Compare editions
401 lines added, 185 removed
- ## THE CONSTITUTION
+ THE CONSTITUTION
- ### Of the Johns Hopkins University
+ OF
- ### Student Council
+ THE UNDERGRADUATE ACADEMIC ETHICS BOARD
- We, the Undergraduate Students, in order to establish unity, to promote integrity, to maintain students and democratic government, to improve educational opportunity and to foster understanding and fellowship do ordain and establish this Constitution.
+ OF THE DIVISIONS OF
- ## ARTICLE I
+ SCHOOL OF ARTS AND SCIENCES
- All actions of the Johns Hopkins University Undergraduate Students, both as individuals and groups, shall be in accordance with the Undergraduate's Code, as stated below:
+ G.W.C. WHITING SCHOOL OF ENGINEERING
- [illegible]r System is the selfimposed moral code of a community
- [illegible]sts in this community, to guarantee high standards
- [illegible]rship to persons who are able and willing to maintain
+ (Revised May 1982)
- [illegible]privilege resting upon the clearly perceived merit of
- [illegible]ust exercise care in order that no suspicion of
- [illegible] upon them.
+ ## CONSTITUTION OF
- [illegible] the Honor Code, all true Hopkins Undergraduates
- [illegible] it, considering themselves privileged to abide by
+ ## THE UNDERGRADUATE ACADEMIC ETHICS BOARD
- ## ARTICLE II
+ ## OF THE DIVISIONS OF
- [illegible]Undergraduate Students shall be named the Student
+ ## SCHOOL OF ARTS AND SCIENCES
- ## ARTICLE III
+ ## G.W.C. WHITING SCHOOL OF ENGINEERING
- [illegible]f the Student Council are the following:
+ *(Revised May 1982)*
- [illegible]ote the Honor System.
- [illegible]ediary between administration, Faculty and students.
- [illegible]rgraduate activities in all matters affecting the
- [illegible]dent Body.
- [illegible]rticulate the interests of the undergraduate Student Body.
- [illegible]guete, coordinated social schedule.
+ ### Preamble
- ## ARTICLE IV
+ It is the joint responsibility of the faculty and students of this University to maintain the academic integrity of Johns Hopkins in all respects. An ethical code must exist in the University community to guarantee high standards of conduct and to limit membership in the community to those persons able and willing to maintain these standards.
- [illegible]cil shall have jurisdiction over all undergraduate
- [illegible] the Johns Hopkins University and shall be responsible
- [illegible]nts actions.
+ An ethical code is based upon the support of the community, students and faculty alike, who must accept two kinds of responsibility: Each member must live honorably and must also take action when necessary to ensure that the community is not injured by negligence.
- Section 2. The Student Council shall have the power to investigate thoroughly any undergraduate activity or any action on the part of the undergraduate student or students, and in all cases except academic breaches of the Undergraduate's Code, shall bring the matter before the Student Council for decision.
+ ### Article One. Violations Of Academic Integrity
- ## ARTICLE V
+ Undergraduate students enrolled in the Division of Arts and Sciences or the Division of the Whiting School of Engineering at The Johns Hopkins University assume a duty to conduct themselves in a manner appropriate to the University's mission as an institution of higher education. A student is obligated to refrain from acts which he or she knows, or under the circumstances has reason to know, impairs the academic integrity of the University. Violations of academic integrity include, but are not limited to: cheating; plagiarism; unapproved multiple submissions; knowingly furnishing false information to any agent of the University for inclusion in the academic records; falsification, forgery, alteration, destruction or misuse of official University documents or seal.
- Section 1. The Student Council shall consist of the following members:
+ ### Article Two. Responsibilities Of Students And Faculty
- (a) The President of the Student Council.
+ #### Section One.
- (b) The Vice President of the Student Council
+ [handwritten: small marginal mark]
- (c) The Secretary of the Student Council.
+ All members of the academic community are responsible for the academic integrity of the University. Students and faculty alike must work together to minimize the possibility of violations of the ethics code.
- # Constitution of the
- # STUDENT COUNCIL
+ #### Section Two.
- ## ARTICLE I.
+ The faculty is responsible for the conduct of examinations, for announcing the ground rules for all work in a course, and for the security of examination papers and teaching laboratories. Proctoring is at the discretion of the instructor. It is the duty of the professor to inform the student when he is suspected of a violation of academic integrity, and to proceed according to the guidelines set forth in Article Four, Section One.
- ### NAME
+ Section Three.
- The name of this body shall be the Student Council of the Johns Hopkins University.
+ It is the responsibility of each student to report to the professor in charge of the course or to the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board any suspected violations of the ethics code. It is not required that the individual suspected violators be identified, but it is apparent that corrective action by the professor can be most effective if it is based on full information.
- ## ARTICLE II.
+ ## Article Three. The Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board
- ### OBJECT
+ ### Section One.
- The objects of this body shall be:
+ The Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board is a subcommittee of the Committee on Undergraduate Studies. It consists of 6 students selected by the Student Council and four faculty members selected by the Academic Council. The terms of service of members of the Board shall be specified by the respective Councils.
- (a) To serve as a medium between faculty and students.
+ [handwritten: “10” and “6” in the margin]
- (b) To correlate the various University activities, promoting co-operation of all parties in all matters affecting the welfare of the University.
+ ### Section Two.
- (c) To uphold and promote the Johns Hopkins Honor System.
+ The Board shall elect a chairman from among its members, and shall select other officers and staff as provided in its Bylaws.
- ## ARTICLE III.
+ ### Section Three.
- ### MEMBERSHIP
+ The Board is responsible for the maintenance of the academic integrity of the undergraduate program in the Division of Arts and Sciences and the G.W.C. Whiting School of Engineering and for all matters concerning adherence to the ethics code, including but not limited to: receiving reports of suspected violations, consulting with members of the University community on ways to reduce possible violations, appointing hearing panels, maintaining confidential records, orienting new students to the philosophy and terms of the ethics code, and informing the community of its work.
- **SECTION 1.** The Student Council shall consist of:
+ ### Section Four.
- (a) The President of the Student Council (hereinafter designated as the President) a Senior.
+ The Board shall find and use effectively means to inform faculty and students of its activities.
- (b) The President of the Senior Class, member ex-officio, a Senior.
+ ### Section Five.
- (c) The President of the Athletic Board, member ex-officio, a Senior.
+ The Board shall submit to the Committee on Undergraduate Studies a written annual report which shall not identify by name the individuals involved in its proceedings. The Committee shall transmit this report, along with its written evaluation and comments, to the Academic Council and the Student Council.
- (d) Two Senior delegates in addition to the above.
+ ### Section Six.
- (e) Two Junior delegates.
+ The Board shall adopt, with the advice of the University’s General Counsel, as part of its Bylaws, rules of procedure for hearings conducted by its hearing panels.
- (f) One Sophomore delegate.
+ Artic[illegible]
- (g) One Freshman delegate.
+ ### Section O[illegible]
- **SEC. 2.** In event of the inability of the President, on account of absence, sickness, or other cause, to carry out the functions of his office, the President of the Senior Class shall act as president of the Student Council, and shall assume his duties and powers in all particulars.
+ When evidence indicates that [illegible]
+ the part of [illegible]
+ course sha[illegible]
+ the studen[illegible]
+ ty has occ[illegible]
+ with the s[illegible]
+ forth the [illegible]
+ Board.
- **SEC. 3.** All questions of eligibility for membership on the Student Council shall be decided in accordance with the following clauses:
+ ### Section T[illegible]
- (a) The Student Council shall have sole authority in settling all questions regarding eligibility for membership; this shall apply both to the eligibility of all prospective members elected for the succeeding year at the regular spring elections, and to that of men elected to complete unfinished terms.
+ Upon rec[illegible]
+ fessor the[illegible]
+ of the cha[illegible]
+ return rec[illegible]
- (b) To be eligible for membership on the Student Council a student must
+ ### Section T[illegible]
- 1. Be a bona fide undergraduate student or a student in the first or second year of the New Plan, or rated, according to the rules laid down by the Student Council, as a member of the class from which elected.
+ If the cas[illegible]
+ the stude[illegible]
+ student a[illegible]
+ Ethics B[illegible]
+ Ethics Bo[illegible]
+ acknowle[illegible]
+ a copy of[illegible]
- 2. Conform to the grade of scholarship prescribed for men competing on the University athletic team
+ ### Section F[illegible]
- (c) No member of the Athletic Board, with the exception of its President, shall be eligible for membership on the Student Council.
+ Upon rec[illegible]
+ fessor, th[illegible]
+ ing panel[illegible]
+ or innocer[illegible]
+ penalty f[illegible]
- **SEC. 4.** Regularly elected members shall hold office for approximately one year, beginning with the date of graduation of the seniors of the preceding Council, and ending at the date of graduation of the seniors of the Council to which they are elected. The term of office of members elected to fill vacancies shall terminate similarly.
+ ### Section F[illegible]
- **SEC. 5.** Two unexcused absences during his term of office shall render any member, except ex-officio members, ineligible for further membership on the Council. Excuses for absence shall be granted only at the discretion of the Council.
+ In the eve[illegible]
+ for any o[illegible]
+ Dean for[illegible]
+ as that te[illegible]
- **SEC. 6.** All references to “the members” or “the members of the Council” in this Constitution or By-Laws, especially as regards voting regulations, shall be understood to include the President.
+ [handwritten: blue marginal brackets, circles, and marks are visible on the right-hand page]
- # ARTICLE IV.
+ ## Article Four. Procedures for Handling Suspected Violations of Academic Integrity
- ## ELECTIONS
+ ### Section One.
- **SECTION 1.** The President shall be nominated at general assembly during the first week in May in each year. The election shall take place during the week following and shall be by signed ballot. The election shall be declared non-valid unless taken part in by at least a majority of the undergraduate body.
+ When evidence is found of a possible violation of academic integrity on the part of a student enrolled in a course, the professor in charge of the course shall review the evidence and the facts of the case promptly with the student. If the professor believes that a violation of academic integrity has occurred, the professor ~~has the choice of settling the case directly with the student or of communicating promptly a written charge setting forth the essential facts of the case to the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board~~.
- SEC. 2. The remainder of the delegates, with the exception of the two ex-officio members, shall be elected by a signed ballot vote of their respective classes within two weeks after the election of the President. The election of any class delegate shall be declared non-valid unless taken part in by at least a majority of the class.
+ [handwritten: Blue bracket and strikeout marks alongside the paragraph; marginal note partly illegible.]
- SEC. 3. In case of a vacancy occurring on the Student Council at any time the President shall direct the President of the proper class to hold the election of a successor within two weeks after the vacancy occurs. Such election shall be held in accordance with Section 2 above.
+ ### Section Two.
- ## ARTICLE V.
+ Upon receipt of a charge of a violation of academic integrity from a professor the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board shall serve prompt notice of the charge on the accused student by hand delivery or by certified mail, return receipt requested. The notice shall contain:
- ### DUTIES AND FUNCTIONS
+ a) a description of the alleged violation of academic integrity including insofar as possible the time, date, and place of the alleged act(s);
- **SECTION 1.** The Student Council shall
+ b) a statement informing the student of the right to inspect at a designated place on campus and in advance of the hearing any documentary evidence intended for use at the hearing;
- (a) Represent the students before the faculty committees, the Trustees, etc., in all matters affecting student-life or welfare.
+ c) a copy of the Constitution and Bylaws of the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board.
- **SEC. 2.** The Student Council shall do all in its power to bring about co-operation among all undergraduate activities in such a manner as to:
+ ### Section Three.
- (a) Avoid duplication of effort and activity.
+ If the case is settled directly between the student and the professor, with the student admitting guilt, the professor must submit the name of the student and the settlement agreed upon to the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board. Upon notification that a settlement has been made, the Ethics Board will obtain a signature from the student admitting guilt, and acknowledging that he is aware of his rights and has been provided with a copy of the Constitution and Bylaws of the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board.
- (b) Initiate effort and activity where lacking.
+ ### Section Four.
- **SEC. 3.** The Student Council shall:
+ Upon receipt of a charge of a violation of academic integrity from a professor, the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board shall appoint a hearing panel to consider the charge. The panel shall decide the issue of guilt or innocence and, if the student is found guilty, shall impose an appropriate penalty from those specified in Article Six.
- (a) Promote a strong sentiment for [unclear: and] uphold the tradition of the Johns Hopkins Honor System among both faculty and students.
+ ### Section Five.
- (b) Endeavor to bring about the hearty co-operation of the Faculty in all matters pertaining to the practical operation of the Honor System.
+ In the event of a violation of academic integrity in which it is inappropriate for any one professor to act as the accuser, a designee of the Associate Dean for Undergraduate and Graduate Studies shall act as the “professor” as that term is used in this Article.
- (c) Investigate and act upon alleged breaches of the Honor System in accordance with Section 6 of the By-Laws.
+ ### Section Six.
- ## ARTICLE VI.
+ A student found guilty may appeal the decision of the hearing panel to the Associate Dean for Undergraduate and Graduate Studies or to a designee of the Associate Dean within 30 days of the decision of the hearing panel. The appeal must be in the form of a written statement setting forth the grounds for the appeal. The Associate Dean shall meet with the accused student before reaching a decision. A full written report of the disposition of each appeal shall be made by the Associate Dean for Undergraduate and Graduate Studies to the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board.
- ### POWERS
+ ## Article Five. Hearing Panels
- **SECTION 1.** The Student Council shall have power and authority to speak for the students in acting as intermediary, as prescribed under Article V, Section 1.
+ ### Section One.
- **SEC. 2.** The Student Council shall have power to investigate thoroughly any undergraduate activity or action, and in all cases except in breaches of the Honor System shall bring the matter before the General Assembly for decision, if necessary.
+ When required under the procedures of Article Four, the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board shall appoint a hearing panel of disinterested persons to consider the case.
- **SEC. 3.** The Student Council shall have power to punish any infringement of the Honor System, in accordance with Section 6 of the By-Laws.
+ ### Section Two.
- ### New Resolutions Adopted
+ A hearing panel shall consist of 5 persons, ordinarily chosen from the members of the Board, the ration of faculty and students on the panel being the same as on the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board.
- 1. The Student Council shall be empowered to promote good order in undergraduate affairs and shall exercise primary jurisdiction in questions of conduct on the part of any undergraduate or group of undergraduates which shall be deemed unbecoming a gentleman or prejudicial to the honor of the University.
+ [handwritten: blue triangular mark and brace in the left margin]
- 2. The Council shall take measures to make the Johns Hopkins Honor System effective in examinations, quizzes and student exercises of all sorts.
+ ### Section Three.
- **ARTICLE VI.**
+ Under extraordinary circumstances the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board may appoint to a panel full-time faculty or full-time undergraduate students from the Divisions of Arts and Sciences and the Whiting School of Engineering who are not members of the Board. Such a circumstance might occur if a panel could not be appointed from among the members of the Board, or if the workload of the Board was unusually heavy.
- **FINANCE**
+ ### Section Four.
- **SECTION 1.** The financial obligations of the Student Council shall be met by an annual levy of $10.00 upon each of the classes, falling due on October 15th of each year.
+ Hearings of the panel shall open to the member of the University bringing charges, the accused, any witness called by either party, and not more than one representative of the accused who is a full-time student presently enrolled in either the School of Arts and Sciences or the Whiting School of Engineering. Hearings shall be confidential and shall be closed to spectators and the press.
- **VIII**
+ ### Section Five.
- **OFFICERS**
+ The accused shall be presumed innocent until found to be guilty.
- **SECTION 1.** The officers of the Student Council shall be the President and the Secretary-Treasurer. Their duties shall be as set forth in Section 2 of the By-Laws. The President shall be elected as prescribed under Article IV, Section 1. The Secretary-Treasurer shall be elected by the Council from among its members.
+ ### Section Six.
- **AMENDMENTS**
+ The decision of the hearing panel on guilt or innocence shall be based upon a preponderance of the evidence and shall be communicated promptly in writing to the Associate Dean for Undergraduate and Graduate Studies.
- **ARTICLE IX.**
+ ### Section Seven.
- **SECTION 1.** No amendments to the Constitution or By-Laws of the Student Council shall be valid unless voted for by a signed ballot vote of at least three-fourths of a General Assembly of more than one-half of the undergraduate body.
+ At least 4 votes of guilty are required for conviction.
- **ARTICLE X.**
+ …g panel to
+ …es or to a
+ … of the hear-
+ …ent setting
+ …t with the
+ …ort of the
+ Dean for
+ Academic
- **STATUS OF BY-LAWS**
+ …rgraduate
+ …ested per-
- **SECTION 1.** The provisions of the By-Laws shall have equal weight with those of the Constitution proper; and the By-Laws may be amended only in the manner prescribed in Article IX, Section 1, of this Constitution.
+ …from the
+ …the panel
+ …oard.
- **ARTICLE XI.**
+ …mic Ethics
+ …rgraduate
+ …ng School
+ …cumstance
+ …members
+ … heavy.
- **PRECEDENCE**
+ …sity
+ …bring-
+ …not more
+ …at present-
+ …ng School
+ …ed to spec-
- **SECTION 1.** As regards all matters treated herein, this Constitution and By-Laws shall supersede and have precedence over all former constitutions, by-laws, resolutions, or rulings. This does not affect former resolutions or rulings regarding matters not treated herein.
+ …ilty.
- **BY-LAWS**
+ … absence of prior misconduct.
- **SECTION 1.**
+ ## Section Eight.
- **MEETINGS**
+ Hearings shall be conducted in accordance with rules of procedure provided for in the Bylaws of the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board.
- (a) Regular meetings shall be held at least once during each month of the school year.
+ ## Section Nine.
- (b) Special meetings may be called by the President at any time.
+ If an accused student fails to appear for a hearing after having been duly served with notice or withdraws from a hearing before its conclusion without the permission of the hearing panel, and if the hearing panel determines that such action has been willful, immediate suspension of the accused from the University may be imposed. Such a suspension shall continue until the hearing can be concluded with the student present.
- (c) Special meetings may be called at any time by any three members of the Council.
+ # Article Six. Penalties
- **SECTION 2.**
+ ## Section One.
- **DUTIES OF OFFICERS**
+ Whenever a student is found guilty of a violation of academic integrity, whether by direct settlement with the professor or by a hearing panel of the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board, the name of the students will be entered on a list of students who have been found guilty of the violations of academic integrity, as per Article Seven, Section One. The following penalties may be imposed upon students found guilty of violations of academic integrity:
- (a) The President shall:
+ a) Retake of the examination, paper, or exercise involved.
- 1. Carry out in spirit and detail the provisions of the Constitution and By-Laws.
+ b) Score of zero in the examination, paper, or exercise involved.
- 2. Preside at meetings of the Student Council.
+ c) Lowering of the course grade as specified by a hearing panel of the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board.
- 3. Preside at General Assembly when necessary.
+ d) Failure in the course.
- 4. Keep in close touch with faculty, students and student affairs.
+ e) Failure in the course with a notation on the transcript that the grade was for a violation of academic integrity.
- 5. Organize the Freshman Class.
+ f) Failure in the course with suspension from the University.
- 6. Oversee the enforcement of the Freshman regulations, if any have been passed.
+ g) Failure in the course with suspension from the University and notation on the transcript that the grade was for a violation of academic integrity.
- 7. Direct arrangements for, and holding of, interclass contests.
+ h) Suspension from the University for at least one semester.
- 8. Supervise class elections.
+ i) Suspension from the University for at least one semester with a notation on the transcript that the cause was a violation of academic integrity.
- 9. Co-operate with the authorities in the preservation of the proper conduct of the students and of the good appearance of the buildings, grounds, lunch-rooms, etc.
+ j) Expulsion from the University.
- 10. Perform any additional duties which may arise consistent with the three main objects of the Student Council.
+ A hearing panel shall make every effort to select a penalty appropriate to the severity of the offense, and may take into consideration any mitigating circumstances brought to its attention as well as any record or absence of prior misconduct.
- (b) The Secretary-Treasurer shall:
+ ## Section Two.
- 1. Act as recorder at meetings and keeper of all records, files, etc.
+ A second or subsequent finding of guilt of a violation of academic integrity shall result in a penalty selected from (g) through (j) in Section One above.
- 2. Act as a treasurer and custodian of funds.
+ Section Three.
- 3. Attend to communications at the direction of the President.
+ A student found guilty of a violation of academic integrity in a course forfeits the right to withdraw from the course or to change a graded course to one pass/fail and any withdrawal from that course or change effected prior to the finding of guilty shall be voided.
- 4. See to the collection of dues from the classes.
+ Section Four.
- 5. Notify members and other necessary parties of meetings.
+ A student who has committed a violation of academic integrity has the option of making a timely and personal report of the offense to the professor in charge of the course or to the Associate Dean for Undergraduate and Graduate Studies. A violation of academic integrity reported and dealt with under this section shall not constitute a first offense within the purview of Article Seven, Section One.
- 6. Pass on all funds, records, files, or other property in good condition to his successor.
+ Article Seven. Records
- ## SECTION 3.
+ Section One.
- ### COMMITTEES
+ The Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board shall maintain among its records a list of names of students found to be guilty of violations of academic integrity. It is this list which is consulted to determine whether an offense is a first offense or is a second or subsequent offense.
- (a) The President shall appoint committees specifically responsible for the work of the council. These shall be:
+ Section Two.
- 1. An Executive Committee, with the President acting as chairman, for the purpose of handling all matters of routine business between meetings of the Council.
+ The confidential records of the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board shall be held in a locked file in the office of the Associate Dean for Undergraduate and Graduate Studies.
- 2. An Intermediary Committee, an Activities Committee, and an Honor System Committee, responsible respectively for recommendation to the Council as a whole regarding the carrying out of its three primary functions. (See Article V, Sections 1, 2, 3.)
+ Section Three.
- 3. A Publicity Committee, preferably consisting of one member, responsible for keeping the faculty and student body informed of the activities and purposes of the Council.
+ Access to the confidential records of the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board shall be limited to the Associate Dean for Undergraduate and Graduate Studies and to members of the Board.
- ## SECTION 4.
+ Section Four.
- ### ORDER OF BUSINESS IN MEETINGS
+ A case file concerning an accused student shall be retained for four years after the student's last enrollment as an undergraduate and shall then be destroyed.
- (a) The order of business in meetings shall be entirely at the discretion of the Council sitting.
+ Article Eight. Bylaws and Amendments
- (b) For all matters except trials for infringement of the Honor System, six members shall constitute a quorum.
+ Section One.
- ## SECTION 5.
+ The Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board shall adopt Bylaws to govern its operation.
- ### FORMAL COMMUNICATIONS TO THE FACULTY
+ Section Two.
- (a) Formal communications to the faculty [illegible] directed as follows: Communications [illegible] infractions of the Honor System, or any matter concerning the faculty as a whole, to the chairman of the Faculty Committee on Student Affairs.
+ Amendments to this Constitution shall take effect when they are adopted in identical language by both the Academic Council and the Student Council.
- (b) All other communications should be directed to either the Dean or the Chairman.
+ Section T[illegible].
- ## SECTION 6.
+ The Const[illegible]
- ### CONDUCT OF TRIALS
+ are public[illegible]
- **(a) General considerations.**
+ Section O[illegible].
- 1. It is the duty of the President and members of the Student Council to prosecute any alleged dishonorable conduct on the part of any student promptly and thoroughly.
+ At the be[illegible]
+ one studen[illegible]
+ extraordin[illegible]
+ The chair[illegible]
+ decide all[illegible]
+ sible for r[illegible]
- 2. All trials are to be conducted on the assumption that the accused is innocent unless the contrary is conclusively proved.
+ Section T[illegible].
- **(b) Initiation of movement for trial.**
+ Upon app[illegible]
+ list of facu[illegible]
+ shall be f[illegible]
+ three stude[illegible]
+ shall be in[illegible]
+ will be exp[illegible]
+ ter if for[illegible]
+ impartial[illegible]
+ alternate[illegible]
- The decision of the president to conduct a trial in any case shall be based upon such evidence as:
+ Section T[illegible].
- 1. Direct testimony of teacher or student.
+ In the eve[illegible]
+ available f[illegible]
+ from-the[illegible]
+ the School[illegible]
+ The Chair[illegible]
+ will sugges[illegible]
+ appointme[illegible]
+ of the four[illegible]
+ Council.
+ members[illegible]
- 2. Direct testimony of a member of the Council resulting from his investigation of hearsay evidence.
+ [handwritten: illegible]
- 3. Circumstantial evidence presented by a responsible party.
+ [handwritten: illegible]
- 4. The President shall in no case assume the responsibility of dropping a case when his attention has been brought to it by a responsible party.
+ Section Three.
- **(c) Preparation for trial.**
+ The Constitution and Bylaws of the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board are public documents.
- Upon reaching a decision to conduct a trial, based on the considerations above, the President shall notify the accused:
+ ## Article Nine. Procedural Appeal
- 1. Of the nature and circumstances of the accusation.
+ Any violation of the procedures set forth in this Constitution and its appended Bylaws shall give the accused student the right to request the dismissal of the case from the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board and/or the Associate Dean for Undergraduate and Graduate Studies.
- 2. That the accused may avoid any investigation by immediate withdrawal from the University, provided he considers defense useless.
+ # ACADEMIC ETHICS BOARD
+ # HEARING PANEL PROCEDURES
+ *(Revised January 1979)*
- 3. That the accused has the right of subsequent appeal to the faculty should he be found guilty by the Student Council.
+ ## Selection of Hearing Panel and Presiding Official
- 4. That the accused has the right, and is strongly advised, to procure the assistance of a friend at the trial.
+ ### Section One.
- 5. Place, date, and hour of the trial.
+ At the beginning of each academic year the Ethics Board shall appoint one student member to serve as the presiding official at all hearings. Under extraordinary circumstances the presiding official may disqualify himself. The chairman will appoint a replacement. The presiding official shall decide all procedural questions. The presiding official will also be responsible for maintaining records of all procedural decisions.
- 6. Any additional information which may appear necessary for the guidance of the accused.
+ ### Section Two.
- **(d)** Unless voluntarily waived by him, the accused shall in all cases have the right of twenty-four hours’ notice before the trial.
+ Upon appointment, the presiding official shall prepare a randomly ordered list of faculty and student members of the Ethics Board. A hearing panel shall be formed by choosing the first two faculty members and the first three student members of the respective lists. Members of the hearing panel shall be informed of the name of the accused and the accuser. Members will be expected to disqualify themselves from participation in any matter if for any reason they believe their ability to consider charges in an impartial fashion will be affected. One faculty alternate and one student alternate shall be chosen in the same manner.
- **(e)** Trial shall be conducted according to the discretion of the Council sitting.
+ [handwritten: marginal note, unclear]
- **(f)** The voting at trials shall be governed by the following rules:
+ ### Section Three.
- 1. Seven members, including President, or the president of the Senior Class if acting for the President, shall be necessary to conduct a trial.
+ In the event that an insufficient number of Ethics Board members are available for a hearing panel, additional panel members shall be appointed ~~from the full-time faculty and full-time undergraduate student body in~~ the School of Arts and Sciences and the Whiting School of Engineering. The Chairman of the Ethics Board, with the aid of members of the Board, will suggest names of individuals willing to serve on hearing panels. Before appointment to a hearing panel, an individual must by approved by three of the four faculty members of the Board and by four of the six student members of the Board.
- 2. If only seven members are present at a trial, a vote of guilty by five members shall be necessary for conviction; if either eight or nine members are present, a vote of six shall be necessary for conviction. (See Constitution, Art. III, Sec. 6.)
+ [handwritten: marginal mark]
- (g) Penalties.
+ # Rights and Responsibilities of Individuals Before a Hearing
- Any case in which the vote for guilty falls below that prescribed for convictions shall be dismissed.
+ ## Section One.
- (h) Penalties.
+ The accused shall be notified in writing of a charge of a violation of academic integrity as provided in Article Four, Section Two of the Ethics Board Constitution. The written notice shall be served personally or sent by certified mail to the student at least seven days prior to the hearing at the address appearing on University records. The accused will have three days from the date of notification to file with the presiding official two peremptory challenges and other challenges for cause against the panel members. Panel members named in peremptory challenges shall be disqualified. The presiding official will rule on challenges for cause. The chairman of the Ethics Board will replace panel members removed by challenge.
- The punishment to be imposed in case of a conviction of infraction of the Honor System shall be decided by the Council sitting; with the understanding that unless strong mitigating circumstances exist, the punishment shall be expulsion.
+ ## Section Two.
- (i) Notification of Faculty.
+ The accuser shall deposit with the presiding official any documentary evidence to be used at the hearing before the times given in Section Three of this Article.
- Following the trial for infraction of Honor, the Secretary-Treasurer shall notify the Faculty Committee on Student affairs formally in writing of the decision reached.
+ ## Section Three.
- (j) Secrecy surrounding trials.
+ The accused and one full-time undergraduate student chosen by the accused to be his representative may inspect all documentary evidence and, if practical, will be furnished with Xerox copies of the evidence. If the School of Arts and Sciences and the Whiting School of Engineering are in session, inspection shall be permitted at least two days, excluding weekends and brief vacations, before the hearing. If the School of Arts and Sciences and the Whiting School of Engineering are not in session, inspection shall be permitted at least five days before the hearing. The presiding official will keep any documentary evidence and be responsible for its security until a determination in the case has been made.
- The strictest secrecy regarding all trials shall be preserved by all members of the Student Council.
+ ## Section Four.
- Announcement to the Student Body of the result of any trial may be made impersonally and uncircumstantially; however, no announcement whatever concerning any trial shall be made within four weeks after the hearing.
+ The hearing panel members shall not be informed of details of the charge before the hearing is convened and shall scrupulously avoid discussing the pending hearing either with the parties concerned, possible witnesses, or any other persons. Panel members shall not discuss the merits of the charges with each other prior to entering into a determination of the charges.
+ ## Section Five.
+
+ The accused and the representative of the accused may discuss procedures with the presiding official but may not approach members of the panel, the accuser, or the accuser’s witnesses concerning any matter directly or indirectly related to the hearing.
+
+ ## Section One.
+
+ Students cha[illegible]
+
+ currence may[illegible]
+
+ official. Cha[illegible]
+
+ from several[illegible]
+
+ instance of[illegible]
+
+ ## Section Two.
+
+ The accused[illegible]
+
+ ## Section One.
+
+ days to file a[illegible]
+
+ ficial. The pr[illegible]
+
+ decision.
+
+ ## Section One.
+
+ The presiding[illegible]
+
+ ing panel sha[illegible]
+
+ ## Section Two.
+
+ The accused,[illegible]
+
+ the accused s[illegible]
+
+ tion of evide[illegible]
+
+ ## Section Thre[illegible]
+
+ Other individ[illegible]
+
+ giving testim[illegible]
+
+ testifying, wit[illegible]
+
+ official of th[illegible]
+
+ ## Section One.
+
+ ### Record
+
+ A full and co[illegible]
+
+ cording or ot[illegible]
+
+ copy of the ta[illegible]
+
+ appeal. No re[illegible]
+
+ shall, howeve[illegible]
+
+ finding of gu[illegible]
+
+ shall be used[illegible]
+
+ and shall be w[illegible]
+
+ ty of individu[illegible]
+
+ reports..
+
+ [illegible]e a Hearing
+
+ [illegible] of a violation of
+ [illegible] Two of the Ethics
+ [illegible] personally or sent
+ [illegible] or to the hearing
+ [illegible]sed will have three
+ [illegible]ding official two
+ [illegible] against the panel
+ [illegible]nges shall be dis-
+ [illegible] cause. The chair-
+ [illegible]ved by challenge.
+
+ [illegible]ny documentary
+ [illegible] in Section Three
+
+ [illegible]osen by the ac-
+ [illegible] evidence and,
+ [illegible] evidence. If the
+ [illegible] Engineering are
+ [illegible] days, excluding
+ [illegible] School of Arts
+ [illegible] not in session,
+ [illegible]e hearing. The
+ [illegible] be responsible
+ [illegible]en made.
+
+ [illegible]ils of the charge
+ [illegible] and discussing the
+ [illegible]ole witnesses, or
+ [illegible] the merits of the
+ [illegible]mination of the
+
+ [illegible]scuss procedures
+ [illegible]ers of the panel,
+ [illegible]atter directly or
+
+ # Joinder of Charges
+
+ ## Section One.
+
+ Students charged with misconduct arising from a single incident or occurrence may have their hearings joined at the instance of the presiding official. Charges of academic misconduct against a single student arising from several incidents or occurrences may be heard at one hearing at the instance of the presiding official.
+
+ ## Section Two.
+
+ The accused will receive written notification of a joinder of charges (see Section One of Rights and Responsibilities). The accused shall have three days to file any objections to joinder with cause with the presiding official. The presiding official will consider the objection and make a final decision.
+
+ # Individual Present at Hearing
+
+ ## Section One.
+
+ The presiding official, who shall act as recorder, and members of the hearing panel shall be in attendance throughout the proceedings.
+
+ ## Section Two.
+
+ The accused, the accuser(s), and the full-time student representative of the accused shall be present throughout the accused’s plea, the presentation of evidence, and questioning.
+
+ ## Section Three.
+
+ Other individuals shall be present at the hearing only for the purpose of giving testimony and only during the duration of their testimony. After testifying, witnesses shall remain available and shall inform the presiding official of their whereabouts and how they may be reached.
+
+ # Hearing Procedure
+
+ ## Section One.
+
+ ### Record
+
+ A full and complete record shall be made of the proceedings by tape recording or other suitable device. The accused shall be furnished with a copy of the tape recording at his request for the purpose of preparing an appeal. No record of the deliberations shall be made. The hearing panel shall, however, prepare a brief written report detailing the reasons for the finding of guilt or innocence and for any penalty imposed. Such reports shall be used only to help establish uniformity of verdicts and penalties and shall be written so as not to divulge, directly or indirectly, the identity of individuals. The Board will maintain a permanent file of all such reports.
+
+ BYLAWS
+
+ 1) The tapes of hearings conducted under the Ethics Code shall be maintained for a period of four years in the offices of the University General Counsel.
+
+ 2) Documentary evidence introduced at hearings conducted under the Ethics Code shall be maintain for a period of four years in the offices of the University General Counsel.
+
+ 3) The records of proceedings at hearings conducted under the Ethics Code shall be deemed confidential.
+
+ 4) The presiding official of each case shall prepare a synopsis of the case. Such synopsis shall specify the nature of the charge, the course in which the alleged violation took place, the determination of the hearing panel and penalty imposed, and the outcome of any appeal. The identity of the accused and accuser shall not be divulged.
+
+ 5) The Chairperson shall make public (after each case) the course in which the alleged violation took place and the determination of the hearing panel.
+
+ 6) A breach of confidentiality of a case shall cause the removal of an Academic Ethics Board member by a majority of the Academic Ethics Board.
+
+ 7) The Ethics Code Hearing Panel Procedures and Bylaws may be amended by the approval of three of the four faculty members and four of the six student members at a meeting of the Ethics Board for which notice has been given at least one week prior to the meeting. The wording of the proposed amendment shall be included with the notice of the meeting.
+
+ [handwritten: Blue margin mark/arrow beside item 7.]
+
+ 8) The Academics Ethics Board shall elect officers as needed. Officers shall be elected by a vote of three of the four faculty members and four of the six student members. The term of each officer shall expire at the end of the academic year.
+
+ [handwritten: Red mark in the left margin beside item 8.]
+
+ 9) A student exercising the option specified in Article Six, Section Four must do so before a formal accusation is made to the Academic Ethics Board. The Academic Ethics Board shall conduct a hearing to investigate the violation and shall impose a penalty but will not record the student's name on its confidential records as specified in Article Seven, Section One.
+
## Sources
- [IMG_2369.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1NLL76AHW809268d2oJxo-39nZJllmYpL/view?usp=drivesdk)
- · [IMG_2370.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ifBzV8phYievzHJ-a7H8mvrhaV1M2tEy/view?usp=drivesdk)
- · [IMG_2371.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/18REDUZXh8yKR3wqkV2oYfN2LZPmAdMJ-/view?usp=drivesdk)
- · [IMG_2372.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1GL4Dl1kg1ZwyD81_ofqyOsjxnFkbSDAW/view?usp=drivesdk)
- · [IMG_2373.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1TbPpcqnoYOGwK1Yhfv5dtVUDEa2IwlP9/view?usp=drivesdk)
- · [IMG_2374.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1eTu8FkPT0j9hUQTZPB_v989ozkjcozMi/view?usp=drivesdk)
- · [IMG_2375.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ZkvuKYxoLWhgTJxEyRuAzkpD1OKAgLVg/view?usp=drivesdk)
- · [IMG_2376.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1SbUvNwHoeVIvGDH9A8sq73LHeOv45erm/view?usp=drivesdk)
+ [IMG_2705.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1fm2dI3g_gZWGJOoPTc7oIMQodANGFXna/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2706.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1h5sSjZUlWd18_GoJleAIGXKE-Q-668bu/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2707.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1w4omKMbmQY7dTVzCZJfISlRWpQrzqZtZ/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2708.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1TInVUILT2v4HvsTvJg6giGsKBSeVcxmf/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2709.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1QXpU8onWdayUeKx2uSTVPMmbzVI8z4vZ/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2710.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1asFf3n3EOPDF8DImaR2ZzJO0O21-jBEV/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2711.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1S5N8V9b1PQAzRgyga06iw9j20uDaNMzZ/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2712.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1AnKChDrrffEgCMWiPYSIF7zXO20JNNe4/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2713.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/12zhCQky_XNdYBDfkHiH4NfGoQG7LeyRh/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2714.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1SGJvq3YXJ8AA6AVtfnLw1PR_54rXTj_m/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2715.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ks_eCAO-5T9E79lQzaA4iv6W7_7jqnVk/view?usp=drivesdk)
Amendments between these editions
- Student Council Approved Amendments to the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board Constitution — Bill / Constitution amendment · October 1981
- Caucus Constitutional Amendment — Bill / Constitution amendment · April 2023 · 111th session
- Secretary and Attendance Amendments to the SGA Constitution — Bill / Constitution amendment · November 2023 · 111th session
- Constitutional Amendment — Bill / Constitution amendment · February 2024 · 111th session
- Constitutional Amendment for Caucus Elections Bill — Bill / Constitution amendment · February 2024 · 111th session
- Bill - Real Representation — Bill / Constitution amendment · November 2026 · 114th session
