Summary Of 2017 OIE Report
Growth at OIE
Over the Past two years there has been a significant increase in the number of reports to OIE, including nearly double the amount of sexual misconduct reports. OIE has attributed this rise in reports to an increase in student awareness of OIE and the services they provide, as well as efforts made by the university to lower the stigma surrounding sexual misconduct. In response to this increase OIE has increased its staff from 7 to 13 full-time employees.
Policies and Training
In 2017, the University launched a new initiative to train the student body, faculty, and staff in Title IX and Harassment Prevention, including training on policies and procedures related to sexual misconduct, harassment, and discrimination. As of October 2018, 645 of faculty and 79% of staff had completed this training.
Students receive training in the following ways: a required sexual misconduct training module completed before arrival on campus, bystander intervention training, and orientation presentations in which presenters discuss sexual violence prevention. Students also must take part in a mandatory workshop on diversity and inclusion.
The University will revise its training policies based on the results of the 2018 Climate Survey on Sexual Misconduct, the COACHE faculty survey and the Gallup employee survey.
Status of Reports Received in 2017
When the OIE receives a report of sexual misconduct or protected class discrimination or harassment, a staff member contacts the person filing the complainant to provide resources and information about the complaint process, offer additional details and discuss options for the process and support in the interim.
Before the OIE proceeds with any action on the matter, it first determines if a report is considered a case under the following three requirements: 1) the OIE has authority over subject matter and the respondent of the report; 2) the complaint requires some university response or engagement; and 3) the OIE is able to gather sufficient additional information. Once a case is determined, the OIE conducts an assessment and concludes if a case will be either closed after assessment, moved onto informal resolution or a formal investigation will be conducted.
Even if a report fails to meet the requirements of a case, the OIE preserves records of the report. Resources and support are offered and the case can generally be reopened at any time with the introduction of new information or by the complainant’s request for further assessment.
In 2017 out of the 25,513 JHU students and 24,401 JHU employees the OIE served, it received 410 reports, 154 of which were classified as cases. Informal resolution was used to resolve 13 cases, 63 cases were closed after assessment and formal investigation proceeded in 78 cases. Within the cases moved onto formal resolution 47 were resolved, 9 were determined as OIE process complete, and in 22 cases the OIE process is still ongoing.
Overall 256 reports were closed without becoming active cases. This is due to a number of reasons. In 37 reports the complainant could not be reached and the OIE was not able to proceed further. 75 reports involved a respondent whom the OIE had no authority over. In these instances, the OIE offered resources and implemented interim measures. 60 reports involved complainants who did not want to move forward with the report. 60 reports were determined to have provided insufficient information. 24 reports were referred to another university department for appropriate action under other policies.
In 2017, sexual misconduct reports comprised 63% of all misconduct reports. In addition, protected-class discrimination or harassment comprised of 29% of misconduct cases. Sexual misconduct reports were sorted into seven categories: sexual harassment at 37%, sexual assault at 33%, stalking at 10%, multiple forms of sexual misconduct at 7%, domestic/dating violence at 6%, sexual misconduct and protected class at 5%, and retaliation at 0.4%.
Within the reports of protected class discrimination and harassment, discrimination/harassment types experienced in order of most to least prevalent included that based on race, gender/sex, disability, religion, national origin, race and gender/sex, pregnancy, ethnicity, sexual orientation, age, retaliation and veteran status. 31% reported discrimination/harassment involving multiple protected classes.
In the reports of sexual misconduct in 2017, the majority of cases, 62%, were filed by a student, 21% were filed by staff, 16% by non affiliate and unknown entities and 1% by faculty. The respondents in these reports were 36% students, 27% staff, 32% non affiliate and unknown and 5% were faculty. Overall, students reports make up the largest amount of cases.
In reports of protected class discrimination the greatest percentage of complainants were staff at 46%. 26% of complainants were students, 7% faculty, 21% non affiliate and unknown, and 1% multiple affiliations. The majority of respondents were staff at 62%. 11% of respondents were students,11% faculty, 11% non affiliate and unknown, and 4% had multiple affiliations.
Of the 410 cases reported to OIE, 154 cases moved on to assessment or formal investigation. At the end of an assessment or investigation of a case, OEI prepares an assessment summary or investigation report. Investigation reports are given to a three person resolution panel organized by Student Affairs, the respondent academic division, or Human resources depending on whether the respondent is a student, faculty member, or staff, along with a recommendation of action if needed. The panel then reviews the information and makes decisions on sanctions and disciplinary actions. Even if there is not a direct policy violation found, there still may be a recommendation for actions such as training or counseling for the respondent.
Of the cases involving sexual misconduct, 38% of the complainants were students, 33% were staff, and 29% had no affiliation or an unknown affiliation to the university. Of the respondents to these cases, 38% were students, 43% were staff, 7% were faculty, and 12% had no affiliation or an unknown affiliation to the university. In cases involving protected-class discrimination and harassment, 47% of complainants were staff, 24% were students, 9% were faculty, and 20% had no affiliation or an unknown affiliation to the university. Of the respondents to discrimination cases, 66% were staff, 13% were faculty, 9% were students, 7% had multiple affiliations, and 6% had no affiliation or unknown affiliations to the university.
Outcomes of Cases Closed in 2017
In 2017, OEI closed 148 cases of sexual misconduct and protected-class discrimination with either an assessment, an informal resolution for formal investigation. Of the 80 sexual misconduct cases closed, 50% resulted in an assessment, 16% resulted in an informal resolution, and 34% resulted in a formal investigation. Of this 34%, 20% of formal investigations found no evidence of policy violations. Of the 68 discrimination and harassment cases closed in 2017, 37% resulted in an assessment, 1% in an informal resolution, and 61% in a formal investigation. Only 9% of the formal investigations found evidence of a policy violation.
Some of the actions taken by the university as a result of formal investigations which found there to be a policy violation included: expulsion, suspension, disciplinary probations, access restrictions, termination or removal from position, suspension without pay, educational sanctions, and required counseling. Some individuals received more than one of these sanctions.
The average time to close a case was 128 days. The average time to close cases which resulted in an informal resolution or assessment was 70 days, while the average time to close cases which resulted in a formal investigation was 194 days. Some common reasons for extending investigations included: complexity of cases, delayed participation by the parties involved, witness participation, investigator caseload, and academic calendar conflicts (breaks, exam periods, etc.).
Commentary and Policy Recommendations
While the PRDC recognizes the efforts of OIE to expand their outreach and raise student awareness of their services, we believe it would be beneficial to investigate the reasons behind the rise in rate of reporting before attributing it solely to these efforts. A possible way to gather information on student awareness of OIE and its services would be to include questions regarding this on the Climate Survey on Sexual Misconduct.
Furthermore, in order to ensure that students are not only aware of OIE and its services but also the processes and procedures behind filing a report, we recommend that a presentation be given to all incoming freshmen on this process. This will work to aid in reducing the stigma and uncertainty surrounding filing reports of sexual misconduct and harassment.
The PRDC recommends an effort to decrease protected class discrimination within the University’s staff (the group with the highest rates of discrimination reports) through mandatory diversity and inclusion training for all staff members.
The PRDC also recommends a mandatory sexual misconduct training for undergraduate students during their junior year. Students make up the majority of sexual misconduct reports, and while there is a large effort to educate students on sexual misconduct throughout their freshman year, these efforts stop once students move on to their sophomore, junior, and senior years. Continuing the conversation on sexual misconduct throughout the following years of student's time at Hopkins will foster an environment of constant awareness and open dialogue surrounding sexual assault and harassment, which will in turn lower the rate of sexual misconduct.
