Peale was one of the participants in the Symposium on the "Crisis of the American Spirit." I don't believe Mr. Peale has had anything new to say in the last thirty years; besides, the university, which should serve as a forum for debating the most fundamental questions in a reasonable manner, is not the appropriate place for a speaker like Mr. Peale. If a local Baltimore club had sponsored him, that would be acceptable. "Big names" are only likely to act as advertising columns for the university. Professor Mr. Gordon Wolman, who attended the lecture by Father Hesburgh and declared it to be an "excellent talk" in a letter to the chairmen, has succinctly described the difficulty that every symposium has faced: "A good topic and excellent knowledgeable speakers versus a flashy topic and popular spokesmen represents a conflict which will never go away. Neither this symposium nor any other gathering seems able to combat a busy clientele and glamour. . . . I would have thought that Father Hesburgh encompassed both knowledgeability and visibility. I was wrong even there."

Despite the fact that this year's Symposium brought to Hopkins the most well-informed people in the country to address themselves to the manifold aspects and ramifications of the immigrant experience in America, attendance was extremely poor. The speakers [illegible] collectively represented the most important sectors of society, including government, church, business, and education. It seems conclusive to me that students do not wish to be enlightened; they are looking, like other less privileged people, for entertainment, or for mere future job satisfaction. This in itself is a comment on the value of a university education. I regret having to pass such an unfavorable judgment on my peers, but honesty demands no less.

I have so far neglected to touch upon the structure of the symposium. It is my view that one person alone should be ultimately responsible for the organization and direction of the symposium. Three associate chairmen, appointed either by the Committee, the Student Council, or the chairman himself, should each handle one of the three most significant aspects of the Symposium: speakers, funding, and publicity. In addition, two or more part-time secretaries should be hired (work-study students perhaps) to take care of the paper-work. Such a structure would facilitate the management of the symposium, and would necessitate the presence of the entire staff throughout the summer at Hopkins. For instance, funding usually lasts from March to May/June, provided that the students are diligent. The associate chairman responsible for funding could finish by June, whereupon the associate chairman responsible for publicity would resume his duties. The chairman should guide the associate chairmen, assisting them in their decisions, and do the required work in the absence of the associate chairmen. I am aware that such an arrangement is not likely to appeal to chairmen.

The Milton S. Eisenhower Symposium 1981

The Johns Hopkins University

Levering Hall/SAC OfficeBaltimore, Md. 21218Tel., (301) 338-8208

Chairmen:

Vinay Lal

Tobias Steed

Rohi Bhatnagar

Sources

IMG_2481.HEIC · IMG_2482.HEIC · IMG_2486.HEIC