An Open Letter to Admissions, Postgraduate Opportunities in response to COVID-19
Dear Association of American Universities,
We hope this letter finds you well in good health and safety.
We, the undersigned representatives from ______ Universities across the country, urge the association to endorse the following amendments to graduate school admission policies such that they account for the unprecedented challenges undergraduates have faced during the COVID-19 pandemic.
In particular, we ask that the admissions offices and professionals of associated institutions:
Evaluate Spring 2020 applicants with the widespread effects of COVID-19 in mind
Do not penalize students who have opted, or were required, to take classes pass-fail
Do not rescind pre-existing offers solely based on Spring 2020 grades
Lighten or remove GPA cutoffs for eligibility of specific programs
Lower thresholds for standardized test scores and prioritize holistic applicant review for both undergraduate and graduate admissions
COVID-19 has significantly impacted students’ wellbeing and learning environments. Its effects include detriments to physical and mental health, food/financial insecurities, rapid change in environment, lack of academic resources, and reduction of support services.
Students have experienced significant difficulty in the following areas:
Adapting to the Online Learning Environment
Just as not all classes have transferred online seamlessly, not all learners can be expected to easily adapt to a fully online format, with little to no prior warning. Therefore, it is nearly impossible to accurately assess students’ performance in these classes to the same extent as prior to COVID-19. Many online classes are asynchronous and no longer have the same level of interaction between students, professors, and teaching assistants (laboratory classes no longer have experiments, seminars without discussions etc…). The result of which is students not being able to fully earn the material, undeniably makes examinations and coursework all the more challenging.
Adapting to Physical Displacement
For many students, returning to their family homes may elicit stress in the forms of (1) newfound family responsibilities; (2) inability to find quiet space necessary for virtual lectures or to complete assignments; (3) need to care for themselves and loved ones who may have been exposed to/are suffering from COVID-19; (4) need to financially support themselves or family who have lost jobs due to layoffs associated with COVID-19; (5) food and housing insecurity brought on by such financial insecurity; (6) exacerbation of mental and emotional harm due to reminders of physical or verbal abuse. Some students may also face anxiety and potential grief from loss of life surrounding the disease.
Adapting to Limited Academic Resources
Many universities making the switch to online learning have not had an opportunity to fully transition important campus resources such as writing centers and library access. Even with resource centers that have made this transition, students rely on peer-to-peer tutoring in the forms of Teaching Assistant sessions and informal assistance from classmates and professors. Teaching Assistants and professors, however, are themselves managing the stressors of displacement, something that is likely to impact the consistency and quality of tutoring services and office hours. Moreover, students who were asked to abruptly leave their campuses were also forced to leave behind study materials and books that are essential to classroom success.
Adapting to Time Zone Inconsistencies
International peers asked to return home now face the burden of unreasonable class hours for synchronous learning, including late at night (11-12 P.M.) and early in the morning (3-4 A.M.). Although many universities have attempted to enact policies protecting international students from these expectations, students across the country have observed professors blatantly ignoring such efforts by requiring that students be present in their courses, or by refusing to record their classes. Such class times pose unreasonable burdens for students who must readjust their entire schedules or miss lessons vital to their academic success.
Variable Pass-Fail Policies
Every school’s P/F policy is unique and dependent upon the institution's approach to academics. That so many institutions are offering academic accommodations in the form of modified P/F policies indicates the severity of the global situation with which we are faced. The P should serve as a relief to students regardless of their situation. And yet, with some _______________ refusing to accept the P provided by some institutions' policies, students now find themselves in a position where they must choose between (1) their health and wellbeing and (2) their future pursuits. This is unacceptable. Students should not have to risk their health to prove their “resilience” to graduate schools.
We also emphasize that the students who are most likely to opt-into P/F are also those who have been most affected by COVID-19 or hold historically marginalized identities. Schools that accept pass/fail grading if universities only award pass/fail grades, or give preference to letter grades if they are offered, unjustly disadvantage the most vulnerable students who may be going home unstable home environments, childcare responsibilities, or additional work for an income, among many other factors. Pass/fail policies were enacted to enable students to prioritize the health and wellbeing of themselves and family members while also taking into account the unexpected burden of sudden changes. As such, students should not be penalized for having a P on their transcript, regardless of whether their school had a mandatory or opt-in P/F system.
Taken together, these uncontrollable circumstances prevent students from prioritizing and achieving their academic pursuits at the same level. Due to the irremediable nature of these barriers to students' academic success, we believe that _______________ must take a compassionate approach to the admissions and evaluations process at this time.
We hope that _______________ supports these changes to the benefit of its future students. Flexibility when reviewing Spring 2020 grades, acceptance of pass/fail courses without any penalty to admission, and lightened or abolished GPA cutoffs are critical in ensuring equity and accessibility during this uncertain time of global pandemic.
Sincerely,
Truman Fritz, Student Body President (2020-2021), University of Southern California
Trenton Stone, Student Body President (2019-2020), University of Southern California
Joshua Crow, Student Body President, University of Connecticut
Robert Blake Watson, Student Body President, UCLA
William Zhou, Student Body President, Brown University
Anna Margaret Clyburn, Student Body President (2020-2021), Rice University
Grace Wickerson, Student Body President (2019-2020), Rice University
Ranen Miao, Student Body President, Washington University in St. Louis
David Rivero, Student Body President, Texas Tech University
Jakiyah Bradley, Student Body President, New York University
Marin Exler, Case Western Reserve University
Aimee Trevino, Student Body President, St. Mary’s UniversityEdward Doan, Student Body President, Lamar University
Johnson Lin, Student Body President, Claremont McKenna College
Kyle Grace, Student Body President, Harvey Mudd College
Andy Theocharous, Student Body Executive Vice President, UC Berkeley
Eleanor Grudin, Associated Students President, UC San Diego
From AAU, we are missing:
Contacts
Subject: [Action Requested] National Student Gov Letter re COVID-19
Hi Student Government Leader,
Hope you are doing well! We’re reaching out on behalf of the student governments at Rice, USC, NYU, Brown, and WashU looking for your support.
In addition to our schools, several Student Body Presidents have come together to write two letters (attached) calling for various accommodations and policy changes to support students during COVID-19. We would greatly appreciate your signature to help with advocacy.
These two letters below:
- An Open Letter to Admissions, Postgraduate Opportunities in response to COVID-19 to:
Evaluate Spring 2020 applicants with the widespread effects of COVID-19 in mind
Do not penalize students who have opted, or were required, to take classes pass-fail
Do not rescind pre-existing offers solely based on Spring 2020 grades
Lighten or remove GPA cutoffs for eligibility of specific programs
Lower thresholds for standardized test scores and prioritize holistic applicant review for both undergraduate and graduate admissions
- An Open Letter to Expand Telehealth Support Access Across State Lines
Mandate the suspension of interstate regulations on counseling services governed by state medical boards so that those who are licensed and in good standing in any state can practice without civil or criminal penalty given the following COVID-19 mental health-related consequences
Expand the telemental health practitioner definition to include any professional, paraprofessional, or unlicensed behavioral health staff who deliver a qualified service via telemental health.
You signing on as a representative of thousands of your peers will help put the pressure of these agencies to change their policies. We urge you to read these letters, consult your student governments, and if you are in favor fill out the form below to become one of the signatories.
Thank you for everything that you do for students. Feel free to reach out for questions!
Take Care,
Former Rice Student Body President Grace Wickerson (mgw4@rice.edu), current Rice Student Body President Anna Margaret Clyburn (ricesapres@gmail.com), USC President Truman Fritz (trumanfr@usc.edu), NYU President Jakiyah Bradley (jeb765@nyu.edu), Brown President Will Zhou (william_zhou@brown.edu), and WashU President Ranen Miao (ranenmiao@gmail.com)
Organizations:
Internships/Full-Time Employment
More prestigious firms/organizations that have large applicant pools have GPA cutoffs or minimums (e.g. must have 3.2 or above to apply)
Coalition of Graduate Schools
Council of graduate students
Fulbright Scholarship Commission
Rhodes Scholar Commission
Marshall Aid Commemoration Commission
Cambridge Scholars Commission
Watson Fellowship Commission
Goldwater Scholarship
Truman Scholarship
Knight-Hennessy Scholarship
Other Big Fellowships?
National institute of health/science
Association of American Universities
Association of American Medical Colleges
Association of American Law Schools
