JHU SGAThe 114th Session

This website is not official. Visit the official site here .

← Back to document

Compare editions

54 lines added, 106 removed

- ## THE YOUNG TRUSTEE BY-LAW
-
- Title I. The Position of Young Trustee
-
- SECTION 1. Nature of the Position One undergraduate student, called the Young Trustee, shall be elected each year as a nominee to the Board of Trustees to serve a two or three-year term, the duration of which will alternate yearly. A Young Trustee may not serve more than one two or three-year term. The Young Trustee must resign at the end of the two or three-year term. For the first year of the term, the Young Trustee will be a non-voting member of the Board.
-
- SECTION 2. Eligible Candidates First-years, sophomores, juniors, and seniors of the undergraduate student body shall be eligible for the Young Trustee position. Eligible seniors include those persons designated as December graduates of the senior class. The current Duke Student Government President is not eligible to run to be the Young Trustee.
-
- SECTION 3. Conflict of Interest No Young Trustee may be an employee of the University (excluding work-study) once the term as Young Trustee begins.
-
- SECTION 4. Deadline for Election of Young Trustee The name of the Young Trustee must be placed in nomination before the Board of Trustees before the February Board of Trustees meeting.
-
- SECTION 5. Criteria for Young Trustee The Young Trustee should meet the following criteria, the interpretation whereof shall be at the discretion of the Young Trustee Nominating Committee and shall not be grounds for litigation:
-
- 1. Evidence an ability to think broadly about the University;
-
- 2. Be able to communicate not only the short-term effects that the Board’s policies will have on students, but the long-term effects as well;
-
- 3. Be able to articulate a worldview about issues with a breadth of understanding;
-
- 4. Be able to speak up in intimidating situations while recognizing when and how to do so;
-
- 5. Demonstrate commitment to making Duke a better place and helping further its mission;
-
- 6. Possess an active interest in continuing to learn about the University and how it works;
-
- 7. Offer evidence demonstrating their good character.
-
- 8. Be able to demonstrate these criteria in their written application materials and interview.
-
- SECTION 6. Overview of Selection Process The selection process for Young Trustee shall proceed as follows, subject to the other provisions of this By-Law:
-
- 1. The University Secretary or their designate and the current Duke Student Government President will solicit applications through the Office of the University Secretary to put together the Young Trustee Nominating Committee (YTNC).
-
- 2. The YTNC shall select two to four Young Trustee (YT) Finalists.
-
- 3. The student body shall elect one of the YT Finalists to be Young Trustee.
-
- 4. The Young Trustee shall be the official nominee of the student body for appointment to the Board of Trustees pursuant to relevant Board policies.
-
- Title II. The Young Trustee Nominating Committee Selection Committee
-
- SECTION 1. Selection of the Young Trustee Nominating Committee The University Secretary or their designate shall conduct a well-publicized application and interview process to select the twelve-member Young Trustee Nominating Committee (YTNC).
-
- The University Secretary or their designate and the DSG President will select the members of the YTNC. Any undergraduate may apply to serve on the YTNC. The University Secretary and the DSG President shall choose as few as ten students to constitute the YTNC and as many as twelve members, and shall also prepare a ranked list of alternates, consisting of applicants to the YTNC who would be qualified to serve but were not selected. The University Secretary or their designate shall select a mentor to advise the YTNC. The mentor must either be a member of the faculty or an administrator to the university. At least one member of the YTNC must have been, or currently be, a voting member of a Board of Trustees committee. No member of or alternate for YTNC may apply for Young Trustee in that year’s selection process. The YTNC shall elect a Chair from within its membership.
-
- SECTION 2. Appointment of Alternates If the membership of the Young Trustee Nominating Committee falls below eight for any reason, alternates shall automatically be appointed to the YTNC, in the order that their names appear on the list prepared by The University Secretary and the Duke Student Government President, to restore the membership of the YTNC to ten. If the list of alternates is exhausted, the YTNC shall choose volunteers from the Senate to restore its membership to ten.
-
- SECTION 3. Quorum A quorum to transact business is seven members of the YTNC or two-thirds of the entire membership of the YTNC, whichever is lesser.
-
- SECTION 4. The YTNC Chair Before Thanksgiving Break, or as soon as feasible thereafter, the YTNC shall convene and, by majority vote, shall elect a Chair. The Chair shall:
-
- 1. Receive applications for Young Trustee;
+ ## THE UNIVERSITY COMMITTEE BY-LAW
- 2. Lead YTNC meetings as an unbiased moderator;
+ Title I. Definitions and General Principles SECTION 1—Scope of Applicability This By-Law applies to all appointments of undergraduate representatives by Duke Student Government to university committees. SECTION 2—University Committee Defined
- 3. Record and transcribe interviews in a detailed, unbiased manner;
+ A. A “university committee” is any committee, council, board, task force, or other body that is established by a proper authority within Duke University, falls outside DSG’s direct jurisdiction and control, and is not explicitly excluded by Clause B or C of this Section.
- 4. Offer opinions only regarding procedural matters;
+ B. Neither the Board of Trustees itself, nor any committee directly involved in the election of the Young Trustee, shall be considered a university committee.
- 5. Avoid evaluating specific candidates;
+ C. No committee implementing the addition, removal, or assessment of residential groups pursuant to another By-Law shall be considered a university committee. SECTION 3—Appointment Defined An “appointment” is any appointment, nomination, designation, or recommendation of a student to serve on behalf of Duke Student Government, of any of its parts, or of the undergraduate student body. SECTION 3—Trustee Committee Defined A Trustee Committee is a committee of the Board of Trustees of Duke University, or appointed under its authority and including trustees as members. Trustee Committees include the Committees on Academic Affairs, Business and Finance, Facilities and the Environment, Institutional Advancement, and Undergraduate Education. SECTION 4—Presidential Committee Defined A Presidential Committee is a group directly established or appointed by the President of Duke University. Presidential Committees include, but are not limited to, the Advisory Council on Investment Responsibility (ACIR), the President’s Council on Black Affairs (PCOBA), and the University Priorities Committee (UPC). SECTION 5—President Defined; Spring Appointments
- 6. Vote only to break a tie;
+ A. When this By-Law refers to “the President” without further qualification, it generally refers to the President of Duke Student Government currently in office.
- 7. Respond to applicants’ questions and concerns;
+ B. The President-Elect of Duke Student Government, rather than the sitting President, shall act as President for the purposes of any selection or nomination process leading to appointments that will become effective only after the President-Elect takes office. SECTION 6—Person Specifically Requested When the university authority overseeing a committee requests that a specific individual or the holder of a specific position be appointed, the President may, with the advice and consent of the Senate, waive any selection process and appoint that person.
- 8. Ensure that the process is conducted in a fair manner.
+ Title II. General Responsibilities of the Executive Vice President
- 9. Lead the creation of a new set of questions for the interview process each year. All questions not specific to the application materials of individual candidates, or follow-up questions within the interview itself, must be approved by the mentor.
+ SECTION 1—General Mandate; Recusal
- SECTION 5. Methods and Procedures
+ A. The Executive Vice President shall coordinate all of DSG’s activities concerning university committees, including the duties outlined under this Title.
- Under the direction of the Chair, the YTNC shall by majority vote adopt methods of evaluation and committee operating procedures in accordance with those outlined in this By-Law. Such methods and procedures shall include, but not be limited to:
+ B. If any conflict of interest or temporary incapacity prevents the Executive Vice President from discharging such duties, the President shall be informed and may either personally undertake them or assign them to a qualified officer.
- 1. An application including questions and the opportunity for a character reference from a member of the Duke community (faculty, staff, fellow student);
+ C. The Executive Vice President may, with the permission of the President, recuse himself or herself only for those positions for which a conflict exists, and continue to discharge his or her duties with respect to other positions. SECTION 2—Maintenance of List of Committees The Executive Vice President shall keep and maintain a list of university committees to which DSG may appoint student representatives. This list shall include the University authority overseeing each committee, its chair, and its purpose, or a citation of a public source where this information may be found. This list shall be promptly furnished to any student on request. SECTION 3—Oversight of Selection Process The Executive Vice President shall prepare and distribute applications, schedule interviews, and see to it that these interviews be properly staffed. He or she should prepare a tentative plan and schedule for doing so no later than two weeks before the selection process is to begin.
- 2. Ideal qualifications of Young Trustee Finalists and Nominees including but not limited to those listed in Title I, Section 5;
+ Title III. Selection of Appointees to Trustee Committees SECTION 1—Reserved Seats The President and the Vice Presidents of Duke Student Government shall occupy reserved seats on Trustee Committees as follows:
- 3. The length and terms of the interview and questioning periods for candidates;
+ A. The President—Undergraduate Education
- 4. A predetermined set of questions including a standardized question battery for all YT semi-finalists and several specifically tailored for each semi-finalist;
+ B. The Vice President for Academic Affairs—Academic Affairs
- 5. Committee discussion and voting procedure for each round. SECTION 6: Bias Training In order to prevent any prevalence of implicit bias (based on race, gender, sexual orientation/gender preference, etc.), the YTNC Chair will organize a Bias training session with the Office of Institutional Equity. The Bias training will occur before the YTNC first reads applications. SECTION 7: Endorsements No member of the YTNC, University Secretary or their designate, nor the DSG President or their designate may formally endorse a candidate through means of social media or active campaigning. This includes, but is not limited to, changing profile pictures, posting online or inperson campaign materials, and door-to-door canvassing. SECTION 8: University Secretary Training In order to ensure that the YTNC is educated on the purpose of the Young Trustee position, the YTNC Chair will organize a training with the University Secretary or their designate in the University Secretary’s office. This training will occur before the YTNC first reads applications.
+ C. The Vice President for Durham and Regional Affairs—Institutional Advancement
- Title III. The Application, Interview, and Election Process
+ D. The Vice President for Equity and Outreach—Business and Finance
- SECTION 1. Dissemination of Written Application A written application, approved by majority vote of the YTNC pursuant to Section 6 of Title II, shall be disseminated to the student body through the Office of the University Secretary before the last day of fall semester classes.
+ E. The Vice President for Facilities and the Environment—Facilities and Environment
- SECTION 2. Information Session It is recommended, but not required, that the Chair of the YTNC conduct an information session in conjunction with the December Board of Trustees Meeting, or at another appropriate time.
+ F. The Vice President for Residential Life—Undergraduate Education
- This session should ideally make the YTNC Chair, a current Young Trustee, and the University Secretary available to prospective candidates for questions and discussion.
+ G. The Vice President for Services—Facilities and Environment
- SECTION 3. Deadline for Written Application
+ H. The Vice President for Social Culture—Undergraduate Education SECTION 2—Seats At Large
- The deadline for submitting applications shall be set, and may be extended for cause, by the YTNC. However, the Senate shall establish a deadline for the YTNC to submit Young Trustee Finalists; the application deadline must be coordinated to enable compliance.
+ A. All other appointments to Trustee Committees shall be by the President, with the advice and consent of the Senate, and through the application process outlined under this Title.
- SECTION 4. Selection of Semifinalists The YTNC shall select no fewer than eight semifinalists to be interviewed by the full committee.
+ B. This process shall occur in the spring, and must be finished no later than the Annual Meeting of the Board of Trustees, except in the case of a student representative specifically requested at another time.
- In making this selection, it shall observe the methods and procedures adopted pursuant to Title II, Section 6. If there are fewer than eight applicants, all shall be semifinalists. The names of semifinalists shall be published, and their applications made available to students on request to the chair of the YTNC and the Executive Vice President of Duke Student Government.
+ C. For all spring appointments under this Title that occur before the inauguration of a new President, the President-Elect shall act as President as authorized by Clause I.5.B. SECTION 3—Publication of Application The Executive Vice President shall prepare an application, determine an application deadline, and publish the positions and applications in campus-wide media at least one week prior to the application deadline. SECTION 4—Eligibility
- SECTION 5. Selection of Finalists
+ A. Any undergraduate shall be eligible to apply by submitting a completed application before the deadline, provided that he or she is reasonably expected to remain an enrolled undergraduate at Duke University’s campus in Durham for the duration of the term.
- 1. The YTNC shall choose no fewer than two and no more than four of the semi finalists to become Young Trustee Finalists through the process described in this section.
+ B. A candidate may apply for two Trustee Committees by completing two separate applications.
- 2. Each semifinalist shall be interviewed by the YTNC sitting as a full committee.
+ C. No person may simultaneously be a candidate for more than two Trustee Committees. SECTION 5—Interview Committees The President shall convene a separate Interview Committee for each Trustee Committee to which a representative is to be chosen. This Interview Committee shall be chosen at the President’s discretion, and shall include the following members:
- 3. The YTNC shall then deliberate on the semifinalists, having regard to both written applications and interviews.
+ A. At least one current or recent student member of the Trustee Committee
- 4. The full interviews shall be audio recorded by the Chair, and not redacted or otherwise edited in an unfair or prejudicial manner. These audio recordings must not include any commentary from members of the YTNC except for the interview itself. A semifinalist may have access to their interview recording upon formal request to the Chair of the YTNC and the Executive Vice President of Duke Student Government. No individual except for YT semifinalists may request access to interview recordings, and semifinalists have access only to their own interview. These recordings must be deleted, destroyed, or made otherwise inaccessible immediately after the conclusion of voting on the day of the YT election.
+ B. A Vice-President-Elect who will serve on the Trustee Committee in question
- 5. Interviews and deliberations shall remain closed and confidential. YTNC members may not disclose information about interview questions, individual candidates’ standing, committee deliberations, or voting procedures.
+ C. A Senator, if possible from a relevant Standing Committee of the Senate
- 6. The YTNC shall use appropriate procedures and voting methods established pursuant to Title II, Section 6 to conduct deliberations and select a tentative list of finalists.
+ D. A second Senator chosen at the President’s discretion The President may serve in person on any Interview Committee, and when the President-Elect acts as President under Clause I.5.B, he or she may include the sitting President. No person shall serve on any Interview Committee assessing his or her own application. SECTION 6—Interviews Each Interview Committee shall normally interview all applicants. At the Interview Committee’s request, the President may pass over without interview any candidate who misses the originally scheduled interview or submits a frivolous application. SECTION 7—Recommendations The Interview Committee shall determine a recommendation by majority vote and transmit it to the President and the Executive Vice President. This recommendation shall include the recommended nominee and at least two alternates listed in order of preference. SECTION 8—Alleged Violations All alleged procedural violations shall be submitted to the Judiciary, which shall then hear the evidence and do one of the following:
- 7. The list of finalists must be approved by a two-thirds vote to become official.
+ A. Rule that no material violation occurred; or
- SECTION 6. General Rule for Deliberations During all discussions, committee members shall refrain from character attacks, gossip, and hearsay, but shall not be prevented from discussing issues relevant to candidate’s character, temperament or qualifications. The candidate should be considered based solely on their materials and qualifications presented during the application and interview process, without taking any outside knowledge of the candidate into account.
+ B. Propose a remedy, and order the President to either implement this remedy or report to the Senate that he or she has elected not to; or
- The Chair shall have the right to rule lines of discussion out of order; the ruling of the Chair may be overturned by vote of the full committee.
+ C. Rule than a material and irreparable violation has occurred, and order the President to report the same to the Senate immediately before it votes on confirmation. SECTION 10—Presidential Nomination
- SECTION 7. Character References When soliciting applications, the YTNC may request that applicants provide a character reference or letter of recommendation for consideration by the committee in full. This letter may be written by a peer, faculty or staff member, or other member of the Duke community. No member of the YTNC, University Secretary or their designate, mentor, and the DSG President or their designate may write a letter of reference or recommendation for an applicant.
+ A. The President may accept or override the recommendations of the Interview Committees, and shall transmit to the Executive Vice President a final list of nominees chosen at his or her sole discretion.
- SECTION 8. Election of the Young Trustee An election shall be held to elect one of the finalists Young Trustee. The election shall be conducted pursuant to the general rules and procedures of the Election By-Law and associated legislation, but no write-in candidates shall be permitted. All Duke undergraduate students shall be eligible to vote in this election.
+ B. No person may be appointed to serve on more than one Trustee Committee. If two Interview Committees have both recommended a candidate, and the President does not wish to override these recommendations, he or she shall offer the choice to the nominee.
- Title IV. Conflicts of Interest and Removal
+ C. The Senate shall be notified of all Presidential overrides of Interview Committee recommendations immediately before it votes on confirmation. SECTION 11—Senate Confirmation The Executive Vice President shall schedule prompt Senate consideration of the Presidential nominations. A majority vote shall be necessary and sufficient to grant advice and consent. If the Senate rejects a nominee, the President shall proceed to nominate another.
- SECTION 1. Formulation of Guidelines Before the Young Trustee application is disseminated to the student body, the YTNC shall formulate guidelines for conflicts of interest and recusals pursuant to Title II, Section 6.
+ Title IV. Selection of Appointees to Presidential Committees SECTION 1—President’s Mandatory and Optional Seats The President of Duke Student Government shall automatically serve on the University Priorities Committee and on the President’s Council for Black Affairs. He or she shall also have the right to serve on any other Presidential Committee at his or her own discretion. SECTION 2—Seats At Large All other appointments to Presidential Committees shall be by the President, with the advice and consent of the Senate, and through the application process outlined under this Title. They may be made in the spring, in the fall, or split at the President’s direction. SECTION 3—Interview Committee
- SECTION 2. Initial Review After all applications are received, the members of the YTNC shall examine the list of applicants and shall disclose to the committee the personal and professional relationships that they have or have had with applicants, including conflicts of interest as well as declared acquaintances that do not impair their objectivity. Members may voluntarily recuse themselves from a portion of deliberations and voting, or may resign from the committee if they deem it necessary.
+ A. The Senate shall elect not fewer than three and not more than six of its members, at its discretion, to serve as an Interview Committee.
- SECTION 3. Disclosure to Applicants The names of the members of the YTNC, the relationships they disclosed, and any actions voluntarily taken in response shall be communicated to the applicants. Within two days of such communication, any applicant may petition the YTNC to recuse a member for serious conflict of interest. The YTNC shall then discuss and vote on the option of removal under Section 4 of this Title.
+ B. The President may assign all Presidential Committee interviews then occurring to this one Committee, or may ask the Senate to elect one or more additional Interview Committees and to distribute the positions under consideration among them.
- SECTION 4. Removal or Recusal Within the YTNC The YTNC may, by a two-thirds vote, remove a member, or prohibit a member from participating in a certain part of deliberations and voting, on one of the following grounds:
+ C. The President may participate in the interviews and deliberations, and may designate Executive or Cabinet officers as non-voting members of the Interview Committee for some or all seats. SECTION 4—Procedure The selection procedure shall otherwise proceed as outlined for Trustee Committees in Title III, Sections 3-4 & 6-11, except that a student may apply to and, if duly nominated and confirmed, serve on any number of Presidential Committees.
- 1. Absenteeism or other nonfeasance of responsibilities;
+ Title V. Selection of Appointees to Other University Committees SECTION 1—President’s Option of Personal Service The President of Duke Student Government may personally serve on any university committee, other than a Trustee or Presidential committee, at his or her own discretion. SECTION 2—Appointment of Other Representatives Otherwise, the President shall nominate and, with the advice and consent of the Senate, appoint students to serve. A majority vote shall be necessary and sufficient to grant advice and consent. SECTION 3—Application Processes The Senate may, by statute, establish an application process and mandate that any deviation from that process be reported immediately before it votes on advice and consent. Nevertheless, the
- 2. Serious or persistent disruption of its proceedings;
+ President shall retain sole discretion to make nominations.
- 3. Other egregious misconduct;
+ Title VI. Accountability and Removal from Office SECTION 1—Communication of Duties Interview Committees shall inform all applicants to Trustee and Presidential Committees of their duties, and shall not recommend for appointment any candidate who does not express understanding and assent. SECTION 2—Key Duties Each student member appointed to a university committee under this By-Law shall:
- 4. Serious conflict of interest if the member refuses to voluntarily recuse themself.
+ A. Attend all meetings of that committee unless excused for compelling cause by its Chair,
- Title V. Additional Provisions
+ B. Communicate with the DSG President or designee thereof regarding the committee’s operations, promptly upon request, and
- SECTION 1. Revision of Process The chair of the YTNC is responsible for reviewing the Young Trustee process each year and for soliciting feedback from members of the YTNC, Young Trustee candidates, and other interested parties. Any formal recommendations shall be submitted to the DSG Senate, and amendments to this By-Law may be enacted acted only by that body.
+ C. Submit a written report of his or her service and the committee’s operations, to the extent that confidentiality permits, to the Senate not less than once per semester. SECTION 3—Penalties for Senators Senators who miss meetings of university committees on which they serve shall be assessed absences in like manner as for Senate meetings. SECTION 4—Removal from Position
- SECTION 2. Limitation
+ A. On the motion of five of its members, the Senate shall consider accusations of malfeasance, misfeasance, or nonfeasance against any student member of any university committee.
- This By-Law shall not preclude the future election of additional members to the Board of Trustees.
+ B. Any member accused shall have the right to present written and oral defense.
- Title VI. Enactment and Effect
+ C. A two-thirds vote of the Senate shall be necessary and sufficient to remove from the position. SECTION 6—Effect of Removal A student removed under this Title shall immediately forfeit the position and tender his or her resignation to the appropriate university authority. If he or she fails to resign, the DSG President shall formally request removal by the university authority.
- SECTION 1. Time of Effect This By-Law is effective immediately upon passage.
+ Title VII. Terms and Vacancies SECTION 1—Term of Appointment Each appointment shall be for such term as the President specifies upon nomination, consistent with the rules and nature of each university committee. Any term longer than one calendar year must be explicitly approved by a two-thirds vote of the Senate. SECTION 2—Vacancies If a student representative on a university committee cannot finish his or her term because of death, incapacitation, resignation, or removal, the President shall, with the advice and consent of the Senate, appoint a replacement to serve out the remainder of the original term. The President shall be permitted, but not required, to follow the selection process that would ordinarily apply to a full-term appointment to the university committee in question.
- SECTION 2. Repeal of Conflicting Laws The previous Young Trustee By-Law is hereby repealed, and all laws and usages contrary to this By-Law are hereby declared null and void.
+ SECTION 3—Interim Appointments If a vacancy occurs or an appointee to a new position is requested when the next meeting of the Senate is scheduled to occur no sooner than in seven days, the President may unilaterally fill up the vacancy by making an interim appointment. This interim appointment shall expire fourteen days after the next meeting of the Senate adjourns, or upon the completion of a regular appointment approved by the Senate, whichever is sooner.
- SECTION 3. Transitional Provision The validity of previous elections of Young Trustees shall be in no way compromised by the adoption of this By-Law. All actions taken pursuant to the previous Young Trustee By-Law in Fall 2013 shall retain their validity, and the selection process shall be continued under this By- Law from the stage reached by such actions.
+ Title VIII. Enactment and Effect SECTION 1—Time of Effect This By-Law shall be effective immediately. SECTION 2—Repeal of Conflicting Laws The previous Presidential and University Committee By-Law is hereby repealed, and any By-Law, Statute, policy, or practice in conflict with this By-Law is hereby declared null and void.
## Sources
- [Duke - Young Trustee Bylaws.pdf](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1bCGLR6_-7_PkgRrrlWW0VpaVtcV69OIM/view?usp=drivesdk)
+ [Duke - University Committee Bylaws.pdf](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1QCPTfE8vak6IYrADrurEht4D1J9ZVXGc/view?usp=drivesdk)

Amendments between these editions