Monday, November 9, 202612:00 PM – 1:00 PMSan Martin Center, Room 200A
In attendance (Quorum):
- Aliza Watters - Associate Dean for the undergraduate curriculum, writing sems (Presiding Officer)
- Jesse Rosenthal (Co-chair) - English department, KSAS Faculty Senator (Co-Chair)
- Mike Bhader - Director of undergrad studies
- Jesse Appel -
- Danielle Evans- president of writing seminar
- James Loeffler - history, undergraduate studies
AGENDA
12:00 – 12:05 Introductions (SGA Undergraduate Representatives, Boyi Chen and Aishani Garg) and approval of the minutes from the 10/12/26 meeting
12:05 – 12:35 Faculty Survey on Grade Inflation (draft attached and in SharePoint)
Addressing Grade Inflation - what IS the question of grade inflation?
- is it a problem?
- Faculty opinion?
- Can we get this sentiment through a survey?
- See attached
What is the goal for this survey?
- We know that grades have gone up, thats a fact
- Are students are given the grades they think they should be given?
- Have personal grading factors changed? Is there discomfort in the fact that it has changed?
- If everyone is prepared, ofc there will be higher grades (technically an inflation)
- Debating whether to add Jerry Burgess' proposed additional questions
- Trying to reduce friction for survey completion
- People here for different times
There is a federal request to address this (NOT ADDRESS, CONSIDER?)Peer institutions haveProbably statements about how this benefits and hurts faculty standards
- these will be anecdotal and uninformed
- Collection of faculty sentiment
- How will this look across different departments? Would applying the same standard across all disciplines work? Is intervention helpful?
Look at the Harvard grade inflation survey (faculty attitudes)
- Why didn't they fully do this?
- Wanted a certain type of information
How will this affect students?
- Depending on the decision made-
Federal Request to consider grade inflation? (national call to action)This survey is only to gather opinion and have a concrete thing to analyze, not being reactive.
Changing grade inflation to grade compression. What does this really mean?
12:35 – 12:45 AI Teaching Practices (Started 12:49pm)
Conversations about AI
- Student involvement with AI
- Discipline, academic honesty, and policy
- AI teaching practices
- Short-term discussion - how you write policy on your syllabus, heres some options to consider
- Long-term discussion -
Looking at disciplinary actions of using AI in work
- What do you do when someone has clearly violated the policy?
- Consistency between departments?
What is it that you're trying to teach in your classes?
- Not what you do, but why you do it?
- Making goals for the class more clear for undergraduate students?
Bhader wants - Send stuff to a different department that looks at ALL violations.
- enforced consistently
- didnt go into this profession to become cops
How is language flagged? What checking system is being used?
- Is this a policy violation or ethics violation? Hard to have a centralized office
12:45 – 1:00 Updates on ongoing work
