JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← All documents

COFHE Schools Report_Wings-WGR-DOSL

This document is from a previous session and is kept for the record. It may have been amended or replaced since.

COHFE Schools Report: Menstrual Products in Bathrooms Initiative July 25, 2019 A collaborative initiative led by Wings, JHU Office of Women & Gender Resources, and JHU Office of the Dean of Student Life Wings Representatives: Bridget Chen, Lina Kim, Chanel Lee, Emily Sturm WGR: Jeannine Heynes Ph.D.

Office of DOSL: Wendy Geist, Smita Ruzicka, Ph.D.

Contents

I. Introduction and Background 2 II. Summary of COHFE School Data and Discussion of Relevant Challenges 4

i. Brown University 5 ii. Princeton University 6 iii. University of Pennsylvania 7 iv. Cornell University 7

v. Yale University 8 III. Budget Projections of Pilot Program 9 IV. Brief Overview of Pilot Program Organization 9

V. Dispensers vs. Baskets Discussion 10 VI. List of Bathrooms being Supplied 10 VII. Funding 11 VIII. Student Volunteer Product Distribution System 11 IX. Next Steps – Moving Forward 11

Introduction and Background Information on the Menstrual Products Initiative Menstruation is a natural human function that deserves to be regarded as a health and equity issue. Currently, menstrual products are not provided in any restrooms across the Homewood campus, even though many students, staff and faculty spend exceedingly long hours in many campus buildings, including the Brody Learning Commons, student and research labs such as NCBI, UTL, Remsen, office buildings such as Wyman and Garland Hall, and other highly-frequented buildings on campus. By not making menstrual products available in any of these places, it strongly insinuates that menstrual needs, needs of more than half of the campus population, are not important enough to be prioritized by the university and reinforces the idea that menstrual needs are an issue that must be discreetly managed by the individual themself, on their own time, means, and efforts, even if it means missing time out of class or studying to take care of those needs.

This issue has been brought to the attention of student administration and faculty on several separate occasions, to name a few: SGA wrote a bill in 2016 to get this conversation started, and separately, professor of Whiting School of Engineering, Dr. Erica Schoenberger was appalled by a student needing to leave mid-class to hastily rush home to retrieve menstrual care items and reached out to her network of faculty to also start the dialogue.

In all cases, this expresses unfair treatment and bias towards a specific gender.

In Fall of 2018, Wings, in collaboration with the Student Government Association (SGA), diligently planned, led, and prepared for student-run “Menstrual Products in JHU Bathrooms Initiative”, the university’s first effort to provide menstrual products free of charge in select restrooms all across campus. This process evolved into a meeting on March 3rd, 2019, that brought together representatives of Wings and administration to discuss the issue and the potential in an institutionally based pilot program as well as a long term one. The meeting had the audience of David Ashwood (Plant Operations), Dean Smita Ruzicka (Dean of Student Life), Jeanine Boyd (Custodial Services), Cecilia Etzel (Facilities), Jeannine Heynes (Women & Gender Resources), and representatives of Finance and Administration, among others. The conclusion of this meeting was the formation of a committee consisting of Wings representatives, WGR and Office of DOSL, joined in the process of moving forward, gathering data, preparing for the next steps of this process. Most immediately is a report on COHFE schools and their menstrual products initiatives.

In this report, we intend to demonstrate that there has been significant action among our peer COHFE universities starting as early as 2016 and reaching a peak of action in the past year. The act of supplying free products in bathrooms in the recent years has not been unprecedented. We have role models at institutions like University of Wisconsin that has introduced products in bathrooms for more than a decade now.

We present the data the Wings team along with Dr. Heynes and Ms. Geist gathered through phone calls, and email communication over the past two months with Facilities directors, student government leaders, menstrual products initiative organizers, to summarize the journey our COFHE schools went through to raise interest and funding, plan a pilot program and/or even successfully implement a long-term program.

The Menstrual Products Initiative is aimed to raise campus awareness for menstrual equity, demonstrate the pronounced need for menstrual resources, and ultimately, gain the Johns Hopkins finance administration's approval for a long-term, permanent initiative. With a successful pilot program, demonstrating results obtained from clear and evidence-based metrics, Wings and Hopkins administration will be able to not only serve the members of the Johns Hopkins Homewood community but also demonstrate that the lack of menstrual products and proper waste containers in the restrooms embodies a direct failure to fully accommodate the health needs of the entire Hopkins community, not just the student body, and raise the issue as a serious matter of menstrual inequity and gender inequality.

Background of Wings:

Wings is a nonprofit organization based in Baltimore that aims to improve menstrual hygiene and equity in the city. We provide menstrual hygiene products free of charge to underprivileged members of the community, host educational workshops on menstrual, sexual, and women’s health, and provide sustainable alternatives to single-use menstrual products, among many other initiatives. In doing so, we hope to increase accessibility of menstrual products, encourage environmental awareness and responsibility, and most importantly, break the social shame, stigma, and silence surrounding menstruation in our communities.

Summary of COHFE School Data and Discussion of Relevant Challenges faced A comprehensive collection of summaries detailing the Menstrual Product Initiatives at each COHFE university we contacted. All miscellaneous details are written in the matrix spreadsheet in JHBox. In these summaries, the following relevant questions addressed:

General Administrative Questions

  1. How long have you had this program in place – are you currently in a pilot phase or has this been an established program?
  2. Who oversees and is ultimately responsible for the implementation, maintenance and effectiveness of this program?
  3. How is this funded? – student group, student fees, facilities, student affairs.
  4. How much funding is allocated to this program? – has it been stable, increased over time? How is it assessed?
  5. Who is responsible for upkeep and restocking of supplies?
  6. How do you handle constant depletion of supplies and prevent the abuse of service (for example, one person taking the entire amount of products offered in a certain location?)
  7. Are there any challenges from a custodial perspective with these machines and products?
  8. How do you get campus partners to collaborate on this?
  9. What other lessons learned or challenges have you faced or do you foresee?
  10. Have you had facilities-related issues (i.e. plumbing problems from improper disposal) stemming from this program? If so, how have you mitigated those problems?

Campus-Specific Questions

  1. What products have you decided to provide?
  2. On what locations on campus do you offer the products?
  3. How did you choose a brand of products?
  4. Do you get discount for ordering in bulk?
  5. What system of distribution do you use?
  6. Guidelines for how to determine the amount of products delivered weekly/biweekly/monthly?
  7. What has been the feedback you have generated up to this point from both the student body and facilities?

Brown University: (written by: Bridget Chen) The conversation at Brown University started with the students and with the 2016 University Council of Students administration1. Their pilot program spanned an entire year from Fall 2016 to Fall 2017, with $5000 as funding, sourced by the Undergraduate Finance Board, and the last semester was funded by the Office of the President. Brown University had a comparatively long pilot program compared to many of the other COFHE universities. However, to their credit, they were also one of the first among their peer institutions to implement such a program. During this time, the initiative was overseen by the UCS and the distribution and restocking of products (in countertop baskets) were entirely student run, with distribution managers, student government representatives and volunteers.

The coverage was 52 bathrooms across campus, each receiving 10-30 products per basket, per week.

Baskets were restocked twice a week and adjusted +/- 5 products based on frequency of depletion.

Unfortunately, the volunteer efforts were inconsistent and unreliable which made it hard to supply so many products across 52 bathrooms1, let alone conducive to gathering quality data on distribution frequency, bathroom traffic, product depletion etc. At points it became a five-member committee that restocked around 40 bathrooms twice a week1. Products used were organic Aunt Flow products and were provided in counter top baskets.

Overall the process to institutionalize the program and transition to a long-term program under operation of facilities took a few years of negotiations between administration and students.

Bathrooms Supplied + Timeline:

• 40 bathrooms in the 2016-17 academic year • Unannounced break in Spring 2018 • 52 bathrooms in Fall 2018 • Institutionalization Agreement in Late Fall 2018 Facilities takeover was fully confirmed in November 20182, and presumably the stocking started not long thereafter. The long-term program is sourced from the campus life budget and the President’s Office. The long-term funding amount was not provided. Facilities will be overseeing the distribution and stocking. Products are from Tampax and Always and are now provided on freely accessible walldispensers. The transition from Aunt Flow to Tampax and Always was most likely logistically easier and cheaper. The transition to institutionalize this process was most likely made easier and not considered an additional burden to custodial services, in that previously coin-operated dispensers were adapted to be free-dispensing, and the products that had always been provided will continue to be provided, but free of cost. Currently Brown supplies products to 52 bathrooms total, which cover all student centers, and presumably in all those bathrooms that have these pre-existing dispensers. As of Sept/Oct 2018, this covers 32 buildings. Dispensers usually exists in every building. There was discussion that new dispensers would be installed in gender-inclusive bathrooms, and other women’s bathrooms that didn’t already have dispensers2.

Some issues that the long-term program is facing is that some students cite that these dispensers are frequently emptied. No further detail was provided. 1 http://www.browndailyherald.com/2018/04/26/ucs-asks-facilities-administer-project-tampon/ 2 http://www.browndailyherald.com/2018/11/11/facilities-takes-project-tampon/

Princeton University (written by: Chanel Lee) In late 2017, Princeton University launched a menstrual products pilot program consisting of five bathrooms within their student center. Since February 2018, policy discussions have taken place with their administration for official implementation of the program. The first stage of implementation was passed in March 2019 and is set to roll out in 56 major campus restrooms spread across 8 academic buildings (locations chosen based on student feedback after pilot program and student data) starting in September 2019. The pilot was funded by the Undergraduate Student Government and now, the Vice President of Student Life is fully funding implementation of the program. Roughly $12,000/year is currently being allocated to the program.

The chosen manufacturer is Aunt Flow, which provides menstrual products and plastic dispensers. A discount was applied for purchasing in bulk. Aunt Flow was selected after researching 5-6 manufacturers and performing detailed financial projections, logistics mapping, and forecasting on which would be best for the most successful program (based on quality of product, anticipated response from student body, cost, logistical feasibility, integration with Princeton Facilities distribution contracts/current company contracts in place, etc.).

Movement for this program was led in large part by the Menstrual Products Task Force, a student-led task force, which built broad support through publicity, conferences, and student testimonials as well as by forming campus partnerships and collaborations with a diverse group of organizations.

The Menstrual Products Task Force spearheaded the initial pilot program and oversaw manufacturer selection and initial logistic scoping, but now the program is managed by Princeton Facilities, who is in charge of fully maintaining and upkeeping the program (ordering, shipping, stocking, set up, etc.) on a daily basis with the students overseeing it in a hands-off manner (by generally monitoring usage numbers, publicizing it, etc.). The student team aims to work closely with Princeton Facilities and Princeton Administration to ensure success and analyze the program to gauge expansion.

In terms of challenges, a representative of the Menstrual Products Task Force states that one is making sure that restrooms are stocked appropriately, and that Facilities prioritizes upkeep of this program just as much as toiletry and other restroom needs. There was a facilities-related issue, which prompted the group to buy new dispensers from a new company (Aunt Flow) instead of modifying current dispensers.

As far as depletion of supplies and the abuse of service go, they were not a major concern in the pilot program, but the representative notes that the possibility is real. To avoid these, they plan on attaching a message on the Aunt Flow dispensers stating, “take only what you need” as well as marketing the program as a “a need-centered program for all students,” in order to encourage students to be respectful when taking products.

Other lessons learned or challenges they have faced or potentially foresee include:

Lessons:

• Need to be extremely specific with policy ask, instead of pushing administration to “understand need” or overwhelming them with reasons for it being important • Think big, then scale back as necessary • Make sure at each step to put down sustainable procedures to expand in the future • Make sure to talk to ALL parties involved for the most effective communications. Meetings were with both administration (funding) and Facilities so that all parties were on the same page. • Note that it is important to work with the manufacturer you decide on since they will have a lot of knowledge based on past clients of similar student body size, etc. This will naturally differ by school, so the pilot program was a good opportunity to get more accurate data on how much product is need for the campus.

Future challenges: (Princeton continued) • Further institutionalizing it (transitioning funding from Student Life budget to Facilities budget) • Keeping momentum going as key team members involved on the project graduate (passing on institutional knowledge and responsibilities effectively to younger students) University of Pennsylvania (written by: Lina Kim) University of Pennsylvania is currently in the pilot phase; they just received funding in April and will be establishing the distribution of the products at the start of the fall semester. Nikhil is in charge of overseeing the program, alongside support from other members of the Undergraduate Assembly and other partner organizations around campus (the Penn Period Project and Penn Association for Gender Equity). Half of the $1000 budget is funded by the Graduate Student Branch of Student Government, and the other half by Penn administration (the Vice Provost for University Life). As this is the first time UPenn is doing this, they are receiving funding for the program and the $1000 was the maximum amount they were able to secure from administration.

The members of the Undergraduate Assembly, Penn Period Project, and Penn Association for Gender Equity are responsible for upkeep and restocking of supplies. The Graduate and Professional Student Assembly (GAPSA) was involved heavily in lobbying efforts and funding $500, while Nikhil is overseeing the upkeep and distribution. As they have not started their pilot yet, they have not had the problem of abuse of service or constant depletion. However, they have prepared signs that remind students to be conscious of how much they take because of difficulty in securing funding. The custodial staff will not be involved in distributing products, so Nikhil does not see any challenges coming from a custodial perspective. To collaborate with campus partners, Nikhil simply reached out by email to some, and others have contacted him on their own after hearing about the initiative in the newspaper.

Nikhil claims that is difficult to garner administration’s support without tangible evidence, both quantitative and qualitative, and very persistent lobbying, especially encouraging the student body to raise their voices, for example through a school-wide petition and awareness through student-run publications. Anything involving university spending raised alarm for administrators. They also foresee problems with re-securing funding once supplies for this pilot are depleted. UPenn will provide pads and tampons, and will be offering them in several high traffic locations on campus which do not already offer them. They will use the brand that Penn already has contracts with, but will not get a discount for ordering bulk. The students will be restocking baskets weekly. The guidelines for how to determine the amount of products delivered weekly was decided upon through discussion and mutual agreement among organizations involved without formal process.

The students at UPenn are very excited about the initiative while the faculties are indifferent because they are not involved.

Cornell University (written by: Wendy Geist) Cornell just completed benchmarking and assessment phase. They will pilot their project as of August 2019 in 1,500 public restrooms across campus. Facilities will monitor usage and inventory. The pilot has been funded by the Student Assembly fees and fundraising from other departments which will benefit from using the restrooms. They have a total of $70K for their pilot. There is a conversation with campus partners for investment, VP, provost regarding who will fund beyond the pilot phase. This has been a student led initiative. To keep costs minimal, tampons and pads will be offered in baskets on bathroom countertops. This maintains ADA compliance as well. Cornell is using Lola as their vendor.

They ordered bulk items and used bulk purchasing to negotiate the best pricing from Lola over Aunt Flow. They preferred Lola’s organic and sustainability products. 15.2 cents per item. 60/40 split (tampons/pads) and free shipping was negotiated as part of their deal. Campus population is over 20K.

Yale University (written by: Emily Sturm) Yale rolled out their pilot program during the spring semester of 2018 at 2 of their 14 colleges, which was funded by the Yale College Council (YCC) endowment3. They provided several types of menstrual products (pads, liners, several types of tampons, and menstrual disks) in two restrooms per college. Two members of the YCC maintained the program themselves, including restocking. The YCC expanded its program to include all 14 colleges this past spring semester (2019), and the same two YCC members continue to maintain the program with the additional help of “college aids”. Financially, the program is the responsibility of the head of each college, not the YCC, although the pilot program was funded by the YCC. They order their products in bulk from boxed.com and amazon.com. In addition, they have sponsorships from two companies: Maxim (maximhy.com) and The Flex Company (flexfits.com), and they do receive products donated by individuals. According to the article, the program expanded another two semesters (end of 2019) with $14,000 in funds being paid for by the Yale College dean’s office and the two aforementioned corporate partners3. Yale found that the donated products didn’t make much of impact and isn’t that sustainable, but this is due to the fact that there are so many colleges and spread out locations. I do not believe that this JHU will experience the same problem because of the small size of our campus. During the upcoming semester, Yale is planning on expanding their program to include more appropriate locations, and they have agreed to send us their data at the end of the semester.

Another really good article shed more light on the process long-term challenges / lack thereof4:

• Some administrators expected the products to be rapidly depleted, “in reality, students were very conscientious about not taking more than they need”. • The pilot’s usage data and survey questions as well as anecdotes from individual students who reached out to the YCC helped show what products were most useful for students. • Restocking process was not facilitated by facilities but rather students (YCC members / senators were the basis of the restocking efforts) • Unique to their situation they secured external funding which made the grounds for a serious conversation with administration possible • It seems like Yale is not quite yet transitioning out of pilot phase, only simply extending it and still in the midst of discussion à would be worth getting further details on Yale’s status to potential institutionalization and the status of their discussions with admin. • Dispensers vs. Baskets? 3 https://www.nhregister.com/news/article/Yale-to-give-students-free-feminine-hygiene-13602828.php 4 https://yaledailynews.com/blog/2019/02/11/ycc-brings-free-menstrual-products-to-residential-colleges/

Budget Projections of Pilot Program Cost Breakdown of supplying JHU Bathrooms with menstrual products for 10 weeks in 20 JHU bathrooms. The spreadsheet that was previously shared at the March 3, 2019 meeting as well as electronically, reflects this same math, but the process in which these figures are reached is explained below. The exact costs are excluded, but if you would like to find out more, please contact wingsjhu@gmail.com. • # of bathrooms: 20 bathrooms (for long-term, can scale up to 50+ bathrooms) • Duration of pilot: 10 weeks (similar to what other schools did and what Brown recommends) • Cost of products in bulk from X company:

o Pack of 500 tampons = $X ($W per tampon) o Pack of 500 pads = $Y ($W per tampon) o 1 dispenser = $Z • All Dispensers Cost: 1 dispenser per 1 bathroom, for 20 bathrooms = 20 dispensers = $20Z.

• Cost of Products:

o 1 Dispenser Per 1 Week: If each dispenser needs 50 pads + 50 tampons (100 products), per week for weekly restock (likely an overestimation due to variable demand) o 1 dispenser, 10 weeks: 500 pads + 500 tampons (1000 products) = $X+Y, (1 pack of each type of product) to maintain 1 dispenser over the 10 weeks.

o 20 dispensers, 10 weeks:

($X+Y for 1000 products for 10 weeks per 1 dispenser) x (20 dispensers) = $20(X+Y) • Bulk Purchase Necessary:

o 10,000 tampons = 20 packs x 500 tampons = 20 x $X = $20X o 10,000 pads = 20 packs x 500 pads = 20 x $Y = $20Y o 20 dispensers = 20 x $100 = $20Z o $20X+20Y+20Z Final cost* (*Tax is not included b/c menstrual products are not taxed in MD) • Final total cost for dispensers + products for 20 bathrooms for 10 weeks: $20(X+Y+Z) • Contact Numbers:

o Bridget spoke and emailed with representatives of various companies that offer products and dispensers (Aunt Flow, Daycon, HOSPECO).

Pilot Program Overview Which bathrooms? – Top voted buildings generated from the campus-wide survey (in JHBox) How many bathrooms based on how much money can go toward the pilot – 20 bathrooms = $6000 Where the money will be coming from – For JHU, Dr. Heynes generously offered $6000 of WGR’s budget. The COHFE schools cited funding from multiple sources, but they almost all included their SGA as well as President’s Office, Facilities, Student Life/Campus Life.

How products will be stocked and re-stocked – Almost all of COHFE pilot programs has ended in institutionalization of program, facilities-driven Student Volunteer Distribution system – For example, Brown Facilities Distribution System – Unfortunately didn’t not hear back from Cornell’s facilities. Can reach out with facilities contact at Brown (Donna Butler), now that it technically has been institutionalized at Brown, but according to a Brown student who was involved in restocking during the pilot, that existence of products stocked by facilities hasn’t officially started yet.

Dispensers vs. Baskets Discussion

Most COHFE schools either utilized countertop baskets, especially during their pilot program, (Cornellpilot, Brown-pilot, Penn-pilot), or readjusted previous wall-dispensers, removing the coin operation (Brown, Princeton). Below outlines pros and cons of both systems, with consideration of ADA compliance. Ultimately, we decided we will be using dispensers instead of baskets because:

• Baskets are more prone to abuse:

o CONS: open to air, close contact with water from sink, easily displaceable, tempting and easy to remove more products than needed) o PROS: easy to ‘install’ and de-’install’ • Dispensers on the wall o PROS: Difficult to remove/displace/abuse, separate from sink water, difficult to abuse and remove large amounts of product, appears more official and permanent o CONS: may be difficult to de-install (if need to be), despite reassurances from AF (To-beresolved: will reach out to AF to get real insight to this process), May not be ADA compliant (resolved: will follow the same protocol used to install wall-hand dryers that are ADA compliant) Bathrooms Being Supplied A list of bathrooms that student, staff and faculty reported and requested in the January 2019 Wings campus-wide Menstrual Products Initiative Pre-initiative survey. We adjusted and added to the list after thoughtful discussion. Bathrooms stocked will be mostly female and some gender neutral.

Campus Wide Survey New Student Center ‘Homewood Campus & Vicinity Restrooms Meetings by Building’ Spreadsheet from facilities:

Brody/MSE Barton Hall (Highly Garland Rec Center travelled by grad Wyman Gilman students) Levering Dining Halls () Shaffer (All Gender bathroom) Dorms () Mattin Center UTL/Mudd Hodson Hodson Research buildings (Dunning, NCB, etc.) Bloomberg Lecture Hall / Research (Remsen, Krieger, Maryland) *Excludable if other campus bathrooms have higher demand Gender Neutral Bathrooms are located in the following buildings:

Shaffer, Mattin, Wyman, Bloomberg, MSE (Staff only), Barton, Latrobe, Shriver, Garland, Levering *Note: Unfortunately, a highly traffic location, BLC, Gilman, Krieger has no gender-neutral bathrooms…

Funding • Short-term funding for Pilot program: Dr. Heynes generously offered $6000 of WGR’s budget. • Long-term funding can hopefully come from Homewood Student Affairs, Whiting/Krieger, Health and Wellness Center, SGA, etc.

• COFHE Universities + their source of funding:

o Brown: (Pilot) UCS funding and (long-term) President’s Office and Campus Life Budget o Penn: (Pilot-to be started) Graduate Student Branch of SG + Penn administration o Cornell: (Pilot) Student Assembly fees + Other Departments o Yale: (Pilot ongoing) YCC (College Council), Yale College Dean, 2 corporates o Princeton: (pilot) Student Government (Long-term) Vice President of Student Life ($12k/year) Student Volunteer Product Distribution System • Student volunteers and Wings involvement in distribution during pilot (with hopes that facilities will eventually incorporate restocking products into their regular custodial routines) o We received feedback from Brown’s student-led initiative and the distributions manager at the time. She describes that the process is difficult to manage if student-driven just because of the difficulty scheduling students who have variable schedules and commitments, but it may be manageable for 10 weeks. She emphasizes, however, that the only viable long-term system is an institutionalized one.

Next Steps – Moving Forward:

• Potential Meetings to start discussing next steps (e.g. mtgs with facilities) • Generating a timeline (similar to below) • End of Summer 2019 + Fall 2019 (After Meeting and ‘Go-Ahead’ with Dr. Ruzicka) o Plan logistics, purchase of products o Publicize the initiative on all websites (WGR, Student Life, SHWC, LGBTQ), Hub, Orca, campus-wide email from higher administration (DOSL / President Daniels / Provost and Vice Provost) § “What are these dispensers/products and what does that mean or you” § Publicity: write up flyers on explaining the ground ‘rules’ for the use of these products (“emergencies only”, “please refrain from abusing”, “contact Wings if you have questions, funded by WGR, partnered with Dean of Student Life, SGA) for set up student-driven distribution system. • Plan and Rollout preparation needed for Student Distribution System: mobilize consistent volunteers, be ready to troubleshoot on/off volunteers, main efforts supplied by Wings, o Reach out to collaborator groups on campus:

§ GRO – Graduate Students § Sororities § Fraternities (i.e. Professional, Service, Co-ed, etc.) § Cultural (Intercultural Greek Council) § Other WGR Board Groups o System of Data Collection + Securing Feedback § Document overall usage, demand, gauge campus response, gathering feedback for improvements, transmitting information out, etc. • Spring 2020: Comfortably roll out the menstrual products program! J

Sources

COFHE Schools Report_Wings-WGR-DOSL.pdf