Compare editions
95 lines added, 65 removed
- RGAC By-Law Mission The student-run Residential House Assessment (RGA) process seeks to promote healthy interactions between members of Selective Houses (SHs) and the broader residential community.
+ ## THE YOUNG TRUSTEE BY-LAW
- 1. Responsibilities of the Residential House Assessment Committee (RGAC)
+ Title I. The Position of Young Trustee
- 1. The RGAC shall carry out the annual RGA process.
+ SECTION 1. Nature of the Position One undergraduate student, called the Young Trustee, shall be elected each year as a nominee to the Board of Trustees to serve a two or three-year term, the duration of which will alternate yearly. A Young Trustee may not serve more than one two or three-year term. The Young Trustee must resign at the end of the two or three-year term. For the first year of the term, the Young Trustee will be a non-voting member of the Board.
- 2. The RGAC shall host a mandatory information session for all SH liaisons at the beginning of each semester.
+ SECTION 2. Eligible Candidates First-years, sophomores, juniors, and seniors of the undergraduate student body shall be eligible for the Young Trustee position. Eligible seniors include those persons designated as December graduates of the senior class. The current Duke Student Government President is not eligible to run to be the Young Trustee.
- 3. The RGAC Chair and Vice Chair shall be available to answer SH liaisons’ questions at any point during the process.
+ SECTION 3. Conflict of Interest No Young Trustee may be an employee of the University (excluding work-study) once the term as Young Trustee begins.
- 4. The RGAC shall solicit feedback regarding the RGA process from students and administrators following each annual assessment.
+ SECTION 4. Deadline for Election of Young Trustee The name of the Young Trustee must be placed in nomination before the Board of Trustees before the February Board of Trustees meeting.
- 2. The Composition of the Residential House Assessment Committee
+ SECTION 5. Criteria for Young Trustee The Young Trustee should meet the following criteria, the interpretation whereof shall be at the discretion of the Young Trustee Nominating Committee and shall not be grounds for litigation:
- 1. 1 Committee Chair
+ 1. Evidence an ability to think broadly about the University;
- 1. i. To be selected by the Residential Life committee of Duke Student Government (DSG). The Chair may not be affiliated with or be a friend of house of any house being evaluated under the RGA process. After completing a one-year term, the Chair may reapply to serve another term. If the Chair does not serve another term, that student will serve as a non-voting advisor to the RGA committee until they graduate.
+ 2. Be able to communicate not only the short-term effects that the Board’s policies will have on students, but the long-term effects as well;
- 2. ii. The Chair need not be a member of Duke Student Government
+ 3. Be able to articulate a worldview about issues with a breadth of understanding;
- 2. 1 Vice Chair
+ 4. Be able to speak up in intimidating situations while recognizing when and how to do so;
- 1. i. To be selected by the Residential Life committee. The Vice Chair may not be affiliated with or be a friend of house of any house being evaluated under the RGA process.
+ 5. Demonstrate commitment to making Duke a better place and helping further its mission;
- 2. ii. The Vice Chair need not be a member of Duke Student Government.
+ 6. Possess an active interest in continuing to learn about the University and how it works;
- 3. 2 Unaffiliated Representatives
+ 7. Offer evidence demonstrating their good character.
- 1. i. To be selected by the Residential Life committee. Unaffiliated representatives may not be affiliated with or be a friend of house of any house being evaluated under the RGA process.
+ 8. Be able to demonstrate these criteria in their written application materials and interview.
- 2. ii. The Unaffiliated representatives need not be a member of Duke Student Government.
+ SECTION 6. Overview of Selection Process The selection process for Young Trustee shall proceed as follows, subject to the other provisions of this By-Law:
- 4. 1 Interfraternity Council (IFC) Representatives
+ 1. The University Secretary or their designate and the current Duke Student Government President will solicit applications through the Office of the University Secretary to put together the Young Trustee Nominating Committee (YTNC).
- 1. i. To be selected by IFC leadership.
+ 2. The YTNC shall select two to four Young Trustee (YT) Finalists.
- 5. 1 Selective House Council SHC Representatives
+ 3. The student body shall elect one of the YT Finalists to be Young Trustee.
- 1. i. To be selected by SHC leadership.
+ 4. The Young Trustee shall be the official nominee of the student body for appointment to the Board of Trustees pursuant to relevant Board policies.
- 6. 1 Panhellenic Representatives
+ Title II. The Young Trustee Nominating Committee Selection Committee
- 1. i. To be selected by PanHel leadership.
+ SECTION 1. Selection of the Young Trustee Nominating Committee The University Secretary or their designate shall conduct a well-publicized application and interview process to select the twelve-member Young Trustee Nominating Committee (YTNC).
- 7. 1 Multicultural Liaison
+ The University Secretary or their designate and the DSG President will select the members of the YTNC. Any undergraduate may apply to serve on the YTNC. The University Secretary and the DSG President shall choose as few as ten students to constitute the YTNC and as many as twelve members, and shall also prepare a ranked list of alternates, consisting of applicants to the YTNC who would be qualified to serve but were not selected. The University Secretary or their designate shall select a mentor to advise the YTNC. The mentor must either be a member of the faculty or an administrator to the university. At least one member of the YTNC must have been, or currently be, a voting member of a Board of Trustees committee. No member of or alternate for YTNC may apply for Young Trustee in that year’s selection process. The YTNC shall elect a Chair from within its membership.
- 1. i. One liaison to be selected from the DSG Cabinet
+ SECTION 2. Appointment of Alternates If the membership of the Young Trustee Nominating Committee falls below eight for any reason, alternates shall automatically be appointed to the YTNC, in the order that their names appear on the list prepared by The University Secretary and the Duke Student Government President, to restore the membership of the YTNC to ten. If the list of alternates is exhausted, the YTNC shall choose volunteers from the Senate to restore its membership to ten.
- 8. Staff Advisor
+ SECTION 3. Quorum A quorum to transact business is seven members of the YTNC or two-thirds of the entire membership of the YTNC, whichever is lesser.
- 1. i. A Staff Advisor may be appointed by HDRL to facilitate communication between selective houses and the RGA committee and the administration.
+ SECTION 4. The YTNC Chair Before Thanksgiving Break, or as soon as feasible thereafter, the YTNC shall convene and, by majority vote, shall elect a Chair. The Chair shall:
- 2. ii. The Staff Advisor will provide the benefit of institutional memory and help guide the decisions of the RGA committee.
+ 1. Receive applications for Young Trustee;
- 3. iii. The Staff Advisor will not have direct authority to overrule the decisions of the RGAC Chair and Vice Chair.
+ 2. Lead YTNC meetings as an unbiased moderator;
- 9. Any selective house that feels that they are not properly represented in the above committee breakdown structure may send a request to the Vice President of Residential Life for additional representation. The VP of Residential Life shall present the request to the student government and the student government may add representation as it sees fit.
+ 3. Record and transcribe interviews in a detailed, unbiased manner;
- Any member of the RGAC who neglects their duties or otherwise fails to meet the standards expected may be removed at the discretion of the Chair, Vice Chair, and the RGAC advisor. The responsibility to replace the member will fall to the respective organization which selected the removed representative (DSG, IFC, PanHel, SHC, etc.)
+ 4. Offer opinions only regarding procedural matters;
- 1. Scoring and Evaluation
+ 5. Avoid evaluating specific candidates;
- 1. Overview of the Process
+ 6. Vote only to break a tie;
- The RGAC shall evaluate Selective Houses annually based on their performance over the course of the previous year in the categories outlined in the accompanying rubric. The RGAC shall not evaluate administratively run housing options such as the Baldwin Scholars, Wellness, and others.
+ 7. Respond to applicants’ questions and concerns;
- 1. i. Timeline: The RGA Chair and Vice Chair, in consultation with the RGA Advisor, will publish an evaluation timetable with all deadlines consistent for all houses. The timetable must be published by October 1 of each year and conform to the requirements outlined in this document and all other relevant materials approved by the Residential Life Committee. The RGA Chair and Co-Chair may petition the Duke Student Government to approve a modification of the scoring timetable outlined in this document.
+ 8. Ensure that the process is conducted in a fair manner.
- 2. ii. House Liaison: Each house being evaluated will appoint one member to serve as liaison to the RGAC. This liaison will serve as the primary point of contact between the RGAC and the liaison’s respective House, and will assist their house in the preparation and presentation of all materials related to RGAC. The Liaison will explain the process to house members and communicate any questions or concerns on behalf of the house members or the RGAC Chair and Vice Chair. The RGAC Chair and Vice Chair may directly contact house leaders as they deem appropriate, but will respect the primary liaison as the official representative of the house.
+ 9. Lead the creation of a new set of questions for the interview process each year. All questions not specific to the application materials of individual candidates, or follow-up questions within the interview itself, must be approved by the mentor.
- 3. iii. Written Plan Each house being evaluated will be required to submit a written plan, in the appropriate format, demonstrating how the house adhered to the RGAC assessment criteria. The RGAC shall evaluate the written plans under the procedure outlined in this document. The RGA Scoring Rubric included in this document will serve as the basis for evaluation. The RGAC may not amend or deviate in any way from the rubric. In the case of any perceived conflict between this bylaw, the rubric, the RGA handbook, and any other materials approved by DSG, the content of the rubric will not be altered or reinterpreted.
+ SECTION 5. Methods and Procedures
- 4. iv. House Presentations: During If a problem arises during the evaluation process that the RGAC Chair believes could be resolved, or requires, a presentation from a house they are at liberty to call for such a presentation as part of the evaluation process. These presentations will consist of a brief self-assessment in front of the RGAC, including a question-and-answer session with members of the RGAC.
+ Under the direction of the Chair, the YTNC shall by majority vote adopt methods of evaluation and committee operating procedures in accordance with those outlined in this By-Law. Such methods and procedures shall include, but not be limited to:
- 5. Damage and Excessive Cleaning
+ 1. An application including questions and the opportunity for a character reference from a member of the Duke community (faculty, staff, fellow student);
- 1. i. The RGAC shall convene prior to the assessment and presentation period to assess house damages, provided by HDRL, and assign each damage a classification of “egregious,” “major,” or “minor”.
+ 2. Ideal qualifications of Young Trustee Finalists and Nominees including but not limited to those listed in Title I, Section 5;
- 1. The committee will decide which category each damage will fall into by a simple majority vote.
+ 3. The length and terms of the interview and questioning periods for candidates;
- 2. ii. The RGAC will also review the excessive cleaning charges, provided by HDRL.
+ 4. A predetermined set of questions including a standardized question battery for all YT semi-finalists and several specifically tailored for each semi-finalist;
- 3. iii. The following information will be provided to houses at least 72 hours in advance of their assigned presentation timeslot:
+ 5. Committee discussion and voting procedure for each round. SECTION 6: Bias Training In order to prevent any prevalence of implicit bias (based on race, gender, sexual orientation/gender preference, etc.), the YTNC Chair will organize a Bias training session with the Office of Institutional Equity. The Bias training will occur before the YTNC first reads applications. SECTION 7: Endorsements No member of the YTNC, University Secretary or their designate, nor the DSG President or their designate may formally endorse a candidate through means of social media or active campaigning. This includes, but is not limited to, changing profile pictures, posting online or inperson campaign materials, and door-to-door canvassing. SECTION 8: University Secretary Training In order to ensure that the YTNC is educated on the purpose of the Young Trustee position, the YTNC Chair will organize a training with the University Secretary or their designate in the University Secretary’s office. This training will occur before the YTNC first reads applications.
- 1. A review of the in-house damage sustained during evaluation timeframe with the severity classification of each damage incident.
+ Title III. The Application, Interview, and Election Process
- 2. A comprehensive list of all charges billed to the house during the assessment period
+ SECTION 1. Dissemination of Written Application A written application, approved by majority vote of the YTNC pursuant to Section 6 of Title II, shall be disseminated to the student body through the Office of the University Secretary before the last day of fall semester classes.
- 3. iv. In the instance where an individual house member takes personal responsibility for a damage, the severity of said damage count half towards their house’s RGA section damages evaluation.
+ SECTION 2. Information Session It is recommended, but not required, that the Chair of the YTNC conduct an information session in conjunction with the December Board of Trustees Meeting, or at another appropriate time.
- 4. v. Houses may appeal damage and cleaning charges in writing to the RGAC, so long as the appeal is filed more than 24 hours prior to a house’s assigned presentation timeslot. The RGA Chair and Vice Chair will determine the appropriate format and ground for appeals and will communicate this format to each selective house. Appeals in person and appeals submitted after this deadline will not be considered.
+ This session should ideally make the YTNC Chair, a current Young Trustee, and the University Secretary available to prospective candidates for questions and discussion.
- 2. RGAC Scoring Practices
+ SECTION 3. Deadline for Written Application
- 1. i. Each member of the RGAC shall independently pre-score all Selective House written plans prior to group presentations and submit these scores to the RGAC Chair and Vice Chair.
+ The deadline for submitting applications shall be set, and may be extended for cause, by the YTNC. However, the Senate shall establish a deadline for the YTNC to submit Young Trustee Finalists; the application deadline must be coordinated to enable compliance.
- 2. ii. After a group has presented its self-assessment, evaluators may adjust their scores, but only in response to clarifications and new, material information learned during the presentation. It is expected that the written plan will serve as the primary basis for an evaluator’s score.
+ SECTION 4. Selection of Semifinalists The YTNC shall select no fewer than eight semifinalists to be interviewed by the full committee.
- 3. iii. Following group presentations, the RGAC Chair and Vice Chair will lead the committee in a “conference” session to discuss the performance an scoring of each house and to address any significant differences between individual evaluator’s scores. The RGAC Chair and Vice Chair will provide an opportunity for each evaluator to revise their initial scores. The committee will respect an evaluator’s right to independently score all houses.
+ In making this selection, it shall observe the methods and procedures adopted pursuant to Title II, Section 6. If there are fewer than eight applicants, all shall be semifinalists. The names of semifinalists shall be published, and their applications made available to students on request to the chair of the YTNC and the Executive Vice President of Duke Student Government.
- 4. iv. The RGAC Advisor, Chair, and Vice Chair will calculate average scores for the Community Interaction subsection of each rubric using the same method of dropping the highest and lowest individual scores for that section.
+ SECTION 5. Selection of Finalists
- 3. Release of Final Scores The committee will release RGA scores within one week of the completion of the annual evaluation process.
+ 1. The YTNC shall choose no fewer than two and no more than four of the semi finalists to become Young Trustee Finalists through the process described in this section.
- The RGAC will consider its deliberations strictly confidential, and will release only:
+ 2. Each semifinalist shall be interviewed by the YTNC sitting as a full committee.
- 1. i. Total scores for each house, prepared as outlined in this document.
+ 3. The YTNC shall then deliberate on the semifinalists, having regard to both written applications and interviews.
- 2. ii. A copy of the Section Management portion of the rubric completed by the RGAC for each house under the guidelines in this document
+ 4. The full interviews shall be audio recorded by the Chair, and not redacted or otherwise edited in an unfair or prejudicial manner. These audio recordings must not include any commentary from members of the YTNC except for the interview itself. A semifinalist may have access to their interview recording upon formal request to the Chair of the YTNC and the Executive Vice President of Duke Student Government. No individual except for YT semifinalists may request access to interview recordings, and semifinalists have access only to their own interview. These recordings must be deleted, destroyed, or made otherwise inaccessible immediately after the conclusion of voting on the day of the YT election.
- 3. Appeal Process Following the release of the RGA scores, all houses will have 24 hours to submit an appeal request in writing to the RGAC Chair, Vice Chair and the DSG vice president of Residential life. Appeals will contain the objections of the group to their RGA score. Appeals will result in a convening of the RGAC committee for a brief presentation by the house, followed by a question-and-answer session with members of the RGAC. The RGAC will have 48 hours from the end of this presentation to change the house in question’s RGA score.
+ 5. Interviews and deliberations shall remain closed and confidential. YTNC members may not disclose information about interview questions, individual candidates’ standing, committee deliberations, or voting procedures.
- 4. Amendment Process
+ 6. The YTNC shall use appropriate procedures and voting methods established pursuant to Title II, Section 6 to conduct deliberations and select a tentative list of finalists.
- 1. The RGA process as outlined in this document will be re-visited, and amended if necessary, by DSG no less than every three years
+ 7. The list of finalists must be approved by a two-thirds vote to become official.
- 2. The RGAC process, which is attached, shall be re-evaluated in three years. At this time, the process shall be updated to better reflect the complexities of Duke Houses. Specifically, a class breakdown requirement consisting of 50% sophomores, 30% juniors, and 20% sophomores shall be implemented for all Selective Houses.
+ SECTION 6. General Rule for Deliberations During all discussions, committee members shall refrain from character attacks, gossip, and hearsay, but shall not be prevented from discussing issues relevant to candidate’s character, temperament or qualifications. The candidate should be considered based solely on their materials and qualifications presented during the application and interview process, without taking any outside knowledge of the candidate into account.
- 1. i. Houses are expected to make significant strides towards this class breakdown within three years. The RGA committee reserves the right to recommend probation for any house it feels has not made active strides towards this breakdown.
+ The Chair shall have the right to rule lines of discussion out of order; the ruling of the Chair may be overturned by vote of the full committee.
- 2. ii. The possibility of a non-selective house assessment process shall also be reviewed at this time.
+ SECTION 7. Character References When soliciting applications, the YTNC may request that applicants provide a character reference or letter of recommendation for consideration by the committee in full. This letter may be written by a peer, faculty or staff member, or other member of the Duke community. No member of the YTNC, University Secretary or their designate, mentor, and the DSG President or their designate may write a letter of reference or recommendation for an applicant.
- 3. Any amendments must be ratified by the Duke Student Government.
+ SECTION 8. Election of the Young Trustee An election shall be held to elect one of the finalists Young Trustee. The election shall be conducted pursuant to the general rules and procedures of the Election By-Law and associated legislation, but no write-in candidates shall be permitted. All Duke undergraduate students shall be eligible to vote in this election.
- 5. Appendix
+ Title IV. Conflicts of Interest and Removal
- 1. The RGA Scoring Rubric, The precise details of the RGA Scoring Rubric are not provided in this Bylaw of the RGA process. The rubric is appended.
+ SECTION 1. Formulation of Guidelines Before the Young Trustee application is disseminated to the student body, the YTNC shall formulate guidelines for conflicts of interest and recusals pursuant to Title II, Section 6.
+ SECTION 2. Initial Review After all applications are received, the members of the YTNC shall examine the list of applicants and shall disclose to the committee the personal and professional relationships that they have or have had with applicants, including conflicts of interest as well as declared acquaintances that do not impair their objectivity. Members may voluntarily recuse themselves from a portion of deliberations and voting, or may resign from the committee if they deem it necessary.
+
+ SECTION 3. Disclosure to Applicants The names of the members of the YTNC, the relationships they disclosed, and any actions voluntarily taken in response shall be communicated to the applicants. Within two days of such communication, any applicant may petition the YTNC to recuse a member for serious conflict of interest. The YTNC shall then discuss and vote on the option of removal under Section 4 of this Title.
+
+ SECTION 4. Removal or Recusal Within the YTNC The YTNC may, by a two-thirds vote, remove a member, or prohibit a member from participating in a certain part of deliberations and voting, on one of the following grounds:
+
+ 1. Absenteeism or other nonfeasance of responsibilities;
+
+ 2. Serious or persistent disruption of its proceedings;
+
+ 3. Other egregious misconduct;
+
+ 4. Serious conflict of interest if the member refuses to voluntarily recuse themself.
+
+ Title V. Additional Provisions
+
+ SECTION 1. Revision of Process The chair of the YTNC is responsible for reviewing the Young Trustee process each year and for soliciting feedback from members of the YTNC, Young Trustee candidates, and other interested parties. Any formal recommendations shall be submitted to the DSG Senate, and amendments to this By-Law may be enacted acted only by that body.
+
+ SECTION 2. Limitation
+
+ This By-Law shall not preclude the future election of additional members to the Board of Trustees.
+
+ Title VI. Enactment and Effect
+
+ SECTION 1. Time of Effect This By-Law is effective immediately upon passage.
+
+ SECTION 2. Repeal of Conflicting Laws The previous Young Trustee By-Law is hereby repealed, and all laws and usages contrary to this By-Law are hereby declared null and void.
+
+ SECTION 3. Transitional Provision The validity of previous elections of Young Trustees shall be in no way compromised by the adoption of this By-Law. All actions taken pursuant to the previous Young Trustee By-Law in Fall 2013 shall retain their validity, and the selection process shall be continued under this By- Law from the stage reached by such actions.
+
## Sources
- [Duke - RGAC (Residential Assessment) Bylaws.pdf](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1EBxj_Ja7km2YI-rtGZD39qB8CSEpSEW8/view?usp=drivesdk)
+ [Duke - Young Trustee Bylaws.pdf](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1bCGLR6_-7_PkgRrrlWW0VpaVtcV69OIM/view?usp=drivesdk)
Amendments between these editions
- The Student Council - Proposed amendment to the by-laws — Bill / Bylaws amendment
- 1987 Changes to Constitution — Bill / Bylaws amendment · March 1987
- SGA-B-1819.02 - Co-Chair Bylaws Amendment Act — Bill / Bylaws amendment · September 2018 · 106th session
- SGA Bylaws Amendments 2023 — Bill / Bylaws amendment · March 2023 · 111th session
- Robert's Rules of Order Clarification and Voting Bill — Bill / Bylaws amendment · October 2023 · 111th session
- Attendance Bylaws Amendment — Bill / Bylaws amendment · October 2023 · 111th session
- SGA-B-2324.X - SAC Removal Bylaws Amendment Act — Bill / Bylaws amendment · November 2023 · 111th session
- Board of Directors Amendment — Bill / Bylaws amendment · February 2025 · 112th session
- Board of Directors Amendment — Bill / Bylaws amendment · March 2025 · 112th session
- Board of Directors Amendment (rev 9/2025) — Bill / Bylaws amendment · September 2025 · 113th session
- Fast-Forward Finance Bill — Bill / Bylaws amendment · September 2026 · 114th session
- S-B.114.09.01.26-4 | Clarifying Legislative Roles and Processess Act (CLeRPA) — Bill / Bylaws amendment · September 2026 · 114th session
- S-B.114.09.15.26-4 | Budget Transparency Act — Bill / Bylaws amendment · September 2026 · 114th session
- S-B.114.10.13.26-1 | Establishing a Transfer Student Caucus — Bill / Bylaws amendment · October 2026 · 114th session
- Bylaws Amendment: Choosing the CSAC Representative — Bill / Bylaws amendment · October 2026 · 114th session
- Closed Session Clarification Act — Bill / Bylaws amendment · October 2026 · 114th session
- Establishing an Lgbtq+ Student Caucus — Bill / Bylaws amendment · October 2026 · 114th session
- Bylaws Amendment: Speaking Time — Bill / Bylaws amendment · November 2026 · 114th session
- S-B.114.11.03.26-2 Attendance Consequence Clarification Act — Bill / Bylaws amendment · November 2026 · 114th session
