Compare editions
211 lines added, 371 removed
- THE CONSTITUTION
-
- OF
-
- THE UNDERGRADUATE ACADEMIC ETHICS BOARD
-
- OF THE DIVISIONS OF
-
- SCHOOL OF ARTS AND SCIENCES
-
- G.W.C. WHITING SCHOOL OF ENGINEERING
-
- (Revised May 1982)
-
- ## CONSTITUTION OF
-
- ## THE UNDERGRADUATE ACADEMIC ETHICS BOARD
-
- ## OF THE DIVISIONS OF
-
- ## SCHOOL OF ARTS AND SCIENCES
-
- ## G.W.C. WHITING SCHOOL OF ENGINEERING
-
- *(Revised May 1982)*
-
- ### Preamble
-
- It is the joint responsibility of the faculty and students of this University to maintain the academic integrity of Johns Hopkins in all respects. An ethical code must exist in the University community to guarantee high standards of conduct and to limit membership in the community to those persons able and willing to maintain these standards.
-
- An ethical code is based upon the support of the community, students and faculty alike, who must accept two kinds of responsibility: Each member must live honorably and must also take action when necessary to ensure that the community is not injured by negligence.
-
- ### Article One. Violations Of Academic Integrity
-
- Undergraduate students enrolled in the Division of Arts and Sciences or the Division of the Whiting School of Engineering at The Johns Hopkins University assume a duty to conduct themselves in a manner appropriate to the University's mission as an institution of higher education. A student is obligated to refrain from acts which he or she knows, or under the circumstances has reason to know, impairs the academic integrity of the University. Violations of academic integrity include, but are not limited to: cheating; plagiarism; unapproved multiple submissions; knowingly furnishing false information to any agent of the University for inclusion in the academic records; falsification, forgery, alteration, destruction or misuse of official University documents or seal.
-
- ### Article Two. Responsibilities Of Students And Faculty
-
- #### Section One.
-
- [handwritten: small marginal mark]
-
- All members of the academic community are responsible for the academic integrity of the University. Students and faculty alike must work together to minimize the possibility of violations of the ethics code.
-
- #### Section Two.
-
- The faculty is responsible for the conduct of examinations, for announcing the ground rules for all work in a course, and for the security of examination papers and teaching laboratories. Proctoring is at the discretion of the instructor. It is the duty of the professor to inform the student when he is suspected of a violation of academic integrity, and to proceed according to the guidelines set forth in Article Four, Section One.
-
- Section Three.
-
- It is the responsibility of each student to report to the professor in charge of the course or to the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board any suspected violations of the ethics code. It is not required that the individual suspected violators be identified, but it is apparent that corrective action by the professor can be most effective if it is based on full information.
-
- ## Article Three. The Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board
-
- ### Section One.
-
- The Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board is a subcommittee of the Committee on Undergraduate Studies. It consists of 6 students selected by the Student Council and four faculty members selected by the Academic Council. The terms of service of members of the Board shall be specified by the respective Councils.
-
- [handwritten: “10” and “6” in the margin]
-
- ### Section Two.
-
- The Board shall elect a chairman from among its members, and shall select other officers and staff as provided in its Bylaws.
-
- ### Section Three.
-
- The Board is responsible for the maintenance of the academic integrity of the undergraduate program in the Division of Arts and Sciences and the G.W.C. Whiting School of Engineering and for all matters concerning adherence to the ethics code, including but not limited to: receiving reports of suspected violations, consulting with members of the University community on ways to reduce possible violations, appointing hearing panels, maintaining confidential records, orienting new students to the philosophy and terms of the ethics code, and informing the community of its work.
-
- ### Section Four.
-
- The Board shall find and use effectively means to inform faculty and students of its activities.
-
- ### Section Five.
-
- The Board shall submit to the Committee on Undergraduate Studies a written annual report which shall not identify by name the individuals involved in its proceedings. The Committee shall transmit this report, along with its written evaluation and comments, to the Academic Council and the Student Council.
-
- ### Section Six.
-
- The Board shall adopt, with the advice of the University’s General Counsel, as part of its Bylaws, rules of procedure for hearings conducted by its hearing panels.
-
- Artic[illegible]
-
- ### Section O[illegible]
-
- When evidence indicates that [illegible]
- the part of [illegible]
- course sha[illegible]
- the studen[illegible]
- ty has occ[illegible]
- with the s[illegible]
- forth the [illegible]
- Board.
+ -78-
- ### Section T[illegible]
+ **Constitution of the Student Activities Commission**
- Upon rec[illegible]
- fessor the[illegible]
- of the cha[illegible]
- return rec[illegible]
+ *Up-to-date as of October 15, 1982*
- ### Section T[illegible]
+ # CONSTITUTION OF THE STUDENT ACTIVITIES COMMISSION
- If the cas[illegible]
- the stude[illegible]
- student a[illegible]
- Ethics B[illegible]
- Ethics Bo[illegible]
- acknowle[illegible]
- a copy of[illegible]
+ **Preamble:**
- ### Section F[illegible]
+ Recognizing the importance of increased allocations and administration of student activities funds, the Student Council establishes the Student Activities Commission to serve as its primary tool for the evaluation of financial policy.
- Upon rec[illegible]
- fessor, th[illegible]
- ing panel[illegible]
- or innocer[illegible]
- penalty f[illegible]
+ ## ARTICLE I
- ### Section F[illegible]
+ ### Section 1
- In the eve[illegible]
- for any o[illegible]
- Dean for[illegible]
- as that te[illegible]
+ The Student Activities Commission shall be responsible for the financial affairs of recognized organizations.
- [handwritten: blue marginal brackets, circles, and marks are visible on the right-hand page]
+ ### Section 2
- ## Article Four. Procedures for Handling Suspected Violations of Academic Integrity
+ The S.A.C. shall be composed of the president, or a representative of, the [unclear: Treasurer], the Student Council and the [unclear: Commissioner].
- ### Section One.
+ ### Section 3
- When evidence is found of a possible violation of academic integrity on the part of a student enrolled in a course, the professor in charge of the course shall review the evidence and the facts of the case promptly with the student. If the professor believes that a violation of academic integrity has occurred, the professor ~~has the choice of settling the case directly with the student or of communicating promptly a written charge setting forth the essential facts of the case to the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board~~.
+ The Commissioner shall have the authority
- [handwritten: Blue bracket and strikeout marks alongside the paragraph; marginal note partly illegible.]
+ 1. to submit [illegible] reports of [illegible] to the Executive Board;
+ 2. to present to the S.A.C. [illegible] the budget [illegible];
+ 3. [illegible]
+ 4. to present [illegible] the Executive Board a [illegible] of 2/3 [illegible].
- ### Section Two.
+ ## ARTICLE II
- Upon receipt of a charge of a violation of academic integrity from a professor the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board shall serve prompt notice of the charge on the accused student by hand delivery or by certified mail, return receipt requested. The notice shall contain:
+ ### Section 1
- a) a description of the alleged violation of academic integrity including insofar as possible the time, date, and place of the alleged act(s);
+ The Treasurer of the Student Council shall be responsible for [illegible], and the following duties shall be:
- b) a statement informing the student of the right to inspect at a designated place on campus and in advance of the hearing any documentary evidence intended for use at the hearing;
+ 1. [illegible] and procedures to the Commission and Executive Board and see that their [illegible] are executed;
+ 2. receive a copy of the Commission’s [illegible] the Executive Board;
+ 3. maintain comprehensive and accurate files of all [illegible] expenditures and [illegible];
+ 4. submit a report of the Student Council and the Executive Activities Commission;
+ 5. supervise all budget activities [illegible];
+ 6. report to the Board of Executive [illegible] any organization [illegible];
+ 7. prepare the [illegible] budget of any organization [illegible], pending review by the Executive Board at the time [illegible], and [illegible] within three days.
- c) a copy of the Constitution and Bylaws of the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board.
+ Constitution of the S.A.C. as of 10/15/82 (cont'd)
- ### Section Three.
+ Section 3
- If the case is settled directly between the student and the professor, with the student admitting guilt, the professor must submit the name of the student and the settlement agreed upon to the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board. Upon notification that a settlement has been made, the Ethics Board will obtain a signature from the student admitting guilt, and acknowledging that he is aware of his rights and has been provided with a copy of the Constitution and Bylaws of the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board.
+ The Executive Board shall meet at least semi-monthly during the academic year. A quorum of the Executive Board shall be the Treasurer and any other three Executive Board members.
- ### Section Four.
+ Section 4
- Upon receipt of a charge of a violation of academic integrity from a professor, the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board shall appoint a hearing panel to consider the charge. The panel shall decide the issue of guilt or innocence and, if the student is found guilty, shall impose an appropriate penalty from those specified in Article Six.
+ In the event that one of the four at large members is unable to fulfill his/her term of office, the Executive Board shall advertise the position for not less than two weeks, interview all S.A.C. members wishing to apply and shall select from these applicants a replacement.
- ### Section Five.
+ Section 5
- In the event of a violation of academic integrity in which it is inappropriate for any one professor to act as the accuser, a designee of the Associate Dean for Undergraduate and Graduate Studies shall act as the “professor” as that term is used in this Article.
+ The S.A.C. general membership shall retain the right to recall any of the four at large members of the Executive Board for reasons other than the S.A.C. can recall these members by a majority vote of all S.A.C. delegates expressed in a petition submitted to the Treasurer. After the petition is certified, the Student Council shall be notified of the officer's removal.
- ### Section Six.
+ ARTICLE IV
- A student found guilty may appeal the decision of the hearing panel to the Associate Dean for Undergraduate and Graduate Studies or to a designee of the Associate Dean within 30 days of the decision of the hearing panel. The appeal must be in the form of a written statement setting forth the grounds for the appeal. The Associate Dean shall meet with the accused student before reaching a decision. A full written report of the disposition of each appeal shall be made by the Associate Dean for Undergraduate and Graduate Studies to the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board.
+ All member organizations must abide by the constitution and by the decisions of the Executive Board. Failure to do so is grounds for freezing of funds.
- ## Article Five. Hearing Panels
+ Section 1
- ### Section One.
+ Each member organization must have a charter fully approved by the Executive Board and the Student Council stating the purpose, class status, and governing rules of the group.
- When required under the procedures of Article Four, the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board shall appoint a hearing panel of disinterested persons to consider the case.
+ Section 2
- ### Section Two.
+ The President and Treasurer of each member organization shall be required to submit in writing, at the request of the Executive Board, an annual budget request (not applicable to Class B). Plans for any project requiring more than $400 must be submitted at least two weeks prior to financial commitment.
- A hearing panel shall consist of 5 persons, ordinarily chosen from the members of the Board, the ration of faculty and students on the panel being the same as on the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board.
+ Section 3
- [handwritten: blue triangular mark and brace in the left margin]
+ All activities using student activities funds are to provide services to the undergraduate community at the Homewood campus. Funds for travel may be permitted by the Executive Board on a case-by-case basis.
- ### Section Three.
+ Section 4
- Under extraordinary circumstances the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board may appoint to a panel full-time faculty or full-time undergraduate students from the Divisions of Arts and Sciences and the Whiting School of Engineering who are not members of the Board. Such a circumstance might occur if a panel could not be appointed from among the members of the Board, or if the workload of the Board was unusually heavy.
+ No member organization may budget student activities funds for any private social function.
- ### Section Four.
+ Section 5
- Hearings of the panel shall open to the member of the University bringing charges, the accused, any witness called by either party, and not more than one representative of the accused who is a full-time student presently enrolled in either the School of Arts and Sciences or the Whiting School of Engineering. Hearings shall be confidential and shall be closed to spectators and the press.
+ Member organizations may spend their allocations only in the manner originally budgeted. Significant deviation requires the express permission of the Executive Board in advance of financial commitment.
- ### Section Five.
+ ## Section 4
- The accused shall be presumed innocent until found to be guilty.
+ Class D organizations are publications. These groups are to be represented on the S.A.C. by two individuals; the chief executive officer and the chief financial officer. Class D groups are limited to request funds annually from the Executive Board. Budget proposals must include all revenues and expenditures outside of S.A.C. funds. In order to satisfy the criterion of service to the undergraduate community, Class D publications must print primarily undergraduate material.
- ### Section Six.
+ ## Section 5
- The decision of the hearing panel on guilt or innocence shall be based upon a preponderance of the evidence and shall be communicated promptly in writing to the Associate Dean for Undergraduate and Graduate Studies.
+ All organizations during their first year of existence shall be Class E, which is probationary status. At the end of the probationary period, the organization's status will be reviewed by the Executive Board and the Student Council for transfer to [unclear: primary status]. An organization may also be placed in Class E solely by majority vote of the Executive Board. This power is to be exercised as a sanction in case of financial irresponsibility or failure to meet constitutional requirements.
- ### Section Seven.
+ [illegible] organizations of any type must be approved by the Executive Board. All organizations with Class E status shall be entitled to one representative on the Student Activities Commission; this position shall be filled by the group's chief executive officer.
- At least 4 votes of guilty are required for conviction.
+ # ARTICLE VI
- …g panel to
- …es or to a
- … of the hear-
- …ent setting
- …t with the
- …ort of the
- Dean for
- Academic
+ ## Section 1
- …rgraduate
- …ested per-
+ The [unclear: whole] membership of the Commission shall be convened at least three times a semester. There must be at least one meeting of any executive group that consists of a simple majority of all chartered S.A.C. groups.
- …from the
- …the panel
- …oard.
+ ## Section 2
- …mic Ethics
- …rgraduate
- …ng School
- …cumstance
- …members
- … heavy.
+ No single person shall have more than one vote on the [unclear: Commission]. Should an individual be entitled to two or more votes, he/she shall relinquish all but one vote, and the position of S.A.C. representative shall be filled by the executive member of the sponsoring group.
- …sity
- …bring-
- …not more
- …at present-
- …ng School
- …ed to spec-
+ # ARTICLE VII
- …ilty.
+ ## Section 1
- … absence of prior misconduct.
+ Amendments to this constitution may only be proposed to the Student Council by a majority vote of the Executive Board, by a two-thirds vote of a meeting of the whole Commission, or, [unclear: upon written request by the student membership]. All such proposed amendments are subject to the approval of a Student Council.
- ## Section Eight.
+ Draft Report of the Constitutional Committee of the S.A.C.44-
- Hearings shall be conducted in accordance with rules of procedure provided for in the Bylaws of the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board.
+ The Committee, at meetings on September 28, 1982, October 5, 1982, and October 15, 1982 met to consider proposals for amendments to the S.A.C. Constitution. It held authority from and reported to the Commission per terms of its establishment by resolution of the Commission on Sept. 16, 1982. Its membership was established as the following:
- ## Section Nine.
+ Henry S. DAVIS, Chairman
- If an accused student fails to appear for a hearing after having been duly served with notice or withdraws from a hearing before its conclusion without the permission of the hearing panel, and if the hearing panel determines that such action has been willful, immediate suspension of the accused from the University may be imposed. Such a suspension shall continue until the hearing can be concluded with the student present.
+ Theodore A. HILL, Committeeman
- # Article Six. Penalties
+ Charles J. KRULNICKY, Committeeman
- ## Section One.
+ Grant M. LALLY, Committeeman
- Whenever a student is found guilty of a violation of academic integrity, whether by direct settlement with the professor or by a hearing panel of the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board, the name of the students will be entered on a list of students who have been found guilty of the violations of academic integrity, as per Article Seven, Section One. The following penalties may be imposed upon students found guilty of violations of academic integrity:
+ James E. SALLES, Committeeman (Secretary)
- a) Retake of the examination, paper, or exercise involved.
+ Mitchell D. SMITH, Committeeman
- b) Score of zero in the examination, paper, or exercise involved.
+ **FORMAT OF THE REPORT:**
- c) Lowering of the course grade as specified by a hearing panel of the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board.
+ This committee shall issue a number of individual proposals, denominated *Committee Proposal*, numbered one upwards. Each shall deal with one proposed section of the constitution, except where the section as proposed contains subparagraphs, in which case each committee proposal shall deal with one proposed subparagraph of a section. In published copies of the draft and final reports of this committee, the current wording of the corresponding passage in the constitution shall appear under the heading "current wording". These are included for reference only. Each proposal shall be understood as calling for the striking of the correspondingly numbered section or subparagraph of the original document, unless a different section or subparagraph is detailed as corresponding to the proposal, in which case the proposal shall be understood as calling for the striking of that section or subparagraph.
- d) Failure in the course.
+ **RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE COMMISSION ON FORMAT OF PASSAGE OF COMMITTEE REPORT OR SECTIONS THEREOF:**
- e) Failure in the course with a notation on the transcript that the grade was for a violation of academic integrity.
+ The Committee recommends to the Commission that it pass the following motion:
- f) Failure in the course with suspension from the University.
+ The proposals passed by this Commission as appearing in the report of the Constitutional Committee of the Student Activities Commission, are to be considered a series of individual, discrete, unamendable, and indivisible proposals, made to Student Council by authority of Article VII Section 1 of the S.A.C. Constitution, which reserves to this Commission and the Executive Board the right to originate proposals for amendments to the S.A.C. Constitution; any attempt to amend any Committee proposal, or to divide the question when a Committee proposal is under discussion, made on the floor of the Student Council, shall result in the proposal being automatically considered withdrawn by this Commission and thus rendered not properly before Council. The Commission also respects any unification recommendations made by the Committee as such shall appear in the addendum to the draft report incorporated into the final report; any two or more Committee proposals recommended to the Commission to be combined by such unification recommendation shall be considered as one discrete, unamendable, and indivisible proposal in the terms of this motion.
- g) Failure in the course with suspension from the University and notation on the transcript that the grade was for a violation of academic integrity.
+ [handwritten: END OF MOTION RECOMMENDED]
- h) Suspension from the University for at least one semester.
+ Draft copy of the Constitutional Committee of the S.A.C. ([unclear: copy number])
- i) Suspension from the University for at least one semester with a notation on the transcript that the cause was a violation of academic integrity.
+ [unclear: Committee Proposal 14 (p. 10 minutes)]
- j) Expulsion from the University.
+ ## Article I, Section 4 (new section)
- A hearing panel shall make every effort to select a penalty appropriate to the severity of the offense, and may take into consideration any mitigating circumstances brought to its attention as well as any record or absence of prior misconduct.
+ Any member of the Council may submit any proposal within the authority of the Executive body to any member of the Executive Board for the Board's consideration. The proposer may request that the Executive Board provide information on the proposal before the proposal is presented. The Executive Board shall be bound by the request and must consider and give a final approval or rejection of the proposal no later than at the close of the second Executive Board meeting following submission of the proposal. The Board may not table or further postpone consideration of the proposal in question, and such decision shall be entered on the minutes of the Executive Board, a copy of which shall be supplied to the originator of the proposal at his/her request.
- ## Section Two.
+ [unclear: Committee Proposal 18 (p. 4 minutes)]
- A second or subsequent finding of guilt of a violation of academic integrity shall result in a penalty selected from (g) through (j) in Section One above.
+ ## Article II, Section 1, paragraph [unclear]
- Section Three.
+ The Treasurer of the Student Council shall chair the Committee and the Executive Board and as Chairman shall;
- A student found guilty of a violation of academic integrity in a course forfeits the right to withdraw from the course or to change a graded course to one pass/fail and any withdrawal from that course or change effected prior to the finding of guilty shall be voided.
+ Current wording: The Treasurer of the Student Council shall chair the Committee and the Executive Board and shall;
- Section Four.
+ [unclear: Committee Proposal 16 (p. 5 minutes)]
- A student who has committed a violation of academic integrity has the option of making a timely and personal report of the offense to the professor in charge of the course or to the Associate Dean for Undergraduate and Graduate Studies. A violation of academic integrity reported and dealt with under this section shall not constitute a first offense within the purview of Article Seven, Section One.
+ ## Article II, Section 1, Sub-paragraph 1
- Article Seven. Records
+ [unclear: and provide an agenda of meetings of the Committee and the Executive Board's basic responsibility in each case for the giving of timely notice to all members of the appropriate body. In the case of meetings of the full Executive Board, it must be given a written notice to each member at least [illegible] days prior to the meeting.]
- Section One.
+ ## Article II, Section 1, Sub-paragraph 6
- The Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board shall maintain among its records a list of names of students found to be guilty of violations of academic integrity. It is this list which is consulted to determine whether an offense is a first offense or is a second or subsequent offense.
+ Strike subparagraph 6. Renumber subparagraph 7 as subparagraph 6.
- Section Two.
+ Current wording: The Board [unclear: shall elect] a secretary and such other officers as may become necessary.
- The confidential records of the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board shall be held in a locked file in the office of the Associate Dean for Undergraduate and Graduate Studies.
+ Draft report of the Constitutional Committee of the A.C. (cont'd)
- Section Three.
+ **Committee Proposal #1 (Minutes p. 15)**
- Access to the confidential records of the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board shall be limited to the Associate Dean for Undergraduate and Graduate Studies and to members of the Board.
+ **Article III, Section 2, subparagraph 12**
- Section Four.
+ to establish and/or approve policy guidelines. A [unclear: copy?] of these guidelines shall be published and made available to Committee members upon request. Any change to such guidelines shall be reported to the [illegible] Commission.
- A case file concerning an accused student shall be retained for four years after the student's last enrollment as an undergraduate and shall then be destroyed.
+ **Concern:** It is possible to revise the Commission guidelines, when necessary.
- Article Eight. Bylaws and Amendments
+ **Committee Proposal #2 (Minutes p. 16 [illegible])**
- Section One.
+ **Article III, Section 2, subparagraph 12**
- The Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board shall adopt Bylaws to govern its operation.
+ That a majority of the members of the Executive Board may [illegible] an appropriate motion at a meeting of the Executive Committee. This motion shall direct the Chairman to call a meeting of the appropriate [illegible], and the Chairman shall give thirty days notice to all members of the appropriate body. A petition of at least [illegible] members of the Commission upon direction by petition signed by a majority of the Commission membership.
- Section Two.
+ Current: A [illegible] call a meeting of the Commission by [illegible] vote of any three members on an appropriate motion at a meeting of the Executive Committee. The motion shall direct the Chairman to call a meeting of the [illegible], and the Chairman shall give thirty days notice to all members called under the provisions of Article I, Section 1.
- Amendments to this Constitution shall take effect when they are adopted in identical language by both the Academic Council and the Student Council.
+ **Committee Proposal #3 (Minutes p. 17 [illegible])**
- Section T[illegible].
+ **Article III, Section 2**
- The Const[illegible]
+ The [illegible] shall be able to [illegible] [illegible] who shall [illegible] the [illegible] Executive Board members.
- are public[illegible]
+ Current version: In the event that one of the four elected members is unable to [illegible] [illegible] of the Executive Board shall be [illegible] by vote of the [illegible] Executive Board members. [illegible] for not less than one or more than two weeks, [illegible] A.C. members wishing to apply and select from those applicants a replacement.
- Section O[illegible].
+ Draft report of the Constitution committee of the S.A.C. (cont'd)
- At the be[illegible]
- one studen[illegible]
- extraordin[illegible]
- The chair[illegible]
- decide all[illegible]
- sible for r[illegible]
+ **Committee proposal #10** (p. 19 minutes)
- Section T[illegible].
+ **Article IV Section 3**
- Upon app[illegible]
- list of facu[illegible]
- shall be f[illegible]
- three stude[illegible]
- shall be in[illegible]
- will be exp[illegible]
- ter if for[illegible]
- impartial[illegible]
- alternate[illegible]
+ corresponds to Article IV Section 2
- Section T[illegible].
+ The President and Treasurer of each organization shall be required to submit in writing an annual budget request to the executive board (not applicable to Clause 5 of Article IV). All organizations receiving funding shall submit revised budgets to [illegible].
- In the eve[illegible]
- available f[illegible]
- from-the[illegible]
- the School[illegible]
- The Chair[illegible]
- will sugges[illegible]
- appointme[illegible]
- of the four[illegible]
- Council.
- members[illegible]
+ Current wording: The President and Treasurer of each member organization shall be required to submit the annual budget request (not applicable to Clause 5). Plans for any project requiring more than $400 must be submitted at least two weeks prior to financial committee.
- [handwritten: illegible]
+ **Committee proposal #11** (p. 19 minutes)
- [handwritten: illegible]
+ **Article IV Section 4**
- Section Three.
+ corresponds to Article IV Section 3
- The Constitution and Bylaws of the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board are public documents.
+ All student activities funds are to provide services to the undergraduate community.
- ## Article Nine. Procedural Appeal
+ Current wording: All activities using student activities funds are to provide services to the undergraduate community. [illegible]
- Any violation of the procedures set forth in this Constitution and its appended Bylaws shall give the accused student the right to request the dismissal of the case from the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board and/or the Associate Dean for Undergraduate and Graduate Studies.
+ **Committee proposal #12** (p. 19 minutes)
- # ACADEMIC ETHICS BOARD
- # HEARING PANEL PROCEDURES
- *(Revised January 1979)*
+ **Article IV Section 6**
- ## Selection of Hearing Panel and Presiding Official
+ corresponds to Article IV Section 5
- ### Section One.
+ [illegible] of the IV section 6. Remember [illegible] contained in proposal #17 as follows:
- At the beginning of each academic year the Ethics Board shall appoint one student member to serve as the presiding official at all hearings. Under extraordinary circumstances the presiding official may disqualify himself. The chairman will appoint a replacement. The presiding official shall decide all procedural questions. The presiding official will also be responsible for maintaining records of all procedural decisions.
+ [illegible]
- ### Section Two.
+ Remember [illegible].
- Upon appointment, the presiding official shall prepare a randomly ordered list of faculty and student members of the Ethics Board. A hearing panel shall be formed by choosing the first two faculty members and the first three student members of the respective lists. Members of the hearing panel shall be informed of the name of the accused and the accuser. Members will be expected to disqualify themselves from participation in any matter if for any reason they believe their ability to consider charges in an impartial fashion will be affected. One faculty alternate and one student alternate shall be chosen in the same manner.
+ [illegible]
- [handwritten: marginal note, unclear]
+ [illegible]
- ### Section Three.
+ [illegible]
- In the event that an insufficient number of Ethics Board members are available for a hearing panel, additional panel members shall be appointed ~~from the full-time faculty and full-time undergraduate student body in~~ the School of Arts and Sciences and the Whiting School of Engineering. The Chairman of the Ethics Board, with the aid of members of the Board, will suggest names of individuals willing to serve on hearing panels. Before appointment to a hearing panel, an individual must by approved by three of the four faculty members of the Board and by four of the six student members of the Board.
+ **Committee proposal #13** (p. 20 minutes)
- [handwritten: marginal mark]
+ **Article IV Section 7**
- # Rights and Responsibilities of Individuals Before a Hearing
+ All organizations recognized by member organizations must be open to all members of the undergraduate community.
- ## Section One.
+ Current wording: All activities sponsored by member organizations must be open to all members of the undergraduate community if the proposed [illegible].
- The accused shall be notified in writing of a charge of a violation of academic integrity as provided in Article Four, Section Two of the Ethics Board Constitution. The written notice shall be served personally or sent by certified mail to the student at least seven days prior to the hearing at the address appearing on University records. The accused will have three days from the date of notification to file with the presiding official two peremptory challenges and other challenges for cause against the panel members. Panel members named in peremptory challenges shall be disqualified. The presiding official will rule on challenges for cause. The chairman of the Ethics Board will replace panel members removed by challenge.
+ Draft report of the S.A.C. Constitutional Committee (cont'd)
- ## Section Two.
+ **Committee Proposal #26** (p. 22 minutes)
- The accuser shall deposit with the presiding official any documentary evidence to be used at the hearing before the times given in Section Three of this Article.
+ **Article V, Section 2**
- ## Section Three.
+ corresponds to Article V, Section 1
- The accused and one full-time undergraduate student chosen by the accused to be his representative may inspect all documentary evidence and, if practical, will be furnished with Xerox copies of the evidence. If the School of Arts and Sciences and the Whiting School of Engineering are in session, inspection shall be permitted at least two days, excluding weekends and brief vacations, before the hearing. If the School of Arts and Sciences and the Whiting School of Engineering are not in session, inspection shall be permitted at least five days before the hearing. The presiding official will keep any documentary evidence and be responsible for its security until a determination in the case has been made.
+ Class A organizations will be represented on the Student Activities Committee by the president, the treasurer, the executive officer and chief financial officer. Class A groups are entitled to petition the Executive Board for annual budget allocation of student activity funds. Class A groups are required to sponsor at least one fund-raising activity per year.
- ## Section Four.
+ Current wording: Class A organizations shall be represented on the Student Activities Committee by the president, the vice-president, the treasurer, the [unclear: secretary] and chief financial officer. Class A groups are required to petition the Executive Board for annual budget allocation of student activity funds. Class A groups are required to sponsor at least one fund-raising activity per year.
- The hearing panel members shall not be informed of details of the charge before the hearing is convened and shall scrupulously avoid discussing the pending hearing either with the parties concerned, possible witnesses, or any other persons. Panel members shall not discuss the merits of the charges with each other prior to entering into a determination of the charges.
+ **Committee Proposal #7** (p. 24 minutes)
- ## Section Five.
+ **Article V, Section 4**
- The accused and the representative of the accused may discuss procedures with the presiding official but may not approach members of the panel, the accuser, or the accuser’s witnesses concerning any matter directly or indirectly related to the hearing.
+ corresponds to Article V, Section 3
- ## Section One.
+ Class C groups shall be the Student Council, the Freshman Class, the Sophomore Class and the Senior Class. These groups are represented by the president, vice-president and treasurer, while the Student Council is represented by the president and treasurer. Class C groups are entitled to petition the Executive Board for annual budget allocation of student activity funds.
- Students cha[illegible]
+ Current wording: Class C groups shall be student government organizations which [illegible] the student [illegible] and the [illegible] officers. Class C groups are represented by the president and treasurer.
- currence may[illegible]
+ **[unclear: Committee Proposal #?]** (p. 26 minutes)
- official. Cha[illegible]
+ **Article V, Section 5**
+ corresponds to Article V, Section 4
- from several[illegible]
+ Class C organizations are permanently budgeted. These groups are to be represented on the S.A.C. by the respective class officers and the [unclear: student government] officers. Class B groups are entitled to petition the Executive Board for annual budget proposals, but receive all revenues and expenditures outside of S.A.C. funds. In order to satisfy the objectives of service to the undergraduate community, Class C groups shall continue their [unclear: primary undergraduate] [illegible].
- instance of[illegible]
+ (cont'd)
- ## Section Two.
+ Draft report of the Constitutional Committee of the S.A.C. (cont'd)
- The accused[illegible]
+ **Committee Proposal #20** (p. 28 minutes)
- ## Section One.
+ Article V, Section 7 (new section)
- days to file a[illegible]
+ In the event that a Class A, B, D or E group's S.A.C. representative was unable to attend an S.A.C. meeting any elected officer as shall be designated by that organization at its S.A.C. meeting as a voting member.
- ficial. The pr[illegible]
+ **Committee Proposal #21** (p. 29 minutes)
- decision.
+ Article VI, Section 1 (new section)
- ## Section One.
+ The rights of freedom of speech and of press shall be guaranteed to all groups by the S.A.C.
- The presiding[illegible]
+ Renumber Article VI to VII
- ing panel sha[illegible]
+ Renumber Article VII to VIII
- ## Section Two.
+ **Committee Proposal #22** (p. 29 minutes)
- The accused,[illegible]
+ Article VI, Section 2 (new section)
- the accused s[illegible]
+ No publication, drama, dance, film, forum or other production by an S.A.C. group may be censored by the S.A.C., S.A.C. Executive Council, or any officer thereof, nor may any groups be prevented from [illegible] in a censoring manner.
- tion of evide[illegible]
+ **Committee Proposal #23** (p. 29 minutes)
- ## Section Thre[illegible]
+ Article VI, Section 2 (new section)
- Other individ[illegible]
+ The executive committee or editorial board of any group shall be responsible for the publication of that publication.
- giving testim[illegible]
+ **Committee Proposal #24** (p. 29 minutes)
- testifying, wit[illegible]
+ Article VI, Section 3 (new section)
- official of th[illegible]
+ Any group desiring to obtain copyright under United States copyright law may designate the publisher, or [illegible] of any [illegible].
- ## Section One.
+ The Grinnell Student Association
- ### Record
+ **Committee Proposal #25** (p. 5 minutes)
- A full and co[illegible]
+ Article VI, Section 1
+ corresponding to Article VI, section 1
- cording or ot[illegible]
+ Meetings of the Committee shall be called at least three times a semester and may be held at least one meeting in any seven week period during the semester, at the request of a [unclear: single/simple] majority of all chartered S.A.C. groups.
- copy of the ta[illegible]
+ # Draft report of the Constitutional Committee of the S.A.C. (cont'd.)
- appeal. No re[illegible]
+ ## Committee Proposal #75 (cont'd. from p. 54)
- shall, howeve[illegible]
+ **Current wording:** The whole membership of the Commission shall be convened at least three times a semester. There may be at least one meeting in any event at which there is a quorum. A quorum shall consist of a simple majority of all chartered S.A.C. groups.
- finding of gu[illegible]
+ ## Committee Proposal #76 (p. 30 minutes)
- shall be used[illegible]
+ **Article VII, Section 2**
+ corresponds to Article VI, Section 2
- and shall be w[illegible]
+ No single person shall hold more than one vote in the Commission. Should an individual be entitled to two or more votes, he shall relinquish all but one vote, and the position of S.A.C. representative shall be filled by the organization(s) involved. No proxy votes are allowed.
- ty of individu[illegible]
+ **Current wording:** No single person shall hold more than one vote in the Commission. Should an individual be entitled to two or more votes, he shall relinquish all but one vote, and the position of S.A.C. representative shall be filled by the executive committee of the organization(s) involved.
- reports..
+ ## Committee Proposal #77 (p. 5, p. 3 minutes)
- [illegible]e a Hearing
+ **Article VIII, Section 1**
+ formerly Article VII, Section 1
- [illegible] of a violation of
- [illegible] Two of the Ethics
- [illegible] personally or sent
- [illegible] or to the hearing
- [illegible]sed will have three
- [illegible]ding official two
- [illegible] against the panel
- [illegible]nges shall be dis-
- [illegible] cause. The chair-
- [illegible]ved by challenge.
+ Amendments to the constitution may only be proposed by a majority vote of the Executive Board, by a two-thirds vote of a quorum of the Commission, if such proposed amendments are subject to the approval of the Council. The constitution may also be amended by student referendum.
- [illegible]ny documentary
- [illegible] in Section Three
+ **Current wording:** Amendments to the constitution may only be proposed by a majority vote of the Executive Board, by a two-thirds vote of a quorum of the Commission, or under direction from the Student Body through a referendum. All such proposed amendments are subject to the approval of the Student Council.
- [illegible]osen by the ac-
- [illegible] evidence and,
- [illegible] evidence. If the
- [illegible] Engineering are
- [illegible] days, excluding
- [illegible] School of Arts
- [illegible] not in session,
- [illegible]e hearing. The
- [illegible] be responsible
- [illegible]en made.
+ ## Committee Proposal #78 (p. 7 minutes)
- [illegible]ils of the charge
- [illegible] and discussing the
- [illegible]ole witnesses, or
- [illegible] the merits of the
- [illegible]mination of the
+ **Article VIII, Section 2**
+ corresponds to Article VII, Section 2
- [illegible]scuss procedures
- [illegible]ers of the panel,
- [illegible]atter directly or
+ Changes in the Constitution of the Student Body of the Johns Hopkins University may be made by the Student Activities Commission and are to be formally and immediately incorporated into this document for the purpose of bringing it into conformity with the Constitution of the Student Body of the Johns Hopkins University.
- # Joinder of Charges
+ ## Committee Proposal #42 (cont’d from p. 55)
- ## Section One.
+ **a)** The Executive Board shall review the names of all candidates for the medal and select 4 [unclear] who have contributed in a significant manner to the advancement of student activities while undergraduates.
- Students charged with misconduct arising from a single incident or occurrence may have their hearings joined at the instance of the presiding official. Charges of academic misconduct against a single student arising from several incidents or occurrences may be heard at one hearing at the instance of the presiding official.
+ **c)** The Chairman shall inform all members of the names of those nominated for the medals.
- ## Section Two.
+ **e)** Members of the S.A.C. shall have one week to submit to the Executive Board any protests for additions or deletions with reasons, which the Executive Board shall proceed to consider.
- The accused will receive written notification of a joinder of charges (see Section One of Rights and Responsibilities). The accused shall have three days to file any objections to joinder with cause with the presiding official. The presiding official will consider the objection and make a final decision.
+ **f)** The S.A.C. shall then approve the revised list, or veto the list by three-fifths vote of a quorum at a meeting of the Commission. If the list is vetoed the Executive Board shall revise the list and continue as in subparagraph (g).
- # Individual Present at Hearing
+ **g)** The Chairman shall then provide all members of the S.A.C., the Student Council, and the Senior Class Award Committee, of the names of those receiving the S.A.C. Medal.
- ## Section One.
+ * * * * * * * *
- The presiding official, who shall act as recorder, and members of the hearing panel shall be in attendance throughout the proceedings.
+ <u>Committee Proposal #13</u> (cont'd from p.64)
- ## Section Two.
+ (continuation of committee proposal:
+ Article III, Section 2, Subparagraph 13)
- The accused, the accuser(s), and the full-time student representative of the accused shall be present throughout the accused’s plea, the presentation of evidence, and questioning.
+ The Chairman shall call a meeting of the Commission upon direction by petition signed by one-quarter of the Commission membership.
- ## Section Three.
+ Current wording: Call a meeting of the Commission by affirmative vote of any three members on an appropriate motion at a meeting of the Executive Committee. The motion shall direct the Chairman to call a meeting at a given time, and the Chairman shall give timely notice to all S.A.C. members as in a meeting called under the provisions of Article II Section 1.
- Other individuals shall be present at the hearing only for the purpose of giving testimony and only during the duration of their testimony. After testifying, witnesses shall remain available and shall inform the presiding official of their whereabouts and how they may be reached.
+ <u>Committee Proposal #29</u> (p. 26, p. 27, p. 60 minutes)
- # Hearing Procedure
+ Article V, Section 6
+ corresponds to Article V, Section 5
- ## Section One.
+ All organizations during their first year of existence shall be Class E, which is a probationary status. At the end of the probationary period, the organization's status will be reviewed by the Executive Board and the Student Council for transfer to permanent class status. An organization may also be recommended for Class E status to the Student Council by a majority vote of the Executive Board at a meeting at which all members are present. In cases of financial irresponsibility or failure to meet constitutional requirements, such a recommendation shall not be submitted to Student Council until after the occurrence of one general S.A.C. meeting after the action is taken. Expenditures of such groups must be approved by the Executive Board, except for groups in the first year of operation so designated. All organizations with Class E status shall be entitled to one representative on the Student Activities Commission; this position shall be filled by the group's chief executive officer.
- ### Record
+ Current wording: All organizations during their first year of existence shall be Class E, which is a probationary status. At the end of the probationary period, the organization's status will be reviewed by the Executive Board and the Student Council for transfer to permanent Class status. An organization may also be placed in Class E status by a majority vote of the Executive Board. This power is to be exercised as a sanction in cases of financial irresponsibility or failure to meet constitutional requirements. Expenditures of such groups must be approved by the Executive Board, and their student activities account shall be open at the discretion of the Executive Board. All organizations with Class E status shall be entitled to one representative on the Student Activities Commission; this position shall be filled by the group's chief executive officer.
- A full and complete record shall be made of the proceedings by tape recording or other suitable device. The accused shall be furnished with a copy of the tape recording at his request for the purpose of preparing an appeal. No record of the deliberations shall be made. The hearing panel shall, however, prepare a brief written report detailing the reasons for the finding of guilt or innocence and for any penalty imposed. Such reports shall be used only to help establish uniformity of verdicts and penalties and shall be written so as not to divulge, directly or indirectly, the identity of individuals. The Board will maintain a permanent file of all such reports.
+ ## Committee Proposal #42 (cont'd)
- BYLAWS
+ ### Proposed By-Law #2 (cont'd)
- 1) The tapes of hearings conducted under the Ethics Code shall be maintained for a period of four years in the offices of the University General Counsel.
+ representative making the nomination.
- 2) Documentary evidence introduced at hearings conducted under the Ethics Code shall be maintain for a period of four years in the offices of the University General Counsel.
+ c) The Executive Board shall review the names of all candidates for the seals and select a list of 25 who have contributed in a significant manner to the advancement of student activities while undergraduates.
- 3) The records of proceedings at hearings conducted under the Ethics Code shall be deemed confidential.
+ d) The Chairman shall inform all members of the names of those nominated for the seals.
- 4) The presiding official of each case shall prepare a synopsis of the case. Such synopsis shall specify the nature of the charge, the course in which the alleged violation took place, the determination of the hearing panel and penalty imposed, and the outcome of any appeal. The identity of the accused and accuser shall not be divulged.
+ e) Members of the S.A.C. shall have one week to submit to the Executive Board a written request for additions or deletions citing reasons, which the Executive Board shall proceed to consider.
- 5) The Chairperson shall make public (after each case) the course in which the alleged violation took place and the determination of the hearing panel.
+ f) The S.A.C. shall then approve the revised list, or veto the list by three-fifths vote of a quorum at a meeting of the Commission. If the list is vetoed the Executive Board shall revise the list and continue as in subparagraph d).
- 6) A breach of confidentiality of a case shall cause the removal of an Academic Ethics Board member by a majority of the Academic Ethics Board.
+ g) The Chairman shall then provide all members of the S.A.C., the Student Council, and the Senior Class Awards Committee of the names of those receiving the S.A.C. seal.
- 7) The Ethics Code Hearing Panel Procedures and Bylaws may be amended by the approval of three of the four faculty members and four of the six student members at a meeting of the Ethics Board for which notice has been given at least one week prior to the meeting. The wording of the proposed amendment shall be included with the notice of the meeting.
+ . . . . . . . . . .
- [handwritten: Blue margin mark/arrow beside item 7.]
+ The Committee votes to include in its report the comment that it considers its proposals #1, #2, #3, #5, #6, #7, #8, #9, #10, #11, #14, #15, #17, #18, #22, #24, #25, #26, #27, #28, #35, #37, #38, and #40 "technical".
- 8) The Academics Ethics Board shall elect officers as needed. Officers shall be elected by a vote of three of the four faculty members and four of the six student members. The term of each officer shall expire at the end of the academic year.
+ . . . . . . . . .
- [handwritten: Red mark in the left margin beside item 8.]
+ The Committee recommends to the Student Activities Commission that its mandate be extended to deal with questions, comments, and concerns raised by Student Council and other parties and be empowered to report to the Executive Board as well as the Commission (rather than, as previously, exclusively to the Commission) to serve as a vehicle for resubmission of revised proposals to Council.
- 9) A student exercising the option specified in Article Six, Section Four must do so before a formal accusation is made to the Academic Ethics Board. The Academic Ethics Board shall conduct a hearing to investigate the violation and shall impose a penalty but will not record the student's name on its confidential records as specified in Article Seven, Section One.
+ . . . . . . . . .
## Sources
- [IMG_2705.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1fm2dI3g_gZWGJOoPTc7oIMQodANGFXna/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2706.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1h5sSjZUlWd18_GoJleAIGXKE-Q-668bu/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2707.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1w4omKMbmQY7dTVzCZJfISlRWpQrzqZtZ/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2708.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1TInVUILT2v4HvsTvJg6giGsKBSeVcxmf/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2709.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1QXpU8onWdayUeKx2uSTVPMmbzVI8z4vZ/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2710.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1asFf3n3EOPDF8DImaR2ZzJO0O21-jBEV/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2711.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1S5N8V9b1PQAzRgyga06iw9j20uDaNMzZ/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2712.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1AnKChDrrffEgCMWiPYSIF7zXO20JNNe4/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2713.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/12zhCQky_XNdYBDfkHiH4NfGoQG7LeyRh/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2714.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1SGJvq3YXJ8AA6AVtfnLw1PR_54rXTj_m/view?usp=drivesdk) · [IMG_2715.HEIC](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ks_eCAO-5T9E79lQzaA4iv6W7_7jqnVk/view?usp=drivesdk)
+ [1982 Constitution.pdf](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1RLv4wOSbK-omzDV20ISfn3pdLtQaDLzU/view?usp=drivesdk)
Amendments between these editions
- Student Council Approved Amendments to the Undergraduate Academic Ethics Board Constitution — Bill / Constitution amendment · October 1981
- Caucus Constitutional Amendment — Bill / Constitution amendment · April 2023 · 111th session
- Secretary and Attendance Amendments to the SGA Constitution — Bill / Constitution amendment · November 2023 · 111th session
- Constitutional Amendment — Bill / Constitution amendment · February 2024 · 111th session
- Constitutional Amendment for Caucus Elections Bill — Bill / Constitution amendment · February 2024 · 111th session
- Bill - Real Representation — Bill / Constitution amendment · November 2026 · 114th session
